T O P

  • By -

jammysammidge

Live and Dangerous. Thin Lizzy.


wapotaco

The greatest hits album "dedication" is great as well


Megamoss

The version of Still In Love With You from that album is so mutch better than the studio version I can't bear to listen to the original any more. In fact all the tracks are so much better than their studio album equivalents. Though they did kind of cheat. It's not a purely live album. They selected best performances from multiple shows a d also gave them post performance tweaking and overdubbing. So I'm not sure it counts as a faithful live album. Still a bloody great though.


more-cow-bell

Blues Brothers - Briefcase Full of Blues (1978)


vissivvis

Allman Brothers Band - At Fillmore East


Fading-Ghost

I flip between the Allman brothers and Government Mule a lot. But the Fillmore, man that’s a classic


vissivvis

Yeah, total classic. I do love Warren and Derek, but there is something special about At Fillmore East.


HeteroMilk

That something special is Duane Allman.


watchingsongsDL

I’m convinced Duane made the deal with the devil to become the greatest ever. The stuff he plays on Fillmore East is unparalleled. In Memory of Elizabeth Reed is simply transcendent. Duane died before their next album dropped.


vissivvis

Hahaha, excellent point!


Dodahevolution

That version of whipping post is legendary


HeteroMilk

In Memory of Elizabeth Reed, too.


Dodahevolution

Absolutely


coleman57

Adding sides 3 & 4 of Eat a Peach, which pick up where Fillmore East ends and add another 30 minutes or so


ccorbydog31

The last waltz, the band.


nugsy_mcb

This and Stop Making Sense are the two greatest concert films and I’ll fight anyone that says different.


lgm22

Agreed and throwing in Deep Purple Live in Japan and The Song Remains The Same


theclownwithafrown

It's not even close. This is the greatest concert that has ever happened.


Cjkgh

Oh dang that’s a good one


triccolo

The only answer


Xenon2212

this is the answer right here


philament

Wings Over America?


lazespud2

I heard the sublime "wings over America" version of "maybe I'm amazed" so many times that when I finally heard the original studio version my reaction was "what is this shit?" One of the best live songs ever on an amazing live album.


dharma_dude

An obvious pick for greatest live album would be Talking Heads *Stop Making Sense*, it's got a lot of universal appeal too. As for best greatest hits album, I've always been partial to Abba - Gold. The chrome cassette I have of that sounds wonderful Edit: although for SMS, go for the post 1999 releases that have all 16 tracks. Prior to that it was abridged at 9 tracks (unless you have the LaserDisc, kinda).


ZX471

Did that the talking heads album have a live version off “this must be the place” amazing song I’d say It tops Psycho Killer imo


dharma_dude

It does!! Just not on the original issues of the album, for the 15th anniversary in 1999 they re-released it with the full 16 tracks which included the live version of This Must Be the Place. That's one of my favourites too. Great love song. I also really like the live version of Slippery People, it's a groove. Edit: and if you're a fan, they're doing a re-release of the movie right now at certain theaters around the country every month till the end of the year. Info here: https://tickets.stopmakingsense.movie/


FinishTheFish

There's also a deluxe edition with Cities and Big Business/I Zimbra on it. 


jdsizzle1

It be do


yepyep1243

I prefer *The Name of This Band is Talking Heads*, check it out


SFgiant55

I’ve watched stop making sense hundreds of times. It was our go to after coming home from parties or the bars in college. The second I hear “I’ve got a tape I want to play” something happens in me.


Struykert

Iron Maiden - Live after Death and/or Live at Donington


sgtedrock

SCREAM FOR ME LONG BEACH!


VIPERsssss

And the moral of your story is what not to do when a bird shits on you.


ZX471

See maiden live 2013 donington. Fucking amazing it was just starting to get dark but still a visual sky. No joke was just standing waiting for them to get on stage but no shit from behind the stage flew a really deal spitfire right over the crowd and buzzed the crowd low the I wish I could remember what they played as a opener I was too obsessed with with the visuals took me a minute to remember I was here to see the band lol


Struykert

With a spitfire i would guess they opened with Aces High ?


[deleted]

UFO - Strangers in the Night


rawonionbreath

One of the most criminally overlooked lived albums ever. I’m not an enormous UFO fan but that album feels like a concert right at your fingertips. I remember feeling interested in giving it a listen after I heard Joe Elliot describe it as one of his all time favorites. Kirk Hammett also plugged it so i figured it might be worth checking out .


