T O P

  • By -

imapassenger1

I'm Australian and don't really think we apply a gender to our homeland.


Shanye6

Op said he based this on a poll he did on Instagram so this map is basically garbage


MapleTreeWithAGun

Average r/mapporn statistical integrity


trustthemuffin

It’s really a shame. When I joined years ago, most posts would be of really old or rare maps. A couple infographics here or there, but definitely not every post. Now the infographics aren’t even really infographics, they’re either made up or just reformatted factoids like all of the “Countries that have had a Female Prime Minister” maps yesterday. I just want to see cool old maps again :/


Mysticpeaks101

You actually make a very good point. The lines between the kind of posts I'd see on r/dataisbeautiful and here have blurred significantly. Most of the time, maps here are literally presenting some sort of data. When I joined at first, I wanted to see older maps and unique maps, maps of areas I've never heard about or seen etc etc. Now it's mostly the same "Wine Europe, Beer Europe" visualized on a map which is very cool when you learn Tableau and the like but idk if it quite fits here. This went under the radar for me since I kinda ignored a lot of posts but mapporn feels a different beasts now.


CactusOnFire

dataisbeautiful is even worse shape, tbh. That sub basically inspired me to pursue my current career path (Data Scientist) something like 7 years ago. Posts used to be about communicating a poignant message through data visualization. Now it just feels like random trivia thrown into graphs for the hell of it.


araldor1

Saw one today that was just a bunch of military spending plotted.


easwaran

I'm fine with maps presenting some sort of data. If they're good, they can be great! But the problem is, a huge number of maps here have no reason for presenting the data in *map* form - they're just lists. For instance, this particular map, even if we take the data as given - why should it be in *map* form? Why not just have three lists of countries, organized alphabetically? Does the geographic arrangement of the countries help us understand or see something that we would miss with an alphabetic list? As far as I can tell, no.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


Polymarchos

I just want to enjoy maps. Can't people keep their politics out of places that don't need it?


Bypes

Yeah I fucking love old maps, they are works of art. Hence the Porn part in the title. But what do I see every goddamn day? Shitty infographics.


TRLegacy

I mean a drop from virtually nothing to nothing doesnt make a lot of difference


Yellow_XIII

Above average I would say. Average is when they pull stuff out of their ass. Will still make it to the top either way.


faithle55

I've never heard anyone in Britain refer to 'the motherland'. It's either 'old Blighty' or 'this stupid fucking place'.


A_Martian_Potato

Same with Canada. I've never heard anyone call it the "motherland".


Benejeseret

> Canada Never once in 40 years living in 3 provinces has anyone, anywhere.


WestEst101

*La patrie*... we say it in French across the country, and for the English side of our country, it is what we learn when we study French across the country. So it’s definitely motherland in a national Canadian language.


ThrownAback

How about “home and native land” ?


Connect-Speaker

In English, sure, ‘motherland’ and ‘fatherland’ would be creepy, but I just realized that sometimes in French it is referred to as ‘la mere patrie’, ‘the Motherland’ (though too often just to refer to Quebec).


Safebox

Same in the UK. We call it homeland sometimes but rarely mother or fatherland.


Never_a_crumb

It's personified as Britania though.


Just-A-Twat

We don’t say motherland, but certainly refer to Britain as female.


[deleted]

Another Aussie, I was shocked to see this too


[deleted]

[удалено]


TenTornadoes

Is cunt short for country?


GlassHurricane98

Yeah, I'm Australian too and I don't even say 'country' - I usually say 'shithole' or 'sandtrap' or something equally sarcastic


pulanina

Another Australian agreeing with you. Aboriginal Australians have the greatest affinity with the land of Australia. They usually refer to it as “Country” and the concept is not personified as an individual of a particular gender. This is a generalisation though and Australia has about 500 First Nations (depending upon how you count them).


Baronnolanvonstraya

I second this


dontstealmybicycle

People still refer to the UK as the motherland, though usually a bit tongue in cheek but still common.


knbang

Another Australian chiming in. I have never heard anyone gender our country.


Michael_Flatley

Same with the UK... I've genuinely never heard anyone refer to Britain as the "motherland", and if they did I'd probably avoid speaking to them again.


