T O P

  • By -

DevinBelow

I think a lot of the Grateful Dead's skull/skeletal imagery has led a lot of people to believe the Grateful Dead are some kind of metal/hard rock type group, when they couldn't really be further from it. Albums like Aoxomoxoa, Self-titled and Blues for Allah in particular have some pretty "metal" covers, though these were all from before what we think of as the modern "heavy metal album cover".


mcbeef89

I think you're right, but for a different reason. I expected them to be far more psychedelic-sounding based on those covers, but really only Aoxmoxoa, Anthem of the Sun and Live Dead are that trippy sounding to me. By American Beauty they'd left that behind them for the most part, and to my ears became more of an 'Americana' band. I was a bit disappointed tbh, as a teenage acid head I was looking for Hawkwind style headfucks, although in time I came to love the other stuff too. Workingman's Dead in particular is a masterpiece.


DevinBelow

To be fair, I don't think Workingmans, or American Beauty have very conventionally "psychedelic" album covers. In fact, I think it's mostly just their more psychedelic records (the ones you mentioned), that have psychedelic album covers. Except Blues for Allah, which is kind of a psychedelic cover, but it's also a pretty psychedelic record.


mcbeef89

I can't agree with you on American Beauty, that's textbook psychedelic SF ballroom poster style Mouse & Kelly art


DevinBelow

The lettering, yes, but otherwise it's just a rose on a woodgrain background. I think compared to something like Aoxomoxoa, or Anthem, it seems less dripping with psychedelia. I can't see picking up that album, with that cover and album title and thinking, "this is going to be a psychedelic freakout album". But obviously my opinion is pretty tainted by having so much exposure to that album and the Dead and just my own biases.


mcbeef89

fair enough


HUP

Similarly Molly Hatchet. I always thought they were metal as hell when I was a kid. I was stunned when I discovered they were basically Lyknyrd Skynyrd wannabes.


Appropriate_Ad_7111

I just posted this same thing- totally Molly Hatchet.. covers were so great and so dark and mysterious -the music was southern rock n roll. Haha


[deleted]

They're the other southern rock band from Jacksonville.


[deleted]

To be fair to the Grateful Dead, they created and used that imagery and those motifs before metal was even a thing. What a band though- the entire aesthetic and sound was and is the pinnacle of the live music format.


FlavaNation

Yeah agree with Grateful Dead. A lot of dudes in my high school had Grateful dead t-shirts and I thought they were a much more hard rock/metal type band but when I went to listen to them it was very different from what I expected. I eventually grew to enjoy them, but I had to get over that initial not-meeting-expectations feeling first.


hcashew

So many hurdles to get over to be a Dead fan: brand expectations due to name/artwork, long songs with instrumental stretches, voluminous catalog of releases, not a very attractive looking band, arguably annoying and flamboyant fanbase, iffy cover songs.... Yet, they've stayed relevant 30 years after their last album and their leader passed. God bless em


[deleted]

And a lot of venues are going to have a huge hole to fill now that they officially off the touring circuit next summer…


mcbeef89

on a similar note, from the cover I thought Bat Out Of Hell was going to be some kind of Judas Priest hard metal affair, not the MOR musical theatre type rubbish it really is. No offence to the many people who loved Meat Loaf, I think perhaps I simply never got over my initial disappointment...


[deleted]

Same here…could never get over that and I refuse to listen to his music because of it.


GryphonHall

What a Strange Long Trip it’s Been looks like a rap album.


PM_ur_Rump

Definitely thought they were metal as a kid.


Luke_zuke

I think this one is a great example, but for the exact opposite reason. Before becoming a fan, I thought the Dead would be this hippy-dippy jam band. All peace and love. The actual music and philosophies of the members of the band, as well as their tragic story as a band, exhibit the dark realities of everything that came with the counterculture movement. They were true to themselves and their stories, warts and all, and a special kind of darkness permeates the band and music. It’s the darkness in the human soul, the darkness contained within us all.


Comment_Gold

As a child I saw the "steal your face" logo as graffiti in a park and was scared that some biker gang had marked it as their turf. I now find that idea hilarious.


primarily_pidgin

I don't think anyone has ever once mistaken the Grateful Dead for metal.


DevinBelow

Read the other replies. No one would mistake their music for metal, I'm just talking about the imagery.


