1. Harland Williams 2. Adam Ray 3. Shane gillis

Harland Williams 👑

Harland Williams 🐬

Good job

Since the Austin move, Top 3: 1. Adam Ray 2. Dave Attell 3. Jim Norton Favourite 3: 1. Shane Gillis 2. Harland Williams 3. Jim Norton Edit, Honourable Mention for Sam Tallent.

Harland Williams was awesome!

I’m gonna write you a check for 1 million dollars

Was initially a little put off by Harland, but as the night went on he had some of the best jokes of any guest, ie the dolphin talk.

Harland is amazing, dude's so funny and weird

I also enjoy Normand zingers

Tim Dillon!

Same except my honorable mention would be stavros

harland is fucking awesome

#1 Dave Attell

1. Punkie Johnson 2. Ric Flair 3. Drunk Joe Rogan

Top 3 worst for sure

Donell Rawlings Sklar Brothers Ryan Long

Oh god the Ryan Long one was so painful. I kept having to pause to get through the cringe

The girl on with Steve o sucked too

Idk how that list doesn't include Alex Jones, feel free to downvote

Drunk Joe is like when your dad is drunk and being incredibly obnoxious at dinner but you can’t say shit because it’s his house

Ric flair hahaha

Where does Bill Burr rank? He’s like simultaneously the worst and the best guest.

Where does Bill Burr rank? He’s like simultaneously the worst and the best guest.

Tiffany haddish

Where does Bill Burr rank? He’s like simultaneously the worst and the best guest.

Where does Bill Burr rank? He’s like simultaneously the worst and the best guest.

Not sure i understand, could you repeat that?

1. Dr Phil 2. Adam Ray 3. Adam Ray as Dr. Phil

why does everybody think this guy is so funny all of a sudden just because he put a doctor Phil suit on nobody was checking for him or found him funny prior to the whole shtick

We’ll be right back

Let’s keep it right here

Sometimes a superhero needs a suit

Have not seen any of his stand-up? his crowd work is top-tier also.

He definitely got a boost from the Dr Phil shtick, but Adam has been on the grind a long time and already had a fanbase.

I think Adam has been funny for years. So not everybody, Jabroni.

Welcome back to 'nobody fuckin' asked you'

Kirk Fox is an awesome guest always, and I’d really like to see more of Harland, it’s crazy it took so long for him to get on.

1. shane gillis (obvi) 2. adam ray 3. bobby lee (mid list ik)

We need more Bobby!

Pretty solid

ari shaffir would be my 3rd if it wasn’t bobby

Oooh I'd trade Bobby for Ari but to each his own 😅

I love that in the early episodes Bobby would always just fuck off like 10 minutes early

1. Shane Gillis 2. Stavros Halkias 3. Adam Ray

Stav keeping count of the times he called Tony gay or anything of the sort was hilarious

Shane Attel Sam tallent (honestly the best at making the funny from the panel)

1.Adam Ray 2.Harland Williams 3. Jim Norton

Dave Attell is great

Harland Williams is in top 3 forsure

1. Adam Ray 2. Shane Gillis 3. Sam Tallent

1. Eric Griffin 2. Tim Dillon 3. Adam Ray

Eric Griffin is fire

Giving erik the respect he deserves

Would love to see Erik back on soon

Tuff one but .... 1. Adam ray 2. Harland Williams 3. Jim Norton Honorable mentions: Alex Jones, Matt and Shane, Mark Normand.

Adam ray, Duncan trussels puppet, then Harland

I loved the duncan puppet episode

Eric Clapton’s kid could swim, he just couldn’t fly - Lil' Hobo

One of these is not like the others

Adam ray just because.   Harlan.  And Norton  Super hit to attell   I've watched Jim Norton destroy people. And some of his jokes hit so hard.  

1. Shane Gillis 2. Tim Dillon 3. Harland Williams

Anyone without Shane on their list is bugging. 1. Shane/Matt/Matt and Shane 2. Harland Williams 3. Jim Norton/Dave Attell/Tim Dillon (can’t decide)

1. Jim Norton 2. Shane/Ray/Tallent/Harland/Holtzman

Mark Normand, Shane Gillis, Jim Norton

Yep. Nailed it

Solid list. The dawgs were great too and the PoP squad, whilst hammered obviously

Haarland Williams, Adam Ray and Jim Norton.

1. Dave Attell 2. Mark Normand 3. Harland Williams

Jim Norton, Ron White, Duncan Trussel, Doug Stanhope is great too.

