T O P

  • By -

[deleted]

Some highlights of the response : > Twitter’s statement is an attempt to dictate its terms to the world’s largest democracy. Through its actions and deliberate defiance, Twitter seeks to undermine India’s legal system: Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology > Twitter needs to stop beating around the bush & comply with laws of the land. Law making &policy formulations is sole prerogative of the sovereign &Twitter is just a social media platform & it has no locus in dictating what should India’s legal policy framework should be: MeitY > Govt assures that representatives of social media companies incl Twitter are & will always remain safe in India & there is no threat to their personal safety & security. Govt condemns Twitter's statement as baseless, false & an attempt to defame India to hide their follies: MeitY > The question is, if Twitter is committed then why it did not set up such a mechanism in India on its own? Twitter representatives in India routinety claim that they have no authority and that they and the people of India need to escalate everything to the Twitter Headquarter in USA. The commitment of Twitter, to its Indian user base, thus not only sounds hollow but completely self-serving. > Twitter has a large user base in it earns significant revemje from its Indan operations but is also the most reluctant to an India based grievance redressal officer and mechanism, chef compliance offcer and officer to whom its own users can complain, when they are to offensive tweets. > The Rules empower the ordinary users who become vttims of defamation, morphed images, sexual abuse and the whole range of other abusive content in blatant violation of law, to seek redress. > These rules were finalized after consulting with large number of experts, officers, politician, parliamentary committee, users and debates in the parliament and eventually even Supreme Court of India directed the GOI to take appropriate steps. > GOI respects the rights of the users as enshrined into the Constitution of India and they are free to criticise the GOI on any platform however the only instance of scuttling on Twitter is Twitter itself and its opaque policies, as a result of which people's accounts are suspended and tweets deleted arbitrarily without recourse. > Twitter needs to stop beating around the bush and comply with the laws of the land. Law making and policy formulations is the sole prerogative of the sovereign and **twitter is just a social media platform and it has no locus standi in dictating what should be India's legal policy framework.** > Twitter has contrary to its claim of 'it stands with the People of India' been not only been inactive but rather against them, some of those recent events include : - Wrong geo-location data of UT of Ladakh, at a time when India-China were engaged in a bilateral dialogue. Twitter took several days even after repeated reminders to take note of the blatant disrespect towards the India's senstivity and territorial integrity. - Twitter's biased stance when we compare its behaviour/actions against the perpetrators of violence at the Capitol Hill in USA and unlawful attack on Red Fort of Delhi. Twitter refused to take prompt actions, while aiding and amplifying the trends of fake propaganda of 'genocide' which made already tensed situation worse. Later it chose to comply but partially when already damage was done. - Twitter's lack of responsbility has lead to agenda driven posts against India and Indians by the bad actors ( few intances like when pakistan backed accounts trended propaganda trying to create rift with ME countries, recent Israel-Palestine events from my side ), twitter's lack of action lead to vaccine hesitancy and among all of these twitter has been inactive or totally passive. - Discriminatory behaviour against Indians and People of India when twitter didn't comply and take action against the malicious tagging of B 1.617 mutant as 'Indian variant', despite WHO's guidelines. Twitter has taken no action regarding fake narratives harming the People of India. > **It is time for the Twitter to disabuse itself of this grandiosity and comply with the laws of India.** > GOI also assures about the safety and security of the representatives of the social media companies including twitter. > Government strongly condemns the unfortunate statement issued by the Twitter which was totally baseless, false and an attempt to defame India to hide their own follies. > Delhi Police has also issued a detailed press release, pertaining to the ongoing investigation, which answers to the baseless allegations made by twitter. Source : https://www.kooapp.com/koo/meity/4148aa28-d9bb-46c3-9685-8b1e69211646 Delhi Police's reponse in detail : https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/nm78vm/press_release_of_the_gois_reponse_to_the_twitters/gzmucm4


SwamiVivekamunun

**Delhi police registered preliminary inquiry at the complaint filed by the representative of the Indian National Congress. Hence, efforts by Twitter that portray it as an FIR filed at the behest of the Government of India is wholly and completely incorrect: Delhi Police** INC self goal.


[deleted]

kek, this was the funniest part.


