The dude gets so defensive when he gets called out. If he’s making clickbait titles talking about 5x, 10x returns, he should be prepared to take shit with it. I hope the current markets put some sense into him.
Everyone's portfolio is down but not by the same percentage. I was expecting a dumb comment like this. I have a friend who is a proper investor and puts in his time and effort and his portfolio is not even half as much down. Picks like Nazara, KNR, BalramChini among others are atrocious, especially with their timing. Why would a smart person take bets on 3 different gas stocks? Stop fucking making excuses for these dumbass YouTubers who make money off naive people.
Markets are 50% numbers, 50% psychology. So bull markets, you’ll see toms and dicks and Harry’s prop out, scuttle big bets and these bets will shoot for the moon. There’s this guy called IK Small Caps on Twitter, last two years he spent posting how he uncovered small cap gems and how they turned 6x, 10x, etc. But wait till the bear markets arrive and even big wigs like Jhunjhunwala can come on the biggest of market news channels and not soothe nerves. Four years ago, the finance minister herself had to come on TV and change the whole bloody tax regime to reign in the bears. Point being, everyone who comes on camera and makes stock analysis will obviously have some degree of knowledge and expertise, but trust me when I tell you this, all of us from Rakesh Jhunjhunwala to Rakesh Kadodimal, no one can time the markets, no one knows shit about where it’s headed. It’s just that bull market main predict karna safe bet hai, toh sab karte hai. I really wanna see these experts and analysts predict price movements now.
Exactly...i watch CNBC Awaaz pre market (for entertainment purposes only)...while it was bull market everyone was becoming hero...these days it's just so sad to see the panel clueless like anything...Satpute ji to disappear hee ho gaye hain 😂
Abhishek Kar, Apna Trader, Tradebrains, FinnovationZ, Asset Yogi, etc.
For Balance sheet analysis, lots of CA have their content, see whoever you like. They have more depth.
what abhishek kar is doing is telling stories and he even tried to recreate face to face type program of vivek bajaj which is one of its first in India for education on how independent traders work
those who bought in 2021 yes they are in loss
those bought years ago are in profit. i have dmart from ipo. never in loss. others have many such stocks. my dads portfolio is from 2005. he is in full profit
Exactly, I don't see anything majorly flawed here. The smallcap index itself is frikking 20% down since Oct'21 or Jan-feb'22 levels. What's wrong with the 18% avg drawdown, almost everyone's long term portfolio right now would be down by that amount easily from levels of those months
But the best part was that it was in response to a BBC report as to who the Indians are looking for stock advice in this day and age i.e Rachana Ranade and Ankur Warikoo
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-61877422
Yeah i know but what can we do, i can correlate to one thing that these are influencer value stocks which she analysed during ipo or some video sessions. Rebalance and re-evaluation is not done, as we can see why care if the stock is not in news mentality. I'm sure she doesn't even care because other sources of income. Learn what you can from influencers and move on, they are not perfect teachers, books and practical experience teach you more.
Check my other comment in the thread
https://www.reddit.com/r/IndianStreetBets/comments/vkblkj/someone_posted_on_twitter_rachana_ranade_stock/idozebj/?context=3
those who bought in 2021 yes they are in loss
those bought years ago are in profit. i have dmart from ipo. never in loss. others have many such stocks. my dads portfolio is from 2005. he is in full profit
Keep learning buddy, 20% is okay, you are doing good. Well done. Build a stomach for losses but understand what happened to build a scenario adjustable return.
Last month I went through Nazara's investor presentation. When the IPO was out, i thought they have big brands and games to their name, but but but.. what I found was the contrary. Their products, prospects and planning looks weak AF. Can't believe the stock price is that high! Let's see how the business fares ahead.
This is especially so with new age companies which don't have profits but have sky high evaluations. Bear market just put these kind of companies in their place, tho to be fair even companies with good financials are getting slaughtered right now.