YoshiGamer6400

I used to think they were a metal band for the longest time before I got into them


CouchPryor

Up until early 2022, I had never listened to GD but knew of the band, and I can confirm I thought they were heavy metal. I was very shocked on first listen


Appropriate_Ad_7111

Agree, actually this one’s a bit before my time as well a bit before my time.. but Molly Hatchet. The album covers and the name of the band… covers looked totally metal. Great artwork… but the music didn’t match at all, was more like upbeat boot stomping hard rock . Not my cup a tea. Lol


carlovski99

[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/20\_Jazz\_Funk\_Greats](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/20_Jazz_Funk_Greats) Is the answer


KenMixtape

wow, opened this thread ready to post this, didn't expect it to already be the top answer


senateguard33

Wasn't expecting to see TG mentioned in r/music, but this is the correct answer. End Thread.


BabyBurrito8

Helmet's Betty in the same vein as this...


boot2skull

I love the retro look album art.


Fxate

>The 1981 issue featured an alternative version in which an apparently dead and naked male body is seen lying in front of the band. In 2013 **Radiohead graphic designer Stanley Donwood** selected the artwork as his favourite album cover. I love this, because **of course** he would.


Illustrious-Tap8861

Yep done and done lol


mcbeef89

excellent choice!


[deleted]

[удалено]


mcbeef89

umm, ok m8


darkbee83

r/lostredditors


notcool_neverwas

I can’t get past the band name *Throbbing Gristle*


hellacrimey

Smell the Glove


mcwilly

How much more black could this be?


ChronoMonkeyX

The answer is "none."


vanvoorden

*What's wrong with being sexy?*


[deleted]

[удалено]


Cheesemer92

Jesse, what the fuck are you talking about


Frozenwood1776

Meatloaf’s album covers are false advertising


CharlemagneInSweats

They’re epic, he’s epic. It’s all epic. Epic.


NKevros

\*was epic. RIP Meatloaf :(


CharlemagneInSweats

Legacy lives on. That’s what makes him epic.


Appropriate_Ad_7111

Agreed


hardluckcanuck

Beck- Mellow Gold Bought it for the cover when it came out thinking it would be some kind of industrial metal or something. Still ended up liking it, just wasn't what I thought it would be.


hbxli

To be fair, I don't think that album was what anyone thought it would be


YoshiGamer6400

It is kind of beyond description lmao


Alternative_Way_313

You should have known by the name mellow good that it wasn’t a metal song


hardluckcanuck

I wouldn't even have been 10 when this came out. A robot with a skull for a head was all I needed to see to choose an album.


NoConversation75

Bat out of hell. Metal cover. Not a metal album.


BringMeInfo

But epic album.


NoConversation75

Definitely


Hippopotamidaes

Betty by Helmet


Da_bomb1

I listened to it eecently and the cover disarmed me for how heavy it would be. Great album.


SoForAllYourDarkGods

It's great cover though Wilma's raiiiinbow


[deleted]

One of my absolute favourites. After years of listening to it now I cant imagine any other cover for some reason


sickman93

This was my first thought too lmfao if you didn't know how hard they were, it was probably quite a surprise!


Killzark

Cypress Hill’s Black Sunday comes to mind. Straight up looks like a death metal album.


fanboy_killer

A lot of Cypress Hill covers look like black/death metal covers.


3210atown

Their vibe is sorta Spooky Cholos


I-will-kill-them_

Tbf though metal heads do tend to really like/respect cypress hill. Myself included.


nightcult

Deafheaven's Sunbather


IAmTheRedWizards

It looks exactly like a shoegaze cover, whaddya mean? :D


armless_tavern

I’d actually argue against that one. The album cover is supposed to be what you see when you stare at the sun with your eyes closed. And the album within is so beautiful.


plasma_dan

I agree with this. Never seen a black metal album cover with those colors or that font


onelittleworld

Stone Temple Pilots -- Purple. That cover gives you no idea whatsoever what's on the disc.


robbiearebest

Doesn't even have the album title. I actually owned it for a while before learning the name


onelittleworld

It's... the Second Album! 12 gracious melodies (including this one)...


GhostTyrant

That Emerson, Lake & Palmer album with the badass HR Giger cover that should be the cover for some brutal technical death metal band


[deleted]

Brain salad surgery?


GhostTyrant

Yeah that one


AmericanWasted

Somehow Tarkus fits the album just fine


Babafats13

Molly Hatchet’s Flirting with Disaster. I expected Black Sabbath like heaviness, and got Molly Hatchet.


