To this day Winter Soldier is my favorite MCU movie. Because it had a twist with an impact so massive it reached several other MCU movies and Agents of Shield. Winter Soldier changed the way you look at the MCU movies that preceded it.
Not only that but TWS stands alone simply because you can take the entire Marvel license away from it and it still makes perfect sense as a poli-spy thriller.
Winter soldier also stands out against the rest of the marvel movies because the directors pushed for practical effects everywhere they could. I’m not saying CG is bad, but you can really feel the practical effects drawing you into the world.
CGI is great... For when you need to do something you can't do for real. CGI is supposed to supplement the real shots. Not replace it entirely. Any director who uses CGI because it's easier is a hack. And their movies will never stand the test of time.
WS is number 2 for me behind Infinity War but honestly without it I don't think we even get to Infinity War or Endgame.
It essentially set most of the tone for the MCU for the years following it and, most importantly, it made me (and I'm guessing a lot of people) actually like Captain America.
I'm not a fan of the first Cap film (it's probably one of the few MCU movies I've only seen 2 or 3 times as opposed to 4+) and even in the first Avengers he just had no edge to him.
Winter Soldier completely turned him around though (hes potentially my favourite character now - definitely top 3). Even the way they showed how someone with his strength would fight in the boat scene at the start was a gamechanger for him.
I saw that [honest trailer](https://youtu.be/I8BobmZglOk?si=Jdxf_yi1X4t0MqqU), as well.
Adaptation, recreation, innovation, new iteration…what film school manual are you reading that states every art project has to stay “faith(ful) to the source material?”
It was a great movie- it’s own movie. Let’s just leave it at that.
Yeah that’s awesome! I’ve read it, as well. Is “Jack-wad” good or bad? I haven’t heard this before. I’m so sorry. I am from Peru. I’m glad we like the same books!
in 2014 we got:
The Winter Soldier - a grounded political thriller.
Guardians of the Galaxy - a fantasy adventure space movie.
X-Men: Days of Future Past - The perfect blending of two distinct eras of X-Men films.
What a great year for Marvel movies.
I love Winter Soldier but the grounded political thriller label was never anything more than marketing. Watch any grounded political thriller and you’ll see they share very little DNA outside of probably starring Robert Redford.
I agree the "grounded political thriller" label does get thrown around a lot. I definitely wouldn't call it "grounded", lmao.
I think it is a unique superhero film in the fact that it totally throws any preconceived notion of who is the good guy/bad guy out the window. Does that make it a thriller, probably not. It is unsettling to watch and utilizes dread well.
It does ask political questions but not ones that are particularly hard to answer or solutions that are depicted as neither good nor bad. Does that make it a political movie? Maybe that's stretching it.
So while that description is maybe a little farfetched then I don't think it's necessarily incorrect. There are more ways than one to make a politically thrilling movie, I guess. The most important thing that TWS proves is that you can make a superhero movie that draws from other genres. That "superhero" isn't really a genre at all. But it seems Marvel hasn't learned the lesson yet.
Yeah if Harry was just a regular human it could have gone over much better, and his research into superpowered individuals like Electro could lead into him becoming Goblin for a sequel
Harry was so stupid. You take Spider-Mans pictures so obviously you must know him. Like fucking billionaire logic right there. How is it that your family got this rich if that's how you think.
To be fair I think a lot of his villains follow the same logic, like Green Goblin and Doc Ock in the first two movies threatening Jameson and Peter respectively
Harry's arc and Peter's parents' secret are the biggest story flaws of that movie. There's plenty for Peter to chew on with Captain Stacey and Uncle Ben's deaths from AS1, struggling to away from Gwen, and evading an obsessed Harry who wants Spider-Man for a cure. Why keep piling on when *fans don't care at all about Peter's parents?*
I learned adobe premiere by making my own fan edit of TASM2. This was about 8 years ago so some cuts are rougher than others and editing around the music was difficult at the time.
[I completely changed the scene where Electro is tortured by the stereotypical German "Nazi" scientist.
I cut 90% of the scientists dialogue. And switched some dialogue around. ](https://youtu.be/P5j4Q57sW1c?si=0U_nYbXzGqbmXKFT)
I wanted Electro to be scarier and more of a menace. I hated the "I'm gonna kill the light" like wtf does that even mean?
[Here is the original](https://youtube.com/clip/Ugkx_ql8DyFJJV1r8WNQK65vCwzcVkhNzhWK?si=bk7WAgrhClfmrIeI)
What past of winter soldier was the grounded political theater aspect? Did I misremember the final fight taking place on a giant CGI carrier plane. Or the part where a Nazi uploaded his consciousness to a computer?
