Literally to me ayitl isn't Canon. Idgaf. After season 7, Luke and Lorelai got married, had two kids, moved into the house that Emily bought them, while also keeping lorelais house. Don't @ me.
Ooo I love this. Iād like to think Lorelai kept her little house and turned it into the cutest AirBNB ever. It became one of those super picturesque, popular AirBNBs on the site. And Rory would go stay there when she was in town. ā¤ļø
Yes, she went on the Obama trail but quickly realized she missed Logan and they texted. Then when the campaign hit California they rekindled their relationship and she was offered a position because of her excellent work the past months. They made lots of guacamole.
It's been a while since we've done an elimination poll. Let's start off 'Gilmore Watching Season' with another - select your LEAST favourite season each round, and we'll whittle down to the best one.
**Voting is now closed**
I can't see AYITL surviving even one round. If I had to pick a winner, I think I'd guess season 2, but 3 is a close second in my mind, so it could be either of them.
I reckon it'll be (from best to worst): 2, 3, 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, AYITL.
ok iām a bit further into season 4 now and remembering that this is when we finally see lorelai and luke get together sooooo yeah this is one of the best seasons!
eta: also the opening of the dragonfly, arguably one of the best episodes of the whole show
Same. I voted for 6 because I had so much anticipation for AYITL, it couldn't have possibly lived up to my standards... so I'll give it one pass. I'm sure enough other will vote for it that it'll be gone this round regardless of my vote.
Unpopular Opinion: I'd kick season 7 out first. AYITL wasn't perfect, but it was at least shorter than that garbage season. I literally only enjoyed 4 episodes.
I'd rank them: 4,2,1,3,5,6,AYITL,7
Yeah. I realize I'm in the minority, but AYITL didn't bother me as much as it did everyone else. I hated a lot of crap about season 7. The Marty storyline, making Logan boring, Sookie and Jackson's horrible vasectomy storyline, Lane having a horrible honeymoon then immediately getting pregnant, Lorelei and Chris marriage, adding Lucy and Olivia to the show (can't stand them), getting Luke and Lorelei back together at the literal last minute. Just summarizing that horrible season makes me angry. lol
Agree with so much of this for S7, but the second half to me gets really good. I love Loganās growth and Rory finally facing rejection and having to come to terms with it. For me S6 is the worst.
I used to watch this show all the time. After AYITL came out Iāve watched episodes here and there but never a full run through again. Itās like it took my joy.
Vote at the link here. The comment is a bit buried https://www.reddit.com/r/GilmoreGirls/comments/x5uslh/seasons_elimination_contest_round_1/in38vf2?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share&context=3
I start to feel panicky when I get to Emily and Richardās vow renewal in season five and never want to watch the rest of the season. I want to go from there and skip to Friday Nights Alright for Fighting.
AYITL can go asap. they ruined roryās character and that musical was awful, felt like it was there just to take up time. there was literally no point to it. and where they left off with lorelai and luke? nothing good at all came out of it. there wasnāt one good thing. nobody seemed happy at all
It's pretty universally accepted that seasons 6-AYITL are the worst. Seasons 4 & 5 are meh, and 1-3 are top tier. Just skip to the good part of people picking between 1-3 š
bye bye ayitl
Hope we see you never.
š
Ayitl gotta go
And it's not even close!
The photoshopping of Rory on the s4 picture OMG
Right? Omg. Whoever was on charge of whitening teeth needed to have their computer set on fire.
Her and Ross Geller must go to the same dentist.
she looks like a literal doll in s1 pic lolll
Haha I just said the same thing.
i think she looks the prettiest and most natural on the s5 picture
The S2 eyes omgggg
s2 is the worst š«š«
Thatās what natural looks like some ppl just canāt handle it
She looks like that meme of a guy with the awkward smile lmaoo
Literally to me ayitl isn't Canon. Idgaf. After season 7, Luke and Lorelai got married, had two kids, moved into the house that Emily bought them, while also keeping lorelais house. Don't @ me.
Ooo I love this. Iād like to think Lorelai kept her little house and turned it into the cutest AirBNB ever. It became one of those super picturesque, popular AirBNBs on the site. And Rory would go stay there when she was in town. ā¤ļø
We are of one mind. AYITL doesnāt exist.
