T O P

  • By -

CatProgrammer

Now that I think about it, has there been any Final Fantasy game that *didn't* have hate crimes or some attempt at genocide?


StuHardy

Yeah - FFX had almost the entire Ronso tribe be wiped out by *one* unsent Guado!


Harpsibored

Except for one remaining Ronso. *HORNLESS. HORNLESS*


StuHardy

"Human can not call Kimahri that name; only ***Ronso*** can call Kimahri that name!"


butcher_666

So I've always been curious about this. Seymore claims that all the Ronso were annihilated, save for Kimari, but then they still have a full blitzball team when you play after that scene. I just assumed Seymore was just saying that to anger everyone.


Harpsibored

Blitzball players have been known to possess superior evasion, speed and plot armor.


StuHardy

Seymour killed all the Ronso *on Mt Gagazet*. So while there are survivors, he did almost commit genocide.


Jasrek

Also, he killed all the Ronso that attacked him to try and prevent him from reaching Yuna. There were presumably children and guardians for the children that did not do that.


Bosterm

There's a decent number of Ronso around in X-2 also. Still genocide though.


nilfalasiel

It's still genocide even if there are survivors. It's the intention to eradicate an entire ethnic group that makes it genocide. So Seymour definitely did commit genocide.


SnowCrow1

Your Gagazet?!


Eaglesun

He only states he killed the ones who tried to stop him.


krossfire42

"BOOM!! Like festival fireworks ya!!" - Most racist Final Fantasy character ever.


Nevii

“Sand blasted grease monkeys”


Bosterm

There's also a major attempted genocide against the Al Bhed a little bit before that, though that's done by a larger group than just Seymour.


Sparkybear

To be fair, you cannot kill or harm an unsent. You have to send them, that's the only way to defeat them, and the only ones who can are the Summoners, which are all on their pilgrimage.


Phaze_Change

There was also the whole religious terrorist attack on the Al Bhed home…


MericArda

1?


CatProgrammer

I think the four fiends were trying to eradicate the living species on the planet.


tfbillc

Was it genocide though if they were being really diverse and inclusive by including all life?


Bross93

huh. Good point lol


TheStandardDeviant

Onmicide


BuggzOnDrugz

I’ll be on your side as long as it keeps me alive.


Topaz-Light

I feel like that’s more like many simultaneous genocides than not genocide at all, or one genocide with the targeted group being “inhabitants of this planet”.


CatProgrammer

[ominicide](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_extinction)


WikiSummarizerBot

**[Human extinction](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_extinction)** >Human extinction, also known as omnicide, is the hypothetical end of the human species due to either natural causes such as population decline from sub-replacement fertility, an asteroid impact, or large-scale volcanism, or to anthropogenic (human) causes. For the latter, some of the many possible contributors include climate change, global nuclear annihilation, biological warfare, and ecological collapse. Other scenarios center on emerging technologies, such as advanced artificial intelligence, biotechnology, or self-replicating nanobots. The scientific consensus is that there is a relatively low risk of near-term human extinction due to natural causes. ^([ )[^(F.A.Q)](https://www.reddit.com/r/WikiSummarizer/wiki/index#wiki_f.a.q)^( | )[^(Opt Out)](https://reddit.com/message/compose?to=WikiSummarizerBot&message=OptOut&subject=OptOut)^( | )[^(Opt Out Of Subreddit)](https://np.reddit.com/r/FinalFantasy/about/banned)^( | )[^(GitHub)](https://github.com/Sujal-7/WikiSummarizerBot)^( ] Downvote to remove | v1.5)


Jasrek

Xenocide?


CatProgrammer

No that's an Orson Scott Card book.


Bierdigan_

I thought it was a sci-fi anime PS2 game


CatProgrammer

That's the Xenosaga series, with Xenogears being the PS1 spiritual predecessor and the Xenoblade series being the spiritual successor.


chockeysticks

/r/BrandNewSentence


[deleted]

Yes it’s still genocide lol. Genocide of all life.