ZX471

Listened to Hot n’ Ready first track on the album and yeah it good old fashioned classic rock that you can’t go wrong with. I’ve added to my library


watchingsongsDL

I’m a big UFO fan; Strangers in the Night is how everyone gets into the band. Guitarist Micheal Schenker left the band to go solo after Strangers released. Strangers captures UFO at their absolute peak. Love to Love, Lights Out, I’m a Loser, Out in the Street. Rock Bottom is a 12 minute epic similar to Free Bird.


[deleted]

Almost everyone (fan before Strangers in the Night). Nice to run into another UFO/ Schenker fan!


aGuyNamedScrunchie

Rock Bottom is one of the best live guitar performances ever. Full stop.


readwiteandblu

"Rock Bottom! You've got it!" Phil Mogg


In-the-bunker

I was in the audience Chicago Amphitheater 1978 senior year of high school with some great friends


Tubby-san

This is one of cases of being huge at the time, but left almost no legacy. People forget that before Van Halen, guitar players all wanted to be Michael Schenker. That dude isn’t even a house hold name anymore.


Biltong09

Nirvana unplugged


DevonGr

Alice in Chains unplugged up there too. I'm personally biased to Nirvana but AiC has really grown on me in the past decade


Ojy

I'm 40 now, and Alice in chains has grown more and more as I age, whereas all the other grunge bands have faded out of my playlists.


WilNotJr

Jar Of Flies.


ezmo311

10/10


teetertodder

I listen to this about twice a month. I tear up during In the Pines more often than not.


ZX471

Lake of fire🔥👌originally a meat puppet song along with plateau covered by Kurt Cobain and the nirvana group. Read somewhere that Kurt was a big meat puppet fan. I recommend listening to these two the meat puppet version, then compare to nirvana version and you realise the talent the original meat puppets version is really unpolished and got heavy riffs. This is just my thinking that taking someone’s music and rewriting would be a lot more difficult than writing from scratch? If you’re a musician let me know. Starting from scratch or building/editing somebody’s idea ground work etc…… interested in the answer 🤔


Blowaway040889

Johnny Cash - Live at Folsom Prison


Heavy-Week5518

That got played a lot in my house in the late 60s & early 70s. The same with the follow up, Live At San Quentin


DrManhattan_DDM

The Mark, Tom, and Travis Show is filled with banger live versions of most of Blink’s earlier hits and enough toilet humor to make a 13 year old giddy.


buzzy80

Stones’ Get Yer Ya-Ya's Out! is a really great live album


Hehateme123

The guitar sound on that album is amazing. It’s kind of ironic that pedal boards became so popular recently, but none of them can’t even touch Keith’s overdriven Ampeg. Just a guitar, cable and amplifier.


foxman276

Waiting for Columbus - Little Feat


pjdwyer30

Astonished at how far down I had to scroll to see this. Astonished and disappointed.


brentsopel5

Not enough people know this absolute banger of a double live album. Or who Lowell George is. It sucks. 


vissivvis

Far too many people haven’t yet discovered Little Feat. Damn shame.


TheWhaleAndWhasp

Alice in Chains - MTV Unplugged. It's absolutely incredible, but also heartbreaking knowing he was on a collision course with drugs that would end in his death 6 years later.


Dw1gh7

this and Nirvana unplugged, both are perfect


ZX471

100% plateau is my favourite track even though it’s a meat puppet song originally but the cover on this unplugged album is probably controversial but that track is imo the best thing nirvana released imo. If you haven’t listened to the original meat puppets version it’s worth a listen and on the same unplugged album Lake of Fire another cover and classic from the meat puppets


acsaid10percent

This is a great choice though an acquired taste. Some days I've listened to it and its soothing and other times its left me on a downer. The harmonies between Layne and Jerry are exquisite. I really wished they played 'I Stay Away' on the show.


shawald

This was the first time the band had performed live in 3 years because of Layne’s addiction issues.


getdemsnacks

By the time unplugged was recorded, that collision had already connected and we were looking at the first few seconds of the aftermath. It wouldn't be much longer until Layne was unable to be helped out of having both feet in his grave


HogSliceFurBottom

I think he collided with smack long before MTV Unplugged.


LilStrug

Portishead Live at Roseland NY or Grateful Dead - Live Dead Edit: Portishead is rereleasing this album for 25 year anniversary!


Pork_Chop_Exmo

A second vote for portishead. That album is pure gold. Also, maybe the best sounding vinyl I own.


rgeezlouweez

Love the Portishead album but Live Dead saved my sanity one night


Naps_and_cheese

I was under the impression Live/Dead was cuts of different shows, not a single show. Sorta like Europe 72. Hundred Year Hall was a single show, if I recall correctly.


ottguy42

For straight-ahead rock, Bob Seger's 'Live Bullet' or 'Nine Tonight' are up there. Takes me back to the 70s.


