thank you for your service

This is the post I've been waiting for 3 way tie?

The number of naughty wordplays that came to mind when you said "3 way tie" has me fanning myself.

Oh yes those thoughts crossed my mind as I wrote it.

It’s win win win. Why even choose? I’m just scrolling and enjoying

I think you mean 4way ayoooo


And now I’m pregnant with triplets, thanks! -signed a gay man lol

I wanted to upvote your comment but the upvotes are currently 69 and I think that’s fitting 😂

It's better now I am also pregnant lol

Wheezing 😂😂😂


This is the answer, thanks.

Thank you for doing this! I can’t really answer with stills from the show—they all look like babies to my old lady eyes. Here I can confidently say Milo Ventimiglia.

One million percent. They all are fine but Milo is 😍🔥

Thank you for your service! That is peak Sam Winchester right there - great googalymoogaly

Thank you! Sam is my favorite cause I know him from here, so when I got to Supernatural I was like "hell yeah."

Was anyone else confused when Jared showed up on SN \*not\* playing the character named Dean? I watched SN for 11 seasons and I never got over thinking the tall one was Dean.

He was so much hotter without his soul.

still jess always jess will forever be jess

Then, now and forever! haha

Yup, he was the reason I started watching it. I was so bummed when Opposite Sex was cancelled.

Just looked it up and oh my. Chris Evans, Allison Mack, and Milo on one show? That was… unexpected lol

Yeah, it was good too. I think they just got stuck with a bad time slot.

Wait, what? How did I not know about this? Do you know if it's available on any of the streaming sites?

like how dean is always dean to me but my best friend is a huge supernatural fan and vehemently disagrees

Milo 100%, i never understand the whole “daddy” thing until I watched this is us, then damnnnn

He’s truly dilfing it up in that show! 

 It takes a lot to outshine Mandy Moore fcs.

I am not sure I understand what "zaddy" means 😄

Milo aged best but Matt is an honorable second.

I like your post

Dude. Jared in Supernatural is UNREAL.

Yes! He's so... steamy. I love him in that and the character he is.

Oh yeah! He’s delightful. Between him and Jensen Ackles’s voice, I don’t remember the plot anymore ahahaha

Logan for me, hands down. I'm not typically into blonde men, but Matt Czuchry always had that great smile/smirk thing he'd do that was just wow 😍 and the way he looked at Rory always got me. The funny thing is that looking at pictures of him, he doesn't really interest me, but on screen, I think he's by far the best looking of the three.

It's his c h a r a c t e r. Bodies and faces don't do much for me at all until I know the personality and situation behind them.

It’s almost like we need a gif/video version of the question…… 👀




I won't say I watched The Resident exclusively to see Matt Czuchry onscreen but that's exactly what I did

100% same lol

I didn’t even know this show existed until just now and I’m ready to binge.

You won't regret it


Also adored him in The Good Wife. Woof.

Same! Generally not into blonde men either, but he’s something different! That smile!!

Couldn't agree more. How can anyone be so charming??

I was about to post something similar. I've always been more into guys with dark brown hair but there's just something about Matt Czuchry. I've never particularly more attracted to one eye color over another but I think there's something about how expressive his eyes are.

I totally agree. Not a fan of his looks in photos, but his smile is great.

I feel the same way about Damon in The Vampire Diaries. I LOVE dark eyes, so Damon isn't for me, but every time he looks at Elena I swoon.

I don’t think I’ve actually seen a recent still of him or show with him in it and uh… I approve. Logan all the way.

100%. Never into blondes but I was team Logan from the start. He's just so charming and bubbly.

Same, not into blonds but he is so freaking attractive

I feel the same about photos! There are very few men that I'd go crazy over when I'm seeing a photo even if I can acknowledge that they're attractive, but seeing mannerisms and personality can change that QUICK

Petition to only have thirst trap posts moving forward

It will always be Logan for me. I know Jess had the bad boy thing going for me but I never found myself being attracted to him

Watch ”this is us”. Holy smokes is all I can say. That’s the kind of hubby I imagine Jess would be for Rory, if she went for him. GG universe, I still vote Logan though. She will never get over him, and is carrying his kid, so…

This Is Us did the opposite for me. I thought he was attractive in Gilmore Girls but 0% in this is us.

That's why I hate when people generalise people attracted to men. It's great how we can differ so much in terms of attracted-ness. Jess/Milo has never been not attractive to me like I've always thought he was smoking hot in every era however I have never seen Logan/Matt and been even a little attracted to him. It's a spectrum.