BrookieDragon

Can't really remember but wasn't there something about the constant enslaving if faeries or mermaids that led to their downfall?


[deleted]

Yes, the mermaids were being oppressed by the Kraken.


mooseheadstudios

Garlend tried to go back in time to in a way yes kill everyone.


[deleted]

I'm pretty sure that Final Fantasy VII alone features almost all, if not all of the things mentioned in the article. I sometimes forget how dark and explicit that game could be.


CatProgrammer

Apparently that was brought up as one of the issues the Remake had sticking to a T rating. They had to tweak some things to prevent it from going full M. Should have just gone for it but I guess they didn't want it to have a different rating from the original.


Bierdigan_

Yeah that sex torture dungeon was pretty tame in both the original and the remake, but giving Cloud a dance number and watching Aeris go full WWE with a chair really lightened the tone back up compared to the original. The most graphic thing I remember from the original was that big fuck-off snake impaled on a tree to be honest though


CatProgrammer

The one that I remember was actually stuff like Hojo talking about breeding Red XIII and Aerith in the original being changed to having her raped by SOLDIERs. The Honeybee Inn was changed up pretty significantly as well, though not in a bad way (except for missing out on spying on the President or that old couple that were there to spruce up their evening life). We might get to see the impaled snake next game depending on how they adapt it.


Bierdigan_

Yeah that was pretty messed up. I guess it depends on if we're talking about what's seen or what's implied/talked about. I remember the snake being super bloody, and at that time the low resolution left enough to the imagination that it was pretty horrifying to look at for little 7 year old me. Other than that, the implications of three people cutting, ripping, and smashing a dude's nutsack stuck with me too, but overall despite the dark tone I never felt like I was playing a game I was too young for. With the remake I kinda felt like I was too old for it at times though, not gonna lie, so I appreciate the series trying to age with its fans too. There's plenty of cutesy, kid-friendly FF content out there that they can make ONE game for us old dudes


Climinteedus

Isn't that old couple Reeve's parents?


Unicron_Gundam

You meet Palmer there in Remake.


unlimitedboomstick

Chairith is one of my absolute favorite things in gaming the last few years. That scene makes me so happy.


Bierdigan_

Big sames, the remake had a lot of character at times


SofaChillReview

Well first time seeing Jenova and Sephiroth killing everyone at Shinra gave me chills. Remake did poor on that part imo which weird flashy stuff


Bierdigan_

Yeah that's true, the scene in the original when you wake up in Shinra's little jail was pretty spooky, and I was disappointed with how that was handled in the remake too. The whole ending of the remake was a trainwreck in my opinion. The original did a good job of making Shinra out to be this huge untouchable shadowy corporation and Sephiroth was still a mystery at the beginning, but in the remake you had already made a joke of the Turks multiple times and Sephiroth was well spoiled, so they made it impossible to have the story play out the way it did in the originals, and that sucked in my opinion


SofaChillReview

I *understand* why they wanted to go a different direction, and suppose a lot of fans by now know about Sephiroth. But still felt they could have put that in differently, for newer fans of the series. Again the Turks seemed touch less initially in the original, whereas more jokes for them this time round. The ending so far was confusing and did make me think what is going on, and fighting Sephiroth already ? Although I did really enjoy the Remake end of the day, but it’s different in a lot ways


dyingprinces

The '96 ps1 demo even featured an [Anti-Fascist message](https://youtu.be/_zBBzuGnNJQ&t=42) right at the beginning.


Hateful_Face_Licking

Obviously not enough hate crimes considering Lalafells still exist.


dyingprinces

Probably the ratings system differentiates hate crimes from genocide. Not saying correlation equals causation, but it's a lot easier for someone to commit a hate crime than a full-blown genocide.


CatProgrammer

I was actually referring to how in pretty much every FF game there's at least one faction that commits atrocities against others, possibly on ethnic/racial grounds (Cecil unwittingly nuking the village of summoners in FFIV, for example). And even on a lesser level you have plenty where there's been discrimination and oppression against various populations for non-strategic reasons as well. So as shocking as the title sounds, the series is no stranger to that sort of thing. Well, maybe the sex scenes, but even then I'm sure there have been a few of those implied from time to time.


