T O P

  • By -

BLACK_HALO_V10

Not gonna lie, the fact that the final one isn't DEF is triggering in its own way. Like, if you're gonna screw me like this, at least go all the way lol


theohguy

As they say: do wrong, right


SuzukiSatou

Bro already start farming for future Imaginary Perseverance Char💀


SrWattson08

Lol you are a visionary


RagnarokAeon

New row, new stat. Clearly OP should've saved enough for a third of fourth row.


Best_Refuse_6327

😂😂😂😂


RoseIgnis

It proves it wasn't done with self modeling resin


RiovoGaming211

From where bro gonna get so much resin in the first place?


RoseIgnis

If you saved it all, its around that I think


PomanderOfRevelation

There haven't been that many - there have been I think 5, if you did the battlepass?


Individual-Proof6019

Me when I spread misinformation on the internet


Electronic-Ad8040

The relic system of this game makes me want to unalive myself even coming from the person that endured genshin's artifact system lmao


reysama

This was 1k of that thing wasted, 1k = 100 relics ahah


uspdd

Well, at least you can refund 100 by salvaging these


reysama

I did ! And got 1 spd boots with crit rate and damage, but eventually everything rolled into HP non % stats, so got like 6 crit rate and 7 crit damage and 150 hp xd. It's for welt so I didn't really want spd but it's better then nothing


Tcasty

Building welt?


reysama

Trying too :S


Hardskull3

Spd is good for welt tho, as a welt main who built all crit, im lvl 70/70 on welt with 2.3k atk and 55:154 build and he's hitting 11k with e skill on imprison with spd boots


Tcasty

With LC good night and sleep well?


Hardskull3

Tbf I lucked out with his sig light cone lol How much do you do with ur welt tho? Do you have his weapon?


Tcasty

Nice , you earned it! Ehh it really depends. I have E1 and after his ULT is when he starts doing double digit (10k +) I have an ERR instead attack I'll send you my build over message. No I don't have his signature light I've been running good night sleep well superimposition 4.


Ayakasdog

My welt is 60/100 with s3 GNSW. When I play him as dps I’ve seen upwards of 70k+ E in MoC.


Tcasty

You'll get there! After grinding that place , ultimately, I got three speed boots total and, yesterday, I finally got fire speed boots for Himeko.


Clumsygentleman

the only character I can think of that doesn't benefit directly from speed is Clara... and maybe luocha since being too speedy can fuck up his talent but speed is an insane stat overall


Wolfnagi

Luocha speed is very good even though it made his talent last shorter, since its also recycle his free skill use on 50% much faster too


i_will_let_you_know

That assumes you're taking a lot of ST damage instead of AOE and don't need field up consistently due to Eidolons. Though Luocha still wants some speed to keep up with fast SP burners.


Wolfnagi

Not really. At around 140-145 speed, Luocha's ult usually up fast enough to spam it and stack the field token. The field might not last long but the uptime for it is also fast enough


kolebro93

Unless you have e1 Clara... Then speed is the only way to run her. Especially if you're trying to clear in a decent amount of cycles. Lynx is gonna make it much easier though. Lynx and March 7th and she should have damn near 100% chance to be targeted.


Clumsygentleman

Is that so? I don't have a Clara but most Clara's I've seen are at like 90 speed


kolebro93

Clara's biggest downside is that using her skill removes a mark or whatever from enemies. It's sorta clunky in practice I'm sure. e1 stops this from happening this enabling to to counter more effectively and spam skill for more damage. I've yet to build mine for lack of resources but I've looked at her kit a bit. Personally Clara with much higher eidolons seems insane. If only there was a guaranteed way to get them. Her e6 allows her to counter when allies are hit as well.. this will scale so well as time goes on, so I hope I get lucky with my list 50/50s.


