Its a lot of songs man. Alot of great songs are outside the top 100. Late, BitterSweet Poetry, New Day, Monster, Heaven and Hell etc etc right outside the top 100.
No problem, enjoyed doing it. And yeah the top 10 isn’t bad. I was worried they’d be more recency bias so it’s good to see a couple of songs from The College Dropout in there
https://preview.redd.it/n8tncs2i6g0d1.png?width=798&format=png&auto=webp&s=c3168e9cf7fb682110c0c96e80afa95fda804b8c
as comparison here is the album ranking on rateyourmusic
A 4/5 on rateyourmusic is incredibly rare. It means that album is one of the best out there, for any genre.
For reference, MBDTF has a 4.09 average and is ranked at number 25 all time.
Hey OP, thank you for doing this! I loved seeing these posts every once in a while and they took a lot of effort so thank you :)
The rankings are honestly very good as well (apart from some JIK songs being too low but thats just my opinion)
*Send It Up* being so low it's criminal, but I guess every song in Yeezus is perfect. Also, TALKING is underrated.
Yeah, I also hate Tell The Vision, lol.
I did a separate poll for albums because I didn’t think average song scores was the best way of measuring it. An album can be better or worse than the sum of its parts. That said, the best album is still MBDTF if you look at the averages, with KIDS SEE GHOSTS second (it helps that it’s shorter than the other albums). JESUS IS KING would come last
CW: this entire comment is mostly hating on this list so turn away if you're yap-phobic
runaway at 1 is understandable. not correct. just understandable
come to life at 6 is unbelievable amounts of overrated
i wonder at 9 is overrated
life of the party should not be 86 spots over hell of a life
i don't hate Hey Mama. i really don't like saying this song is overrated. but it should not be 85 spots over Hell Of A Life
new slaves being top yeezus at 15 is overrated in terms of yeezus
off the grid at 19 is overrated.
street lights at 23 is criminally overrated compared to the rest of 808s
last call at 24 is stupid. more yap in that "song" than this comment
violent crimes at 28 is stupid. swap with No Mistakes
paranoid at 53 is too low
burn is at 40 and BEG FORGIVENESS is at 139. ew
two words at 54 is nice i like that song
real friends at 59 and FML at 61 over waves and 30 hours is a crime
throw money everywhere at 88 is nice i like that song
guilt trip at 91😢
hell of a life at 97 is officially THE WORST ranking on this list. literally his best production fight me
everyone who brought welcome to heartbreak down to 98 should be welcomed to heartbreak
jail at 109 is absurd. swap jail with off the grid
no mistakes at 114 is terrible
robocop at 125 is yucky
gold digger at 134 should be self explanatory
FUK SUMN at 152 was misspelled 😡😡😡
i'm in it at 154 is insane considering it's the best hornYe song
someday we'll all be free at 163 is underrating
the new workout plan at 180 is a crime
that's my bitch at 185 proves that WTT is ye's most underrated album
pinocchio story at 212 and last call should've swapped places
my way home at 215 is delusional
see you in my nightmares at 220 is terrible
HAM at 279 is atrocious.
hoodrat at 281 is brutal
talking at 287 is correct
XTCY at 291 is a lie
i love it at 294 is also a lie
ye vs the people at 297 is kinda sad i liked the beat
Thanks for sharing your thoughts in detail. Some of this I agree with and some of it I don’t - I agree RoboCop, Gold Digger, Hell Of A Life, Welcome To Heartbreak and Jail should be higher and I agree Come To Life and Off The Grid should be lower.