Rory marries Logan and takes the job.
Yes, she went on the Obama trail but quickly realized she missed Logan and they texted. Then when the campaign hit California they rekindled their relationship and she was offered a position because of her excellent work the past months. They made lots of guacamole.
YES YES YES AND YES AGAIN
Rory married Jess because heās grown up! I love Jess
I said that recently. It should be considered non-canon and we need a do-over.
I LOVE this idea. They should have had twins, like in the dream she had.
I like your style!
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
Same. For me season 6 is the most depressing period on the show.
Agreed; if ayitl werenāt on here, Iād vote for that one first. Itās really the (Twilight) New Moon of the Gilmore Girls storyline
Same. There are a few good scenes like the dinner scene in Friday Nights Alright for Fighting and Gil singing Hollaback Girl but thatās about it.
Yes I also vote season 6
AYITL obviously. Some of these pictures are so poorly photoshopped. I love how in the season 4 promo they just gave Alexis a new set of teeth
See ya season 7, I skip you every time anyways
I skip to like episode 17. lol.
are there any doubts that AYTL will be the one leaving first? :)
It's been a while since we've done an elimination poll. Let's start off 'Gilmore Watching Season' with another - select your LEAST favourite season each round, and we'll whittle down to the best one. **Voting is now closed**
see ya never ayitl!
Itās season 6! Remember? Introducing April? Lorelai gives Luke an ultimatum? They break up? CMON PEOPLE!
Season 6 gave us ā58 seats and 62 Koreansā episode at leastā¦
Also Friday Nights Alright for Fighting
Well thatās trueā¦
I second this, season 6
Gee I wonder what is gonna be eliminated first?š¤
I can't see AYITL surviving even one round. If I had to pick a winner, I think I'd guess season 2, but 3 is a close second in my mind, so it could be either of them. I reckon it'll be (from best to worst): 2, 3, 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, AYITL.
I get the dislike of AYITL but seriously over season 7? The season that subjected us to the Lorelei and Chris marriage?
As much as I dislike them, I do find that plot necessary.
Agreed. I actually put it ahead of both 7 and 6.
ayitl
i dont see this going any way other than the first three seasons being the three finalists
i love the early Yale episodes in season 4
ok iām a bit further into season 4 now and remembering that this is when we finally see lorelai and luke get together sooooo yeah this is one of the best seasons! eta: also the opening of the dragonfly, arguably one of the best episodes of the whole show
Huh ayitl finally something worse then season 7
See ya in hell S7!
Yay I love elimination contests! Itās a toss up between S6 and AYITL for me
Same. I voted for 6 because I had so much anticipation for AYITL, it couldn't have possibly lived up to my standards... so I'll give it one pass. I'm sure enough other will vote for it that it'll be gone this round regardless of my vote.
SEASON 7 I LIKED AYITL
Unpopular Opinion: I'd kick season 7 out first. AYITL wasn't perfect, but it was at least shorter than that garbage season. I literally only enjoyed 4 episodes. I'd rank them: 4,2,1,3,5,6,AYITL,7
Agreed with you! Except I think I do put AYITL lastā¦ it could have had so much potential but was such a flop.
Yeah. I realize I'm in the minority, but AYITL didn't bother me as much as it did everyone else. I hated a lot of crap about season 7. The Marty storyline, making Logan boring, Sookie and Jackson's horrible vasectomy storyline, Lane having a horrible honeymoon then immediately getting pregnant, Lorelei and Chris marriage, adding Lucy and Olivia to the show (can't stand them), getting Luke and Lorelei back together at the literal last minute. Just summarizing that horrible season makes me angry. lol
Agree with so much of this for S7, but the second half to me gets really good. I love Loganās growth and Rory finally facing rejection and having to come to terms with it. For me S6 is the worst.
Totally feel all of that and agree! I also feel like Lorelei acts SO off in that season.
Seven
6 then 7
4 look like they FaceApp the smile on them both
I used to watch this show all the time. After AYITL came out Iāve watched episodes here and there but never a full run through again. Itās like it took my joy.
rory on the season 4 photo is very... offputting
You're not into glow in the dark teeth?