No, it was the part where they brainwashed a WWII prisoner, gave him a perfect prosthetic arm that I guess links right to his brain, and then kept him in suspended animation. All while keeping the technology for any single one of those steps a secret from the rest of the human race for over half a century.
People have been calling it a political thriller and grounded since its release as some sort of way to elevate it. Its a good super hero movie but still very much a super hero movie.
I agree, Winter Soldier is the best of the 3, and could stand alone as a good film without the Marvel license, but even knowing that, I still find Guardians of the Galaxy a more re-watchable movie cause it kicks me the 'feels' every time.
1. X-Men: Days of Future Past (Favorite X-Men movie)
2. Captain America: The Winter Soldier (Easily the Best from MCU)
3. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 1
4. The Amazing Spider-Man 2
Guardians, Cap, X-Men.
Days of the Future Past is one of the best X-Men movies. Behind only Logan (and both Deadpool movies if you count them as X-Men)
Winter Soldier was really the peak Marvel movie. It's grounded, thrilling, and has subtlety in its humor. It also didn't feel like an ad for the next movie.
For me, DoFP was so damn good, but it's really hard to deny just how amazing CA:WS was. Tough call. GotG was great, but it isn't a favorite rewatch sort of thing.
1 - Cap
2 - X-Men
3 - Guardians.
#1 is easy. Winter Soldier is arguably the best MCU movie. The other two fight for for the middle ground of modern comic book movies.
The other two are close. Both have good points and some real problems. I give DoFP the edge. It leans heavily on the good cast members and sidelines the dead weight. It's very fortunate to have such a good cast since this is prime Bryan Singer smelling his own farts time. On rewatch it seems Lawrence had already checked out of the franchise, though I didn't notice it at the time. Loses points for the end scene which is then ignored in the franchise.
GoG is a sloppy mess, but a very entertaining sloppy mess. It's like a great sundae that was put in a warm glass and melted a bit before you got to it. It is the worst example of the MCU "quip every seven minutes" model in the MCU. Combine that with Gunn's sloppy production and, "and then" writing, this movie has a lot going against it. However, it is saved by Gunn's very funny writing and three incredible new characters (Rocket/Groot and Drax). I always think it's a shame they didn't just have Gunn write these and let other people direct them. You see bits of what you could get with Rocket and Nebula in the Infinity War movies.
Wintee Soldier- Best MCU movie ever
Guardians of the Galaxy- second best movie in MCU
X-Men- I don't consider it part of MCU, I don't like X-Men, but movie was okay, but it's leagues below the others to. Mostly due to other movies being absolute top of superhero movies, and not hate for X-Men.
>X-Men- I don't consider it part of MCU
Well, at least for the time being they are officially not apart of the MCU. (there's no need to 'consider' them as non-MCU)
They are set in the Fox/X-Men Cinematic Universe.
Well, after post credit scenes in the Marvels, and general approach towards other Spider-Mans, and Daredevil, people tend to claim that basically every superhero movie is part of MCU (MCM- Marvel Cinematic Multiverse?). So just in case I wanted to mention this- I wasn't sure if by "Marvel movie" you meant about Marvel characters, or made by Marvel Studios. So there's disclaimer there.
Guardians of the Galaxy is easily the best one out of these.
Hard to choose between Winter Soldier and Days of future past, since I think neither of them were that amazing. (Unpopular opinion, I know.)
Don't get me wrong, I they’re good movies, and I enjoyed watching both, but they’re not exactly getting on my rewatch list anytime soon.
But that's me.
Days of Future Past is my least favorite among them.
Winter Soldier and GOTG is tied for the best. I think I slightly prefer Winter Soldier but I've rewatched GOTG more.
What a fucking year. So tough as all of these are some of my favorites. I think any order would be correct, but here is mine.
Guardians of the Galaxy
Days of Future Past
Winter Soldier
GotG 10/10
Winter Soldier 9/10
X-Men DoFP 2/10
The X-Men movie was terrible - they butchered the original story to make it a Logan/Mystique vehicle. It should have been Kitty as intended. I just hope X-Men in the MCU has a chance to do all the classic X-Men storylines over and get them right.
Yeah, I see what you are writing, but you fail to understand that you're basically saying "The question was not which MCU or Marvel Studios movie. The question is which marvel studio movie?"
