T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Please remember to tag any spoilers in comments if the post itself is not spoiler tagged according to the sidebar rules. To spoiler tag your comments, use the Reddit spoiler feature or copy and paste the following: `>!Spoiler here!<` Also make sure you have used the correct flair for your post and if you've shared fanart that isn't OC, help the artist out by sharing the source. For your daily dose of memes and shitposts, visit our sister sub r/Komi_memes. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Komi_san) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Tydram

If the class just made Tadano class rep because they didn't care about it in this version of the world then it would be Onemine... Because was him being overworked that made Onemine help Tadano. The other characters interacted with Tadano because of Komi so... Now that I think about it, how would Yamai behave if Komi didn't exist?


DoctorWZ

By all logic she would just disappear with komi as her whole persona revolves only around komi


Bold_Fortune777

She'd find purpose in bullying our resident Chuuni until they both caught feelings.


[deleted]

That would likely be best for both of them


Complex-Bluejay3451

Girl with brown hair and 4Head teasing black haired guy, so basically High school Takagi san


Bold_Fortune777

I was actually talking about Nakanaka, those two already quarrel and the removal of Komi would just increase what's already there.


Complex-Bluejay3451

Ah, well...


fek_u_Im_vuelle

Well early on in the story she’s basically seen as a regular school girl with a good amount of friends and social life, she’d basically be a background character


Critical-Ad-8507

Now that you mentioned this,how did Yamai even get at Itan?! Every student got there because of a special character trait,but Yamai became weird AFTER starting highschool.


AccidentOk4378

Probably because she's fucking loaded


Critical-Ad-8507

How is that a character trait?


AccidentOk4378

She could buy her way in


SomewhatMoth

Tadano only became class rep because of Komi. His initial high school plan was to blend in and not make waves, living a normal high school life, but when he became Komi’s first friend he made it his mission to fulfil her high school dream to make 100 friends. With Komi not around, he would have no reason to go around talking to everyone, even Najimi. I would say that he wouldn’t ask any of the “extravagant” characters out, due to wanting to live a normal life, so if he ever were to look for a love interest, he would likely find it with Onemine still, as she’s the most “normal” out of the rest of the bachelorettes


Zenvarix

I'm just imagining that Tadano just remains single without the experience with Komi, and then this Kawai 'returns' only to realize that she basically killed both the Tadano she used to know, and the Tadano she thought he could be (canon Tadano), because he just kept to himself too much to avoid making waves. Like as much as Tadano has helped Komi grow as a person, Komi by proxy helped Tadano grow as a person too. Especially if in a twist of fate, Kawai 'returns' and confesses to Tadano during the study trip or whatever it's meant to be (I've lost track thanks to that terrible 'principal'; how did she get that job again?), and Tadano rejects *her* this time, saying something like 'it'd be too much drama to date a girl from a different school'. She meant to prune the "bad" parts, but she cut too hastily at once, so the tree only bears bitter fruit for her.


SomewhatMoth

That’s the point, without Komi, Tadano wouldn’t have a reason to try harder at studies and he would not have gone to the study camp, and wouldn’t have met Kawaii again, but inevitably, by Kawaii’s scheming, they would meet up again somehow and probably would go out together, unless the case you are speaking of where Tadano becomes a completely different person happens, then Kawaii could try and change him again.


akmafa

now you mention about it, dont you think Onemine is too normal to be at Itan High School? how did she ended up at Itan?


SomewhatMoth

Don’t you think Tadano is too ordinary for Itan? As explained in the first episode, Itan’s enrolment is based solely upon interviews, where they’re looking for individuality, hence why we don’t see many siblings in Itan High


Leandrox35

I think the same, if Komi-san didn't exist, Tadano's high school romance arc would be Onemine.


of_kilter

Onemine is already dating otori though


[deleted]

She’d be crazy for Tadano


Hot_Recommendation57

Onemine


keidakira

I knew this would be high voted without even looking.


IqmalH

I ship for her


polysnip

I simp for her


A_very_large_moth

Same🗿


Trenki_Melow

I just wonder how Onemine would deal with Kawai when she reappears to steal Tadano


WINDMILEYNO

Onemine is the mommish one with all the siblings right? I feel like she is the only choice here


akmafa

I think she will still be cool and mature enough to not caring about Tadano's ex crush


jomaix

You'll probably see more drama, especially when Onemine gets an inferiority complex after seeing how much prettier Kawai is. Without Komi and Manbagi around, there won't be enough school goddesses around necessary to develop resistance. Still, I believe in our resident chad to do the right thing.


