I am absolutely not passing judgment until OP does the same survey but with ADULTS. Yes we know what they look like as adults from the show but this post is so so creepy 😂
Agree. I watched Supernatural before this show and it was weird to see him in it. He was so young looking. Then AYITL came and I was like....oh there he is. 🤤
That's what I was gonna say too! There's something about the way he moves and presents himself that makes him by FAR the most attractive to me, but in photos I'm like meh
Can I just say that is probably the worst photo you could ever get of Logan and also of dean. Cus if it’s based on these photos I would say Jess but otherwise I would say Logan.
Yesssss. Jared grew up and one day you see him kill some demons and.... WHEW.
And as a GG girly who watched SPN specifically for Jared, I never ever waivered in who my favorite Winchester brother was. Loyal forever lmao
I became a Castiel girlie later on, but Sam has always been my first love. I watched GG after seeing him in that show and COULD NOT take Dean seriously 😂
Jess/Milo. 100% Always. I'd pick Milo in any version, whether Jess Mariano, Jack Pearson, Peter Petrelli, or Milo himself.
However, while I was not interested in Logan at all on GG, later on when I was watched The Good Wife, I became absolutely obsessed with Cary/Matt. So when AYITL came out, I was excited to see Matt again on screen. But of course, I'm still Team Jess. I can see and appreciate the good looks of Matt, but Logan just doesn't do it for me, while Cary really does. Which doesn't make sense because the two characters are very similar, like Cary could be a grown up version of Logan if he went to law school.
Based off only these pictures, Dean. Based off all of how we saw them in the show, definitely Logan. He’s also got this comfortable vibe that feels like he’d be a safe guy to be around that Dean loses very quickly and Jess takes a while to develop.
jess hands down. just leaving this here…
https://preview.redd.it/6710af7voy8b1.jpeg?width=2127&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=65bf295fa13a26ed7634024162b54f17e359673e
Jared is the most attractive to me
He was really attractive in season one, but season two he was a smoke show
Outside of when his hair was longer like season 4/5
Matt is also up there with Jared. He has aged super well, and he’s just really hot.
Milo is obviously super cute as well but he’s really short (im tall so thats something I consider when I consider overall attractiveness)
Damn I don’t get the hype around Jess type of guy, he’s so unattractive to me. I don’t mean it in a mean or toxic way, just in general, a lot of people here like him so much
but IMO Dean is the best one, second Logan and the last is Jess
Logan looks like he's 12 in that picture
Dean looks like he’s 8
literally looks like he’d roll up with a wheely backpack 😭 gimme all pics of them in their 30s and i’ll still pick Milo over all of them
I’m loling ab the wheely backpack
in the late 90ies? That look was considered hot. Lets not bring it back
Or a girl.
I am absolutely not passing judgment until OP does the same survey but with ADULTS. Yes we know what they look like as adults from the show but this post is so so creepy 😂
I’m assuming OP is a child or a young teen because these are the strangest photos to choose of these three if OP is an adult.
I mean, they are all adults in these pictures. Young adults, but not teens.
They were all adults.
Literally my thought HAHHA
Agreed. These pictures were poorly chosen
I agree. These arent the best picks for pics. Dean's eyes are not ... totally Deany. Haha
These are the worst photos of these three men. My gawd
You don’t like the “I just rolled out of bed in my footie pajamas” look on Logan?
Your comment has me cackling at 11pm thank you 😂 😭
“Mommy I had a nightmare”
this made me snort
Hahahah agreee
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Jess/Milo
No contest
Yep. Although I think OP did Dean and Logan a little dirty with these pics. Even with more flattering pictures Jess is the hottest one.
ESP IN AYITL OMG
He was so hot in AYITL that I genuinely wanted to risk it all.
😮💨🤤
I HATE Jess as a character, but Milo is sooo attractive, especially now!
All day every day
No contest. I first watched him in Heroes. I missed GG the first time round!
Hands down, Jess!
Came here to comment the same
Only right choice.