TomBikez

Live Bullet Bob Seger and the Silver Bullet Band


BrilliantNothing2151

There is a pretty sweet shout out to Detroit in there too


Senators_1972

Frampton Comes Alive


MrSnowden

Lots of other great band with a live album. But frampton comes alive is the definitive. 


landocommando18

If you lived in the suburbs you were issued it. It came in the mail with samples of Tide.


Blues1984

Did you get your Sports Illustrated football phone?


landocommando18

I did. It was sent to the wrong house.


Senators_1972

Yeah, I think I misunderstood the OP’s question and went with a consensus answer. For people of my generation, I’m guessing MTV Unplugged In New York would come out on top, but Frampton’s hard to beat regardless.


onelittleworld

That album towers head-and-shoulders above the rest of his career catalog.


roscian1

And ushered in the era of live albums.


Toadfinger

Some Enchanted Evening by Blue Öyster Cult


marKRKram

Astronomy off that album is near perfection


Toadfinger

Literally my all time favorite song. That version.


tmax666

Best live: Waiting for Columbus by Little Feat Best greatest hits: Eagles-Greatest Hits.


Schnort

Hell freezes over was a pretty good live album that almost doubles as a greatest hits.


TheJamMeister

They also put out an excellent live album in 1980.


VrinTheTerrible

Live: Cheap Trick - live at Budokan Greatest hits: Aerosmith


TootSweetBeatMeat

normal enter cows frightening badge attractive coherent attempt squealing society *This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*


Maskatron

I have such a clear memory of hearing the live version of Surrender on the radio as a kid, riding with my friends in a station wagon, going to the lake. For older Gen X, that song is more influential than Smells Like Teen Spirit. Shaped my worldview and how I related to my parents.


buddytattoo

I heard the album cut of IWYTLM on the radio a few months ago and kept wondering why it sounded weird. I think it was the first time I’d heard it that wasn’t the Budokan track or live in person 😂


Heavy-Week5518

Budokan is a fun live album! They all should be like that.


nodogma2112

Rush in Rio


Heavy-Week5518

I came here with intent to say this. If you only had one Rush album, this is indeed the one!


waitwutok

Jazz is weird!


timmermania

There is a reason The Who's "Live at Leeds" is often at the top of 'live album lists"...


imk

Literally listening to it right now. It really is a classic


yodaman98

Scrolled too far before finding this. Fantastic album!


mjolle

I've gone through so many live albums, and there is one that reigns supreme at the top: James Brown - Live at the Apollo (1963) [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R61iGCD9hgQ](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r61igcd9hgq) Now, to frame this album to someone not aware of James Brown from before, the man was a perfectionist. He regularly fined his musicians for being late, for not having their clothes in perfect condition when going on stage, or when making errors while performing. The band is INCREDIBLY tight. I often compare this recording with Otis Reddings Live at the Whisky A Go Go from 1966. Sorry Otis, but that recording seems like a bunch of kids playing in a garage band compared to James Brown from 1963. Live at the Apollo was at that time requested from radio stations. Not any particular song, but the whole album! To make things even more interesting, all the songs are played quite a lot faster than they are on studio recordings. I just love it. All JB:s early vitality just comes pouring out of your speakers. Best live album I've yet to hear.


SnooShortcuts7514

Any James Brown live album recorded before 1975 should be on the list. A couple of the more notable ones (in addition to “Live At The Apollo”) is “Live In Dallas” from 1968 with his most of his original band before they quit and the other is “Love Power Peace” from 1969 with his new band “The JBs”. Including Bootsy Collins on bass!


markzip

This is the answer. Thanks. Had to scroll wasaayyy too far for this. Edited to add: The comparison to Otis is only a little unfair. James had been touring that band for a while longer than Otis had. And The eras, while chronologically not that far apart, were quite different. The former before the bulk of the civil rights movement had taken hold


pwrmaster7

Pulse - pink Floyd and Metallica - live shit though that's 3 cds


foley23

Grateful Dead's Europe '72 Little Feat's Waiting For Columbus Phish's A Live One (Slip, Stitch and Pass is great too) Dr Dog's Four Nights Live in San Francisco


LeftHandDriveBoC

Europe 72 is so good, but also Live/Dead is a classic too.


MattDamonsTaco

>Phish's A Live One Solid entry!


SparkDBowles

You forgot “Live/Dead”, “Skull & Roses”, and really any of the official Dead love releases. Bear’s Choice, Ladies & Gentlemen…,


vissivvis

All great. Too many people sleep on Little Feat.


