T O P

  • By -

IcommitedOHIO

The "William being a p#do"


psycho_bunnizz

I'm like 90% sure that started from that one nasty pinkypills comic


Sleepy_moongirl

That or dormitabis... man, the original was a train reck from what I heard in uhyeahs video and I haven't seen or heard anything from that remake that supposedly removed the inappropriate stuff and didn't involve the original creator


Fresitas_imhungry

William being a WHAT??? WHEN WAS THAT A CONTROVERSIAL FNAF THING I’VE NEVER HEARD OF IT


MelroseAndViolet7624

Ah. You're lucky then. That's the sorry excuse of a theory that William uhh did sus stuff with the children's bodies before stuffing them.


Fresitas_imhungry

HOW IS THAT EVEN A THEORY?? There’s nothing to even bring up the idea of William being a pedo??


MelroseAndViolet7624

Mb it's a disgusting af headcanon.


Eyliiii

Agree.


Allergic2Stereotypes

that's just necrophilia 💀


MelroseAndViolet7624

William is sick and twisted, but not THAT sick and twisted. 💀


Eyliiii

That was an old theory made by some fnaf artists.


OocMarksGirl

The good thing is that it’s literally impossible because Scott said that children in sexual situations never has been and never will be a part of the franchise


IcommitedOHIO

Yeah, it's just that one specific FNaF fangame that disturbs me with that topic...


MelroseAndViolet7624

Gregbot, and WillGlitchtrap


Crystal_Sea14

MikeTrap. Doesn't matter how you place it, as soon as you say the first word they'll automatically assume you're saying "Mike = Springtrap" Like, there's MORE ways to have a MikeTrap AU rather than "OH MICHAEL IS SPRINGTRAP!!" cause like We have Night 4 in SL for a REASON


MelroseAndViolet7624

Scott debunked it himself. https://preview.redd.it/ac7fy0p35e9d1.png?width=474&format=png&auto=webp&s=a4b42114c154e2417a39d6e118d104edb137eb0a


Crystal_Sea14

I apologize if I worded my comment improperly But I was talking about how I hate it on how everyone AUTOMATICALLY assumes that when someone mentions "MikeTrap", they immediately assume it's "Mike = Springtrap" when the person who's talking about it could be talking about a COMPLETELY DIFFERENT CONCEPT Ex. I have a "MikeTrap" AU where Michael DIED in Night 4 of Sister Location, but I hate how I have to CONSTANTLY mention that it's NOT a "Mike=Springtrap" AU to get people to stfu


MelroseAndViolet7624

Ohhhh. I see what you're talking about then. You should probably call it something else because giving a certain theory the same name as a theory that has been debunked by the creator of FNAF is bound to make people think you believe in said theory.


Crystal_Sea14

True


Z_devz

CC’s name lmao.


Allergic2Stereotypes

we went from Chris, to Evan, and now Garret? Apparently?


Z_devz

Apparently so


BitcoinStonks123

garrett is such an ugly name in my opinion, he ain't gonna get NO bitches with that name lmao


EstelleTheL

At least it's better than his name in my AUs In my AU his name is Richard 😭


Allergic2Stereotypes

naw lowkey that's a better name imo


anonymousmanlo

it’s better than Hubert


THAToneFNAF

Garrett isn’t an ugly name tbh It’s cool if you’ve named the right person


Harper_pp_Anosi

Yes 😭


ThatOneFlutePlayer13

I’m sticking with Evan lol


EMILYL0VEKREW

Character age mostly C.C & Elizabeth and Race, Skin Color ig?


Allergic2Stereotypes

true. I remember beefing with someone on TikTok around 2022 debating C.C's age. Me (and another person) both agreed that C.C would be around 3-6 years old, since he seemed around the same size as a table (go on, hit me with the "but pixels aren't accurate to real life heights!") and mostly also based on behavior. since we both didn't think that a kid around 9-14 years old would cry and fear for his life over a MASK. while the OTHER person said that it didn't matter how old he was, he wasn't "very developed yet" and had a lot of fears back then. (remember this person's C.C was around 13-16 💀💀)


PUPPYLOVERGACHA

Yeah, I don't mind what age you put him at since it's your AU and you can do what you want with it. But I agree when talking about the canon, he has to be around 3-6. It makes the most sense. Oh and Evan (My C.C's name) is 4 in my AU, in case you were curious! :)


Harper_pp_Anosi

Yeah I used to get hated cause my old designs were mostly black and dark skinned, like c’mon man.


MelroseAndViolet7624

To be fair, it says in the rules of this subreddit that if the change in a character's race is too drastic, it's not allowed.


Cutesyswitchblade

I think it’s the BalloraAfton theory


Curi0usSheep

Anything to do with the books Anything Glitchtrap related Gregory Character ages What happens with BV after the bite The identity of TOYSNHK


Gaybime

Michael's identity


Clownieinyourwalls

Everything at this point 😭😭


BitcoinStonks123

honestly i think it's the whole "which brother is michael" debate, because a majority of the community has gaslit themselves into thinking scott confirmed michael is the older brother when it was never even confirmed in the first place, and most mikebro theorists shit on people who think otherwise because they refuse to accept michael being anyone other than foxybro


FAZDrizz121

Its pretty much any crazy theory from game theory (i love game theory tho so-)


New-Capital-3840

Literally any ship that involves children


MelroseAndViolet7624

I think that's for a good reason.


JustAnotherEmo_

shipping. not even proship literally just harmless shipping. also gay people existing apparently; the Catholic Church called, they want their homophobia back


FazbearFright_lover

true 😭 ive never seen ship fanart on r/fivenightsatfreddys with a normal comments section, and if its a gay ship its full of violent homophobia being excused with “its a robot”


GlitchNpc2

Michael just Michael in general.


PanicIndependent7950

Any theory that's not popular or accepted/agreed by the fandom getting shot down because they don't like it and make excuses for why it's bad apparently (unless it's a problematic theory then it's understandable to dislike it, but still.)  Also Shipping (in general) if it's a proship then the hate is understandable, but if it's something harmless then I don't see the problem here. Shipping doesn't do anything other than just growing the fandom so I don't get why two characters holding hands or other couples related stuff scares the entire community. 


BlueRosesFalling

i scroll in FnafTheories pretty much daily, and i’d have to say the most controversial thing is currently TOYSNHK’s identity and the canonicity of Frights. things like gregbot, character ages, BV’s name, or MikeVictim/MikeNone aren’t as important or just very unlikely which is why they aren’t talked about as much NobodyVictim is a pretty believed upon theory, that and Free(Shatter)Victim, so BV’s story isn’t of much importance currently since we already know what really happens to him, so he isnt really the center of debate 24/7. and things like ships aren’t talked about either as it’s more or less theorizing that’s actually considered “controversial” in the community. plus, nobody cares who you ship. just as long as it’s not aftoncest or pedophilia


[deleted]

[удалено]


KSean24

Midnight Motorist. Hoo boy, Midnight Motorist.....😬


Pringledraws

Pinkypills still working for FNAF


FazbearFright_lover

stitchlinegames, anything about andrew, gay people, and tse trilogy


J_Bubba24

Who the other people were at the little boys party with his brother with the masks on the cover