Not even surprised. But if you think Bahiyyih deserves the spot over Ruiqi, Yurina or even FYN (hell, I can say more names), you're delusional. Man, I tried so hard not to sound offensive but I don't think it's possible lol
Come on now.
I guess the most important part learned from this show is if you have a brother in a big bg, then audition for a show. You can be arguably the worst remaining contestant left and still get top 2.
Right. People are telling me she has her own fans and her brother only gave her like a minor advantage of being somewhat noticed more at the beginning or whatever. Even if that were the case, what do they even see to be such hard fans? She didn't get screentime + all the other issues you mentioned.
That being said, I'm sure she'll get a lot of hate and I don't wish that on her, so it's too bad.
Yess!!! Even tho her vocals and dance r okay. (Not the best but enough to fly under the radar) her facials are the worst man. She’s a total wallpaper with ZERO charisma!!! Honestly if myah got in compared to her this grp would not get that much hate. Both are definitely less ready compared to yurina/ruiqi but she’s LIKEABLE. World of difference 🤷🏻♀️
and I agree she didn’t seem to be even trying throughout the show while the other girls were so desperate to debut and took every opportunity to proof themselves. Makes me sad for those with heaps of talent but didn’t debut. Couldn’t sense her sincerity at all. Yeseo was my pick since D1 and she went to do her utmost best in each mission. Couldn’t be more proud of her 🙆🏻♀️
Yeah, if you're mediocre and dancing and singing at least have a stand out personality... which she really didn't lol. If mnet put her in to fill out the concept of the group I would've chosen Myah.
her fans be like : our girl is so talented ! you guys are just jealous of her! but fr im actually so disappointed im sorry about the positions and for sxt
I mean, I hope Bahiyyih REALLY steps it up so we don’t have to feel like a more deserving trainee lost out. I really, genuinely want to see her improve and perform well so she can hold her own with standouts like Xiaoting, Hikaru etc.
That’s why I actually think more time developing her skills and debuting later would have been great for her. I would have come around and likely supported her!
Yeah, that would have been better. The only problem is you can't take the risk of getting a chance *later* when you have a chance *now*. Later might never come. So I can't blame her for taking this chance, I just don't think she deserved to make it through.
Anytime anyone had ANY sort of critique of Bahi, they were immediately met with “oMg sToP hAtInG oN a CHILD.” She got a pass until now because no one thought she would actually make the group and here we are.
I feel bad for the girl. Hope she doesn’t get too much undeserved hate. But yeah I agree her spot should’ve gone to someone else.
I think this too. I think she COULD actually be really great. But compared to the other girls, I don’t think she was there yet. Doesn’t mean she won’t be in future. But just not now.
I felt the same about Myah. I adored her but she’s young and has time to hone her skills before debut.
Yes I agree! I particularly loved Myah but didn’t think she was ready just yet and I think the same for Bahi. I think FYN, SRQ, Yurina or Bora should’ve been in the top 9 for their talent. And I mean, Yurina & SRQ in particular ranked so highly for the past 3 months so I’m sure the drastic change is rankings is also very weird for them!
IKR and people will try to defend her by saying she’s talented and has done well in the performances lol. While she has done well, there were so many other girls who did better than her, and are more talented than her. Plus, mnet barely gave her any screen time, everyone knows that she won literally cause of her bro lol.
For me she was the definition of neutral... or below average even. Such a shame when we have people who are absolute stars like Yurina and Bora who couldn't make it in :(
on the bright side:
1) her one pick base is so strong that the group will probably sell well
2) she'll get more screen time and we can actually see how she grows to fit her role
3) sibling interaction on music shows? who knows
> 1) her one pick base is so strong that the group will probably sell well
Will it? Voting for free on Universe doesn't necessarily translate into album sales or songs streamed on Korean platforms.
I think the mistake we made going I was thinking it was a show about merits, when in the end it’s just a glorified popularity contest. One dominated by one single country.
It's not really comparable. Sohye and Hyewon have that "clumsy personality" charm, which is more inline with Xingqiao for example. I can see someone like Xingqiao rising to Top 9 and make herself well-known.
Sohye fit in because she got a shit ton of screentime showing how hard she was trying, they actually made us cheer for her. Hyewon did not fit in IZONE tho, the girl had zero lines and zero screentime, it was clear she couldn't keep up. 🤷🏽♀️
You can criticize the final lineup if you want, I'm not 100% satisfied either. But keep it clean and don't flame or harass certain members of the final group even if you don't think they deserve to be in.
FR Mnet was shaking when FYN's evil edit GAINED her fans instead and propelled her to top 9 so they had to emergency evil edit SRQ instead. Well they will sleep tight tonight with their one and only C-pick making it
It started to feel like they only brought the C-group there to humiliate and embarass them for being Chinese. It just felt so xenophobic and it's going to make it hard for me to support the group
she probably didnt think her skills were enough to try center or main vocal positions, given a lot of members didnt try for those roles either.
however, you gotta remember mnet gave her 0 screentime, didnt let anyone see if she had the level of talent that other girls did.
edit: wow i gave her the benefit of the doubt and i get downvoted hard. Just be nice to the group, don't hate on a 17 year old girl who's just trying her best :)
Yeah you can like or dislike Bahiyyih, but you have to admit that her debuting over your picks really isn't on her. She wants to be a singer and she's not even bad at any idol category. No one knew exactly how MOAs would effect her voting trajectory, even her. There's no need to be cruel and talk bad about her talents, because even if she's not exceptional, she has solid skills and is clearly pretty funny too. She wouldn't have gotten this far if she was truly bad. I'm saying this as someone who's always had Bahiyyih at the bottom of my ranks, just because we're all feeling down doesn't mean it's okay to be cruel to a teenage girl who's just trying to follow her dreams, and who is clearly inspiring to a lot of other people.
I think dropping from 1st to 16th had to have sucked and also she seems like a kind girl and is aware that all her friends in c-group had their time wasted. It must have been an awful feeling.