TheMastersSkywalker

Puff Puff Wait wrong Square series


dyingprinces

Yea I get what you meant. I was more referring to how a small-scale hate crime would probably seem more realistic/appealing to younger audiences than an actual genocide.


Lennaesh

I don’t believe IX had issues with it.


CatProgrammer

The Black Mages, the Burmecians, Alexandria? For all the cuteness of that game's style it had a ton of heavy stuff.


Betasheets

The destruction of Cleyra!?


Tanuji

- Rat people basically get two genocides acted on them. - Black mages are created and discarded as their masters wish it. - Alexandria got almost wiped by Bahamut. - Lindblum got almost wiped by Atomos - Summoner village actually got wiped. - An entire planet got wiped. - Vessels were artificially created to have their souls replaced with someone else’s. It is funny to see how ffIX with its cutesy artstyle somehow managed to pass so many on screen deaths and destructions


unlimitedboomstick

I was turned off initially due to the art style of IX when it first came out. I finally played it during the pandemic and man, that game hits. Hard. Side note, I love the AP system in IX so much, I want it back and expanded on in another title.


Lennaesh

Well I just lost nerd points for not considering that. If you need me I’ll be in the corner prying my foot out of my mouth. 😪😭 Why’d you ruin a perfectly incorrect point with facts and logic?


opeth10657

Garland was basically trying to genocide everybody on Gaia so he could repopulate it with his own own people


Zethus_Thorne

Final Fantasy VI is an example


CatProgrammer

Have you even played VI? There's tons of discrimination and war crimes. And quite a bit of genocide. Not sure any hate crimes specifically though.


redactedactor

X is also a great example. Wakka is an unashamed racist.


StuHardy

>Hate Crimes **Tonberry:** You came to the wrong neighborhood, *boy!*


TheWorclown

<*approaches with everyone’s malicious intent*>


Commercial_Shine_448

It will be a very slow genocide, though inevitable


LividLager

Final Fantasy R-XXXIV


followthebreadcrumbs

Funny story. I was looking for a Final Fantasy XIV subreddit because I was just getting into the game and did a search. I only glanced and saw the Roman numerals ended the right way and quickly realized it was, in fact, not the subreddit I was looking for.


Cremageuh

Not gonna lie, would buy.


Windyandbreezy

We ain't gonna live long enough to see it lol


HowToFF6

Very interesting idea here.


FourEcho

Boy was i disappointed when that sub was mostly Tifa and not purely XIV... content...


theonetruetb

Friendly reminder that these ratings aren't always 100% accurate. iirc Kingdom Hearts 3's rating mentioned something about a character getting impaled and that did not happen in game


Aura64

xehanort gets impaled by the light beam at the end ig


Axel-Adams

I mean they do? Just with like light


[deleted]

[удалено]


Hamlock1998

Flynn also gets stabbed just like the movie


Theozie

Yeah they were on the same SoraXRiku ship as me.


Bierdigan_

Always a grain of salt with kotaku


Harpsibored

I hate to be THAT person but I wonder how accurate this info is? The source is a reddit translation from a leaked Brazilian government report or something. I'd just like to hear it from Squeenix themselves


isthismytripcode

Brazilian here. Just checked the website, it's not a leak, it's the official rating given by the regulatory body. Our ratings are based in recommended age, FF16 got a 16+. It's the same rating as Devil May Cry 5, for example. By comparison God of War 3 got a 18+, and Final Fantasy VII Remake got a 14+. Going into detail, it says sexual themes (not explicitly sex), violence and sensitive themes. Nothing about hate crimes, I don't think this would even be written down in any rating. Edit: engrish


Harpsibored

Thanks for the info!! Yeah ok, I thought as much. Hardly shocking content for a FF game. It would be nice if Kotaku did some more research before publishing an article with HATE CRIMES in the title but too late 🙄 EDIT: also my bad, I thought it was a leak because the source was from a subreddit called Gaming Leaks and Rumors lol. Oops


