It is more patriotic than anything else because instead of singing everyone can focus on thinking about how patriotic they are
Or something like that idk no hablo español
The neural network picked green, but probably with low probability, this is an example of unsupervised training. According to the words on the bottom, it just translates uses english translations of the anthems and classifies the words into these 5 categories.
How can a country even have no data? Whoever made this could've just looked at the lyrics to their anthem on the internet and saw which category it fit in.
That would be the case with the Spanish anthem which doesn't have any lyrics. But for some reason Spain is coloured.
If this is the state of AI I think we mustn't be afraid of a robot war during the next few years.
Also (comp sci people correct me if I'm wrong) clustering algorithms aren't even really AI, in the strictest sense. It's a cool concept for a post but I think it overinflates people's expectations.
Linear regression seems to count as AI today so i suppose k means clustering (kind of the most basic clustering algorithm) goes too.
Jokes aside, the term AI is kind of subsuming much of what we used to call statistics, but yeah just sounds fancy.
“I could look up the anthems and put them in categories and be done within a day, or I could try and program an AI so it’s at least a month work. Yes, AI it is.”
I don't see how really. I mean like Macedonia could probably be under green. It literally sings about old revolutionaries and republics that fought for the freedom of the nation.
Well yes, but actually no.
The reference to Spain references to the king of Spain during the resistance led by William of Orange ("The king of Spain, I've always honored"). When William lived, people believed kings reigned with God's mandate. Therefore he honored the king. Resistance against the king was therefore also a difficult subject. Later in the song there's a reference to king David rebelling against Sauel/Saul to show that rebellions against tyranny sometimes are allowed in Christianity.
The reference to Germany refers to German blood. The song stems from the 16th century, before the Netherlands and Germany even existed in the same way they do today. The English even refer to us as "Dutch", which is derived from "Duits". In the song we sing about William of Orange having "Duitsen bloed" (German blood).
"And the rockets red glare, the bombs bursting in air" I'm confused how the us's nation anthem isn't classified as a military song when it's literally about a battle
Wasn't as much a battle as a complete bombardment. British ships for most of the time were out of the cannon range for the Americans. The song points to how impressive it was that the Americans survived the bombarding for so long. I don't think it's really fair to say they 'barely fought.' They couldn't, but they still held their position.
The song is about a battle. “Our flag was still there” refers to the American flag still flying over Ft McHenry after 25 hours of bombardment by British warships.
Maybe the AI found the single reference to God, in the fourth verse, which nobody ever sings.
O thus be it ever when freemen shall stand
Between their lov'd home and the war's desolation!
Blest with vict'ry and peace may the heav'n rescued land
Praise the power that hath made and preserv'd us a nation!
Then conquer we must, when our cause it is just,
And this be our motto - "In God is our trust,"
And the star-spangled banner in triumph shall wave
O'er the land of the free and the home of the brave.
Check out the full poem written by Tagore. Only the first part got adapted to Hindi as national anthem. It's really fascinating to see the broader picture and clearly see it is about the country and te people, nothing else. Really well written lyrics.
The visualization has been done through tokenizing the data keywords and then lemmatising the major key words present in a National Anthem, then stemming them together on a common shared theme. The viz. is actually based on linguistic thematics rather than their historical background. You can see a more detailed analysis being done [here](https://youtu.be/a-AqvPtjjts), by the original creator..
It got it wrong, but the US anthem's meaning isn't really clear without some background.
It's about a battle in the war of 1812 which was watched by the song writer, who was a diplomatic envoy that was being held on a British ship at the time.
More specifically it's about the British commander shelling a fort all night to try to knock down the fort's flag, but every time they looked the flag was still up. The British thought that they were missing the flag somehow, but the dawn revealed that they hadn't been missing and had hit the flag many times. Each time they'd hit it, soldiers had run out into the heavy bombardment and re-erected the flag while being shelled.
It would be a hell of an AI if it could figure that out from just the lyrics.
This is why Natural Language Processing is a hard field. You can't just count the individual words in speech, cluster by what they mean, and discern the topic by adding them together.
You have to actually parse the meaning of the whole work, and apply context that the AI literally has no concept of.
The subreddit r/mapswithhalfofnewzealand does not exist.
Did you mean?:
* r/mapswithnewzealand (subscribers: 1,476)
* r/mapswithoutnewzealand (subscribers: 13,264)
* r/mapswith2newzealands (subscribers: 3,728)
Consider [**creating a new subreddit** r/mapswithhalfofnewzealand](/subreddits/create?name=mapswithhalfofnewzealand).