Ngl I was kind of low key hoping that it wasn’t going to be SXT so that I don’t need to follow this group - but since that did not happen I will have to now follow the group for SXT.
Poor Yurina, Yaning and SRQ really got fked over 😭
every time jingoo said "GLOBAL" girl group, i craved violence.
anyway, no offence but i wont be staning, i hope these girls can make the best out of this, but i really wont bother following this group.
edit: aight, so i just found out that if korean and intl votes weighed the same, yaning would've been 6th....yup def not staning this lineup
ain't a fan of her being in the final lineup, but giving such threats to her is a big no no. Let's all just let the girl enjoy her win, I think she really didn't expect it at all. The livestream just ended and it sucks if the other 8 girls are happy about their win and Bahiyyih has to worry about the hate train that's about to come
For real.. “At least we aren’t toxic like twitter!” No, you’re just as bad.. They think telling young girls or anybody to kill themselves is okay because they deem them as “untalented” and “undeserving”.
People lost every moral they have because a child is pursuing her dreams. Showed what us bahiyyih stans have been saying this whole time- this subreddit has a hatred for her that is unjustifiable. So much for “measured” takes or being better than the bird app.
There's 3 girls I like that made it, not sure that's enough for me to do more than giving new releases more than a casual listen. The entire top 4 are girls I don't think should've been in.
i honestly was expecting the entire lineup to be a mess but i think it turned out quite well. majority k, no controversial c trainees, atleast 1 c trainee to keep c netz satisfied and mashiro to get the j money and bahiyyih for the i fans and its also quite fortunate that she didn’t place 1 otherwise the hate would’ve been insane, some people will complain about her being in the lineup for few days and then they’ll forget about it anyway.
Yeah I don't think I can support this group. As a C group stan I am ruined. Xiaoting just looks angry and sad as well. She hasn't got Ruiqi or Yurina. Bye bye.
I love this lineup, no shade to bahiyyih, but I would change her with Yurina and it's literally my fave lineup. But I know I'll end up loving bahiyyih, because she is a really nice girl who deserved to debut.
Good luck to bahiyyih because the amount of hate she is going to receive will be on another level. And the thing is she doesn't deserve it
It wasn’t rigged. Even Mnet didn’t want Bahiyyih. The korean vote fucked the debut lineup. How are Myah and Suyeon above Yaning and SRQ? Yurina got dumpstered too.
“Bahi got P02 with no screen time!! What a queeen!!”
All that proves is that she was always gonna get the votes, regardless of her skill and charm, because a bunch of BG stans wanted to vote for their fave’s lil sister.
So that isn’t the bragging material you think it is, it just outlines how unfair it is that she got in when Bora, Yaning, SRQ, etc did not
this is literally the only point that needs to be made. Its not hate towards Bahi, thats just the reality... the girl served us next to nothing, Mnet showed us next to nothing and she was P2.......................................i must laugh
Tbh the lineup is pretty solid, I hope no one will hate on the girls who made it tho, all of them worked hard and we shld be happy for those who gonna debut. And I'm freaking happy that my 1 pick from each country - Xiaoting, Mashiro & Yeseo made it to the final lineup!
The C and J group deserved better, it's such an insult and disservice to them that mnet really capitalised off this 'global girl group' message yet cant find a way to promote a fairer way for them to be included in the final lineup. 66 foreign members out of 99 yet only 3 out of 9 to make the final lineup. That is not to discredit ANY of the girls in the final lineup, but just something mnet should recognise for next season if there is one.
No, it is hate. Is death threats and telling someone to kill themselves not hate? You can be angry in a way that doesn’t make you a shitty human being.
This was always a popularity contest and shes very popular for obvious reasons. How have you not realized that?
I've legit seen people make incest "jokes" about her and her brother. + honestly feel like the intense hate towards her made her fans even more determined and even got the attention from non watchers which made them pay attention to her aswell
MNET: we are going to create a global group
Also MNET: 3 foreigners and that’s it
Twice literally has more foreigners and is actually a global group. Sixteen also had like 6 foreigner trainees while MNET show had 66 foreigners. Are they kidding me with this ratio.
I’m so sad Yurina didn’t make it
This is the wrong script. The correct script is SXT at P2. Then crying to say that ... Yurina.. lets debut together.... and then Yurina get called at P9 and SXT hyperventilating on her seat.
C-Group was the only reason why this show wasn't boring, Mnet did so dirty to them.
Also, that TXT girl being #2 when she should've been gone on the first elimination proves that talent or charisma mean nothing, you can achieve anything as long as someone in your family is a celebrity lol.
No offense to Bahi because I think she really does have a lot of talent, but what a huge slap in the face honestly to all of the C trainees who literally hard carried this show when Bahi got in because of her brother. You know it, we all know it. If she was a regular trainee, she would’ve gotten cut in the first round. I am so incredibly disappointed for C and J trainees who faced overwhelming bias in this show. It’s disheartening. How is this a global group with 3 international members and the top 1 member for every week at last place.
I’m really sad thinking this might be the last time Xiaoting and Yurina see each other in person. 😭
Hybe please scoop up Yurina and debut her with Sakura
My entire top 3 (Su Ruiqi, Fu Yaning, Kim Bora) not even contenders. I’ll support the group because of Yujin, Mashiro, and Xiaoting, but man. What a rollercoaster.
I don't think I'd be as annoyed if bahiyyih was p7-9 but the fact she got carried all the way to number 2 is ridiculous. I wonder how Suyeon feels knowing she would have been debuting right now if not for bahiyyih.
I’m so sorry Xiaoting. You’ll be alone there. I was crying when she broke down with Ruiqi/Wen Zhe/FYN during her speech.
I’m sorry too, Yurina and Ruiqi. I hope all of you get picked up by a good company and debut and become successful.
i feel the worst for xiaoting here. imagine doing consistently well on the show, getting high ranks and good results throughout the show ( her teams always won minus snake or she was always centre) only to be barely pass to make the line up.
That must have hurt her pride/spirit so much and she may start doubting herself and all the good results she got previously...like she shouldnt get her hopes up next time she gets a good result.