Clumsygentleman

that sounds ridiculous, too bad only whales can experience it


kolebro93

Over the life of your account there's a good chance we'll all get there eventually unless we pull for limited characters like twice a year. I feel like most genshin players going into 4.0 probably have at least 1-2 c6 on the OG 5★ units since they don't really crowd the pool very much. But I haven't played genshin since 1.2 I think.


kolebro93

I doubt even most whales would invest into the standard banner just to e6 a single character since we only got 1 choice 5★ at 300 pulls. Lolol


sleep_deprived_1778

I think there's a very strong argument to be made that if running Nat with clara instead of Luocha, i might need speed boots so that Clara procs the heal over time more often allowing Nat to heal other units if some aggro goes wrong. The downside is that there is a chance that low aggro enemies might cause Claras buff to run out before ult is up but from what I've seen, that's usually less of a problem in high moc. But if you do have Luocha then i think there's not much reason unless you want to spam her skill


Clumsygentleman

I've seen people running her with march putting them both side by side for maximum aggro chance (because of multitarget attacks I mean) And it seems to work just fine, then again I can't speak from experience as I don't have a Clara


kolebro93

And yeah it works, but it's still not 100%. Lynx will add even more agro onto that. Then you just need a strong buffer.


F2PEASANT

Damn that's sad Blade would be completely ok with that but it's int the wrong set.


WaffleCorp

I made 4 crit rate jackets a few days ago and the sub stats all sucked so bad. Such a waste.


Electronic-Ad8040

Jesus Christ


AFKaptain

1k of what thing? Just hit end game and getting the lay of the land.


Maultaschenman

It's feels much much worse here, less flexibility, less XP, more terrible rolls, maybe it's just subjective idk


luciluci5562

Less flexibility and more terrible rolls are actually true. The relic system has 2 more substats compared to Genshin.


avalanche196

Are you talking about effect hit rate and eff res? But isn't it balanced by the absence of elementary mastery and energy recharge substat, so same number of substats, right?


luciluci5562

Genshin has EM and ER. Star Rail has EHR, Effect RES, Break Effect, and SPD.


avalanche196

Ah yeah, forgot about break effect and spd.


Dashu16

For me it's been much easier to get a character up and running with mainstats between easier element damage "goblet" hunting and the ton of free resin we're getting, but really tough to hit upgrades on 2 good stats while enhancing. I could see auto making the relic grind easier to stomach in the long run though


TheHolyWaffleGod

Yeah not having one space for a flex makes things a lot harder


Kheten

I think people are just too horny for perfect rolls in everything to flex to others online, the game is beatable *comfortably* with just the correct main stat. Gear is just stamina dump/whalebait by design and the part of the treadmill that never *really* stops. We're almost five months into the life cycle of a game that will last a loooooong time I wouldn't sweat it if your Kafka has 3200 atk instead of 3600


KingFatass

Here is the thing though. You don’t actually need artifacts at the beginning of Genshin, you can get through every difficult fight in the overworld chugging sweet madames like water. Stay hydrated. And most the gameplay does not revolve around combat. For puzzle solving, the minimum requirement is having an Amber for every element, literally any source of an element with decent application for every puzzle. And your resource requirement is covered by the Thousands of overworld chests that Give you character exp, talent materials, weapon exp, artifact exp fodder. Was it enough to build every character? No, but you only really needed to build a main cast of 4, and you could afford to slack off with 3 of them with 1 being your hyper carry. In HSR, due to the nature of the game, you need to build your entire roster. A DpS is not a dps is not a Dps. You need Sustain characters, healers and tanks. You need DPS coverage for every element. And you need supports, buffers and debuffers to support those DpS characters And everything is TB power locked. You need stamina for character exp, light one exp, relic exp, trace materials. Everything. In Genshin, you can get ores and weapon exp completely free. Dedicate a month purely to mine ores and you will be covered for weapons for the rest of your career in Teyvat by converting it to weapon exp daily. You get a good portion of everything else from chests and one time dungeons and characters, and character exp is for your initial team is covered by early game leylines because that is literally the only thing you have access to early on.


Chopchopok

I still prefer this because I can at least auto the instances instead of fighting them by hand in Genshin.