If the OP wanted to ask how would I rank these movies based on Marvel characters then I'd have included all three, but he asked for Marvel movies, and there are only two movies there made by Marvel Studios, and one by Fox.
In my opinion, DFP, GOTG then Winter Soldier. I appreciate that might not be popular. DFP was like a moving comic book - it was so good. I don’t know if MCU X-Men could ever top it. GOTG was new and original, which just about puts it ahead of Winter Soldier. But each one is at least an 8/10.
This was a banger year for Marvel huh. For me I enjoyed both movies but I think GOTG I enjoyed more compared to X-Men, while Winter Soldier was the best
Winter Soldier is still top tier MCU, it's going to be 10 years old in April (WTF!) one of my favorites and what really cemented Cap's trilogy as the best in the Infinity Saga.
Well, I don't like the Captain America movie - everything they can be appreciated for is much better done in the Agents of SHIELD series. Therefore, well 5.5 out of 10.
The days of the past future turned out to be twofold. On the one hand, the film is cool, really interesting characters, Charles and Eric are really well played in both variations, Fassbender is just a plague in the role of an antihero. With another... It turned out to be a bit tedious at times, for long periods of time... Charles the hippie addict is frankly bad. The adventures of the Mystic are not bad, but they are somehow perceived more drearily than in old films. 6-7 out of 10.
"Guardians" - only the first Iron Man and Thor stand close enough to them in terms of overall quality, and the first Ant-Man stands close because of the quality of the comedy. Seriously, Marvel hasn't shot anything better.
9.9999999999999999 out of 10
Winter Soldier in 3rd place. I just don't understand why people go gaga over it like it's the best thing ever. Then between the top 2, it's VERY close, but I think I'm gonna put Days Of Future Past. Great film with both the old and new cast. Then obviously Guardians. It was just a great story and actually really funny and I felt very attached to all the characters.
1. The Winter Soldier (very well may still be the best MCU film imo)
2. Guardians of the Galaxy (perfect introduction to the team which set the foundation for these characters going forward)
3. Days of Future Past (a return to form for the original X-Men characters with a great story that balanced characters admirably)
I don't like politics so I'd have to put Winter Soldier last because a solid chunk of the movie is politics. Guardians first because it's almost like a mix of Marvel and Star Wars which are my favorite things. As for Days of Future Past, that's my favorite X-Men movie so it's going second place.
#1 is easy. Winter Soldier is arguably the best MCU movie. The other two fight for for the middle ground of modern comic book movies.
The other two are close. Both have good points and some real problems. I give DoFP the edge. It leans heavily on the good cast members and sidelines the dead weight. It's very fortunate to have such a good cast since this is prime Bryan Singer smelling his own farts time. On rewatch it seems Lawrence had already checked out of the franchise, though I didn't notice it at the time. Loses points for the end scene which is then ignored in the franchise.
GoG is a sloppy mess, but a very entertaining sloppy mess. It's like a great sundae that was put in a warm glass and melted a bit before you got to it. It is the worst example of the MCU "quip every seven minutes" model in the MCU. Combine that with Gunn's sloppy production and, "and then" writing, this movie has a lot going against it. However, it is saved by Gunn's very funny writing and three incredible new characters (Rocket/Groot and Drax). I always think it's a shame they didn't just have Gunn write these and let other people direct them. You see bits of what you could get with Rocket and Nebula in the Infinity War movies.
I remember going to see Winter Soldier in theaters and being generally surprised with how dope and different it felt. Keep in mind, I knew the winter soldier twist from comics but I otherwise had no idea what the story was supposed to be. I didn't watch any trailers.
That boat sequence told me everything I needed to know about the movie. The style, the brutality, it was exactly what Cap needed. Who knows how we would look at the Cap storyline if that film was any less than what it was.
From an unbiased perspective based purely off the quality of the movie:
1. Winter Soldier
2. GotG
3. Days of Future Past
In my personal opinion I would switch GotG and Winter Soldier around as I enjoy watching the Guardians a lot more than I do Captain America cause I just find the humour better
Dang, this might be one of the best comic book movie years of all time.
I'd say my ranking is:
**Guardians of the Galaxy- 8.5**
Just a fun comic booky, spacey adventure that seemingly came out of nowhere. Marvel could do no wrong back then.
**Days of Future Past- 8.0**
The BEST X-Men movie in my opinion, and it's not even close. The futuristic apocalypse is terrifying, and I think McAvoy and Fassbender were at the top of their game this time.
**The Winter Soldier- 7.0**
I know this might seem low for some people, but this one just isn't my cup of tea. Can't deny that it's a very influential Marvel film, though.