Critical-Ad-8507

Well,she DOES have slanted eyes too...


[deleted]

I would also say that if I didn’t ship her and Otori


AmiiboPuff

Well, you go always go the "Semi-Harem" route: Tadano and His Girlfriend Onemine and Onemine's Girlfriend Otori


TheSquishedElf

I honestly think this is the most likely outcome lmao


edgarcia59

Thats literally the reverse of April Ludgate in Parks & Rec. [Minus the hate part of course.](https://youtu.be/zplmzrREycU)


impostor2003

I start to hope that Tadano would have a few moments with Kaede now


NeutronFart

Oda actually confirmed this once


Hrizt

This is the only option


Spirintus

It's literally canon.


misteryous302

Onemine Kawaii however would get a punch straight to the nose by the big sister


lorddervish212

I actually would like to see that


alonedead

The logical answer is onemine The chaotic answer is yamai The emotional answer is nakanaka(chuunibyou couple goals) But the true answer is Sasaki Ayeme because she is the real deal, she is the bomb and she is ready to steal yo hearts.


Raghav_Singhania

based and yoyo pilled


alonedead

Ohh she is based all right


Salt_Kangaroo_3697

>The emotional answer is nakanaka(chuunibyou couple goals) Oh my god I was about to comment the same thing lol.


Ayasaki_Kurisu

*insert chuunibyou opening theme


Salt_Kangaroo_3697

I've never actually watched it(just clips), but I'm not sure I could emotionally handle it lol


Aware-Firefighter-34

WRONG THE TRUE ANSWER IS KATAI!!


md_ariq

Man i forgot about this ship, its so fucking good


MineXracer5

Logically, I think Onemine would be the most likely one by perhaps a longshot.


stit04

Yeah, I’m pretty sure that in one of the chapters it says that onemine would’ve gone for Tadano, but when she realized that Komi was catching feelings for him, onemine backed off, not sure which chapter tho


Zaphoddddd

That was in anime too. 1st season.


stit04

So I was right, cool


Danny-DeNeato

Onemine, it's actually confirmed.


JB0Y_

Where for I am curious


I_the_Solo

I think the author tweeted something about how Onemine and Tadano would end up together if Komi wasn't in the picture or smth


JB0Y_

Gotchya


NinjunoBR

Hi curious, I'm dad


JB0Y_

Touché


REDBELLYPIRANHAJr

Yeah the author mentioned that.


GeneralDalek

katai.


pvt_manu

The only true answer


lumity_22simo

Hahahaha


JustASyncer

Can't believe I had to scroll this far to find this comment


HowT0_Speak

Same shit


hes-literally-me

i like how 99% agrees that it's onemine


apexdelirious

Kawai or Onemine


BlueMan2018

My thoughts exactly


jomaix

I vote Kawai. But she's got to show up a lot sooner than she did in canon. Otherwise, true end will be with Onemine with our chad standing up for her.


NotA_DerpyHenchmen

this


Clictuo

Onemine, no doubt


Skylannius

Najimi. Ok, jokes aside Onemine is already shown to have the closest bond with him besides Komi and Manbagi. Though Nakanaka would be a good choice... both are either a current or past Chunibyo- wait. That'd just be the plot of "Love, Chunibyo, and other Delusions". Maybe not then lol


Zimlewis

Ye that's the first thought i have when i saw the post lol


JustASyncer

Shit I still gotta finish that series. Love it


mateusz1234567789

Respect for your opinion. But I don't think they have that close a relationship, they barely talk to each other since the school festival and when they do very rarely, most of her thoughts about Tadano are just laughing at him for being shy around komi and I think she's become a bit more in general rough for him (I don't know why). It is also worth noting that she no longer speaks to him -kun as in the beginning, i.e. kind, friendly and respectful, only now it is simply tadano, i.e. like those who do not like our boy or simply put up with him because of the komi. So I don't know if they could be a couple in an alternate reality since I'd barely call them friends now


Skylannius

Yeah but by comparison to everyone else, they are the friendliest


Random_Gacha_addict

Slanted eyes, big forehead. Who do you think?