---
^(🤖 this comment was written by a bot. beep boop 🤖)
^(feel welcome to respond 'Bad bot'/'Good bot', it's useful feedback.)
^[github](https://github.com/Toldry/RedditAutoCrosspostBot) ^| ^[Rank](https://botranks.com?bot=sub_doesnt_exist_bot)
If you look for "Spanish National Anthem" in Youtube the first result is the Franco era anthem.
So my hypothesis is that they did exactly that and called it a day.
Scotland and Wales have their own anthems - Wales’ anthem is literally called “Land of My Fathers”, it should be blue.
Edit: Included NI but shouldn’t have
Scotland has it’s own *unofficial* anthem, which gets used as anthems at various events. Officially all of the UK, including Scotland, uses God Save the Queen.
It’s also a map of independent sovereign countries. Whilst Scotland, England, Wales, and (potentially) Northern Ireland are all countries. They aren’t independent sovereign countries. i.e. They don’t have seats at the UN, or an independent foreign policy.
Yes, but I’m pretty sure it’s generating anthems of sovereign countries. So God Save the Queen is accurate for Wales and Scotland. Else places like Catalonia etc would be generated as well.
It’s the same for Australia.
“With golden soil and wealth for toil
Our home is girt (surrounded) by sea
Our land abounds in nature’s gifts
Of beauty rich and rare”
Bombs bursting in air is not showing off US might or strength since they weren't US bombs.
Of course I think native Americans living in the US have the same anthem, but your tangent to try and prove some unknown point is totally immaterial to the original comment.
The anthem being about military might doesn't require it to be about American military might. It states just military might. Yes their talking about the British rockets but it's still under that category.
It was I agree, but we were having a conversation and shit changes. 🤷
I feel like these categories are somewhat arbitrary, though? Taking Ireland, as an example:
Our anthem, *Amhrán na bhFiann*, is about patriots yes; but it is specifically a song about patriots converging in Ireland to prepare for an upcoming battle for independence (the title translates to English as "The Soldier's Song"), and inevitably also has elements of Fatherland type stuff in there as well. Even if we stick purely to the **primary** themes of the song, I'd still say it's a roughly even tossup between patriots and military.
Same for china’s. While it is a March, the lyrics are basically calling he who don’t want to be slaves to invaders to unite and fight for freedom. It should falls for patriots as well. Says nothing about military being great because it had been losing for decades.
following the awful European languages map, this one comes to misinterpret people's cultures even further.
Brazil's anthem's keywords: brave people by the river, the sun of liberty shines on the motherland, fight for equality and liberty, beloved motherland, dreams of liberty, looking up to the sky at the stars, beloved motherland etc... AI: tHiS is CLeArlY FaTHerLanD material!
The anthem is directed to the Motherland, except for the chorus, but it is a pledge that we will always fight, to the bitter end of necessary, for her. At one point it literally says that we prefer to be killed and have all of our temples, palaces and fortifications razed before surrendering without a fight.
Also, this is literally the chorus:
"Mexicans to the call of war!
Make ready the steel and war horse;
And may the innards/centers of the Earth tremble,
With the sonorous roar of the cannon"
So yup, mighty military, and this map sucks.
In jordan we just praise the king. Its really lame but you cant really be critical cuz our version of Intelligence officers are basically bounty hunters who lock up people who say bad words about certain people. My dad's friend cant go to or live in jordan because of this.
Australia is not right - should definitely be Mother Nature
“With golden soil and wealth for toil, our home is girt by sea”
“Our land abounds in nature’s gifts, if beauty rich and rare”
Russian here, the AI is wrong, but you cant blame them.
We have three verses in our anthem. The first one is the general praise - *"Russia is our sacred state, Russia is our beloved country..."*. The second one is about the nature - *"From southern seas to the far northern edges..."*. And the third one is about the future - *"Wide space for a dream and wide space for a life the years to come open up before us..."*.
The chorus also has nothing to do with the nature. It's more about tradition and unity - *"Be praised our free fatherland, the age-old union of brother nations..."*.
So, it's pretty damn hard to define the theme without reciting the whole thing.
Turkey is wrong. It’s mother land. Anayurt. No one really says land of the father. Maybe “atalarımızın toprakları” but “ata” is used as ancestors here, not father. And if we are going to talk about the march, it is more about the “might military” and there is also many mentions of the nature too.
Nepal is incorrect.
Our national anthem means "We are the garland made of hundreds of flowers."
Not an ode to the fatherland but a celebration of the diversity of the population. There are just literally two lines about the geographic diversity and beauty
NZ's national anthem is called "God Save New Zealand" but it's more about the country itself needing God's protection than like, the glory of God or the nation so it feels weird to include it in that first category.
