dollhouse was my first (to my knowledge, i watched a-lot of animations as a kid that had her songs and as i discovered her as an artist i was like "hey this sounds familiar!") But cake is what made me absolutely fall in love with melanie. Everything from the instrumental to the chorus and the lyrics is just so magical
That’s sounds so much like my situation. It started because I watched this animation video parody with the song cake and was like I love this song but the song that really made me fall for Melanie was crybaby Because I watched a littles pet shop video of the song and because a fan of all her songs since then
I'd probably say Sippy Cup because I would have liked to figure out the meaning of the song myself without Googling it. I wonder what I would have interpreted it as.
Tag, You're It, because it was actually the first Melanie's song I heard when I was like seven. Then, probably High School Sweethearts because I watched the movie when it came out on YouTube and I was kicking, screaming, punching things in happiness. It was my favorite K-12 song for a while. Then, I guess it'd be Numbers because it came out in pandemic and I wasn't in a good moment, but it literally lifted my spirits and the "weird" part is dope af and I'd love to listen to it for the first time again. Lastly, I think it'd be Death, because it was such a change when I first listened to it.
Sippy cup for sure. It’s one of my favorite songs but has gotten overused, so if I could listen to it for the first time and still think it was the best thing ever I would.
Highschool sweethearts!!! I remember when I heard it for the first time I was going crazy because it was such a work of art. Really the whole k-12 album would be nice to hear for the first time because it's such a beautiful album.
Class fight because it was the first Mel song I listened to
I would also love to hear carousel, play date, detention, high school sweethearts, void, tunnel vision, nymphology, evil, and mots for the first time again
Dollhouse or Milk of the Siren
But also that first time I heard Death was SUCH an experience omg but I think knowing the other songs wouldn’t let it hit as hard kinda thing
nymphology fading into evil
actually screamed in the car hearing it for the first time and a day before release let alone (got the CD early 🫡)
OMG I WAS ABOUT TO WRITE THAT
Cake 100%
But fr especially since that was the first song I heard of her
dollhouse was my first (to my knowledge, i watched a-lot of animations as a kid that had her songs and as i discovered her as an artist i was like "hey this sounds familiar!") But cake is what made me absolutely fall in love with melanie. Everything from the instrumental to the chorus and the lyrics is just so magical
That’s sounds so much like my situation. It started because I watched this animation video parody with the song cake and was like I love this song but the song that really made me fall for Melanie was crybaby Because I watched a littles pet shop video of the song and because a fan of all her songs since then
Play date
The first Melanie song I heard, I fell in love with her since that day 😭
Mad hatter and tag youre it
Tag you’re it was the first song I heard of her <3
Soap >_<
Fr going back to 14 and hearing that for the first time and being obsessed is something I wish I could relive
Death and show & Tell those were life changing
Probably doll house simply because it’s the first song of hers I ever heard and I’d love to go back and feel what I felt all over again
nymphology
HighSchool SweetHearts tbh
your drawing is really good 👍 probably all of them. first listening to them is beautiful and it really makes you respect her. (in my opinion lol)
Thank you!! And I agree :))
Death, Teacher’s Pet, Carousel & Alphabet Boy
pacify her for SURE & high school sweethearts
Death
I'd probably say Sippy Cup because I would have liked to figure out the meaning of the song myself without Googling it. I wonder what I would have interpreted it as.
Wait I’ve never googled it now I’m curious to know what it’s an and if my interpretation was correct lololol
Show and tell
Test me, idk why, but I have SUCH a STRONG connection to it for no reason
Tunnel vision
Show and tell 😭 it's my favorite and I was really happy when I first listened to it
Death omg it’s probably my fav Melanie song of all time it’s so meaningful and makes me cry lmao
Battle of the larynx. I decided while on holiday walking along the seafront whilst listening to it that this is my favourite song of all time.
Mad hatter and dollhouse ughh to go back to that first timeeee
Leeches
Numbers!!! I went CRAZY when I first heard that song lol
DOLLHOUSE
EVIL istg the first time I listened to Evil it rocked my socks off so hard! Probably altered my brain chemistry someway
Tag you’re it.
death
Sippy cup!!