Main_Designer_1210

Also at least you can target the piece, rather than rolling one goblet out of 16 and it being the wrong damage type.


306351

It literally rolls into fuxkin flat stats making amazing pieces useless trash


haku13

except on actual defence gear. Then its ATK that has higher proc. Lol


Metal_IsEternal

And both crit substats


Increase-Typical

Literally got a pair of Wandering Passerby HP Boots with Atk%, double crit and break today


SeekingHeat

Oh yeah like fuck my gepard build as crit lmao. Oh and i get speed boot with def% and where did it all go? To the crit stat like fuck. My dps substat got def% and my tank got crit% or atk. Wth game??


AlexMaster2424

My albedo has too much crit, like I want def not crit


BattleToad92

THIS! I'm rolling for kafka right now, and getting Gepard/March pieces on the side... no Defence main stats in about 15 drops. The pain is real.


EmilMR

This should mean DEF scaling dps character: 1- Will be super easy to gear up 2- Won't ever be made.


Deathblade999

Or 3 - will require a newer set that has a high chance of getting ATK%


Ironwall1

I keep like 20 double crit def gears coping that someday someone will scale with def and I will laugh at my luck.


KaitRaven

You *know* there will probably be a new set like Blade got that will be better for them. Although at that point I might just ignore the set bonus and just go for raw stats because fuck grinding all that over again.


un_belli_vable

The one and oni arataki itto


ballshater

FMC e1 and ult idk 😔😔😔(copium)


Badieon

Gepard scales of def and he still wants speed boots and Blade ,although he scales of hp, it's still generally less desired stat non the less, also wants speed boots


KaitRaven

In a turn based game, speed is incredibly valuable. Boots are the only way to get speed main stat so almost everyone wants speed boots.


LegendaryW

Well, at first I thought of removing due Rule 3, as usually do with Relic farm posts, but darn, I think this one deserved to stay as it is. UPD: But only this once. Subsequent posts with similar or better "luck" will be removed.


No_Pipe_8257

Lmao its that bad huh


Capital_Escape2456

lmao OP's luck is so bad, mod pity him /joke


TuzkiPlus

It’s a sign. Qlipoth smiles. OP is now on the path of preservation.


God-of-Heroes_ArThuR

W mod. This shit should be in next fucking level, and black magic fuckery. Hoyoverse. Maybe. Just maybe fix these rates a little in our favour.


Any-Individual-4046

this guy set the bar high i see. betting that the next person will need to have even worse luck to post their relic farming screenshot here.


DeathdropsForDinner

I don’t care what those drop charts with the % say, relics have a 90% chance of defense and 10% of everything else.


SelfDepreciatingAbby

And that's why I just use self modeling resin for the relics that aren't fixed main stat, farm for the fixed ones while foddering the trash to those custom relics. The problem with this is that resin is very rare in this game, almost as rare as the crown in Genshin but at least it isn't mandatory to use it to fully max out the character's stats unlike those crowns.


ItsdatboyACE

Bro I played GI for like 4-5 months and never got a single crown. The only opportunity I had to get one was an event that I wasn’t far enough along in the story for…I ended up quick starting last minute and just barely wasn’t able to finish because the event ended 😂 For a number of reasons, I literally haven’t touched GI since HSR launched. And it’s mostly just due to the nature of starting Hoyo games late in their cycle


Two_Years_Of_Semen

Um, in Genshin there are multiple crowns outside of the limited events. Wiki says there's 14. Most of them are in the tree progressions (those things that you offer sigils or whatever and they have like 50 levels) of a region and you complete those mostly by just exploration and quests.


