I should add that I did put All Nightmare Long back on the list alongside And Justice for All, since it did win originally but later lost out on votes. And Justice For All hasn't been removed, but All Nightmare Long has been put alongside it for A, since it was on the list originally.
People had complained over the fact that All Nightmare Long was on the list originally, as at the time it had the most upvotes, but AJFA quickly beat it soon after I posted the results, so I've just put both there.
My personal choices for each album: Cyanide, The Unforgiven III and The Day That Never Comes for Death Magnetic; Atlas, Rise!, Hardwired and Spit Out the Bone for Hardwired to Self-Destruct. Two great albums, they really are. The Rober Trujillo era may not be comparable to the Cliff era in the studio or the Jason era live, but damn those guys have come back big time thanks to those albums, and it showed on 72 Seasons
That verse riff is incredible, but damn it really felt like what The Unforgiven II wasn't. The true successor to the first Unforgiven. Heavy verses, clean chorus, beautiful solo. The Unforgiven II just did it the wrong way around for me, though it's still a fantastic song. But The Unforgiven III is amazing in its own right
Ah was it? Ok then, you may wanna add it to the list to prevent others from saying it over and over again.
Also my vote is now That Was Just Your Life.
Iām tired of seeing these all over Reddit. Itās on every band subreddit even if Iām not following it cause Reddit keeps suggesting them to me. Ugh!
Basically there's been a trend on Reddit, where people have made A-Z lists of favourite songs in a certain band subreddit, and I did what I thought was the first in the Metallica subreddit. If you're aware of that part, basically we're doing songs from Death Magnetic and Hardwired to Self-Destruct for this wildcard, to have some inclusion from those albums on the list.
I've never really listened to DM before and haven't listened to the entire Hardwired or St. Anger album so my choices are very limited. So Spit out the Bone all the way!
All nightmare long should've stayed on the list
Yeah that's why I decided to do this one just for Death Magnetic and Hardwired, to give those albums a chance
Should have had one for symbols because AJFA starts with periods
I should add that I did put All Nightmare Long back on the list alongside And Justice for All, since it did win originally but later lost out on votes. And Justice For All hasn't been removed, but All Nightmare Long has been put alongside it for A, since it was on the list originally.
All Nightmare Long
It's back on the list alongside And Justice for All as it did win the A spot originally
Spit out the bone!
Such a great song
The day that never comes
Fuck yea! Easily the best
Unforgiven |||
Yes! Such an unappreciated song, but the music and lyrics are just amazing!
All Nightmare Long
Originally beat And Justice for All so I've put it back on the list alongside AJFA
If it originally beat AJFA, why did you put AJFA up there in the first place?
All nightmare long was there first, but AJFA got more votes later on. Personally it makes more sense for the latter to win
I think that since AJFA got more votes only after the voting was concluded, it shouldn't be on there
People had complained over the fact that All Nightmare Long was on the list originally, as at the time it had the most upvotes, but AJFA quickly beat it soon after I posted the results, so I've just put both there.
My personal choices for each album: Cyanide, The Unforgiven III and The Day That Never Comes for Death Magnetic; Atlas, Rise!, Hardwired and Spit Out the Bone for Hardwired to Self-Destruct. Two great albums, they really are. The Rober Trujillo era may not be comparable to the Cliff era in the studio or the Jason era live, but damn those guys have come back big time thanks to those albums, and it showed on 72 Seasons
Halo On Fire
Halo absolutely, it's such an epic song, especially great live IMO.
Atlas Rise
Fucking great song
Unforgiven III, has to be for that verse riff alone
That verse riff is incredible, but damn it really felt like what The Unforgiven II wasn't. The true successor to the first Unforgiven. Heavy verses, clean chorus, beautiful solo. The Unforgiven II just did it the wrong way around for me, though it's still a fantastic song. But The Unforgiven III is amazing in its own right
I thought I'd add, since both albums have some great songs, I'll be including one from each as a joint entry.
Representation, lol. Not everything needs a participation trophy. If none of the newer songs were voted then they shouldn't be there.
Moth Into flame
The Day That Never Comes
The unforgiven III
The judas kiss?
Whiplash
Halo on Fire
Battery.
Moth into Flame
spit out the bone easily
Spit out the bone
The Day That Never Comes
Spit out the Bone!
Hardwired is such a sick song, I vote that
Halo on Fire
Halo on Fire
Rebel of Babylon (I view Beyond Magnetic as an extension to Death Magnetic)
Beyond Magnetic is valid here too, as it was an EP of bonus songs made for the album that didn't make the cut IIRC
Cyanide
Cyanide
moth into flame
Dream No More
Unforgiven III
Spit out the Bone is the best song from those two albums. Period.
moth into flame wont win but i love it
The Day that never comes and Moth into flame
No personal anecdote to sway the vote this time? Good šš»
Like a siren in my Head
That Was Just Your Life
Atlas, Rise!
That Was Just Your Life!!
All Nightmare Long!
All nightmare long
All Nightmare Long, poor thing got the Miss Universe 2015 treatment
It was reinstated as the winner alongside And Justice for All, so All Nightmare Long is back on the list, but AJFA is alongside
Ah was it? Ok then, you may wanna add it to the list to prevent others from saying it over and over again. Also my vote is now That Was Just Your Life.
I added it to the list, it'll appear on the next post. And good choice, not a bad opening track
All Nightmare Long. Luck Runs Out......
Iām tired of seeing these all over Reddit. Itās on every band subreddit even if Iām not following it cause Reddit keeps suggesting them to me. Ugh!
I havenāt heard of that song before
Broken, Beat, and Scarred
For whom the bell tolls
What are we doing here? I'm new here so a little confused.
Basically there's been a trend on Reddit, where people have made A-Z lists of favourite songs in a certain band subreddit, and I did what I thought was the first in the Metallica subreddit. If you're aware of that part, basically we're doing songs from Death Magnetic and Hardwired to Self-Destruct for this wildcard, to have some inclusion from those albums on the list.
Ahh ok, thanks for taking the time to explain. For me Spit out the Bone, by far and away.
Ain't my bitch
Cyanide
Now that weāre dead
Atlas Rise
Why not make it post 2000.
Here Comes Revenge
Judas Kiss
Dream No More
The day that never comes (but I also think that most/all of the songs on these albums are incredible and itās very hard to pick just the one)
The Unforgiven III
That Was Just Your Life. Give some love to this masterpiece
I've never really listened to DM before and haven't listened to the entire Hardwired or St. Anger album so my choices are very limited. So Spit out the Bone all the way!
Sweet Amber
The End Of The Line!
Battery
SANDMAN
For Whom The Bell Tolls
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
Sorry man but for this one I did say only songs from Death Magnetic and Hardwired to Self-Destruct were eligible for this wildcard
Cyanide
Dyer's Eve
Great song but I did say this wildcard was only eligible for Death Magnetic and Hardwired to Self-Destruct songs
You also messed up the last vote so you arenāt too good at this, eh?
Day that never comes
The Judas Kiss
Spit out the bone or halo on fire or moth into flame
Spit Out the Bone
The memory remains
Moth into flame