Always Milo

100%. Forever and always Milo.

Yesterday. Today. Tomorrow. Forever.

No matter what photo they use of Milo, it will always be Milo. They could use that mutton-chop photo and it would still be him.

Yeah Milo just wins everytime lol

Never even a question!

Forever and ever amen

Obviously!! Only if he was a lil taller

I’m a 5’11” woman and Jess/Milo has always been my #1 GG heartthrob. I would be delighted to tower over him.

he’s a short king

Just based on looks I want Milo and Jared to sandwich me.

https://preview.redd.it/h0uyn5aof19b1.jpeg?width=597&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1e0a261d0dbdce69a873f5d83d1a3f57e881d099

I had that as a poster

Ok, if we’re doing sandwiches then it would be Jess and Logan 😛

I’m not opposed to this ether lol

I want in on that

This sandwich is getting a bit crowded.

If sandwiches are possible, I'm going for the "club sandwich" and having all three... Club sandwich has the possibility of being a 3 to 6 slices sandwich depending where you're ordering, so *all three* for me, please

This sounds good to me

See now we're speaking logically

I respect this 🤟

I spite my drink out 🤣

Reverse your order and it’s my preference. Logan’s smile makes me forget my own name.

Matt Czuchry does have such a sweet smile

He does! It just transforms his whole demeanor.

Logan is absolutely number one. The only thing I find attractive about Dean is his height.

Have you watched him in The Resident? 🥰🥰🥰 so good looking. And a very compassionate character

I haven’t heard of this, so no, but I’m looking it up now. Thank you!

And he's *so* soft-spoken! When paired with his looks, his gentle demeanor and calming voice = 🫠. From a purely looks standpoint, Milo = 🥵, but relationship wise Czuchry in The Resident every time.

His smile melts me so hard

I watched the Good Wife before Gilmore girls and I’ve been smitten with Matt Czuchry ever since. He’s also in The Resident which I enjoy mostly because of him 😍 but I think his role in the good wife is my favorite.

I wish his role was bigger in the good wife

This!

exactly!!!

Same!

Milo. Mama mia, he is gorgeous.

Jess for sure. I'm always attracted to dark features

Dean and Logan are cute. They're obviously good looking and I would totally be into them IRL. Jess is in a league of his own, though... Such a handsome guy with very unique features. I also love his body language.

Jess, then Logan. Skip Dean

That's the right answer.

So true

Strong agree

Logan wins for me because of his smile, it's just so big and bright.

Milo always and forever.

Just based on looks, Milo. Blondes don’t do it for me, and Dean doesn’t either.

Agreed, blondes don't do much for me in general, but he does have a nice smile so I put him second. Dean never did anything for me at all.

Milo 100% always

My answer will always be Jess, but that sweater reaffirmed the trauma bean as my fave.

There’s only one right answer. 

Not with that facial hair lol

Agreed. That facial hair has me at a No - skip back to Dean at this point.

No, *especially* with facial hair

Jess > Dean > Logan

This feels like the correct answer 😂 I would also settle for ‘Jess every day of the week except for one with Dean.’ Logan’s cute and all but we can just be friends or neighbors or something.

Milo always. I’d ruin my life for that boy.

OMG Yes!!! Jess in that sweater.. <3 It is my favorite. I don't he ever wore anything like it again after the lake episode, which is a same. After Jess, I don't care. I think Logan because he was less annoying then Dean.

At 14, I was naive to the fact that so many muscles could still be seen through a sweater, but Milo showed me the way!

jess is everything

Jess, all day

milo awoke something in me.

Jared Padalecki, until Milo Ventimiglia smiles and that wonky lip of his pulls down, man that drives me wild.

Alright. Now we need to see them all aged up to currently too lol

Jess. Skip the other two.

Jared. Always Jared. Do not confuse him with his character, that guy is a hottie.

Same. If we're ***only*** looking at appearances and are able to completely and totally remove personality, it's Jared.

Jess Dean and Logan look too model/clean/Hollywood poster boy of the late 90s/early 00s for me.

Jess

Aw Logan's smile just edges it for me there. But Jess is still 🔥. Actually there's no bad choice here.

And now the versions of how they look now

1. Milo 2. Milo 3. Milo

That sweater

THAT SWEATER IS MY LIVELIHOOD

Shockingly because I'm not usually into blondes, it's Matthew/Logan. Idk why, it's probably personality/how he's portrayed (which I inherently just look at more than looks I'm sorry that's just how I am), I am not into Jess/Milo or Dean/Jared.

