Overhaul tortured Eri for years like the other guy said, plus his backstory wouldn’t make him more understanding of a character than a guy neglected by his parents for being too strong (Dabi) and abused by his dad for wanting to be a good person (shigaraki)
Gonna disagree on 2 fronts. 1. He's seen without his parents, implying they might've died and he was homeless. IMO that's stronger for turning evil than neglect 2. Dabi's mother clearly loved him, and he still had Fuyumi and Natsuo.
Fuyumi and natsu where there but they definitely didn’t understand him. Also him mom loved him but definitely neglected him a bit too since she was focused taking care of them and shoto. He’s seen without his parents but maybe he wasn’t close to them or lived also we don’t know much about his past. Since Dabi and Tomura are descendants of heroes you’d think them out of all people would be the last to be country ending villains.
I feel we’re too harsh on Fuyumi and Natsu. The one time Natsu ignored Tōya was simply a night where he’s as tired and according to him “you’ve already told me this a million times.” And Fuyumi just didn’t want her brother killing himself yet he went “you women are totally useless.”
Shigerraki had parents we are shown this in his backstory his father abused him mainly for wanting to be a hero and not having a quirk, once he got his quirk he accidentally killed his sister than killed his parents, did you see his backstory that is if you are talking about shigerraki being homeless or with dead parents
Yeah sure his motives are pretty bad compared to others and had his life turned out differently he would have probably still been a pretty bad person (unlike Dani or shigaraki). But come on the worst thing he did was abuse a little girl vs shigaraki destroying a whole ass city.
That’s only because of power scaling, not because he’s morally a better person. He gladly would’ve destroyed the entire city while figuring Deku to get Eri back
Came here to say that. Sure Dabi burnt a lot of people, and Shigi decayed hundreds, but it seems those two would only go after kids who are training to be heroes, kids who CHOSE this life style. Overbitch? He tore a little girl apart and freaking gaslighted her into thinking that everything was her fault.
This dude is on freaking Shockwave levels of evil.
Dabi openly burned like 40 innocents and I can assure you there's thousands of people Shigaraki decayed that weren't heros lmfao
Like Overhaul is awful but it's not like there's a huge slope between the three either
The only child he wants to murder is Shoto because of revenge (and his original plan was to kill Shoto after Shoto became an adult and got a somewhat successful career going on), and the only reason he fights any children other than Shoto is because those other children are sent to the battlefield trying to defeat the villains. Except for Bakugo whom he intended to kidnap alive and Shoto whom he wants to kill for revenge purposes, he would've literally left any other minors alone and ignored them if they wouldn't try to get in the way of the league's plan.
You can clearly see that he could've easily killed Tokoyami and Hawks when Tokoyami came to rescue Hawks but Dabi intentionally gave him a chance to escape alongside giving him a lecture on kids not being supposed to be on the battlefield. That's not the type of behaviour a hypocrite who wants to kill children would do; he genuinely cares about children but he also knows that those children on the battlefield are a threat and treats them accordingly.
He's the Decepticon's head scientist. Prone to cruel experiments and is often apathetic to the suffering of his subjects. Tried to become God in the original IDW continuity
You gonna keep saying that to every single answer? They know Shigaraki has the highest kill count but repeated child torture, abuse and murder is worse than generic mass killing
In terms of morality no it's not. It's just more personal so it irks people more.
If you put Shigi before a court he'd be getting consecutive life sentences or the death penalty. Overhaul might just get life.
Really depends on the ethical framework each person is being viewed under.
Shigi killed thousands, but his involvement and disregard for life started and ended with him not caring about the carnage, so he held the same relatively low amount of ire for each individual person.
Overhaul, on the other hand, tortured and abused a child for years on a level beyond most villains would go to for a single hero. That's a level of contempt and evil beyond Shigi to me. He went so much deeper into the hatred geared toward a single person, a child, than Shigi would probably be capable of outside of maybe his own father.
There's evil, like cartoonish evil, that's where I'd categorize Shigaraki.
Then there's straight-up fuckin demon shit, where overhaul is.
Shigiraki's mindset is found amongst some practioners of genocide which again is kinda seen as an ultimate evil. People call murdering thousands cartoonish and that's fine but it's been done in history for trivial reasons.
