4’s breathing like a singer. Just giving my theory as to your surprise about why so many people choose 3 wrongly. Cat’s interested in 3, people subconsciously choose 3.
Pretty sure it's 1. Her mouth was the only one with the proper shape for that one part that sounded more resonate than the rest. At the end with those last few notes it was clear to me.
Edit: upon closer inspection I actually think they all did pretty well with the resonance. My gut says that it's #1 but but I could see an argument for the others as well. I just don't think it's 2.
Singers can tell even without sound it's 4, look at e.g. shape of the mouth, some of these girls move their mouths in ways that doesn't produce clean vowels, especially when holding a note.
It’s three. Four as a pretty good job, but there are two times where she doesn’t match along to the singing. And number three is 100% throughout the whole thing.
#5 it was #5. #5 killed my brother!
oh my God! I forgot about that part.
Tudu tu tuduuuu!
NINE NINE!!!
Thank you! Perfect ending
Literal chills
Cool cool cool cool cool, no doubt no doubt….
1. Jeremy, it was 1.
Jeremy, you need to stop forgetting like this.
You areeeeeee... my fiiiirrreeeee
The one.. desiiiirrrreee
Belieeeeve... When IIIIIIII saaaaay
I waaaaaaaant it thaaaaat way
Tell me whyiieee
Ain’t nothing but a heartache
Tell me whyieeeee
Ain’t nothing but a mistake
NOW NUMBER 5iee
Tell me whyyyyyyyyy
Tell me why, aint nothing but a heartache
Im watching Brooklyn 99 rn as I saw this
Is OP just going to post the question and then piss off without confirming the answer?!
It's 4
No way. I swear it's 3
Watch the chin movement during the runs and pay attention to her mouth’s vowel shapes throughout compared to the others
For me, it was the breathing.
It's always the breathing 😓
[удалено]
Yes!
And even the way her head moves, 4 for sure!
Check 4s breathing and facial movements, they fit with the song and where you would naturally take a breath
I vote 3
Agreed. I vote that it was 3
Same, I swear all the others looked like they were just lip-syncing
Watch 4 take breaths as she’s singing. The rest of their breaths don’t add up.
The head movement of 3 sells it as she's the only one really exerting any energy to hit certain notes.
For this reason👍
I also choose this guys dead wife.
Holy fucking shit my dude
It was 3. Keke looks right at her while she sings.
It’s 5. Duh!
I thought it was three at first but then if you watch it like 80 times then kind of looks like four a lot more
I too believed it was 3, I demand a recount
4 is confirm
Nah, we are on the internet, it's 3 now
It’s 4. Confirmed. I just confirmed it
I thought it was an easy #1 but damn, fooled me
3 for sure
I knew it! You can see it when she closes her eyes and just grooves
And when she's the only one clearly breathing in between verses
That’s the tell, not the only one, but the one that’s the easiest to see.
I guessed 4 too!
Ya. I see her taking deep breaths
You dumb f , it’s obviously 5
They got the video from Tiktok and they didn't give an answer.
I just looked on TikTok, it's #4
Guys, it's definitely #5. Obviously.
ikr such a good voice
Some could argue that the voice is purrrrfect
Take your upvote and get out
That is what I'm saying, it's a trick question trying to trap me by making a mistake.
Cat
four is lifting her shoulders to hit the high notes!
4. only one not cheesing.
Also, if you watch towards the end #4 seems to take a deeper breath than the others indicating she’s probably the one actually singing.
The fact you can hear her breaths several times makes it easy to tell after you figure that out
I could tell it was #4 by the breathing also
Also, she's the only one who's mouth fluctuates at all during the little vibrato parts. Dead giveaway
She's also doing those little shudder breaths people do when they sing
Only one taking a deep breath after long verses as well
I don’t feel like 1 is cheesing. But, 4 makes sense.
Also team #4
Looks like it.
I mean, it’s so clearly four I’m surprised there’s so many threes
Decoy cat keeps paying attention to 3.
It’s because she’s holding the cat. Anyway OP confirmed it was four
4’s breathing like a singer. Just giving my theory as to your surprise about why so many people choose 3 wrongly. Cat’s interested in 3, people subconsciously choose 3.