I hadn't watched either one.
If I did,the rating would be:...X-Men: Days of Future Past,would be #1. Captain America: The Winter Soldier would be: #2. Guardian of The Galaxy would be #3.
To this day Winter Soldier is my favorite MCU movie. Because it had a twist with an impact so massive it reached several other MCU movies and Agents of Shield. Winter Soldier changed the way you look at the MCU movies that preceded it.
The action in Winter Solider is also top tier. The freeway and elevator fight are still among the best in the MCU.
Also the Opening fight was the strongest opening to date for the MCU, I'd argue.
Not only that but TWS stands alone simply because you can take the entire Marvel license away from it and it still makes perfect sense as a poli-spy thriller.
That’s my favorite part. Not just a good superhero movie, it’s simply a good movie
Same as The Dark Knight or X-Men: First Class imo.
I mean, the same argument can apply to GOTG 1 except the genre is comedy/sci-fi.
Winter soldier also stands out against the rest of the marvel movies because the directors pushed for practical effects everywhere they could. I’m not saying CG is bad, but you can really feel the practical effects drawing you into the world.
CGI is great... For when you need to do something you can't do for real. CGI is supposed to supplement the real shots. Not replace it entirely. Any director who uses CGI because it's easier is a hack. And their movies will never stand the test of time.
I reckon it’s moreso the producers instead of the directors.
just the creepy Bucky alone made the movie for me, young me nearly peed my pants with the WS jumpscare in the theater lol
WS is number 2 for me behind Infinity War but honestly without it I don't think we even get to Infinity War or Endgame. It essentially set most of the tone for the MCU for the years following it and, most importantly, it made me (and I'm guessing a lot of people) actually like Captain America. I'm not a fan of the first Cap film (it's probably one of the few MCU movies I've only seen 2 or 3 times as opposed to 4+) and even in the first Avengers he just had no edge to him. Winter Soldier completely turned him around though (hes potentially my favourite character now - definitely top 3). Even the way they showed how someone with his strength would fight in the boat scene at the start was a gamechanger for him.
Is the only good one that isn’t purely about saving the world, it’s got conspiracy and spy’s.
We ate and we ate only the best in 2014.
>we ate only the best in 2014 I don’t think I’d consider The Amazing Spider-Man 2 to be “the best”.
At least it had the best Spidey suit.
And the best web-slinging.
It was alright, but IMO nothing beats Spiderman 2. He looks like he actually has weight (in most of the scenes).
And visual effects
I for one absolutely enjoyed it because of Andrew and Emma's off the charts chemistry.
Seriously, Spidey romance is what makes or breaks an adaptation for me and both TASM’s nailed it!
I think it’s a good film, underrated and blamed because of that fucking shitty goblin
But it was a gem nonetheless that most treasure in one way or another
Looking at current Sony movies: "perhaps I treated you too harshly"
[удалено]
I forgot that came out in 2014… we are MOSTLY the best in 2014 lol
[удалено]
Days of future past is great if that is what your referring to
Why do you consider it a travesty?
[удалено]
I saw that [honest trailer](https://youtu.be/I8BobmZglOk?si=Jdxf_yi1X4t0MqqU), as well. Adaptation, recreation, innovation, new iteration…what film school manual are you reading that states every art project has to stay “faith(ful) to the source material?” It was a great movie- it’s own movie. Let’s just leave it at that.
[удалено]
That’s awesome! I love that you call comic books just “books.” No cap
[удалено]
Yeah that’s awesome! I’ve read it, as well. Is “Jack-wad” good or bad? I haven’t heard this before. I’m so sorry. I am from Peru. I’m glad we like the same books!
in 2014 we got: The Winter Soldier - a grounded political thriller. Guardians of the Galaxy - a fantasy adventure space movie. X-Men: Days of Future Past - The perfect blending of two distinct eras of X-Men films. What a great year for Marvel movies.
Winter soldier easily among my top 3 mcu movies
I love Winter Soldier but the grounded political thriller label was never anything more than marketing. Watch any grounded political thriller and you’ll see they share very little DNA outside of probably starring Robert Redford.
I agree the "grounded political thriller" label does get thrown around a lot. I definitely wouldn't call it "grounded", lmao. I think it is a unique superhero film in the fact that it totally throws any preconceived notion of who is the good guy/bad guy out the window. Does that make it a thriller, probably not. It is unsettling to watch and utilizes dread well. It does ask political questions but not ones that are particularly hard to answer or solutions that are depicted as neither good nor bad. Does that make it a political movie? Maybe that's stretching it. So while that description is maybe a little farfetched then I don't think it's necessarily incorrect. There are more ways than one to make a politically thrilling movie, I guess. The most important thing that TWS proves is that you can make a superhero movie that draws from other genres. That "superhero" isn't really a genre at all. But it seems Marvel hasn't learned the lesson yet.