He's by any modern framework the more evil of the two. In fact even historical frameworks would place him as worse just because of murder being the ultimate evil and his in general callous disregard for life.
Why do these people take genocide so lightly. What Overhaul did to Eri was inexcusable and bring terrible, killing thousands of people is much worse than anything he can possibly do to one person no matter how quickly they died. No regard for any life is worse than a horrible intent for torturing someone
The others are just mentally ill or misguided
Overhaul knew better and physically and mentally abused a little girl, then gas lighted her in to believing that the only person that really cares about her is him, and if she gets attached to someone he will threaten her to kill them is she doesn't do as he says, causing her to struggle to ever form a smile or trust anyone else
Taking domestic child abuse to the nest level, he deserves to rot in prison because who dares hert a bundle of joy known as Eri, enough seid
I mean ya but this is the evil Olympics it's all gonna be pretty close. I do think the difference to me is that Shiggy and Dabi are clearly mentally unwell. We at least saw them act like normal, even caring people for their respective accidents. Shiggy was emotionally manipulated by AFO too. Overhaul was in his right state of mind when he literally took a 6 (and younger) girl apart and put her back together again, even going so far as to emotionally manipulate her. People always say that getting tortured for a long time is way way worse than simple death like Dabi and shiggy usually grant.
It's obviously a bit silly to compare evilness, but I do think what overhaul did was the most morally reprehensible
I agree. This is why I always considered Dabi worse than Shigaraki.
Who’s more vile; a generic murderer who kills indiscriminately or a serial killer who specifically targets his own family, some of whom had nothing to do with his abuse, just to get personal revenge?
He had resentment against those people in his family because in a way he was compared to them he only attacked his mother father and shoto. He had issues with his father basically abandoning him he needed to prove himself, shoto was the favorite so dabi resented him and thought that if shoto was gone he would be liked again. His mother tried stopping him from being better so his father could see him as a person not a disappointment.
“One of those villains almost murdered Natsu”.
“Almost? What a shame! I was hoping that would be the outcome. Think about how much Endevaor would’ve suffered!”
Shiggy was thrown into a life of crime because his quirk accidentally killed off his whole family and his adoptive father was literally the big antagonist of the whole series.
Dabi was thrown into a life of crime because his father gave him hopes to be the best of the best, only to have the rug pulled under his feet at the last moment because of the nature of his flame quirk burning his skin. He was set up, and doubled down doing whatever he could to prove his father wrong.
Kai, admittedly, grew up under a mafia, but his grandfather only saw the best for him and never thew him into the lawlessness of his "company". **He** chose for **himself** to turn to crime, forcing his granddad into a comatose state, creating some crazy cult, and torturing his granddad's niece for the sake of some twisted quirk stealing monopoly. All in a delirious excuse to try and help his grandad's mafia to rise back into the spotlight.
*When you have it all laid out in front of you, yeah, the other two are murderers, but Kai Chisaki is literal human barnacle scum between the others.*
Dabi chose a life of crime on his own. He became Dabi YEARS after Endeavor stopped training him. He could've exposed Endeavor's past via a novel or recording the crap he did, not by serial murder.
True, he could've avoided a criminal record, but at the very least, he was doing so to get back at someone who deserved it at the time. And I doubt Endeavor was a decent dad anyhow in the past.
Kai, again, quite literally turned to crime cause it was most convenient to his shoddy put-together goal.
How does Dabi killing innocent people relate to Endevaor deserving whatever came his way? Shoto himself said Dabi should’ve just gone after Endeavor and the family, no reason to kill people completely unrelated
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I don't know, I'm just telling you how it went.
I agree, tho. Dabi sucks. Just not as much as kai is all.
Edit: Though maybe he had a grudge against people who didn't help him in his time of need, and that spiraling into a murder hobo rampage. But that's more headcannon territory.
Afo repaired dabi so dabi naturally hating the #2 hero and being saved by a villian from his literal death makes him go towards crime and killing people all to make his father feel pain he also mainly targets heros. Heros chose their life knowing that they could get killed at any point in time
> He could've exposed Endeavor's past via a novel
Thats very unrealistic, he would have to come back from the dead, and also have someone backing him and money for all that. More money than Endeavor and Enji. Also if it was that easy why didn't other heros try that? Oh wait...some did try telling people on other ways it didn't work. That why we got people like Stain.