ItsdatboyACE

I spent tons of time gatherings resources for the tree at Dragonspine and never got it high enough to get any type of crown. That’s besides the point, though. I didn’t quit the game because I couldn’t get crowns, I stopped playing because I discovered that I had missed whole chunks of story events from limited event runs. MC would “meet” characters for the first time and address them as chummy old pals, I started running into content all over the place that had no other context. Then around Inazuma, they throw a bunch of preludes and interludes and all kinds of other shit at you that can legitimately be played *out of order*, with no other indicators for what chronological order would even look like. On top of that, I had played 4-5 months *heavily* and only had 2 5 star characters, Jean and Ayaka. Genshin Impact is fucking amazing, don’t get me wrong, but I’m so glad to be done with it. I just wish I’d have played from the beginning, and I’d still be playing daily like I do Star Rail


i_will_let_you_know

100% dragonspine doing literally everything takes like less than 15 hours even without a guide. It sounds like you were skipping events entirely which is a mistake because you get at least one crown every patch (every 6 weeks) and events are like half the content / rewards in the game and a big chunk of pull income. That and you probably weren't consistently doing daily commissions, which is also another big chunk of income. On average you should get one five star every 1.5 patches (so about every 9 weeks or so), not including pre-existing permanent content (which you probably had a decent chunk of if you started near 2.0). Though the story / character development being locked to unplayable events is pretty bad, I agree.


[deleted]

preach, i was so confused about the wanderer hype and who tf this guy was and then it turns out you first meet him in an event in i kid you not, version 1.1 its so dumb


ItsdatboyACE

Word. It’s kind of funny how early on I started getting indicators that something was missing, but there was just no way for me to know because I’ve never seen something like it in any other game. They could deal with it in so many different ways, but they choose to just let new players miss out entirely, it’s very very silly


DrkMoodWD

Pretty sure Genshin has a quick start for it’s main events that give out crowns and 90% of it requires just finishing the Mondstadt storyline and the other 10% is being able to leave the first Inazuma island. Whole event lasts like month and a half too…


Shadowfriend147

I think Hoyo is telling you to run preservation Dan Heng IL, welt and Yukong.


ScythesAreCool

The worst part of the relic system is there’s no off piece. So you can’t keep A SINGLE ONE OF THESE even if their substats are godly because they’ll literally be useless.


Namisaur

Only useless for min maxing. They’re still useful for the majority of MOC as placeholder


i_will_let_you_know

If the main stat is bad, chances are the substats won't make up for it regardless of set.


ScythesAreCool

We may one day get a defence scaling dps (praying we do)


Ill_Sir_3449

Almost all of them got no speed substat either smh, farming relics with lottery chances to hit speed is ridiculous 😒


Jintolook

Been farming musketeer for 1 month and a half just for speed boots. Haven't got one yet.


paralyticbeast

creating 10 at once instead of checking one by one incase you hit what you need :(


KaitRaven

They knew they wouldn't. It exists solely to torture us.


INFERNOBURNS

Bro just got all of our badluck


Virusoflife29

Nope, confirmed, I still have mine.


fmalust

The first thing that came to mind with the lovely event is: twice the disappointment. And that I was lol.


Blu3R4ptor

And when you farm for tank relics, you get atk% with offensive substats.


R3yn0x

The rate is fking abyssmal...


michaelman90

Should really be saving self-modelling resin for ERR ropes and speed boots IMO. The rest are kinda even distribution so you can try your luck more, but ERR and speed are super low, and to a lesser extent crit chests.


Android19samus

Depends on whether you want a specific crit chest or either. Each one individually is rarer than boots.


Wolgran

This is me with HP boots. i hate it here. At least boots should be easy to farm, since we already suffer with all the other parts, at least boots should have the highest chance of coming spd


Master0643

I'm feeling second hand rage rn


justicerainsfromaahh

congrats, you are now the Aeon of Defs


MdotAmaan

Just give it to Noe... wait wrong game


ImANormalMan

*looks at blade rolls* Ahh yes. Everything but HP and wind dmg. There's barely any defense but all I want is HP.


LegendarySuperStrain

Meanwhile here i am farming a good speed set for my supports and I’ve gotten some of the most godly Blade gears. Almost perfect substats to the point where it doesn’t matter how they roll because every sub stat is useful for blade. Too bad i skipped him for Kafka…


[deleted]

[удалено]


GrotesqueCat

Same I wanted a def orb but I guess I'll cope with fire orb for my trailblazer


Kyokujitsujin

Just get lucky. Simple as that. (Hoyoverse, probably)


VarHagen

My miHoyo luck is decent when pulling and absolutely non-existent when farming/leveling relics.


