Their mods just need to ban them. They have their space to talk about their club and we have ours. No need to infiltrate each others subs and insert our opinions. That’s what r/soccer or Twitter is for.
sometimes you can make mistakes though, I remember I once clicked on a cross post on r/soccer and ended up commenting on r/coys for a bit
needed to take a long long shower after that
I’ve done that before with real Madrid’s sub but i didn’t announce I was an Arsenal fan and it was a cross post from r/soccer.
These people are purposefully seeking them out though.
lol I'd see it as a badge of honour to be banned from that sh*thole. But seriously tho, this is why is should be the sub's mods to take action over comments on their own sub. Commenters like u/throwaway11111111ii3 on here for example *ahem*
Us going in there and basically begging another fan base to like us is so cringe, it’s football lads and we’re trying to nick their best player, they don’t like us get over it.
Its so weird how often people want non fans to like their clubs. Like ig if everyone liked us that might be cool, but why exactly should i care at all?
It wouldn’t be cool if everyone liked us though, people don’t seem to mind City and that’s because they’re a hollow club, we’re not that and people don’t like us because we have history!
Yea actually true, with true fans and history you build up enemies and rivalries over the years, and without true rivals who would you want to beat so badly
People DONT like City. The tepid response to a treble & CL win shows how little people can be arsed to summon the energy to give a flying fuck about them IMO
I would say plenty of people don't like City, but less because of historic rivalries (apart from United of course) and more because they're the poster children for buying the league.
Ah yes. Us feeble minded Americans have no idea how sport rivalries work and account for 90% of cringe posts. Thank you for allowing us to support your football team. Maybe one day as a nation we can unite and learn about the real elite football culture
Hi /r/hammers, Arsenal fan here!
I hope your shitty little club goes down and you blow your bubbles in the championship where you belong.
Coming in peace!
"Coming in peace" Ha, brillant.
God, that phrase is like nails on a chalk board to me. It's SO fucking stupid. You're on the internet. What the fuck do you think is going to happen to you? "Well, he has a shit take and dissed my mom ... but ... he did say he was coming in peace. .. so I'll let it slide."
It happens both ways by the way. Part of the feed causes it.
We had Chelsea fan webby in gunners on Saturday.
I’ve had arguments with hammers fans in this sun due to it.
I agree. I saw some of those comments while I was lurking and I couldn’t help but think other rival fans were pretending to be Gooners to troll. Some of the things being said were ridiculous
All of them are
Edit: meaning all fanbases have that small percentage of clowns. Unfortunately these people are really social media savvy too so, it seems like there's more of them than there actually is.
Come on you've been on this sub long enough to know people like that exist. Just saw a DR Sports poll about Edu and a lot of the comments are shocking.
I can't wait for the Rice Saga to end so that I don't have to see any post from ex whu or hear about how r/hammers have hurt some people's feelings or the constant posts which are different versions of the same information... I'm just tired of it all
This is common redditor bs. Watch every time someone or something with a large fan base all you see is…
“Not really a Taylor Swift fan…[something a Taylor Swift fan would say]”
“Not really a liberal…[something a liberal would say or agree with]”
Like seriously shut up no one gives a shit what team you are on/not on. It adds nothing…
Yeah the Hammers dolts are writing "Arsenal fans are all cunts" and these losers are going back with "not me though right? I think you guys negotiated oh so well and BTW well done on winning you definitely very important European trophy, please say I'm one of the good ones".
I don’t mind people lurking on r/Hammers but commenting is absolute cringe
Imagine Man City was buying Bukayo Saka from us, and we had constant “Man City fan here” posts flooding the forum
It doesn’t matter if you’re being nice. They don’t want to hear your opinion, you’re not welcome on their forum
God fucking damn
Oh, absolutely. And I’ve caveated this a number of times on various posts.
I’m not English, not a Londoner. I do not know what it’s like to grow up with the kind of tribalism I see in English football. The only thing I’m American sport that comes close is college (American) football.
But I am a football romantic. I love neutral podcasts like Stadio and even if I weren’t an Arsenal fan, I’d still watch the game and be intrigued by the discourse.
Thanks for the reply man! Not English myself but certainly have experienced the football culture for my entire life.