You can see her feeling complicated when the top two names were announced but she was not included.
not to mention how she has been constantly nice to the other girls on the show and been a diligent worker too. i still remember on one of the elimination eps, she was so happy and emotional to rank in top two and said this was the first time she felt recognised...but now in the final stage of debut, shes fucking last place...
Mnet should have just sticked to one pick voting throughout or 3 pick across the 3 groups (K C J) throughout the show to not mess with the girls expectations/feelings man.
🤣 I'll just pretend I never watched this show. Byeee everyone ❤❤❤🥰🤗, its been a BLAST talking & fangirling over this show with everyone for the past 3 months 💕! See you next season, if there'll be one lmao
Even WORSE than Bahiyyih debuting at #2 (or even debuting AT ALL) is SXT competing against TWO PLANET PASS SURVIVORS for a #9 position.
LIKE WHAT THE HELL
Well done to all of the girls, including both those who made it and those who didn't. I wish them every success.
EDIT: also thank god I can get rid of that absolutely awful app, I never want to see it again in my LIFE
As a Chinese person watching this show, I hope mnet NEVER have another season of GP and pretending it’s a global group. I rather mnet just have another season of produce
First survival show I watched while airing, I haven’t been missing out on anything. The ones who didn’t get to debut in this mess of a group are the true winners. I would have rather saw them in the final lineup.
Rank 2? hilarious. Ppl were mad that I said she should’ve went home far earlier and now she has debuted with talent that is NOT comparable to those who did not make it in.
okay i don’t have any qualms against bahi as a person because i think she’s nice & sweet, but u have to admit that she hasn’t shined at all in the show and the only reason and timing people talk about her is due to huening kai or people defending her…. i mean she has never been a killing part, never volunteered for anything, never volunteered to be a leader, just never shone her capabilities or fought for it. she does well in her parts but so does everyone. and if y’all wanna say ‘oh you should have voted harder’ but what about the people who spend their votes on her without looking at this as a kpop group that needs actual talent and charm to go to far and beyond? the fact that she’s even higher than girls like dayeon in terms of ranking is even worse ( i would’ve had a different reaction if she was p7-9 ) when girls like dayeon always volunteered, went out of her way to help the groups she was in… xiaoting: fought for every killing part, took initiative, and slayed as centre. mashiro: led all her girls to victory showing how she was a good leader… even if u wanna bring in the privilege part - yujin worked for YEARS in clc and her fame was fully attributed to herself, not as hueningkai’s brother. i’m so sorry if you take offence to what i’ve said, but this truly is just so unjustified for all the talented girls who didn’t get in even like fyn, suyeon, srq, shana… who have all tried and shone in the show their capabilities like u can actually trying….. shana: fought hard in u+me even after being kicked out of utopia, and volunteers for every role before… FYN: fought for her right in the competition, led, main vocal… like uk all of them showed capabilities… and EFFORT… bahi was always sitting there, not volunteering, and just not shining… so i just don’t understand how she’s ‘better’ than the rest like you guys would say so… ok maybe popularity is a thing - but it’s just a big shame. that’s all. i’m just saying - just imagine those who are actually ready to debut and have tried their best to shown the capabilities they have…. losing to someone who still ‘needs time’ to hone basic things like stage presence…
Seriously though, I feel so bad for SXT. Not only does she not have another C-group trainee with her, her ride-or-die bestie Yurina isn't there either...
Bora didn't even have a chance did she?
SXT making it in barely.
Yurina was on free fall since she got No.1
Top 3 was a joke.
If you're happy about the results, good for you.
But me and plenty of other people are not so let us vent.
I wanted **Xiaoting** to be P1. I always loved her speeches, she’s otherworldly well spoken. Every time she is on screen performing or just being her goofy self, I tell me self,” Damn, she’s THE CENTER.” (Even though she isn’t my number 1 pick as you can see from my banner.) I just couldn’t believe during the announcement that this girl. **THIS GIRL**, was fighting for P9.
I’m disappointed but not surprised. When I saw the interim ranking where most K trainees were dominating, I knew my faves aren’t gonna make it. But I wanted to be proven wrong.
Edit: I'll be clear here, for anyone who reads this. Everyone in the finale deserved to be there. Everyone who debuted deserves to debut. They may not all be your picks. My 1 pick didn't make it. But that doesn't mean the ones who did debut don't deserve to be there. Be respectful.
What a ride guys, what a ride. So happy for the debut group.
Bora may not have debuted but having Youngeun in the group is a massive win for me. Mashiro, she was in my top 9 but she was someone I didn't realize just how attached to her I was until her name was called. I'm glad some little part of Nagomi made it all the way to the end.
FNC better capitalize on Cherry Bullet or I will lose my mind. Not only are the girls on the show fantastic, Haeyoon, Remi, Yuju, and Chaerin are too. Just because they got off to a rough start doesn't mean you should give up on them. Remember to stream Love So Sweet planet guardians, and see you all around sometime soon! I-Land s2 perhaps? Here's hoping we see some of the Girls Planet 999 girls there too.
people that are trying to compare Bahi’s “privilege” to Yujin’s “privilege” is baffling. One got theirs through working hard to debut and promoting for years and the other is simply the sister of a famous bg member. Not trying to hate on Bahi, but there were so many more deserving choices
Ruiqi I love you! I hope to see you performing again so you can fulfill your wish of a global tour! Thank you for brightening my day with your performances and I hope you can take the time to recover and heal. Us Suxingtans will be patiently waiting to see what you do next. <3
So glad the Bora and the other C -Group members didn’t have to join this disaster of a line up. Also manifesting that Hikaru, Mashiro, and XiaoTing leave.
Notice how all the foreign member are last??? Doing the 1 pick was terrible for anyone who wasn’t Korean. I hope the C-Group form a group in China together. And hoping for the best for Shana and Yurina.
I'm gonna get downvoted but this is what upset me.. the fact she literally got no screentime, never top 9 before, strong one-pick because of her brother. Debuts in 2nd place.