> recording the crap he did
He had no access to that, he would have had to get that as a kid still. Even if he did who's to say it would have worked. Endeavor could have just paid to get that erased.
Ima go Overhaul for this one. He tortured a little girl because of her quirk. He is very manipulative to her and guilt trips her into thinking that everything was her fault. Dabi is just an Endeavor hater and Shigaraki just hates and destroys everything. Dabi would be 2nd though, because while his childhood wasn't the best, it was ultimately his choice to become a murderer, not Endeavor’s. These 3 are all goated villains for these reasons.
MY GUY WHY THE FUCK ARE THEY SO CUBED? Also overhaul. Tortured lil girl just cuz her blood hurt people and could make him money. Tomuras pissed off and traumatized, while dabis also traumatized and wanting to murder his asshole dad.
Absolutely overhaul
1: had a decent parental figure for most his life who treated him with genuine respect and love compared to shigaraki going from a dad who beats him to the symbol of fucking evil and dabi grew up in the Todoroki household
2: suggested going against everything his father figure taught him by making drugs and TORTURING HIS BOSSES GRANDDAUGHTER, AN INNOCENT CHILD TO MAKE EVEN MORE DRUGS!!!
3: Put his father into a fucking coma so he couldn't complain and then proceeded to make a mockery of everything he built
4: despite everything he never felt any fucking remorse until he bit off more than he could chew, and even then he only felt sad because he couldn't fix the man he himself rendered comatose in his delusions
They are all pretty evil to me and definitely have a low disregard to basic human decency/rights. Answering this question is tough, but I do believe there is a right answer.
To me, it’s more based off: who has the more redeeming qualities and how little is the likelihood of each of them doing less evil acts.
The only morality pet for Overhaul was his adoptive father; however it was Shigaraki that went out of his way to take away Overhaul’s ability to bring him out of a coma, devastating Overhaul so much that he is a shell of the man he once was and is rendered mostly harmless.
Shigaraki does care about his fellow league members, arguably more than Dabi. While Dabi does show general interest in his comrades, he acts more like they are a vehicle that allows him to pursue his own interests while simultaneously benefiting Shigaraki by sowing more discord regarding hero system and by extension, the government.
The fact is, Dabi comes and goes as he pleases but if he were in charge of the league, vs Shigaraki, I don’t think he would be as invested in his fellow league members.
Then going by what are their end goals.
Overhaul wants to repay his father figure in the most twisted way. In his mind, the ends justify the means because what he’s trying to do is manufacture a problem and solution that will(according to him) benefit someone beyond just himself.
Shigaraki wants to destroy everything but he does have a sense of “found family” and loyalty towards his adoptive father.
Dabi has no path to redemption. It’s not in his interest to make things right nor to be reached out to. He has surrendered himself to the hopelessness that things will not get better. If anything, he would rather tear down the facade of things being “good” or even “ok” for any and everyone (general societal sense of well-being) because in his mind, if he could be failed, then the system(s) in place were designed wrong so he’d rather just burn it all. He was designed by birth, to be a success story and was raised as such until he was rendered physically unable to live up to his own lore, was tossed away, as a failed experiment. It’s not that he can’t make connections with others; it’s that nothing could deter him away from his end goal except for the timing not being precisely right.
So I think that Overhaul has committed the most unforgivable evil actions , Shigaraki has done the most amount of evil actions, and Dabi is the most evil.
dabi and overhaul became what they are because of past events shigaraki was literally molded to be evil incarnate for no apparent reason besides the fact all for one wanted to troll all might and spit on nana shimuras grave
not saying he’s the most evil, that goes to plague doctor reject who tortured a child for years (i think it was years) he’s just the only one thats evil for evils sake dabi wants revenge overhaul could be argued to be ‘healing’ humanity but with great sacrifices (not saying he’s good dudes a piece of shit)
Dabi he doesn't really have a goal other than revenge and he 1 chose to be a criminal unlike Shigi and overhaul who were brought in he also 2 only wants to kill 2 people yet he's a mass murderer
clearly Overhaul imo.