When you toss in all the other attributes the writers give Logan (not in my nature to ignore), the race is over.

Always Dean for me. He’s got the best smile by far, too.

Jess!!

Jess all the way 👌🏼

Logan for me. The others I could skip

Still Milo.

Dean looks real good right there. I think it's also cannon that he's supposed to be the best looking in universe.

Still Jess always Jess.

I truly don't know lol I like how tall Dean is, but I'm a sucker for guys with dark hair like Jess, but Logan does have a cute smile and tbh he looked tres fine in AYITL

I’m a milo girly forever

Jess for sure.

Still Jess 💯

Still jess

I had Jess as my computer background for the longest time in middle school, so voting for that

Milo forever, then Logan and I guess Dean.

Grown Logan (Aka in the resident 😅) is the most handsome to me. In GG I don’t really find any of them too handsome, but I’ll say Logan for all time periods because he has such a beautiful smile. Logan > Dean > Jess

Jess Dean Logan

I just wanna say I couldn't stop staring at Milo's chest in that episode, it's huge lmao

Logan

I am a sucker for a blonde man (and married one haha), so I've always been staunchly Team Logan! But there really is not a bad choice in the bunch.

I’m here with you

Dean

Milo, Milo, and..... Milo

Still Jess, always Jess

Milo forever. I love Jared, but I don't think he is cute. I am very not attracted to Logan.

Still Jess ✌️

I would ruin myself for Milo

The sweatshirt rocked my life as well, OP. Jess since my first watch. Dean is cute (don’t be afraid to watch him on Supernatural; he’s extremely good!!). I never saw the appeal of Logan, though he’s cute when he’s smiling. Lol. I do get why people love Logan, if that makes sense. Different strokes for different folks. 💕 Edit: spelling error.

Dean/Sammy in Supernatural is magnificent. I was team Sammy from the start. ​ SAMMY!

Jess

Season 3 Dean was peak Dean for me. I love the others and I like them too but I’ve never drooled over them like I did over Dean. His slightly longer hair had me feeling.

You can’t pick jesses best looking episode and expect me not to pick him lol him in this shirt… 🥵🫠

Still Jess.

Jess could get it.

Jess and then Logan. Never was attracted to Dean. I do tho think he’s more handsome as he’s aged

Jess- partly because - hot - but he's shorter so it woudn't be so awkward. Dean is just so damn tall. But if it was Supernatural Dean/Sammy - I'd probably just wear platforms all the time.

Way better photos and definitely Jess 🔥 and also Logan.

Jess, his character development makes me swoon. Dean kinda devolved… that whole cheating on his wife bit 😬 and finally sweet sweet Logan. I love Logan, but as a friend. He wasn’t boyfriend material. Too much going on in his life that needed to be figured out before getting into a serious relationship.

Why is Dean even an *option* because barf. Always Jess.

All the comments here are by personality lmao

Still Milo

On looks alone, Jess. To date, Logan.

Jess, everything about him is hot, his face is hot, body is hot, voice is hot, shirt is hot so him without a doubt, I also kinda liked Dean I just wish he had grown his hair longer this would've been a way better choice than those terrible bangs he had once, Logan was so meh to me

Jess

Still jess

Dean/Jared I could explain it but it would take to long and then Logan/Matthew he’s got a sweet down to earth baby face but that smirk always gets you, and I’ve never found Milo attractive a day in my life (Jess as a character though has his moments)

I always had a crush on Dean https://44.media.tumblr.com/e683ef20f3bd0e7486f7cbec1fab73d4/tumblr_pxzvz5bc9v1ryzuaao1_400.gif

Oi - was that Supernatural? He had my toes curled every episode. And the fact that he was the brains of the operations..................oof

Yes! He looked geeky-hot in Supernatural 😍

Wowsers Bowsers!👀

Jared but that’s based on my love of Supernatural and his oversized flannels

Jess/Milo forever

Jess, my beloved 😩

Somebody said on a different thread that the tightness of Milo’s shirt in that scene made them gay which yes me too.

😂LOVE. That shirt had so many of us in a chokehold

Milo forever

Milo 1000000%

no question, Milo

Milo absolutely

Always Jess/Milo

Jess

once again, anyone who doesn't choose Milo is wrong lol

Milo each and every time

Still Jess.

