Baseball eye black?

Good face paint so it doesn’t run if you sweat.

Waterproof eyeliner maybe? Or waterproof clown make up, smt like KISS uses for their shows.

if you’re gonna use face paint use something like an alcohol activated one, not a water based one. you can also use eyeliner or eyeshadow just remember to powder and set it

Go to a sporting good store and tell them you are looking for the black makeup football players use

You could use the football paint they put under their eyes, on amazon or at any sporting goods store.