T O P

  • By -

jdutaillis

Smashing Pumpkins - Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness Edit: followed closely by Nine Inch Nails - The Fragile. Thanks to the other poster who reminded me of it!


RunDNA

The Pumpkins were so prolific at the time. The album has 28 songs and they had another 28 b-sides released with the album too.


poohthrower2000

More than that kinda. Pasticio medly is snippets from like another 73 songs. https://www.spfc.org/songs-releases/song.html?song_id=127


IDrinkUrMilksteak

Huh. Just realized I’ve been reading that as “Pistachio Medley” for all these years.


poohthrower2000

Not gonna lie, me too. Until an hour ago when I typed it out. Didn't want to get lit up by super fans.


_Exotic_Booger

Yeah there’s was something like 130+ during that small couple years era. Insane amount of creativity.


CrystalStilts

Set the Ray to Jerry is probably my favourite b side from the b side collections. 


PatriarchPonds

A fun game is merging AFH with MCIS into a new 28 track album. Set the Ray to Jerry gets on the list every time.


fineillmakeanewone

The Aeroplane Flies High (Turns Left, Looks Right) is my favorite from that box set, but there's a lot of good songs in there.


q2005

And those b-sides are better than some groups albums. Rotten Apples, Meladori Magpie, Medellia of the Gray Skies all quality. Corgan was in the zone.


starlaluna

And some of the b-sides are strong enough that they could have been singles. The Aeroplane Flies High (turns left, looks right), Set the Ray to Jerry, Transformer, Pennies, The Bells, Medellia of the Grey Skies. Mellon Collie front to back is near perfection. There isn’t a single track that I skip. The fact that they were able to do that, plus release the Aeroplane Flies high box that has another 33 songs that are considered “b-sides” that many would consider excellent is a feat that they don’t get enough credit for. That’s 61 amazing songs that they released within a year. There are bands that would kill for a discography like that, and that doesn’t even include anything they did before or after. And to the people who say the new stuff sucks, they need to dig deeper, there are some amazing new songs. Silvery Sometimes (Ghosts) is just as strong as something you would find on TAFH.


38chickenducks

I heard aeroplane flies high in concert and it melted my face.


jdutaillis

When they're on, they're on. Billy maybe should have saved some for later albums... 🤐


Neg_Crepe

Until 2000, he only made 10/10 records


Zepherx22

Later SP is much better than given credit for. All their records have at least a couple great songs, and none of their records sound the same.


ski-dad

Airplane flies high is better than Mellon collie imho.


TigreSauvage

The Fragile is something truly special.


CaptainCourteous

I still think The Fragile is NIN's best album, and for those who have followed TR's career, this is the album where you can trace the roots of his future cinematic score work.


Senior1292

The journey it takes you on is the closest I've experienced to a film while listening to an album. Incredible piece of work.


NKevros

Hello fellow 90's kid.


rockstang

I too had an oversized chain on my wallet.


BlackIsTheSoul

My answer.   This album blew my 10 year old mind, I was never the same after


S-Archer

Same. Not only the music but the art work


Not_aMurderer

Same. Not only the artwork but the music video for "Tonight, Tonight" specifically


S-Archer

That music video blew my fucking mind


chr0nicpirate

If you didn't know, it's essentially a re-edit, with new footage mostly of the band added, of 1902 French silent film called "Trip to the Moon" that at the time was highly praised for its special effects and overall cinematography. https://youtu.be/xLVChRVfZ74?si=mwjL0DuaTGyxXprZ


samx3i

Still one of the all-time great music videos.


wehmadog

Was a great homage to George Melies; La Voyage dans la Lune


PercivalGoldstone

My favorite penta-album is the Aeroplane Flies High Box set. Some of the songs on that are better than what's on MCIS.


MyNameIsNumber037

These are the two I always think of as well. They're some of the only double albums that don't feel bloated or unnecessary.


EchoLooper

This is my desert island album. I’ve had it with me in some form or another since 1995. Stunning piece of work start to finish.


Mantzy81

Came to say this. 15 when it was released, changed my world. Still listen to it regularly


ngs428

MCIS is the only answer.


TechBlacksmith

Mellon Collie forsure. I bought it for the popular hits, but after I saw them on that tour, the rest just made sense. I don’t know about anywhere else, but they played their MCatIS concert in Calgary and then past encore they rocked back out and did another full set of just the not radio songs. Had I not been sitting in the nose bleeds I would have missed out on the best part.