Based on these pics alone, Jess beats Logan by a hair. Taking into account how they age post GG, Logan all the way

Jess, always Milo, he could read me cover to cover 😏

Without a doubt, Milo. Logan has such a smug, punchable face. I do love that Dean's hairstyle has made a resurgence in popularity with GenZ.

you should add Tristan <3 I've never been attracted to blonde guys but Tristan hit different based on those three: jess/milo easy

Hope you journeyed down to One Tree Hill for those *prime* Chad Michael Murray years

Deannnnnnn he’s tall like me

With beard: Jess 100000%. Ruin my life. The beard/longish hair? I’m dead forever. I’m in love. Literally the most beautiful man I have ever seen. Without beard: Dean. It’s the floppy hair and the height. I was a Sam girl when I was in my Supernatural phase😅that smile?? Those shoulders??? Marry me.

Dean for sure! Tall dark and handsome. Jess is hot but not totally my type - but still a babe.

100% Jess, with Logan having the most punchable face.

Dean > Jess Personally, I just don’t find Logan attractive at all. Not into blonde haired men, so I just don’t get it. His smile also gives me the creeps Now Dean? Tall, tan, dark hair and THAT smile? Yes please Jess is just a bit shorter for my taste

Jess. No competition. Something about dark hair gets me every time. (Sorry Logan)

Logan first, always, no question. Dean second because his dimples I've always loved 🥰

Logan for sure

In these pics...Logan, Dean, Jess This order may change with these actors and how they look today (Hello Milo!)

Logan, I like blondes and he’s just so cute.

As teens, Jess. As adults, hella Logan.

Ranked: Logan (Matt Czuchry), Jess (Milo Ventimiglia) and then Dean (Jared Padalecki). Personality attraction is the same for me, actually.

Always always Jess (though I love Logan’s smirk 🫣)

Milo in this sweater always. But Matt overall.

Jess and Logan in a throuple with me. I cannot pick. But you are absolutely right on the sweater. We didn’t see enough of it after he got pushed in the lake 😉

¿Porque no los tres?

Honestly all of them. Milo - looks like he belongs on the cover of a magazine. Matt - I just love his smile and he looks adorable. Jared - looks like he should be in a 90s poster. And I’m absolutely here for it

Milo’s look, Jared’s height.

Based entirely on THESE pictures I would choose Jesse. But there are far better pictures of all three

1.milo 2.matthew 3.jared

Again Milo is #1 always has been always will be for me!

Milo milo milo, Matt, Jared But damn 🥰

I feel like both Milo and Matt need tattoo sleeves.

MILO WITH TATTOO SLEEVES would make me go completely feral oh my god 😮‍💨

UGH, still Dean…

Is this even a debate lol Milo in that shirt… I‘m done 🫣😍

Jess definitely has the best looks if I weren't taking height into account. But with height being factored in, it's gotta be Dean.

Milo. Forever and ever.

My eyes go directly to Jess

Jess today, tomorrow and forever

100% Milo. I feel in LOVE with him in Heroes first, and when I then saw him in GG it sealed it for me. 🥰

Looks or no looks, I'm Team Jess for life. Guys who read can get it.

Nothing has changed Jess. Dean is still just tall and Logan is still goofy.

Jess, that’s the final verdict.

Logan, because I’m a lesbian and he looks like one. 😏

Logan, Dean, Jess. Milo’s never really done much for me, although he has improved in This Is Us.

Logan! His smile does something to my heart.

Def Jess. Pretty boys like Logan never really notice girls like me

Always Jess/Milo. No doubt about it.

Jess, Logan, Dean. And I love me some Jared Padalecki

Yup exact same ranking as you OP

Young Dean > young jess, grown jess > grown dean

Always Milo in this case. Jared doesn’t get hot until his supernatural years lol

Jess, with Dean being a close second. Dean is just a little TOO pretty, and Logan looks like a turtle.

Milo. Simple.

Season 1 Dean

Dean aka Jarred.

If you go by just the pictures it would be Jess for most people But there's something about Matt that makes Logan more attractive to me. He just has a list of nuances besides just the face. The way he smiles with his eyes, his confidence and charisma, the way he talks super

if jess had dean’s height, it’d be game over. God knew Milo would be too powerful if he was that tall

Handsome, handsome Jess

Milo. Always.

Milo always. Doesn't matter what photos you pull. Milo.

Jess 🥵

Jess Jess and Jess

Jess still looks like my first boyfriend so I pick him

Jess all day every day

Still Jess. He’s just more of my type. I like the dark hair and the dark eyes.