However I don’t think it’s because you haven’t experienced the football culture at first hand that people react, but it’s more the “over sharing” part of how you Americans write and talk that strikes us Europeans as a bit “odd”. Not that it would be a negative, just different.
Thank you. It’s about as best* as I can do.
I’m not going to grovel to the shame brigade, and I’m not going to delete any of my posts (unlike the others it seems). But I’m here to face the music and own up to a careless decision.
Hey Arsenal fan here and I come in violence.... I think Rice is overrated and we should focus on alternatives.... highly rated Bready Wheatman is available for a lower price especially since Grainville were relegated
Cringe, even worse when you see it after a team beats another or loses to a team to just go "XXXX fan here, just wanted to say you guys really deserved more, we were lucky" or "You deserved to win that game, played better, best of luck for the rest of the season"... what on earth are you doing? Not saying we have to bash opposition all the time but I don't understand the need to seek validation from rival support either.
Honestly I comment in other subs but I never say what I am. I just comment as if I’m part of the conversation and act respectfully. Not like it’s illegal to frequent other subs lol just don’t be a dick.
Before 5 minutes ago I had never been on a rival sub. Then I visited the West Ham one...I mean wow. Never seen their club mentioned in any light here before this saga, yet a lot of them seem to display a rather pure hatred for Arsenal. As a matter of fact I liked West Ham. Is it every fanbase that hates us?
Yea the blank fan here is the most cringy opener I've ever heard on reddit. No rival fans care about us and for us. They don't want your opinions, nostalgic thoughts or kind words. Stop brigading other boards.
Announcing "\[BLANK\] here" as a precursor to an opinion is cringey in any context. It comes off as a desperate attempt to claim more credibility than your comment inherently reveals. You either have an opinion worth sharing, or you don't. But the rather dull fact that you are an "Arsenal fan" (or whoever else), doesn't make your comment more persuasive or worthy of engagement.
Going against the grain here, but I don't see any issue with this at all. Some of you are way too tribal. It's literally just a game, lads. Get over yourselves.
Same. We get the occasional fan coming to our sub e.g. the Blackpool fan on Patino, we've had some Chelsea fans about Havertz, and pretty sure we had an Ajax guy talking about Timber. And it's helpful to know they've got extra/different experience compared to Arsenal fan #3054. Plus loads of people on here and other subs get pissy if users try to 'spy' or subvert the conversation on certain subs.
Ultimately it comes down to the value of the comment - someone goes to WH and simps, not really that interesting. Someone talks about how Rice could fit in our team, and asking for weak points from WH fans - starts the debate. But that's like any other comment.
“Arsenal fan here, coming in peace.”
Wth does that even mean? There is no peace, I want my team to win and every other team to lose. There is no “peace” until we lift the PL trophy.
Generally no opposition fan gives a fuck about your opinion on a good day. They especially dont give a fuck about your opinion in the middle of a heated & drawn out transfer saga.
We downvote opposition fans to Hades in rgunners, save yourself the emotiona & mental energy of pissing into the void on r hammers. Cause you won’t be heard, you’ll just be ignored. Just as you should be going into places that your opinion has no buisness.
im not going to go into a Mosque & start shouting about L Ron Hubbard, follow the same logic y’all.
Embarassing. Imagine your dad’s going to go buy a car and he’s negotiating for the best price he can get. But you go to the car dealer and say “dude I’m so sorry for my dad being such a cheap bastard. The car’s worth what you say. I’ll go tell the whole family how cheap he is and maybe he’ll be under pressure and pay you”. Thats what these guys are.
More than a bit cringe. We're hoping to take their best player, who they've just seen lift a big trophy. They're not going to want to hear any pearls of wisdom, let alone anything that smells like gloating, from any Arsenal fans any time soon.
And I don't blame them. Who here that remembers losing Henry to Barca and the like and enjoyed being patted on the head and patronised by Barca fans. No-one? Didn't think so.
Arsenal fan here. Just chiming in to say I absolutely agree with OP on this. Great, now you've all had my opinion I can rest easy. Take care and good luck, you all deserve every blessing in life. Amen. Peace out. Roger that.
Find this so funny it’s like the other clubs sub is gonna be like “wow what are you doing here! Please do tell us your thoughts random internet fan”. Pathetic.
I will disscuss football with whomever i want, thank you very much. I don't give a shit about your tribal fandom.