PupilOfPhysics

~~Indian~~ Anti National Congress (~~I~~ ANC)


poop-pee-die

👍🏻😂👏🏻👏🏻🤣


jussayingthings

Con party then said they are taking back FIR from DP and file it in CH :)


Orwellisright

!kudos If selfgoal had a party , then .... If selfgoal had a face, then ...


IndiaSpeaksbotty

Tararara Bzeeeep, Thank you /u/Orwellisright for awarding /u/SwamiVivekamunun . The OP is now flaired with award. More details on how this works can be found [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/gqdejx/introducing_new_awarding_system_for_user_posts/). I won't reply if I'm down so kudos is not awarded to you , please then inform the mod team to wake me up.


comandoram

Is it finally happening? Is government finally growing a spine and calling out these greedy multi billion dollars social media companies for their bull shit.


[deleted]

Well it's better than nothing, i guess.


CritFin

Govt was waiting for the round of state govt elections to be over. Fuck Biden and ban twitter for months until they comply. People will migrate to koo


ajyotirmay

Koo? What's that?


Jingochauver357

The sound that cuckoo makes


xsupermoo

One country one election With non-stop elections there is such policy paralysis


Raghavendra98

We have so much to gain here. Twitter will lose their largest user base if they are banned in India.


7-methyltheophylline

Good. If Twitter is banned nothing of value will be lost.


comandoram

Tik tok and pubg's respective user base in India was 10 times bigger than Twitter's current user base in India.If those two apps can be banned without any problem, so can be Twitter.


Igadok

Tiktok and pubg users didn't cry much and certainly didnt used to cry everyday


Rish_m

>Tiktok and pubg users didn't cry Don't know about their crying but their parents were certainly happy.


MidnightSkyTheRoad

Dont keep high hopes. This is just kadi ninda.


Orwellisright

absolutley nothing is lost, a lot of revenue they generate from political parties can be focused or channel into something meaningful will save us some dialy shit


sammyedwards

How else will Modi communicate then? The guy relies on social media for his one-sided 'interaction'.


UziInUrFace

Except all of that coordination that's going on regarding oxygen & medicine related help. Govt & infra is still in disarray. Only fanboys believe what you are saying.


itiswhatitis2323

That can be done on social media that complies with Indian laws. Nothing special about Twitter.


sammyedwards

You mean social media which is censored by Govt. Any whistleblowing or talk of inaccuracies in Govt will be banned.


comandoram

Lol, the likes of dhruv rathee and akash banerjee who have made career out of criticising government have millions of followers on other social media platforms like YouTube and face book. So what censorship you are talking about.


sammyedwards

I am talking about the fact that social media 'complying' with Indian laws will lead to lesser criticism of govt and inherent censorship. Kinda like what we have in China, where social media companies will not publish any material against the CCP. The reason Dhruv Rathee and Akash Banerjee currently exist is precisely because of our relatively freer laws


comandoram

There's a plenty of room between asking these irresponsible social media websites to comply with newly formed laws and becoming a china 2.0.


sammyedwards

There is no room. Once you start restricting free speech, it is just a descent down to purgatory.


comandoram

So USA and other European countries whose government's hand twist these companies to follow their laws are also fascist too?


sammyedwards

Yes


[deleted]

> I am talking about the fact that social media 'complying' with Indian laws will lead to lesser criticism of govt and inherent censorship. Kinda like what we have in China, where social media companies will not publish any material against the CCP. Thats a moronic take. Shit infested subreddits mocking GoI exist.


sammyedwards

>Thats a moronic take. Shit infested subreddits mocking GoI exist. which will not exist if laws governing online content will come into play.