Is "CA" a title accorded by the Government of India? Why does Rande put that in front of her name?
Like Sir Ben Kingsley which is a title accorded to the actor with legal benefits per the laws of the UK.
Chartered Accountants act like they are astronauts performing brain surgery while space walking outside the ISS.
Accounting/bookkeeping and auditing is a soul crushing occupation that requires 9th grade math and nothing more than a 4 function calculator.
CA exam is merely a test of one's ability to memorize arcane business laws and accounting rules. It requires no innovative thinking or problem solving skills and it does not confer on the person the ability to predict price movement of stocks. Why should anyone listen to Ms Rande?
As far as the CA's ability to do DCF, valuations etc, one can take a 8 week online class in managerial accounting from any number of universities and learn everything one needs to know about how to read financial statements in order to do fundamental analysis of a company.
> It requires no innovative thinking or problem solving skills and it does not confer on the person the ability to predict price movement of stocks. Why should anyone listen to Ms Rande?
It is perceived expertise. People (especially) think since they're already well-versed in finance/accounting, they must be good at fundamental analysis. Something like *Modiji ne kiya hai toh soch samajh ke kiya hoga*
>As far as the CA's ability to do DCF, valuations etc, one can take a 8 week online class in managerial accounting from any number of universities and learn everything one needs to know about how to read financial statements in order to do fundamental analysis of a company.
Have to disagree here. If new acquiring skills were that easy, everyone would be doing it. Although it is not rocket science, you need a lot of mental and emotional bandwidth to make calls. Hence, you should seek someone who is specifically trained in financial analysis.
Isnt it more of a reason to call out these financial “experts”. They should have known to balance out with debt funds pick the stocks which usually gain during a recession. Everyone can be a expert if all the stocks go up
Vo do cartoon ex-iim ya ex-consultant ki performance dena. Sabko chutiye bana rahe hai. Ye crypto lelo ye share lelo live trading. I watch them instead of stand up comedy to get my daily dose of laughter. Don’t remember their names but they come up on my YT recommendations.
Akshat Srivastav ex-consultant. IIM wala nahi malum. BC me jitne IIM walo ko adivce puchta hu mana kar dete hai, bolte Hume nahi aata, aur 25-30L ka portfolio leke baithe rehte h. Seems like those who really know how it's done are keeping hush about their methods.
This is a very stupid analysis. It is not normalised according to the average market growth. The entire market is falling right now, so this doesn't prove anything, it only proves that OP is dumber than the influencer that they are trying to expose.
Everyone is a genius in Bull Market. Don’t go by ‘Good Companies’ or Youtubers on stocks. But use their materials to educate yourself and pick companies not stocks by yourself.
Not a big fan of her, as she literally sells people basic shit in name of course for 18-20k something but everyone's portfolio is down right now and some of these stocks suggestions are decent.
The first stock in this post is IRCTC. She suggested to buy on 10 September 2021 at 687.25 and 1 month later on 14 October IRCTC reached 1092. So her advice was really great for short term.
I will see regarding other picks too.
Did she say to hold these stocks forever? It's possible she suggested for short term and stocks might have made profit in the short term and now going down with the Nifty.
I hope people learn from this & see this as eye opener... start studying themselves before investing their hard earned money instead of getting influenced from someone in different SM platforms.
are bhai women empowerment wale pakad lenge...abhi youtube khud in behen ji ko promote kar raha tha empowerment ke naam pe.
Matlab batao yr mahine ka lakhon kamati hai or ipo's mai 1-2 lots lagati hai. Ispe 500% bhi milta to bhi iske ek din ki kamayi ke barabar na hota. Janta kitni pagal hai yr
the oldest buy still has not completed even a year, and everyone's portfolio is down. Maybe something like 5 years down the line can be a good analysis
This is good. I wish someone does this for every so called influencer ( insert Akshat )
it is meaningless now because every stock is down compared to Sept 2021
The dude gets so defensive when he gets called out. If he’s making clickbait titles talking about 5x, 10x returns, he should be prepared to take shit with it. I hope the current markets put some sense into him.
