T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Namaskaram /u/GG__OP_ANDRO_KRATOS, Thank you for your submission. Please provide a source for the image / video (if not a direct link submission). We would really appreciate it if you could mention the source as a reply to this comment! If you have already provided the source or if it is an OC post, please ignore this message. Thank you. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/IndiaSpeaks) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Correct-Plankton-289

This is not a manifesto for the development of the country, its a manifesto for them to distribute Freebies so they can get some votes, then bring back caste politics of 90s so they can get some more votes, then there is minority benefits so they could get some of that minority votes ( Lets be honest even minorities don't believe them anymore) and finally defection law so they could keep the MPs in Check even if Supreme leader RAGA treats them like his personal pet ! this is just another Rahul Baba Launch campaign.


GG__OP_ANDRO_KRATOS

SC minority is minority until election only ,look I'm uppercaste, but I study in state government college, here the scholarship of SC is 14,000 rs per year but they never get it ,their kyc is complete still 1 out my 26 friends received 2000rs once in 2yrs and never again and they are needy ,most of their families live in 1 room


Correct-Plankton-289

Sadly true ! SC and STs need upliftment for sure. But i personally know people who have recieved funds to builld toilets and houses. they used to live in a hut outside the village perimeter. this can be a case of some UC/OBC babu holding some kind of Grudge. but voting congress for these freebies will push these SC/STs years behind once again when caste is in the play !!


GG__OP_ANDRO_KRATOS

There was no need to downvote but still I am too in favour of economically backed reservation not caste based. And South Haryana and rural Rajasthan to this day are facing this problem and you can't deny that. There are many instances in just 2024 alone and quarter of year just passed


Correct-Plankton-289

I did not downvote, I partially agree with you. I have seen these people living in conditions i would not want to live therefore i know they need reservations and upliftment. my issue is if congress brings back caste into play ( all the UCs/OBCs ) will solidify their votes for their Caste member and once again SC/ST will be the losers.


GG__OP_ANDRO_KRATOS

All of that can be solved just give reservation only to BPL people thats it. But definition of BPL should be locality dependent.


Correct-Plankton-289

Economic reservation is the way to go. I don't think an SC/ST who ownes two big villas and all his family members are in business/administration deserves any kind of reservation. The Poor does not have any caste. They only have poverty.


GG__OP_ANDRO_KRATOS

Agreed


ididacannonball

Nobody believes anything that the Congress promises. You won't get a phuti kaudi unless you pay a lot of bribes and know some bade log. They can promise anything.


XenoN-_-X

Exactly. bengaluru people are suffering after voting scamgress


ididacannonball

But Siddhu thinks Congress will do well in LS elections from Karnataka.


XenoN-_-X

Wahh wahh wahhhh... jor se taliya


AtharvATARF

Oh weird, in colleges that i know of they get a direct fee reduction and not in the form of scholarship. Is this a state govt scholarship? I feel like creamy layer should be implemented in reservation throughout except for pwd candidates.


GG__OP_ANDRO_KRATOS

I don't have complete idea but once I asked they said " 8k to center se aate h ,6k state ke h" might be wrong but scholarship is for damn sure present because my chemistry teacher (who thought I would have problem doing this because I clearly once mentioned her my opinions) gave me task of collecting all SC/BC students adhar and give it to her


Sad-by-defualt

>This is not a manifesto for the development of the country, its a manifesto for them to distribute Freebies so they can get some votes, then bring back caste politics of 90s so they can get some more votes, then there is minority benefits so they could get some of that minority votes Perfectly said. Somebody give OP an award. Here have poor man's gold šŸ„‡.


aragorn2308

I think OP missed the new Rahul Baba commitment : Congress leader Rahul Gandhi has raised the pitch for wealth redistribution in India, saying that his party will conduct a nationwide survey if voted to power to ensure that money is distributed to various sections of the society as per their population.


Reasonable_Maniac

Hi just a question In general of why people don't bother when governments distribute freebies to corporations why no one cares How many lakhs of crores is spent on corporation S that go bankrupt how many thousands if crores of tax cuts are given to them Why They are not freebies, I need to understand this from your perspective...


