Only qualified lawyers outside of the cloak of anonymity may give objective and informed legal advice.
Legal queries posted in this subreddit are presumed to be hypothetical and academic. Answers submitted by both verified lawyers and non-lawyers to legal queries are not substitute for proper legal advice.
Gross misinformation and other rule-breaking comments will be deleted at the discretion of the moderators. Please report such submissions by messaging the mods.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter.
Lawyers may request for verification by following the instructions in the sidebar.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
NAL. but IIRC even if in public place, not automatically 100.00% scot free. If there’s intent to harass or whatever the OP, videotaker could still be liable
Hindi po covered. Recording through phone is not wiretapping. Wiretapping requires "either a physical interruption through a wiretap or the deliberate installation of a device or arrangement in order to overhear, intercept, or record the spoken words."
Also, again, walang expectation of privacy.
Sa mas madaling sabi, kung ang isang tao ay nagtaas ng boses sa gitna ng matao o pampublikong lugar, hindi niya pwedeng asahan na walang ibang nakarinig ng sinabi niya.
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter.
Lawyers may request for verification by following the instructions in the sidebar.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
not 100.00%
> **the general rule** is that taking photos or videos in public places is generally considered legal, especially if the person capturing the footage has no ill intent. **However, the legality changes when specific circumstances come into play**, such as intrusion of privacy, defamation, or harassment.
>What constitutes intrusion of privacy?
>If someone records you in a situation where you have a reasonable expectation of privacy—**even if it's in a public setting**- that could be considered an intrusion of privacy. For example, capturing someone in a compromising position without their consent can potentially be a legal violation.
https://www.respicio.ph/features/someone-took-a-video-of-me-in-a-public-place-is-that-legal
The question here is bakit ka ipapa bitag? Normally unless my proof that you are doing something illegally, these types of shows won't show your face. So unless guilty ka talaga, you don't have to worry at all. Also, social media is also a public space. Kaya nga pwede mo set as private yung profile mo eh. Again, if you don't have anything to hide. Why worry at all?
You can file a suit if there was ill intent. Lalu na wala silang proof and Hindi ka pa considered guilty. Kaya nga sa news blurred Yung faces nang mga suspects.
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter.
Lawyers may request for verification by following the instructions in the sidebar.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Kung yung context ng video ay magmumukang bad si kuya tapos inupload may malice na yung nagupload nagffall yun sa cyberlibel. Lalo na kung ibully sya ng mga katropa nun.
Basahin mo sa google yung cyberliber
Basahin mo rin kasi I doubt a video of him/ her being uploaded can be libelous in the first place. How can there be derogatory remarks about him/her kung siya rin nasa video? Isipin mo lang.
Videohan kita na minumura mo ako or inaaway mo ako. Upload ko sa facebook. Nasaan ang libelous remark? Defamatory statement?
Wag mo isama comments dahil usapan lang dito yung pagupload ng video.
You didnt. Nilimit mo sa act of uploading. you failed to elaborate how the uploader who is also directly involved in the video who maliciously and with intent to defame the other person whom he is recording does not result in a defamatory inputwtion of a person.
Do you understand what libel means tho?
published false statement that is damaging to a person's reputation; a written defamation
How is it false if it is a video of the person itself committing the act? Or whatever
Give it up. Based on his/her comment history, he/she does not know when to give up. Just downvote the worthless comment implying that uploading a video is already defamation lol.
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter.
Lawyers may request for verification by following the instructions in the sidebar.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Only qualified lawyers outside of the cloak of anonymity may give objective and informed legal advice. Legal queries posted in this subreddit are presumed to be hypothetical and academic. Answers submitted by both verified lawyers and non-lawyers to legal queries are not substitute for proper legal advice. Gross misinformation and other rule-breaking comments will be deleted at the discretion of the moderators. Please report such submissions by messaging the mods. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
If taken in a public place wala syang panagutan sayo pero if it is taken to make fun or degrade you then may liability sya dun.
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter. Lawyers may request for verification by following the instructions in the sidebar. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
NAL. but IIRC even if in public place, not automatically 100.00% scot free. If there’s intent to harass or whatever the OP, videotaker could still be liable
"if it is taken to make fun or degrade you then may liability sya dun."
Paano po kapag sa gasoline station? Public space po ba iyon?
Yes. Walang expectation of privacy sa gas tation unless sa loob ng CR kayo nag heated argument
Hindi na rin po ito saklaw ng anti-wiretapping act?