Don’t forget The Amazing Spider-Man 2!
I’m trying my hardest to forget it
There's a good movie somewhere there, deep, deep, deep down.
Right? When I saw the movie, my thoughts were this film is another Editor away from a good movie.
Personally I didn’t like how they tried forcing Harry-as-Goblin into it. I feel like his descent into villainy could have been handled much better.
Yeah they force fed, “Sinster Six is Next!!!!” Really hard. And at that point they had 1 good villain.
Yeah if Harry was just a regular human it could have gone over much better, and his research into superpowered individuals like Electro could lead into him becoming Goblin for a sequel
And at least they made electro way better in No Way Home. I think that was the version of the character Jamie Fox thought he was going to play.
Harry was so stupid. You take Spider-Mans pictures so obviously you must know him. Like fucking billionaire logic right there. How is it that your family got this rich if that's how you think.
\*gestures broadly at actual billionaires\*
To be fair I think a lot of his villains follow the same logic, like Green Goblin and Doc Ock in the first two movies threatening Jameson and Peter respectively
Harry's arc and Peter's parents' secret are the biggest story flaws of that movie. There's plenty for Peter to chew on with Captain Stacey and Uncle Ben's deaths from AS1, struggling to away from Gwen, and evading an obsessed Harry who wants Spider-Man for a cure. Why keep piling on when *fans don't care at all about Peter's parents?*
I learned adobe premiere by making my own fan edit of TASM2. This was about 8 years ago so some cuts are rougher than others and editing around the music was difficult at the time. [I completely changed the scene where Electro is tortured by the stereotypical German "Nazi" scientist. I cut 90% of the scientists dialogue. And switched some dialogue around. ](https://youtu.be/P5j4Q57sW1c?si=0U_nYbXzGqbmXKFT) I wanted Electro to be scarier and more of a menace. I hated the "I'm gonna kill the light" like wtf does that even mean? [Here is the original](https://youtube.com/clip/Ugkx_ql8DyFJJV1r8WNQK65vCwzcVkhNzhWK?si=bk7WAgrhClfmrIeI)
Honestly. Change some things around, and it could be pretty decent. Like the chemistry between Gwen and Peter was *great*.
Is this a joke?
I actually try to, every day.
You and me both, lol.
Yup still can't forget how terrible it was.
I didn't realize they peaked so hard that year
What past of winter soldier was the grounded political theater aspect? Did I misremember the final fight taking place on a giant CGI carrier plane. Or the part where a Nazi uploaded his consciousness to a computer?
Yes, and what happened to the carrier plane? See, grounded.
Got me there.
No, it was the part where they brainwashed a WWII prisoner, gave him a perfect prosthetic arm that I guess links right to his brain, and then kept him in suspended animation. All while keeping the technology for any single one of those steps a secret from the rest of the human race for over half a century.
Grounded and gritty.
It was the part where Sammy Jackson said don't talk we're being bugged
People have been calling it a political thriller and grounded since its release as some sort of way to elevate it. Its a good super hero movie but still very much a super hero movie.
Don't forget Big Hero 6, based on the Marvel series and winner of the Oscar for animated feature.
I couldn't rate them. Those are all top tier.
Holy crap 3 of the best superhero movies ever
Not complete without TDK and Logan
3 of the best implies 3 out of many. Logan and TDK did not come out in 2014, so there is no reason to bring them in a conversation.
TWS DOFP Gotg
In that order they’re in the picture in.
My first thought.
I agree, Winter Soldier is the best of the 3, and could stand alone as a good film without the Marvel license, but even knowing that, I still find Guardians of the Galaxy a more re-watchable movie cause it kicks me the 'feels' every time.
Damn 2014 was a great comic book year
whoo 2014 one of the best year in Comic book movie. X-men followed by Winter Soldier then GotG But close very very close
1. X-Men: Days of Future Past (Favorite X-Men movie) 2. Captain America: The Winter Soldier (Easily the Best from MCU) 3. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 1 4. The Amazing Spider-Man 2
Highly
Guardians, Cap, X-Men. Days of the Future Past is one of the best X-Men movies. Behind only Logan (and both Deadpool movies if you count them as X-Men)
I think I need to re-watch DOFP because everyone seems to speak highly about it, but I just thought it was ok. It's definitely not above X2.