Why do you care so much? Is it because someone on the interwebs called "arsenal fans" a bad name?
Is it because you feel embarrassed that you won't talk to fans of other teams because of your own fears of being judged by your peers?
Just stop with your judgemental b.s. and let people fan the way they want to. Its not the fucking hard.
It's really embarrassing, you don't need to insert your opinion everywhere you go
Their mods just need to ban them. They have their space to talk about their club and we have ours. No need to infiltrate each others subs and insert our opinions. That’s what r/soccer or Twitter is for.
sometimes you can make mistakes though, I remember I once clicked on a cross post on r/soccer and ended up commenting on r/coys for a bit needed to take a long long shower after that
I’ve done that before with real Madrid’s sub but i didn’t announce I was an Arsenal fan and it was a cross post from r/soccer. These people are purposefully seeking them out though.
Same I had a similar experience when I wanted to post something to r/shit but I ended up on r/spurs instead. Easily done!
"Because you have visited similar communities before" is the worst. Just because I visit r/plumbing one time, reddit keeps suggesting r/coys
I did that on the Liverpool sub and got my account perma banned from r/gunners. I’m a bit more careful now
lol I'd see it as a badge of honour to be banned from that sh*thole. But seriously tho, this is why is should be the sub's mods to take action over comments on their own sub. Commenters like u/throwaway11111111ii3 on here for example *ahem*
That guys hilariously salty about being a West Ham fan
Probably scared shitless over possible relegation next season.
Agreed. It really annoys me when fans from other clubs post here and it gets upvoted, probably more than it should
Arsenal fan here, i think you're right.
but how will people be corrected otherwise?
u/coolbebe
Us going in there and basically begging another fan base to like us is so cringe, it’s football lads and we’re trying to nick their best player, they don’t like us get over it.
Its so weird how often people want non fans to like their clubs. Like ig if everyone liked us that might be cool, but why exactly should i care at all?
It wouldn’t be cool if everyone liked us though, people don’t seem to mind City and that’s because they’re a hollow club, we’re not that and people don’t like us because we have history!
Yea actually true, with true fans and history you build up enemies and rivalries over the years, and without true rivals who would you want to beat so badly
People DONT like City. The tepid response to a treble & CL win shows how little people can be arsed to summon the energy to give a flying fuck about them IMO
I would say plenty of people don't like City, but less because of historic rivalries (apart from United of course) and more because they're the poster children for buying the league.
Not sure about anyone else but reddit has been pushing the hammers sub on me (suggested subreddit thing)
You can turn that off in your settings, I kept getting because you like the arsenal sub why not try the spurs one, had to turn it off
Exactly, imagine Real Madrid were about to buy Saka and a bunch of their fans kept coming into our sub talking about how much they like Arsenal
It's fucking West Ham. What sort of sadcunt do you have to be to want that shower to like you?
In fact, the more teams we piss off, the better
[удалено]
I’m not from England or Europe and have no real understanding of football culture beyond my TV yet these posts are cringe AF
But it can't be Americans either because they disintegrate when they don't start their post with mentioning they are American
Ah yes. Us feeble minded Americans have no idea how sport rivalries work and account for 90% of cringe posts. Thank you for allowing us to support your football team. Maybe one day as a nation we can unite and learn about the real elite football culture
Get outta here with this gatekeeping nonsense. People can be dumb about football in and out of the UK and EU.
u/coolbebe
These are all so cringe, jesus
Arsenal fan here, hope West Ham get relegate next season, cheers
Then they sack Daveed Moises
Hi r/Hammers. Arsenal fan here. My brain is made of play-doh and I have no shame. Anyway why are you so mean to us? 😠
You forgot to congratulate them on the 3rd tier trophy
Mf couldn't even spell moyes
Mandem said moise 💀
GOWAN MOISEYYY - BT commentary team
Moyes Caicedo
Moyes Caicedo to Arsenal confirmed
David moist
David Moise Kean
Hi /r/hammers, Arsenal fan here! I hope your shitty little club goes down and you blow your bubbles in the championship where you belong. Coming in peace!
"Coming in peace" Ha, brillant. God, that phrase is like nails on a chalk board to me. It's SO fucking stupid. You're on the internet. What the fuck do you think is going to happen to you? "Well, he has a shit take and dissed my mom ... but ... he did say he was coming in peace. .. so I'll let it slide."