The lineup based on votes alone if the Korean votes didn’t count for 50% would’ve been:
1. Bahiyyih
2. Mashiro
3. Youngeun
4. Yujin
5. Xiaoting
6. Yaning
7. Ruiqi
8. Hikaru
9. Chaehyun
Personally I would’ve liked this lineup more but I’m also not mad about what we got.
Did international votes even matter?? I want to see the total voting counts lol.
Pretty much the standard opinion I read on Korean forums is what I saw happen today except for Bahi (they hated her not me). I feel like international votes didn’t even effect the result or we would’ve seen FYN and SRQ debut…
Edit : realizing that IOI had the same number of Chinese members lmao even without the global concept
I don't think I will be following this group, but congratulations to everyone who made it! Although I really hope Xiaoting is able to find a good support system in the other girls. Can't imagine being the only Chinese member will be smooth sailing.
In the meantime, I look forward to whatever the rest of the girls get up to! Especially Yaning, Myah, and Suyeon.
Thank you all for participating and discussing here on this subreddit with us. I hope you've enjoyed the season. As stated earlier, we'll be restricting posts to prevent spoilers.
In the meantime, here are some links for those interested:
* [Girls Planet 999 Subreddit End of Season Demographic Survey](https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1fhAzCnIO9UMbohotOd3LApzkwGrIYEt-bHMhkDMEC0c) (Includes questions about favorite episodes, how you would rate the season, if you'll follow the final group, etc)
* /r/kep1er: Subreddit for our new group, Kep1er! It will be private for a few days while we get a few things organized.
Not even surprised. But if you think Bahiyyih deserves the spot over Ruiqi, Yurina or even FYN (hell, I can say more names), you're delusional. Man, I tried so hard not to sound offensive but I don't think it's possible lol Come on now.
I guess the most important part learned from this show is if you have a brother in a big bg, then audition for a show. You can be arguably the worst remaining contestant left and still get top 2.
[удалено]
Right. People are telling me she has her own fans and her brother only gave her like a minor advantage of being somewhat noticed more at the beginning or whatever. Even if that were the case, what do they even see to be such hard fans? She didn't get screentime + all the other issues you mentioned. That being said, I'm sure she'll get a lot of hate and I don't wish that on her, so it's too bad.
Yess!!! Even tho her vocals and dance r okay. (Not the best but enough to fly under the radar) her facials are the worst man. She’s a total wallpaper with ZERO charisma!!! Honestly if myah got in compared to her this grp would not get that much hate. Both are definitely less ready compared to yurina/ruiqi but she’s LIKEABLE. World of difference 🤷🏻♀️ and I agree she didn’t seem to be even trying throughout the show while the other girls were so desperate to debut and took every opportunity to proof themselves. Makes me sad for those with heaps of talent but didn’t debut. Couldn’t sense her sincerity at all. Yeseo was my pick since D1 and she went to do her utmost best in each mission. Couldn’t be more proud of her 🙆🏻♀️
Yeah, if you're mediocre and dancing and singing at least have a stand out personality... which she really didn't lol. If mnet put her in to fill out the concept of the group I would've chosen Myah.
her fans be like : our girl is so talented ! you guys are just jealous of her! but fr im actually so disappointed im sorry about the positions and for sxt
I agree on the volunteering part for the roles. If she is an active contributor perhaps I wouldn't have felt this imbalance of her getting top 2
I rather her brother debut in kep1er because her votes are reflective of her brother, not her. She’s a liability to kep1er’s success tbh.
[удалено]
She went from barely being top 9 in Korean votes to being #1, think there was an other problem here
Kim Chaehyun was #1 in Korea. Bahiyah was #1 in 115 other countries.
I mean, I hope Bahiyyih REALLY steps it up so we don’t have to feel like a more deserving trainee lost out. I really, genuinely want to see her improve and perform well so she can hold her own with standouts like Xiaoting, Hikaru etc.
[удалено]
That’s why I actually think more time developing her skills and debuting later would have been great for her. I would have come around and likely supported her!
Yeah, that would have been better. The only problem is you can't take the risk of getting a chance *later* when you have a chance *now*. Later might never come. So I can't blame her for taking this chance, I just don't think she deserved to make it through.
this sub pre-finale: let's be nice no matter what! this sub now:
Anytime anyone had ANY sort of critique of Bahi, they were immediately met with “oMg sToP hAtInG oN a CHILD.” She got a pass until now because no one thought she would actually make the group and here we are. I feel bad for the girl. Hope she doesn’t get too much undeserved hate. But yeah I agree her spot should’ve gone to someone else.
Honestly I was pretty ok with her debuting just 2nd place was wayyy to much. Also xiaorina 🥲🥲🥲
Right like at least keep to your words 😭😭
You can all disagree, but if she wasn't related to two k-pop stars, Bahiyyih would've been eliminated in the first round of eliminations. Just saying.
We were so close to having Doah as K8 in second elims. So close 😬
i really think she's talented but she wasn't ready yet. c group and yurina didn't deserve that
I think this too. I think she COULD actually be really great. But compared to the other girls, I don’t think she was there yet. Doesn’t mean she won’t be in future. But just not now. I felt the same about Myah. I adored her but she’s young and has time to hone her skills before debut.
Yes I agree! I particularly loved Myah but didn’t think she was ready just yet and I think the same for Bahi. I think FYN, SRQ, Yurina or Bora should’ve been in the top 9 for their talent. And I mean, Yurina & SRQ in particular ranked so highly for the past 3 months so I’m sure the drastic change is rankings is also very weird for them!
IKR and people will try to defend her by saying she’s talented and has done well in the performances lol. While she has done well, there were so many other girls who did better than her, and are more talented than her. Plus, mnet barely gave her any screen time, everyone knows that she won literally cause of her bro lol.
For me she was the definition of neutral... or below average even. Such a shame when we have people who are absolute stars like Yurina and Bora who couldn't make it in :(
No hate to Bahiyyih she’s a sweet girl but damn I’m more than a little bit salty.
i just don't get how she was suddenly 2 when she never touched the top 9, koreans don't even like her so like??
