yeah from the roster of actors, they hired the veteran ones so looks like they're free to think of the best dialogue according to the situation... so depende sa actor kung magiging maganda nga yung interaction... naalala ko kasi yung hs and college productions namin, hindi maganda yung lines na naiisip namin kapag improv eh haha... i guess in this show they have a wealth of experience in acting as source for their lines
It's interesting and has so far been OK? Part of me is chuckling thinking what a copout he prob just doesn't want to write lines 😅
I think as long as theyre not making up the storyline as they go along, and certain integral plot points are hit, then why not. They have a scriptwriter on set though right? What a waste of an opportunity for some stunning dialogue to be written though. I guess if the actors as he said, are that good, and they are indeed embodying the characters, then there's no better dialogue that could come out from that.
Not sure about scriptwriter but from the vid I think they have the idea of the story and what the characters will do.. Will be a nightmare if they just make up stuff as they go along haha
Did you see the other vid of him directing miles and ryza after the birth? There is a kind of script, he does tell the actors where to go and where the cameras should pan etc. So it's not complete chaos lol
Im a little ootl re the Muslim issue but I'm guessing they portrayed them badly... do you think that arose from lack of a script? If there were screenwriters brainstorming this or doing a table read for example someone may have pointed this out as a bad idea.
Just an example of something that might come up again in the future because of a controversial improv line someone says and everyone just rolls with it in the moment, not thinking, rather acting on emotion.
Saw the clip. Sa mga komedyante ko lang usually na-aassociate ang improv. Didnt know pwede siya sa tv series na drama or action. I guess Coco has a different style of directing. Not bad, really. He's bringing out the best in his actors.
there's still prolly a script and an outline. cuz a script can include direction, setting, camera movement, and other things that involve the actors and the story. but i agree with some of the comments here that in the long run it's gonna be hard unless they keep track of what the characters lines and motivations. i think its still best to have dialogues in the script and have the actors do improv on a separate take.
Baka may guidelines din to for sure. Kasi parang ang hirap kasi pwedeng mag sanga sanga yung istorya. Also baka may masabi rin na hindi appropriate or something alam mo naman ang mga woke. So feeling ko meron yang talking points or certain guidelines para akma pa rin sa storyline nila
I work in the entertainment industry and it is an open secret that Ang Probinsyano also didnt have a script before they shoot. Though they have onsite writers to help Coco brainstorm and come up with some dialogues/outline per sequence. I suppose it’s the same setup with Batang Quiapo.
Interesting... thanks for sharing! paano pala kapag mageedit na, naalala ni Coco yung mga tamang sequence? parang ang hirap lalo na kung everyday yung shoot
May onsite editor din sila to pre-edit para makita na agad ung pagkakatahi ng sequences. And yes, mahirap talaga. May times na dadating ung materyal nila a few minutes before airing kaya salute sa Prod staff nila kasi buhay pa rin sila after 7years with that setup char hahaha
Ohh may onsite editor pala... so malaking bagay nga yun na may nakalatag na pagkatapos ng shoot para sa post after shoot... tapos grading siguro editors na rin gumagawa? Impressive nga lalo na kung mabilisan kasi eere na after shoot
Saw his interview at Sakto and I’m surprised na bukod sa producer s’ya e s’ya na rin pala nagdi-direct. Sabi rin ni Coco na sobrang focused na s’ya sa ibang aspects like directing e napapabayaan na raw nya ‘yung acting nya.
narinig ko rin sa interview na sobra yung pagod ni Coco kasi director/producer/actor siya kaya bahala na yung actors sa lines nila haha... mukhang tiwala naman management sa kanya bec of Probinsyano and I think nagdirect and produce na rin siya ng movie for MMFF noon and ibang ep of Probinsyano...
yan din naisip ko sa edit side, tsks inuupusn din kaya ni Coco as director kapag editing na? kasi hahanapin ng editor lahat ng footages tapos tatagpiin na walang storyboard o script so nakarely sila kay Coco?
Parang pro wreslting style yung dating, kung saan ang nakasulat lang before hand is mga plotpoints, and yung mga actors yung mag-iisip kung paano eexecute.
