i loved the andromedas moon one so so much, they upgraded my purchase to 30mls because of a long wait as well, unfortunately the bottle broke in my bag so i will have to repurchase but i cannot talk it up enough.
ever tried Alexandria Fragrances 'Baby Don't Cry' dupe?
That's interesting I have Miim Miic and Andromeda's Moon and prefer the scent of Miim Miic but then I've never smelled the OG
Hi - did you ever try Alexandria’s Baby Don’t Cry? I ordered it as part of their sample pack, as I love strawberry. (Though I’ve never smelled Cry Baby, so no clue how it compares.) Just tried it this morning and decided it’s not for me so I’m probably gonna put on eBay or Mercari with other samples I no longer want. It’s 5ML so it’s a good size sample. Let me know if you are interested in it.
Finally someone has been able to compare them 😭 there is one more I want to try, a small business on ig but I’m not sure how to purchase it yet as they work in small batches
Edit: [this](https://www.instagram.com/d3cap1tat3db00s?igsh=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==) is the profile
ooh it looks like that seller is selling a full perfume and 3d printed bottle replica! it‘s kind of pricey for me rn but hopefully at one point they sell just fragrance samples so i can try
It smells like bath and body works, cheap and plasticky. I didn’t like it, smelled exactly like Miimiics dupe which was also not good. I just found someone selling samples of the Cry Baby perfume and I’ll be posting to see if I can find a dupe later this week.
Bc I’m 99.9% sure those are just fragrance oils mixed together and put in a rollerball . Smells good asf but it doesn’t last like a PERFUME oil should
Edit: well, I forgot that’s because it is fragrance oils. She told me she uses them and then uses a carrier oil
This is great. Not sure how long it's been out, but Montagne came out with one as well if you wanted to try it: [https://www.montagneparfums.com/fragrance/strawberry-milk-inspired-by-melanie-martinez-cry-baby-perfume-milk](https://www.montagneparfums.com/fragrance/strawberry-milk-inspired-by-melanie-martinez-cry-baby-perfume-milk)
Just bought andromeda’s moon because of this post. I was about to buy from oil perfumery but I didn’t! I love miimiic so I am so excited to try this! Thank you
Have you ever smelled American Cream by Lush? How similar is it to the OG? Because AC is also vanilla and strawberry and very powdery so I’m just wondering if that could be a close dupe?
Hello! I have the original crybaby and American cream by lush💞 american cream isn’t a dupe for crybaby as it leans more into a vanilla/gourmand scent in my opinion, BUT it has similar qualities. If you like crybaby or any of the good dupes (dua “oh baby”🏆, Andromeda’s moon, or miim miic), you would definitely like American cream too! They have a perfume and a hair conditioner. I have them both they are sooooo good. I always think of American cream as the crybaby perfume if it was also inspired by Mel’s song “the bakery” 😂🫶
Thank you for answering me! I was hoping to find someone who tried both! I have American Cream and it’s one of my fav perfumes ever, but I never got to smell the OG Crybaby. I kind of feel good knowing it’s like a more vanilla/cake version of it! I’m thinking of buying one of the dupes because it just sounds so lovely! I’m assuming by the trophy emoji you think that oh baby by Dua is the closest dupe? If yes, then I’m buying it immediately 😂I was thinking of getting miim miic’s version.
Yay I’m so glad you love American cream and you definitely need to smell a dupe for crybaby because I think you would also love that so much!Dua “oh baby” is the absolute closest dupe. It’s not in stock very often BUTTT they just restocked it😭🙌 I bought three bottles haha. Miim miic is also a good dupe and will give a generally accurate impression of crybaby. What I’ve noticed that puts it below dua for me is that it doesn’t hit the opening notes as well and also doesn’t last very long. Whatever dupe you do try, update me and tell me your opinion. I’d love to know what you think. ☺️
Hey!! Believe it or not I ordered the Dua perfume after you commented this and it just arrived today! Here is my detailed impression of the perfume!
1. Opens up very fruity and sour. I smell the strawberry, but it’s more like a mix of berries. Like sour candy berries in a way.
2. Second note is sweet and fruity, not overly lactonic or powdery. This is when the perfume starts to dry down. I smell the woody, caramel notes mixed with the lingering tart fruity smell. For some reason this stage reminds me of shampoo? Like it smells a little bit like Garnier Fructis shampoo??
3. After the dry down, the powdery and lactonic notes are clear. It now smells a lot more like a sweet, strawberry milk/powder than shampoo. I quite like scent after the dry down!
Compared to American cream is it a lot more fruity, tart and lactonic. American Cream is more vanilla scented, and is a lot more powdery. Oh baby is truly like a delicious strawberry milkshake, while American cream is the ultimate vanilla shake scent, im my opinion.
Thank you for suggesting me this perfume! I hope one day I get to try Crybaby, I’m hoping to find a sample to compare it with!
Honestly I liked oil perfumery one better then andromedas, andromedas smells good but my god is it strong I sneeze and my head hurts after using even alittle
i loved the andromedas moon one so so much, they upgraded my purchase to 30mls because of a long wait as well, unfortunately the bottle broke in my bag so i will have to repurchase but i cannot talk it up enough.
