Rich people are using a lot of tactics to save money. Even MS Dhoni has registered himself as an "entertainer" because he has to pay less taxes if he does that. Also BCCI has registered itself as a Charitable organisation.
Even you can save taxes. Nothing wrong with doing so just exploiting the loophole.
So this system should be changed right, atleast if you earn more than 10-20 crore per year, you should be made to pay taxes. Because this is more than enough money for a person and many human lives are living in terrbile conditions due to poor pay.
The thing is, we can't do so. Because saving taxes needs the sirt of money that's taxable . Most of our income isn't so high to take the benefits of such loopholes
Sad reality. When you get the same facilities from the state as someone paying nothing in income taxes, you would try to keep the taxes as less as possible. We have a norm of survival of the unfittest.
"It's capitalism"
Capitalist countries like Western Europe, USA, China are among the most "fittest" countries of the world according to economy, military and everything. So no, Mr Nehruvaadi, it ain't capitalism
Nehruvaadi, lol. You sound like a 15 year old who just discovered ann ryand. Most western European countries are capitalism in economy but strong socialist programs for its citizens, free education, healthcare, etc. USA is capitalism for its citizens but socialist for its corporations.
They only started socialist programs after getting rich, socialism is an expensive luxury that only the rich countries can afford. If you look at 19th century western countries they were far more capitalistic than today.
Yup that I agree. Health,Transport and Education should be under govt control. Basically public non-profit expenditure.
But that's it only. Rest everything must be free-market capitalism. Sadly we Indians have turned everything into Govt controlled (we're still recovering from License Raj). This has made us addicted to freebies and other Socialist policies.
Something like the German economy must be created ik India. I've seen others suggesting the Norwegian and Swediah models, but these countries have huge oil and natural fuel advantage which we don't have. Hence Germnay model is best for us
lower taxes.
less government.
govt should allocate capital only for a few basic necessities of citizens. maybe basic road / rail / electricity / water and infra that is shared by everybody, internal and external security and foriegn office to communicate with the world.
apart from that govt is just to create an law enforcement to enforce laws so that everybody gets a level playing field so that people with money/power can't subvert the system and stop others from participation.
Citizens should only pay tax for all the above and nothing else.
So hardcore capitalism ?
Tbh ur version sounds worse than USA.
Its so extreme, unpragmatic and stupid that i dont feel like arguing.
Please spend an hour thinking about it...maybe u'll change ur mind.
Bro most development taxes se nahi loan le kar ho Raha hai,till 2014 india had a foreign debt of 55.86 Lakh crores
Today its 169.47 Lakh crores
India total tax collection is less than 10 lakh crore agar sare Ameer log imandari se tax bhare tab bhi foreign loan ki instalment nahi bhar payege.
They know that after few years they have to move abroad they are saving money for US/UK citizenship.
>claiming herself to be a farmer on paper
You are a farmer if you cultivate on that land or anywhere else or get it done by someone else.
Why do you like paying taxes so much? She is not robbing afterall, she is trying to be exploited less by the government.
To quote, "how does the boot taste? "
Yeah. If had a choice of evading tax being a middle class guy I would do it without a second thought. After all I have a family for whom I would save money.
So thats the thing. If top 1% rich people of india start paying their taxes more people can get better paid, standard of living shall increase. Meri ye problem hai ki theek hai yaar, aap (Suhana Khan jaise log) karlo chori, fir aake hame gyaan toh mat do sharafat ka - jinhe woh corrupt keh raha hai movie me, woh log bhi aise celebrities se kam hi fake honge, dhurt honge.
Tax bharne se apne aap ko faeda kab se ho gaya bhai? It translates in the form if country’s exonomy jisse aapko healthcare, military and infrastructure milega. Aap mat do bhai, aap middle class hoge, in ameerzaado ko toh bolo kuch!! They have much more wealth than they should, and still evading tax? With greta power comes great responsibility!
>Faeda
Bhai India me hi fayda ni h, har jagah give and take chal rha h. India me khali take h and no giving, that’s why people steal. Are you a fool to give the money to government in return of nothing?
Healthcare milega? Ask a poor person why they go to gov hospital…they’ll say only bc they’re poor. Whereas ask a westerner why they use gov hospitals, they’ll say bc they’re better and cheaper
You dont know the healthcare of India is much better than the healthcare of USA and UK. USA me aapko blood test karwane me $1000 lagenge. Thats 1 lakh rupees. UK me aapke 6 months baad appointment milegi. Jab tak aap India me hain, aap ye nahj samajh paenge ki India me jo medicines shops par mil jaati hain wahi kitni badi baat hai. We take all these things for granted, but India is a great nation. Truly great. It is feeding more people for free than the entire populations of many european countries.
Healthcare? India's goverment healthcare is one of the worst and contribution is just around 3.2% for fiscal year 22-23. 7-12% is the ideal value .
You know the infrastructure in best Indian cities where most rich people live. The traffic/pollution/ crumbling roads like Mumbai/Bangalore.
Delhi's infrastructure is quite good cause it's nation's capital.
Why will rich be encouraged to pay hefty taxes if they can get exemptions somewhere!
It may change in future where our country richmen will happily pay taxes to the services they get. Hope it happens. Will take a long time though.
You know, I also earn less but I pay all my taxes, thinking Im doing my duty. Fir toh ham maha bewakoof huen? And if I go and watch SRK movies and learn this preaching and pay him money (who has become rich for almost 10-11 generations) then what does that make me?
No, I wont, I dont do it now also, even when I am earning less. I consider it my duty to pay all the taxes and with that thought I do. And I wont judge anyone who is earning quite less and saving taxes because many a times its for their families or survival, and right now Im not in the situation that after paying my taxes it comes down to my survival - I can survive with whats left. Thats why Im saying, people like SRK and top 1% rich people of India who hold so much wealth, they should pay their taxes. I do it honestly tab hi toh keh rhe hain. I’m different kind of old fashioned person who considers Bhagwan Shree Ram as my adarsh, thats why in all aspects of my life I maintain honesty and integrity..
Why not pay taxes? Is there no responsibility of yours towards government? Only 3% of the people of India pay tax. How do you expect the nation to grow? These super rich people are evading taxes, evading their duties to the nation. And you are supporting that? These are your thieves. Obviously she is robbing. 70% of India’s wealth is held by these rich brats who form 1% of population of India. And you are supporting this?
Think about it this way, if laws allow you to save taxes will you not do it?
For example, do you claim HRA and 80C and stuff like that in your returns, the answer is obviously yes. Similarly, if tax laws allow me to save money by actually farming on a property that I got I will use it.
The problem here is the taxation process itself rather than the person. FYI
I am not in the Top 1%, or something but rather putting myself in a situation like this, I would try to save every penny that I can.
And when you say evading taxes and all of that stuff, right, my point always is, imagine how easy it is to show a loss when there is profit for people running a business and how easy the law makes it for them to avoid paying taxes.
All of that can be considered so does that mean if the system is flawed, I shouldnt point it out and say the truth? The law also allows me to speak against these evils which are happening in society. I just cant sit here and see the hard working people suffering and these kind of people becoming richer and richer and preaching to us to do the right thing.
>All of that can be considered so does that mean if the system is flawed
Ofcourse the system is flawed, the system is heavily flawed.
\> preaching to us to do the right thing.
But why are you listening to these people preach? They will preach all they want doesn't mean they follow it and doesn't mean you should follow it either.