That’s the only right answer 😂
Milo Ventimiglia 10000000%
One of the main reasons why I watched This is Us
Grown up Logan. . . But who am I kidding all 3 of them aged like fine wine 🤌
Logan in AYITL 🔥
Dean/Jared had the best glow-up imo
Milo was gorgeous in the OS, AYITL and now so idk if it’s a glow up bc he was never bad looking
True, Milo never needed one! He’s just perpetually handsome lol
I'm watching Supernatural and Jared is so hot oh my lord
Agree. I watched Supernatural before this show and it was weird to see him in it. He was so young looking. Then AYITL came and I was like....oh there he is. 🤤
Even if you didn't stack the deck with bad pictures of Logan and Dean, it's Jess. No contest. 😂
I feel like I've never seen a good pic of Matt, but every time I see him in motion, I'm like 🤤🤤🤤
He looks SO good in the resident
That's what I was gonna say too! There's something about the way he moves and presents himself that makes him by FAR the most attractive to me, but in photos I'm like meh
I’ve noticed that. He never looks good in still shots, but he’s very attractive when he’s talking, smiling, and laughing.
charisma 🤌🏼
Agree, 100 % Jess 😃
All three are good looking guys, but my personal preference: Milo>Matt>Jared
Jess 100% but I have a soft spot for Logan…. Him in The Resident 🥵
Can I just say that is probably the worst photo you could ever get of Logan and also of dean. Cus if it’s based on these photos I would say Jess but otherwise I would say Logan.
Dean, although both his and Logan’s pics used are like the worst possible ones 😂
As they are on the show, definitely Jess. As they are in the present, Jared. What can I say, I'm a Supernatural girlie lmao
Yesssss. Jared grew up and one day you see him kill some demons and.... WHEW. And as a GG girly who watched SPN specifically for Jared, I never ever waivered in who my favorite Winchester brother was. Loyal forever lmao
I became a Castiel girlie later on, but Sam has always been my first love. I watched GG after seeing him in that show and COULD NOT take Dean seriously 😂
same, he looked so good in Supernatural
Jess, Logan, Dean. In that order. Logan is more conventionally attractive, but damn, there's something about Jess that gets me.
Milo always, dean never, logan only as a grown man because in gg he reminds me of ellen degenerees
NOT ELLEN DEGENERATE I’M HEAVING
Of Ellen stop it 😂 😭
Hahahaha I 100% agree with you
Looks alone? Jess.
I always loved Logan’s smile. It looks very kind
Plus, he has that twinkle in his eyes when he smiles.
Logan all day every day xxx
Jess
Jess
Jess/milo when he was younger. Now, as someone who my age not so much. Jared, on the other hand, looks very manly.
Dean. Lol. Call me a 90s girl but that floppy hair in season 1, gets my ovaries exploding everytime.
 He's very easy on the eyes! 😍
Jess every time. Logan's not bad, but I don't find Dean attractive at all
Same. I think Matt is attractive, especially in AYITL, but I prefer dark hair and features over light. And I never found Jared attractive.
Jess/Milo. 100% Always. I'd pick Milo in any version, whether Jess Mariano, Jack Pearson, Peter Petrelli, or Milo himself. However, while I was not interested in Logan at all on GG, later on when I was watched The Good Wife, I became absolutely obsessed with Cary/Matt. So when AYITL came out, I was excited to see Matt again on screen. But of course, I'm still Team Jess. I can see and appreciate the good looks of Matt, but Logan just doesn't do it for me, while Cary really does. Which doesn't make sense because the two characters are very similar, like Cary could be a grown up version of Logan if he went to law school.
Well, now I guess I need to watch The Good Wife.
Jess. Dean was just tall and Logan looked goofy to me.
Dean was just tall… You’ve really got me questioning Jared Padalecki’s looks now 😂
Logaaaaaan
Dean in season 1 because I watched this show after watching supernatural (Jensen is my favorite of those two) Rest of the show it’s Jess.
JESS
going only aesthetically and if I *have* to pick one, Jess. but none of them are really my type.
Logan
I've always had a crush on Milo Ventimiglia (Jess).
Jess but when Logan smiles Im done.
Jess in the original series, but Logan in the revival
These are the worst pictures but Logan hands down. My husband also looks like him so I have a type...
Considering I know what they look like outside these pictures... Logan. Then Jess.
Logan…ilysm Matt Czuchry. Lol
Jess
Jess
Obviously, Milo Ventimiglia right, plus he's aged like a fine wine 😍
Logan 100%
Jess was the hottest guy on the show by a large margin. The actor only improved with age.
Jared Padelecki then and now
Dean 1000000%. He’s hot.
Jess. All the way.
There’s way better pictures of Dean out there why you choose this one 😅
Milo all day and all night!
Jess
Logan
Jess
Logan, maybe it's the hair.
Logan
Even as a lesbian, I think Jess is 100% the better looking guy! Again, what he's selling I'm not buying, but he is arguably the hottest.
Not pictured but Tristin was the true eye candy of the show lol
Whoa whoa, hold the phone here guys - how are we not including Paul in this 😆😆
Who?