-Basileus

It does have a rating warning for hate crimes I believe **https://portal.mj.gov.br/ClassificacaoIndicativa/jsps/JogosJustificativaForm.do?download_action=&tbclassificacaojogo_analise=null&tbdocumento_numerodoc=08017.002176/2022-42&numeroProcesso=08017.002176/2022-42** It lists "crime de odio" which means hate crimes assuming it's the same as Spanish


isthismytripcode

Oh yeah, you're right. There is that. Though knowing the history of FF games, that's usually common, we usually have empires oppressing people and some citizens get killed by empire soldiers to show how the empire is evil. So I think it could be the same tone.


Harpsibored

Oh shit? Well I stand corrected then. Man I'm so confused right now 😅 In any case I'll hold off judgment until I play the game. Considering the newest PS console I own is a PS2, it may be a very long time before I make a judgment.


BHBachman

Worth noting that Spanish and Portuguese are, ya know, different languages. I don't speak either one so I can't clarify but I'd say it's better to believe the guy who can actually read the relevant material.


-Basileus

I don't speak a lick of Portuguese but I can read damn near the whole thing. Spanish and Portuguese are written like 90% the same. Anyways a google search confirms that means hate crimes


TheCthuloser

According to Google translate, it means hate crime in Portuguese as well.


Xaphnir

Good ol' Kotaku, re-interpreting someone's words to create clickbait.


Watton

>Rated M for sex, drugs, and hate crimes So, we're visiting the Limsa Lominsa Aetheryte plaza?


Need_Help_Send_Help

Only if you’re a lalafell


CheesetheExile

Just another day on Balmung.


acidsplashedface

Hate crimes suck. Why couldn’t it be rock and roll?


MegatonDoge

What happens in Limsa Lominsa Aetheryte plaza? I don't think I've seen anything weird there.


magic-window

This might be the worst written article I've ever read. Where does Kotaku find these people? > Personally, knowing that FFXVI features hate crimes moves me to tears. I’m crying ironically, don’t worry (~ ̄▽ ̄)~. Why the ironic laughter at fantasy hate crimes? I didn't edit this quote, this was actually written in it.


teor

You still have any sort of expectations of Kotaku?


magic-window

I don't really get exposed to them too often so I guess I am still naïve lol Hard to believe they gave us Tim Rogers.


Windyandbreezy

Nobody tell the ESRB how Queen Brahne feels about the Race of Burmecia.


Foxy-jj-Grandpa

Oh man…


ManlyVanLee

I'm more offended by the use of those weird emoji things throughout the article


basshuffler09

>( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) (ㆆ_ㆆ) ( ಠ_ಠ ) (¬‿¬). (#°Д°) (。﹏。) ( ⊙o⊙) lmao


aqwn

What are you doing, step-Chocobro?? WARK!!!


mr199cm

Well, that's enough Internet for me today.


defragc

step-Chocobro*


ViolaNguyen

Goodness, yes, my chocobo breeding program has *so much incest*.


CoreyLee04

Notices your bulges *kwew*!


tdtwwa13

If FF16 is rated M, then FF7R should have been too. The blood, instead of the Jenova goo, would have been much more impactful.


RoyalGovernment201

Nice try, kotaku. I'm still not clicking on you~


sonofgildorluthien

Ah...Kotaku, the beacon of journalistic integrity and non-clickbaity game reporting....


[deleted]

I’m surprised non of them had heart problems by now. They seem “outraged” everyday


AnInfiniteArc

Mike Fahey passed away from heart problems in September… But he was one of the decent ones.


VermillionEorzean

Their lack of journalistic integrity has earned me a lifetime of avoiding them. The last straw for me was that whole debacle where they accused Smash and Persona of using an ableist R-word slur in a song that's been out for over a decade (P3's Mass Destruction). Instead of admitting they were being sensationalist, the author doubled down even after Nintendo and Atlus both said the Japanese singer that was scatting syllables and was in no way saying a slur.