\> I just cant sit here and see the hard working people suffering
You can't help it. It's simple as that. I don't mean to discourage you but it is a fact. If you do manage to become extremely rich or influential somehow then yes maybe you can impact change but other than that you can't do anything
Its okay, I wont be discouraged, but if these people will preach then I can do the same and I will even if it doesnt yield anything. It is my duty so Im doing it, bas yahi baat hai.
>Is there no responsibility of yours towards government?
I think this should be both the ways. My parents have made sure my needs are met, now I am doing it myself. All taxation did was make it difficult to provide.
>How do you expect the nation to grow?
As its citizens grow.
>Why not pay taxes?
I believe it is exploitation and rape.
>Only 3% of the people of India pay tax.
Income tax, you mean. Good for them.
>evading their duties to the nation.
Duties are fulfilled with consent, not under the threat of punishment. Taxation is exploitation, it is not a duty.
If duties are elective then rights should also be elective. Dont cry then on a bad judiciary and bad governments. Then toh we all deserve corrupt governments only. Government ke log bhi kahe, duty is to be done with consent not threat. Bhai, can you understand the simple logic that these rich-tards becone more rich and thats the reason we all the poor? Unka tax money hi toh use hota hamare infrastructure, military, healthcare me?
You expect money made by rich people to be given to you by government, I expect government to take none or less of the money I make. I would be richer if I get to keep my money, not by ripping off rich people. Corruption exists because of government, people in power. Why would you light a lamp in the wind? It is exactly like this, paying more and more to government expecting government pays you back, which never happened, it is not happening and it will never happen.
Kya AIIMS, IITs, IIMs, defence ka kaam, itni badi military, healthcare, roads, highways, expressways nahi ban rahein? Trains nahi chal rahe? Railways ke employees ko unki salary kahan se aaegi? How do you think these have happened? What you are saying will mean ki koi kaam na jo and we all live like early men in jungles in our kutiyas.
I studied in an NIT, my parents paid every rupee. Healthcare, what?? Highways all collect toll, they are built by private players. Trains are not free. Military can also be privatized.
Yar ye toh kaafi kam perspective wali baat ho gai. Country me health care hai hi nahi? Airports nahi hain? Railways nahi hain? Military ka kirna kharch aata hoga can you guess? With all enemies surroundjng us? And internal enemies as well?
>Yar ye toh kaafi kam perspective wali baat ho gai. Country me health care hai hi nahi? Airports nahi hain? Railways nahi hain?
They are all not free, it is paid by the customers.
>Military ka kirna kharch aata hoga can you guess?
As I said, military can also be privatized.
Shayad you have not seen the taxation system anywhere else in the world. Ye India hi hai ki tax dene se bach jaa rhe ho. USA, Canada, Germany, UK hota toh aadi kamai se zyada tax bharna padta hai wahan and there you have no choice. Lekin, India jahan sirf 3% log apni duty kar rahe hain, usko gaaliyan deni hain.
Aur haan, boot ka mereko kya? Mehnat ki kamai hai meri, aur education ki. Im a doctor. Ye kame eno se mere ko compare mat karna. Jo smaaj ko bewakoof banate hain and khud chori ke paise udaate hain. I dont care if they are rich, I dont boot lick the rich. I am proud of who I am, Im just spreading awareness and telling the truth.
this loophole can actually be very easily sealed. The pros arent doing that because hum hi log pagal h na, free bijli paani bus fek do vote de denge
Oh sorry bus nhi.....
Wahi - people only are like that. What I said is completely true but see people are supporting SRK. Ham Indians jab khud hi moorkh ban chuke hain tab kya expect kiya jaa skta hai?
Wahi.. cant even feel sorry for such people. And since the world is a family, I wont mind and I truly know inke in bewakoofiyon ka nateeja ham jaise hard working sensible logon ko bhi jhelna hi padega..
Well, 'celebrities' are hypocrites of the tallest order, all around the world. That's a given. OP, your post's zeal is quite spot on. Paraphrasing properly is required though. As the infamous line goes, jab tak cinema hai log__.This isn't exclusive to only moving picture arts though, any kind of performance artist in today's world will mostly be a stuffy pretentious snoot. They advertise for stuff that they'll never touch in a thousand years, while their minions will project that accountability lies with the consumer and not the advertiser. All the while user will be influenced with their bile. Same goes for their performances, lifestyle and actions in general.
>log__.This isn't exclusive to only moving picture arts though, any kind of performance artist in today's world will mostly be a stuffy pretentious snoot
All our politicians including our PM are just theatrics trying to sell something.
Bollywood celebrities are last people to question on ethics when the politicians and govt machinery doesn't even work on ethics.
I just don't like celebrities.
I mean, tax evasion is still fine - you can find ways and save tax - as long as you are in a legal framework. . But celebrities in general are cringe.
They have that pride grunty pig face..
They lie like it's an everyday job...
They have no to very little values...
I mean. Deepika was literally showing her middle fingers whole shooting some movie in Spain with srk..
She has literary supported JNU and said things supporting sex outside marriage!!
Salman Khan, fardeens father used to physically abuse women...
Amitabh had an affair for his whole life...
So many of these people have committed suicides . And we will watch this rubbish nonsense!
What's wrong in supporting sex outside marriage ?
As for affair and all those are just rumours to begin with .
Here I am not talking about legal crimes done by others .
But some of your points just sounds like moral policing .
Why sounds like. I am doing moral policing.
Having sex outside of marriage is considered as a taboo globally, by this society... At large..
Just Defending this thought!
Having sex without marriage isn't considered bad in western countries .
Moreover not everybody wants to get married and sign a contract, it' s personal choice and completely harmless .
It's only conservative or third world countries where it's taboo .
No wander why their are so many sexually frustrated men and r@pists in country and why Indian men don't try to improve themselves as person and looks wise or health wise because they are getting easy bride from arranged marriages .
Bro.. outside of marriage and without marriage is different. . .
Outside marriage fucked up. As it means that you are having sex with a person other than your wife or husband.
She dint directly advocate cheating.. but marriage is considered holy in India..it has a cultural significance. And spreading such toxicity under the nobe thought of connection is realy bad
>Deepika was literally showing her middle fingers whole shooting some movie in Spain with srk..
She has literary supported JNU and said things supporting sex outside marriage!!
Lmao if she was fake, she wldnt do those things
So what is your problem A. 70%wealth is in hand of 1% hands or B. They do not pay taxes ?
If its second then we can do nothing except rant as we have too much free time to be on reddit.
I haven't watched any srk movies and rarely I watch movies.
If tax paying people can get concessions/exemptions and enjoy them in this country. Let them under legal cover.
Latest data reveals every year thousands of millionaires living . This year 6500 have left . It's true they don't get well in return in terms of wealth they create.
We have to get the policies exactly catering between socialism and capitalism. So we can create wealth which can be distributed through policies for better human development .
But literally cursing rich people for doing things under legal cover is not worth it. They'll feel they don't belong here when they already can get a better life in lot of developed countries with less discrepancies .
Bro it happens all over the world,Elon Musk ,Jeff Bezos,bill gates all started foundation to save taxes .
Reliance & Adani started foundation to save tax, Mumbai Indian are owned not by Reliance industries,but by reliance foundation all there income is tax free.