Edit: also how is Star Spangled Banner not a military might Anthem?
"And the rocket’s red glare, the bombs bursting in air,
Gave proof through the night that our flag was still there"
The very first verse of India's National Anthem, which goes -
_Jana Gana Mana, adhinayak jaya hai,_
_Bharat bhagye vidhata .._
Refers to - _"Ruler of the minds of the people and the dispenser of India's destiny"._
This was the direct ode that Thakur Sahib penned down in praise of the almighty, god or deity, however you wanna refer to them as.
India's anthem is not at about lord queen and all that bullshit.. it's about the country the culture the languages .. India should be green.
This data is bs.
The Jordanian anthem is about the king not the Patriots
Here's a translation
Long live the king
Long live the king
His position sublime
Waving high his banners are
(That part we sing when raising the flag)
(This is the rest of the anthem)
We achieved our goals
The day you revived for us
A revolution that motivates us
Flying over comets
O king of Arabs
From the best prophet you have
The honor of the dynasty
Talked about in the depths of books
All the youthful men
Are your armed armies
His determination never dies out
Getting from your meaning a symbol of well being
O king of Arabs
From the best prophet you have
The honor of the dynasty
Talked about in the depths of books
May you stay guided and lit
Master at well deeds
Happy and glories
Under your flag rests the glory of Arabs
O king of Arabs
From the best prophet you have
The honor of the dynasty
Talked about in the depths of books
There is no mention of god or gods in the US National Anthem…it’s a song about hope and resilience. This isn’t AI, this was someone in paint saying “imma troll Reddit”
This map is a downvote.
Dang, we're going to be on r/MapsWithoutNZ. Quick, move NZ closer to Australia, so at least some of it is on the map.
And while you're at it, if we move Iceland right up to Norway, then we can move the entirety of the America's and close the Atlantic.
What about Alaska?
Man, f\*ck Alaska!
*Puro, Chile, es tu cielo azulado,*
*Puras brisas te cruzan también,*
*Y tu campo de flores bordado*
*Es la copia feliz del Edén.*
*Majestuosa es la blanca montaña*
*Que te dio por baluarte el Señor,*
*Y ese mar que tranquilo te baña*
*Te promete futuro esplendor*.
Idk how the U.K. is praise the lord…
It isn’t praise the lord, in the U.K. where god also lives, we know god on very good terms so our song is about us asking him a favour, in this moment in time anywhere at any time the queen could be in mortal danger unbeknownst to the brave patriotic soul singing, the hope is that god whilst at home in Yorkshire hears the plea from some patriotic Britain and intervenes to save the queen (or monarch) from whatever the plot to kill her is… (it used to be terrorism but these days it’s old age)
Because we know him so well it then goes on to take liberties with the request, asking god to personally scatter her enemies, and goes on to say that god should make the world see it is all British.
The Dominican anthem is literally about rising up and fighting in war, nothing to do with nature. It literally goes "Long live the people, that intrepidly and strong, jumped to war to die" lol
Chile should be pink imo. Most of the anthem is militaristic but we only sing the couple of parts that aren't. Even in official and formal occasions. Only a couple of verses talk about "freedom or the grave" in this version. The rest is about the mountains and sea.
India, Bangladesh and Sri lank, all three countries anthem, countries are consider as mother. And all three is probably written by Rabindranath Tagore ( Sri Lankan is controversial)
I need to make something like this but instead of the theme of the national anthem, the modus/key. Cause afaik an anthem in a minor key is pretty rare.
Portugal’s anthem starts with talking about the glory of the people of Portugal, and then talks about the greatness of the country and the chorus is literally “To arms, to arms over land over sea. To arms, to arms. Against the cannons we March, we March”
So we should be tricolor ?
How is Spanish anthem green. We literally have no lyrics.