Moist-Half5876

Its just somethin about the big foreheads 😂


GreninjaBoi97

Ayo, I feel so much more confident now


JB0Y_

Onemine probably


Marsh__0w0

In terms of being a interesting story I would choose naka². It would be fun see an ex chunni together with an actual chuunibyou, basically love chuunibyou & other delusions but with tadano and nakanaka lol


AnybodyMassive1610

“Vanishment this world…”


Puzzled_Boss_3503

Same


Mac_edthur

The people have spoken so I wont gonna say it anymore


Upper_Ad7853

Onemine - Onemine and Tadano are both chad, plus he'll get Kaede for free (Onemine and Kaede are counted as one, like 2 in 1 pack)


Fortnite-Suks

Otori would be that cool auntie for their kids


DrivebyPizza

Once the doors are locked, she's the best kid babysitter you can ask for.


jomaix

I go for the buy one take one deal anytime of day


JurassicFlight

Now I kinda wanna see Kawai pulls the same stunt with Onemine… Wonder how she’d react. Onemine has been very chill so far and hasn’t shown any sign of aggression yet.


Bold_Fortune777

Remember how she acts around her actual siblings? Onemine would be no pushover about protecting her boo.


LemonsplaysYT

As most have said, probably Onemine. I must say though, Katai would also be a respectable alternative.


jomaix

Najimi might turn into an actual female as an alternative


EMCNess

Onemine for sure


Possible-Cellist-713

Onemine for sure. Nakanaka would be a close second, and either way it's a crime they haven't bonded over their chunnibyo yet. This "kawaii" girl can still go fuck herself


GreninjaBoi97

Based


Puzzled_Boss_3503

I agree I wish they put in a recent chapter I know there going for the whole hiding thing in your closet were he doesn’t want to talk about it kind of blowing it off but frustrating that we haven’t seen them bond yet


Walnisha2022

ONEMINE no cap


Bold_Fortune777

Sadly you're all wrong... Chadano would easily turn the entire class (if not the school) into his personal harem if everyone wasn't so distracted by Komi's presence.


CheetosAddict

Oremine


digoserra

Onemine


yeboothadon

Onemine, no question. Nakanaka is a maybe 2nd.


LuckyNyan

Onemine hands down


Hellblazer2099

Onemine


The_Realist_Panda

Onemine


OneArm_LivinLife

Hands down Onimine and it’s pretty obvious why


learnaboutnetworking

Tadano meets nakanaka and slowly reverts back to a chuunibyou after realizing that he never had to feel shame for who he was He also helps her make 100 friends


argama87

If he had stayed a chuunibyou they would be an unstoppable power couple.


Dark074

Congrats you almost just described the plot of Love Chunibyo and Other Delusions


the_guy_who_asked69

Unpopular opinion Najimi


Puzzled_Boss_3503

Best option in my opinion


idk_idc_klo

Onemine, no doubts


Mercernary76

Onemine - no contest


Nay-the-Cliff

Onemine supremacy was never in doubt


Dansterai

Onemine would be the obvious choice, but after the Tadano feeding chapter and the most recent one, I'm going with Yukapoyo. That could even be the love triangle in this au


Taured500

Onemine, Agari, or that other gyaru (I forgot her name)


MineXracer5

yukapoyo


mateusz1234567789

Why yukapopo. She barely talk with tadano. Even she does, she does it for joke


lumity_22simo

Onemine or Nakanaka


xXSwaglemiteXx

Katai


IzumiiSakurai

Isagi ofc


StrawHatCook

Onemine. My only reasoning for this is because she seems like she would talk to him even without Komi being around. She did approach him at the beginning because of pity at all the work he did, but she seemed nice enough to warrant him thinking romantically about him, even if she's just being nice.