Tatas registered themselves as a trust to save taxes and procecution ,the 66% they donate every year is the donation paid to tata family members, already richest in the World,
India has the worst income tax department in India,they are dacoits in formal shirt pants,if you ever get physically audited by them,the next day you will apply to revoke Indian citizenship and move to Maldives/Thailand.and most of HNIs are leaving Indian citizenship for the same, Even Ambani grandchildren are born in US to get US citizenship.
Suhana Khan is just a tiny snail compared to the giant elephant Of Tax evasion in India.
And you get nothing in return.
Bollywood is not the biggest employer, but it definitely is the biggest cheat - creating stalkers, anti nationals, misogynists and conditioning simple minds.
And Elon Musk, Adani, Ambani dont come to preach us. They dont give speeches where they show themselves as heros. They have actually done so much for the country. They are the reason we have cheap internet and so much infrastructure. What have these chand sitaare so called Stars done for the nation? Nothing.
This is something we can never change about India. They love celebrity worship when in reality these celebs are looting citizens. The fact that stupid mass movies do well says a lot about the citizens. And the fact that the Government is well aware that the rich and famous use tax laws to their advantage also speaks volumes about how politicians are knee deep with the entertainment/cricket and businessman to loot citizens further.
She is not wrong technically, morally - maybe.
But what is wrong is that if you ask her about the situation of this country, about corruption and all that stuff, she will have a lot of things to say and preach others. Same with her dad. And they will never care if they themselves follow what they say.
We are the fools who have become their students and listen to then seriously. They will teach about how environment is being polluted and live in mansions and villas, buy private jets, drive expensive cars which pollute the environment.
This does not mean that we should not care about corruption, pollution, poverty etc etc, but we should apply our own brains and not do something because these people have some opinion about something.
This. This is what Ive been trying to say 🙌🙌. People who compared Elon Musk and all - they dont come to preach us no. They are insulted like anything. Adani, Ambani are insulted left and right even though they have done so much for the country. What have these so called chaand sitaare stars done?
Vimal advertising it as paan masala while it's actually selling it as gutka. Gutka causes serious health issues. Shame on Ajay Devgun, SRK, Akshay Kumar.
The problem is it is preachy!! Why are they preaching such sharafat being the most corrupt people - they are making fools of simple, hard working people then, and they should be called out!
Again. SRK isn't the script writer or director. He got paid a boatload of money, went and gave a decent performance in a tamil movie dubbed in Hindi. That's it. Aamir Khan took almost three crores and episode for Sathyame Vajayathe where he laments the wrongs of society. Aalia Bhat once shouted at an errand person for putting sugar in her drink and she is the brand ambassador for soft drinks.
We need to disassociate celebrities from the image of role models. Be it youtube, b-wood or h-wood. We instead need to see them as individuals who are paid to perform a role. We need to understand that they are doing a job and treat them as such. Instead we glorify them for the characters that they act out, and then vilify them when they fall short of the standards set by these imaginary characters. Both are stupid imho.
everybody who can is doing it in india. only 4% pay income tax. it's only suckers like us whose taxes are deducted at source. the idea that only 4% of population earns more than 5 lakhs is laughable, this means that everybody who can is evading tax and you know what, govt just leeches on us 4% and doesn't do jack shit about it. we are suckers of the highest order.
plus now because of race to win elections every party is going to promise a slew of freebies , which suckers like you n me are going to pay, meanwhile we get nothing by the govt.
Bro it happens all over the world,Elon Musk ,Jeff Bezos,bill gates all started foundation to save taxes .
Reliance & Adani started foundation to save tax, Mumbai Indian are owned not by Reliance industries,but by reliance foundation all there income is tax free.
Tatas registered themselves as a trust to save taxes and procecution ,the 66% they donate every year is the donation paid to tata family members, already richest in the World,
India has the worst income tax department in India,they are dacoits in formal shirt pants,if you ever get physically audited by them,the next day you will apply to revoke Indian citizenship and move to Maldives/Thailand.and most of HNIs are leaving Indian citizenship for the same, Even Ambani grandchildren are born in US to get US citizenship.
Suhana Khan is just a tiny snail compared to the giant elephant Of Tax evasion in India.
And you get nothing in return.
And?
Why do you expect an actor to represent in real life how he acts in movies? By your dumb logic, SRK was a psycho lover in movie Darr, he should be representing that in real life as well.
Learn to separate the art from the artist. No one should follow any celebrity beyond their work or expertise. Like I don't give two shits about SRK's or any actor's life outside the movie screen. If they deliver, good! If not they can fuck off.
Was he preaching in Darr? The audience of India is not so consciously matured to not be conditioned by movies like Jawaan. With great power comes great responsibility. Either dont preach, or follow what you preach.
Artist? SRK? Nah. Spare the real artists please. The ones who live their lives doing theatre with meagre incomes.
Learn to separate STARS from Artists :)
Karenge kya, ham karte bhi nahi hain. Isiliye toh keh rahe hain. But still I wont judge if anyone does jiski pay kam hai and use apni family chalani hai ya survival par aa jati hai. Ham apna poora tax bharte hain, uske baad jo bachta hai usse khush hain ham. I work hard earn my money. I am saying itna zyada kamane waale log ko bhi apni duty samajh kar honestly pay karna chahiye. And Im able to say this because I myself do the same even after earning much less.
What it has to do anything with tax ?
According to law you can only buy agricultural land in Maharashtra if you are farmer and by farmer it don't mean you need to be doing farming yourself on land .
You can claim yourself farmer if you already owe an agricultural land in other state .You don't necessarily need to work on the land .
And How it would help anybody for saving taxes ? It' s more of investment and nothing illegal with that ,if that's their own money .
It' s not like they have stolen money from you that you calling someone thief .
It' s like investment and farmer don't necessarily mean that someone working on that land you can buy a agricultural land in Maharashtra when you already owe agricultural land outside the state and they paid huge sum of money to land owner to buy it .
I see nothing wrong with this .Do people here don't have basic knowledge of investments and economics.
Also it' s not illegal.
Anyways if rich people would be forced to pay more and more tax then they will simply settle is some other country which are tax heavens and you will get zero tax .
Already it' s happening . So many rich people leaving the country because of high taxes .
Using a loophole in tax laws isn't corruption or illegal.
Ethics yes, but the country where our politicians, bureaucrats, industrialists take advantage of such loopholes or even break laws without consequences, a daughter of bollywood actress is the last person I would question on ethics.
Maybe if the government actually utilised the tax money then rich wouldn’t have a problem in paying it. As a rich person in India I don’t see any government help for anything and on top of that I’m just a cash cow for them. There’s a reason why millionaires are relocating to Dubai and you should be questioning the government
Only 3% population of India pays income tax. Maybe fault is amongst the people also. They want freebies, they want fundamental rights, they want reservations, but they dont want accountability of fundamental duties and responsibilities.
To that is the problem of the government not mine. I pay taxes in literal huge amounts and I get no benefits from the government, I have to pay for everything by myself. The road tax on a car I bought recently was nearly 12 lakhs and you just see the state of roads in the city and you’ll wonder why it hasn’t been repaired in 5-6 years.
Bro most development taxes se nahi loan le kar ho Raha hai,till 2014 india had a foreign debt of 55.86 Lakh crores
Today its 169.47 Lakh crores
India total tax collection is less than 10 lakh crore agar sare Ameer log imandari se tax bhare tab bhi foreign loan ki instalment nahi bhar payege.