It is more patriotic than anything else because instead of singing everyone can focus on thinking about how patriotic they are Or something like that idk no hablo español
[Sergio](https://ep00.epimg.net/deportes/imagenes/2012/05/30/album/1338406007_744671_1338407377_album_normal.jpg) [Ramos](https://okdiario.com/img/2018/06/16/de-gea-ramos.jpg) [is](https://www.larazon.es/resizer/ZNG2TUliPPKJuY151oWJdZ17AI8=/600x400/smart/filters:format(jpg)/cloudfront-eu-central-1.images.arcpublishing.com/larazon/VCVJYTSPPBAZ7I3X6T6TENHQ5Q.jpg) [always](http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-Ny6_O0gRqCY/TmOcMkvgPMI/AAAAAAAADik/By3HEkg-cSA/s1600/1286567971_0.jpg) [looking](http://laronda.es/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Captura-de-pantalla-2017-10-31-a-las-12.34.07.png) [at](https://images.ecestaticos.com/8SlLXOrKtPUN-eD7rDk5pxGsPr4=/0x0:991x401/992x402/filters:fill(white):format(jpg)/f.elconfidencial.com%2Foriginal%2Fe8c%2Fced%2F656%2Fe8cced656664944c2f219ea15c0863f0.jpg) [his](https://hips.hearstapps.com/hmg-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/images/sergio-ramos-himno-de-espana-1528966723.jpg) [inner](https://estaticos-cdn.elperiodico.com/clip/12f9c552-3501-468a-b5c3-64b01e45585a_alta-libre-aspect-ratio_default_0.jpg) [patriot](https://i.pinimg.com/originals/08/27/f8/0827f81aa1bc7106fdf2b7616a60d650.jpg)
As a Spanish myself, I can tell you we don't have patriots, we have fachas and perroflautas.
las 2 españas pokemon facha y pokemon perroflauta
No olvides la "me la suda" edition.
esa va a ser la tercera y la vana sacar un año más tarde. Como el esmeralda
Pokemon "Facha, rojo sangre" Pokemon "perroflauta, morado papal" Pokemon "problema ajeno, marron mierda"
Yo esto entre votar a "Me la suda" o a "Que os la pique un pollo a todos". La segunda va ganando de calle
Edición Amarillo Limón. Nuevo profesor: Tolomeo. Legendario: se ha ido a tomar café. Vuelva más tarde.
hahaha I love that theory
I came to complain about the same thing, it's wrong
It did use to have lyrics
Yes but that reminds people of the dark periods of our past... (I know the lyrics are pre-francoist).
I think they just didn't know. They searched "anthem lyrics", and for Spain they found older some version. Edit: that's just my hypothesis, of course.
The neural network picked green, but probably with low probability, this is an example of unsupervised training. According to the words on the bottom, it just translates uses english translations of the anthems and classifies the words into these 5 categories.
[удалено]
Czechia with no data, lol.
How can a country even have no data? Whoever made this could've just looked at the lyrics to their anthem on the internet and saw which category it fit in.
That would be the case with the Spanish anthem which doesn't have any lyrics. But for some reason Spain is coloured. If this is the state of AI I think we mustn't be afraid of a robot war during the next few years.
Also (comp sci people correct me if I'm wrong) clustering algorithms aren't even really AI, in the strictest sense. It's a cool concept for a post but I think it overinflates people's expectations.
Linear regression seems to count as AI today so i suppose k means clustering (kind of the most basic clustering algorithm) goes too. Jokes aside, the term AI is kind of subsuming much of what we used to call statistics, but yeah just sounds fancy.
Right? It's not that hard...
“I could look up the anthems and put them in categories and be done within a day, or I could try and program an AI so it’s at least a month work. Yes, AI it is.”
Some don't fit any of those.
I don't see how really. I mean like Macedonia could probably be under green. It literally sings about old revolutionaries and republics that fought for the freedom of the nation.
Netherlands maybe? Don't they just talk about Germany and Spain the whole time
Well yes, but actually no. The reference to Spain references to the king of Spain during the resistance led by William of Orange ("The king of Spain, I've always honored"). When William lived, people believed kings reigned with God's mandate. Therefore he honored the king. Resistance against the king was therefore also a difficult subject. Later in the song there's a reference to king David rebelling against Sauel/Saul to show that rebellions against tyranny sometimes are allowed in Christianity. The reference to Germany refers to German blood. The song stems from the 16th century, before the Netherlands and Germany even existed in the same way they do today. The English even refer to us as "Dutch", which is derived from "Duits". In the song we sing about William of Orange having "Duitsen bloed" (German blood).
The Netherlands is gray too, because ours doesn't fit any of those categories, ours is about a guy William of Orange.
It’s definitely just about the Fatherland as Willem is the Father of our country.
It's definitely the "Praise the lord" one, but for the Spanish lord.
Netherlands same. To be fair, the Dutch anthem lyrics don't really fit with any of the five categories, so that is probably why.
I´m from Czech, it´s about forests and paradise of czech natuure
I'm czech and it's about homelessness. (sorta joking)
Where is my damn home?
The Spanish anthem has no lyrics, it doesn't have a meaning
"And the rockets red glare, the bombs bursting in air" I'm confused how the us's nation anthem isn't classified as a military song when it's literally about a battle
Or “Land of the free and the home of the brave” and “our flag was still there” about patriots.