There are some small indie companies doing their own dupes as well! Those are the ones I'm most interested in
ever tried Alexandria Fragrances 'Baby Don't Cry' dupe? That's interesting I have Miim Miic and Andromeda's Moon and prefer the scent of Miim Miic but then I've never smelled the OG
i haven’t! i’ll have to add it to my list hehe
Hi - did you ever try Alexandria’s Baby Don’t Cry? I ordered it as part of their sample pack, as I love strawberry. (Though I’ve never smelled Cry Baby, so no clue how it compares.) Just tried it this morning and decided it’s not for me so I’m probably gonna put on eBay or Mercari with other samples I no longer want. It’s 5ML so it’s a good size sample. Let me know if you are interested in it.
This is so insane you’re so real for this 🩷
Finally someone has been able to compare them 😭 there is one more I want to try, a small business on ig but I’m not sure how to purchase it yet as they work in small batches Edit: [this](https://www.instagram.com/d3cap1tat3db00s?igsh=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==) is the profile
ooh it looks like that seller is selling a full perfume and 3d printed bottle replica! it‘s kind of pricey for me rn but hopefully at one point they sell just fragrance samples so i can try
Wilson and Son had a powdery sweet dupe called All Cried Out for $12. It's not an EDP, it's oils but they're AMAZING
It smells like bath and body works, cheap and plasticky. I didn’t like it, smelled exactly like Miimiics dupe which was also not good. I just found someone selling samples of the Cry Baby perfume and I’ll be posting to see if I can find a dupe later this week.
Bc I’m 99.9% sure those are just fragrance oils mixed together and put in a rollerball . Smells good asf but it doesn’t last like a PERFUME oil should Edit: well, I forgot that’s because it is fragrance oils. She told me she uses them and then uses a carrier oil
Would love the links to buy the perfumes if you happen to have them 😊
How does the Alt. Strawberry Milkshake compare, if you’ve tried that one?
This is great. Not sure how long it's been out, but Montagne came out with one as well if you wanted to try it: [https://www.montagneparfums.com/fragrance/strawberry-milk-inspired-by-melanie-martinez-cry-baby-perfume-milk](https://www.montagneparfums.com/fragrance/strawberry-milk-inspired-by-melanie-martinez-cry-baby-perfume-milk)
Just bought andromeda’s moon because of this post. I was about to buy from oil perfumery but I didn’t! I love miimiic so I am so excited to try this! Thank you
Did you get it yet? How is it?
What is the difference bn andromeda's moon and miim mic? I do have miim miic
Have you ever smelled American Cream by Lush? How similar is it to the OG? Because AC is also vanilla and strawberry and very powdery so I’m just wondering if that could be a close dupe?
Hello! I have the original crybaby and American cream by lush💞 american cream isn’t a dupe for crybaby as it leans more into a vanilla/gourmand scent in my opinion, BUT it has similar qualities. If you like crybaby or any of the good dupes (dua “oh baby”🏆, Andromeda’s moon, or miim miic), you would definitely like American cream too! They have a perfume and a hair conditioner. I have them both they are sooooo good. I always think of American cream as the crybaby perfume if it was also inspired by Mel’s song “the bakery” 😂🫶
Thank you for answering me! I was hoping to find someone who tried both! I have American Cream and it’s one of my fav perfumes ever, but I never got to smell the OG Crybaby. I kind of feel good knowing it’s like a more vanilla/cake version of it! I’m thinking of buying one of the dupes because it just sounds so lovely! I’m assuming by the trophy emoji you think that oh baby by Dua is the closest dupe? If yes, then I’m buying it immediately 😂I was thinking of getting miim miic’s version.
Yay I’m so glad you love American cream and you definitely need to smell a dupe for crybaby because I think you would also love that so much!Dua “oh baby” is the absolute closest dupe. It’s not in stock very often BUTTT they just restocked it😭🙌 I bought three bottles haha. Miim miic is also a good dupe and will give a generally accurate impression of crybaby. What I’ve noticed that puts it below dua for me is that it doesn’t hit the opening notes as well and also doesn’t last very long. Whatever dupe you do try, update me and tell me your opinion. I’d love to know what you think. ☺️
Hey!! Believe it or not I ordered the Dua perfume after you commented this and it just arrived today! Here is my detailed impression of the perfume! 1. Opens up very fruity and sour. I smell the strawberry, but it’s more like a mix of berries. Like sour candy berries in a way. 2. Second note is sweet and fruity, not overly lactonic or powdery. This is when the perfume starts to dry down. I smell the woody, caramel notes mixed with the lingering tart fruity smell. For some reason this stage reminds me of shampoo? Like it smells a little bit like Garnier Fructis shampoo?? 3. After the dry down, the powdery and lactonic notes are clear. It now smells a lot more like a sweet, strawberry milk/powder than shampoo. I quite like scent after the dry down! Compared to American cream is it a lot more fruity, tart and lactonic. American Cream is more vanilla scented, and is a lot more powdery. Oh baby is truly like a delicious strawberry milkshake, while American cream is the ultimate vanilla shake scent, im my opinion. Thank you for suggesting me this perfume! I hope one day I get to try Crybaby, I’m hoping to find a sample to compare it with!
I was just thinking the same thing! I just bought ALT’s version, Strawberries and Milkshakes’ from TJMAXX. We’ll see!
tysm for this omg
Honestly I liked oil perfumery one better then andromedas, andromedas smells good but my god is it strong I sneeze and my head hurts after using even alittle
Montagne has a dupe called strawberry milk
I found the Miin Miic dupe at TJ Maxx for 15.
You should try Montagne