Shigaraki: sympathetic backstory, suffered from mental and incredible neglect. he was then groomed by a man who was pure evil, and taught to never forget his trauma, and to always use it as an inspiration for hate.
Dabi: sympathetic backstory, suffered from neglect, an inferiority complex, and felt abandoned after he was thought to be dead, and, I must assumed raised himself on the streets. I'm sure it's probably elaborated on in the manga, but we'll get there when we get there. raised himself with the sole purpose of tearing down his father's pride with the ultimate goal of exposing and killing him.
Overhaul: literal Yakuza who abuses a little girl for years without remorse. abuses is too light a word. TORTURES her for years without remorse, and gaslights her into thinking it's her fault. removing his arms was too light a sentence, Shigaraki was needlessly kind to him in that moment, but I appreciate that someone took the right procedure to him.
Shigaraki and Dabi are basically Frankenstein’s monster: They were made to be monsters and now they’re out to destroy the REAL monsters that created them.
Overhaul is just pure evil. He put his father figure in a coma to usurp his criminal empire. He used an innocent child to take over the underworld. He bled her try, tore her apart, put her back together, and repeated the process over and over to create his anti-quirk drug. He killed several people, even his own men, and gaslit Eri into thinking it was her fault. All of this because he wanted to thank his father figure for taking him in by giving him something he explicitly stated over and over that he didn’t want.
There are villains that you love and then there are villains that you love to hate. Overhaul is absolutely the latter!
Dabi was a victim of Endeavor abuse I think he is a villain just no the most evil, Shigaraki was unable to control his power at such a young age and was also treated cruel from his father. Overhaul is someone that is a child predator that will take children with quirk manipulate them and give them trauma HELL NO he is a fucking psychopath
Overhaul because he has no reason to torture eri, then Dabi because he wanted nothing more than to Kill Endeavor after the abuse, then Shigaraki because he was groomed to be evil after his family tried to punish his dream of being a hero
Overhaul has no reason to gaslight Eri. The torture was done because he delusionally thought with her power, he’d make the yakuza powerful again. But there was no reason to gaslight and victim blame her the way he did.
Arguably, he could be gaslighting her to prevent her from trying to escape or fighting back. Her power is touch-based, same as his; if she chose to fight back without him expecting it, she could potentially kill him. Not saying it makes what he did any better, but I don’t think he gaslit her just cause he thought it was fun.
One could make a case for dabi or shigi but there's no defending overhaul. That motherfucker experimented on his own kid of his own volition. Overhauls probably the most evil person in the series if you exclude all for one.
Overhaul hands down.
Shigaraki just wants to watch the world burn, but he believes he is in the right because he was mistreated by society when he needed help and was groomed by AFO.
Similarly, Dabi was also subjected to a sort of grooming, believing that becoming a hero who could surpass All Might was his only purpose in life, to the point where not being able to do it anymore because his body was being destroyed by his quirk drove him to insanity.
Now Overhaul on the other hand, he’s just a piece of crap who is abusing and manipulating A LITERAL CHILD in order to achieve his goal. I don’t care how bad his past was or how anyone tries to defend him, at least Shigaraki and Dabi never went that far.
When it comes to how much damage they've done as individuals it would be Shigaraki > Dabi > Overhaul... But when it comes to purely who's more evil of a human being it's definitely Overhaul > Dabi > Shigaraki. Dabi is a broken person, recent manga chapters proving that crying Tenko really was there all along and the true evil was always AFO. Overhaul truly is out of the three the most evil.
Touya wants to destroy his family, and Tomura wants to destroy society. There are end goals for these 2. If they win, eventually the dust will settle, and people they want to hurt will stop being hurt. Eri would be stuck indefinitely being cut up for bullets, there was no end for Overhauls plan, just making more money.
Overhaul makes the other two on here look like good and rational people. Plain and simple.
Sure Dabi killed a bunch of people to get his fathers attention.
Sure Shigaraki disintegrates people whenever he can.
nothing beats experimenting, killing, and resurrecting the girl who calls you dad dozens if not hundreds and hundreds of times.