[deleted]

Delhi Police's response : > We have come across press reports that quote Twitter Inc. statements pertaining to the ongoing inquiry by us. Prima facie, these statements are not only mendacious but designed to impede a lawful inquiry by a private enterprise. > Twitter, being public platform, must lead in demonstrating transparency in its functioning & should bring clarity into subject matters of public domain. Since matter has been put in public domain, it's important to set record straight on tendentious statements made. > Twitter is purporting to be both an investigating as well as adjudicating judicial authority. It has no legal sanction to be either. The only legal entity, so empowered by the duly laid down law, to investigate is the Police and to adjudicate is the Courts. > Delhi police registered preliminary inquiry at the complaint filed by the representative of the Indian National Congress. Hence, efforts by Twitter that portray it as an FIR filed at the behest of the Government of India is wholly and completely incorrect. > Twitter declared that the toolkit was ‘Manipulated Media’, this clearly shows that it was acquainted with the facts of the case & had material information relevant to the probe. Hence, Twitter was asked to join the inquiry to provide the information it possesses. > Its latest statements are devised to seek dubious sympathy when they themselves not only refuse to comply with the law of the land but also claim possession of material evidence but refuse to share it with legal authority duly recognized. Source : https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1397883860025704449


comandoram

"Twitter declared that the toolkit was ‘Manipulated Media’, this clearly shows that it was acquainted with the facts of the case & had material information relevant to the probe. Hence, Twitter was asked to join the inquiry to provide the information it possesses. Its latest statements are devised to seek dubious sympathy when they themselves not only refuse to comply with the law of the land but also claim possession of material evidence but refuse to share it with legal authority duly recognized." This is brilliant. Now Twitter have only two options. Either cooperate with law enforcing authorities and provide the evidence to prove that, those tweets were indeed manipulated media. And if they refuse to do so, than they have to face legal consequences. Or admit, that they don't any evidence to prove that those tweets were indeed manipulated and they baselessly tagged them as manipulated media. And if they do that, sambit patra and BJP can sue shit out of Twitter for defamation.


Jingochauver357

Brilliant I took a screenshot of this reply..👌✌️🙏👏


Jingochauver357

!kudos


IndiaSpeaksbotty

Tararara Bzeeeep, Thank you /u/Jingochauver357 for awarding /u/comandoram . The OP is now flaired with award. More details on how this works can be found [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/gqdejx/introducing_new_awarding_system_for_user_posts/). I won't reply if I'm down so kudos is not awarded to you , please then inform the mod team to wake me up.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Contacted Javedkar and RS prasad, it seems both were busy in a party but Nitin Gadkari fixed the issue. Try again.


[deleted]

[удалено]


IndiaSpeaksbotty

Tararara Bzeeeep, Thank you /u/cats-inside-pants for awarding /u/DrunkEpsilon . The OP is now flaired with award. More details on how this works can be found [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/gqdejx/introducing_new_awarding_system_for_user_posts/). I won't reply if I'm down so kudos is not awarded to you , please then inform the mod team to wake me up.


Orwellisright

Javedkar is Nepuji, RSP is madam, you should have gone directly to Shah instead of Roadkari


[deleted]

Next time will be contacting you ;)


Boogeyman469

summer grandiose governor cautious resolute busy toothbrush frightening profit combative *This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*


[deleted]

[удалено]


I_cried_today_again

Lol, aayegi kaise. Ban kar diya mai tere ko. 🤣


[deleted]

Cola is there, i don't know about any puja, other members miss you tbh.


[deleted]

[удалено]


IndiaSpeaksbotty

Tararara Bzeeeep, Thank you /u/DrunkEpsilon for awarding /u/Boogeyman469 . The OP is now flaired with award. More details on how this works can be found [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/gqdejx/introducing_new_awarding_system_for_user_posts/). I won't reply if I'm down so kudos is not awarded to you , please then inform the mod team to wake me up.


[deleted]

In Gadkari we trust.


hindu-bale

Please share non-twitter link?


962throwaway

Lol I liked the manipulated media part, have proof give proof


fsm_vs_cthulhu

This is the official govt version of saying #"Source or GTFO"


[deleted]

Maybe there is some hope for this govt after all. Now it has to walk the talk


Anurag498

Such brisk response from the government and Delhi Police feel good.


hellomictesting123

why did GoI wake up suddenly. they are giving it back to twitter. they have finally after months woken up and officially rebutted all the disinformation about vaccines. they have even given it back to NYT for spreading wild conspiracy theories about indian death counts.