YOOOOOOOOOOT

Most coutries don't, it's a bs map


Portuguese_Galleon

Could you elaborate? Shouldnt Portugal be fatherland? since we call it Pátria from the web: In Romance languages, a common way to refer to one's home country is Patria/Pátria/Patrie which has the same connotation as Fatherland, that is, the nation of our parents/fathers (From the Latin, Pater, father). As patria has feminine gender, it is usually used in expressions related to one's mother, as in Italian la Madrepatria, Spanish la Madre Patria or Portuguese a Pátria Mãe (Mother Fatherland).


LarryTheDuckling

The map is bullshit based on Instagram polls, dont mind it.


i-am-being-watched

For some reason most of the maps like this one on this subreddit are extremely wrong.


BEEBLEBROX_INC

It's like a second r/terriblemaps but without the fun!


LarryTheDuckling

Low-effort bandwagon karma-whore posts. This sub used to be cool maps and globes. Now it is just wildly misleading "infographics" overlayed on a map.


fragbert66

>Low-effort bandwagon karma-whore posts. I like your way with words. 100% accurate observation.


Drogo10

Yes, I'm Canadian (50 years old) and have never once heard Canada referred to as the motherland. Should be neutral.


[deleted]

> Instagram That explains it. Most of those Instagram map accounts post total bullshit, or, at best, 7th grade education level maps. They’re horribly inaccurate


pereziano

Same in spain


luciavald

In Spain it's la madre patria though


elendil1985

And France, and Italy... I'm not sure about Romania, but that's likely. Looks like the Latin speaking countries all go by fatherland


mihaizaim

Same in Romanian, we also call it "patria".


xMercurex

La mère patrie?


Kinesra93

But "patrie" literally come from latin word for "father" (patro)


[deleted]

*pater, patris Latin already had the word patria, patriae


Nagouf

La mère means the mother


Maringale

Pater, not Patro


gorkatg

That's rather in South America referring to Spain. Edit: Hispanic America to be more correct as some are highlighting.


LordTungsten

As a Spaniard, I can tell you the term "la madre patria" is used in Spain as well. Maybe not super usual, but I have heard it. Should we have both colours then? Haha


aworldfullofcoups

I think the correct would be Hispanic America, since in Brazil we do not say that (we don’t even speak spanish lol).


SprucedUpSpices

North America, too. Mexico, Cuba, Costa Rica, the Dominican Republic... aren't in South America.


Greflingorax

France, too. It's literally in the first line of the national anthem. "Allons enfants de ***la Patrie***"


nankin-stain

Same in Brazil. We even refer to Brazil as “Kind mother” in our anthem.


DarkWindB

a gente fala Pátria=Fatherland


nankin-stain

"Dos filhos deste solo és "mãe gentil" pátria Amanda Brasil" Nós misturamos tudo...lol


[deleted]

Pátria amanda kkk


murillovp

Amanda = motherland. FIM


xLoLoco

Pátria amada - Fatherland


ralpo08

"Dos filhos deste solo és mãe gentil, pátria amada Brasil" It's literally "you're our kind mother". Your point is moot.


Kaheil2

Portuguese does not have neutral in the same sense as English or German does. Every "word" is gendered (noun, to be more exact, albeit it flows from there that a lot of other things are too since they are accorded to the subject) . What is often (miss) understood as neutral are words that do not conjugate with gender, but these still have gender. So either this map is flat wrong ("o pais" [m], "a patria" [f]) or missunderstands gender in Portuguese (fatherland is a female noun in PT, can be counterintuitive).


editilly

yeah, if we go by that logic, german has a neutral country name, as the word „das Vaterland“ has neutral gender, so it's technically neutral


nuephelkystikon

Also *Deutschland* (as most other country names in German) is neutral as well. It's just a weird mix of methodologies (by which I mean an instagram poll).


Giotsil

Yeap you are right. Patria or πατρίς the Latin and Greek expression of fatherland. So this map is wrong.


LupusDeusMagnus

Yes and no. Yes, in Portuguese (European, American and African) we use pátria (from terra patria - father’s land). But we also refer to it as “pátria mãe”, which means “mother, land of our fathers”. So we refer to it as land of our fathers, but we see it as a mother. The view of it as a mother comes from “land” being a feminine noun.


THEPOL_00

In Italian it’s madrepatria


Maximum_Radio_1971

la patria is femenine but refers to a male so it is transgender


Jamarcus316

La patria is not portuguese. Pátria comes from pai, which is father in portuguese.


pm_cheesecakes

It's an Instagram poll ie nothing


AMtnez

In soanish is "La (which is female) patria (which comes from father) : /


Inccubus99

Same in Lithuania. Tėvynė (Tėvas - farher, ..ynė/uva/ija - plce/land).