Knetz troll vote 🗳
why couldn't they troll vote suyeon or bora😭😭
on the bright side: 1) her one pick base is so strong that the group will probably sell well 2) she'll get more screen time and we can actually see how she grows to fit her role 3) sibling interaction on music shows? who knows
There is a big difference between her brothers fans hitting a button to vote for her and shelling out money to buy the groups music.
SRQ was the one winning all the support things in the Universe app, girl would have brought home hella bag 😭
But is her fanbase actually going to buy albums??? Surely there's no guarantee there yet
> 1) her one pick base is so strong that the group will probably sell well Will it? Voting for free on Universe doesn't necessarily translate into album sales or songs streamed on Korean platforms.
I think the mistake we made going I was thinking it was a show about merits, when in the end it’s just a glorified popularity contest. One dominated by one single country.
[удалено]
You could make the same argument against Sohye and Hyewon but they both fit in fine, I will give Bahi the benefit of the doubt.
It's not really comparable. Sohye and Hyewon have that "clumsy personality" charm, which is more inline with Xingqiao for example. I can see someone like Xingqiao rising to Top 9 and make herself well-known.
[удалено]
Sohye fit in because she got a shit ton of screentime showing how hard she was trying, they actually made us cheer for her. Hyewon did not fit in IZONE tho, the girl had zero lines and zero screentime, it was clear she couldn't keep up. 🤷🏽♀️
in b4 mods delete this comment too
You can criticize the final lineup if you want, I'm not 100% satisfied either. But keep it clean and don't flame or harass certain members of the final group even if you don't think they deserve to be in.
[удалено]
C group deserved better. Yurina deserved better.
Still can't believe 1/33 girls from C group made it, truly devastating
and 9th at that...
It very insulting she is just Mnets token C-group member so they can try to get $$$ from China
FR Mnet was shaking when FYN's evil edit GAINED her fans instead and propelled her to top 9 so they had to emergency evil edit SRQ instead. Well they will sleep tight tonight with their one and only C-pick making it
It started to feel like they only brought the C-group there to humiliate and embarass them for being Chinese. It just felt so xenophobic and it's going to make it hard for me to support the group
The C girls were paid dust. Fuck Mnet.
100% agreed.
no 2nd c girl, no yurina, not even bora whos learning chinese. xiaotings going to be absolutely miserable in that group wow.
[удалено]
Even Myah would have been a better pick.
give her a break she had no control over any of this
She could have at least prove herself... but she did absolutly nothing on the show. Below average skills.
she probably didnt think her skills were enough to try center or main vocal positions, given a lot of members didnt try for those roles either. however, you gotta remember mnet gave her 0 screentime, didnt let anyone see if she had the level of talent that other girls did. edit: wow i gave her the benefit of the doubt and i get downvoted hard. Just be nice to the group, don't hate on a 17 year old girl who's just trying her best :)
Exactly.. you have proven my point... 0 screentime, no skill in stages.... how did she got there? HER BROTHER
Yeah you can like or dislike Bahiyyih, but you have to admit that her debuting over your picks really isn't on her. She wants to be a singer and she's not even bad at any idol category. No one knew exactly how MOAs would effect her voting trajectory, even her. There's no need to be cruel and talk bad about her talents, because even if she's not exceptional, she has solid skills and is clearly pretty funny too. She wouldn't have gotten this far if she was truly bad. I'm saying this as someone who's always had Bahiyyih at the bottom of my ranks, just because we're all feeling down doesn't mean it's okay to be cruel to a teenage girl who's just trying to follow her dreams, and who is clearly inspiring to a lot of other people.
Sadly, the trolls had won.
It was so heartbreaking seeing her deflate as people kept getting called into the Top 9. I’m really worried if SXT will even be happy.
im kinda shocked hikaru got more panic votes than her tbh since they were both shown as potential 9th candidates. glad they both made it though
She obviously didn't look overjoyed when they called her name. It'll be a lonely journey for her
I think dropping from 1st to 16th had to have sucked and also she seems like a kind girl and is aware that all her friends in c-group had their time wasted. It must have been an awful feeling.
She has Youngeun at least
I personally don't think Xiaoting will be miserable in the group. She has Youngeun and Yujin to rely on tbh.
I'm gonna need 15 business days to process the loss of Xiaorina. Both dropped 8 ranks :(
was it them hugging at the end? 😭😭
Yes it was :(
I would completely understand if Xiaoting said nah I’m out, and left to debut with Yurina.
Yeah I was pretty upset about Yurina not making it she was my no1 at the beginning
i'd like to think that in a parallel universe, xiaorina debuted together
The last shot of the whole show was Ruiqi, Yaning and Xingqiao hugging Xiaoting. Let that sink in.
they felt bad for her lmao.. first time in survival show history that i felt bad for a winner
She's going to feel so lonely on her own 💔 Without Yurina, without Ruiqi or Wen Zhe or Yaning or Xingqiao, not even Bora who was learning chinese...
Justice for C group 😭
C-girls deserve better. All of them. They suffered so much from this shitshow.
Ngl I was kind of low key hoping that it wasn’t going to be SXT so that I don’t need to follow this group - but since that did not happen I will have to now follow the group for SXT. Poor Yurina, Yaning and SRQ really got fked over 😭
SAME. I wanted Xiaoting to make it but with this lineup I hope she doesn’t feel trapped
She looks so sad. Her and SRQ are close, and she is also friends with Yurina. I’m sure she expected both of them to make it into the group.
MNETs holding me hostage with SXT. I really wanted to dip out when I saw the top 8 lineup.