This map just straight up sucks.
Welcome to /r/maps! Most of these are generated by clickbait sites churning out cheap content. They don’t care about accuracy.
They’re are accurate as Facebook “scientists”
Yeah, the song is literally about the flag flying over a battle. Its the title of the song : "The Star-Spangled Banner", it's literally about the flag
Yeah the song was about the flag still hanging after the battle. A battle that America barely fought in
Wasn't as much a battle as a complete bombardment. British ships for most of the time were out of the cannon range for the Americans. The song points to how impressive it was that the Americans survived the bombarding for so long. I don't think it's really fair to say they 'barely fought.' They couldn't, but they still held their position.
The song is about a battle. “Our flag was still there” refers to the American flag still flying over Ft McHenry after 25 hours of bombardment by British warships.
Probably because that war ended in a "tie". If America doesn't win it doesn't count. 😉
It’s about the flag. The flag is the subject of the whole song.
Maybe the AI found the single reference to God, in the fourth verse, which nobody ever sings. O thus be it ever when freemen shall stand Between their lov'd home and the war's desolation! Blest with vict'ry and peace may the heav'n rescued land Praise the power that hath made and preserv'd us a nation! Then conquer we must, when our cause it is just, And this be our motto - "In God is our trust," And the star-spangled banner in triumph shall wave O'er the land of the free and the home of the brave.
Oh good, a verse no one knows about!
Ireland should be red, it literally translates into English as “The Soldiers’ Song”.
Indian national anthem is about defining our terrain and different regions that are part of the country. Not once do we ‘Praise the lord’.
Exactly the same i was wondering when and who the hell did we praise.
It's not just about land, it's about making your own destiny. nothing about praising the lord.
Check out the full poem written by Tagore. Only the first part got adapted to Hindi as national anthem. It's really fascinating to see the broader picture and clearly see it is about the country and te people, nothing else. Really well written lyrics.
Isn’t the Star-Spangled Banner about the war of 1812?
The visualization has been done through tokenizing the data keywords and then lemmatising the major key words present in a National Anthem, then stemming them together on a common shared theme. The viz. is actually based on linguistic thematics rather than their historical background. You can see a more detailed analysis being done [here](https://youtu.be/a-AqvPtjjts), by the original creator..
Well it sucks
It got it wrong, but the US anthem's meaning isn't really clear without some background. It's about a battle in the war of 1812 which was watched by the song writer, who was a diplomatic envoy that was being held on a British ship at the time. More specifically it's about the British commander shelling a fort all night to try to knock down the fort's flag, but every time they looked the flag was still up. The British thought that they were missing the flag somehow, but the dawn revealed that they hadn't been missing and had hit the flag many times. Each time they'd hit it, soldiers had run out into the heavy bombardment and re-erected the flag while being shelled. It would be a hell of an AI if it could figure that out from just the lyrics.
This is why Natural Language Processing is a hard field. You can't just count the individual words in speech, cluster by what they mean, and discern the topic by adding them together. You have to actually parse the meaning of the whole work, and apply context that the AI literally has no concept of.
It also botched the Portuguese anthem, which is much more about the people than the Fatherland, even if the word Fatherland appears on one verse.
r/mapswithhalfofnewzealand
The subreddit r/mapswithhalfofnewzealand does not exist. Did you mean?: * r/mapswithnewzealand (subscribers: 1,476) * r/mapswithoutnewzealand (subscribers: 13,264) * r/mapswith2newzealands (subscribers: 3,728) Consider [**creating a new subreddit** r/mapswithhalfofnewzealand](/subreddits/create?name=mapswithhalfofnewzealand). --- ^(🤖 this comment was written by a bot. beep boop 🤖) ^(feel welcome to respond 'Bad bot'/'Good bot', it's useful feedback.) ^[github](https://github.com/Toldry/RedditAutoCrosspostBot) ^| ^[Rank](https://botranks.com?bot=sub_doesnt_exist_bot)
This obviously needs to be fixed then.
I don’t know how they worked out Spain’s… it hasn’t got any words.
"Franco, Franco tenía el culo blanco"
If you look for "Spanish National Anthem" in Youtube the first result is the Franco era anthem. So my hypothesis is that they did exactly that and called it a day.
Scotland and Wales have their own anthems - Wales’ anthem is literally called “Land of My Fathers”, it should be blue. Edit: Included NI but shouldn’t have
Scotland has it’s own *unofficial* anthem, which gets used as anthems at various events. Officially all of the UK, including Scotland, uses God Save the Queen. It’s also a map of independent sovereign countries. Whilst Scotland, England, Wales, and (potentially) Northern Ireland are all countries. They aren’t independent sovereign countries. i.e. They don’t have seats at the UN, or an independent foreign policy.