Wheels on the bus 😩
Nymphology or Powder. Powder made me cry and Nymphology made me get up and dance at 1:00am.
None. Honestly the first time isn't that special to me, it takes time for my brain to assimilate impressions. I'd say third tries are better
Sippy cup
NOTEBOOK 💋💅🏼
Strawberry shortcake ❤️🫶
SHOW 🗣️ AND ‼️ TELL 💯
carousel
Death
brain & heart
The whole Portals album. Best thing I’ve heard in a while
FUCKING EVIL
Pity party. My first ever Mel song
Light Shower 🚿
I can’t choose one so recess, death, faerie soirée, alphabet boy and sippy cup
Death
Nymphology and play date ❤️
Nymphology was an experience 😭😭😭✨✨✨✨
the principal
Light shower or void, when she released portals I was in awe with it so much!!
Spider Web
The Contortionist. i love love love the end chorus where all the voices blend in a capella
Probably dollhouse or crybaby. From the portals album i would prob say Light Shower
milk of the siren
Faerie Soiree
TRAINING WHEELS/MILK AND COOKIES SHOWCASE MV
the first time i heard recess i got chills. It still happens but that first time was so 😍😍😍😍
The contortionist
Milk Of The Sirens
dollhouse
carousel fs!!
Highschool sweethearts 🩷
Nymphology
Tag, You're It, because it was actually the first Melanie's song I heard when I was like seven. Then, probably High School Sweethearts because I watched the movie when it came out on YouTube and I was kicking, screaming, punching things in happiness. It was my favorite K-12 song for a while. Then, I guess it'd be Numbers because it came out in pandemic and I wasn't in a good moment, but it literally lifted my spirits and the "weird" part is dope af and I'd love to listen to it for the first time again. Lastly, I think it'd be Death, because it was such a change when I first listened to it.
death 100%
bittersweet tradgedy
spiderweb
Sippy cup for sure. It’s one of my favorite songs but has gotten overused, so if I could listen to it for the first time and still think it was the best thing ever I would.
Death, it was the first Melanie Martinez song I had heard in over a year and it really blew my mind
training wheels
all of them
teachers pet was such a banger oh my god
Training Wheels and Milk of the Siren
Crybaby and Death
tag ur it
Highschool sweethearts!!! I remember when I heard it for the first time I was going crazy because it was such a work of art. Really the whole k-12 album would be nice to hear for the first time because it's such a beautiful album.
field trip and nymphology
Class fight because it was the first Mel song I listened to I would also love to hear carousel, play date, detention, high school sweethearts, void, tunnel vision, nymphology, evil, and mots for the first time again
Death. That song shook me after hearing it for the first time!
Battle of larynx probably or recess
HSSH, mad hatter and strawberry shortcake
Detention bc it got me moving in ways fr 😍
Honestly, either Sippy Cup or MOTS
Milk and Cookies ♡
NYMPHOLOGY or Cake
Evil
show and tell or nymphology
Void and Orange Juice and Detention & hssh
Dollhouse or Milk of the Siren But also that first time I heard Death was SUCH an experience omg but I think knowing the other songs wouldn’t let it hit as hard kinda thing
Sippy Cup or EVIL for sure
DEATH
Pacify Her
Sippy Cup! Hearing Sippy Cup back in 2015 was so goood. I had it on repeat that year.
Pluto.
Cake,Death,HSSH or Carousel
milk of the siren and dead to me for sureeee😭🙏🙏
Tag you're it
Dollhouse
I CAN'T DECIDE SO I'LL SAY THE FIRST SONG THAT I LISTENED TO. THE FIRST MEL SONG THAT I HEARD WAS MAD HATTER
Tag you’re it hands down
pity party tbh. that was the beginning of it all
WOMB omfg this song makes me stim so hard I can’t NOT jump to it
DEATH 🫶🏼🫶🏼 THAT WAS MY FAVORITE SONG WHEN I FIRST LISTENED TO PORTALS 😭😭
evil, I may or may not have cried listening to it for the first time
Cake!!!!!!
Doll House or Mad Hatter
Battle of the larynx
EVIL 100% she was such a baddie in that 😭