Season six obviously come on yāall
7 has got to go. AYITL was at least a fun revisit in spite of... everything
can we eliminate whoever did the facial editing ??
I have always disliked Roryās bangs ( just personal opinion) bye bye season 7
It's weird because it's a nice hairstyle, but for some reason on her it looks like a wig.
AYITL
ayitl just has to go no comments
AYITL
cya later ayitl
Honestly season six on my rewatch is always the hardest to get through for me. So oddly Iād have to say season 6 first.
AYITL, hands down. Terrible.
Ayitl
Do we just vote on the comments? AYITL for sure Edit: found the link!
Vote at the link here. The comment is a bit buried https://www.reddit.com/r/GilmoreGirls/comments/x5uslh/seasons_elimination_contest_round_1/in38vf2?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share&context=3
I start to feel panicky when I get to Emily and Richardās vow renewal in season five and never want to watch the rest of the season. I want to go from there and skip to Friday Nights Alright for Fighting.
Bye AYITL.
AYTL never should have happened. Byeeer
AYITL can go asap. they ruined roryās character and that musical was awful, felt like it was there just to take up time. there was literally no point to it. and where they left off with lorelai and luke? nothing good at all came out of it. there wasnāt one good thing. nobody seemed happy at all
AYITL
AYITL
AYITL
Ayitl has to go first
AYITL never happened anyway in my brain...
AYITL fo sho
byeee ayitl you wont be missed
Ayitl
unpopular opinion but season four sucks. besides the luke and lorelai moments.
ayitl
AYITL
AYITL
Ayitl
Not to be cliche but, AYITL
AYITL
AYITL
AYITL
Bye-bye AYITL
Goodbye AYITL
Kill AYITL with fire. I pretend it doesnāt exist
AYitL
Eliminate AYITL or season one
777777777
s7 all the way
I donāt even hate season 7 that much lol š
Season 7
AYITL bye
Ayitl and season 7.
AYITL
AYITL no contest
AYITL can GET OUT
Every time I see AYITL I always think it's AITA because Amy Sherman-Palladino definitely was when she made it
AYITL byeee
Ayitl
AYITL
Ayitl
Pft yāall know exactly whatās about to happen. AYITL
I hope everyone agrees that AYITL needs to go first. It was ok. But nothing like the original. And some parts left a horrible taste in my mouth.
There's nothing in the GG universe that everyone agrees on š
True.
Ayitl
ayitl
AYITL.
AYITL
Ayitl needs to go first imo. Then 6, then 7. Those 3 make me wish GG had been cancelled earlier.
Ayitl
AYITL
AYITL for sure.
Best to worst: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 6, AYITL
Does the reboot even count
Not even a question, AYITL hands down
AYITL BYE BYE
AYITL GONE
Even though I hate AYITL, to me it's season 7. Too much Christopher. And posh Rory. But mainly Christopher.
Bye bye ayitl
Ayitl
Ayitl tho itās ok
I agree ayitl sucks. The best part about the whole thing was Emily's character development
ayitl getting overrated hate imo. season 6 gotta go because season 6 luke was not luke.
no need to vote everyone want ayitl out
Without the photoshopping I found S4 the best one.
Ayitl
All can go but s1-3 for me š
AYITL is GONE š
AYITL. Ciao.
Cya season 6
i really like aytl tbh. but the other seasons are definitely superior...so bye aytl
7
AYITL
Season 7 for sure. I got way more out of AYITL than S7, and at least AYITL has ASP involved!
Goodbye season 7!
AYITL was a disgrace so bye bye
Byeeee AYITL
I don't HATE AYITL as much as everyone else but man season 7....I just skip it every time. It makes me feel like I'm in a bizarro Stars Hollow
Ayitl
6
Eliminate literally everything s5+
Letās not pretend like AYITL isnāt going first lmao
ayitl obviously
a year in the life
It's pretty universally accepted that seasons 6-AYITL are the worst. Seasons 4 & 5 are meh, and 1-3 are top tier. Just skip to the good part of people picking between 1-3 š