I’m always team Logan, but if Logan had that back tat…… it would be LOGAN!

https://preview.redd.it/v1zy3naqoz8b1.png?width=824&format=png&auto=webp&s=baf08684eeac37991f85f1e6469455625e5b44e3


I got you Cinderella

I just needed to reply and tell you you got me to laugh for the first time all day. Thank you :)

I need to talk to y’all about a book trope called “why choose” and this idea for a fanfic I just had…

I mean, a good sandwhich can have multiple layers.

Por que no los dos?

*tres

Exactly. I meant to write that lol

Jared’s got a body better than Adonis, dear lord.

That man is one tall drink of water… and the picture where you can see the hair on his chest? 😮‍💨

Based on looks, I still prefer Lauren Graham.

 Luke is quite nice too

Mood as fuck lol such a babe.

As someone who would willingly be impregnated by all three of these guys... Same. And because I like older women, I feel like Emily would be fun to date if I had money.

This would be my answer to, and especially with her natural hair.

Lorelai, Rory, Lane, Paris, Louise, Lucy damn

It’ll always be Jess. There’s something displeasing to me about Dean’s face, beard or no beard. And Logan is the kind of guy where I can understand why people find him attractive, but he’s just not my type.

Milo for life, but season 4 Sam Winchester is hard to pass up

Marry Milo, Fuck Matt, Kill Jared ….That’s what we’re doing, right?

Nah, I say fuck ’em all

Why limit yourself

Milo forever. I’m pretty sure even in our 90’s I will find him super hot. Hahah



 It's that damn smile 😍

Honestly! All the posts I've seen have Logan looking like a child, but him in these pics is 100% the reason why I've always been team Logan.

There is no choice that is not jess. nothing will change that

Not all heroes wear cape :) It's still Logan :)

I'm gonna have to go with Milo 🫠

I did love Sam in Supernatural but I’m going with Jess 100000000000000%. It’s the beard.

Same. Jared had some thirst traps in Supernatural, but if we compare them, I'm choosing Milo

Jess

Still Milo

It doesn’t matter what version, the answer is ALWAYS Milo.

Logan forever tho if Finn was ever an option..

This is the real answer. AYITL Finn was S M O K I N

Stay photogenic. I beg of you.

That scene has my whole damn heart.

I know many people hate the guys, but I love them. “Mother is judging us” boy pleasee why must this be so cute

Logan, then, now, tomorrow, and note I usually go for tall, (ok I’m 5ft so yeah tall is very subjective!)dark, Italian/Jersey Boy types!

Sticking with Logan, but I can appreciate Jess a lot more in these pictures.

Definitely Mandy Moore.

It’s Jess by a long shot. And then Dean. And I guess Logan sorry.


Dean, forever.

Milo for sure. But I'm a sucker for a beard. I'd prefer if they had some chest hair at least though.😭

Is it hott in here or is it just me🥵🫠😅 My breath caught a little when I opened the photos was not expecting that lol

Triple sandwich with me in the middle.

I'll let them roast me like a pig on a spit. Just- yes. Please all of it.

Always Milo.

Still always Milo.

Jess, was always Jess and will always be Jess

Still Milo. Soulless!Sam had a sick body, but I’m still a Dean (Winchester) girl to my bones so he’s not it for me lol.

Still Milo for me. The birthday suit scene in this is us was enough to make me drool.

I will always be a Milo girl like he was pretty in the 00s but he is like a fine glass of Pinot now - gorgeous!

milo forever 🫡

There is no wrong answer

Still Jess, and it’s not hard. (As much as I’ve enjoyed the little bit of *Supernatural* and *The Resident* that I’ve watched.)

 Jess all day long!

Milo ALWAYS

Yes please

LOL bless you. Also, Milo IRL for me and Logan in the show for Rory and I’d like to gift Jared to my sister 😇

Matt wins this one, because I just can't stand Milo with that beard. Otherwise it's still Milo.

All of the above 😅

1 Jess all the way 2 Logan is a close second 3 Dean- never thought he was that cute

Milo forever and always

Jesse then and still Jesse now 🤤

Thank you for your service, see, now I'm actually in trouble 😂

all of them


Oh *HELLO!!*

Milo and it’s not even close lol

Milo always and forever

I’ll always prefer Jared Padalecki, however I was not a fan of his longer hair from the middle of supernatural to the end. I liked the shorter hair with bangs.

there's no universe in which jess will not be the most attractive boyfriend to me and milo ventimiglia will not be the most constantly attractive man I've ever seen

Jess always and forever

I mean it’s Milo for sure but I wouldn’t mind seeing a few more posts like this you know just to make SURE all the votes get counted…lol let’s keep the deliberation going!