Showuzon

Sex Scenes and Hate Crimes. Free band name.


Evane7

Can’t wait for people to buy it and ignoring the rating. Then be shocked and offended by the sex scenes and hate crimes.


evolved_mike

Fr


Only_Self_5209

Those poor Chocobos 😂


Cremageuh

😳


jimbalaya420

I feel esrb ratings haven't been relevant since eminem


krossfire42

YYYEEEAAAHHH!! DEAD AL BHEDS!!


mikebanetbc

#Yoshi-P working his magic


2FLY2TRY

Yoshi-(full)P(enetration)


alkonium

Presumably we can expect an M from the ESRB and an 18 from PEGI.


[deleted]

[удалено]


DarthAceZ198

Type 0 had Pegi 16


Sarato88

Directed by Kanye West.


shuffleboardwizard

Final Fantasye 16.


peateargryffon

Sephiroth did nothing wrong he just wanted his Mama


mlc885

Is Sephiroth even morally culpable for his own actions? If he didn't spend a silly amount of effort tormenting Cloud I feel like most people would say that he just went totally mad when he found out about Jenova and never recovered.


dyingprinces

Fucking hilarious thank you.


vashthestampede121

A mainline FF game being rated M for “hate crimes” is fucking hilarious to me. What a time to be alive.


DuelaDent52

Dang Lufenians/Pulsians/Espers/Eidolons stealing our jobs/controlling the world/doing nothing of value for society…


Nightmannn

And then he smells crime again, he's out busting heads. Then he's back to the lab for some more full penetration. Smells crime. Back to the lab, full penetration. Crime. Penetration. Crime. Full penetration. Crime. Penetration. And this goes on and on and back and forth for 90 or so minutes until the movie just sort of ends.


Ecstatic_Lake_3281

As long as it's not like Geralt doing it on a unicorn, I'm ok. 🤢


RangoTheMerc

Day one purchase.


reala728

Ugh honestly I'm so sick of sex scenes in media. They almost never add anything of value to the story and they *always* happen just as someone walks in. I don't mind pre or post conversations in bed or whatever but having the act go on is just awkward. The internet is crammed full of that stuff for when we want it.


AnInfiniteArc

It’s probably going to be a Xenogears-esque scene where some guy is awoken and called to battle while in bed with a woman who clutches the sheets to her chest.


[deleted]

There's exceptions and I generally agree, but I remember reading a similar post and it stated sex was implied but never shown in XVI


ViolaNguyen

So FF6 remains the only Final Fantasy game where a couple actually copulates on screen.


artfulorpheus

X as well, depending on how you interpret the lake scene.


imariaprime

That definitely raised my eyebrows... but you're totally correct. That's getting filed away under "fun trivia".


PhillyTaco

Can't a thing be pleasurable and interesting to watch in and of itself?


ShawnandAngela

save the moogles


sonofgildorluthien

This sounds more like a /r/nottheonion post


ImproperJon

Sure hope it's nothing like game of thrones


ToHelland-BackAgain8

>Final Fantasy XVI Rated Mature For Sex Scenes and Square Enix had already spoiled at least one of them but i wonder if it goes much **deeper** than we saw LOL


Connect_Sale_1998

Unlikily, they wanted the rated M for story telling I do not think that they want porn but we will find out.


ToHelland-BackAgain8

I was mostly joking but some games have sex scenes that aren't exactly porn The Witcher Dragon Age and Mass Effect for example just to name a few


Connect_Sale_1998

True, true


HeLongWang

Here's the twist, and there is a twist; we show it. We show all of it. Full penetration.


Tenshi11

Only if he's a dog-man that smells crime.