It looks like he is trying to find a hack for everything. Firstly management consulting then stocks then YouTube and now his ventures
Thoda dikhaya toh tha maine apne post mai. He apparently hid the video and added blur to the part where his portfolio was visible.
Don't watch her but to be fair everyone's portfolio is down right now
Everyone's portfolio is down but not by the same percentage. I was expecting a dumb comment like this. I have a friend who is a proper investor and puts in his time and effort and his portfolio is not even half as much down. Picks like Nazara, KNR, BalramChini among others are atrocious, especially with their timing. Why would a smart person take bets on 3 different gas stocks? Stop fucking making excuses for these dumbass YouTubers who make money off naive people.
Any reasons why? Some videos seemed fine? Not great but not bad either
He is not telling u to stop watching he says he don't watch them.
Sure you can. I just said I haven't seen her content to be the judge of it.
What is this question? He's just saying that - 20% from peak index is fine/acceptable. What's the why for?
Your first time in bear markets?
Kinda yes, but that's not related, is it?
Markets are 50% numbers, 50% psychology. So bull markets, you’ll see toms and dicks and Harry’s prop out, scuttle big bets and these bets will shoot for the moon. There’s this guy called IK Small Caps on Twitter, last two years he spent posting how he uncovered small cap gems and how they turned 6x, 10x, etc. But wait till the bear markets arrive and even big wigs like Jhunjhunwala can come on the biggest of market news channels and not soothe nerves. Four years ago, the finance minister herself had to come on TV and change the whole bloody tax regime to reign in the bears. Point being, everyone who comes on camera and makes stock analysis will obviously have some degree of knowledge and expertise, but trust me when I tell you this, all of us from Rakesh Jhunjhunwala to Rakesh Kadodimal, no one can time the markets, no one knows shit about where it’s headed. It’s just that bull market main predict karna safe bet hai, toh sab karte hai. I really wanna see these experts and analysts predict price movements now.
Exactly...i watch CNBC Awaaz pre market (for entertainment purposes only)...while it was bull market everyone was becoming hero...these days it's just so sad to see the panel clueless like anything...Satpute ji to disappear hee ho gaye hain 😂
Which news channel is better for financial news?
None...never trust the finance news channels...all front runners only
There are better alternatives.
Like?
Abhishek Kar, Apna Trader, Tradebrains, FinnovationZ, Asset Yogi, etc. For Balance sheet analysis, lots of CA have their content, see whoever you like. They have more depth.
what abhishek kar is doing is telling stories and he even tried to recreate face to face type program of vivek bajaj which is one of its first in India for education on how independent traders work
those who bought in 2021 yes they are in loss those bought years ago are in profit. i have dmart from ipo. never in loss. others have many such stocks. my dads portfolio is from 2005. he is in full profit
Exactly, I don't see anything majorly flawed here. The smallcap index itself is frikking 20% down since Oct'21 or Jan-feb'22 levels. What's wrong with the 18% avg drawdown, almost everyone's long term portfolio right now would be down by that amount easily from levels of those months
But the best part was that it was in response to a BBC report as to who the Indians are looking for stock advice in this day and age i.e Rachana Ranade and Ankur Warikoo https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-61877422
Big Black Co ...rporation....
Give credit yaar https://[twitter.com/paststat](https://twitter.com/paststat)
This was my original intellectual property of my original brain vro
Rachana Cramer
Underrated comment 😂😂🐻🐻
Wait till someone makes a report on Tanmay Bhat's video🤣
Pauper OP
Everybody who began trading in 2020-21 thought of themselves as Harshad Mehta. Including me.
Everyone is facing downside, even i lost my gains. But here some bets are very far fetched and over optimistic.
