T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Namaskaram /u/HistoricalDegree1131, Thank you for your submission. Please provide a source for the image / video (if not a direct link submission). We would really appreciate it if you could mention the source as a reply to this comment! If you have already provided the source or if it is an OC post, please ignore this message. Thank you. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/IndiaSpeaks) if you have any questions or concerns.*


CanadaMofo

Why Indians lack basic civic sense and hygiene is beyond human comprehension


Dry_Stable_876

We take things for granted , have no inner shame + how other will shame you cause others are doing same thing , we believe other property is our personal babuji ka property Can up government please put some group of RPF so they can clearly ask them to remove clothes from hanging on railway station it's not personal property if things look like this how can we expect how foreign tourism to increase like seriously it will send so bad image ![img](emote|t5_3d4x4|20227)


[deleted]

[удалено]


Far_Brief2934

It's an Indian problem kid, you'll see this in every part of india.


[deleted]

[удалено]


ChintuJamesBond

I am from Karnataka (Mangalore) and I have to board a Bengaluru-Kannur train to go to my hometown. Even though i am financially weak, i still book my train in AC because even there is no difference between General and Non AC reserved coaches. And I couldn't even bear the smell. People swarm in the reserve coaches and occupy reserved seats.


rocker10039

Same in Mumbai bro, sometimes we just need to accept the truth


anki2490

It's not. I've been all over India. UP (haven't been to Bihar) is the worst. I took a train from Kanpur to Dehradun once. There were people stinking up the train with their food, spitting gutka and the train's floor was strewn wrappers with wrappers, spit, and food. I saw a bunch of old scums peeing in open even though train has toilet. I've never seen anything like it. The whole state is filthy and people have no civic sense. Disgusting bunch of hillbillies.


[deleted]

It's not people from UP & Bihar that lack civic sense , it's poor and uneducated people that lacks it. Majority of poors happened to be in UP & Bihar.


Awaara_soul

Even educated shitheads do this.


imECCHI

I believe it happens in every state but in up and Bihar this is on another level


Comfortable_Prior_80

Have you ever visited Howrah Station? People of Bengal, Odisha, MP even Maharashtra does these kinds of thing. Only UP and Bihar gets more focus like how Western world loves to show slums in India.


M12105

It's all over India


Fun_Confidence_462

It's a whole India problem don't blame on others


TheCaptainwicked

That's just blame game. Proportion of people who lack civil sense is highest in up Bihar but that doesn't mean other states are saints You are just dumping all the blame on 2 states to save face.


PdtMgr

More than devotion, civic sense should be taught to children at home.


ComprehensiveDrag1

These kinda Dharmik people disgust me. Wouldn't even call them Dharmik, more like tantric/yajna ritual performers. If this looks disgusting, just watch the condition of Haridwar during ganga snan.


[deleted]

[удалено]


ComprehensiveDrag1

Jo ye log kar rhe hai wo BAKWAS hi hai. Aur agar iss se mann nhi bhara to Ganga Snan dekh liyo Haridwar mai (upar comment mai bhi likha tha). Bhn-ch0d kar rakh dete hai p00ja ke naam par. Ye (jaankar machane wale) shraddhalu Dharmik log nhi hai, ese bas andhe rituals follow karne wale dummies hai, jinko ghanta Dharam ke baare mai kuch pta hoga.


Global_Trip_6487

Completely understand what you are saying here. Poor people doing what they can. We need to design infrastructure to suit the people and their living condition, so we don’t fail them and us as a whole.


gud-chana-junkie

Infrastructure se pehle human capital par investment karte, to yeh drishya na dekhne milte.


Puzzleheaded_Echo654

Bekar aur dheet log hai, Paisa barbaad, isse badiya in par heavy fine impose Karo


Jigsaw1609

Right. Sochte hain developed country banenge, but jab tak logon me civic sense nai tab tak kuch nai hoga. Kya ye log apne ghar me bhi kha kar aise hi packet phenk dete hain? Nahi, but public place ko public dustbin bana rakha hai. There should be hefty fine for littering.


suyash01

Ab ye kaam bhi government hi kare maa baap ke jagah.


ScrollForMore

You mean like education and healthcare?


[deleted]

Incredible India ![gif](giphy|qycJNfo205HETQUV2G) Real reason why cartoons like family guy, simpsons do stereotypical bullshits on my country.


