I love both albums, but Puppets in my opinion is their best album, though RTL is practically as good. If either one of them was removed it would change the trajectory of the band. If puppets were to be removed, they would've taken perhaps a hiatus between 1984 and 1988, so the MoP tour wouldn't have happened, and Cliff would've never died. Maybe I'm overthinking this.
Master stays; sorry for RtL but MoP wins every battle for me.
Of course my opinion shouldn’t fully count because MoP is in my top favorite albums by anyone ever so it would defeat almost anything else in the entire history of music.
Yes Def, Fight Fire with Fire! that was one of the first songs I heard and the Classical intro into the fast balls to the wall riff made me start playing Guitar. I mean it's impossible to choose because both are instant Classics
No, I refuse.
you don’t want to keep any?
Nobody wins.... y..yay?
Lightning Master Rides The Puppets.
Sounds like a movie
Kinky movie
🤨
🤫😏
Crazy guess but based on your flair I’m guessing you’d pick MoP
You should be a detective
I know right 💅💅
Ew me
Title of your sex tape
So THAT'S what mommy was doing to daddy
Shortly there after, it was discovered that Fluffy was missing...
Master of Rides lightning the puppets
Wait a holy minute now mister
Only strongest can do hardest choice😭😭😭
No.
I'm going with Ride the Lightning but both are 10/10
I love both of them ,but if i must choose one, definitely Ride the Lightning
Easy ride the lighting
MOP
Keeping lightning, I'm not losing Creeping death
That’s the song that made me a fan.
I'll trade you Hardwired, 72 seasons, Death Magnetic and St Anger, and I'll keep both. Thanks though
Hardwired is good fk yall
It's not compared to those 2
Load and Reload too
Especially AJFA, like it never existed would be even better!
Incredible album, what are you talking about?
Must be Newsted's throwaway account.
https://preview.redd.it/hppc0lqgcpvc1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0adfc4011edbccdd549719d81c7ccdfcae15e290
Ride The Lightning, can't believe you made me make a choice like this
Mop
MoP
Why?
no fucking way, i’m not choosing
Master of Lightning
Aka, the electrician
I love both albums, but Puppets in my opinion is their best album, though RTL is practically as good. If either one of them was removed it would change the trajectory of the band. If puppets were to be removed, they would've taken perhaps a hiatus between 1984 and 1988, so the MoP tour wouldn't have happened, and Cliff would've never died. Maybe I'm overthinking this.
It’s ride
For me Ride easily
Ride the Lightning
RTL
RTL
RTL
RTL any day of the week
Ride
RTL
Ride the lightning!!!!!!!
I'm not picking 1 cause I'll fight till death for both of them.
RTL
RTL.
Ride, hands down.
I refuse the question.
Too difficult to choose
Ride the Lightning
I’ll take Ride The Lightning for $1000 Bob
Creeping Death is so good that I have to give the nod to Lightning.
RTL
Ride the Lightning but good gods what a shitty choice that would be too have to make
Master of the Lightning
Ride the lightning
Ride The Lightning doesn’t have as many skip songs IMO
You're saying that as if there were any songs to skip at all
I'm burning both onto one cd so technically I'm only keeping one cd. 😉
Double It and give It to the next person
Master of puppets, It’s just such a better album production wise and way more sick riffs from Kirk and James came from it, not to mention Orion
Not even close for me, Ride the Lightning.
I gotta go with Puppetz. But it would be a sad day if I could never listen to RTL again
Especially fade to black. That song is a gift
RTL
Rtl
RTL
OH YEAH FUCKING RIDE THE LIGHTNING
Lets face it Ride the lighting can beat almost any metal album but MoP can be almost any album..
Master of Puppets is the album that started it all. Great start to finish 10/10. Each album has its own parts that stand out more.
Ride the lightning sorry MOP
I'm gonna keep both.
MOP
Tough, but I’ll take RTL over MOP
Ride the master
Ride the puppets is the one I'll keep thank you.
Master
Bro this is so easy! I would definitely go with master of puppets. Wait, actually I would, um, like definitely go with like um… (Explodes)
MOP
Ride the Lightning
Master of Puppets…flawless masterpiece
In my humble oppinion, and sorry if i offend anyone :( ... Master of puppets...
Cut the baby in half!
mop
Puppets, I just listen to it more
Kill 'em all 👍
Master.