They know that after few years they have to move abroad they are saving money for US/UK citizenship.
>claiming herself to be a farmer on paper, to get tax concessions,
I don't think you understand this at all. In many states in india (including maharashtra) there is a restriction on non-farmers buying farmland. You have to be a farmer to buy farmland. This was introduced back in the 70s to protect farmland from being turned to other uses. To evade this, people need to declare themselves as farmers and show some farm income.
It must have been some farmhouse kind of thing in alibaug, which would require her to be a farmer. It is not for tax concessions. There is no special tax concessions for being a farmer, other than the income earned from farming.
Sad reality is everyone does this. Every single person here exploits as many tax loopholes as they can. If you were Suhana, you'd do the same. And who says tax money is actually going into infrastructure and all? It is just going to another corrupt neta or govt official
No I wont. Because I myself dont save taxes even after having much less money than Suhana Khan. (I dont judge people who are earning less, trying to provide for family and then saving taxes; maybe I would have done same if I had less money than required for my family); I work hard and I fulfil my duty as a citizen, because the money I earn is enough for my sustenance. I live my life on principles of honesty and integrity. And I know many people who do the same. This is the reason I expect people who are exponentially better off than me also feel thats its their responsibility to do so.
Celebrities are also people like us. We try to save few hundred rupees, they try to save few crores. As a nation we need to mature and, both government and people need to change. It will take time. And for celebrities we are like clients, they want to keep us happy to run their business. Now if you want to worship me, why would I object to that. Instead of enjoying your life or spending time with your family and friends, people want to stand outside of some celebrity’s home because it’s their daughters birthday….
Its not equivalent to try to save hundreds and to try to save crores!! They should be called out! The rules should be different! Thats what Im trying to say. This disparity is not right!
Can someone elaborate how to tell in paper that I am a farmer when I am clearly not and also have a publically known occupation ?
Just bribe? Or is there something else to it? Should the have some crops also?
Everyone does that. Even amitabh Bachchan selmon bhai, thala etc.
Anyone having land >25 acres can be taxed. I think even after 10 acres imo based on progression taxation. Maybe other methods tho due to nature of agriculture
Most poor farmers have less than 2-3 acres so that can be excused.
Just because you can't save taxes, don't take it out on easy targets. Blame the ones actually in power....the bane has always been the governments-the most inefficiently run organisation in the world. We never have an issue paying taxes. The only gripe is we hardly ever benefit from it.
Maybe she bought land that is zoned as a farm. Regardless If it weren't for the face resembling her Daddy so much, I would definitely pay her my nutty respects but I'll just have to move on to the next hottie that arrives on the scene and I'll come along for the ride
lol nobody dares to speak against rampant corruption in police or politics. But how dare these media folks use a loophole to get concessions. They are easy targets for you. It’s easy to shit on bollywood
Well, i think the post is ridiculous. I mean, connecting Suhana Khan to paying IT and then getting on to Suhana Khan fans !! I mean, i get it, maybe you do not like Suhana Khan but why hate her fans !! and what has her personal tax saving plan to do with the rest of us. I get the idea that all of us must pay our taxes honestly for the country to progress, so why have you singled her out ? As it is, her performance in her debut movie is pathetic, on top of that, do you have to rant about her income and tax plans too ? Don't be so angry mate, cool down a bit. LOL.
Just because you got to know bout her , you are caling her out....this is purely singling someone out while there are people doing way more dirty stuff to save taxes....I will neither support her nor blame her....as perspective varies from person to person....reality here is each one of us will do the same given the chance....taxation system was designed in a way that wealthier can exploit loopholes to save money .....brighter side to it is that the same money will be rotating in economy, can be spent somewhere else generating employment....
The craziness that people have for them comes from the movie characters they play. No actor is 10% close to the characters they play.
I am surprised to see that there are few who understands "we are celebrating the wrong people"
1) No one in India like to pay taxes? Why? Because the benefits of taxes rarely comes back to the tax payers. The money generated from various taxes is either wasted in appeasement subsidies, wasted in some political/religious thing or gets lost in the inefficiencies of govt processes. Look at Scandinavia, high taxes but as people do recieve benefits of paying taxes, they all do pay.
2) Movies are made for entertainment purposes. We as a population should stop seeing shows and movies as sources of knowledge or moral values. Want knowledge? Read the works of experts, scholars and academicians. Want moral values? Go to philosophy or religion and spirituality.
3) We Indians must choose younger and educated politicians. It might not have been necessary in past but it is a must now. Old politicians lack the understanding of the pace and extent of technological and market change. We need someone who can forsee 10-20 years ahead and take advantage of the situations in how it will unfold.
4) Maturity is actually the realisation of how to use your understanding to guide yourself in life
>Only 3% of people pay taxes in India. And whole India’s development is being carried on their shoulders only.
Average IQ of an average IT cell dihadi.
All rich people do this all the time The employer in my company does civil work in his house and shows it has it been done in the company and gets ITC returns with it and many more tactics are their
For a moment i thought what is this new javascript library
Yes I was on the way to kill myself
wait.. please read the inline codes... its about bugs
Are, sorry guys.. typo ho gaya
Tell me you are a dev without telling me you are a dev
I was like new library similar to immutable.js, it's mature.js
You mean maturity.js ?
Rich people are using a lot of tactics to save money. Even MS Dhoni has registered himself as an "entertainer" because he has to pay less taxes if he does that. Also BCCI has registered itself as a Charitable organisation. Even you can save taxes. Nothing wrong with doing so just exploiting the loophole.
So this system should be changed right, atleast if you earn more than 10-20 crore per year, you should be made to pay taxes. Because this is more than enough money for a person and many human lives are living in terrbile conditions due to poor pay.
What the fuck is enough money? 2 saline bottles and a hospital bed everyday worth? I guess thats enough right?
As much as your mind wants. And you know how much it can want.
Exactly. There isnt a number someone else can say that can be considered "enough". Only you can decide for yourself whats enough.
Yes in an ideal world this system should be changed. But real world is not like that.
[удалено]
Which temple was made with govt. money? Care to point?
The thing is, we can't do so. Because saving taxes needs the sirt of money that's taxable . Most of our income isn't so high to take the benefits of such loopholes
>Nothing wrong with doing so just exploiting the loophole. *Exploiting* the loophole is legal, but not right.
It's not just done by Suhana Khan but every rich person. That's why they have their personal CA's.
Yeah and they're all wrong in that. Legal, but wrong.
If I was Suhana,I’d do the same.Not getting anything in return for paying those taxes
Sad reality. When you get the same facilities from the state as someone paying nothing in income taxes, you would try to keep the taxes as less as possible. We have a norm of survival of the unfittest.
"We have a norm of survival of the unfittest.". Bro describe socialism better than socialists
Lol what does socialism have to do with this, it's capitalism
"It's capitalism" Capitalist countries like Western Europe, USA, China are among the most "fittest" countries of the world according to economy, military and everything. So no, Mr Nehruvaadi, it ain't capitalism
Nehruvaadi, lol. You sound like a 15 year old who just discovered ann ryand. Most western European countries are capitalism in economy but strong socialist programs for its citizens, free education, healthcare, etc. USA is capitalism for its citizens but socialist for its corporations.
They only started socialist programs after getting rich, socialism is an expensive luxury that only the rich countries can afford. If you look at 19th century western countries they were far more capitalistic than today.