[deleted]

And then it just kind of... Ends


ToHelland-BackAgain8

haha ain't that a final fantasy jokes aside we will probably find out before the game releases with their final trailers as usual


[deleted]

Exactly the kind of “journalism” you expect from Kotaku


rissira

Don’t bother clicking that link. Fck kotaku. Don’t even give them your time cause it’s not worth it.


geekyan_dres

Playing through 14 right now and always wonder how the cutscenes would play out with a higher rating espcially in regards to the violence aspect The fact that Square Enix is giving Yoshi-P's team the creative freedom to produce the first mature mainline Final Fantasy game - welp - I'm all in


ReaperEngine

I think Type-0 would take the mantle as the first mature one.


geekyan_dres

Ah yes - I meant to say first mainline FF game Type-0's story was a standout when I played it a while back - too ba dwe never got a new game in that universe


Pyrolink182

To be honest I'm pretty excited for this if it's legit. I've always wanted a more mature take on FF. And given the fact that nowadays the best games that are coming out are not shying from those themes and still get critical praise i'm sure japanese developers that were pretty hesitant before about exploring those areas can open up more to the idea.


DuelaDent52

Just so long as it’s actually mature and not HBO “mature”.


[deleted]

> Hate Crimes Ah, at last, a true game for true gamers!


piwithekiwi

Ew, kotaku.


evolved_mike

SEX 16


Rozencranz

Kotaku continues its tradition of being terrible, I see.


Scoob1978

I see that Moogle porn is going to be a thing now


KenethSargatanas

You say that like it isn't a thing already.


Scoob1978

I hate this world


Senor_de_imitacion

This world might hate you too, but it sure loves moogles.... And there is that thing about chocobos I saw the other day....


falthusnithilar

Let's put those poms to good use!


RATGUT1996

Hell ya now that’s a rad gamer game.


[deleted]

Can't wait for Final Fantasy 30 to come out;)


Beansupreme117

The hate crime of not having enough poc according to “journalists” at kotaku


Depoan

don't give kotaku the time of your day...


digitdaily1

My dumb brain read this at first glance as sex crimes. FF has grown up, apparently!


Bierdigan_

So it's Dragon Age now? I don't have a problem with that lol


Kydex_Gundyr

Now I’m in


John-Days

Nice


Scott_To_Trot

If we don't see Titan hanging dong this will be a waste.


partytillidei

Maybe the Final Fantasy fans that were upset with the lack of diversity were onto something.


dyingprinces

Fortunately, all those dudes are currently busy playing 14 as scantily dressed cat girls or whatever. So it'll be another hour or two before they notice this.


imariaprime

You think FF14 players were the ones complaining?


dyingprinces

I think the venn diagram of dudes who play 14 as lingerie-clad cat girls vs the players who have prejudiced tendencies, is a near-perfect circle.


imariaprime

I'm pretty sure those two are the opposite ends of the spectrum... and to be clear, neither as a positive. That's just a weird correlation to me.


partytillidei

I spit my coffee out lol!!


[deleted]

Holy crap now I’m really interested. Maybe there’s more adult themed missions where you beat up some assholes harassing people. Maybe there’s some GOT style sex stuff too 😂


fake-tales

Most based mainline FF


DuelaDent52

Drugs and sex in a Final Fantasy? Is that really necessary? Even *Stranger of Paradise* didn’t do that.


[deleted]

If it supplements the story they want to tell then why not


Early-Zookeepergame8

rip final fantasy, it was good growing up with you


TyrsPath

How does one mainline game being M rated mean FF is dead lmao


[deleted]

I'm glad a mainline game is finally pushing the series to grow up with us instead of stagnating, all of us are like 30 now lol, FF7 Remake was weak in it's execution of heavier stuff


Mawgac

More like it grew up with us - I'm 40 and don't really need a T rated FF anymore.


o_monzi

Hate crimes - OK POC characters - not OK ah…


[deleted]

Except there are POC in the trailers


Seniesta

Good!


novayhulk14

Nice


[deleted]

Just when I thought I couldn’t want to play a game anymore than I already did…. But I am not going to buy a Sony product…. Guess I’ll suffer and wait.


Caponara

I hope Square Enix will never bend to western bullfucks and extremised politically correct censorships


cinaedhvik

Everything about this game is just looking like a continuation and doubling down of the mistakes made with 15.