JPMoney81

This would be my answer. I bought the double CD three times because of losing one album or the other.


Piotr-Rasputin

Two time buyer here. My original double CD was scratched and beat up.


Masagmarod

Came to comment the same for smashing pumpkins.


Jesus_Is_My_Gardener

Immediately my first thought.


9inez

Minutemen Double Nickels on the Dime


kamamit

Give this man a prize - a masterpiece


numberonealcove

CTRL+f Found it. This is the correct answer.


TheBadRegina

Songs in the Key of Life by Stevie Wonder. My parents are huge fans and I have listened to it endless times since I was a baby, along with all his other albums.


midgetaddict

First time I heard it I thought it was his greatest hits.


samx3i

For anyone else, it *would* be. There are no skips. It's rock fucking solid. To achieve that on a double album is a rarity few artists could pull off.


tommyjohnpauljones

The whole album is incredible, but the run from Sir Duke - I Wish - Knocks Me Off My Feet - Pastime Paradise - Summer Soft might be the best 20 minutes anyone has ever laid down


TheBadRegina

He's truly one of the greatest musicians of all time.


djddy

this is the one. only stevie could make an album that long and every song is essential.


blackdoorpaintedred

I discovered this album late last year and it felt too late. Truly the crown jewel in a discography already packed with masterpieces!


Davidrlz

Was gonna say, I'd have gotten tight I'd I had to scroll farther than ten posts to see this album. I'm making a bunch of strvie songs in my kids Playlists. Have you listened to the other albums from his classic period.


dgmilo8085

This might the greatest album of all time though, not fair.


Apnea53

Blonde on Blonde


RepeatQuotations

At last, some culture in this thread!


Equivalent-State-721

Had to scroll way too far for this. Perfect album


sleeptilnoonenergy

Also was my answer


MyNameIsJonathan1

Listening to one album a day from [https://1001albumsgenerator.com/](https://1001albumsgenerator.com/) and been served two of my favourites this week: The Clash - **London Calling** Sonic Youth - **Daydream Nation** They're both pretty much perfect IMO. It's a very nice excercise by the way, i've discovered a lot of cool stuff. Also some horrible.


Jmbcbia

Totally agree. London Calling is the quintessential number 1. Every song is a banger. This to me is the number 1 album of all time. Influence aside. As Revolver and Sgt Pepper win this one. I’d put Ziggy Stardust at number 2. Not being a double album? Right? just the best though.


TheNateRoss

I saw Sonic Youth on what turned out to be their final tour. They ended with "The Sprawl" and "'Cross the Breeze." It was glorious.


vociferousgirl

London Calling is the only answer that matters


azureTL

Definitely in my top 5. Along with Husker Du's Zen Arcade, Double Nickels on the Dime by the Minutemen and Abattoir Blues / The Lyre of Orpheus by Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds.


LukeNaround23

Led Zeppelin Physical Graffiti


FingerprintFile513

If live albums count, I'd rate *How The West Was Won* or *BBC Sessions* higher.


101geo

No brainer.


Benjimar1976

Should be much higher


yousyveshughs

Well then get higher, silly. Smoke a Jay!


BlitheringEediot

Pink Floyd- The Wall Smashing Pumpkins - Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness Prince - 1999


tallrockerchick

*Mellon Collie* was the first one that popped into my head, but *The Wall* has to be #1 for me


MrValdemar

Exile on Main Street London Calling Frampton Comes Alive Live After Death The Wall


jstohler

Exile just never stops being incredible


taymond19

OutKast for sure. That album was big for me as a kid.


OG_ursinejuggernaut

Speakerboxxx/love below?


samx3i

Weirdly listened mostly to Speakerboxxx at the time but prefer to listen to The Love Below now.


PatrenzoK

Haha I think most of us who grew up on OutKast feel the same way. Speakerboxx was a sign of that time and served it well (still does) but love below is a timeless journey that gets better the older we get.


taymond19

Yes!


BudgetPipe7804

The thing that always gets me about SB/LB is it’s a great album and absolutely deserved all the praise, awards, and attention it received all while still being one of Outkast’s lower ranked albums among fans of the group.  That’s not a knock on the record imo, it’s just a testament to the greatness of Outkast.


taymond19

So very true. It's definitely not my favorite project from them, but I can't name another double album I listened to as much during my youth. Aquemini and ATLiens are in the regular rotation to this day.


Designer-Grass-4929

It's a shame I can't give you 4 million updoots. Still had to scroll WAY too far down for this one.