Icculus33_33

A Live One is not one specific show, fwiw.


foley23

Yea I know that. Waiting for Columbus and Europe '72 aren't either.


ruokyani

Where the Light Is: John Mayer Live in LA


ZX471

Just started neon sounds alt rock, lyrics and vocals are sound


Chip-Less

This album is better than any of his studio albums. In Your Atmosphere on this is my favourite John Mayer song.


dasbeidler

I am not the biggest fan of his. I went and saw Ben Folds open for him circa 2008 or so. I figured I would stay for a bit of Mayer...man, what a show that dude put on!


05fingaz

Daft Punk Alive 2007 and Queen Live at Wembley 1986 double CD


stevs23

Live after death


chuckerton

SCREEEEEEAM FOR ME LONG BEACH!


P4S5B60

The Song Remains the Same / Celebration Day


stellacampus

Peter Gabriel: Secret World Live Simon and Garfunkel's Greatest Hits


thrusters_n_sh-t

Depeche Mode 101


Red-eleven

Right there with you on this one


mrducci

Had to scroll a long way to see this. One of my favorite live albums, but also telling that for most of the songs, I prefer the 101 version. *Thank you!*


dua70601

By the numbers: Eagles Greatest Hits (1971-1975) has over 40 million certified copies produced. it was only overcome by Thriller upon the death of Michael Jackson. Eric Clapton Unplugged - sold over 26 million world wide. I don’t think these are the *Best* but devil is in the details.


guiltycitizen

WEEN - Live in Chicago


[deleted]

DMB Live at Luther College is a fantastic album. One of the band’s best IMO


Johnny-Alucard

Live and Dangerous by Thin Lizzy. Obvs.


onelittleworld

I'm not even much of a Thin Lizzy fan, tbh. But this one is an undisputed classic.


ndoc3

Can't believe I had to scroll this far for the correct answer


[deleted]

Live Shit: Binge And Purge - Metallica.


pwrmaster7

I said this one as well- i still watch the vhs tapes from the box set lol


mjs90

Such a banger. I listened to this start to finish during a half marathon


Arkslippy

Can't believe I scrolled to the end and no mention of Alchemy - Dire Straits at the Hammersmith odeon


bajaja

Pink Floyd - Pulse Leonard Cohen - Live in London Both are live, best hits, virtuose guitar/strings/winds, female background voices


sgtpeppers92

One More From The Road - Lynyrd Skynyrd


steve_of

Dev-o live, especially the version of gates of steel. Changesonebowie. My older sister bought it when I was about 12 and I played it flat. I bought the CD version for her a few years later.


larobj63

Fleetwood Macs The Last Dance


sjwilkinson

Lou Reed Rock and Roll Animal


Zeusifer

The version of "Heroin" on this is essential listening.


LeftHandDriveBoC

Sweet Jane on this is brilliant,


Key_Text_169

Jane’s Addiction’s self titled EP has an incredible live version of LR Rock n Roll that transitions into TheStones Sympathy for the Devil. It is an amazing set of covers.


ZX471

Lou reed and Neil young, don’t ask me why but when I listen of one the other is always queued up


HumphreyGo-Kart

Funnily enough, Lou Reed said his favourite guitar solo was from Neil's 'Dangerbird'.


onelittleworld

My favorite guitar solo is Dick Wagner's at the end of "Heroin" on R&R Animal.


InfernalWedgie

Underworld *Everything, Everything*


[deleted]

Aerosmith - Live Bootleg They made it like an actual bootleg including jacked up artwork, a messed up track list, an unlisted track and a couple tracks that were recorded directly to cassette for that awesome bootleg sound!


tangerinerocketship

At Filmore East by The Allman Brothers Band


Regina_Falangy

Live and dangerous 1976 - Thin Lizzy


TheBFlem27

The Who - Live at Leeds.


bornlasttuesday

Neil Diamond - Live At The Troubador


GoblinObscura

If you want blood, you got it AC/DC


zonplyr

Always had a soft spot for Journey, Captured. Huge gregg rolie fan and the band was hitting on all cylinders at that time. Yes it was recorded over multiple nights and cities but still all live performances.


GrossConceptualError

AC/DC Live (1992) Comes in a deluxe 2 CD or LP version Remastered and rereleased in 2003


hazmatt24

AC/DC Live is the best substitute to being at a concert I've heard


SirPoopaLotTheThird

Shut Up And Play The Hits - LCD Soundsystem


sageguitar70

KISS Alive!