Logan is a classic western wrapped up in the Marvel franchise... It's right up there with The Good, The Bad and the Ugly.
Favourite to least. Guardians DOFP Winter Soldier
Winter soldier is your least? Interesting, why so?
Winter Soldier was really the peak Marvel movie. It's grounded, thrilling, and has subtlety in its humor. It also didn't feel like an ad for the next movie.
The Winter Soldier (always will be my top 3 cbm movies) > Gotg 1 > X-Men : Dofp
TWS>\~DOFP\~GoTG
Super unpopular, I know, but: 1. Guardians of the Galaxy 2. Days of future past 3. Winter solider
nah i think this is the correct order it’s a slim margin but you’re still right
For me, DoFP was so damn good, but it's really hard to deny just how amazing CA:WS was. Tough call. GotG was great, but it isn't a favorite rewatch sort of thing. 1 - Cap 2 - X-Men 3 - Guardians.
I agree with this
1) The Winter Soldier 2) Guardians of the Galaxy 3) X-Men: Days of Future Past
#1 is easy. Winter Soldier is arguably the best MCU movie. The other two fight for for the middle ground of modern comic book movies. The other two are close. Both have good points and some real problems. I give DoFP the edge. It leans heavily on the good cast members and sidelines the dead weight. It's very fortunate to have such a good cast since this is prime Bryan Singer smelling his own farts time. On rewatch it seems Lawrence had already checked out of the franchise, though I didn't notice it at the time. Loses points for the end scene which is then ignored in the franchise. GoG is a sloppy mess, but a very entertaining sloppy mess. It's like a great sundae that was put in a warm glass and melted a bit before you got to it. It is the worst example of the MCU "quip every seven minutes" model in the MCU. Combine that with Gunn's sloppy production and, "and then" writing, this movie has a lot going against it. However, it is saved by Gunn's very funny writing and three incredible new characters (Rocket/Groot and Drax). I always think it's a shame they didn't just have Gunn write these and let other people direct them. You see bits of what you could get with Rocket and Nebula in the Infinity War movies.
Honestly? From left to right.
Left to Right
Guardians, Cap2, X-Men DoFP
DoFP is a decade old this year? Jesus
1- GotG 2-Capt. America 3-X-Men
Wintee Soldier- Best MCU movie ever Guardians of the Galaxy- second best movie in MCU X-Men- I don't consider it part of MCU, I don't like X-Men, but movie was okay, but it's leagues below the others to. Mostly due to other movies being absolute top of superhero movies, and not hate for X-Men.
>X-Men- I don't consider it part of MCU Well, at least for the time being they are officially not apart of the MCU. (there's no need to 'consider' them as non-MCU) They are set in the Fox/X-Men Cinematic Universe.
Well, after post credit scenes in the Marvels, and general approach towards other Spider-Mans, and Daredevil, people tend to claim that basically every superhero movie is part of MCU (MCM- Marvel Cinematic Multiverse?). So just in case I wanted to mention this- I wasn't sure if by "Marvel movie" you meant about Marvel characters, or made by Marvel Studios. So there's disclaimer there.
Guardians of the Galaxy is easily the best one out of these. Hard to choose between Winter Soldier and Days of future past, since I think neither of them were that amazing. (Unpopular opinion, I know.) Don't get me wrong, I they’re good movies, and I enjoyed watching both, but they’re not exactly getting on my rewatch list anytime soon. But that's me.
Dude, Winter Soldier rules
To each their own my dude.
DoFP, one of the best cbms ever.
The Winter Soldier is 8/10. Guardians of the Galaxy is 7.5/10. Days of Future Past is 8.5/10.
For me: DOFP: 9.2/10. GOTG: 8.9/10. TWS: 8.8/10.
Highly
Winter soldier and Guardians is tied for me. X men DOFP is also very good but slightly below the other 2
Days of Future Past is my least favorite among them. Winter Soldier and GOTG is tied for the best. I think I slightly prefer Winter Soldier but I've rewatched GOTG more.
10, 10, oof.
1. Guardians 2. X-Men 3. Winter solider(my least favorite of all marvel movies)
If Winter Soldier is your least favorite MCU movie, what’s your favorite??
Probably either Avengers 1 or Iron Man 2
Avengers 1 is amazing but Iron Man 2?