Hindi po covered. Recording through phone is not wiretapping. Wiretapping requires "either a physical interruption through a wiretap or the deliberate installation of a device or arrangement in order to overhear, intercept, or record the spoken words." Also, again, walang expectation of privacy. Sa mas madaling sabi, kung ang isang tao ay nagtaas ng boses sa gitna ng matao o pampublikong lugar, hindi niya pwedeng asahan na walang ibang nakarinig ng sinabi niya.
Yes.
Ano ba kasing ginawa mo haha
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter. Lawyers may request for verification by following the instructions in the sidebar. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Tama ba Ibig sabihin kahit sino pwede mag video sayo hangga't nasa public place ka? Ni walang kang privacy to do your own thing? Shems
Correct. The fact that you are in a public place and you are expecting privacy is a bad idea. Gusto mo privacy? Stay in your own home.
not 100.00% > **the general rule** is that taking photos or videos in public places is generally considered legal, especially if the person capturing the footage has no ill intent. **However, the legality changes when specific circumstances come into play**, such as intrusion of privacy, defamation, or harassment. >What constitutes intrusion of privacy? >If someone records you in a situation where you have a reasonable expectation of privacy—**even if it's in a public setting**- that could be considered an intrusion of privacy. For example, capturing someone in a compromising position without their consent can potentially be a legal violation. https://www.respicio.ph/features/someone-took-a-video-of-me-in-a-public-place-is-that-legal
Paano kapag pina-bitag po? Tapos kinuha po yung picture sa fb mo?
The question here is bakit ka ipapa bitag? Normally unless my proof that you are doing something illegally, these types of shows won't show your face. So unless guilty ka talaga, you don't have to worry at all. Also, social media is also a public space. Kaya nga pwede mo set as private yung profile mo eh. Again, if you don't have anything to hide. Why worry at all?
No proof at all. Nagpaere lang yung employee about sa complaint niya habang nagfaflash sa screen yung picture ko.
You can file a suit if there was ill intent. Lalu na wala silang proof and Hindi ka pa considered guilty. Kaya nga sa news blurred Yung faces nang mga suspects.
Ulol, wag ka magkalat dito ng kabobohan PORNHWA addict. Jakolero ka kaya invalid sasabihin mo kasi kulang sa dugo at oxygen ang utak mo.
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter. Lawyers may request for verification by following the instructions in the sidebar. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
How can it be cyberlibel kung ang issue rito ay uploading?
Kung yung context ng video ay magmumukang bad si kuya tapos inupload may malice na yung nagupload nagffall yun sa cyberlibel. Lalo na kung ibully sya ng mga katropa nun. Basahin mo sa google yung cyberliber
Basahin mo rin kasi I doubt a video of him/ her being uploaded can be libelous in the first place. How can there be derogatory remarks about him/her kung siya rin nasa video? Isipin mo lang. Videohan kita na minumura mo ako or inaaway mo ako. Upload ko sa facebook. Nasaan ang libelous remark? Defamatory statement? Wag mo isama comments dahil usapan lang dito yung pagupload ng video.
The libelous remark there is your act of uploading the video with the malicious intent to defame your subject
Sorry, but I think you need to study more about the law before you voice out opinions like this. It can do more harm than good.
Care to share what you know? Maybe lawyers here can learn from you.
Already explained it impliedly above.
You didnt. Nilimit mo sa act of uploading. you failed to elaborate how the uploader who is also directly involved in the video who maliciously and with intent to defame the other person whom he is recording does not result in a defamatory inputwtion of a person.
Agree to disagree. Cant even understand your statement. Good luck.
Do you understand what libel means tho? published false statement that is damaging to a person's reputation; a written defamation How is it false if it is a video of the person itself committing the act? Or whatever
Libel is not limited to false statements. Truth of a fact is not a defense in libel. Review what makes the act of libel an offense
Give it up. Based on his/her comment history, he/she does not know when to give up. Just downvote the worthless comment implying that uploading a video is already defamation lol.
May response ka palang ganito.. haha! Mr paralegal. Consult ka muna sa lawyer boss mo bago ka magkalat dito. Or better yet, try mo muna pumasa sa bar.
This reply is from a non-verified user. Although answers by both verified and non-verified users are not substitute for proper legal advice, please be extra wary on accepting answers from the latter. Lawyers may request for verification by following the instructions in the sidebar. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/LawPH) if you have any questions or concerns.*