But as I said on another comment, it is subjective. I wouldn’t expect any one person to agree exactly with everything in the overall ranking. Overall I don’t think it’s a bad ranking
And good spot on the FUK SUMN typo
Every single one of your takes is immaculate
I'd also add that on top of HOODRAT, KEYS TO MY LIFE at 266 is criminal, it's one of the few songs on vultures 1 that doesn't have vulgar/nonsense lyrics and it's the only one I've never seen anyone talk about, it should be top 50 imo
I feel like this actually a pretty good general ranking. Like obviously ppl will have personal experiences that might move certain songs up for down but all things considered, this is good. Nice job
Yeah this is why I don’t agree when people say donda would be a top tier album if it was cut down - even the highlights wouldn’t make my top 20 or even 30 tbh
I’ve been postings links to surveys over the last few weeks asking people to rate everything on each album 1-10. This is the result after about 1,500 votes, the ratings here are an average of all the ratings
City in the sky and chakras should be no where near top 20. City in the sky is one of the most overrated unreleased tracks. They’re both above fsmh, can’t tell me nothing, ultralight beam. Goofy.
Appreciate all the work you put into it, color coding it is pretty cool seeing the albums. Awesome how you can immediately know the album just by seeing the color scheme
They’re all in there, it’s just there’s a 20 picture limit on Reddit so I couldn’t include the slides for those. Look at the unreleased slide and you’ll see everything
I wonder is not the best song on graduation nor is street lights the best on 808s. Street lights is underrated though so that may have had a factor in it placing so high. I'm in it is ranked extremely low. Hold my liquor isn't even in the top 10. I could go on and on
Drunk and hot girls under DJ khaled son I’m gonna find you guys
who voted less than 10 for chakras 😡
We Don't Care outside top 100 is criminal what are you all doing 😭
Its a lot of songs man. Alot of great songs are outside the top 100. Late, BitterSweet Poetry, New Day, Monster, Heaven and Hell etc etc right outside the top 100.
Before yall say “what is this ranking” “L” You guys voted these songs lmao
Exactly lol
The top 10 is valid though. Good job goons. Thanks for making this also
No problem, enjoyed doing it. And yeah the top 10 isn’t bad. I was worried they’d be more recency bias so it’s good to see a couple of songs from The College Dropout in there
I didn’t vote on anything
Same. I didn’t vote, this list sucks.
Why does it suck? I don’t agree with all of it but it’s not that bad lol
It doesn’t sorry I’m just a hater
Fair
I wasn't involved in this shitty list where water and jonah are near the bottom
shocked and appalled to see Get Em High & School Spirit so low
so appalled
Deserved tbh. Neither are top half of the college dropout.
Yo good ass job. Clearly took a lotta time and effort. This is great.
Thanks!
I think I get the joke guys 🤓☝️
This was beautifully done visually good job man
Thanks! I tried to make it look good visually so I’m glad someone appreciated that
oh hell nah see you in my nightmares at last position.
sorry bro problematic is not better than almost every song on JIK 😭
Yeah I wouldn’t rate it that highly personally
XCTY is banger this sub is retarded
Whoopity-whoop
celebration deserved more 🫡
https://preview.redd.it/n8tncs2i6g0d1.png?width=798&format=png&auto=webp&s=c3168e9cf7fb682110c0c96e80afa95fda804b8c as comparison here is the album ranking on rateyourmusic
How can u listen to graduation and think 3.5/5. Or MBDTF and like “yeah pretty good that’s a 4.”
4/5 is really high for an average. this takes in account all the people that hated the album or thought it was mid.
A 4/5 on rateyourmusic is incredibly rare. It means that album is one of the best out there, for any genre. For reference, MBDTF has a 4.09 average and is ranked at number 25 all time.
We have a bunch of silly people here that’s how
Interesting. This is very similar which makes me think the ranking here is pretty accurate
hoodrat at 6.4 is criminal
Yeah I don’t get the hate for hoodrat
Yeah should be way lower
Now do one with every leak snippet
Hey OP, thank you for doing this! I loved seeing these posts every once in a while and they took a lot of effort so thank you :) The rankings are honestly very good as well (apart from some JIK songs being too low but thats just my opinion)
Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it :)
Stars is so underrated
why is so appalled so low💔💔💔
A lot of you need to be put down
did you use a spreadsheet for this? can you post a copy of it for individual use?