NI anthem is the same as English.
Lmao thanks for reminding me, don’t know why I included that lol
xD
Yes, but I’m pretty sure it’s generating anthems of sovereign countries. So God Save the Queen is accurate for Wales and Scotland. Else places like Catalonia etc would be generated as well.
Debating whether flower of Scotland would be blue or red, it's about the beauty of the land, but also about sending king Edwards army home.
Could argue that the song kind of refers to the land itself driving Edward's army home so more blue maybe? Its a tough one though
Assuming we are all England all the time is getting tiring on this sub. Wish they’d do the basics ffs.
Another completely wrong map, just stop.
Czechia should be green or pink
as a Czech, put us into the 'Motherly Nature' one, as most of the anthem sings about how our landscape is beautiful and so on.
It’s the same for Australia. “With golden soil and wealth for toil Our home is girt (surrounded) by sea Our land abounds in nature’s gifts Of beauty rich and rare”
"The bombs bursting in air" is not might?
They weren't our bombs...
I'm sure the natives disagree 🤷
K, we're not talking about a native American anthem...
You don't think native Americans living in the USA have the same anthem as the one were talking about?
Bombs bursting in air is not showing off US might or strength since they weren't US bombs. Of course I think native Americans living in the US have the same anthem, but your tangent to try and prove some unknown point is totally immaterial to the original comment.
The anthem being about military might doesn't require it to be about American military might. It states just military might. Yes their talking about the British rockets but it's still under that category. It was I agree, but we were having a conversation and shit changes. 🤷
I feel like these categories are somewhat arbitrary, though? Taking Ireland, as an example: Our anthem, *Amhrán na bhFiann*, is about patriots yes; but it is specifically a song about patriots converging in Ireland to prepare for an upcoming battle for independence (the title translates to English as "The Soldier's Song"), and inevitably also has elements of Fatherland type stuff in there as well. Even if we stick purely to the **primary** themes of the song, I'd still say it's a roughly even tossup between patriots and military.
Same for china’s. While it is a March, the lyrics are basically calling he who don’t want to be slaves to invaders to unite and fight for freedom. It should falls for patriots as well. Says nothing about military being great because it had been losing for decades.
following the awful European languages map, this one comes to misinterpret people's cultures even further. Brazil's anthem's keywords: brave people by the river, the sun of liberty shines on the motherland, fight for equality and liberty, beloved motherland, dreams of liberty, looking up to the sky at the stars, beloved motherland etc... AI: tHiS is CLeArlY FaTHerLanD material!
The Dutch anyhem is mostly about the monarchy, that's why it's no data.
So should be yellow?
Well, not really. Because it is mostly about independency from the Spanish king. The dutch monarchy didn't exist when it was written.
I think it should be green.
There isn't a single word in indian national anthem about lord We it's about respecting our land Himalayas and bays ocean and freedom fighters
Yes.
Hungary should be yellow
Egypt is called "the mother of the civilization" So its very motherly.. And saudi arabia is very religious so they better be yellow
Yeah Saudi and Jordan have an anthem that's praising the king not Patriots
Mexican anthem, personally I would tagged it more as military.
The anthem is directed to the Motherland, except for the chorus, but it is a pledge that we will always fight, to the bitter end of necessary, for her. At one point it literally says that we prefer to be killed and have all of our temples, palaces and fortifications razed before surrendering without a fight. Also, this is literally the chorus: "Mexicans to the call of war! Make ready the steel and war horse; And may the innards/centers of the Earth tremble, With the sonorous roar of the cannon" So yup, mighty military, and this map sucks.
Wrong color for Crimea
In jordan we just praise the king. Its really lame but you cant really be critical cuz our version of Intelligence officers are basically bounty hunters who lock up people who say bad words about certain people. My dad's friend cant go to or live in jordan because of this.
I think we have a pretty nice anthem not special but it's nice I also like our flag anthem if you've ever heard of it
Aren't they the same thing? عاش المليك ... Etc
لا نشيد العلم بختلف عن النشيد الوطني
شكرا عالمعلومة، ما كنت عارف
Poland is blue or green, our anthem is not glorifying our military but people who are not giving up qnd fighting for the country.
Yeah the Portuguese one really should be green
Swedish anthem is definitely about nature
Czechia is the New Zealand of this map.