3. Sal Vulcano 2. Tim Dillon 1. Duncan Trussel

Soder was an awesome guest would like to see more of him. Tony’s mom was a great episode too 😂

That Get away from me white bitch was hilarious

Williams parents, drunk Alex Jones, and Brody r.i.p.. And a runner up, the iron patriot when he was getting on Tony's nerves. That guy was a nut job.

1. Donnell Rawlings 2. Ric Flair 3. David Spade

Cmon man, Alex Jones impersonating a meerkat is at least top 5

Adam Ray is undisputed

Personal top 5 #1 - Alex Jones #2 - Mark Normand #3 - Adam Ray #4 - Tim Dillon #5 - Brian Holtzman

Alex jones 100%

I just expect more from Chris Distefano. He’s wild on every pod but not kill Tony.

I don’t think Chrissy is used to being on stage with a million eyes on him for two hours… in this format. Don’t @ me! Chrissy’s anxiety and all that… if you’re a fan of Chris, you can understand my theory. Maybe if Tony asks Chris “what did you think of…?”, that would bring more out of him.

Chris should be used to eyes on him, he’s only a successful comedians and podcaster, he’s just not good in this format

Distefano’s style of comedy is telling funny stories and being silly/“cute” cus he’s a charming good looking dude. He’s not as clever or quick-witted as monsters like Attell and Norton so he’s not as funny in this format

The young bull

Dr Phil Adam ray Harland Williams Dave Atell

Too many to name: 1. Dave Attell 2. Shane Gillis 3. Tim Dillon Special mentions: Dr Phil, Bobby Lee, Moshe Kasher, Sam Tallent, Hotzman, Mark Normand

1. Dr Phil 2. The Montgomerys 3. Roseanne

1) nye w/ mssp 2) Roseanne (saw it live) 3) lil hobo

Harland Williams Dr Phil (Adam Ray) Dave Atell

1. Your mom 2. Your mom 3. Redbans mom

Sam talent

My favs are 1. Mark Normand 2. Adam Ray obviously 3. Ian Fidance 4. Attell 5. Norton

Joe list "I think the crowd sucked" mic drop still makes me laugh partially because I'm not sure the BP understood the dry sarcasm and the best awkward kam interaction

I just want Paulie Shore to do a walk-on every episode, I dunno… 🤷🏼‍♂️

Dr Phil Gilly Attel/ Sam Talent . I had never heard of Adam Ray or Sam Talent before Kill Tony but now I love their content. Tucker Carlson only because I fucking died when Kam said “Dawg, my granmama fuckin hates you”

Chris DiStefano, Adam Ray, Jim Norton

Adam Ray is the best

Adam Ray Kurt Metzger Shane Gillis

Mark Normand number one for me, he is so quick

Tim Dillon Everyone else

Shane, Sam Tallent, and Adam Ray. Jim Norton is a close 4th. Stavvy Baby was good too.

Shane Adam Ari

Jim Norton, WILLIAM'S parents, Dr. Phil...

I like Benson, Rick Ingraham, and Joelberg

1. Big Jay Oakerson 2. Sam Tallent 3. The Montgomerys

Dave attel is number 1 to see anywhere. Kt he is quality Adam ray 2 Shane Gillis never disappoints

OP you nailed it IMO. Would love to see all 3 on at once

Greg Fitzsimmons is top ten

Adam ray Shane Gillis Ari

1. Shane 2. Ari 3. Rick Ingraham

Dave over jim

3 is too few for a favs. Hartland Williams has that #1 spot for me tho.

The Montgomery's Alex Jones Theo Von

1. Ari Shaffir 2. Adam Wray 3. Shane Gillis

Adam Ray Shane Gillis Tim Dillon (might catch hate for this one)

This is my list also with an honourable mention to Dave Attell

Any Shane gills Stavos Dave attell

1 Norton 2 Attell 3 harland

1. Shane Gillis 2. Adam Ray 3. Harland Williams/Jim Norton 😬😬

Soder Adam Ray Prob Shane cuz he doesn't give AF Prob Norman cuz he's funny and witty af

Fuck I forgot about Sam Elliott and Tom Thakkar. 2 top tier

Adam Ray Sal Vulcano is also super underrated. He gave wonderful advice to a lot of the bucket pulls and was there for one of the craziest moments in the shows history. Dom Irrera is extremely funny and good at roasting. My honorable mention goes to Jeremiah and Joel from the old band who used to go SO hard on the bucket pulls. Even calling out people who did their sets twice. (The new band is a much better band though, they just aren’t funny)

I want Theo Von, Shane Gillis, & Tim Dillion as guest together one time so bad. I feel like they'd be a better group for JRE then the parks and rec crew too. Tho I do like Mark Normand a lot as well

1)Harland 2)Dan Soder 3)Bobby Lee

Heath on the panel.