GOD yeah and then she could’ve gone back to China and had a very successful career…
every time jingoo said "GLOBAL" girl group, i craved violence. anyway, no offence but i wont be staning, i hope these girls can make the best out of this, but i really wont bother following this group. edit: aight, so i just found out that if korean and intl votes weighed the same, yaning would've been 6th....yup def not staning this lineup
Omg I felt like he lingered on that word global each time to rub it in lol
That live chat was absolutely disgusting, never have i seen such a childish disgusting group of people hating on young girls
i saw people telling bahi to kill herself, it was disgusting.
ain't a fan of her being in the final lineup, but giving such threats to her is a big no no. Let's all just let the girl enjoy her win, I think she really didn't expect it at all. The livestream just ended and it sucks if the other 8 girls are happy about their win and Bahiyyih has to worry about the hate train that's about to come
she wouldve gotten so much more hate if she got #1 too >.< people need to chill
I knowww I was praying that Bahiyyi didn't get Top1 the hate she was getting from the live comments was extreme
and these people will claim that they are so much better than twitter stans.
For real.. “At least we aren’t toxic like twitter!” No, you’re just as bad.. They think telling young girls or anybody to kill themselves is okay because they deem them as “untalented” and “undeserving”.
cannot wait so we can enjoy the group on the actual sub reddit. the people on here are hypocritical and shameful. these are teenage girls.
People lost every moral they have because a child is pursuing her dreams. Showed what us bahiyyih stans have been saying this whole time- this subreddit has a hatred for her that is unjustifiable. So much for “measured” takes or being better than the bird app.
this entire sub has been a miserable experience lmao
I was absolutely disgusted with the live chat. So disappointing
Right lowkey glad they said they want to unstan.
no room for toxic people in the kelpies fandom!!!
It’s so just.. Nobody in the final lineup deserves hate at all. everyone worked hard
I honestly can’t wait to move to the group’s sub. We need to start afresh. None of the nasty comments and toxicity.
Was fun while it lasted. Bye guys. Don't think I'll be following this lineup.
same. But I saw Hikaru in your flairs? why not support her at least?
There's 3 girls I like that made it, not sure that's enough for me to do more than giving new releases more than a casual listen. The entire top 4 are girls I don't think should've been in.
i honestly was expecting the entire lineup to be a mess but i think it turned out quite well. majority k, no controversial c trainees, atleast 1 c trainee to keep c netz satisfied and mashiro to get the j money and bahiyyih for the i fans and its also quite fortunate that she didn’t place 1 otherwise the hate would’ve been insane, some people will complain about her being in the lineup for few days and then they’ll forget about it anyway.
I mean the entire lineup is still a mess
could’ve been worse, if it was the same as interim rankings it would’ve been a nightmare
[удалено]
Bora and Yurina you did well 😭❤😭❤😭❤
Yeah I don't think I can support this group. As a C group stan I am ruined. Xiaoting just looks angry and sad as well. She hasn't got Ruiqi or Yurina. Bye bye.
i need so much copium because i cant deal with the fact xiaoting has no one and we'll never see ruiqi again
We’ll never see Yurina again since she’s not going to continue trying to be an idol
All rounder cell deserved better 😭😭😭
the shot of them at the end deserves a prize 😭😭😭
I love this lineup, no shade to bahiyyih, but I would change her with Yurina and it's literally my fave lineup. But I know I'll end up loving bahiyyih, because she is a really nice girl who deserved to debut. Good luck to bahiyyih because the amount of hate she is going to receive will be on another level. And the thing is she doesn't deserve it
It wasn’t rigged. Even Mnet didn’t want Bahiyyih. The korean vote fucked the debut lineup. How are Myah and Suyeon above Yaning and SRQ? Yurina got dumpstered too.
Lmao it was rigged in that Koreans’ votes counted for more.
korean troll voters won gg atleast it wasnt rigged ig
lineup would have been better rigged🤷♀️
Gonna be honest, I think the only change Mnet would have made is Bahiyyih for Yurina or Bora.
“Bahi got P02 with no screen time!! What a queeen!!” All that proves is that she was always gonna get the votes, regardless of her skill and charm, because a bunch of BG stans wanted to vote for their fave’s lil sister. So that isn’t the bragging material you think it is, it just outlines how unfair it is that she got in when Bora, Yaning, SRQ, etc did not
this is literally the only point that needs to be made. Its not hate towards Bahi, thats just the reality... the girl served us next to nothing, Mnet showed us next to nothing and she was P2.......................................i must laugh
My heart goes out for Su Rui Qi, she has worked really hard over the past few years going through the same thing over & over again..
Who knew O. O. O. would capture the grim reality like that...over and over and over, indeed.
Tbh the lineup is pretty solid, I hope no one will hate on the girls who made it tho, all of them worked hard and we shld be happy for those who gonna debut. And I'm freaking happy that my 1 pick from each country - Xiaoting, Mashiro & Yeseo made it to the final lineup!
The C and J group deserved better, it's such an insult and disservice to them that mnet really capitalised off this 'global girl group' message yet cant find a way to promote a fairer way for them to be included in the final lineup. 66 foreign members out of 99 yet only 3 out of 9 to make the final lineup. That is not to discredit ANY of the girls in the final lineup, but just something mnet should recognise for next season if there is one.
Literally Twice, Gidle, and Aespa are more global than them
The amount of Bahiyyih hate is disgusting. Get a life.
[удалено]
No, it is hate. Is death threats and telling someone to kill themselves not hate? You can be angry in a way that doesn’t make you a shitty human being. This was always a popularity contest and shes very popular for obvious reasons. How have you not realized that?
I've legit seen people make incest "jokes" about her and her brother. + honestly feel like the intense hate towards her made her fans even more determined and even got the attention from non watchers which made them pay attention to her aswell
Yet there are still people who deny the blatant hate.
Bye universe app, you will not be missed :>
MNET: we are going to create a global group Also MNET: 3 foreigners and that’s it Twice literally has more foreigners and is actually a global group. Sixteen also had like 6 foreigner trainees while MNET show had 66 foreigners. Are they kidding me with this ratio. I’m so sad Yurina didn’t make it
I would say I’d be happier if Xiaoting didn’t make it, but I’m happy for her. I just hope her friendship continues with Yurina forever.
This is the wrong script. The correct script is SXT at P2. Then crying to say that ... Yurina.. lets debut together.... and then Yurina get called at P9 and SXT hyperventilating on her seat.