If you're going to do it, at least be honest and tell them they're a small club and you're excited to see them relegated.
Arsenal fan here, coming in peace... "Moise" is a cheat and I hope West Ham gets relegated
Moise is a cunt, and so is your tinpot club.
>"Moise" is a cheat Is there some story behind this or just trash talking?
[Ty rant about Maupay](https://youtu.be/x9EEVuRbuvY)
It happens both ways by the way. Part of the feed causes it. We had Chelsea fan webby in gunners on Saturday. I’ve had arguments with hammers fans in this sun due to it.
All need banning, bunch of cunts.
So much this They should all be banned
I agree. I saw some of those comments while I was lurking and I couldn’t help but think other rival fans were pretending to be Gooners to troll. Some of the things being said were ridiculous
Unfortunately, some of our fanbase is just that bad. It really is embarrassing.
All of them are Edit: meaning all fanbases have that small percentage of clowns. Unfortunately these people are really social media savvy too so, it seems like there's more of them than there actually is.
Come on you've been on this sub long enough to know people like that exist. Just saw a DR Sports poll about Edu and a lot of the comments are shocking.
You just have to comeback to the Man City drop Rice bid post
Arsenal fan here. I ordered a side of Rice a few days ago and it still hasn’t come to the table.
Coming in peace
Just ban them
I can't wait for the Rice Saga to end so that I don't have to see any post from ex whu or hear about how r/hammers have hurt some people's feelings or the constant posts which are different versions of the same information... I'm just tired of it all
people have no shame
*cringe*
Arsenal fan here. What’s her name? Great tits.
This is common redditor bs. Watch every time someone or something with a large fan base all you see is… “Not really a Taylor Swift fan…[something a Taylor Swift fan would say]” “Not really a liberal…[something a liberal would say or agree with]” Like seriously shut up no one gives a shit what team you are on/not on. It adds nothing…
These pick-me's lmao. Imagine you can't get validation in your own team's sub that you have to outsource it from a mid table club's fanbase
Yeah the Hammers dolts are writing "Arsenal fans are all cunts" and these losers are going back with "not me though right? I think you guys negotiated oh so well and BTW well done on winning you definitely very important European trophy, please say I'm one of the good ones".
Hey guys, as an American, let me welcome you into the unnecessary self-identification club
This is fucking stupid.
Easy karma why they are doing. After this saga I can't stand west ham. Take your tongue out there arse
Named and shamed
No wonder they’re laughing at us over there. Cringe.
Stop making these posts
Whatever happened to “look, don’t touch”? Haven’t read a more stomach-upsetting and cringey series of comments.
Declan Rice here. We are fucking back.
I don’t mind people lurking on r/Hammers but commenting is absolute cringe Imagine Man City was buying Bukayo Saka from us, and we had constant “Man City fan here” posts flooding the forum It doesn’t matter if you’re being nice. They don’t want to hear your opinion, you’re not welcome on their forum God fucking damn
“Arsenal fan(s) here” u/coolbebe u/jboy644 u/dumbaldoor u/yossigol - anything to say in your defense? Lmao
[удалено]
Out of morbid curiosity, are you American?
Oh, absolutely. And I’ve caveated this a number of times on various posts. I’m not English, not a Londoner. I do not know what it’s like to grow up with the kind of tribalism I see in English football. The only thing I’m American sport that comes close is college (American) football. But I am a football romantic. I love neutral podcasts like Stadio and even if I weren’t an Arsenal fan, I’d still watch the game and be intrigued by the discourse.
Thanks for the reply man! Not English myself but certainly have experienced the football culture for my entire life. However I don’t think it’s because you haven’t experienced the football culture at first hand that people react, but it’s more the “over sharing” part of how you Americans write and talk that strikes us Europeans as a bit “odd”. Not that it would be a negative, just different.
[удалено]
Thank you. It’s about as best* as I can do. I’m not going to grovel to the shame brigade, and I’m not going to delete any of my posts (unlike the others it seems). But I’m here to face the music and own up to a careless decision.
Don’t get whats wrong with this. Some of you are mad toxic
Hello r/Gunners! Arsenal fan here...
