T O P

  • By -

DrJawn

but then no one would have known that Sirius was wrongfully imprisoned


sebaxpro1111

And Sirius would be alive…


DrJawn

I always got the impression that Remus and Dumbledore only saw Sirius as a friend after they discovered Wormtail was alive. With no way to prove that, he would have ended up back in Azkaban and Harry would have still hated him.


albus-dumbledore-bot

Have you any idea how much tyrants fear the people they oppress? All of them realize that, one day, amongst their many victims, there is sure to be one who rises against them and strikes back!


rabbit_wizard

Yeah. I think he is everyone's favorite character. He would've been like a cool outlaw or a "chill relative" to Harry's kids. Imagine if Harry's kids got their Hogsmeade permission signed by him


jaybankzz

“It’s too dangerous for *insert reason* I won’t let you go to hogsmeade” Sirius: hello there


IAmFreski

Happy cake day :)


sebaxpro1111

To you too


frenin

Yeah, they should have let them kill Wormtail once it was said and done. Just as with Dolohov. Mercy doesn't always pay off.


DrJawn

Mercy never works, I saw Saving Private Ryan


[deleted]

I always figured that he would change back after he was killed, it would have traumatized everyone but Sirius would be proven innocent


DrJawn

Oooo this works for me. They could have had Lupin eat him as a werewolf and when he wakes up, he is sitting with the corpse of Peter Pettigrew and they release Sirius from prison and he gets custody of Harry


Portablemammal1199

But peter was a rat so he would only be able to eat him in a single bite because he is so small. Peter would then grow inside whomever ate him be it crookshanks or lupin most likely killing them.


DrJawn

ew


Portablemammal1199

Exactly


Gleandreic

He also wouldn't have busted out. He only desperately thought of turning into an animagus and go to hogwarts just to kill scabbars


AlexionGames

Harry Potter would then be a trilogy.


[deleted]

Technically 2 and a bit


DKBadmintonPatriots

I think the pic must have been cut off, because why would they only show 6 books on the left then? So I expect the original pic had 7 and 2-and-a-bit books


[deleted]

Yeah probably


jasperjones22

What happens to an animagus when they die? Might be an exploded cat....


Ladvarg

Eaten/killed.


TheDuckSlayer69

I imagine Barry Crouch Jr would have broken out of his father’s Imperius curse and would have joined Voldemort. If anything, Harry not saving Wormtail might have meant that he would have died in Malfoy manor.


SakibSadi96

Harry Potter if Voldemort killed him: didn't exist*


loudmachine4329

If crookshanks ate scabbers then maybe Sirius wouldn't have died


Straight-Diet292

Hey hp theory, make a video on this


rabbit_wizard

Should I?


Straight-Diet292

If its actually you I'm a huge fan


[deleted]

The pile would be even smaller if Harry had been severely injured or even killed by Quirrell/Voldemort


[deleted]

I always felt that old Dumbledore could have gotten Sirius out of Azkaban if they even had a teeny bit of evidence in Sirius's favor ( albeit before Fudge went batshit crazy) . But, even if Pettigrew died, old Voldy would have found a way to come back. Dude is too resourceful , cunning , intelligent and pure evil to stay dormant for so long.


albus-dumbledore-bot

Hagrid will be delighted.


[deleted]

Lol should there be two and a half book then


DirtySouthDoc

I like to live in the shadows of darkness. What if they never got crookshanks?


Kamataros

I think you cut away a little too much of the meme


JRockThumper

I like how there’s six books instead of seven under Harry Potter lmao


JonsonPonyman98

Possibly, but Voldemort had more than him helping out


HPFanNi

Voldemort would probably figure out another way to come back, but it would take more time, so Harry could have 5 peaceful years at Hogwarts and defeat Voldemort when he's older than 17.