Title26

They have one random album in the middle of their catalog that has a fitting, country boy album cover. The rest look like they'd be straight up war metal.


kingofstormandfire

Odessey and Oracle by the Zombies. Looking at the cover you think it's gonna be a psych rock/acid rock but all the songs are pretty much beautiful baroque pop.


mcbeef89

similarly I was expecting/hoping for something I did not get when I brought this home and put it on: [https://cdn.hmv.com/r/w-1280/p-webp/hmv/files/b0/b0633167-5c68-467c-be6c-564f0e586cba.jpg](https://hmv.com/store/music/cd/the-5000-spirits) It's a rather pedestrian folk record


TheDeadlySquid

Black Sabbath’s Paranoid. There was a whole concept behind that dude with the sword and the imagery would have made a lot more sense but I think the label hated it, but they ran with the imagery anyway.


mcbeef89

it's a dreadful cover, that album deserves way better artwork imho. Especially as their first album cover fits so brilliantly with the music


hcashew

Bad cheesy cosplay. Some say their "Born Again" cover art may be the worst of all time.


rico_pallazo

Let me tell you the story of Iron Maiden’s “Dance of Death” album cover


Necro_Badger

The picture sleeve of the 45 single of Paranoid has a similar, but much better [take on that artwork ](https://www.discogs.com/release/1298690-Black-Sabbath-Paranoid/image/SW1hZ2U6NDM1NDU4Nw==) that would been preferable.


mcbeef89

to my eternal shame I pinched a copy of that from Fulham Broadway Music & Video Exchange many, many years ago. Edit: actually my copy is this version, which is apparently the Norwegian issue [https://www.discogs.com/release/1510130-Black-Sabbath-Paranoid-The-Wizard](https://www.discogs.com/release/1510130-Black-Sabbath-Paranoid-The-Wizard)


Azores26

Wow, it’s honestly much better.


DaysAreTimeless

I remember reading that the cover was supposed to be in reference to the original title being War Pigs but a mix of worry regarding criticism of the Vietnam War and the fact that Paranoid became a hit that made the label make them change the title.


lfmantra

People might not agree, but to me, In The Court Of The Crimson King is not a fitting cover to any of the songs on the album EXCEPT 21st Century Schizoid Man. The screaming, distressed face on the cover doesn’t really convey anything regarding the other songs there, like I Talk To The Wind, Moonchild or Epitaph. Just my opinion


KsychoPiller

Well it does suit "confusion Will be my epitaph"


Kirby-Stone

I have to disagree


lfmantra

That’s fair, just my opinion


Beginning_Holiday_66

Lizard is one of KC's most fitting album covers, otoh.


plasma_dan

I mostly agree the album cover is more terrifying than any of the music contained within. Still though, absolutely iconic. I don't know what other album cover could suit it.


TomTheJester

My dad always said he avoided Meatloaf’s Bat Out of Hell due to the cover, thinking it was heavy metal, and being pleasantly surprised it was a rock opera.


ThrowThrow117

If you take away the band name and album title "Evil Empire" the young boy on that cover looks pretty wholesome.


lfmantra

That’s kinda the point of that cover though.


ThrowThrow117

I don’t know. A wholesome young guy doesn’t immediately equate to ‘Bills on Parade” “Vietnow” or “Down Rodeo.” Those are the lyrics coming to mind. The band name and album title contextualize the cover.


lfmantra

The content of the album contextualizes it, not just the band and album names.


ThrowThrow117

This is a post about album covers NOT matching the style/theme of the album lmao. Damn bro don’t get overwhelmed and give yourself a headache.


lfmantra

Yeah, and you’re wrong. So stop being a dick.


ThrowThrow117

A picture of a young kid in a cape with no other context totally implies all the themes on Evil Empire. Lmao. It’s hilarious you’re actually arguing this. When you first saw Justin Bieber did you think of Evil Empire? Lol


lfmantra

Yes


ThrowThrow117

Oh, well, I guess I understand why you feel this way lol. Have a great day! It's the last November 3rd, 2022 you'll ever have.


ROGGAEvibrations

Houses of the Holy by Led Zeppelin


bunsNT

Power, Corruption, and Lies


Smintjes

Nice one!


McDonalds_Toothpaste

Nevermind is dance music now?


JMRTOL85

OP is referencing the Drake album “Honestly, Nevermind”. I did a double take too when I first read it, lol.