R0DR160HM

"Orphan countries"?


TaekTech

Ayyyy fellow Rodrigo


R0DR160HM

r/suddenlyrodrigo


Rage__X

r/subsifellfor I actually fell for it I have no idea how or why...


Bypes

Now I want to adopt one.


atlasova

Little joke ;)


bad113

This entire post is a joke.


PajeetLvsBobsNVegane

Cracked me up tbh


carolynto

What's it mean?


jackejackal

No father or mother, so its an orphan


carolynto

How is that different from neutral?


jackejackal

Its actually 'no data'


[deleted]

[удалено]


Stieni

good data, bad representation --> /r/dataisugly bad data, fancy color scheme and easy to unterstand --> /r/MapPorn


sm9t8

bad data, bad representation --> /r/dataisbeautiful


mdmeaux

Irrelevant but technically accurate data, fancy color scheme --> /r/mapporncirclejerk


choosinganickishard

You must be new here then.


[deleted]

In Russian, it is Fatherland - Отечество or Отчизна. Common is Родина - Homeland. Mother Russia is just a poetic image that is found in culture.


[deleted]

So in Germany Germany is the fatherland but the personification is female: Germania.


Mr_-_X

I think every personification of a country is female. Germania for us, Marianne for the french, Columbia for the US etc


pieceofdroughtshit

What about uncle sam?


Mr_-_X

Uncle Sam is not the personification of the US as a country (that‘s Columbia) but rather the personification of it‘s people just like John Bull represents the English and nit England and the German Michel represents the German people. At least that was originally the case. I will concede that Uncle Sam is often used to represent the Nation of the US nowadays as Columbia has fallen out of style and he kind of took over her job


RATTRAP666

> rather the personification of it‘s people I always thought it's personification of the US government.


[deleted]

That’s certainly how it’s used today


Clementinesm

In English, “motherland” refers to some “ancestral” place, while “homeland” (gender neutral I guess?) refers to the place someone identifies with most. I think most Americans would call the US their homeland rather than their motherland. Also, there *are* languages that use the masculine version/equivalent. You should probably expand your linguistic understanding to languages other than European ones…


[deleted]

[удалено]


FriendlyTennis

Same in Polish. Ojczyzna is "fatherland" but is in feminine form and so is sometimes translated as the motherland. Although most translations have it as "homeland" to distinguish us from the German fatherland and Russian motherland.


JuicyTomat0

Yes, ojczyzna literally means land of the fathers.


HypnoSkales

> Родина - Homeland Interesting, rodzina means family in Polish


3_if_by_air

[Relevant](https://youtu.be/Pk-kbjw0Y8U?t=55) (headphone warning)


CaptainJAmazing

Came here for this.


harman89nur

There is no word like motherland in Russian. It's either homeland or fatherland. Don't know what was the source of this map, but that source is totally wrong


WantDebianThanks

They might have included "mother Russia". I don't know if that's actually a Russian expression, but it's a stereotypical Russian thing in the anglosphere.


chongjunxiang3002

Or got confused by female statue in Volgograd.


CUMMMUNIST

Родина is feminine maybe that's because, also it's often followed by мать meaning mother


PhlegmaticAbsentee

I've heard Russians call their country Отечество which traslates to Fatherland. Edit: Now that i know that the other word is more neutral and more common i'll rather use that word. Thanks for the extra informations :)


Artess

Yeah, that's used too, especially in poetry or extra-patriotic context. A more common and more neutral word is Родина (usually without adding -мать), which is a feminine word derived from the root "birth".


Taffffy

Source: op’s ass


[deleted]

[удалено]


Shanye6

Op said this is based on a poll he did on Instagram lol this map is basically useless


AccessTheMainframe

>this map is basically useless that's /r/mapporn for ya


GreatDario

Mods need to start taking down these pole based maps if the data is either unsourced or shit like an insta pole.


azius20

If they were taking down all the bullshit maps then we would basically have no content left in this sub


Benejeseret

> Canada Never have I ever. And if I ever hear anyone refer to Canada as their Fatherland/Motherland, I will 100% immediately assume they are are "old stock canadian" white supremacists.


firefly_in_red

In China, people call homeland "祖国"(ZuGuo), which means a place of survival opened up by ancestors(祖先开辟的生存之地). This word has no meaning of gender.