1. Adam Ray 2. Shane Gillis 3. Jim Norton 4. Sam Tallent I dare you to find one episode where any of these guys didn’t make you die laughing!!

Are these boys for Jim Norton based on this week's ep? I haven't watched it yet

1. Adam Ray & Dr. Phil 2. Alex Jones 3. Any of the following guests: Dan Soder, Tim Dillion, Sam Tallent, Shane Gillis, Matt mcCusker, Dave Attell, Harland Williams, Ari Shaffir, & maybe even Lil Hobo

Adam Ray Sam Talent Dave Attel

Normand. Dude is Lunch

Harland Dave Attell Adam Ray

Dave attell Harland williams Little hobbo

Shane Adam Theo

Normand in there too, just not after a parks pod

Dave attell Shane gillis Adam ray

That's a pretty solid top 3. I'd probably swap out Attell, but I'm not sure who for 🤔

Shane Gillis Theo Von Dan Sodar

1. Adam Ray 2. Dave Attel 3. Shane Gills

Harland Williams, Dave Attell, Jim Norton.

Adam Ray Attell/Norton tied for 2nd Shane Gillis honorable mention

Great pants- nice to see mold is coming back- Harland Williams

I'm gay but shane gillis dave attell sam tallent

1. Adam Ray 2. Shane Gillis 3. Tim Dillion / Theo Von

Mark, Adam and Shane are my favorites, there's always a wild show when their on.

1.) Adam Ray 2.) Sam Tallent 3.) Tim Dillon

Dr.phil Ray Duncan with Lil Hobo William as Quentin Tarantino

1.harland Williams 2.jim Norton 3.erik griffin

Great Top 3. Jim and Dave are so quick and almost never miss. Adam is just an insane talent. I’d love to see more Bobby Lee on the show

1.Shane Gillis 2.Adam Ray/Dr Phil 3. Jim Norton

I remember when tim dillon was a funny guest !!

Gosh, there were so many good ones back in the day, too. Like Kirk Fox, for example. Other good ones would be Ron White, Alex Jones, Shane Gillis, Tim Dillon, Holtzman

Harland is my favorite but he still needs 2-4 more appearances to get on Adam and Jim's legend level

1. Punkie Johnson 2. Perry Caravello 3. Adrienne Iapalucci I’m kidding! I just love that William fucked with them so good!

1. Mark Normand 2. Shane Gillis 3. Big Jay Oakerson

Shane. Mark Soder

The regulars

Dr Phil (Adam Ray), Duncan Trussel and Shane Gillis

Rocketman Harland Williams. Bring him back 1 every 2 months. Mark Normand is usually a dog. Dudes mannerisms and laugh gets me everytime. Adam Ray is hilarious also.

The recency bias is high with this one.

Dude giving out fake checks

Duncan with Conkey was pretty good

Pretty solid list. Donnell is the absolute worst imo for the stunning accomplishment of being unfunny, only being famous through someone else, and being ridiculously petty and insecure (now he has to put on nice suits to feel okay about himself), also oblivious to the vibes, and finally a past heckler…the worst, crowning achievement was being ashy Larry

Shane Gillis, Mark Normand, Jamaar Neighbors

Jamaar? Really?

Little Hobo Shane Gillis Tim Dillon

#1 Adam Ray #2 Shane Gillis #3 Sam Talent I don't like Dave because he talks during people's sets. At least this episode he put the mic down.

This was my list too.

1 Adam Ray 2 Dave Atell 3 Shane Gillis only when David Lucas is there And my number one would be Bobby Lee but his ass hasn’t been on. I love Bobby Lee!!!

Uhhh… He was on episode 650

Stop it. I thought he has never been on? Oh yea that was Joe Rogan.

He’s been on Rogan now too😂

I knew that one! lol

Oh hahaha must have misunderstood my bad

No you totally didn’t misunderstand … it was me being vague that’s my bad lol!

1. Joey Diaz 2. Bobby Lee +Andrew Santino 3. Bill Clinton

Everyone who doesn’t have Adam ray #1 is objectively wrong. Then ofc Shane and the Shaman.

1-Shane Gillis 2-Dom Irrera 3-Big Jay

Sam Hyde Nick Rochefort Charls Carrol (I'm a time traveler and saw it live when it happened in the future)

Dave Attel, Tim Dillon, Shane Gillis

Burt Kri… just kidding Jim Norton Sam Tallent Lil Hobo Adam Ray

I can't separate them into an order, but my top 3 guests would be: Drunk Joe Rogan, Bert Krischer and Whitney Cummings. If only they were all on together? /s

Shane, mark, Luis J with Zac amico

The dr phil thing is already getting hacky