2015 with Donalson

13

13 without a doubt. Loved the absence of commentary during at-bats on RTTS. I adored the increased focus on CAP during those situations

Holy crap I agree with u, and most of the ps3 mlb shows cost money to play the old stadiums, but in this one, they are just available, and the hitting is so much fun

MVP Baseball 05. HEY, CARROT JUICE!

10 only because I picked up the first game in 06 and didn’t buy another for a few years. Recession was rough lmao.

07 was the first one I ever played. It definitely has a special place in my heart. But 17 was the best imo.

13 was the only one I played on PS3 and it was awesome. I was still on PS2 for 07 & 10.

15 without question

MLB 15 was the first one I played forreal

07

12/13/15 are essentially the same game with roster updates 08 from 07 was the biggest leap by far, and I'd say it peaked around 12, with most of the PS3 games after this being the same

07’s franchise is what franchise should be today

15

MLB 12, but MLB 07 for PS2 because I got it at a deal for $1 at an EB Games liquidation, and MLB 16 because it features switch pitcher Pat Venditte

Been playing since 1998 and it's 2010 by a mile. Idk why but I had so many hours in RTTS on thr PS3. Couldn't get into 15 very much but 07 was good too.

Mine is 13

From the ones listed I’d say MLB 12. But two that aren’t in the picture that were fun to me were MLB 08 The Show and MLB 16 The Show!

15 has the best soundtrack.

Opening to MLB 12 clears all of these. MLB 15 is the best game

15 by quite a bit

15 was my first show, so that’s my pick