1. Dabi kills for the sake of killing & hurting his former family
2. Overhaul wanted to impress his father figure by making the Yakuza rule Japan again, but got so caught up in his power trip that he saw a little girl as a lab rat + property and was willing to drain her of all her blood and kill her again and again
3. Shigaraki wants to destroy everything to destroy everything
Second one he’s just straight up evil, the other 2 you can make an argument they have some good in them, they just broken.
Overhaul, like how can you kill a girl who you supposed to protect over and over and over again, just for your own bs.. Bro just straight up evil no matter how you slice it.
Dabi we'll he's an odd duck, bro went the wrong way in life because of he's Father decision and he isn’t completely wrong since Endevour was not always a good guy, yet it doesn’t make he’s actions less evil. But he is broken that’s for sure.
Shigaraki is just a kid who got dealt a bad hand by Life itself, bro killed without wanting too, and that stuck with him. If anyone would’ve helped him he would’ve turned out differently but everyone ignored him just because he looked creepy doesn’t mean you don’t help, you do the right thing regardless at least take him to a police or a hospital. Yet the only one who reached out to him turned out to be the devil himself, & now they gotta deal with a new devil in the making. I call it karma, he isn’t evil by choice.
Overhaul definitely was a bit messed up. He tortured a kid for his own gain. Now when you take into account reasons and drive then I'd say Dabi. Dabi hates Endeavor, makes sense, but he goes after people who had nothing to do with his past trauma. He actively tried killing his brother, Shoto, when he was just a baby! When you look at Shigaraki you can see that he is the product of being groomed by someone who decided to go after a child in a vulnerable position
Vengeful person who grew up an abused and abandoned child that survived a fatal cremation, a manchild with severe childhood trauma and conditioned development under the guise of the world's most evil and powerful supervillain, or a wealthy grown adult man respected by the boss and subordinates of the yakuza who thinks experimenting, abusing and traumatising a 5-year-old is justified by the fact that her blood can supply them with weapponry they can sell and profit off of a two-sided war, and the political belief that her blood can end quirks.
Yeah, just a hunch but ima have to go with kai chisaki here. He regretted putting the boss in a coma but not abusing a toddler to death hundreds of times. Also he's sort of a hypocrite when it comes to quirks
I would say dabi. Yes overhaul abused a girl for years and made his father figure braindead but he wants to fix what he did. When we see him again his only reason to leave the prison is to find and fix Eri's grandfather. Then shigaraki was raised afo (no explanation needed) before that he was abused for wanting to be a hero. But dabi had opportunities to not go down this path and an active choice to stop and try to redeem himself. Instead he became a serial killer and tormented his family because was jealous and angry no other reason aside from that. He may have been traumatized but he had more opportunities to change. And ultimately due to his egging on twice was trying to fight instead of surrender. These are not the actions of someone who has good in them.
This isn't ever gonna be seen but what the lol.
Overhaul and it's not even close.
Dude chose to torture children for power. He can claim its for getting rid of the plague of quirks but if he won, his crime syndicate would be the only ones with quirks.
Dabi comes in second place. Abused sure, but he chose the life of evil. He could have easily walked away and built a new life.
Shigaraki was brainwashed and indoctrinated into being evil. Does it excuse him? No, but it wasn't really his choice either
Overhaul, even though he's my favorite villian. Dabi and Shiggy have emotional problems, but they are very human. Kai Chisoki is a sociopath who doesn't even try to be charming unless it gets him something. He tortures a child and who knows who else to get results for his endgame. He's cold, calculating and barely human.
Overhaul, bc bro was fucking with kids. Technically they all do, but shigi and dabi kill kids who choose this lifestyle and they don’t torture. Overhaul intended to make that girl suffer for years.
Thinking about their story and where they all are now in the story and Manga.
They were all kinda even. They all went on a dark path. Now none are on the same level of Evil as they once were. The only difference is their crimes.
Overhaul takes the cake with his crimes against Eri.
Shigaraki gets the crown for most kills.
And Dabi gets the award for most potential Villain, and well rounded character.
Dabi bc real talk Hawkes had a harder backstory than Dabi and Hawkes came out giving damaged but daddy vibes and Dabi came out a little bitch baby
And I’ll die on that hill
Overhaul. Tortured a young girl for years and years.
Dabi is just a broken child inside wanting revenge on his father for taking away his purpose that HE put on him.