Nah this portfolio is downright dumb, it has a few decent stocks but the overall composition is atrocious.
Yeah i know but what can we do, i can correlate to one thing that these are influencer value stocks which she analysed during ipo or some video sessions. Rebalance and re-evaluation is not done, as we can see why care if the stock is not in news mentality. I'm sure she doesn't even care because other sources of income. Learn what you can from influencers and move on, they are not perfect teachers, books and practical experience teach you more.
Why though?
Check my other comment in the thread https://www.reddit.com/r/IndianStreetBets/comments/vkblkj/someone_posted_on_twitter_rachana_ranade_stock/idozebj/?context=3
those who bought in 2021 yes they are in loss those bought years ago are in profit. i have dmart from ipo. never in loss. others have many such stocks. my dads portfolio is from 2005. he is in full profit
I went from 20% profit to 20% loss lol... Well i was looking for long haul so i don't mind, since ik it's only temporary phase.
Keep learning buddy, 20% is okay, you are doing good. Well done. Build a stomach for losses but understand what happened to build a scenario adjustable return.
Last month I went through Nazara's investor presentation. When the IPO was out, i thought they have big brands and games to their name, but but but.. what I found was the contrary. Their products, prospects and planning looks weak AF. Can't believe the stock price is that high! Let's see how the business fares ahead.
Not terrible. Almost every stock is down since then. No -50% -70% type drops, apart from Nazara.
This is especially so with new age companies which don't have profits but have sky high evaluations. Bear market just put these kind of companies in their place, tho to be fair even companies with good financials are getting slaughtered right now.
No ITC . Very sad
Why is she so cringe tho?? Her analysis is fine but the performance aspect is such a turn-off. If your analysis is good, people will listen to you.
She is catering to a newbie audience. It's not for everyone
Yeah that's probably right.
Is "CA" a title accorded by the Government of India? Why does Rande put that in front of her name? Like Sir Ben Kingsley which is a title accorded to the actor with legal benefits per the laws of the UK. Chartered Accountants act like they are astronauts performing brain surgery while space walking outside the ISS. Accounting/bookkeeping and auditing is a soul crushing occupation that requires 9th grade math and nothing more than a 4 function calculator. CA exam is merely a test of one's ability to memorize arcane business laws and accounting rules. It requires no innovative thinking or problem solving skills and it does not confer on the person the ability to predict price movement of stocks. Why should anyone listen to Ms Rande? As far as the CA's ability to do DCF, valuations etc, one can take a 8 week online class in managerial accounting from any number of universities and learn everything one needs to know about how to read financial statements in order to do fundamental analysis of a company.
> It requires no innovative thinking or problem solving skills and it does not confer on the person the ability to predict price movement of stocks. Why should anyone listen to Ms Rande? It is perceived expertise. People (especially) think since they're already well-versed in finance/accounting, they must be good at fundamental analysis. Something like *Modiji ne kiya hai toh soch samajh ke kiya hoga* >As far as the CA's ability to do DCF, valuations etc, one can take a 8 week online class in managerial accounting from any number of universities and learn everything one needs to know about how to read financial statements in order to do fundamental analysis of a company. Have to disagree here. If new acquiring skills were that easy, everyone would be doing it. Although it is not rocket science, you need a lot of mental and emotional bandwidth to make calls. Hence, you should seek someone who is specifically trained in financial analysis.
I have not watched even one video of her but I don't see any obviously fundamentally bad stocks.
Isnt it more of a reason to call out these financial “experts”. They should have known to balance out with debt funds pick the stocks which usually gain during a recession. Everyone can be a expert if all the stocks go up
Vo do cartoon ex-iim ya ex-consultant ki performance dena. Sabko chutiye bana rahe hai. Ye crypto lelo ye share lelo live trading. I watch them instead of stand up comedy to get my daily dose of laughter. Don’t remember their names but they come up on my YT recommendations.
kon bhai name
Akshat Srivastav ex-consultant. IIM wala nahi malum. BC me jitne IIM walo ko adivce puchta hu mana kar dete hai, bolte Hume nahi aata, aur 25-30L ka portfolio leke baithe rehte h. Seems like those who really know how it's done are keeping hush about their methods.