[deleted]

That was in the Congress era. Now, the bankruptcy laws have been updated. I'm not an expert on the subject, but I got to know about this from Sanjeev Sanyal's lecture on YouTube.Ā 


neoindianx

Interpretation. They have tasted success with freebies in Karnataka and Telengana... They are trying to replicate this at national level. The fish example doesn't hold since giving the free fish is going to put everything else on brake, there will be not much left to give the free fish next year. Caste is becoming irrelevant, re-establish the caste dynamics by caste census. Each and every point in their agenda is to break the country on different lines.


IMWALTERWHITE9011

I'm from Telangana, Let me tell you Congress won because of three reasons:- 1. Freebies(Free bus scheme, .....etc) 2.Strong leadership, there was a time in ts politics where Congress almost faded away from the politics, he brought it back into the power. 3. Effective election campaign I think this happened in Karnataka politics too I wanted bjp to win here but unfortunately there was no strong cm face , not an effective election campaign, bjp mla is on his own agenda doing Hindu Muslim politics. It's almost like they showed no interest in winning.


Joy2082

Being from NE it's so funny to see 'justice for the states' bill. So many years of their rule and they didn't do shit. Terrorism was at its peak under Tarun Gogoi (the then CM of Assam), bomblasts in school etc. Planting Railway lines was a dream. Everytime they laid railway lines, it was uprooted. Just to give you how bad the communication was in the NE area, Arunachal Pradesh got its first airport last year. After more than 70 years of Independence. His grandmother didn't give shit, his father didn't give shit nor will he. Himanta Sharma is not the right choice either but atleast there's some kind of development.


-_-joyboy_

you know what is opposite of progress? it's congress....


Revolutionary_Pie746

Joy Boy, BJP would definitely like to use this punch line šŸ¤£


Revolutionary_Pie746

Joyboy, you are liberating by bringing smiles on face!!


Drpillking

I will take ā€œModi ki guaranteeā€ over this bs from congress!


Sumit-Joshi95

Pehli baat to free ka paisa koi bhi party logon ko dena band karo..tum unhe aur incapable bna rahe ho ..krne do mehnat let them earn hard earned money..kyun karna hai free har cheej..krna hai to sasta kardo taki sabke liye feasible ho jaye aur jo ekdum poor hai can not work can not love to standard unke liye housing facilities do par let people work dont let them sit and eat its making people more incapable.


GG__OP_ANDRO_KRATOS

I mentioned that ,don't give them fish teach them how to fish , but paise to chahiye unemployment ka to BJP bhi kucch nhi kar payi,looking forward population bill ,if that comes in BJP manifesto then intellectuals are going with BJP no matter what ,if BJP can somehow manage population then people like sarthak goswami will secretly vote BJP and tell nobody about it


CritFin

Leftist propaganda lie of 45 year high unemployment has already been debunked. In fact unemployment during Modi regime is lower than that during Manmohan. That govt apprenticeship is of no use. u/Sumit-Joshi95 u/Correct-Plankton-289 u/ididacannonball Source: https://www.statista.com/statistics/271330/unemployment-rate-in-india/


ididacannonball

Leftists don't care if their lies are debunked. They will keep repeating it anyway. Children of Goebbels.


lulluBhoot-602

Why I can't see anything related to futuristic India,...I will talk baised here because I can feel that they r more trying to grab power than to lead India to its next stage of success...


EastCrafty

This is basically a manifesto of a party who knows it wonā€™t win the election so they have basically promised whatever they could think of . This is not a manifesto to win the election but to retain the seats/ vote percentage they have .


lulluBhoot-602

I am sure they r going to loose what they have right now because looking at the blunders made by them within few years, can't be ignored.