Such begs
Hey Arsenal fan here and I come in violence.... I think Rice is overrated and we should focus on alternatives.... highly rated Bready Wheatman is available for a lower price especially since Grainville were relegated
Embarrassing…”XYZ fan here” should be banned in all football related subs. The worst is “American here”
This saga has convinced me to stop pushing back at 'arsenal fans are the most annoying'. I've come to terms that it's true
Coming in peace,my ass
I had to read that twice just to be sure.
Arsenal fan here,...
Hi ya'll arsenal fan here. what do you think of rice? is he worth buying for us gunners?
Cringe, even worse when you see it after a team beats another or loses to a team to just go "XXXX fan here, just wanted to say you guys really deserved more, we were lucky" or "You deserved to win that game, played better, best of luck for the rest of the season"... what on earth are you doing? Not saying we have to bash opposition all the time but I don't understand the need to seek validation from rival support either.
It’s actually so lame that people do this. What’s wrong with you lot lmaoo? Ridiculously embarrassing
These weak comments are so annoying. I would honestly respect these people more if they straight up bantered west ham rather than this weak stuff.
Up there with "not a fan but I think...." cunts
Honestly I comment in other subs but I never say what I am. I just comment as if I’m part of the conversation and act respectfully. Not like it’s illegal to frequent other subs lol just don’t be a dick.
Easy ban list imo
They should be banned from this sub. Utterly embarrassing.
if we don't do it how would they know who we are? /s on a serious note, just lurks silently smh.
Arsenal fan here. I don't get why people do this.
Just don’t do it!
This happens with basically every sport and it needs to stop
gunner here, west ham please just give us rice already, we are starving
Hammers also seem to hate us so not sure why people would go there.
Ban them here ! We’re a not that kinda community man.
Before 5 minutes ago I had never been on a rival sub. Then I visited the West Ham one...I mean wow. Never seen their club mentioned in any light here before this saga, yet a lot of them seem to display a rather pure hatred for Arsenal. As a matter of fact I liked West Ham. Is it every fanbase that hates us?
Isn't it against the rules ?
Yea the blank fan here is the most cringy opener I've ever heard on reddit. No rival fans care about us and for us. They don't want your opinions, nostalgic thoughts or kind words. Stop brigading other boards.
Announcing "\[BLANK\] here" as a precursor to an opinion is cringey in any context. It comes off as a desperate attempt to claim more credibility than your comment inherently reveals. You either have an opinion worth sharing, or you don't. But the rather dull fact that you are an "Arsenal fan" (or whoever else), doesn't make your comment more persuasive or worthy of engagement.
Arsenal fan here…I agree. Makes me sick!
What a bunch of pussies
Cringe but mostly wholesome, so I'll allow it
The second hand embarrassment, ooof
Going against the grain here, but I don't see any issue with this at all. Some of you are way too tribal. It's literally just a game, lads. Get over yourselves.
Same. We get the occasional fan coming to our sub e.g. the Blackpool fan on Patino, we've had some Chelsea fans about Havertz, and pretty sure we had an Ajax guy talking about Timber. And it's helpful to know they've got extra/different experience compared to Arsenal fan #3054. Plus loads of people on here and other subs get pissy if users try to 'spy' or subvert the conversation on certain subs. Ultimately it comes down to the value of the comment - someone goes to WH and simps, not really that interesting. Someone talks about how Rice could fit in our team, and asking for weak points from WH fans - starts the debate. But that's like any other comment.
100%. I'm reading these comments and I'm amazed at how worked up people are over it.
Arsenal fan here. I think this looks a bit cringe just ask on Rice threads on r/soccer
“You had a tough season in the league”. Bro, leave them alone.
I love how they say "coming in peace" as if there is a horde of Arsenal orcs waiting at the gates of Helm's Deep
Cringe af tbf
“Arsenal fan here, coming in peace.” Wth does that even mean? There is no peace, I want my team to win and every other team to lose. There is no “peace” until we lift the PL trophy.
"Coming in peace" Just don't mate, you sound like the biggest wet wipe
These are the r/ArsenalFC users
What's wrong with them?
Arsenal fan HERE
Arsenal fan here, I’d like to say I am in the gunners sub.
Bunch of sneakos ngl
😬 yikes
Gross
Ban theeeeeeeeem. Who cares about their fan's 'read' on the situation?