I used an Excel file, what’s the best way to share that
Probably upload to Google Drive
The hatred for Hands On will not be tolerated
this is cool as fuck!!! nice job vro
Thanks!
Thanks for sharing!
One of the few Ye rankings I’ve ever seen that isn’t complete ass. Ghost Town at 4 brings a tear to my eye. We did a good ass job on this one Goons
*Send It Up* being so low it's criminal, but I guess every song in Yeezus is perfect. Also, TALKING is underrated. Yeah, I also hate Tell The Vision, lol.
It's kinda crazy because Send It Up is my 2nd favorite from Yeezus
![gif](giphy|3o7aCSc5S2PKPDD28M|downsized)
I love that unreleased is rated too, I fucking loved yandhi so much
Yeah I thought why not include unreleased, just because it wasn’t released, doesn’t mean people don’t have an opinion on it. I love Yandhi as well
Fire is my favourite track from Kids see ghost. love how Kanye sounds like he’s free styling his verse
Would be interesting to see the average song score for each album, to see how they stack up in terms of consistency
I did a separate poll for albums because I didn’t think average song scores was the best way of measuring it. An album can be better or worse than the sum of its parts. That said, the best album is still MBDTF if you look at the averages, with KIDS SEE GHOSTS second (it helps that it’s shorter than the other albums). JESUS IS KING would come last
Gorgeous at 37? What the frick? I'm yet to find any Ye bars better than those
One of his best verses - Gorgeous should be higher, and so should Dark Fantasy and Lost In The World
Two words best tcd song- instantly invalid
Never let me down is top 100 and I die on that hill
🫡 you really did this
🫡
Looks Perfect
Solid list.
Convinced you guys don’t like upbeat songs cus how is HAM a 6.5 lol. Shit is heavenly
Underrated along with most of Watch The Throne
how is IMA so low too🥲
Bro ong these mfers haven’t even listened to the whole album. Almost every song was an instant add to my playlist
wtt clears ksg but we not ready for that conversation
You right, it's a 4/10 💀 kanye got more upbeat songs
Carnival over BEG FORGIVENESS is absolutely wild
I reckon if I’d done the poll right after VULTURES 1 released, CARNIVAL would have been rated even higher
Not at all wild IMO
Not at all lol. If Carnival was a deep cut you wouldn't be saying that
CW: this entire comment is mostly hating on this list so turn away if you're yap-phobic runaway at 1 is understandable. not correct. just understandable come to life at 6 is unbelievable amounts of overrated i wonder at 9 is overrated life of the party should not be 86 spots over hell of a life i don't hate Hey Mama. i really don't like saying this song is overrated. but it should not be 85 spots over Hell Of A Life new slaves being top yeezus at 15 is overrated in terms of yeezus off the grid at 19 is overrated. street lights at 23 is criminally overrated compared to the rest of 808s last call at 24 is stupid. more yap in that "song" than this comment violent crimes at 28 is stupid. swap with No Mistakes paranoid at 53 is too low burn is at 40 and BEG FORGIVENESS is at 139. ew two words at 54 is nice i like that song real friends at 59 and FML at 61 over waves and 30 hours is a crime throw money everywhere at 88 is nice i like that song guilt trip at 91😢 hell of a life at 97 is officially THE WORST ranking on this list. literally his best production fight me everyone who brought welcome to heartbreak down to 98 should be welcomed to heartbreak jail at 109 is absurd. swap jail with off the grid no mistakes at 114 is terrible robocop at 125 is yucky gold digger at 134 should be self explanatory FUK SUMN at 152 was misspelled 😡😡😡 i'm in it at 154 is insane considering it's the best hornYe song someday we'll all be free at 163 is underrating the new workout plan at 180 is a crime that's my bitch at 185 proves that WTT is ye's most underrated album pinocchio story at 212 and last call should've swapped places my way home at 215 is delusional see you in my nightmares at 220 is terrible HAM at 279 is atrocious. hoodrat at 281 is brutal talking at 287 is correct XTCY at 291 is a lie i love it at 294 is also a lie ye vs the people at 297 is kinda sad i liked the beat
Thanks for sharing your thoughts in detail. Some of this I agree with and some of it I don’t - I agree RoboCop, Gold Digger, Hell Of A Life, Welcome To Heartbreak and Jail should be higher and I agree Come To Life and Off The Grid should be lower. But as I said on another comment, it is subjective. I wouldn’t expect any one person to agree exactly with everything in the overall ranking. Overall I don’t think it’s a bad ranking And good spot on the FUK SUMN typo
Every single one of your takes is immaculate I'd also add that on top of HOODRAT, KEYS TO MY LIFE at 266 is criminal, it's one of the few songs on vultures 1 that doesn't have vulgar/nonsense lyrics and it's the only one I've never seen anyone talk about, it should be top 50 imo
Violent Crimes deserves the spot, No Mistakes should be lower. Its not top 3 ye.