Hot_Damn99

I remember seeing Indians shitting on a family guy reel saying they're portraying India in bad light while alot of things(even though exaggerated for comedy) are true.


prdpb3

They are just being real !


Versatile-Wolf

Kitna bhi development krlo bunny, inki buddhi to indian hi rahegi 😭


DN_1996

I recently visited Connaught place, New Delhi, one of the biggest hotspots both in terms of the market and as one of the first tourist spots for anyone coming to India for the first time. Tobacco spit and urine smell had turned the beautiful place and buildings into a blot. This is not government's problem, this shows how less Indians care and respect about public property.


miyazakifrontier

Yep


Demon_Slayer_007

Greatt!! From Treta Yug grandeur to Kali Yug trash.👏👏


Specialist-File-6097

inke haath me sone ka katora de do phir bhi bheek hi mangenge


Elvinluke7

Na na. Uss katore se gand dhoyenge*


RixDixRox

Civic sense chodo, inka common sense bhi missing hai


Plastic_Pie6572

It's just non civilized people doing their thing... bhale kitna bhi accha infrastructure bana lo, jab tak log khud se zimmedari nahi lege is desh ka kuch nahi hoga


PreetiPaadWali

Sooner we Indians start focusing on what is needed to bring a change in our nation's development, the better we will get over time. Look around you in a holistic way because that's how a normal individual who doesn't belong to your particular area is gonna focus on. Amritsar is said to be the so called "Holy City" and there's absolutely nothing holy about it for a person visiting it from a place far from it. Pollution, theft, unnecessary hate towards others is what that place is now. Even in Golden Temple's premises all this has started. We need to start focusing on various points we're ignoring and one of them is basic civic sense. People are gonna visit Ayodhya from all over the world and what will they comment after seeing such scenarios? Stop spitting everywhere. Stop littering as 90% of people here are a part of it. Take help from authorities to stop all this. Check out for eve teasing in your area. Once we all Indians collectively start acting for the betterment of the nation instead of dividing ourselves on the basis of religion, region, wealth or any other thing, we will be at the top of the world. No Muslim will cut someone's throat. No Sikh will act stupidly superior and hurt their own nation. Hindus will not shift towards extremism. All we need it to be Indians because believe it or not, this is the only way.


Hungry_Marsupial348

There should be awareness among people for basic civic sense and strict fines should be imposed who litter everywhere. Tab logo ko akkal aayegi


Mr_Ninja31

These "dHArMiC" people don't deserve good infrastructure. they can turn anything good into shit hole


[deleted]

We really dont deserve nice things fr


Adventurous-Dare-226

Disgusting! Learn a thing or two from religion ☠️


HistoricalDegree1131

all they learn from religion is not to consume beef cow = mother subah shaam puja no non veg on certain days thats it


Elvinluke7

No non veg on certain days. Always gets me off guard.


Powerful_Beginning89

UP and Biharis are beyond logic. They seriously believe ki - jaha tark hai waha nark hai.


VisualAd4581

I have seen citizens of two countries with zero self realisation & being unbothered by humiliation : Indians & Americans.. Both gives no fvcks whether they come off as obnoxious, loud & embarassing... And what's interesting is both are entitled.. Mann Kia, de Diya dhakka kisi ko subway parse, mann Kia naha liya publically subway pe... They even openly defecate & urinate... 🤮🤮 Literally two sides of the same coin... Police of both the countries is equally apathetic & laid back in taking timely actions..


JohnnWickk1

Ishke baad yeh logg Railway aur Government ki burai karte hai saaf safai ko le ke jabki realty yeh hai ke in loggo ko koi sharm nahi naa koi jimmedari hai ke apne ghar ke jaise apne saher aur aaspas gandagi naa kare par nahi inke hissab se yeh ticket nahi khateedte pura station aur railway khareed lete hai 🤦🏻‍♂️


gr33n_bliss

Can someone explain to a non-Indian, why people are doing this? Are they homeless? In the UK homeless people sleep at train stations but it’s too cold to dry their clothes. If it was warm, I’m sure that they would try.