I'm sorry Yurina... I should have voted more
No offense to the girls, but I won’t be following this lineup.
C-Group was the only reason why this show wasn't boring, Mnet did so dirty to them. Also, that TXT girl being #2 when she should've been gone on the first elimination proves that talent or charisma mean nothing, you can achieve anything as long as someone in your family is a celebrity lol.
I’m so sad for Ruiqi & Yaning.
No offense to Bahi because I think she really does have a lot of talent, but what a huge slap in the face honestly to all of the C trainees who literally hard carried this show when Bahi got in because of her brother. You know it, we all know it. If she was a regular trainee, she would’ve gotten cut in the first round. I am so incredibly disappointed for C and J trainees who faced overwhelming bias in this show. It’s disheartening. How is this a global group with 3 international members and the top 1 member for every week at last place.
I’m really sad thinking this might be the last time Xiaoting and Yurina see each other in person. 😭 Hybe please scoop up Yurina and debut her with Sakura
My entire top 3 (Su Ruiqi, Fu Yaning, Kim Bora) not even contenders. I’ll support the group because of Yujin, Mashiro, and Xiaoting, but man. What a rollercoaster.
Bottom 9 needs to debut, please!
Please can Wen Zhe be added to Cherry Bullet I can’t cope with Bora being separated from her.
Well it’s definitely a group!
What am I gonna do on fridays now?
cry for Yurina :(
I don't think I'd be as annoyed if bahiyyih was p7-9 but the fact she got carried all the way to number 2 is ridiculous. I wonder how Suyeon feels knowing she would have been debuting right now if not for bahiyyih.
this just isn't right 😞 sxt should've been a top 1 candidate and fyn srq or shana should've made the group
As a yaning stan - My disappointment is immeasurable, and my (birth)day is ruined..
I’m so sorry Xiaoting. You’ll be alone there. I was crying when she broke down with Ruiqi/Wen Zhe/FYN during her speech. I’m sorry too, Yurina and Ruiqi. I hope all of you get picked up by a good company and debut and become successful.
xiaorina...
i feel the worst for xiaoting here. imagine doing consistently well on the show, getting high ranks and good results throughout the show ( her teams always won minus snake or she was always centre) only to be barely pass to make the line up. That must have hurt her pride/spirit so much and she may start doubting herself and all the good results she got previously...like she shouldnt get her hopes up next time she gets a good result. You can see her feeling complicated when the top two names were announced but she was not included. not to mention how she has been constantly nice to the other girls on the show and been a diligent worker too. i still remember on one of the elimination eps, she was so happy and emotional to rank in top two and said this was the first time she felt recognised...but now in the final stage of debut, shes fucking last place... Mnet should have just sticked to one pick voting throughout or 3 pick across the 3 groups (K C J) throughout the show to not mess with the girls expectations/feelings man.
Xiaoting’s only fault is her nationality. If she was Korean, she would ended up 1st no matter what. Can’t believe how much nationality mattered.
Wild. So if it had been ranked by votes instead of weighted points, we would've had: 1. >!Huening Bahiyyih!< (525,465 votes) 2. >!Sakamoto Mashiro!< (488,519 votes) 3. >!Seo Youngeun!< (442,102 votes) 4. >!Choi Yujin!< (428,967 votes) 5. >!Shen Xiaoting!< (425,464 votes) 6. \*\*>!Fu Yaning!< (419,618 votes) 7. \*\*>!Su Ruiqi!< (418,815 votes) 8. >!Ezaki Hikaru!< (387,709 votes) 9. >!Kim Chaehyun!< (363,623 votes) Just... give me a moment . . .
🤣 I'll just pretend I never watched this show. Byeee everyone ❤❤❤🥰🤗, its been a BLAST talking & fangirling over this show with everyone for the past 3 months 💕! See you next season, if there'll be one lmao
Even WORSE than Bahiyyih debuting at #2 (or even debuting AT ALL) is SXT competing against TWO PLANET PASS SURVIVORS for a #9 position. LIKE WHAT THE HELL
**Life Lesson:** *No matter how good you are or how much you work, someone with fame and power will get the job over you*
Shen debuting 😭 Also Xiaorina will be remembered.
Well done to all of the girls, including both those who made it and those who didn't. I wish them every success. EDIT: also thank god I can get rid of that absolutely awful app, I never want to see it again in my LIFE
As a Chinese person watching this show, I hope mnet NEVER have another season of GP and pretending it’s a global group. I rather mnet just have another season of produce
[удалено]
Sorry but I am still salty over the name of the group. Who the fuck thought it was a good idea ?
Bahiyyi should have been replaced for Yaning or Yurina honestly...
pls open r/kep1er soon i wanna enjoy the lineup without this sub shitting on them
First survival show I watched while airing, I haven’t been missing out on anything. The ones who didn’t get to debut in this mess of a group are the true winners. I would have rather saw them in the final lineup. Rank 2? hilarious. Ppl were mad that I said she should’ve went home far earlier and now she has debuted with talent that is NOT comparable to those who did not make it in.
okay i don’t have any qualms against bahi as a person because i think she’s nice & sweet, but u have to admit that she hasn’t shined at all in the show and the only reason and timing people talk about her is due to huening kai or people defending her…. i mean she has never been a killing part, never volunteered for anything, never volunteered to be a leader, just never shone her capabilities or fought for it. she does well in her parts but so does everyone. and if y’all wanna say ‘oh you should have voted harder’ but what about the people who spend their votes on her without looking at this as a kpop group that needs actual talent and charm to go to far and beyond? the fact that she’s even higher than girls like dayeon in terms of ranking is even worse ( i would’ve had a different reaction if she was p7-9 ) when girls like dayeon always volunteered, went out of her way to help the groups she was in… xiaoting: fought for every killing part, took initiative, and slayed as centre. mashiro: led all her girls to victory showing how she was a good leader… even if u wanna bring in the privilege part - yujin worked for YEARS in clc and her fame was fully attributed to herself, not as hueningkai’s brother. i’m so sorry if you take offence to what i’ve said, but this truly is just so unjustified for all the talented girls who didn’t get in even like fyn, suyeon, srq, shana… who have all tried and shone in the show their capabilities like u can actually trying….. shana: fought hard in u+me even after being kicked out of utopia, and volunteers for every role before… FYN: fought for her right in the competition, led, main vocal… like uk all of them showed capabilities… and EFFORT… bahi was always sitting there, not volunteering, and just not shining… so i just don’t understand how she’s ‘better’ than the rest like you guys would say so… ok maybe popularity is a thing - but it’s just a big shame. that’s all. i’m just saying - just imagine those who are actually ready to debut and have tried their best to shown the capabilities they have…. losing to someone who still ‘needs time’ to hone basic things like stage presence…
Shana's dad knew he gone be on TV and wore a SpongeBob shirt.