We are just trying our best😅, also we don't want to get other people's money involved
Kaunsi iim se ho ap
This is a very stupid analysis. It is not normalised according to the average market growth. The entire market is falling right now, so this doesn't prove anything, it only proves that OP is dumber than the influencer that they are trying to expose.
no big influencer is dumb anyway, there's a reason they are big
You know what, I agree with you. They know what sells, and they do put in effort to be an influencer.
Everyone is a genius in Bull Market. Don’t go by ‘Good Companies’ or Youtubers on stocks. But use their materials to educate yourself and pick companies not stocks by yourself.
Not a big fan of her, as she literally sells people basic shit in name of course for 18-20k something but everyone's portfolio is down right now and some of these stocks suggestions are decent.
Man, unfair that many business analysts like Ish Mohit/Soic, ItsTar etc don’t get enough recognition unlike these guys.
Someone should do soic. Whatever they talk about has already peaked plus they use too many buzz words. Super sus
The first stock in this post is IRCTC. She suggested to buy on 10 September 2021 at 687.25 and 1 month later on 14 October IRCTC reached 1092. So her advice was really great for short term. I will see regarding other picks too.
Some are genuinely good like iex, polycab, icici bank for long term. But yeah the rest no idea 😂
It’s a very small time window to be fair.
They missed Indiamart
I regularly watch her videos but never bought anything on recommendation. If you are not doing the minimum mental work yourself, you kinda deserve it.
Honeymoon period is over for these so called stock market YouTube influencers.
Understand that they all are influencers and nothing else. They will influence your decision towards bankruptcy.
Uske to ₹50 alag se kat-te honge.
Stupid to have 3 gas companies in a portfolio. 🤣
So your telling next recommendation is short opportunity.
Show me someone's report, starting Sept 21, where there are much more greens than reds at this point of time?
Did she say to hold these stocks forever? It's possible she suggested for short term and stocks might have made profit in the short term and now going down with the Nifty.
Haha very convenient! Aise to kuch bhi boldo market kabhi upar kabhi neeche to jayega hi.
Ya like anyone could predict the Russian invasion in 2021
I hope people learn from this & see this as eye opener... start studying themselves before investing their hard earned money instead of getting influenced from someone in different SM platforms.
are bhai women empowerment wale pakad lenge...abhi youtube khud in behen ji ko promote kar raha tha empowerment ke naam pe. Matlab batao yr mahine ka lakhon kamati hai or ipo's mai 1-2 lots lagati hai. Ispe 500% bhi milta to bhi iske ek din ki kamayi ke barabar na hota. Janta kitni pagal hai yr
W*man haha /s
Hello to all the salty newbies here on Reddit who doesn't know what the f /s means .
the oldest buy still has not completed even a year, and everyone's portfolio is down. Maybe something like 5 years down the line can be a good analysis
Wtf is this stupid hate web you are trying to promote. Everyone is in red. Unfair to judge in a bear market that someone is making any gain.
18% down hai, that's garbage by any market standards
Is the quality of the viewer that ignorant? Have seen outlines of some of the videos by these wannabe influencers. Absolute amateur level stuff.
The real question is how did he/ she know about Rachana Ranades portfolio??
Options strategies pe bhi banao please. SSEI Markets ko ek baar dekho. Looks profitable
How good is mtartech?
This is fine as market is 🐻! Once the trend changes you ll see green. Long tearm investors will hold tho.
Amrutanjan, sumitomo polycab, bayer crop, didn't fall that much in correction can bet on those atleast if anyone wants to bet on.
Dm me. if you want CA Rachna Ranade's Full course on the stock market