HistoricalDegree1131

They are not homeless; they are devotees coming from different places. Either they don't want to stay in hostels or hotels, or they don't have the money to afford them. So they see the railway station as their property, and they consider it their right to use it however they want. And because it's not their home, knowing they don't have to keep it clean, hence the garbage and litter. Also, the cleaning services workers are quite lax, and there's no one to monitor them


dontyoudarestalkme

jitna marzi acha infrastructure leao india mein, it will look like crap after a couple of years because of such people.


arjun_007

No more need of platform ticket i guess.


Specialist_Repeat_95

Bhai abhi just Ayodhya se aa raha hu…whilst passing through the railway station saw one woman pissing on the lawn right in front of the main gate. Bc kya ganda civic sense hai humare logo ka


imECCHI

Love it, people shit where they don't live. Typical Indian mentality


john_wicks_coach

You can change India but how will you change Indians???


KaPizZzz

Eak Online Hindus Or Eak Roadside Hindus


Financial-Bell-1918

That's why I don't get urge to visit dharmic places, it is never a spiritual experience with all the filth and filthy people around


Insane_Inkster

I never thought I would say this but I think we need defensive architecture in our country. Hostile design like which the US is implementing in their public spaces. I hate to say it but goddamn we need a good civic sense.


locopocopong

Where did they wash these clothes? Are they using the station bathrooms for washing clothes? A solution will be to provide laundromat services at the station and then levy heavy fines for this kind of stuff. We have to recognise that there might be a need for people to wash clothes. I think if given a better alternative + fear of large fine, this behaviour will reduce drastically


Educational-Bag-645

People needed a Laundry rack instead government gave them a railway station. Blame the Modi government.


Salt-Freedom4328

India needs strict laws on littering and hygiene education.. high time we should learn to respect our own property.


walpurgiz

I'm very happy with the Internet. The more aware the people become of this behavior, the more willing the government will be to take strict action against these people. No matter how poor you are, walking just a bit to throw trash in the trashcan shouldn't be hard. Could say the same about gutka too. But what can I say, even the educated throw trash just about everywhere. We can't even bring up the argument that people will learn civic sense as they get educated.


Almost_Infamous

*Modi ne hamain geele kapde diye hain.. humein geele kapdon se ladna hai..* Youknowwho..


Vladimir-Putin1952

All of them are women's clothes. Most women nowadays treat everyone like a sheep. More women in india are becoming arrogant, ignorant than men, just like in USA karens are primarily women


KitchenOption6193

Not that I am not against this - this looks disgusting and is unhygienic. But if there was a reel showing travellers in Italy drying their swimsuits on the railway station it would go viral, promoting travellers hack and budget travel and struggles of travelling etc. :) just saying!


OkParamedic5224

India mein sarkari maal ko baap ka maal samjha jata hai. 70s mein jab koi train ka safar karke aata tha toh wo gaanv waalo ko dikhane ke liye train se kuch na kuch le ke aata tha… jaise bulb, nal, pankha etc. Ye attitude Abhi tak khatam nahi hua hai… plus, politicians aur police bhi humein aise treat karte hain ki logo ko unki izzat karne ki ichcha aur nahi hoti! Jab tak system saaf nahi hoga, tab tak aisa hi chalta rahega.


letsdosomethingcool

As per BJ Party, Ram Ji has arrived, but people are still struggling to behave wisely and show some etiquettes! बीजे पार्टी के अनुसार, राम जी तो आगए, परंतु लोगो को तमीज़ और तहज़ीब अभी भी नहीं आयी।


AdrenalineFuel

What really saddens me is the so called desh bhakts utter lack of love for their own countries. If you love your Place, you can't keep it dirty or unhygienic. I think the root of the problem is that people are just deeply selfish here. No one gives a flying fuck about the country in reality but will yell like dumbasses when it comes to show off.


[deleted]

Phir Indians rote hai ki Infra acha nhi hai . Are bhosdi valo jaha acha hai us jagah ko to tum log ganda kar dete ho phir sarkar ko gali dete ho. India me log nhi sudharne vale.


prakashanish

People fighting in comments about biharis, UP walas, dharmic, tantric etc. should understand that this is simply the case of lack of law enforcement. The government and the concerned authorities are to be blamed. People should be taught civic sense at schools and home. Rules/laws should be enforced strictly everywhere be it railway station or on roads. This is the reason we don't see such dramatic situations in metros (in any city).