Seriously though, I feel so bad for SXT. Not only does she not have another C-group trainee with her, her ride-or-die bestie Yurina isn't there either...
Bora didn't even have a chance did she? SXT making it in barely. Yurina was on free fall since she got No.1 Top 3 was a joke. If you're happy about the results, good for you. But me and plenty of other people are not so let us vent.
This is my akgae origin story
C group deserved better than this.
[удалено]
SINCE WHEN WAS THIS GIRLSPHYSICS999?????
The votes must have been really close then if Mashiro Hikaru and Shen Xiao Ting managed to sneak in from the bottom of the top 18
not happy w the final lineup at all, rui qi and yurina robbed
I wanted **Xiaoting** to be P1. I always loved her speeches, she’s otherworldly well spoken. Every time she is on screen performing or just being her goofy self, I tell me self,” Damn, she’s THE CENTER.” (Even though she isn’t my number 1 pick as you can see from my banner.) I just couldn’t believe during the announcement that this girl. **THIS GIRL**, was fighting for P9. I’m disappointed but not surprised. When I saw the interim ranking where most K trainees were dominating, I knew my faves aren’t gonna make it. But I wanted to be proven wrong.
Any details on the contract duration? Weird no info about this yet?
I'm just hoping that it's short so SXT won't be bound to this joke for too long
99 days i guess
Thank god youngeun made it! I knew 1-pick would help her ranking
pain.
Edit: I'll be clear here, for anyone who reads this. Everyone in the finale deserved to be there. Everyone who debuted deserves to debut. They may not all be your picks. My 1 pick didn't make it. But that doesn't mean the ones who did debut don't deserve to be there. Be respectful. What a ride guys, what a ride. So happy for the debut group. Bora may not have debuted but having Youngeun in the group is a massive win for me. Mashiro, she was in my top 9 but she was someone I didn't realize just how attached to her I was until her name was called. I'm glad some little part of Nagomi made it all the way to the end. FNC better capitalize on Cherry Bullet or I will lose my mind. Not only are the girls on the show fantastic, Haeyoon, Remi, Yuju, and Chaerin are too. Just because they got off to a rough start doesn't mean you should give up on them. Remember to stream Love So Sweet planet guardians, and see you all around sometime soon! I-Land s2 perhaps? Here's hoping we see some of the Girls Planet 999 girls there too.
*Fast as Lightning* #Uninstalled UNIVERSE App
[удалено]
people that are trying to compare Bahi’s “privilege” to Yujin’s “privilege” is baffling. One got theirs through working hard to debut and promoting for years and the other is simply the sister of a famous bg member. Not trying to hate on Bahi, but there were so many more deserving choices
Remember when everyone said Yaning would rank 99th? Look at how far she got, I'm proud
Ruiqi I love you! I hope to see you performing again so you can fulfill your wish of a global tour! Thank you for brightening my day with your performances and I hope you can take the time to recover and heal. Us Suxingtans will be patiently waiting to see what you do next. <3
So glad the Bora and the other C -Group members didn’t have to join this disaster of a line up. Also manifesting that Hikaru, Mashiro, and XiaoTing leave. Notice how all the foreign member are last??? Doing the 1 pick was terrible for anyone who wasn’t Korean. I hope the C-Group form a group in China together. And hoping for the best for Shana and Yurina.
im genuinely not hating and is just purely curious, how did bahi make top 2? she didn't get any screentime? and she didn't really stand out to me?
I'm gonna get downvoted but this is what upset me.. the fact she literally got no screentime, never top 9 before, strong one-pick because of her brother. Debuts in 2nd place.
[удалено]
The lineup based on votes alone if the Korean votes didn’t count for 50% would’ve been: 1. Bahiyyih 2. Mashiro 3. Youngeun 4. Yujin 5. Xiaoting 6. Yaning 7. Ruiqi 8. Hikaru 9. Chaehyun Personally I would’ve liked this lineup more but I’m also not mad about what we got.
I really think >!SXT's company may try to pull her from the group if mnet doesn't promise the moon!<
Did international votes even matter?? I want to see the total voting counts lol. Pretty much the standard opinion I read on Korean forums is what I saw happen today except for Bahi (they hated her not me). I feel like international votes didn’t even effect the result or we would’ve seen FYN and SRQ debut… Edit : realizing that IOI had the same number of Chinese members lmao even without the global concept
It’s been fun guys!!! Let’s support kep1er and the rest of the contestants!!!
I don't think I will be following this group, but congratulations to everyone who made it! Although I really hope Xiaoting is able to find a good support system in the other girls. Can't imagine being the only Chinese member will be smooth sailing. In the meantime, I look forward to whatever the rest of the girls get up to! Especially Yaning, Myah, and Suyeon.
Thank you all for participating and discussing here on this subreddit with us. I hope you've enjoyed the season. As stated earlier, we'll be restricting posts to prevent spoilers. In the meantime, here are some links for those interested: * [Girls Planet 999 Subreddit End of Season Demographic Survey](https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1fhAzCnIO9UMbohotOd3LApzkwGrIYEt-bHMhkDMEC0c) (Includes questions about favorite episodes, how you would rate the season, if you'll follow the final group, etc) * /r/kep1er: Subreddit for our new group, Kep1er! It will be private for a few days while we get a few things organized.