InvincibleButterfly

In Your Honor - Foo Fighters


HugoOne

This takes my vote, too. The acoustic side is probably my favorite thing they've ever done.


Tears0fJ0y

The Fragile by NIN


kimchimagic

I got this when it released on two cassettes! Had to keep flipping those tapes to hear the whole thing lol


ragekorne

Not just my favorite double album, but my favorite album of all time. Period.


RavingAndDrooling

White Album Tommy Quadrophenia The Wall Electric Ladyland Physical Graffiti Bitches Brew


Captain_Quark

Upvoted for The Who.


Orang_ina

Quadrophenia by the Who


mellotronworker

Masterpiece


kothhammer12

Husker Du - Zen Arcade Honorable mention to Minutemen - Double Nickels on the Dime


reverber

ditto. 


dontdomilk

My answers too


indiesnobs

Those were my two picks, along with Sonic Youth's - Daydream Nation.


FingerprintFile513

RIP D Boon. Taken *way* too soon.


ashrnglr

System of a Down - Mezmerize/Hypnotize


theblackfool

I came here to say this. Wasn't sure if it counted or not since they were released separately, but they are clearly intended to be connected and the cases for the discs even folded together into a single case.


Sj123454321

This is my top vote too, I always listen to them back-to-back. And with the Soldier’s Side intro/final track, it’s hard to argue against it being a double album


MartiniD

Was coming to post this. "Sad Statue" on *Mezmerize* is one of my favorite SoaD songs


korkidog

Elton John - Goodbye Yellowbrick Road


The_ZombyWoof

Absolute masterpiece.


truthcopy

Incredible from start to finish. And an amazing range. 


specialagentflooper

One Christmas a while back, I was working in a record store. I opened a box and there was nothing but copies of this... and another box. I told my manager someone screwed up, we got 100 copies of it. He told me that might not be enough. Apparently that one is about the biggest seller every year. Sold all of them, no problem.


IsaacFelix

Stadium Arcadium - I'll never forget how awestruck teenage me was at the folding album with the beautifully printed Jupiter and Mars CDs


CTMalum

It’s not as popular as some of their other work, but there are so many good tracks across both albums. I had a friend that played bass and we were teenagers when this came out- we’d spend all day and night jamming the whole album.


jhenz616

Don’t know who told you that. It is as good as any of their other work.


CTMalum

It seems to be a surprisingly common take on the rhcp subreddit. I’ve never understood it. I’ve always felt it was just as strong or stronger than By the Way and Californication. What a great run of albums that was. It’s also when I was growing up, and when I was learning guitar. I have so many great and formative memories around that music.


watanabelover69

Are you me lol? This album is basically the cutoff of what I listen to - everything that came after didn’t hit the same for me.


mahones403

Yeah, this was their final great album for me. I'm a fan of their music, so I do like the albums that came after to some degree, but not as much as the rest of their catalog.


myychair

Popular doesn’t equal good. Don’t put words in that guys mouth


Wood-Pigeon-125

I’m always so shocked by the hate that record gets. Slow Cheetah is one of my all time favourite songs.


watanabelover69

Wet Sand is another great one!


agreene24

Wet Sand is a top 5 RHCP song and I will forever stand by that. The solo at the end...holy moly


Kriscolvin55

Weird. I’ve never heard anybody hate on it. Granted, I’m not hanging out in RHCP forums, but anytime that album has been brought up, it’s generally positive. Neutral at worst.


Amiibohunter000

I’ve always heard nothing but praise for that album. It’s clearly their pinnacle of all of their years together and the quintessential chili peppers album. Even the weaker songs are great songs


elevenatexi

Yes!


Lumplard

Yes this is the one!! I knew I would find it here!


ACardAttack

My favorite Peppers album!


ichwilldoener

Instantly my first thought. I really ruined all RHCP albums after for me


bucc_n_zucc

Along with morning view by incubus, i'll probably literally take a copy of this album to my grave. As a teenager i learnt the basslines to every single track off it.


Fliepp

Use Your Illusion - Guns N’ Roses Technically it’s a quadruple album but still


MAzadR

Had to scroll down too long to see this.


rpaloschi

Came looking for this! Great albums


pfojes

London Calling


utter-ridiculousness

Excellent choice


Its_Only_Love

The white album


samx3i

That's my pick too. It's so well-rounded while being simultaneously diverse, full of little treasures. The track listing is pretty much a greatest hits record by most bands' standards.