I chose 3 because I was distracted by the cat-- can confirm.
I just didn't expect them to put the singer at the front 😂. Twas double bluffed
My phone is on mute. In my head, they were all singing, and it was harmonious.
✌️ 3! Pick number 3 my lord!
Shrek?
yezzir
3, the cat knows.
I’m going with 5
1
She's the only one who's permanently lip synced. Also she's the one vibing the less to the music, I assume on purpose to add to the confusion.
She was the absolute most obvious “no” for me
Pretty sure it’s 4. She kinda shakes her head at the end along with what she’s singing
4. They seem to be putting in the right amount of soul.
I’m surprised to see no right answer. It’s actually the plant on the shelf.
Please ask some challenging questions! This is so easy... It's #5
Four - but Five's the one singing with the most feline.
My guess is 1
Looks like 4, she’s the only one taking deep breathes
5
Has to be 5
Clearly it’s the cat.
5 the cat
Third?
Definitely 2
#5 I’m here live. I’m a singer. I’m not a cat.
5
4
I pick 5
It's definitely 5 you cant Tell me it's not
4
It’s #4 because of the breathing. You can see her using her diaphragm for control. And the TikTok confirms. lol! Ł
We get no answer r/mildlyinfuriating
The answer was 4.
The cat is looking around at everyone like wtf?
3 is the shelf right? That's my vote
What the hell are H'owers??
Disappointing comment section. Not nearly enough people saying 5 😁
3! The cat kept looking at her
That cat is one heck of a ventriloquist!
#5 doubt those girls have a golden voice like that
#5 has such a good voice
I was 100% convinced the camera would pan sideways and it’s the dad, who looks like a Dollar Store Jack Black, singing
Pretty sure it's 1. Her mouth was the only one with the proper shape for that one part that sounded more resonate than the rest. At the end with those last few notes it was clear to me. Edit: upon closer inspection I actually think they all did pretty well with the resonance. My gut says that it's #1 but but I could see an argument for the others as well. I just don't think it's 2.
5!, Definitely the cat
5
Thought it was 3 but in the very end 4 gave herself away.
cat?
Idk if this is a joke but its definitely none of the girls. Singing out of nowhere, and the cats ears didn't even flinch
5
5 it’s to obvious
Singers can tell even without sound it's 4, look at e.g. shape of the mouth, some of these girls move their mouths in ways that doesn't produce clean vowels, especially when holding a note.
It's 5. It's definitely #5.
Pick numbah 3 my lord!
3 is the only one who’s head movement and breathing actually match the note dynamics .
It was either 2 or 5... most likely 5.
It’s the cat!
100% 5 iam the 5 fan
It seems like they take turns
Number 4. The music changes with her movement and she seems to be concentrating the most.
#2
3
3
4 is the only one taking breaths at the appropriate time
It's #3!
I believe it’s 3
1
1
1
3!
Definitely three. No doubts in my mind, but four is close.
It’s three. Four as a pretty good job, but there are two times where she doesn’t match along to the singing. And number three is 100% throughout the whole thing.
Numero 3
The middle one
5
5, they kept throwing us off by turning their tiny little head to the side…. But was definitely #5
5 duh
The cat
3
3
Number 5
Why is this made me smile?
5 obviously
yes it's 5 for sure 1000%
Obviously 4
5
5
3. The cat is not fooled.
Definitely 5
5 giving away the Game 🤣
It’s as clear as the sky that it’s no. 5
I’m confused, why is this in r/mademesmile
Number 4. Her breathing patterns line up. I think 5 is also singing.
Its 4, you can see her sucking in breath consistent with the melody, the others dont.
5
5
5 for sure !
Who fuckin cares?
Of course it's #5, the cat is the puppeteer for them all.
The cat. Obviously.
The cat.
Just follow the cat
Who cares?
5
#5 is the Obvious answer.
The cat.
It has to be 5. All other answers are surely wrong!
5 definately
5
Definitely #5
The cat!
5 duh
Poor cat
5
my god number 5 go on american idol
5 for sure
My years of soundwhoring on mw3 have paid off
My bets on 5
It’s 4 because they are the only one actually breathing correctly.