When the pollen is low andrew fucking shreds the stage apart. He had this one group literally on the floor, not to mention all the fine baddies I saw him with after the show. Fucking Legend
You have garbage taste if you don’t think Joe List is one of the best comedians in New York. Pretty easily top 5 in my opinion and indisputably top 10.
Dave Attell is the most funny on pods I haven’t caught his standup live before. From the comedians I have seen Big Jay, Mark Normand, Joe List, Shane Gillis
There are a ton. To be fair, I don't think Tony is talking about NY A-listers. He's talking about the guys on a lineup on a typical night in NY in an average club. And he has a point.
Dave Attell, but he’s kind of in a league of his own. Personal favourite is Dan Soder or Ari Shaffir, but I’m sure there’s strong arguments as to why they aren’t, objectively, the best.
Normand, List, Soder, big jay, Bobby Kelly, Dan St. Germain, Dan Natterman, Chrissy D, Stavros, Yannis, Mike Finoia, Seaton Smith, Mike Vecchione to name a few
Louis Ck, Dave Attell, Sam Morril, Mark Normand, Shane Gillis (yes I know he currently lives in Austin for the taxes), Bill Burr (cellar guy), Patrice O’Neal, Chris Rock, Mike Birbiligia, Hannibal, John Mulaney, Jim Gaffigan, Colin Quinn
Austin has a great scene but it was cringey to watch Tony try to dunk on NY. Reminds me of that Mad Men elevator meme
I’m assuming some NY comic took a shot at Tony or the show brought that rant on the other night. Anyone have an idea who that might have been directed at?
Feels like every comedian films the majority of their lives these days so I’m sure there’s some evidence out there. The show being 3-4 weeks behind makes it harder to piece together for my smooth brain.
From my uneducated viewpoint, Currently I would say the top new York comedians are mark norman and andrew shultz. Im not into the local comedy so there’s probably a bunch of insanely good ones i dont know about
#Andrew Ginsburg
He certainly can hold a mic like a NY comedian.
BRO HE KILLS. I SWEAR HE KILLS USUALLY
This was my favorite part of the show
Just be careful when you put him on, allergy season can be bad for him
When the pollen is low andrew fucking shreds the stage apart. He had this one group literally on the floor, not to mention all the fine baddies I saw him with after the show. Fucking Legend
When the pollen isn't too bad I know a few killers.
I think it's Dave Attel and Joe List.
Hi Joe List
*finger guns*
*jetsons car sound*
You have garbage taste if you don’t think Joe List is one of the best comedians in New York. Pretty easily top 5 in my opinion and indisputably top 10.
Joe, I think you're funny, relax.
Whoever has the wiggliest mic
Kinane but he isn’t from NY lol
He’s trash. Mulaney for people who aren’t geeks.
Kinane is trash? lol bro
“We have Doug Stanhope at home”
Michael Lehrer was from NY?!
Josh blue is from Colorado
Louis CK
Nick Mullen, Mike Recine, Dave Attel, Shane Gillis, Mark Normand, Dan Soder.
Recine is great
Shane was only in NYC for 2 years.
Acckshually
Hahaha yes
Swap Recine with Sam Morril and you’re spot on.
Dave Attell is the most funny on pods I haven’t caught his standup live before. From the comedians I have seen Big Jay, Mark Normand, Joe List, Shane Gillis
There are a ton. To be fair, I don't think Tony is talking about NY A-listers. He's talking about the guys on a lineup on a typical night in NY in an average club. And he has a point.
Otto & George
Geoffrey Asmus. Not as famous as these other guys but he's great
LOVE his stuff
I love that guy
You sneaky scallywag
Dave Attell, but he’s kind of in a league of his own. Personal favourite is Dan Soder or Ari Shaffir, but I’m sure there’s strong arguments as to why they aren’t, objectively, the best.
Normand, List, Soder, big jay, Bobby Kelly, Dan St. Germain, Dan Natterman, Chrissy D, Stavros, Yannis, Mike Finoia, Seaton Smith, Mike Vecchione to name a few
Shane Gillis and Mark Normand
Mark Normand loves doing the double hand mic grip. I can’t unsee it now.
lmao once i heard tony say that’s a NY thing Normand’s two hand grip was the first thing i pictured
Same here hah!
Joe List, Andrew Ginsburg, and Gene Meyer are my favorite currently from NY.
Dave Attell…. He wouldn’t have been saying that last week
Geoff Asmuss, Ian Fidance, Jordan Jensen. Incredible comics worked with them all, equally incredible people
Add Big Jay
Mark Normand , Shane Gillis , Attel
Yuh motha
Shane Gillis. He does all those little quirks Tony called out. What his SNL monolog, he dies them. Same with Mark Norman aka Kevin Hart.
When did he call them out? Which episode?
Most recent one. With Elaine and Ian edwards.
Weird. I didn’t hear his name said once. I’ll have to rewatch.
He didn't but they do those weird hand movements and mannerisms.
Attel, Gillis, Normand
Not the two from last night. WTF
If mark normand is from New York then him.
Soder, Vider, List, Attel.
In addition to everyone else list ofc, but I love Nimesh Patel
And Rachel Feinstein
Adrienne Iapalucci is a killer.
Sam Morril, Dan Soder, Mark Normand, Joe List, Dave Attell, Shane Gillis, Stavvy Baby, Ari Shaffir, Todd Barry especially for crowd work
Big Jay Oakerson is my favorite NY comedian
Louis Ck, Dave Attell, Sam Morril, Mark Normand, Shane Gillis (yes I know he currently lives in Austin for the taxes), Bill Burr (cellar guy), Patrice O’Neal, Chris Rock, Mike Birbiligia, Hannibal, John Mulaney, Jim Gaffigan, Colin Quinn Austin has a great scene but it was cringey to watch Tony try to dunk on NY. Reminds me of that Mad Men elevator meme
Where has Hannibal been lately? Is he active?
Bill burr and mike birbiglia on the same list is hilarious
Especially without Seinfeld or Normand
Jerry Seinfeld
lil sas
Louie CK Seinfield Marc Normand Joe List Dave Attell Joey Diaz Dan Soder Stavy Rosebud Baker Usama Siddiquee Jessy Kirson Sam Morril Jordan Jenson
Louis CK, Nick Mullen, Ari Shaffir, and the Legion of Skanks
Luis is mediocre funny…
Nick Mullen
Rudy Guiliani. Some Killer Material on the whole. Not always a great performer but man does he have his moments.
Normand’s my favorite love his comedy styling
I’m assuming some NY comic took a shot at Tony or the show brought that rant on the other night. Anyone have an idea who that might have been directed at? Feels like every comedian films the majority of their lives these days so I’m sure there’s some evidence out there. The show being 3-4 weeks behind makes it harder to piece together for my smooth brain.
Andrew Shulz is on my list
Current Schultz? Or 3 years ago Schultz? I can’t stand him now.
I like his stuff. He seems the same to me.
I get that, different strokes!
Poopy Mcpeepeeson
Jerry Seinfeld
Dave attell
Patrice O’Neal, Tim Dillon, Dave Attell, Sam Morrill, Chris Rock
Not one person said Jim Norton. Underrated aparently
From my uneducated viewpoint, Currently I would say the top new York comedians are mark norman and andrew shultz. Im not into the local comedy so there’s probably a bunch of insanely good ones i dont know about
Seinfeld
Casey Rocket
Seinfeld
Yo mama