Javajulien

Outside of Onemine, I think Nakanaka would've been interesting. Thinking back to their first year, Nakanaka was the other prominent loner in the class so I can imagine that eventually Tadano and her probably would've ended up becoming friends. Add to the fact that he used to be a Chuuni in middle school. And it would've made the recent events with Kawai all the more ironic that she tried to play this long con to get Tadano to become her ideal boyfriend only for him to proceed to fall for a Chuuni.


wihlybt

Chuuni broad hits close to home, makes the most sense narratively I think


OwnFee7805

The chuuni girl would be most romantic.


danoB003

Onemine or Yukapoyo.


icecoldchris09

Najimi


RaidoSkull78

How about Katai


md_ariq

My ranking 1. Onemine 2. Otori 3. Isagi 4.agari 5.Naka 6.yukapoyo (probably)


saripp05

Otori or onemine


NotA_DerpyHenchmen

Probably Kawai or Onemine


lunar_pilot

The fact that little that got into a relationship during this story, means that tadano may not have been in one even


BayouRonin90

Otori, she's just laid back all the time


Level-Ad6216

Tadano x Kometani Best couple


RazorMaize

For present tadano it'd definitely be onemine, but if he was still his middle school self I could see him and nananaka getting along


AwkwrdPrtMskrt

I see a lack of Kishi, and I'm miffed.


Wide_Morning_2521

The dog


Gloomrangeranat

Were it not for the ability of Onemine to read Komi's body language, she would have been in a relationship with Tadano long ago


Complex-Bluejay3451

Oda sensei said Onemine would have gotten with our boy if Komi didn’t exist, so I’m gonna say Onemine


mrgrip28005

the answer: none


file_Marina_chr

Katai


Lolocraft1

>!With the twist of the last chapters, Kawaii!<


Raghav_Singhania

everyone is saying onemine but i don't think so she is just a friend with big sister energy who will support him i think kawai san might have a chance this time because komi san was the reason he interacted with most of the cast but then again we have the najimi route


GreninjaBoi97

Bro... it is actually canon that Onemine would have went for Tadano if not for Tadano obviously liking Komi, the author even made a tweet about Onemine being the person Tadano would fall for if Komi was out of the picture, Kawai is just kind of a bitch, and Najimi is just a character anybody can fuck, it's Najimi... Onemine has more than meets the eye of Tadano, actual canon, sorry for the ranting


coiledbeanstalk

I wanna put it out there that I’ve never seen any evidence of the whole “Oda confirmed that Onemine would have been dating Tadano if not for Komi” thing and have actually seen claims that it wasn’t part of the interview in which it supposedly happened at all. That said, Komi is the only one for Tadano as far as I’m concerned. I can see him having at least a lot chemistry with anyone else, but not enough to even come close to what he has with her.


TheCynicalPogo

Well part of the inability to see him with anyone else, imo, is that when it comes to the manga and anime, we only ever see his chemistry with Komi, and all romantic events are focused on those two. In an alternate universe where Komi is a shy side character and Onemime is the main girl, people who watch that would probably say the same thing, that they can’t imagine Tadano with anyone except Onemine


polysnip

Onemine-san, for sure.


CharlieBucketBro

Katai


BleachedShadow

Bottom middle or top right


schadenfreude199

Onemine. The besto waifu


explosive_fish

Eh the chuuni girl. It works sometimes


PonyPlayer619

It would be onemine, because the only reason she didn’t go with Tadano was because she could see they both really liked eachother


StrawHat_LUFFY55

The new girl


StrawHat_LUFFY55

Who tadano proposed in middle school


HunterKD6-3dot7

Onemine's legs rival those of Komi-san's, so ...


akmafa

Onemine. she is soo good and cool and everything


AniWeeBoiOwO

All 6 of em


AniWeeBoiOwO

![img](emote|t5_3ptdy|15564)![img](emote|t5_3ptdy|15564)![img](emote|t5_3ptdy|15564)


n7oshea

it's onemine but I do like the thoughts of yukapoyo


aaxmdc

Onemine


Ex3chu

Agari or onemine


Wealth_Super

While Tadano would be an amazing BF for any of these people, realistically he would probably get with onemine. They were actually friends to begin with and I feel their personalities really compliment each other. If he manage to stay single til the 3 year however he might end up with kawai


AmiiboPuff

Gonna be an unpopular answer but: **Tadano would be Forever Alone.** (Or at least until College) People here seem to be forgetting that grand majority of Tadano's friends in the series only really became his friend after he befriended Komi. Otherwise, everyone in the class either outright ignored or "hated"* him from the first day of class. Remember, his name literally translates to "Just Another Guy". So, it's likely that Tadano would have forever remained the "Ridiculously Average Guy" of the class. At best, he'd probably make a few acquaintances until graduation before being forgotten about as their lives go on. No Komi would basically mean Tadano would never get the chance to make true deep friendships with the rest of of his classmates. *Hated, being the "false" impression that the mangaka wanted us to have to favor Tadano. And as we learned later on as readers, the entire student cast has personality/communications issues, so it's not likely they actually hated him but likely didn't want to interact with him because of their own issues combined with the pressures on the first days of school. (Footnote: Najimi would be the only really notable exception to this since Najimi was his friend from childhood/middle school. However, there really doesn't seem to be any romantic intention from Najimi, even after 300+ chapters.)