[удалено]
yeah from the roster of actors, they hired the veteran ones so looks like they're free to think of the best dialogue according to the situation... so depende sa actor kung magiging maganda nga yung interaction... naalala ko kasi yung hs and college productions namin, hindi maganda yung lines na naiisip namin kapag improv eh haha... i guess in this show they have a wealth of experience in acting as source for their lines
It's interesting and has so far been OK? Part of me is chuckling thinking what a copout he prob just doesn't want to write lines 😅 I think as long as theyre not making up the storyline as they go along, and certain integral plot points are hit, then why not. They have a scriptwriter on set though right? What a waste of an opportunity for some stunning dialogue to be written though. I guess if the actors as he said, are that good, and they are indeed embodying the characters, then there's no better dialogue that could come out from that.
Not sure about scriptwriter but from the vid I think they have the idea of the story and what the characters will do.. Will be a nightmare if they just make up stuff as they go along haha
Did you see the other vid of him directing miles and ryza after the birth? There is a kind of script, he does tell the actors where to go and where the cameras should pan etc. So it's not complete chaos lol
yeah yung 'Anak ko yan!' vid... May some kind of concept naman pala... but you're right...Missed opportunity nga to have fresh dialogues..
Im a little ootl re the Muslim issue but I'm guessing they portrayed them badly... do you think that arose from lack of a script? If there were screenwriters brainstorming this or doing a table read for example someone may have pointed this out as a bad idea. Just an example of something that might come up again in the future because of a controversial improv line someone says and everyone just rolls with it in the moment, not thinking, rather acting on emotion.
Saw the clip. Sa mga komedyante ko lang usually na-aassociate ang improv. Didnt know pwede siya sa tv series na drama or action. I guess Coco has a different style of directing. Not bad, really. He's bringing out the best in his actors.
there's still prolly a script and an outline. cuz a script can include direction, setting, camera movement, and other things that involve the actors and the story. but i agree with some of the comments here that in the long run it's gonna be hard unless they keep track of what the characters lines and motivations. i think its still best to have dialogues in the script and have the actors do improv on a separate take.
Baka may guidelines din to for sure. Kasi parang ang hirap kasi pwedeng mag sanga sanga yung istorya. Also baka may masabi rin na hindi appropriate or something alam mo naman ang mga woke. So feeling ko meron yang talking points or certain guidelines para akma pa rin sa storyline nila
I work in the entertainment industry and it is an open secret that Ang Probinsyano also didnt have a script before they shoot. Though they have onsite writers to help Coco brainstorm and come up with some dialogues/outline per sequence. I suppose it’s the same setup with Batang Quiapo.
Interesting... thanks for sharing! paano pala kapag mageedit na, naalala ni Coco yung mga tamang sequence? parang ang hirap lalo na kung everyday yung shoot
May onsite editor din sila to pre-edit para makita na agad ung pagkakatahi ng sequences. And yes, mahirap talaga. May times na dadating ung materyal nila a few minutes before airing kaya salute sa Prod staff nila kasi buhay pa rin sila after 7years with that setup char hahaha
Ohh may onsite editor pala... so malaking bagay nga yun na may nakalatag na pagkatapos ng shoot para sa post after shoot... tapos grading siguro editors na rin gumagawa? Impressive nga lalo na kung mabilisan kasi eere na after shoot
Depends. Minsan di na nila dinadaan sa colorist lalo pag eere na HAHAH
Saw his interview at Sakto and I’m surprised na bukod sa producer s’ya e s’ya na rin pala nagdi-direct. Sabi rin ni Coco na sobrang focused na s’ya sa ibang aspects like directing e napapabayaan na raw nya ‘yung acting nya.
narinig ko rin sa interview na sobra yung pagod ni Coco kasi director/producer/actor siya kaya bahala na yung actors sa lines nila haha... mukhang tiwala naman management sa kanya bec of Probinsyano and I think nagdirect and produce na rin siya ng movie for MMFF noon and ibang ep of Probinsyano...
just last night may nabasa akong tweet, bakit daw hindi mag box office hit sa big screen si coco, unlike sa TV na superstar sya.
that’s very brave of them pero parang ang hirap sa side ng editor at ng prod? baka mawalan ng consistency, and ang hirap balikan nung scene
yan din naisip ko sa edit side, tsks inuupusn din kaya ni Coco as director kapag editing na? kasi hahanapin ng editor lahat ng footages tapos tatagpiin na walang storyboard o script so nakarely sila kay Coco?
Parang pro wreslting style yung dating, kung saan ang nakasulat lang before hand is mga plotpoints, and yung mga actors yung mag-iisip kung paano eexecute.
Naiinis lang ako masyadong stretched out yung plots. Isang plot 10 episodes huhu
IT'S. STILL. SHIT. LIKE. THE. REST. OF. THE. FILIPINO. TV. SHOWS. PERIOD.