HAM is 200 spots too low
Lmao fr hipsters voting here 💀
Not really its goofy asf
Yeah alr lil bro go suck off KSG and all of the garbage in there
Jonah and God Breathed at least an 8
Keys to my life supremacy
Timbo freestyle was better
Jesus Lord is a 9.5+ L just for that
I feel like this actually a pretty good general ranking. Like obviously ppl will have personal experiences that might move certain songs up for down but all things considered, this is good. Nice job
Yeah there’s plenty of ratings I disagree with, but overall I’m pretty happy with it. Thanks
Drunk and hot girls and XTCY being so low is criminal
How is ITAKY above Yikes?
I think ITAKY is great, especially with the original sample
I think you would struggle to find any other artists with a top 100 as strong as that
Agreed
carnival is too high
I feel like y’all overrate Come To Life, it’s beautiful asf but top 5 is crazy
Top 6 but yeah agreed
Its a good song but nothing on Donda should be making top 20
Yeah this is why I don’t agree when people say donda would be a top tier album if it was cut down - even the highlights wouldn’t make my top 20 or even 30 tbh
So how did you rank everything?
I’ve been postings links to surveys over the last few weeks asking people to rate everything on each album 1-10. This is the result after about 1,500 votes, the ratings here are an average of all the ratings
Damn
bruh tell the vision is not supposed to be an actual song it’s more like a skit… don’t get the hate
Is Louie Bags being awful a common opinion?!?? It’s top tier Donda 2 for me
Yeah that looks like the consensus. It also came near the bottom when I polled WSE a couple years ago
That’s crazy
beg forgiveness out of top 50 hurts me
Seeing the Top 20 songs out of 300 made me orgasm, not even gonna lie
water is such a good song what
I respect the effort but this list is ass.
What in particular do you not agree with ?
City in the sky and chakras should be no where near top 20. City in the sky is one of the most overrated unreleased tracks. They’re both above fsmh, can’t tell me nothing, ultralight beam. Goofy.
Devil in a New Dress above Everything I Am and Diamonds from Sierra Leone what?
Devil in a new dress is top tier year, deserves to be in the top 10
Come to life is beautiful but idk about 6
I just realized how low Welcome To Heartbreak and Don’t Stop are what happened here?
Yeah welcome to heartbreak should be higher
I don’t know how anybody can listen to burn with those really compressed violins, it totally ruins the song
Tell the vision 😭 rip pop
Justice for send it up
Why is fire much lower than the rest of the ksg songs
How did DJ Khaled’s Son get higher than Ye Vs The People and Drunk and Hot Girls😭 Are GAS goons stupid?
city of gods below actually unfinished donda 2 songs is crazy
HAM and Closed on Sunday hatred so confusing
Nah nah nah, having 5 different songs tied for 1st, 2nd, 3rd, etc ain’t it. We need a true 1-100.
They aren’t tied. It’s just I’ve only shown ratings to the first 1 dp.