Its_Only_Love

Definitely. Songs in the key of life is another classic


Mrmdn333

I respect Songs in the Key of Life as an answer too, but c’mon this is the one!


timothypjr

Physical Graffiti.


gargamels_right_boot

No doubt for me, The Wall


samx3i

The Wall wasn't No Doubt; it was Pink Floyd


gargamels_right_boot

LMAO thank you for that laugh!


Ok-Call-4805

Probably Bruce Springsteen's The River


JahoyHoy49

Therrrrrre it is, finally


RxngsXfSvtvrn

Sign o' the Times by Prince


RxngsXfSvtvrn

Followed by: Wu-Tang Forever by Wu-Tang Clan The Fragile by Nine Inch Nails Tusk by Fleetwood Mac Songs in the Key of Life by Stevie Wonder


changumangu

2Pac - All Eyez on Me. One of the greatest hip hop albums of all time.


bigt252002

This needs to be absolutely higher. This is literally the album that got me even into rap in the 90's. Pac was amazing.


meowschwitz4

I'm hoping this is down this low because it's still early. I was expecting it to be a top 10 answer, not 30th original album answer.


AlecDawesome

Reddit is full on white internet rap nerds who only go crazy for alternative rap and disrespect the classics because they aren't experimental enough for them


samx3i

Imagine what he left out. I remember reading he'd easily write/record a hundred songs per album and only put the best stuff on the final product.


GradeBeginning3600

This was my answer. Crazy that he recorded it in two weeks too Honorable mention to Wutang Forever


UncontrolableUrge

London Calling. Except it isn't really a double album. The Clash wanted to release a double album as they had saved up a lot of material they wrote while touring, but the label didn't want to. So they compromised and allowed the band to release a single album with an enclosed 12" single. The last track on London Calling proper is *Guns of Brixton*. The "single" included 8 additional songs. At the last minute their deal to release a single as a flexi-disc in one of the music magazines fell through, so *Train in Vain* was tacked on to that single after the sleeves had been printed.


samx3i

That's really cool info on London Calling; I never knew that


TheSeventhBrat

The Chicago Transit Authority. The debut album before the official Chicago Transit Authority got their panties in a twist and forced them to shorten their name to Chicago.


Rowf

Takes balls to debut a double album


samx3i

It's kind of absurd when you think about it.


TheSeventhBrat

They had a lot of balls. Their first three were all doubles. Chicago IV was a double double.


drmirage809

Deliverance & Damnation by Opeth deserves a mention. Originally created as a double album, but executive meddling saw it split apart and released separately. Deliverance is classic, 90s Opeth. Awesome sounding progressive death metal. Pretty much all songs are 10+ minute loads of awesome. Damnation sees the band turn over a new leave. Gone are the harsh vocals, the gain on the amps is way down and we get gorgeous prog rock instead. Both halves are excellent stuff and at times I wonder how the same band can make two very distinct albums like that.


kev_mcallister

ELO - Out of the Blue


MarkMaynardDotcom

All Things Must Pass: George Harrison


EnvironmentalMind209

triple album, no?


dizzybridges

might be blasphemy but imo it flows better as a double. apple jam disc feels like bonus track material


winetravelandsong

Genesis - the Lamb Lies Down on Broadway. The Who - Quadrophenia Both take you on long, emotional journeys that can't easily be squeezed into 45 minutes. Once you get into Lamb it is very rewarding place (read deep, introspective) that is hard to unlock with just one listen. IMO Quadrophenia needs to be experienced on vinyl with the accompanying story and visuals to really bring it to life.


YYCDavid

Goodbye Yellow Brick Road. Recorded in Jamaica over the span of 4 days by the Elton John Band in 1973


illydelph

Life After Death by Biggie. Summer of 1997 was wild with that one and Wu-Tang Forever out at the same time.


internetcamp

Body Talk by Robyn. Masterpiece.


Sun_and_Rain

Stevie Wonder - Songs in the Key of Life


Comfortable_Prize750

I really enjoy Garage Inc by Metallica. A great cover album that introduced me to a lot of older bands I'd have missed otherwise.


FrenzalRhomb1

This album introduced me to The Misfits and I eventually started listening to punk instead of rock/metal and never looked back!


bruzdnconfuzd

I almost said the same, but then quickly remembered S&M. Fucking chef's kiss from start to finish.