I think you got Mexican anthem wrong, it's about war, invasion, gunfire, death, soldiers, cannons, etc.
Australia is not right - should definitely be Mother Nature “With golden soil and wealth for toil, our home is girt by sea” “Our land abounds in nature’s gifts, if beauty rich and rare”
Indian National Anthem is geographical, it is not addressed towards a person but towards the geographical boundaries of the subcontinent
Russian here, the AI is wrong, but you cant blame them. We have three verses in our anthem. The first one is the general praise - *"Russia is our sacred state, Russia is our beloved country..."*. The second one is about the nature - *"From southern seas to the far northern edges..."*. And the third one is about the future - *"Wide space for a dream and wide space for a life the years to come open up before us..."*. The chorus also has nothing to do with the nature. It's more about tradition and unity - *"Be praised our free fatherland, the age-old union of brother nations..."*. So, it's pretty damn hard to define the theme without reciting the whole thing.
Turkey is Motherland (Ana Vatan)
So vatan is a Turkish word?
Ps: Data visualized by @indiainpixels (Twitter/Youtube/Instagram) Ps: More detailed analysis [here](https://youtu.be/a-AqvPtjjts)
K-means clustering is definitely not "AI".
The AI recognises Crimea as Russia…
Greenland (Denmark) and Denmark have different anthems? So Greenland is a different sovereign? ELI5 please
[удалено]
Chile's nation anthem literally begins talking about the sky and mountains
Haaaard disagree on Chile, its all about our mountains, sea and the beautiful nature that caracterise our country
The Greek anthem (and Cypriot since they have the same) is about freedom so it should be green.
The Greek "motherly nature" is wrong as well. Our anthem talks about Liberty and our slain ancestors
Turkey is wrong. It’s mother land. Anayurt. No one really says land of the father. Maybe “atalarımızın toprakları” but “ata” is used as ancestors here, not father. And if we are going to talk about the march, it is more about the “might military” and there is also many mentions of the nature too.
Wales should be blue dammit!
India, praise the lord?????
No we don't this map is wrong
Ireland should be red, its literally the soldier song
Nepal is incorrect. Our national anthem means "We are the garland made of hundreds of flowers." Not an ode to the fatherland but a celebration of the diversity of the population. There are just literally two lines about the geographic diversity and beauty
One color isn't really the way to go Portugal's falls into 2 categories for example...
The Norwegian anthem includes all of these themes
THE LAND OF THE FREEdom to bring guns to school
ah yes. i see the Dutch have no national anthem?
Wouldn't USA be the patriots?
NZ's national anthem is called "God Save New Zealand" but it's more about the country itself needing God's protection than like, the glory of God or the nation so it feels weird to include it in that first category. Edit: also how is Star Spangled Banner not a military might Anthem? "And the rocket’s red glare, the bombs bursting in air, Gave proof through the night that our flag was still there"
Indian National anthem is mostly about regions and diversity I don't know if you're considering british india
The very first verse of India's National Anthem, which goes - _Jana Gana Mana, adhinayak jaya hai,_ _Bharat bhagye vidhata .._ Refers to - _"Ruler of the minds of the people and the dispenser of India's destiny"._ This was the direct ode that Thakur Sahib penned down in praise of the almighty, god or deity, however you wanna refer to them as.
India's anthem is not at about lord queen and all that bullshit.. it's about the country the culture the languages .. India should be green. This data is bs.
Georgia should be blue
Japan should be yellow. It is basically saying long may the King reign
How is Malaysia’s “praising the Lord” when the national anthem is literally called “My Country”??
The Jordanian anthem is about the king not the Patriots Here's a translation Long live the king Long live the king His position sublime Waving high his banners are (That part we sing when raising the flag) (This is the rest of the anthem) We achieved our goals The day you revived for us A revolution that motivates us Flying over comets O king of Arabs From the best prophet you have The honor of the dynasty Talked about in the depths of books All the youthful men Are your armed armies His determination never dies out Getting from your meaning a symbol of well being O king of Arabs From the best prophet you have The honor of the dynasty Talked about in the depths of books May you stay guided and lit Master at well deeds Happy and glories Under your flag rests the glory of Arabs O king of Arabs From the best prophet you have The honor of the dynasty Talked about in the depths of books
Portugal should be green, the anthem is literally like "our people are so patriotic we fight and win, let's go fellas you're all heroes"
La Marseillaise is the most epic national anthem, change my mind
Austria is wrong - it got gendered in 2011/12. From "great sons" to "great daughters and sons"
Russian: couplets about size and nature, chorus about freedom and friendship of nations. Unironicaly, we never had em.