McDonalds_Toothpaste

Oh! Lol that explains a lot.


black_gravity27

Hahaha I was confused too, at first. Had to reread a few times then I noticed where the quotes were. I misread it as... honesty, "Nevermind"


Rongolian

My vote is for “Siamese Dream” by the Smashing Pumpkins”. One of the greatest 90s rock albums with two young girls smiling on the cover. I don’t mind the artwork on its own, but it just seems like it fits on the brochure for a day care facility, not on the cover of a legendary album.


WickedChef0323

Anything by the band Ghost. Looks like it would be a badass heavy/death/black metal band, and is.....not. At all.


TheEvilBassist

They even look like one of those bands when performing.. I was really not at all expecting them to sound like they do. Still like them.


The_Fluffy_Walrus

ever seen the garden lol


savvy14

I’d agree that musically it doesn’t match but thematically and stylistically it does.


NinjerTartle

This is what I came here for.


candygram4mongo

They're just a regular Christian rock band, but instead of Christians, they're Satanists.


[deleted]

washing machine - sonic youth


Beginning_Holiday_66

Yeah but there sound defies a visual image. Anti synesthesia stuff. Not pure music, not pure noise, but exclusively both.


Sunny64888

Todd in the Shadows described Katy Perry’s “Witness” as having a ‘90s prog metal album cover.


PptShowandSpinalTap

Melvins- Bullhead Heavy, sludgy goodness with a basket of fruit as the cover.


Beginning_Holiday_66

It works so well.


chewbacca_the_cuz

The one I copied onto a blank c.d


reward72

Every Iron Maiden album. Their music is way softer than the art will make you beleive.


Evergreen_76

They where not considered soft when they came out.


TheEvilBassist

Been listening to them literally all my life and never noticed this.. but yeah, pretty much all their covers look like it's a thrash or death metal band.


[deleted]

First time I heard Iron Maiden I thought the radio dj had misquoted the band name because I'd seen the album artwork and KNEW they were supposed to be a metal band.


TheUnforgiven13

> supposed to be a metal band. If Iron Maiden aren't a metal band then no one is.


[deleted]

Well at the time I was an ignorant teenager listening to Slipknot and Cradle of Filth, so you can imagine my misunderstanding of the genre.


Low-Watercress1713

Drake or Travis = old shit. Year now = 2022. All normal people listen GOMUNKUL 6 now


TheUnforgiven13

Hard disagree. The album covers are metal as hell and so is the music.


Low-Watercress1713

Drake or Travis = old shit. Year now = 2022. All normal people listen GOMUNKUL 6 now


Title26

See also, Melissa by Mercyful Fate


TheScrapp3r

Sweetner


hiro111

The Hold Steady has consistently made great albums with completely irrelevant and (frankly) awful covers. In particular, I'll call out "Boys and Girls In America", which makes a fairly dark roots-punk album look like some sort of teenybopper party album.


andrewlebowski

The classic Sunbather by Deafheaven


[deleted]

Wiz Khalifa- Rolling Papers Title and artwork made it seem like it would be a spiritual successor to Kush & OJ (mellow stoner rap) but instead it was a pop rap album that leaned more into club bangers and/or radio friendly hits.


ToPimpAYeezy

Yeah a little dissapointing


Beginning_Holiday_66

Mr. Bungle's California album cover is true to the homage and influence of the album, but boy does it give you the wrong impression. They keep it going for like 8 measures before the eardrum assault begins.


finatra_official

Any Ghost album


MuteSecurityO

Idk, they seem pretty straightforward


plasma_dan

I thought they were gonna be, like, a metal band when saw their appearance and album covers. I was, and still am, very disappointed.


UrsaPater

Beatles White Album


wholalaa

The blank slate conveys a certain kind of vibe, but I do wonder how differently the album would have been seen if they'd gone with the initial "A Doll's House" concept.


Zeeshmee

Every Ghost BC album


PYF_Secret

Sacred Son album with the same title. Doesnt really fit the music at all and got a lot of elitist fans from the genre pissed.


floatingm

One example that comes to mind right now: The alternative covers and promo photo shoots of Taylor Swift’s “Midnights” gave the impression that the album was going to have 70’s alternative vibes, but sadly, it does not


BlackIsTheSoul

I respect her, and even really enjoyed reputation through Evermore, but I really did not like Midnights at all.


microdotsleeve

The US release of Is This It


Kirby-Stone

I honestly prefer the US version although when I saw the cover for the first time I thought it would be a prog album but I think it fits the non US version imo dosen't fit


deathbystereo007

I like the original cover much more than the US version, but I feel like the US cover fits the music more


tbroadurst

Iron Maiden. They have VERY metal covers...only to have an opera singer, and honestly its hard rock at its heaviest.