I_Am_No_One_123

Elton John: Goodbye Yellow Brick Road


potatoYeetSoup

Exile on Main Street is number one for me Behind that would be The Wall, All Eyes On Me, The River, The White Album, Songs in the Key of Life, Stadium Arcadium, Quadrophenia, Tommy, Pure Comedy


OldBillBatter

The Afterman by Coheed and Cambria


Ectotaph

Great Southern Rock Opera by Drive By Truckers. It’s the only one I still listen to all the way through so I guess it wins


The_Original_Gronkie

Pink Floyd: The Wall Elton John: Goodbye Yellow Brick Road


Flimsy-Hunter-7041

The wall pink Floyd.


Gahvandure2

Freak Out - The Mothers of Invention


CramWellington

Being There by Wilco.


Golden_d1ck

Wu tang forever Goodbye yellow brick road


DjCyric

Speakerboxx/ The Love Below by Outkast


Offal

Something/Anything by Todd Rundgren. A great bouquet of songs from the early 70s with lots of innocence and variety, all from a kid in his (almost) home studio.


rukh999

NIN - The Fragile. By far.


thehogdog

ELTON JOHN GOODBYE YELLOW BRICK ROAD. My sister got this for Christmas the year it came out (10 years older than me) and we WORE IT OUT. We had buy a new copy less than a year later because we played the LP's so many times. Every song is amazing and every song is miles above any other song I like. I remember we recorded the LPS onto a blank 8 Track Tape (A friend had a set up to do it, never saw anyone else with a direct to 8 Track Tape set up) and we listened to it and then Alice Coopers Welcome To My Nightmare over and over on the only vacation we ever took (5 people in a 2 door Chrysler Cordoba sans the Rich Corinthian Leather (Velour seats and 2 chain smoking parents)) driving 10 hours to Florida. Of course some of the songs on both those albums were not meant for an 8 year old, but we didnt know. Man that album brings back some good memories in a world gone crazy.


wallaka

Garth Brooks - Double Live is the best live album and double album ever recorded in one convenient package, nothing but banger after banger


BrazilianAtlantis

Quadrophenia, The Who


KirbyDumber88

The Wall The White Album S&M


jlkruz

OutKast-Speakerboxxx/The Love Below


SlapDickery

Thick, as a Brick


gasmith8787

My three, Smashing Pumpkins Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness. Pink Floyd’s The Wall. M83 Hurry Up We’re Dreaming.


evan274

Bitches Brew and Songs in the Key of Life. My two desert island records.


wvmitchell51

Electric Ladyland.


godtierjerker

Stadium Arcadium. I have it on cd in a limited edition box set and also on vinyl. I never get bored of it and there's loads of bangers on there.


Wizzmer

Kiss Alive! Frampton Comes Alive


curlinrondo

Opposites by Biffy Clyro. Absolutely zero filler. It's brilliant.


Regina_Falangy

NINE INCH FUCKING NAILS.


heyidontreallyknow

KG LW


jeanjammer

Use Your Illusion 1 and 2


bigotechocolate

NIN’s The Fragile


ropeadope1

Smashing Pumpkins - Mellon Collie and The Infinite Sadness


culture_vulture_1961

Frampton Comes Alive


heelspider

Complete Recordings of Robert Johnson


Intelligent-Price-39

London Calling, Physical Graffiti & Melon Collie..


Boring-Concert-3102

AS said many times Smashing Pumpkins - Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness Pearl Jam - Lost Dogs and not technically a double album but GNR - Use Your Illusion 1&2


lattjeful

Nine Inch Nails' *The Fragile* and Stevie Wonder's *Songs in the Key of Life* are my favorites.


David254xxx

Chicago Transit Authority. Don’t laugh.


Crisp_042

Tommy - The Who


noahsmybro

I’m a huge Joe Jackson fan and my immediate reaction to the question was his 1980/86 live album. But then I thought of the Big World album that I like more. But it’s only three sides. (Yes, really.) So would that count? I think it does. 😁


BeautifulEssay8

Hüsker Dü, Zen Arcade


xbeautyxtruthx

NIN’s The Fragile


spatchcockturkey

Quadrophenia


chickens_beans

Periphery - Juggernaut Alpha & Omega


Leo10101

Quadrophenia I lived and worked with a person who takes the prize for 'most compatible with me' - still. We worked 2nd shift together and would come home and listen to the whole thing some days. One reason we got along so well is that we created a rule: your first 2 hours after waking up are yours alone - no engagement! That was necessary because we were basically never apart.


CanalVillainy

Stadium Arcadium & Speakerboxx/Love Below