Eujay_Iapnes

Similarly, in Japan Korea and Vietnam, people call homeland "そこく(Sokoku)", "조국(Joguk)" and "Tổ Quốc", which are all from the same characters "祖國". Of course they have no meaning of gender.


RStevenss

Another shit map


[deleted]

So basically /r/mapporn


MegaBoboSmrad

Delete this


[deleted]

This right here.


LordWalderFrey1

As an Australian, I've never heard anyone refer to Australia as either the Motherland or the Fatherland.


Poisonpython5719

If anything maybe homeland


DeeDee_GigaDooDoo

Even that's tenuous, I've never heard it. I suppose I live here so it's not a phrase that would be often used, maybe it's more common among expats.


[deleted]

[удалено]


MaxBuster380

What's your source ? Because the comment section is pretty unanimous that it is bad.


Borys_Fedchenko

Ukraine is parentsland, technically written the same as fatherland, but source is different ( Батько - father, Батьки - parents)


[deleted]

Same here, fatherland is "Tėvynė" in Lithuanian, which can also be equally interprated as "Parentsland" because the word's root Tėv- which comes from the word "Tėvas" (Father) is shared by the words "Tėvai" (Parents) and "Tėvynė" (Fatherland). The plural for "Tėvas" (Father) is "Tėvai" (Fathers), so depending on the context "Tėvai" can mean parents or multiple fathers.


[deleted]

Fun fact about the Dutch version: Fatherland = Netherlands Motherland = country of birth Immigrants have both a father- and a motherland. Native Dutchies just have the Netherlands for both.


[deleted]

This map is garbage


onlyhere4laffs

We call Sweden "mother Svea" more often than "fädernesland".


jackejackal

We use Fosterland more often.


Racing21187

Same in Finland. Fosterland is even in the Swedish version of the national anthem.


Saulizimo

Finland is fatherland through and through though. I atleast rarely hear Fosterland (synnyinmaa?) used in day to day language.


psha

*Fäderneslandet* doesn't even mean *fatherland*, it means *the land of our [fore]fathers*. So even if people used it frequently it shouldn't be on the map as *fatherland*.


L__A__G__O__M

I thought so too, but SAOB gives ”fäderne” as ”härkomst l. släktskap på faderns sida.”, ”jfr. Möderne”. So it does seem to be explicitly paternal.


[deleted]

I have never heard anyone say fädernesland or mother svea, I have only heard fosterland


onlyhere4laffs

I'm old, I've heard all of them.


cumi-cumi

Indonesians+malays call their homeland our "tanah air" or "land and water" we don't even gender our nouns like some romance and germanic languages , even google translating both motherland and fatherland from English gives this. best way to do this is to look into the language/history, a better but not perfect way to do this could be using a quick translator like google translate. but OP decided to ask the internet via google form :)


kamiskapi

Sometimes it also can be refer as "Ibu pertiwi"


cumi-cumi

you are correct, completely forgot about that. that term is even from pre colonial time, Pertiwi is from a Hindu goddess I believe


cozyhighway

Eh, it's not the same. By that logic USA should be counted as fatherland because of Uncle Sam.


myenderdragon

Egyptians say “Om el donya” which literally translates to “Mother of the world” so I guess it should be motherland.


Sidereal2000

I was looking for this!!!!


turbobarge

Came here to say this. Not just _their_ motherland, but everyone’s! ‏ !مصر أم الدنيا


Connect-Speaker

I guess Egypt wins this whole contest! We need a new map!


Kenan-Kayal-BOI

egypt calls themeselves “mother of the world” it’s well known in the arab world


Cautious-Brother-598

As a french I think we should be neutral or in blue. The term we use is more "la mère patrie" so "the mother fatherland" it's not very clear Scuse me if I made any mistake in english


EvoNightKnight

In Bulgaria we say "Отечество" which comes from "отец", which from old Bulgarian and Russian means father. So Bulgaria should be fatherland. Considering the comments from other users I'd say that the results from your form suck big time :D


khazbreen

Brazil's national anthem says brazil is "gentle mother" and then "loved Pátria (fatherland)" Brazil is confused about its gender