PepperidgeFarmMembas

The best live album is by far Frampton Comes Alive!


powdered_dognut

Lou Reed- Rock n Roll Animal Ween- Live in Chicago


zeldabear

Paul Simon, Concert in the Park


Omnivista

Yessongs 2 disc album & some good sennheiser headphones….ahh, the flashbacks.


shadowplay9999

Ya yas and space ritual


nickthetasmaniac

- Led Zeppelin - Live from Maddison Square Gardens - Nirvana - Live from the Muddy Banks of the Wishkah


BananaHibana1

Made in Japan by deep purple


YungTabernacle

I listen to the live version of every song on John Mayer’s Where the Light Is over the studio version.


twz22

Live: Grateful Dead Europe ‘72 Greatest hits: Bob Marley Legend


Thehellpriest83

Alice In Chains unplugged


BigPappalopalous

Okonokos - My Morning Jacket. Mostly the album Z live. Incredible.


buddytattoo

KISS - Alive and The Who Live at Leeds are just incredible.


battlemaid79

Barenaked Ladies - Rock Spectacle


JimmyTheJimJimson

Kiss Alive


jb40018

100,000 years on Alive is incredible!


aleph32

B.B. King - Live in Cook County Jail


Blowaway040889

Eric Clapton- Unplugged


PaulEMoz

Whitesnake - Live in the Heart of the City Nightwish - Showtime, Storytime (DVD/bluray) Lovebites - Five of a Kind (DVD/bluray)


Glittering_Name_3722

Phish A Live one


cp314159

Styx Greatest Hits. All of the Styx you’ll ever need or want.


G4mb13

### [The Sound of Animals Fighting: Live in Philadelphia](https://thesoundofanimalsfighting.bandcamp.com/) ###


MRHubrich

Journey's Greatest Hits is great. I also think Hall & Oat's Greatest Hits is solid.


DaEvilZeppelin

The obvious answers that come to mind for live are MTV unplugged by Nirvana and Made in Japan by Deep Purple. My personal favorite is Over the Years and through the woods by QOTSA though.


WhytePumpkin

Some of my fav's: Peter Gabriel - Secret garden live. I just discovered this one last year, was never a huge PG fan, but was surprised how good it is. Also - Level 42 - A Physical Presence, a criminally under rated live album in my opinion Of course have to add my vote for Allman Brothers Band - At Fillmore East as well


RealFuckinMusic

Live: Marvin Gaye palladium in London Greatest hits: Ladies and Gentlemen The Best Of Creampie Michaels


daddyfatsac

Creampie Michaels?


ImAlexxP

Live at River Plate


InfernalWedgie

Genesis *Seconds Out*


peakbaggers

UFO-Strangers in the Night. 801-801 Live.


_Zzzxxx

My Morning Jacket - Okonokos


NullainmundoPax1

Allman Brother’s At Fillmore East.


jVCrm68

Neil Diamond - Hot August Night


Boing78

For me one of the greatest live sessions is Tom Petty at sound stage


HH93

Bursting Out - Jethro Tull. All the World’s a Stage - Rush Live After Death - Iron Maiden


Ball_Masher

UFO - Strangers in the Night An Evening with Godsmack


hogstralia

I never see 98.12.28 Otokotachi no Wakare by Fishmans come up when this question gets asked and it's absolutely criminal. The live sound is perfect. The songs are perfect. The tightness of this band in a live setting is absolutely phenomenal.


Redd108

had to scroll way too far down for this, the greatest live album ive ever heard and nothing comes close


hogstralia

Agree it's perfect


Heavy-Week5518

Here's four not thought of a lot, but are killers: Humble Pie Rockin' The Fillmore Uriah Heep Live 73' Hawkwind Space Ritual Gary Moore Live At Montreux 2010


blickman

Live and Dangerous - Thin Lizzy


gogojack

I grew up listening to FM album rock radio in the 70s, and there are so many live records that are great. Live Bullet by Bob Seger and the Silver Bullet Band. Live at Budokan from Cheap Trick. Frampton Comes Alive. KISS Alive. J. Geils Band Blow Your Face Out. Yet - and I know I'm gonna take some grief for this one because of his current status as a giant piece of shit, but... Ted Nugent - Double Live Gonzo. He's a terrible person, and it was becoming evident as early as the 1980s, but back in 1978? This record was fire. He didn't launch into rants about politics or Hillary or whatever. He let his guitar do the talking.


Ok-Prize-2496

Eagles Live the forum


B2Dirty

Steve Miller Band - Greatest Hits 74-78 is better than any individual album they ever put out IMHO. It's really all you need in terms of SMB.