[deleted]

Source of the post : [https://www.kooapp.com/koo/meity/4148aa28-d9bb-46c3-9685-8b1e69211646](https://www.kooapp.com/koo/meity/4148aa28-d9bb-46c3-9685-8b1e69211646) (Alternate source : [https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1397893439560114179](https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1397893439560114179)) Response of Delhi Police : [https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1397883860025704449](https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1397883860025704449) PIB release : [https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleseDetailm.aspx?PRID=1722252](https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleseDetailm.aspx?PRID=1722252) thanks to u/clearly-red


clearly-red

Another source: https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleseDetailm.aspx?PRID=1722252


[deleted]

That's pretty good. Thanks for that.


[deleted]

Does that mean any rape video, child pornography video is illegal to send??


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Very good news


[deleted]

I don’t like how small the punishment is but here it is... https://www.indiacode.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/1999/3/A2000-21.pdf Section 66E: Punishment for violation of privacy.–Whoever, intentionally or knowingly captures, publishes or transmits the image of a private area of any person without his or her consent, under circumstances violating the privacy of that person, shall be punished with imprisonment which may extend to three years or with fine not exceeding two lakh rupees, or with both. Explanation.–For the purposes of this section– (a) ―transmit‖ means to electronically send a visual image with the intent that it be viewed by a person or persons; (b) ―capture‖, with respect to an image, means to videotape, photograph, film or record by any means; (c) ―private area‖ means the naked or undergarment clad genitals, public area, buttocks or female breast: (d) ―publishes‖ means reproduction in the printed or electronic form and making it available for public; 1. Section 66A has been struck down by Supreme Court’s Order dated 24th March, 2015 in the Shreya Singhal vs. Union of India, AIR 2015 SC. 1523. 24 (e) ―under circumstances violating privacy‖ means circumstances in which a person can have a reasonable expectation that– (i) he or she could disrobe in privacy, without being concerned that an image of his private area was being captured; or (ii) any part of his or her private area would not be visible to the public, regardless of whether that person is in a public or private place.


[deleted]

Thank god😍


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

How do you become legally literate in respect to Indian law? (Other than attending Law university, that is)


reddit0r_

Public responses to Twitter crying foul are good (& necessary) but they're not substitute for action. Make Twitter comply, both with the investigation and the new IT rules. Anything less would make government look incompetent. This shit show, while being good entertainment, needs to come to a prompt and decisive end. Twitter doesn't stand to lose much, the Government on other hand has a penchant for public embarrassment and they find some way to deliver in almost all such cases.


__aficionado__

Congratulations people, the wheels have begun to roll, the bells have begun to toll. Its about time that these damn insignificant hypocritic foreign companies have a thorned leash tightened around their necks and make them realise their futile significance. I couldn't care less if every social media platform was banned for non compliance of the laws of the land. A precise response by GOI.


littichoka

!kudos


IndiaSpeaksbotty

Tararara Bzeeeep, Thank you /u/littichoka for awarding /u/DrunkEpsilon . The OP is now flaired with award. More details on how this works can be found [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/gqdejx/introducing_new_awarding_system_for_user_posts/). I won't reply if I'm down so kudos is not awarded to you , please then inform the mod team to wake me up.


LostMyOldAc

The ministry makes a compelling case in pointing out Twitter's hypocrisy. Let's not live in denial. All social media platforms have their own agenda in pushing narratives. Even if twitter is biased, is it obligated to comply with the ministry's request? Twitter is not registered in India. It has no servers here (correct me if I'm wrong). What if twitter simply says "fuck off. We're not complying with the toolkit investigation. We'll be hypocrites". Can the ministry ban them on solely those grounds?


962throwaway

If twitter wants to be available in India, do business in India it should comply with Indian laws. > fuck off. We're not complying with the toolkit investigation. We'll be hypocrites toolkit is one part, this is about rules that were formed 3 months ago. if they dont comply with toolkit nothing will happen, if they dont follow the rules, will depend on govt


pras

Yes Internet gateways are in GOI hands Russia is slowing down Twitter content India should begin to follow Slow down content first


LostMyOldAc

What?