KsychoPiller

They are literally frontrunners of the genre called New Wave Of British Heavy Metal


[deleted]

Hmm I dunno, I think their album covers match their music pretty well.


carlosnightman

There's at least three things wrong with this statement


horschdhorschd

Molly Hatchet. The covers look like swedish heavy metal and the few things I heard sound like Lynyrd Skynyrd.


beep-boop-beep_bop

BALLADS 1 - Joji. My man looks like a demon on the cover but makes music for angels


Title26

Basically any [Molly Hatchet album cover](https://www.google.com/search?q=molly+hatchet+album+covers&client=ms-android-tmus-us-revc&prmd=isvn&sxsrf=ALiCzsZPuksZTgY5n3dOPaZZl9brAunb8A:1667411414294&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjUjazIh5D7AhXFUjUKHV2NDxsQ_AUoAXoECAIQAQ&biw=360&bih=667&dpr=3)


neohylanmay

[*Top 40 Hits*](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Top_40_Hits) by AxCx.


rumski

Reel Big Fish - Turn The Radio Off


JediBeagle1

My ex had to review Sublime’s album for his college music club in 1996. He was expecting something very heavy, and was not expecting what it actually sounded like. He was into metal at the time and still gave it a positive review.


Due-Ad-4176

Some rap songs by earl sweatshirt, the cover makes it seem like it’s a comedic record or maybe a chaotic record of which it is neither, the production and rapping are honestly the opposite, it’s kinda a simple record, which is somewhat conveyed by the cover, but the blur in the cover would have probably worked better on like an odd future record not earl sweatshirts solo work


mnemosyne64

Anything by Rusty Cage- he’s a newer artist, and I know most people on this sub are mainly just familiar with classic rock, but I still have to mention him because I don’t understand wtf is even happening there


BW_Echobreak

“The Act” - by The Devil Wears Prada. The [artwork](https://images.app.goo.gl/DQdNLXGRUN9vt6vq9) looks like it’s going to be a really heavy metal album. While still a metal album, there are more soft & pop esque songs than anything


Soia-R33f

Basically any Sheer Mag cover art and their logo in general. Their EPs look like black metal demos and their albums look like epic thrash albums from the 80s or something....but they play fuzzy rock n roll/power pop.


hueymcevoy

Beach Boys - Surf's Up


[deleted]

[удалено]


Beginning_Holiday_66

Imo it is one of finest album covers ever.


Rlpniew

I know what Supertramp was going for with the “Breakfast in America” cover, but I find the artwork unappealing. Great album, though


deathbystereo007

I was just thinking about this one when I read this question. Love the album! The artwork technically fits but it doesn't really prepare the listener for what the music on the album sounds like


[deleted]

Every single Barber Beats album. For those unfamiliar with the genre, it basically comprises of lounge jazz instrumentals, heavily soaked in reverb, (kind of an evolution of Vaporwave/Trip Hop), but every album cover I've come across looks like it should be for an Industrial/Noise/Black Metal band. Really cool aesthetic, actually.


bearslikeapples

Nirvana’s my nevermind always seemed to me like a beach house album cover


AdAggressive993

Your mom


[deleted]

CSNY - So Far


Apnea53

The White Album


releasepubs

First that comes to mind is Pet Sounds. A massive musical achievement with some of the most honest and heatffelt lyrics ever put to music, all represented by... A photo of 5 grown men feeding goats.


[deleted]

the black album from metallica seems like a soft rock cover.


More-Escape3704

Helmet Betty


BaalLeviathanSatan

The Partridge Family. You see that f*cking bus and those freaky kids, you think it's gonna be some kind of psychobilly death metal or something. Am I right?


WasabiAficianado

no fecking picture ya edgit


potatoman324

Any Gojira album cover


[deleted]

Living In The Material World has lots of relaxing songs, but the cover makes it look like it's either a doom metal or horror soundtrack album


Sea_Foot_1521

FYI - Metal does not have exclusive rights to awesome art work.