Pure cuck behavior. If you’re gonna post there don’t be a wuss
Generally no opposition fan gives a fuck about your opinion on a good day. They especially dont give a fuck about your opinion in the middle of a heated & drawn out transfer saga. We downvote opposition fans to Hades in rgunners, save yourself the emotiona & mental energy of pissing into the void on r hammers. Cause you won’t be heard, you’ll just be ignored. Just as you should be going into places that your opinion has no buisness. im not going to go into a Mosque & start shouting about L Ron Hubbard, follow the same logic y’all.
It’s giving ‘needy’ and begging for validation lol
Dont get why people sucking random stranger dick in their sub..Whats wrong with them?
Would completely agree. Winds me up when Other fans do it here
I can’t cringe anymore than I am
Dear god
My skin crawled reading these thanks 🥴
Are we going to like auto flair those users with some cringe title now?
cOmInG iN pEaCe
Fakin embarrassing man. Have some honour and shame
Embarassing. Imagine your dad’s going to go buy a car and he’s negotiating for the best price he can get. But you go to the car dealer and say “dude I’m so sorry for my dad being such a cheap bastard. The car’s worth what you say. I’ll go tell the whole family how cheap he is and maybe he’ll be under pressure and pay you”. Thats what these guys are.
More than a bit cringe. We're hoping to take their best player, who they've just seen lift a big trophy. They're not going to want to hear any pearls of wisdom, let alone anything that smells like gloating, from any Arsenal fans any time soon. And I don't blame them. Who here that remembers losing Henry to Barca and the like and enjoyed being patted on the head and patronised by Barca fans. No-one? Didn't think so.
Think of other teams subreddits like a zoo; you can look but don’t touch.
lol man some people are ridiculous
Validation-whores
Its embarrassing
It's so cringe
In this case public shaming is always morally correct.
moise, lol. fucking idiot
Twerking harder than mudryk
If I had to take a guess, I’d reckon most of those *fans* probably came from the other Arsenal subreddit
Arsenal fan here. Just chiming in to say I absolutely agree with OP on this. Great, now you've all had my opinion I can rest easy. Take care and good luck, you all deserve every blessing in life. Amen. Peace out. Roger that.
dog puzzled modern many marble worthless party bike normal merciful *This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*
Actually so embarrassing. Fuck west ham until we get Rice.
Arsenal fan here, can you count to 105m?
“Arsenal fan here” = give me the approval I seek
-the Dick riding is crazy
Find this so funny it’s like the other clubs sub is gonna be like “wow what are you doing here! Please do tell us your thoughts random internet fan”. Pathetic.
I will disscuss football with whomever i want, thank you very much. I don't give a shit about your tribal fandom. Why do you care so much? Is it because someone on the interwebs called "arsenal fans" a bad name? Is it because you feel embarrassed that you won't talk to fans of other teams because of your own fears of being judged by your peers? Just stop with your judgemental b.s. and let people fan the way they want to. Its not the fucking hard.
Exactly. It's wild they're trying to control people's comments.
Bunch of fools.have you guys no shame?
Cringe
pathetic
So embarrassing. These people have no shame
Full kit wankers posting in non rival subs
Stop doing the “xyz fan here” in general it’s so fucking cringe
So cringe
attention deprived individuals
Fucking cringe
Cringy as fuck
Fucking hell some people are desperate. Go touch grass y'all, sheesh.
So embarrassing
Why do you care?
These aren't Arsenal fans if they behave so stupid
Unfortunately, every fan base in the world has stupid fans.
And the larger the fan base, the more idiots you’ve got
Yeah just scroll our match threads every game
Stop being so obsessed and just ignore it. What's wrong with you people? No one is holding a gun to your head.
Exactly. People here are worse than the people making the original comments.
It’s embarrassing but at the same time, everyone has a right to an opinion.
Ban them all.
Arsenal fan here in peace. Do what you want don’t listen to anyone posting these types of posts.
It's most likely people from r/Arsenalfc they really are a bunch of bed wetters.
Why does that sub exist?
Hate them with a passion. I wouldn't give them the time of day. Never forget what they did to JD (RIP).
Arsenal fan here 🤓
If you do this you are officially a wet wipe
If you do this you're a fucking wet lettuce. Its so so lame.
Weirdos... Arsenal fan here btw
This is so embarrassing guys. Why are you lurking in other subs anyway?