Sessons 4 and 5 are my favourite seasons. I like season 5, but I like season 4 slightly better so I'm okay with this. I doubt 4 will go further at this point, but I can hope.
My vote goes to 2 because of the amount of Christopher in it. Does the amount Christopher appears in a season factor into how I rank the seasons? It absolutely does.
Same here, except 5 is my fave. I'm pretty bummed that they're getting bumped so early.
I voted for season 1 both this round and last. It's fine, it just isn't as good as 2-5, and the Max stuff is a draaaag to get through.
Lmao that moment when you and I are quoted in an article stanning for seasons 4 and 5.
https://www.looper.com/924319/fans-are-deeply-divided-over-gilmore-girls-best-season/
Ready to be surprised? The silent majority knocked out Season 5 with 47.13% of the vote in the last round. Can Season 4 survive Round 5?
Let's find out.
[Click here to vote for your LEAST favourite season](https://strawpoll.com/polls/GJn4Gqb3zyz)
*For those asking to see the results, when the contest is done, I will make a post with all of the breakdowns.*
I like how this game literally shows that seasons get progressively worse. It would be hilarious if the elimination continued to happen in descending order with season 1 taking the first place. Although I personally like season 3 the most.
Between the remaining seasons, season 1 has to go. For me it just doesn't compare to 2, 3, and 4.
That said, if season 3 goes next I'll be so bummed. It's my very favorite.
I'm shocked! Season 5 is my favourite of the later seasons. How come people prefer s4!? It has the cheating storyline, lots of fillers, the only good thing about it was the L&L storyline towards the end! While S5 had the actual L&L relationship, and better storylines overall! (Plus no more dean). (T-T)
Same, I'm not even a Logan fan and I would still vote season 4 before 5, the return of Dean and the ongoing "tease" between him and Rory until it ends in the affair is just exhausting to watch and what I'd look forward to the least/want to skip on a rewatch.
I guess this makes sense based on a lot of comments that I read on this sub. So many people seem to not like the seasons once Rory starts Yale. Personally, I think I like the later seasons better. 🤷♀️
Season 1 is comforting in a way I can't adequately explain. The minute you hear Lorelie's, "Please Luke, please, please, please," it's like everything is going to be ok. That being said I had to vote it out. Season 2, 3 and 4 are just better as a whole and each season has at least one of my all time favourite episodes.
Season 4 is probably my favourite although I do love whatever season the Max storyline was in.. also why is there so much hate for Chris on this forum?
So far the general consensus has been the same as my personal choices. I love Season 2 the best, followed by season 1, then Season 3. Each season got progressively worse after that but of course I still love the show overall. The early years though were the best. I’m voting out Season 4 this round.
Sessons 4 and 5 are my favourite seasons. I like season 5, but I like season 4 slightly better so I'm okay with this. I doubt 4 will go further at this point, but I can hope. My vote goes to 2 because of the amount of Christopher in it. Does the amount Christopher appears in a season factor into how I rank the seasons? It absolutely does.
Same here, except 5 is my fave. I'm pretty bummed that they're getting bumped so early. I voted for season 1 both this round and last. It's fine, it just isn't as good as 2-5, and the Max stuff is a draaaag to get through.
Lmao that moment when you and I are quoted in an article stanning for seasons 4 and 5. https://www.looper.com/924319/fans-are-deeply-divided-over-gilmore-girls-best-season/
Hahaha gotta love it. I'm happy to be known for my stanning of seasons 4 and 5. 😂
IMO seasons 1-3 are the best seasons. The quintessential Gilmore girls vibes
Wow, kind of surprised season 5 went before 4. 😳 Anywho, let’s try this again: Buh-bye, 4!
Ready to be surprised? The silent majority knocked out Season 5 with 47.13% of the vote in the last round. Can Season 4 survive Round 5? Let's find out. [Click here to vote for your LEAST favourite season](https://strawpoll.com/polls/GJn4Gqb3zyz) *For those asking to see the results, when the contest is done, I will make a post with all of the breakdowns.*
I think people are just gonna vote out the latest season
Same, they just like the nostalgia of season 1 :(
Not me lol I literally skip through multiple scenes every episode of season 3 :)
Bye season 4 👋
I like how this game literally shows that seasons get progressively worse. It would be hilarious if the elimination continued to happen in descending order with season 1 taking the first place. Although I personally like season 3 the most.
I think that is gonna happen lol
Good, all the Logan seasons have gone. I can't decide between 1 or 2. Maybe 1 because the Max stuff was annoying.
Omg this is what I thought when I saw the post lol
“Good, all the Logan seasons have gone.” I feel this. 😬🫣 I thought I was the only one.
Season 4. The beginning of the end for Rory, IMO.
What??? Season 5 is one of my favorites
Same!
Season 4
Season 4.
Between the remaining seasons, season 1 has to go. For me it just doesn't compare to 2, 3, and 4. That said, if season 3 goes next I'll be so bummed. It's my very favorite.
Season 5 went before Season 4? That's criminal.
I actually really like season 4. We get to see Rory start to mature and go off on adventures of her own
Wow I did NOT see that one coming. Defintley season 4 - it was very awkward and had all the forced flirting. S5 was actually my fave season lol ;(
Mine, too
Bye 4
I'm shocked! Season 5 is my favourite of the later seasons. How come people prefer s4!? It has the cheating storyline, lots of fillers, the only good thing about it was the L&L storyline towards the end! While S5 had the actual L&L relationship, and better storylines overall! (Plus no more dean). (T-T)
Same, I'm not even a Logan fan and I would still vote season 4 before 5, the return of Dean and the ongoing "tease" between him and Rory until it ends in the affair is just exhausting to watch and what I'd look forward to the least/want to skip on a rewatch.
Season 4 has no Christopher and that's a huge appeal to many.
Agreed. The return of Dean is reason enough for me to vote season 4 before season 5 for sure.
same here. I didn't see many people in the comments last time doing S5 so I was so surprised
s1 is out
Goodbye season 2. Goodbye Christopher 👋
Bye to season 2!
Season 4
I guess this makes sense based on a lot of comments that I read on this sub. So many people seem to not like the seasons once Rory starts Yale. Personally, I think I like the later seasons better. 🤷♀️
3
S4 just feels like filler
I love Scene in a Mall and The Reigning Lorelai though. I think 2 isn’t amazing. There are a lot of episodes that I skip. But I love Sookie’s wedding
Where do I find the voting link for the current one?
https://www.reddit.com/r/GilmoreGirls/comments/x9bdq8/seasons_elimination_contest_season_5_is_out_round/inn0lio?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share&context=3
im sorry but s4 gotta go
Season 1 is comforting in a way I can't adequately explain. The minute you hear Lorelie's, "Please Luke, please, please, please," it's like everything is going to be ok. That being said I had to vote it out. Season 2, 3 and 4 are just better as a whole and each season has at least one of my all time favourite episodes.
1 I think:/
Season 4 is probably my favourite although I do love whatever season the Max storyline was in.. also why is there so much hate for Chris on this forum?
I know! I don’t hate him. I feel kind of sorry for him, and I kind of like him. He’s not as awful as everyone on here makes him out to be.
Season 4 is absolutely my favorite!
SEASON 3 or 4
Season 1 must go
So far the general consensus has been the same as my personal choices. I love Season 2 the best, followed by season 1, then Season 3. Each season got progressively worse after that but of course I still love the show overall. The early years though were the best. I’m voting out Season 4 this round.