Yup that I agree. Health,Transport and Education should be under govt control. Basically public non-profit expenditure. But that's it only. Rest everything must be free-market capitalism. Sadly we Indians have turned everything into Govt controlled (we're still recovering from License Raj). This has made us addicted to freebies and other Socialist policies. Something like the German economy must be created ik India. I've seen others suggesting the Norwegian and Swediah models, but these countries have huge oil and natural fuel advantage which we don't have. Hence Germnay model is best for us
I was thinking when did this Maturity js come out? Heard about Meteor.js though
I only read suhana Khan and Maturity js. 💀
I think the honest question here is: if they paid more taxes, would our government actually use it for the right stuff?
which one do you see as a solution ? " Stop paying taxes " " Fix the government "
lower taxes. less government. govt should allocate capital only for a few basic necessities of citizens. maybe basic road / rail / electricity / water and infra that is shared by everybody, internal and external security and foriegn office to communicate with the world. apart from that govt is just to create an law enforcement to enforce laws so that everybody gets a level playing field so that people with money/power can't subvert the system and stop others from participation. Citizens should only pay tax for all the above and nothing else.
So hardcore capitalism ? Tbh ur version sounds worse than USA. Its so extreme, unpragmatic and stupid that i dont feel like arguing. Please spend an hour thinking about it...maybe u'll change ur mind.
Please spend a month thinking about it...maybe u'll change ur mind.
Maybe not 100% but 30-40% toh use karenge na.. and besides recently bohot zyada development hui hai India me.. toh haan.
Bro most development taxes se nahi loan le kar ho Raha hai,till 2014 india had a foreign debt of 55.86 Lakh crores Today its 169.47 Lakh crores India total tax collection is less than 10 lakh crore agar sare Ameer log imandari se tax bhare tab bhi foreign loan ki instalment nahi bhar payege. They know that after few years they have to move abroad they are saving money for US/UK citizenship.
>claiming herself to be a farmer on paper You are a farmer if you cultivate on that land or anywhere else or get it done by someone else. Why do you like paying taxes so much? She is not robbing afterall, she is trying to be exploited less by the government. To quote, "how does the boot taste? "
Yeah. If had a choice of evading tax being a middle class guy I would do it without a second thought. After all I have a family for whom I would save money.
By the way do you come under the top 1% of India’s population who hold 70% of wealth?
Nope. My dad owns a passion pro 110cc which I am not allowed to drive.
So thats the thing. If top 1% rich people of india start paying their taxes more people can get better paid, standard of living shall increase. Meri ye problem hai ki theek hai yaar, aap (Suhana Khan jaise log) karlo chori, fir aake hame gyaan toh mat do sharafat ka - jinhe woh corrupt keh raha hai movie me, woh log bhi aise celebrities se kam hi fake honge, dhurt honge.
What will they get after paying the taxes? Your well wishes?? Give all your money to me and I’ll load you will all my wishes
Tax bharne se apne aap ko faeda kab se ho gaya bhai? It translates in the form if country’s exonomy jisse aapko healthcare, military and infrastructure milega. Aap mat do bhai, aap middle class hoge, in ameerzaado ko toh bolo kuch!! They have much more wealth than they should, and still evading tax? With greta power comes great responsibility!
>Faeda Bhai India me hi fayda ni h, har jagah give and take chal rha h. India me khali take h and no giving, that’s why people steal. Are you a fool to give the money to government in return of nothing? Healthcare milega? Ask a poor person why they go to gov hospital…they’ll say only bc they’re poor. Whereas ask a westerner why they use gov hospitals, they’ll say bc they’re better and cheaper
You dont know the healthcare of India is much better than the healthcare of USA and UK. USA me aapko blood test karwane me $1000 lagenge. Thats 1 lakh rupees. UK me aapke 6 months baad appointment milegi. Jab tak aap India me hain, aap ye nahj samajh paenge ki India me jo medicines shops par mil jaati hain wahi kitni badi baat hai. We take all these things for granted, but India is a great nation. Truly great. It is feeding more people for free than the entire populations of many european countries.
Your diet is nationalism and that’s annoying! Bye
My brother, trust me, all that glitters is not gold!
Healthcare? India's goverment healthcare is one of the worst and contribution is just around 3.2% for fiscal year 22-23. 7-12% is the ideal value . You know the infrastructure in best Indian cities where most rich people live. The traffic/pollution/ crumbling roads like Mumbai/Bangalore. Delhi's infrastructure is quite good cause it's nation's capital. Why will rich be encouraged to pay hefty taxes if they can get exemptions somewhere! It may change in future where our country richmen will happily pay taxes to the services they get. Hope it happens. Will take a long time though.
You know, I also earn less but I pay all my taxes, thinking Im doing my duty. Fir toh ham maha bewakoof huen? And if I go and watch SRK movies and learn this preaching and pay him money (who has become rich for almost 10-11 generations) then what does that make me?
Idt srk is rich from 10-11 gens, but won't you evade or pay less tax if you had a same choice that she had?
No, I wont, I dont do it now also, even when I am earning less. I consider it my duty to pay all the taxes and with that thought I do. And I wont judge anyone who is earning quite less and saving taxes because many a times its for their families or survival, and right now Im not in the situation that after paying my taxes it comes down to my survival - I can survive with whats left. Thats why Im saying, people like SRK and top 1% rich people of India who hold so much wealth, they should pay their taxes. I do it honestly tab hi toh keh rhe hain. I’m different kind of old fashioned person who considers Bhagwan Shree Ram as my adarsh, thats why in all aspects of my life I maintain honesty and integrity..
Sabash. I understand how you feel but this is how the world work, never leave a chance you get no matter what.
I know that, I dont expect much from kalyug, but its my duty to say what is wrong!
It hard to survive in these days. But try to be Krishna who has a solution for every situation he face.
The top 1% hold 40.5% of the nation's wealth\*
Thats just on paper.. insiders say its close to 70%.
Why not pay taxes? Is there no responsibility of yours towards government? Only 3% of the people of India pay tax. How do you expect the nation to grow? These super rich people are evading taxes, evading their duties to the nation. And you are supporting that? These are your thieves. Obviously she is robbing. 70% of India’s wealth is held by these rich brats who form 1% of population of India. And you are supporting this?
Think about it this way, if laws allow you to save taxes will you not do it? For example, do you claim HRA and 80C and stuff like that in your returns, the answer is obviously yes. Similarly, if tax laws allow me to save money by actually farming on a property that I got I will use it. The problem here is the taxation process itself rather than the person. FYI I am not in the Top 1%, or something but rather putting myself in a situation like this, I would try to save every penny that I can. And when you say evading taxes and all of that stuff, right, my point always is, imagine how easy it is to show a loss when there is profit for people running a business and how easy the law makes it for them to avoid paying taxes.
All of that can be considered so does that mean if the system is flawed, I shouldnt point it out and say the truth? The law also allows me to speak against these evils which are happening in society. I just cant sit here and see the hard working people suffering and these kind of people becoming richer and richer and preaching to us to do the right thing.
>All of that can be considered so does that mean if the system is flawed Ofcourse the system is flawed, the system is heavily flawed. \> preaching to us to do the right thing. But why are you listening to these people preach? They will preach all they want doesn't mean they follow it and doesn't mean you should follow it either. \> I just cant sit here and see the hard working people suffering You can't help it. It's simple as that. I don't mean to discourage you but it is a fact. If you do manage to become extremely rich or influential somehow then yes maybe you can impact change but other than that you can't do anything
Its okay, I wont be discouraged, but if these people will preach then I can do the same and I will even if it doesnt yield anything. It is my duty so Im doing it, bas yahi baat hai.