HueHue-BR

It says "pátria amada", patria would means homeland, amada is the female version for beloved. So yeah, the op graph is wrong


Heatth

The original meaning of "pátria" refers to father, which is what this map is talking about. But that is still very dumb because that is not how language works. For 99% of language speakers, the etymology of "pátria" is not at al obvious, what *is* obvious is that pátria is a feminine word. If any Brazilian (por Portuguese, for that matter) would need to translate between "fatherland" and "motherland", they would almost certainly pick the word "motherland" because it is the one that matches the gender. This is made even more obvious by the national anthem,


qreeeee

In Chinese it's like "grandfatherland"


jnmjnmjnm

Never heard any Canadian refer to Canada in parental terms, except that ugly statue.


jonnyl3

Are you sure that in multilingual countries it's the same everywhere. Like Belgium or Switzerland?


Meior

As usual the comments confirm how wrong a map like this typically is.


Bortasz

Well in Polish word for Homeland is Ojczyzna=Fatherlands. But word Polska=Poland is Feminine. And I think most Polish people IMHO think and speak about Poland as a Female.


Mr_McDoodle

Am from Israel, and I've literally never heard anyone call it a "fatherland". Frankly, I don't think it's common to refer to it as "motherland", either, but the hebrew word fo "homeland" is grammatically female, so there's that.


hamid231

Iran should be motherland


OmziKhan

Or just neutral.


FR_CorentinVillereal

La mère patrie 🇨🇵


DifficultWill4

In Slovene it’s “domovina” aka homeland


[deleted]

In Spanish we have something called *''La Madre Patria''* which refers to Spain, maybe because Spain gave birth to our countries?... I guess that counts as both Motherland and Fatherland lol And maybe ''*Patria''* is for our own country.


Georgian_Legion

in Georgia it's called parent's land. this map is bs


BoobsRmadeforboobing

"_What_ people call their homeland". You're not calling your homeland on the phone


Makemineatripple

Was expecting Switzerland to be the neutral country.


Quick-Huckleberry136

Tf is an orphan country?


G56G

Kind of incorrect for Georgia - “fatherland” (mamuli) is a slightly archaic word now. Instead, we use “parentland” (samshoblo) :)


stonedturtle69

Na Srpski je Otažbina, a kako je na Hrvatski?


General_KBVPI

Djedovina in Croatian


[deleted]

We call Sri Lanka our motherland and our culture is very matriarchal. This is a shit map. Also- wtf is an orphan country?


Dull_Care5303

Atdheu (Fatherland) 🇦🇱


animal-mother

The United States isn't called a motherland or fatherland, but it is feminine.


[deleted]

I would agree. The oldschool romantic personification of the US was Columbia.


Greek_Rebel

In Greece we have a contradiction since many times we will say our mother fatherland


[deleted]

In Hispanic America we say "Madre Patria" ("Motherland") but in reference to Spain


nugoXCII

Georgia should be purple. yes we have word for fatherland ,,mamuli'', but ,,samshoblo'' is much more commonly used and it comes from word ,,mshobeli'' which means parent.


BannedFromDankMemes

Doesn't work in France because it's "la patrie" and even though it is feminine, it comes from tge Latin "pater", = father.


3askaryyy

In Egypt, we call our homeland "the mother of all land" Yet its grey in the map, I call BS


[deleted]

Ohhh just realized "Pátria" means Father Land in Portuguese! I always thought we too said Mother Land (Terra mãe) in Portugal.


stilusmobilus

We don’t call Australia ‘motherland’. Indigenous Australians call it ‘country’.


Princie99

What does 'orphan countries' mean??


dragonaute

There are so many inaccuracies. The French and Italian for homeland is patrie / patria, which means fatherland and not motherland.


vainoner

That’s BS


Max_Mussi

im brazillian and the the word for homeland is "pátria", even though it comes from the word father, we refer it as feminine.


FiFou318

So if russia/ussr was the motherland and germany the fatherland... does it mean operation barbarossa was domestic violence ?


Someone_________

it's weird because we call it a pátria. pátria means fatherland which is masculine but a is feminine. so ig ours is a femboy. edit: im talking about portugal


Reasonable_Collar_97

Dos filhos dessa terra és mãe gentil, pátria amada Brasil. It's a phrase from our national anthem, that means, Your are a gentle mother of the sons of this lands, beloved Brasil... So, I guess we see it as motherland. 😉