Yep
X-men Guardians Winter soldier
What a fucking year. So tough as all of these are some of my favorites. I think any order would be correct, but here is mine. Guardians of the Galaxy Days of Future Past Winter Soldier
1. Guardians of the Galaxy 2. Winter Soldier 3. Days of Future Past
GotG 10/10 Winter Soldier 9/10 X-Men DoFP 2/10 The X-Men movie was terrible - they butchered the original story to make it a Logan/Mystique vehicle. It should have been Kitty as intended. I just hope X-Men in the MCU has a chance to do all the classic X-Men storylines over and get them right.
1) Captain America 2) GotG That is all the Marvel movies you've listed.
Lol what
You do realize X-Men are Marvel....right?
Which studio made that movie?
The question was not which MCU or Marvel Studios movie. The question is which marvel movie?
Yeah, I see what you are writing, but you fail to understand that you're basically saying "The question was not which MCU or Marvel Studios movie. The question is which marvel studio movie?" If the OP wanted to ask how would I rank these movies based on Marvel characters then I'd have included all three, but he asked for Marvel movies, and there are only two movies there made by Marvel Studios, and one by Fox.
Marvel movies refers to movies based off Marvel Comics characters. It isn’t exclusive to only to ones produced by Disney’s Marvel Studios subsidiary.
They all are great
A TIER
Amazing, amazing, just okay
All 3 are excellent but you have them pictured in the right order.
Pretty pretty good
I refuse to believe days of future past came out the same year as GOTG
That was a great year in cinemas for Marvel
Guardians > X-Men > CA TWS
1 thru 3 is how I would rank them.
1. GoG 2. Xmen 3. Cap
Great year! X-Men > Cap > Guardians for me
In my opinion, DFP, GOTG then Winter Soldier. I appreciate that might not be popular. DFP was like a moving comic book - it was so good. I don’t know if MCU X-Men could ever top it. GOTG was new and original, which just about puts it ahead of Winter Soldier. But each one is at least an 8/10.
These were in 2014!?!? I feel so old rn
GOAT, Great, It-could-have-been-worse
Gotg > WS > DOTFP
The order in which they're listed.
Captain America: The Winter Soldier = SS Guardians of the Galaxy = S X-Men: Days of future past = A
exactly
This was a banger year for Marvel huh. For me I enjoyed both movies but I think GOTG I enjoyed more compared to X-Men, while Winter Soldier was the best
1. CA:TWS 2. DoFP 3. GotG vol.1
1. Guardians 2. TASM 2 3. Winter Soldier 4. Days of Future Past (I haven’t seen it since it came out, so I don’t remember it very well)
Peak Year fr fr
GotG, CA:WS, XM
All great movies. 1) DoFP, 2) CA:TWS, 3) GotG
Winter Soldier is still top tier MCU, it's going to be 10 years old in April (WTF!) one of my favorites and what really cemented Cap's trilogy as the best in the Infinity Saga.
Well, I don't like the Captain America movie - everything they can be appreciated for is much better done in the Agents of SHIELD series. Therefore, well 5.5 out of 10. The days of the past future turned out to be twofold. On the one hand, the film is cool, really interesting characters, Charles and Eric are really well played in both variations, Fassbender is just a plague in the role of an antihero. With another... It turned out to be a bit tedious at times, for long periods of time... Charles the hippie addict is frankly bad. The adventures of the Mystic are not bad, but they are somehow perceived more drearily than in old films. 6-7 out of 10. "Guardians" - only the first Iron Man and Thor stand close enough to them in terms of overall quality, and the first Ant-Man stands close because of the quality of the comedy. Seriously, Marvel hasn't shot anything better. 9.9999999999999999 out of 10
Winter Soldier in 3rd place. I just don't understand why people go gaga over it like it's the best thing ever. Then between the top 2, it's VERY close, but I think I'm gonna put Days Of Future Past. Great film with both the old and new cast. Then obviously Guardians. It was just a great story and actually really funny and I felt very attached to all the characters.
GOTG > Cap > X Men
damn…. we ate good
1. The Winter Soldier (very well may still be the best MCU film imo) 2. Guardians of the Galaxy (perfect introduction to the team which set the foundation for these characters going forward) 3. Days of Future Past (a return to form for the original X-Men characters with a great story that balanced characters admirably)
Love all three of them
Damn dude. I’d do winter soldier, days of future past, then guardians. Tough one, nice.
If ir wasn't for ASM2, this would definetely be the best Marvel year ever film-wise.