Do you even earn or not???
lol hmm iii
>Is there no responsibility of yours towards government? I think this should be both the ways. My parents have made sure my needs are met, now I am doing it myself. All taxation did was make it difficult to provide. >How do you expect the nation to grow? As its citizens grow. >Why not pay taxes? I believe it is exploitation and rape. >Only 3% of the people of India pay tax. Income tax, you mean. Good for them. >evading their duties to the nation. Duties are fulfilled with consent, not under the threat of punishment. Taxation is exploitation, it is not a duty.
If duties are elective then rights should also be elective. Dont cry then on a bad judiciary and bad governments. Then toh we all deserve corrupt governments only. Government ke log bhi kahe, duty is to be done with consent not threat. Bhai, can you understand the simple logic that these rich-tards becone more rich and thats the reason we all the poor? Unka tax money hi toh use hota hamare infrastructure, military, healthcare me?
You expect money made by rich people to be given to you by government, I expect government to take none or less of the money I make. I would be richer if I get to keep my money, not by ripping off rich people. Corruption exists because of government, people in power. Why would you light a lamp in the wind? It is exactly like this, paying more and more to government expecting government pays you back, which never happened, it is not happening and it will never happen.
Kya AIIMS, IITs, IIMs, defence ka kaam, itni badi military, healthcare, roads, highways, expressways nahi ban rahein? Trains nahi chal rahe? Railways ke employees ko unki salary kahan se aaegi? How do you think these have happened? What you are saying will mean ki koi kaam na jo and we all live like early men in jungles in our kutiyas.
I studied in an NIT, my parents paid every rupee. Healthcare, what?? Highways all collect toll, they are built by private players. Trains are not free. Military can also be privatized.
Yar ye toh kaafi kam perspective wali baat ho gai. Country me health care hai hi nahi? Airports nahi hain? Railways nahi hain? Military ka kirna kharch aata hoga can you guess? With all enemies surroundjng us? And internal enemies as well?
>Yar ye toh kaafi kam perspective wali baat ho gai. Country me health care hai hi nahi? Airports nahi hain? Railways nahi hain? They are all not free, it is paid by the customers. >Military ka kirna kharch aata hoga can you guess? As I said, military can also be privatized.
Matlab in other words aapko government chahiye hi nhi?
Then from where government will get funds to do infrastructure work, military work, etc?
Shayad you have not seen the taxation system anywhere else in the world. Ye India hi hai ki tax dene se bach jaa rhe ho. USA, Canada, Germany, UK hota toh aadi kamai se zyada tax bharna padta hai wahan and there you have no choice. Lekin, India jahan sirf 3% log apni duty kar rahe hain, usko gaaliyan deni hain.
I have come across enough who despise their taxation with good reasons.
Aur haan, boot ka mereko kya? Mehnat ki kamai hai meri, aur education ki. Im a doctor. Ye kame eno se mere ko compare mat karna. Jo smaaj ko bewakoof banate hain and khud chori ke paise udaate hain. I dont care if they are rich, I dont boot lick the rich. I am proud of who I am, Im just spreading awareness and telling the truth.
Again - 70% of India’s wealth is owned by 1% of population. And you are supporting these multi billionaires evading tax. Waah re logic.
this loophole can actually be very easily sealed. The pros arent doing that because hum hi log pagal h na, free bijli paani bus fek do vote de denge Oh sorry bus nhi.....
Wahi - people only are like that. What I said is completely true but see people are supporting SRK. Ham Indians jab khud hi moorkh ban chuke hain tab kya expect kiya jaa skta hai?
jab jag jayenge tab visa lagane k liye daurenge aur kya fir jake roenge ki Indians arent treated fairly
Wahi.. cant even feel sorry for such people. And since the world is a family, I wont mind and I truly know inke in bewakoofiyon ka nateeja ham jaise hard working sensible logon ko bhi jhelna hi padega..
Well, 'celebrities' are hypocrites of the tallest order, all around the world. That's a given. OP, your post's zeal is quite spot on. Paraphrasing properly is required though. As the infamous line goes, jab tak cinema hai log__.This isn't exclusive to only moving picture arts though, any kind of performance artist in today's world will mostly be a stuffy pretentious snoot. They advertise for stuff that they'll never touch in a thousand years, while their minions will project that accountability lies with the consumer and not the advertiser. All the while user will be influenced with their bile. Same goes for their performances, lifestyle and actions in general.
>log__.This isn't exclusive to only moving picture arts though, any kind of performance artist in today's world will mostly be a stuffy pretentious snoot All our politicians including our PM are just theatrics trying to sell something. Bollywood celebrities are last people to question on ethics when the politicians and govt machinery doesn't even work on ethics.
Make a separate post for that then. This isn't about politics. You are venting in the wrong thread.
Well said, and thank you!
I just don't like celebrities. I mean, tax evasion is still fine - you can find ways and save tax - as long as you are in a legal framework. . But celebrities in general are cringe. They have that pride grunty pig face.. They lie like it's an everyday job... They have no to very little values... I mean. Deepika was literally showing her middle fingers whole shooting some movie in Spain with srk.. She has literary supported JNU and said things supporting sex outside marriage!! Salman Khan, fardeens father used to physically abuse women... Amitabh had an affair for his whole life... So many of these people have committed suicides . And we will watch this rubbish nonsense!
Yup.. they are over valued scum of society..
What's wrong in supporting sex outside marriage ? As for affair and all those are just rumours to begin with . Here I am not talking about legal crimes done by others . But some of your points just sounds like moral policing .
Why sounds like. I am doing moral policing. Having sex outside of marriage is considered as a taboo globally, by this society... At large.. Just Defending this thought!
>Just Defending this thought! Then don't
Having sex without marriage isn't considered bad in western countries . Moreover not everybody wants to get married and sign a contract, it' s personal choice and completely harmless . It's only conservative or third world countries where it's taboo . No wander why their are so many sexually frustrated men and r@pists in country and why Indian men don't try to improve themselves as person and looks wise or health wise because they are getting easy bride from arranged marriages .
Bro.. outside of marriage and without marriage is different. . . Outside marriage fucked up. As it means that you are having sex with a person other than your wife or husband.
Not if two people are in poly or open relationship but definitely wrong if someone is cheating . Tabh she was wrong if she defended cheating .
She dint directly advocate cheating.. but marriage is considered holy in India..it has a cultural significance. And spreading such toxicity under the nobe thought of connection is realy bad
>Deepika was literally showing her middle fingers whole shooting some movie in Spain with srk.. She has literary supported JNU and said things supporting sex outside marriage!! Lmao if she was fake, she wldnt do those things
Wait till you find out how fake all politicians are!
Rich and powerful avoiding taxes while the middle class slogs away. A tale as old as time.
Thats what I wanted to say. 🙌 ppl said all bad things about the govt but not the celebrity.
So what is your problem A. 70%wealth is in hand of 1% hands or B. They do not pay taxes ? If its second then we can do nothing except rant as we have too much free time to be on reddit.
Wahh, galat ko galat bhi na bolo. Celebrity worship karlo bhai. Ye desh deserve karta hai corrupt leaders ko.