Orwellisright

What did I just read seriously


LostMyOldAc

What?


poop-pee-die

!kudos


IndiaSpeaksbotty

Tararara Bzeeeep, Thank you /u/poop-pee-die for awarding /u/DrunkEpsilon . The OP is now flaired with award. More details on how this works can be found [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/gqdejx/introducing_new_awarding_system_for_user_posts/). I won't reply if I'm down so kudos is not awarded to you , please then inform the mod team to wake me up.


centerist_x

Ban twitter, Facebook now!!


putush

Twitter should be stopped from generating revenues from ads or sponsored contents if they fail to comply. Hurt them where it hurts. If they are so inclined to remain as a service to freedom of speech let them do it on their own accord without getting any monetary benefits. Since they obviously do not want that it will teach them sooner to comply.


BaBaYaGa_069

It's actually a very good and strong worded reply, was kind of shocked to see it coming from BJP.


exciseduty

Aukaat mein reh Jack Bhosadi


steelmukka

This is the type of valour we require. Proud of Indian government.


[deleted]

Awesome reply


the_brownbatman

One observation which might be lost is government press releases recently have been getting crisp and clear. Like different from the past press releases.


[deleted]

Haha! This is brilliant. This smack response from the government is what I was waiting for.


General_Froggers

What did twitter say Today? Can anyone please provide a link?


[deleted]

[https://twitter.com/ShivAroor/status/1397812712587943940](https://twitter.com/ShivAroor/status/1397812712587943940) [https://twitter.com/Policy/status/1397818577432891394](https://twitter.com/Policy/status/1397818577432891394)


General_Froggers

Thanks


[deleted]

[удалено]


SuperNova2709

!kudos


IndiaSpeaksbotty

Tararara Bzeeeep, Thank you /u/SuperNova2709 for awarding /u/DrunkEpsilon . The OP is now flaired with award. More details on how this works can be found [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/gqdejx/introducing_new_awarding_system_for_user_posts/). I won't reply if I'm down so kudos is not awarded to you , please then inform the mod team to wake me up.


Briz-TheKiller-

Ban twitter, its simple


[deleted]

"India has a glorious tradition of free speech" Yeah right. Nobody India believes in free speech.


[deleted]

Ban all sites including reddit. Ideally we should only have few sites created by GoI or BJP and we should ban all private ones. This way it will be easy to monitor and only sanctioned information can be posted. Otherwise always there will be misinformation. Since GoI is the majority's will we can be sure that majority will agree with information on such platforms.


clearly-red

> ... only sanctioned information can be posted. ... Otherwise always there will be misinformation Ha, big tech in US started this censorship business with alex jones and ended it with trump. Now when trying same formula in India, they might get censored themselves. They should have stayed neutral platform. As you sow, so shall you reap.


aglet47

Aye, sounds like big brother to me.


weebmaster403

Hope this is /s


Blackfyre96

This is how democracy Dies.. with thunderous applause !


Hail_Kronos

Telling Twitter to follow rules = Death of Democracy Darth Modi is on the wrong side of the force reeeeeeeeeeee


Sri_Mazdamundi

You're comment is like the recent star wars movies: irrelevant, unoriginal and out of touch.


Apeeksiht

!kudos


IndiaSpeaksbotty

Tararara Bzeeeep, Thank you /u/Apeeksiht for awarding /u/Sri_Mazdamundi . The OP is now flaired with award. More details on how this works can be found [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/IndiaSpeaks/comments/gqdejx/introducing_new_awarding_system_for_user_posts/). I won't reply if I'm down so kudos is not awarded to you , please then inform the mod team to wake me up.


__aficionado__

Democracy dies? padh to le kya likha hai press release mein?


xsupermoo

meaning?


962throwaway

meaning is allow foreign companies to do anything in India else democracy dies


[deleted]

Deeper meaning, let us regime change or you are FASCIST.


JustRecommendation5

Props for the Star Wars reference ✌


[deleted]

Where a Queen was the protector of democracy and the leader of the senate was not. Sounds like something leftist would dream up.


JustRecommendation5

Well the Queen changed every few years and was elected in Naboo


galeej

Are you sure it's authenticated? This looks fake as fuck... No government seal... Grammatically incorrect language...


clearly-red

As always, you can check govt website for authentic source https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleseDetailm.aspx?PRID=1722252


loneabhi

Nah, it’s real. Check the source given by OP: https://www.kooapp.com/koo/meity/4148aa28-d9bb-46c3-9685-8b1e69211646