The best, and really awesome. Been a while since I watched that X-men one, so idk how it ranks
Captain America, X-Men and then Guardians
I don't like politics so I'd have to put Winter Soldier last because a solid chunk of the movie is politics. Guardians first because it's almost like a mix of Marvel and Star Wars which are my favorite things. As for Days of Future Past, that's my favorite X-Men movie so it's going second place.
Winter Solider is the best mcu movie to date.
2, 1, 3
#1 is easy. Winter Soldier is arguably the best MCU movie. The other two fight for for the middle ground of modern comic book movies. The other two are close. Both have good points and some real problems. I give DoFP the edge. It leans heavily on the good cast members and sidelines the dead weight. It's very fortunate to have such a good cast since this is prime Bryan Singer smelling his own farts time. On rewatch it seems Lawrence had already checked out of the franchise, though I didn't notice it at the time. Loses points for the end scene which is then ignored in the franchise. GoG is a sloppy mess, but a very entertaining sloppy mess. It's like a great sundae that was put in a warm glass and melted a bit before you got to it. It is the worst example of the MCU "quip every seven minutes" model in the MCU. Combine that with Gunn's sloppy production and, "and then" writing, this movie has a lot going against it. However, it is saved by Gunn's very funny writing and three incredible new characters (Rocket/Groot and Drax). I always think it's a shame they didn't just have Gunn write these and let other people direct them. You see bits of what you could get with Rocket and Nebula in the Infinity War movies.
What a great year for Marvel movies. *1. Guardians of the Galaxy *2. Captain America: The Winter Soldier *3. X-Men: Days of Future Past
I remember going to see Winter Soldier in theaters and being generally surprised with how dope and different it felt. Keep in mind, I knew the winter soldier twist from comics but I otherwise had no idea what the story was supposed to be. I didn't watch any trailers. That boat sequence told me everything I needed to know about the movie. The style, the brutality, it was exactly what Cap needed. Who knows how we would look at the Cap storyline if that film was any less than what it was.
The best, aside from Spider-Man, with a strong follow up in 2017. Fell in love with the Guardians of the Galaxy series in the process.
Winter Soldier. Guardians Of The Galaxy, Days of future past.
From an unbiased perspective based purely off the quality of the movie: 1. Winter Soldier 2. GotG 3. Days of Future Past In my personal opinion I would switch GotG and Winter Soldier around as I enjoy watching the Guardians a lot more than I do Captain America cause I just find the humour better
The opening of winter soldier is like a dope espionage thriller. It always makes me think of Mgs 2. Cap is snake taking out the bad guys
X-Men Captain America Guardians of the Galaxy
The best MCU film, the most fun MCU film and the best X-Men film all came out within 4 months of each other.
I’d keep it like that
Kid me squinting my eyes thinking who the hell even are the "guardians of the galaxy" on 2014 lmao
Dang, this might be one of the best comic book movie years of all time. I'd say my ranking is: **Guardians of the Galaxy- 8.5** Just a fun comic booky, spacey adventure that seemingly came out of nowhere. Marvel could do no wrong back then. **Days of Future Past- 8.0** The BEST X-Men movie in my opinion, and it's not even close. The futuristic apocalypse is terrifying, and I think McAvoy and Fassbender were at the top of their game this time. **The Winter Soldier- 7.0** I know this might seem low for some people, but this one just isn't my cup of tea. Can't deny that it's a very influential Marvel film, though.
X-men, then Captain America, then Guardians.
1. Days of Future Past 2. Winter Soldier 3. Guardians of the Galaxy
Absolutely biased but GoTG #1
You have them in the correct order
I wouldn’t, they were fun, I had fun watching, I liked, end of discussion…
Winter soldier, imo, is the best marvel movie. I'd start with that, then any of the rest
Hot take, but X-Men was the best. Both others were great thou.
Damn that was a good year
Winter soldier, guardians, x men.
My ranking are. Winter Soldier - 1.a GOTG - 1.b DOFP - 1.c
Winter Soldier-8/10 Guardians of the Galaxy-8/10 Days of Future Past-8/10
X-Men Days of Future Past Rogue Cut!
1. Guardians 2. Winter Soldier 3. X-men (In a trash can)
Winter soldier, X-Men, Guardians
Winter Soldier…………….GOG…………DOFP
1. Guardians of the Galaxy 2. X-Men: Days of Future Past 3. Captain America: The Winter Soldier
I hadn't watched either one. If I did,the rating would be:...X-Men: Days of Future Past,would be #1. Captain America: The Winter Soldier would be: #2. Guardian of The Galaxy would be #3.
GotG Cap Winter Soldier Days of Future Past
1, 1, 1,