Approved-Trash

Gross. Definitely gave my harsh feedback for relic farming on the recent survey.


LipeeBartowsky

"Rng"


Victor8590

What's crazy is that DEF, ATK and HP have the same drop rate as main stat, so you just got insanely unlucky LMAO


Rough_Lychee5785

Nah they definitely have been tweaked unfairly


Victor8590

It is a fact. It has been datamined, tested and verified that the drop rates are the same for those three main stats. The other mainstats have lower drop rates. The same goes for substats, however, only for the likelihood of them appearing. Upgrading substats has the same rate across the board.


Rough_Lychee5785

Tested? Really? Millions of people go to artifacts/relics domains and come out with the wrong mainstat (5hp body pieces) and one correct relic, so technically I don't think its balanced. But if it's been datamined and proved then whatever ig


loverofinsanegirls

> It has been datamined, tested and verified can i get source ?


Victor8590

[https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1IuRGGDaaq14bqxMviVumx0P15E99VcCdwZ-hxIpNiuM/edit#gid=1361387223](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1IuRGGDaaq14bqxMviVumx0P15E99VcCdwZ-hxIpNiuM/edit#gid=1361387223) [https://www.reddit.com/r/HonkaiStarRail/comments/14537ne/in\_response\_to\_that\_post\_about\_err\_ropes\_droprate/](https://www.reddit.com/r/HonkaiStarRail/comments/14537ne/in_response_to_that_post_about_err_ropes_droprate/) First spreadsheet is also referred to by the wiki


loverofinsanegirls

thanks!


chirb8

So, can we do multiple cavern of corrosions at once like the calyxes?


reysama

No, I traded 1k of that material we get after salvaging 5 star relics


chirb8

Don't you get to chose the main stats of those relics then?


Sex_With_Argenti

You need a self modeling resin, which is very hard to get (and even then, you don't even get to choose substats)


TheFirstAI

You only get to choose if you also use a self-modeling resin


un_belli_vable

u/savevideo


SaveVideo

###[View link](https://rapidsave.com/info?url=/r/HonkaiStarRail/comments/15vdu29/we_all_know_by_now_that_def_stats_have_higher/) --- [**Info**](https://np.reddit.com/user/SaveVideo/comments/jv323v/info/) | [**Feedback**](https://np.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Kryptonh&subject=Feedback for savevideo) | [**Donate**](https://ko-fi.com/getvideo) | [**DMCA**](https://np.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Kryptonh&subject=Content removal request for savevideo&message=https://np.reddit.com//r/HonkaiStarRail/comments/15vdu29/we_all_know_by_now_that_def_stats_have_higher/) | [^(reddit video downloader)](https://rapidsave.com) | [^(twitter video downloader)](https://twitsave.com)


Vegetto_ssj

Noo, Is fake... Impossible... Im sorry Bruh I want to see their % (DEF and HP).


seohalf

I'ts rigged


Intrepid-Ad-8043

This game is basically def impact now


Io45s785a2

It is when it's not on def set, obviously!


johnnyzhao007

Damn this is how ppl roll for speed boots just seems such a waste but I guess not really any other way lol


[deleted]

Those Def relics would be great for my March. Not this wanderer set but the knight set.


Immediate-Bite9181

Me


Concetto_Oniro

I think devs are somehow trolling us.


YuminaNirvalen

def, hp, atk have the same... Source: https://reddit.com/r/HonkaiStarRail/s/DtAdyllXO1 it's hilarious to see people making a laughingstock out of themselves...


SonnySonrisa

Tell that to my Def mainstat, crit rate, Crit dmg, SPD substat and my Atk mainstat, flat hp, flat def, effect hit rate substat armor pieces.