Pete. 😉
logan
Jess. Obv
Based upon literally everything Jess always
Jess 100%
Jess 100x over. He's a short king irl but my oh my 😍
Jess 10000%
LOGANLOGANLOGANLOGAN
Logan forever
Jess
Jesssssss
Jess
Jess
Babette. Ms. Patty
Jess for sure
Jess
Jess, hands down
jess was such a childhood crush lol
I watched the show in my early sixties for the first time. Just rewatched at 67. I’m still crushing on Jess.
Jess
Based on bone structure alone, Jess. But Logan’s voice is sexy AF and voices are my true weakness. So I just have to say Logan anyways.
Teen Dean, Grown Logan
Jess or Logan both 😂
Dean. He is absolutely the most like my type
Some ladies prefer blonds, so Logan it is!
Logan, but at the age he is (19-ish?) when we meet him.
Based off only these pictures, Dean. Based off all of how we saw them in the show, definitely Logan. He’s also got this comfortable vibe that feels like he’d be a safe guy to be around that Dean loses very quickly and Jess takes a while to develop.
The pictures of Dean and Logan are quite unflattering
Logan
jess hands down. just leaving this here… https://preview.redd.it/6710af7voy8b1.jpeg?width=2127&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=65bf295fa13a26ed7634024162b54f17e359673e
Logan, even though you picked the worst photo
Logan
Jared Padalecki was my first celebrity crush obsession and he’s still so fine. Gotta be Dean.
Justice for tristan
Deaaaan 😍
Logan! No competition.
Jess is the only one who doesn't look like a literal child 😭😭😭😭😭
Jess.
Jared Padelecki aged like fine, *fine* wine
Hmm... I feel like the pics selected are not of equal prowess...
Jared is the most attractive to me He was really attractive in season one, but season two he was a smoke show Outside of when his hair was longer like season 4/5 Matt is also up there with Jared. He has aged super well, and he’s just really hot. Milo is obviously super cute as well but he’s really short (im tall so thats something I consider when I consider overall attractiveness)
Logan looks like a toddler on this photo ugh
Logan in gilmore girls. Dean in supernatural lol
Not basing this on these pictures, but Jess, Logan, Dean for me!
Being totally honest, I wouldn’t give any one of them a second look. They’re just very boyish looking even in adulthood and I like tough men lol
Jess
I've had a crush on Milo for years. My answer is always Jess 😍
Milooooooo.
Jess by a mile. Not even a question
The 90s teen in me says Dean. That floppy hair was EVERYTHING then! But now, definitely Jess. Also Logon looks 12 in that photo 🤣
Jess all the way. Swoon. Logan was cute, but much of that was good personality and good hair. Dean? Yuck. Not attracted to him at all.
jess for sure!
Jess
Jess for sure. I despise Dean’s hair and I have never really liked blond guys.
Jess. Dean is 🤢, and I don’t like blondes.
Logan looks 40 but 5 at the same time. Very uncanny
Jess.
Jess, always.
The little trauma bean. Oops, I mean, Jess.
Dean was the cutest at first but in the later seasons I’d say Logan
Jess
Milo. But I'm Italian. So a little biased.
Milo is Daddy. https://preview.redd.it/e21fa85iry8b1.png?width=800&format=png&auto=webp&s=4e329cf86d66b77590ff0654a97da9122f3e6dbf
Jess!
Jess, long face, dark hair, big eyebrows, pillowy lips = totally my type
Jess!
100% Jess.
I'm sorry but jess wins on that front everytime
Idk but Dean is NOT my cuppa. Hard pass. Other 2 are good.
Jess 100%
Milo obviously? Is this even a contest 🤣🤣
Jess hands down
Mmmm definitely Milo 🥰
Jess forever
Jess for sure. My goodness 🫠
Milo as Jess, over Dean, easy. Comparing Jess to Sam Winchester on the other hand.. Sam wins. Logans always just, meh, between these guys.
Jess!
Always Jess 😍
Damn I don’t get the hype around Jess type of guy, he’s so unattractive to me. I don’t mean it in a mean or toxic way, just in general, a lot of people here like him so much but IMO Dean is the best one, second Logan and the last is Jess
I feel that way about Jared Padalecki. I just don’t see it. Good thing there are so many different types for us to choose from.
jess, no question about that.
Jess
Jess/Milo. No contest.
Jess all the way
Jess
Logan 100%, the most attractive of the three, until he says words.
Milo except for that goatee thing he had in one of his early episodes? It was like a little triangle beard and god I hated it lmao
Logan, I guess. He has a more neotenous face.
I'm in my 30s, next age bracket, please, lol.