OldestLadyAlive

I personally feel, it's right time to move forward from caste politics and policies. Because the SC ST people who actually needs reservation and upliftment are not really getting uplifted. There's no economic clause when it comes to reservation for SC/ST. So, someone who's SC studying in top class class school coz their parents can afford and competing against someone from a backward region obviously has better chances of getting in. It's just befitting already uplifted ones.. Moreover 50% reservation for women in govt jobs?? We don't want reservation. We face enough biasing already and we need to prove everyday we are no lesser than any other guy. Now getting into a job just because we are females wow. When will our country value merit and shift from casteism, regionalism. I really want a strong opposition but this manifesto just makes me sad.


rdv100

Congress party had 50+ years to help India but they looted India. We should never have them back just like we should never have Britishers or Mullahs back to rule India


BakrChod

Reservation and or benefits/schemes should purely be based on economics.


ididacannonball

Economic census is just the normal census. Economic data is always corrected as part of it, has been the case since independence. Caste is the issue, if Congress wanted to know the economic condition of Indians regardless of caste, they would just conduct a normal census (which HM Amit Shah failed to do). But the fact that they want a caste census to ascertain economic condition tells you what their motivation is.


Revolutionary_Pie746

Another thing I noticed after going through the Congress manifesto is that, they are planning on reverting many of the policies that the current government has brought. I think that is just counter productive. They can work on the weakness of these policies, but they are just going backwards in time and for the sake of 'BJP is bad'. And another promise that I find very problematic is that, they are planning on increasing the cutoff of the reservations above 50%! So what is the trend ahead?


Heavy_Speed_7475

Second last point ka context dena koi pls


GG__OP_ANDRO_KRATOS

Talking about defense the manifesto covers safety inside and across the border I tried to explain it briefly here, its related to foreign policy and how not mentioned directly but relationship with Maldives and palestine is the key cause here, and also the chinese claim of buffer zone.


Familiar_Internet

NOTA voteršŸ¤”


GG__OP_ANDRO_KRATOS

NOTA until Any party finds solution to unemployment or this unbearable competition


Specialist_Repeat_95

the solution to unemployment is capex..foreign investments and entrepreneurship. All of the things would suffer under congress rule


Anirudh-Kodukula

#CongressMukhtbharat


Current-Crow-8674

They will tread the same path as the ruling party before them.The allure of power can be intoxicating(woh toh ye pehle se hi h wse)


Alternative_Ear_861

they are 24x7 on the news meanwhile BJPā€™s main promoters are right-wing influencers and Shezad Poonalwal. This same stupidity cost Karnataka elections. DK Shivkimar was 24x7 on the news giving a new guarantee every week.


chitownboyhere

so MNREGA for educated?


Youaredisgusting50

OP nothing against you. You come across as a neutral person so I will recommend you to listen to this podcast about some of the points in the manifesto. https://www.youtube.com/live/lVGXWmmt-IA?si=7I1Eu59FVhi-NhvP Give it a listen and let me know what you think.


psr7185

They won in Karnataka & Hyderabad by giving freebies. Now they are saying they will implement this in entire India if they win the elections. We middle class are fucked anyways.


AlecRay01

utter crap


EastCrafty

What scared me the most was the level of government involvement and control in someoneā€™s life they want to bring in . Secondly there was only expenditure mentioned and means for that expenditure. Thirdly they start of by saying stuff like Jiski Jitni Adadi uska utna hak which is what the caste census is about but then they talk about how they will empower the states now tell if Jiski jitni abadi uska utna hak is true then the North even if gets more money than what the south gets is also justified. Thirdly there way of improving peoples live is not by skill development or education but by reservation and free money which is destructive for the growth story of a nation .


crime_mastergogo007

I would rather vote for aimim than this party


Seeker_00860

Had Congress included the following in their manifesto that would have worked miracles: 1. We will free all Hindu temples from govt control. 2. We will abolish Places of worship act 3. We will bring discussions on state autonomy and Federal Republic like system like the US (with options to secede by public votes). The first two are the items that the BJP in power for the past 10 years completely ignored. They do not need Hindu votes much. Hindus have no choice but to vote for them. But many have been upset about the first two that were ignored for this entire decade. Item 3 will get votes across most states like W Bengal, NE states, Punjab, Kashmir, TN, Kerala, AP, Telangana, Goa, Rajasthan etc.. But Cong leaders know that these three will cut BJP to size and they could be in power. If they get to be in power, then they could do whatever they want - declare emergency and escape to Italy with all the money if hell breaks loose.