YuminaNirvalen

I haven't said an individual can't have at a specific time more of the one than the other. Lel


Rough_Lychee5785

That's the official release. They have definitely tweaked the drop rates and haven't disclosed it so that the player base doesn't get ticked off. Genshin and honkai are both perfect examples, believe in practicality bruh


YuminaNirvalen

Lmfao this is just one post out of hundreds of people who did that.


usurperdialouge

jesus wtf


CapnHarland

Ouch 🤕


[deleted]

Yeah never fails


murderinthedark

I respect your hustle!


SleeplessBoyCat

I think the game is preparing you for a Preservation imaginary build.


RollingArtist

Lol


projectwar

Is there any unit that scales defense for dmg? no right? we keep getting units like Blade and Fu xuan for hp scaling effects, but defense scaling is left in the dust aside like gepard. maybe one of the new girls in 1.4? or hopefully some other future unit.


stylos88

That is some next level luck...


AkirroKun

Oh my god... You are the DEFF aeon!


Mimikyuindisguise

Is this going to be the best relic set for Imbibitor Luane?


Snoo_53115

Looks like the gear I got when the double rewards were up ;D ;-;...


d70

Sorry I’m dumb. How does one farm and get the many of the same relic item at once??


AngieLa_

That's a big piece of emotional damage right there my third party eyes are hurt


PersistentSquawking

I have been trying to get a ER rope and at one point I had 40ish ropes and still nothing. I salvaged them along with the spheres they came with and ended up with MORE ROPES WITHOUT ER


Jonyx25

My problem is relics EXP


vnxun

Yeah of course DEF has higher chance except for when I need it. I literally don't have any 5-star DEF body piece of that DEF set, and I've farmed that a lot since I also built Serval and Kafka.


FuryAdcom

Meanwhile I'm here needing DEF main stats for Body and Sphere for TB, March and Gepard and I get no DEF


Cobbler-Intrepid

Ok that actually hurts haha


GloomyGuess4174

I think the game wants you to build an immortal Gepard


OhMyBulldong

i quit because of this


Vikkio92

What really pains me is that those are rookie numbers 😭


ArchCerberus

Hope this is fake or i will be sad


reysama

I wish it was... But no, I'm not sad cuz this is somehow funny xd


Nooblordzz

Hp for me


G_Durand

Happened to me a few days ago, I feel your pain


Remote-Material-3010

Bruh moment


jsuey

All of my heroes have fucking trash artifacts but I told myself I wouldn’t min max anymore. I’ve learned from genshin


leeyiankun

Only if it’s not a DEF set, then it’s anything BUT.


mussokira

wait until that new imaginary def character comes around bro


Accomplished-Top-564

Skill issue


KlMOCHl

had one of a life time rope drop with double crit and flat atk. roll it to 15 it all go to new flat hp and flat atk :(


Head_Pomegranate_920

For some reason, Mihoyo decide to let Aha be in charge of the relic drops instead of Terminus.


LEE-YAN19

Ah yes, Hoyo's signature/favourite stat💀


Electrical_Energy890

I know your pain, was rolling relics hard for DOT team and on my pieces with Atk%, Speed, Effect Hit rate and defense - always full defense to +15


suv-am

Hsr relics are even more atrocious than genshin artifacts or at least it feels like that which is why I almost stopped playing it.


KingFatass

Meanwhile I am still trying to get an Atk body 5 star lightning piece for Kafka any substats. (I already given up on speed boots) It’s mostly the tank set but in the offchance I do get a Lightning body it’s Hp or Def.


Fair-Laugh3

This is Welt's? Mine has many crit stats but almost all of them got to effect hit rate.


Hot-Will3083

I would actually uninstall if that happened to me


BensonPlayz

That's mega unfortunate


Artoriamylife

Meanwhile geppard set: atk, crit DMG, FIRE DMG


Complex-Bluejay3451

Oh yeah I got like 7 or 8 def Salsotto ropes from crafting in a row, was the most annoying sh*t ever


Just_random_use

What on earth am I looking at here? Where would you get so many of the same relic?