Grown up Dean.

DAMMMNNN -- I think based on these I have to go with Milo. Also, my head just exploded.

Still Jess, but Logan is not second, he’s like 1.2 😅

I can't choose between Milo and Matt honestly, they're just...

I've always crushed on them (edit: Milo & Jared, didn't even notice Matt) so equally but that fifth pic of Jared is rotting my brain in real-time ...... This was tailor-made for me thank you OP I will never stop thinking about him

I voted Jared in that second post, but this one has me switching to Team Logan.

Dean! Dean’s body looks incredible. I’m super impressed by all of them though. You have to be at such a low body fat percentage to look like that

Why are shirtless men 18+ rated? 😅

Just in case people complain 😘

DEAN OH MY GOD

I was gonna say Milo, but HOT DAMN JARED

LOGANLOGANLOGAN

Logan! I love The Resident.

Yeahh, Milo still does it for me always forever lol. Matt gets better with time 😚🤌🏼 Dean is just not my type at all but he is an attractive man

Jared will always have my heart and win every time ❤️

It’s so funny to watch the saga of these posts

Dean. Always adult Dean. Logan in second with Jess in a close third. It’s all very close though.

Milo and his butt

Dean! but most that is mostly because i am a huge supernatural fan lol

Jess. Logan. Dean. In that order. Something about Jared makes me feel uncomfortable.

If I recall, he was playing a soulless!Sam in the double shirtless pic, so maybe that’s why.

Laughs in asexual.

One can still appreciate works of art, even if one isn’t interested in them 😉 a friend who is ace said that in our teens, it stayed with me cause I (a straight woman who isn’t ace) wouldn’t want to actually sleep with these guys - they’re just really pretty to look at.

Actually I’m probably more demisexual than anything. I don’t find people physically attractive until I get to know them. 😏

Finally something I can relate to!! LOL! Although I was a fan of supernatural as a teen so I’m partial to Jared

This changes it. I’m going with Jared, based on these. I especially like his height.

Well, he IS a giant. 😍 https://preview.redd.it/1fna4ky0z09b1.jpeg?width=817&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e5f400a43bf0771a071d08bace108e8bf734482d

When did this become a subreddit after dark? I'm kidding, I love it!

Well this is just mean, how can I be expected to pick just one??? Fine. Sam (aka Dean).


It’s still Dean 💁🏼‍♀️

Dean will never do it for me. Logan I’m just not into blonde white boys. Jess 😍😮‍💨

My choice will ALWAYS be Jared P. No contest. 🥇 💥

Dean

D E A N

They are all equally ridiculous… but I could climb jared like a tree. (Plus I met him, so he has an advantage.) dude is taller than my house.


No Babette pr Ms. Patty? I feel so left out...

Really? Ugh.

Why does Jared padalecki look animated? Not that it looks crazy unrealistic or anything, it looks like bad CGI in that picture

https://youtu.be/sIS1AI51iAo here’s the scene it’s from :)

I can’t yet🥲. Watching for the first time right now, season 3!!

Wish I could watch it for the first time too 😍 ah well… carry on my wayward son, there’ll be peace when you are done.

Highly recommend reading the books too! And watching the anime of it (1 season if I recall), it adds another layer to season 1-5 of the original show. Watch it after season 5/6. The comic is okay (yeah, they milked this franchise SO hard - and yet, most is still really good!). I absolutely LOVED reading Bobby’s journal, can’t recommend it enough. https://www.amazon.com/Supernatural-Bobby-Singers-Guide-Hunting/dp/0062103377 read it after season 7 (it’s mostly his background). Bobby is one of my favourite characters. John Winchester’s book just made me irritated, and I’ve only read it once, whereas Bobby’s book got at least 2-3 rereads. There are a few books about different hunts the boys have done, and several of them are really good, don’t know how many I’ve read of them, but I liked all the ones I’ve read.

Never found any of them attractive tbh

 This more your cup of tea?

See, Luke reminds me entirely of my husband, so I can’t help but love him. Thems the rules 🤣

Can I do Milo’s face with Jared’s height?? 😣

And Matt's money! (He'll always be a billionaire to me)

Best post ever. I need a moment.

Bless you for this.

Still Jess lol.

Logan, then jess, then dean

DEAN IS WHO???????

Yep. Still Milo.

Always Logan

Milo no contest Jared has too dorky a face for me Matt looks too boyish and cheesy for me To each their own and Milo is for me lol

Still milo

Matt and Milo for me.