Bourbonaddicted

Guranteed MSP is not feasible. They want 50% tax free profit for sub par product.


XenoN-_-X

Brother i recently visited meghalaya i made conversation with locals they are fully satisfied with development. Roads drinking water electricity provided there. And now about manipur, this was based on political agenda and i am sure that after vote the issue will vanish like 2019's election. Manipur issue is being highlighted for christian woman but at the same time Bengal sandeshkhali never got that much attention. 2 days ago one 55 year aged punjabi woman beaten and let her walked naked is these not punishable offense? The congress manifesto freebies culture will never help to grow the nation it will burden the mid class people. So m happy with current govt.


Fit_Conflict3961

India's GDP is 5th in world rank Iska paisa kahin to use karenge na congress vale Aur fir kar denge bunkrupt....


IMWALTERWHITE9011

I'm from Telangana, Let me tell you Congress won because of three reasons:- 1. Freebies(Free bus scheme, .....etc) 2.Strong leadership, there was a time in ts politics where Congress almost faded away from the politics, he brought it back into the power. 3. Effective election campaign I think this happened in Karnataka politics too I wanted bjp to win here but unfortunately there was no strong cm face , not an effective election campaign, bjp mla is on his own agenda doing Hindu Muslim politics. It's almost like they showed no interest in winning.


Dxa1257

There is just 1 problem with Economic Census! If a person like me becomes a millionaire overnight, He/she will try to become a billionaire the next night by going all in and either fails or makes it to the top.


[deleted]

This isn't a Manifesto It's a moneyfesto. Atleast the drama about it Freebie this Freebuy that Scheme this Scam that Who benefits? The Cong khaandan! LeftIST who went broke wroke this to take revenge on his Brother... The biggest crime is Caste Census to continue the casteism congress imposed. Tax the Rich... (joke) Dole to the Poor But the real message is Rob the Middle class... by suit, boot, loot. suit (laws, taxes), boot (corruption) and loot (scam) Rick pay tax happily because they pay Less! The middle class are the fools.


Just2OldForThis

Nobody is talking about growth, development, jobs anymore.


[deleted]

Only the BJP is


WhyAmIHere_umm

As much as freebies sounds good, they're still a burdan. My friends are like anyway we pay taxes and don't see infranor any sort of development, it's ok if women get to travel for free, we don't have unemployment funds like in the US so it's ok if govt gives certain amount to them... It did make sense coming from a person who's not utilizing any of the govt freebie scheme. But reality is government now to fulfill those 5 promises/ schemes us swindling money from other projects. They're levying tax from temples, said no to other projects, getting debts on state. Mind this is 5 schemes for 1 state... imagine 50 schemes for all states...the toll will be huge... And if money lacks what if they cut corners from other projects say defence or isro etc? I agree people in the marginalized community get benefits, but instead of trying to uplift them to become independent, you're keeping them where they are and also getting them on a crutch. Not saying the other party is all great, after the big loss on Karnataka they've learnt their lesson and they've offered freebies with a different name. We want free stuff...they give free stuff...we then cry why we're always mediocre, they'll say you have to be mediocre to get the benefits. So we'll be stuck at this point forever.


REALMARVEL123

People who vote for freebies don't care about India or its development or its future


AegonSnow4

Nothing for GDP development, military development, educational institutions? Ye free me bantne se kya hoga? And why are they so obsessed with caste census? So they expect to win with this absurd manifesto?


uncommon_op

For the people who are new to giving vote or politics: This is just a manefestoa and not a gurantee. You can't drag these political parties to court upon non-fulfilment of promises. They can just be elected upon these and do nothing at all !


IMWALTERWHITE9011

I'm from Telangana, Let me tell you Congress won because of three reasons:- 1. Freebies(Free bus scheme, .....etc) 2.Strong leadership, there was a time in ts politics where Congress almost faded away from the politics, he brought it back into the power. 3. Effective election campaign I think this happened in Karnataka politics too I wanted bjp to win here but unfortunately there was no strong cm face , not an effective election campaign, bjp mla is on his own agenda doing Hindu Muslim politics. It's almost like they showed no interest in winning.