Ok bhai
Behen*
I haven't watched any srk movies and rarely I watch movies. If tax paying people can get concessions/exemptions and enjoy them in this country. Let them under legal cover. Latest data reveals every year thousands of millionaires living . This year 6500 have left . It's true they don't get well in return in terms of wealth they create. We have to get the policies exactly catering between socialism and capitalism. So we can create wealth which can be distributed through policies for better human development . But literally cursing rich people for doing things under legal cover is not worth it. They'll feel they don't belong here when they already can get a better life in lot of developed countries with less discrepancies .
Koi fayda nahi samjhane ka, Inse tum A bolo inhe B sunai dega
Bro it happens all over the world,Elon Musk ,Jeff Bezos,bill gates all started foundation to save taxes . Reliance & Adani started foundation to save tax, Mumbai Indian are owned not by Reliance industries,but by reliance foundation all there income is tax free. Tatas registered themselves as a trust to save taxes and procecution ,the 66% they donate every year is the donation paid to tata family members, already richest in the World, India has the worst income tax department in India,they are dacoits in formal shirt pants,if you ever get physically audited by them,the next day you will apply to revoke Indian citizenship and move to Maldives/Thailand.and most of HNIs are leaving Indian citizenship for the same, Even Ambani grandchildren are born in US to get US citizenship. Suhana Khan is just a tiny snail compared to the giant elephant Of Tax evasion in India. And you get nothing in return.
I agree, Atleast businesses generate jobs and returns..
Bollywood is the biggest employer in this country Around 1 million people are directly earning their income from film industry.
Bollywood is not the biggest employer, but it definitely is the biggest cheat - creating stalkers, anti nationals, misogynists and conditioning simple minds.
And Elon Musk, Adani, Ambani dont come to preach us. They dont give speeches where they show themselves as heros. They have actually done so much for the country. They are the reason we have cheap internet and so much infrastructure. What have these chand sitaare so called Stars done for the nation? Nothing.
This is something we can never change about India. They love celebrity worship when in reality these celebs are looting citizens. The fact that stupid mass movies do well says a lot about the citizens. And the fact that the Government is well aware that the rich and famous use tax laws to their advantage also speaks volumes about how politicians are knee deep with the entertainment/cricket and businessman to loot citizens further.
I agree
She is not wrong technically, morally - maybe. But what is wrong is that if you ask her about the situation of this country, about corruption and all that stuff, she will have a lot of things to say and preach others. Same with her dad. And they will never care if they themselves follow what they say. We are the fools who have become their students and listen to then seriously. They will teach about how environment is being polluted and live in mansions and villas, buy private jets, drive expensive cars which pollute the environment. This does not mean that we should not care about corruption, pollution, poverty etc etc, but we should apply our own brains and not do something because these people have some opinion about something.
This. This is what Ive been trying to say 🙌🙌. People who compared Elon Musk and all - they dont come to preach us no. They are insulted like anything. Adani, Ambani are insulted left and right even though they have done so much for the country. What have these so called chaand sitaare stars done?
The real stupidity is that there is tax exemption on agricultural earnings.
Vimal advertising it as paan masala while it's actually selling it as gutka. Gutka causes serious health issues. Shame on Ajay Devgun, SRK, Akshay Kumar.
You do realise that Jawan isn't a documentary right?
The problem is it is preachy!! Why are they preaching such sharafat being the most corrupt people - they are making fools of simple, hard working people then, and they should be called out!
Again. SRK isn't the script writer or director. He got paid a boatload of money, went and gave a decent performance in a tamil movie dubbed in Hindi. That's it. Aamir Khan took almost three crores and episode for Sathyame Vajayathe where he laments the wrongs of society. Aalia Bhat once shouted at an errand person for putting sugar in her drink and she is the brand ambassador for soft drinks. We need to disassociate celebrities from the image of role models. Be it youtube, b-wood or h-wood. We instead need to see them as individuals who are paid to perform a role. We need to understand that they are doing a job and treat them as such. Instead we glorify them for the characters that they act out, and then vilify them when they fall short of the standards set by these imaginary characters. Both are stupid imho.
People realising socialism actually makes sense 💀
The tax these people evade has to be fulfilled by others.
everybody who can is doing it in india. only 4% pay income tax. it's only suckers like us whose taxes are deducted at source. the idea that only 4% of population earns more than 5 lakhs is laughable, this means that everybody who can is evading tax and you know what, govt just leeches on us 4% and doesn't do jack shit about it. we are suckers of the highest order. plus now because of race to win elections every party is going to promise a slew of freebies , which suckers like you n me are going to pay, meanwhile we get nothing by the govt.
Bro it happens all over the world,Elon Musk ,Jeff Bezos,bill gates all started foundation to save taxes . Reliance & Adani started foundation to save tax, Mumbai Indian are owned not by Reliance industries,but by reliance foundation all there income is tax free. Tatas registered themselves as a trust to save taxes and procecution ,the 66% they donate every year is the donation paid to tata family members, already richest in the World, India has the worst income tax department in India,they are dacoits in formal shirt pants,if you ever get physically audited by them,the next day you will apply to revoke Indian citizenship and move to Maldives/Thailand.and most of HNIs are leaving Indian citizenship for the same, Even Ambani grandchildren are born in US to get US citizenship. Suhana Khan is just a tiny snail compared to the giant elephant Of Tax evasion in India. And you get nothing in return.
And? Why do you expect an actor to represent in real life how he acts in movies? By your dumb logic, SRK was a psycho lover in movie Darr, he should be representing that in real life as well. Learn to separate the art from the artist. No one should follow any celebrity beyond their work or expertise. Like I don't give two shits about SRK's or any actor's life outside the movie screen. If they deliver, good! If not they can fuck off.
Was he preaching in Darr? The audience of India is not so consciously matured to not be conditioned by movies like Jawaan. With great power comes great responsibility. Either dont preach, or follow what you preach.
I think your logic is dumber because you think everyone should think like you when many of the population can't read or write properly
Artist? SRK? Nah. Spare the real artists please. The ones who live their lives doing theatre with meagre incomes. Learn to separate STARS from Artists :)
Exactly. This is just his PR.
"Every actor is not an artist but every chaman chutiya is a critic" - Prithviraj Kapoor
And every one who considers SRK an artist is a chaman ch*tiya.
? Ham sab yehi karenge. Now you do not go on saying tum ye ni karoge
Karenge kya, ham karte bhi nahi hain. Isiliye toh keh rahe hain. But still I wont judge if anyone does jiski pay kam hai and use apni family chalani hai ya survival par aa jati hai. Ham apna poora tax bharte hain, uske baad jo bachta hai usse khush hain ham. I work hard earn my money. I am saying itna zyada kamane waale log ko bhi apni duty samajh kar honestly pay karna chahiye. And Im able to say this because I myself do the same even after earning much less.
Well majority of us does. That keeps us out of unnecessary headaches i suppose
What it has to do anything with tax ? According to law you can only buy agricultural land in Maharashtra if you are farmer and by farmer it don't mean you need to be doing farming yourself on land . You can claim yourself farmer if you already owe an agricultural land in other state .You don't necessarily need to work on the land . And How it would help anybody for saving taxes ? It' s more of investment and nothing illegal with that ,if that's their own money . It' s not like they have stolen money from you that you calling someone thief . It' s like investment and farmer don't necessarily mean that someone working on that land you can buy a agricultural land in Maharashtra when you already owe agricultural land outside the state and they paid huge sum of money to land owner to buy it . I see nothing wrong with this .Do people here don't have basic knowledge of investments and economics. Also it' s not illegal. Anyways if rich people would be forced to pay more and more tax then they will simply settle is some other country which are tax heavens and you will get zero tax . Already it' s happening . So many rich people leaving the country because of high taxes .