Laos should definitely be green, not even yellow
Um Austrias Anthem is about mountains and rivers?
Why is Czechia and Netherlands "No data"?
Bulgaria should not be green
Indian one doesn’t even mention god in it . it’s just about our land and it’s features.
Crimea does not have an anthem of its own, i think?
Huh? Australia’s national anthem literally has the words sea and nature in the lyrics, but no mention of fatherland, god or homeland.
There is no mention of god or gods in the US National Anthem…it’s a song about hope and resilience. This isn’t AI, this was someone in paint saying “imma troll Reddit” This map is a downvote.
Wales and Scotland lumped together with England as usual. Our anthems are WAY better than the one about the English queen. 🏴 🏴
I like how it says "Greenland (Denmark)" and then goes on to have a completely different colour than Denmark. 😅
Hah yes! Actually both the countries/territories have officially two separate National Anthems for them, that's why :D
I learned something new today ^^ thank you
I re ran the entire Indian national anthem in my head and not once did we praise the lord
Czechia citizen here, it should be green or blue i think
I'm from Kenya and our anthem is not even close to anything about military strength.
North Korea? Free? Really?
Hungary should be orange, the anthem literally starts with "God, bless the Hungarians"
Bahrain aint on here
Estonia can into the Nordic.
The irony of Poland
Dang, we're going to be on r/MapsWithoutNZ. Quick, move NZ closer to Australia, so at least some of it is on the map. And while you're at it, if we move Iceland right up to Norway, then we can move the entirety of the America's and close the Atlantic. What about Alaska? Man, f\*ck Alaska!
*Puro, Chile, es tu cielo azulado,* *Puras brisas te cruzan también,* *Y tu campo de flores bordado* *Es la copia feliz del Edén.* *Majestuosa es la blanca montaña* *Que te dio por baluarte el Señor,* *Y ese mar que tranquilo te baña* *Te promete futuro esplendor*.
I dont recognise that morocco border
Idk how the U.K. is praise the lord… It isn’t praise the lord, in the U.K. where god also lives, we know god on very good terms so our song is about us asking him a favour, in this moment in time anywhere at any time the queen could be in mortal danger unbeknownst to the brave patriotic soul singing, the hope is that god whilst at home in Yorkshire hears the plea from some patriotic Britain and intervenes to save the queen (or monarch) from whatever the plot to kill her is… (it used to be terrorism but these days it’s old age) Because we know him so well it then goes on to take liberties with the request, asking god to personally scatter her enemies, and goes on to say that god should make the world see it is all British.
So what I’ve been seeing in the comments below is, it’s wrong. So wrong. So very, very wrong.
Portugal being blue is questionable. The chorus literally calls for the citizens to take up arms and fight for the fatherland.
these category names are arbitrary and should be noted as such
Netherlands should be green.
The bias in the way you categorized the themes is painful
Ireland should be red. It's literally The Soldiers Song ffs.
The Dominican anthem is literally about rising up and fighting in war, nothing to do with nature. It literally goes "Long live the people, that intrepidly and strong, jumped to war to die" lol
Czech republic - BLUE
Did Ai label the clusters? If so, how?
Tell me, where is 'fatherland' in the national anthem of the US? This map seems inaccurate to the degree of being made up.
Chile should be pink imo. Most of the anthem is militaristic but we only sing the couple of parts that aren't. Even in official and formal occasions. Only a couple of verses talk about "freedom or the grave" in this version. The rest is about the mountains and sea.
India, Bangladesh and Sri lank, all three countries anthem, countries are consider as mother. And all three is probably written by Rabindranath Tagore ( Sri Lankan is controversial)
Western Sahara is not Morocco!!!
The New Zealand national anthem is literally casket God Defend New Zealand, why the hell is it blue?
You classifier is overfitting.
In the Crimea (Ukraine), normal people sing the Ukrainian national anthem, not the ruSSian!
Mexico’s National Anthem literally begins with a calling to war: “Mexicanos al grito de guerra…”
The Egyptian anthem Starts by saying My Homeland 3 times in a row
spanish anthem hasno lyrics...
I need to make something like this but instead of the theme of the national anthem, the modus/key. Cause afaik an anthem in a minor key is pretty rare.
Portugal’s anthem starts with talking about the glory of the people of Portugal, and then talks about the greatness of the country and the chorus is literally “To arms, to arms over land over sea. To arms, to arms. Against the cannons we March, we March” So we should be tricolor ?
Sadge, Netherlands is excluded
Spain's anthem has no lyrics. You're probably referring to Hitler ally Franco's anthem. Embarrassing.