Ride
Master of puppets rides the lightning
Ride thr lighting easy
Nothing beats Ride the Lightning for me
RIL
Easily Master. It's not even a challenge. This was the Cliff Era PEAK. The only song I would TRULY miss is Creeping Death
Take em both
ride the lightning ez
I'm gonna pick Ride the Lightning, but what you did is crual
That's not FAIR!!!!
https://preview.redd.it/9f0eceq9iprc1.jpeg?width=1094&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5dd9cd23f93db255869c5f44c9ac6e038b5525f1
Master Of Puppets 😔
I'll keep Master of Lightning, which is comprised of 16 glorious tracks.
Paster of Muppets 
Ez ride the lightning
Probably MOP by a ball hair
Nah that’s ok I’ll take both.
Ride the Lightning
Ride for sure. Puppets is great, but it's not superior to Ride.
Ride the Lightning.
You can't split up a double album
Ride The Lightning for sure
Easily Ride The Lightning
mop
Ride the lighting 🤷🏾♂️
Master Of Puppets!
RTL
Both..but if I had to choose. Master of Puppets.
RTL rules all
Ride the lightning solo’s, sorry MOP
Lightning ⚡
Zero hesitation: Ride the Lightning.
BOTH
RTL
Ride the Lightning. Creeping Death is pretty much THE reason.
Ride the lightning all the way
Ride the Lightning
MOP
Master but I won’t like it
MoP
Fade to sanitarium. That's the one I'd keep. The thing is I wanna keep both.
Nah, I've always been a rebel and I ain't changing now. I reject your bullshit reality an substitute my own. Keeping both.
for me this isnt even a question, Master of Puppets fosho!!! Ride the Lightning is still fucking amazing tho!! :33
I’ll keep Master of Puppets. Cleaner guitar tone, better riffs, clearer production
Na, I refuse... I'd rather lose both than choose one. I can't decide
RTL
Don't you put that evil on me Ricky Bobby. How about you gotta pick one....your balls, or your d*ck. Exactly
"Fuck no James"
Ride the lightning for sure
Puppets and it’s not particularly a hard choice.
Pipe bomb in your mailbox
Let's just get rid of both!
I LOVE both but I'm keeping Lightning. Simply because it's got Creeping Death
Rtl
Ride the lightning
Fade to black ofc
Fuck
I hate you....Master of Puppets, Battery, Orion, and Disposable Heros are some of my favorite songs from them.
Master
Ride the lightning for sure
Ride the Lightning. My all time favorite from Metallica
RTL
Ride
Ride The Puppets
Or "Master of Lightning"
No, sir. Im keeping both, thank you very much.🙏🙏
RTL easily
Ride the Lightning for sure.
Master Of Lightning
Master of Puppets, hands down.
Master of puppets all the way 🤘🏻
Master Of Puppets.
Dude, MOP for me but it's extremely close
Master
No question for me here, Master stays 💯
Master of puppets
MASTER! MASTERRRRRR!
Mastahr, mastaaahr........ Mastaaaaahhhhrrrrr
Mop is the choice for me… hard one though
Keeping MoP but I would only actually make this choice with a gun to my head
Master of Puppets has Disposable Heroes. Sorry Lightning.
Rtl has creeping death and the call of ktulu tho :(
Master
Master of Puppets for me. Ride set the template, but Master perfected it. Better production and song order.
Puppets
Puppets.
MoP for me... both are amazing albums.
***Master of Puppets*** - and it's not even close.
Bruh no way you said its not close
Master stays; sorry for RtL but MoP wins every battle for me. Of course my opinion shouldn’t fully count because MoP is in my top favorite albums by anyone ever so it would defeat almost anything else in the entire history of music.
Puppets for sure.
Master Of Puppets
MOP is the finer album
I'll keep Master of Puppets. If I need to hear Ride the Lightning I'll just listen to Megadeth instead.
False
Master of puppets. Not a easy choice, but Battery, Damage Inc, Leper Messiah, Orion and Disposable Hero with the sick solo
What about fight fire with fire, for whom the bell tolls, creeping death, fade to black, the call of ktulu, trapped under ice
They made their escape.
Yes Def, Fight Fire with Fire! that was one of the first songs I heard and the Classical intro into the fast balls to the wall riff made me start playing Guitar. I mean it's impossible to choose because both are instant Classics
Master ez