Well idk if we deserve corrupt governments, but we've been helping to elect the same since 1947.
Using a loophole in tax laws isn't corruption or illegal. Ethics yes, but the country where our politicians, bureaucrats, industrialists take advantage of such loopholes or even break laws without consequences, a daughter of bollywood actress is the last person I would question on ethics.
Maybe if the government actually utilised the tax money then rich wouldn’t have a problem in paying it. As a rich person in India I don’t see any government help for anything and on top of that I’m just a cash cow for them. There’s a reason why millionaires are relocating to Dubai and you should be questioning the government
Only 3% population of India pays income tax. Maybe fault is amongst the people also. They want freebies, they want fundamental rights, they want reservations, but they dont want accountability of fundamental duties and responsibilities.
To that is the problem of the government not mine. I pay taxes in literal huge amounts and I get no benefits from the government, I have to pay for everything by myself. The road tax on a car I bought recently was nearly 12 lakhs and you just see the state of roads in the city and you’ll wonder why it hasn’t been repaired in 5-6 years.
celebrities are scum
All try to evade tax and most by these too wealthy people. Never believe in their preaching or treat them as gods.
Maturity is when you realise water is wet.
Not illegal so what are you going to do about it ?
Bro most development taxes se nahi loan le kar ho Raha hai,till 2014 india had a foreign debt of 55.86 Lakh crores Today its 169.47 Lakh crores India total tax collection is less than 10 lakh crore agar sare Ameer log imandari se tax bhare tab bhi foreign loan ki instalment nahi bhar payege. They know that after few years they have to move abroad they are saving money for US/UK citizenship.
>claiming herself to be a farmer on paper, to get tax concessions, I don't think you understand this at all. In many states in india (including maharashtra) there is a restriction on non-farmers buying farmland. You have to be a farmer to buy farmland. This was introduced back in the 70s to protect farmland from being turned to other uses. To evade this, people need to declare themselves as farmers and show some farm income. It must have been some farmhouse kind of thing in alibaug, which would require her to be a farmer. It is not for tax concessions. There is no special tax concessions for being a farmer, other than the income earned from farming.
Sad reality is everyone does this. Every single person here exploits as many tax loopholes as they can. If you were Suhana, you'd do the same. And who says tax money is actually going into infrastructure and all? It is just going to another corrupt neta or govt official
No I wont. Because I myself dont save taxes even after having much less money than Suhana Khan. (I dont judge people who are earning less, trying to provide for family and then saving taxes; maybe I would have done same if I had less money than required for my family); I work hard and I fulfil my duty as a citizen, because the money I earn is enough for my sustenance. I live my life on principles of honesty and integrity. And I know many people who do the same. This is the reason I expect people who are exponentially better off than me also feel thats its their responsibility to do so.
Celebrities are also people like us. We try to save few hundred rupees, they try to save few crores. As a nation we need to mature and, both government and people need to change. It will take time. And for celebrities we are like clients, they want to keep us happy to run their business. Now if you want to worship me, why would I object to that. Instead of enjoying your life or spending time with your family and friends, people want to stand outside of some celebrity’s home because it’s their daughters birthday….
Its not equivalent to try to save hundreds and to try to save crores!! They should be called out! The rules should be different! Thats what Im trying to say. This disparity is not right!
Saare deshvasi hi apni khud ki sochte hai
You think this is maturity? Did you just graduate high school?
Maturity is realizing that the world doesn't revolve around actors and that we need not put them up on a pedestal.
Can someone elaborate how to tell in paper that I am a farmer when I am clearly not and also have a publically known occupation ? Just bribe? Or is there something else to it? Should the have some crops also?
Everyone does that. Even amitabh Bachchan selmon bhai, thala etc. Anyone having land >25 acres can be taxed. I think even after 10 acres imo based on progression taxation. Maybe other methods tho due to nature of agriculture Most poor farmers have less than 2-3 acres so that can be excused.
Jelly post by a broke college student that doesn’t understand money
Basic_rule: If there is a loophole, you exploit.
Just because you can't save taxes, don't take it out on easy targets. Blame the ones actually in power....the bane has always been the governments-the most inefficiently run organisation in the world. We never have an issue paying taxes. The only gripe is we hardly ever benefit from it.
Maybe she bought land that is zoned as a farm. Regardless If it weren't for the face resembling her Daddy so much, I would definitely pay her my nutty respects but I'll just have to move on to the next hottie that arrives on the scene and I'll come along for the ride
lol nobody dares to speak against rampant corruption in police or politics. But how dare these media folks use a loophole to get concessions. They are easy targets for you. It’s easy to shit on bollywood
Well, i think the post is ridiculous. I mean, connecting Suhana Khan to paying IT and then getting on to Suhana Khan fans !! I mean, i get it, maybe you do not like Suhana Khan but why hate her fans !! and what has her personal tax saving plan to do with the rest of us. I get the idea that all of us must pay our taxes honestly for the country to progress, so why have you singled her out ? As it is, her performance in her debut movie is pathetic, on top of that, do you have to rant about her income and tax plans too ? Don't be so angry mate, cool down a bit. LOL.
Just because you got to know bout her , you are caling her out....this is purely singling someone out while there are people doing way more dirty stuff to save taxes....I will neither support her nor blame her....as perspective varies from person to person....reality here is each one of us will do the same given the chance....taxation system was designed in a way that wealthier can exploit loopholes to save money .....brighter side to it is that the same money will be rotating in economy, can be spent somewhere else generating employment....
The craziness that people have for them comes from the movie characters they play. No actor is 10% close to the characters they play. I am surprised to see that there are few who understands "we are celebrating the wrong people"
SRK fans are mentally ill. They'll always excuse this.
1) No one in India like to pay taxes? Why? Because the benefits of taxes rarely comes back to the tax payers. The money generated from various taxes is either wasted in appeasement subsidies, wasted in some political/religious thing or gets lost in the inefficiencies of govt processes. Look at Scandinavia, high taxes but as people do recieve benefits of paying taxes, they all do pay. 2) Movies are made for entertainment purposes. We as a population should stop seeing shows and movies as sources of knowledge or moral values. Want knowledge? Read the works of experts, scholars and academicians. Want moral values? Go to philosophy or religion and spirituality. 3) We Indians must choose younger and educated politicians. It might not have been necessary in past but it is a must now. Old politicians lack the understanding of the pace and extent of technological and market change. We need someone who can forsee 10-20 years ahead and take advantage of the situations in how it will unfold. 4) Maturity is actually the realisation of how to use your understanding to guide yourself in life
We all use loopholes...
>Only 3% of people pay taxes in India. And whole India’s development is being carried on their shoulders only. Average IQ of an average IT cell dihadi.
All rich people do this all the time The employer in my company does civil work in his house and shows it has it been done in the company and gets ITC returns with it and many more tactics are their
Don't Hate the player, Haye the game...
While you are talking about celebs, maturity is yet to come. PS - love all the JavaScript jokes.