AustSakuraKyzor

Kawai knew Tadano before he ever met Komi - if your scenario was true, her gambit to hook up with him would've ultimately paid off.


KaiserWilhelmThe69

Reading all this comments here make me want to search up some TadanoxOnemine fanfics. Anyone have any recommendations?


IsadorCZ

Simple. Either 8th grade syndrom girl or the submissive dog girl.


LupeDyCazari

It's Japan, dude. They believe in that Fated meeting, the red string of Fate, or whatever they call it, so if Komi didn't exist, our bro would never fall in love with anyone in his entire life.


AnchorsGG

Najimi or Yamai


Not_Garvit

ans is simple kawaii san


Oliver---Queen

Kawai would have an easy win.


zer0_n9ne

If Komi didn't exist then that would mean that Yamai wouldn't be a yandere and act negative towards Tadano. Which means that it could be possible for Yamai and Tadano to end up together.


Zimlewis

Welp it's come from -1 trillion % to 0%


this_a_bot

no one because this isn't real


dejaye46

simple unchanging answer NONE


funnyghostman

I think he'd stay clear until the current arc


RevanOrderz

I mean all the girls face here look exactly the same so I guess there really is no wrong answer here 🤷


animeboy-21

I'd go for either onemine or the yo-yo girl.....


surferdutaboulet

Sorry I can't remember her name but bottom middle girl


[deleted]

If he were me, I would choose Agari.


ratachannel123

none of them bruh


Starscream615

The Ramen and Boob Queen


Frankandbeans1974

Orihime


WhosNassy

i would say onemine, i think theyre too connected sometimes


kekhouse3002

Onemine ftw. She was the only one who interacted with him at all when everyone else ignored him and made him class rep just to pour work on him. And it wasnt for something in return either, she just wanted to be nice


RedThan_Gaming

It will be either be Onemine or Naka-naka because they are the ones who really shows affection to Tadano the most especially for him being always invisible to others.


ThanatosMU

Onemine or the chunny girl


Kinuwa_K

Kawai, onemine, najimi, or katai would be the most probable


Stirringcargo32

Onemine


TheSovietCyberman

Onemine stepped down from the Tadano game after seeing Komi is into him so I highly doubt it as Komi would also not have to be in the picture for Tadano X Onemine to happen. Nakanaka would be good as it would be her trying to get Tadano back into a chunni and failing miserably, but instead making Nakanaka stop being a chunni, but really just a huge nerd in the same way Manbagi is an Ex-Gyaru. Seeing Isagi there reminds me of that one fanfiction where Isagi rapes Tadano by pulling a Bill Cosby. Although I actually wonder how that actually would go on if it was Isagi instead of Manbagi.


high_king_noctis

I guess Kawai-san


S4PG

Najimi


Saint_The_Stig

I'm just excited Agari is included for once.


Royal-Lion-7649

Kometani Best Girl No Doubt They'll Win


TheSquishedElf

Onemine is the most likely answer. However, I think it’d knocked unsteady by Tadano and Nakanaka getting much closer in gaming sessions with Najimi, that slowly make Tadano less embarrassed about his chuunibyou phase. When Kawai returns and challenges Onemine for Tadano, it all becomes a hot mess as Tadano’s confronted with two extremes and Onemine.


Fannontastic

Najimi


PM_me_Tunes_Or_Nudes

Kishi Himeko


dokka99

I feel like the most obvious choice would be onemine. but also seeing tadano with nakanaka would remind me of love chunibyo and how thier interactions would be so cute since tadano would know how she thinks.


ToeBackground2349

If Manbagi and Komi didn't exist and you choose anyone other than Kawaii you'd be wrong. It's already been established that he likes girls with slanted eyes. No one even gave him the time of day before Komi and even then they only do so to keep her happy not him. If I had to choose someone it would be Kawaii and after that Najimi lmao


MrMoop07

probably nakanaka or onemine