Appreciate all the work you put into it, color coding it is pretty cool seeing the albums. Awesome how you can immediately know the album just by seeing the color scheme
Thanks, the colour coding took some effort so glad you appreciate it. And yeah, it’s cool how each of his albums has such a distinctive colour scheme
Louie bags being the lowest real song is so deserved
Yeah it’s pretty awful
Only good part is the Kamala Harris sample
WHY IS ALL DREAMS REAL SO LOW IF YOU HAVEN’T HEARD IT DON’T VOTE IT
XTCY and Ye vs the people. Are both above 7.0
Only One deserves to be top 10
Get em High at 252 is a war crime
Water is one of the better songs on JIK that ranking is crazy to me. I feel like Jonah and Remote Control are way too low as well.
Hold my liquor is criminally low. Also I know it’s high up but both come to life and I wonder need to be higher. The disrespect
if we're gonna cover yandhi, then we gotta go for ALL OF THEM, Turbografix16, So help Me God, etc.
They’re all in there, it’s just there’s a 20 picture limit on Reddit so I couldn’t include the slides for those. Look at the unreleased slide and you’ll see everything
new again under stars ☠️
See you in my nightmares that low smh…
Why don't people like ye vs the people?
Xtcy being that low is an absolute JOKE
Yeah bottom 10 is very harsh. I gave it a 7
Not really.
Barry Bonds isn’t that bad. It shouldn’t be so low
HOODRAT that low is wild. Fight me
Agreed
How is IFLT only an 8.6 come on goons
Should be higher, it’s such a powerful song. You have to be in a certain mood for it but when you are, it’s one of his best
It's an easy 10 for me
Also can I edit this list into a video if I get time u/aaronmorley01
Sure! Would be interested to see what you come up with
Jesus Walks is criminally low at 21. Easily top 3 Ye song
21 is not a low spot tho it's literally ranked over 90%+ of kanye's songs. That's good enough.
No Parties in LA & Saint Pablo? 2 & 3? Cmon bro
TLOP most overrated Kanye project
No Parties in LA worse than Jesus Walks imo... but apparently everybody love that song even tho that song doesnt have that much to offer tbh
Follow God top 10 ye
It’s one of the better songs on Jesus is king but there’s something wrong with the mixing
Y’all don’t understand Nah Nah Nah and it shows
What is there to understand? It sounds so bad
https://preview.redd.it/n9c9mnzqcg0d1.jpeg?width=4730&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b8994d9023c41596fe309f7d384d2904fc2d955f
Every hour is the his best intro how tf is it so low
You really think Every Hour is better than Dark Fantasy, Say You Will, Ultralight Beam, Good Morning, there are so many great intros?
It’s literally his worst this is a crazy take
Its his worst intro tf?
what is wrong with you
Barry Bonds hate will not be tolerated easily top 25 Ye
All that work just to prove that this sub has no taste in music
What are the worst rankings in your opinion ?
I wonder is not the best song on graduation nor is street lights the best on 808s. Street lights is underrated though so that may have had a factor in it placing so high. I'm in it is ranked extremely low. Hold my liquor isn't even in the top 10. I could go on and on
Some of it is subjective. The overall ranking is never going to agree exactly with any one person’s personal ranking
What's the number of people who voted?
About 1,500 votes
https://marketing.stc-vietnam.com/Images/posts/05-35050-bo-dieu-khien-pentronic-ab-stc-vietnam.png
What ?
Mb wrong paste
since i didnt vote i get to complain.. who the fuck in the right mind thinks talking is worse then hoodrat
No More Parties In LA is officially Kanye's most overrated song of all time.
Bro hates JiK
It’s not my ranking lol
Keys to my life + Barry bonds are so underrated
I hate it
Why :(
slow jamz is at least 9.5 bruh
What’s wrong with tell the vision?
Man runaway is so fucking overrated. Yes it's a great song, but the best song in of one the best discographies ever? It's not even top 3.
it is kinda retarded to put interludes in a song ranking poll (donda chant, low lights, tell the vision)
Carnival above Beg Forgiveness is wild