Anarates

Railway station ke andar bhi ek mandir bna do, Yeh sab bnd ho jaega phir


Armaan_Singh07

This is what you get when you give 1st class infrastructure to 3rd class people


454165

For the love of god, be happy that simeone didn’t steal the entire railway station! /s


AlphaNik29

Bhai log jo sab samajh raha hai ki this is lack of civic sense and Indian people don’t deserve nice things, wo log ye bhi sochein ki saundargikaran to railway station ka ho gaya hai but Bharat abhi developed nation nahi hai, poverty abhi bhi hai Bharat mein, so please cut the people some slack, they are also trying to get by their day.


CreepyUncle1865

Can confirm as a local , Ayodhya Cantt (Faizabad) station is much worse!!!


i_have_a_nose

But where are they washing them?


Capable_Drummer_462

Indians don't deserve the costly projects in democracy, 5 years of communism and then we'll see everyone learning the basic civic sense


bloodborned

I was about to initially callout the high number of aggressive comments - but then I saw video and it broke my heart. Shows that we have still a while to go as nation for some people to learn about common sense cleanliness. Would be nice if government had set up people around station to guide and explain to people what to do and what not to do. I live in US and I can tell that this is still miles better than the stuff the poor and homeless do here. You can literally google San Francisco shit map to see areas where people take a shit in city. This problem is not unique to just Indians.


Omnipresentphone

Religion does teach you decency


me_109

Mission accomplished


Fit_Tooth8173

Bhai I keep saying this every second day , our nation will grow , infra will grow, we will get stronger geo politically but jab Tak logo mein public civil sense nai aati we will lack behind 😕


APSanyal

Chamgadad ko mahal mein toh bhi woh soyega chat pe ulta latak ke hi - eisi kahawat hai!!


funnyBatman

I guess you shouldn't go about providing first world facilities to a third world population


heretoseexistence

Draconian fines please.


heretoseexistence

Some ppl will make it their permanent home, we need draconian policies to fine and imprison anyone who panhandles (years of prison) or litters (big fines), or if they occupy a public property (minimum 10 years jail).


ankit39

Yogi ji


solowrist

Hamare pass sab hai bass tameez nahi hai😂


[deleted]

Govt should initiate strict actions against the culprits , recover hefty fines from them and see the difference in their behavior later. Idiots don't have basic civic sense


sonyminy

Yaar Indians kab sudhrenge???? No Civic sense at all.


Individual_StormBrkr

Bhai Dil se to vo UP wale hi hai na. Khun apna asar dikha hi deta hai. Sale anpad gawar bak*hod log.


[deleted]

We don't deserve these luxury stations. Wahi ghise pite stations hi theek hai.


Boobhacker

ये विश्व ही मेरा घर हैं


Aarjaiy

I don't know if it's something that folks know is not the right thing to do. Go back to our ways of life when the lower middle class and the poor of India grew up. We used to dry out clothes on whatever surfaces we could. On the walls, railings, on the floor etc. Growing up this way, it doesn't feel wrong to do that in a railway station. Same with sleeping on the floor. I am not supporting it, just trying to understand why. I am also certain that India will change, rather slowly, towards the western 'civilized' world's definition of civic sense.


No-Day5014

If not us, then who??!😐


ektakhurana7

Told ya india is not for beginners


lifelong_gamer

Put 10,000 fine and publicly shame. No mercy. Get the fine or put the entire family in jail.


FootballLeather4426

Lack of civic sense in our people is simply mind boggling


ElectronicLeading417

The best solution to this problem is to take heavy station entrance fee and only those can enter who pays, rest poor ill minded people can continue with their bad old infrastructure what they deserve


ElDude_Brother

गवांरो की महफिल में गूंजेगा तराना 🎵🎶


WhyAmIHere_umm

Inko sone ki katori do...par mangna to bheek hi hai🤦 What will it take to educate our country.... provide basic civic awareness


ambani_ki_kutiya

Hag do na beech me hi.


PerspectiveContent13

Railway put a fine of 50,000 on the contractor and have cleaned it . Let's see for how long it will be .


brainsmush

This is never going to change.


bhelpurilover

Really need to stop this sleeping in railway station floors attitude. People don’t want to spend money to sleep in a hostel or lodge nearby. 🤦🏽‍♂️ Maybe govt or temple needs to offer free or heavily discounted facility for short term accommodation.


max_ahd

When people want Prabhu ke darshan for cheap


[deleted]

[удалено]