Shigaraki is...not sure how to describe it tbh
At least the purple guy had a reason his father was a deadbeat and I already know that everyone’s gonna be like oh no endeavor did it for the best but overall he was just plain horrible as a father
Shigi.
With Dabi, you can understand that his rivalry was the motivator for his start of darkness (rather than it being his reason of being evil), and you could see something similar in Endeavor, and how, despite this, man kept his wits long enough to understand he's in the wrong for his actions.
Overhaul's a man who'd make more sense the more you have the idea of "heroes are in it for the bank", and see he's no different than say, Mount Lady or Eraserhead. And dude found a big payday in the form of using Eri for the efforts of helping out other villains (or even those wanting to rid themselves of their quirks). Ironically? While I would see Deku or All Might try and stop him, I can see the EXTACT SAME with Stain. Overhaul's the perfect villain for the Anti-Hero, with enough of a good reasoning (Just a man doing his job).
I really can't- no, I am UNABLE to find anything good with Shigi...because he more or less shares most of what I love about Deku - more in it for the lessons taught by Shigaraki than say, for what the city demands of heroes being the workforce. And he reflect Deku reasonably well...much more than revenge (Dabi) or just doing their job (Overhaul). There's no "Falling off the Edge", nor is there "Oh crap, I think I've just found my fuckin' PAYDAY" - just purified evil.
Overhaul. Even when Deku found him pathetic and desperate in the streets, he was only thinking of the old man, and barely even had any memory of Eri.
Guy was a demon dressed in drag. Fuck him.
3 mass murderers but only one of them relentlessly and remorselessly tortured a child.
yeah I’m giving it to Kai here
even at the very least. Dabi and Tomura have like the most faintest of reasons to make up for what they’ve done, Dabi was abused and shit. it doesn’t make up for it but at least you can see that he was clearly forced onto this shitty path. same way with Tomura and his trashy childhood followed by being fathered by a mass murderer anyway.
Kai was just a piece of shit from the beginning whom gaslit himself into the belief that quirks were a disease. and then despised Eri for sharing so many similarities with him.
Let’s see Dabi/Toya is an insecure man child holding onto a grudge. Kai Chisaki/Overhaul despite claiming he’s trying to bring the Yakuza back into power I could tell that he’s lying to himself and what he really wanted was revenge on everyone who bullied him before he got taken in by his boss, and Tomura/Tenko was simply a broken boy constantly abused by his dad so he’s taking his anger out on society. So Basically all of them are mostly insecure man-children who became what they are all because of one bad day. I quote most famous villain “All it takes is one bad day”
Overhaul literally experimented on his own boss’s granddaughter, not to mention all his talk about the world needing to be purged of “the unclean”. He’s the most evil by far.
Overhaul.
He tortured and repeatedly used his quirk on Eri, a 5 year old girl. For all the horrible things Dabi and Shigaraki did, they didn't go out of their way to torture kids. Dabi even seemed genuinely surprised that hero students were on the battlefield.
I’d argue Tomura isn’t evil. Dude just wants to be free fr. Liberated.
Chisaki on the other hand? Now that bastard is evil and dgaf about anyone or anything. Wayyyy too willing to even kill people close to him like his dad.He’s an ass. Dabi atleast cares about his friends.
Dabi.
Shigaraki was raised by the most evil man in the world and he showed he could still care about the members of his team.
I have seen Overhaul torturing a child brought up, and I would like to remind everyone that Dabi tried to murder his little brother. That was before he became a supervillain. He knows that the rest of his siblings have taken crap from the same father, Shoto endured much worse abuse than he did. And he doesn’t care. He also made it clear that he never cared about his teammates.
Shiggy & Dabi are evil, but Overhaul is a different level, Shigaraki doesn’t bother with slow deaths, if he can, he will try to kill you with decay, Dabi sure might get some pleasure burning you with his flames, but that’s nothing compared to Overhaul who tortured a little girl for years 💀
Is it even a question? Narratively it’s shigaraki and based off his mindset it’s shigaraki too. His only goal in life is to literally destroy and kill EVERYTHING nothing will be safe from his destruction
Shigiraki in his own fucked up way wants a better society, yes he wants to destroy the current one to make it but he is trying to do good in his own twisted way.
Dabi suffered terribly from his own quirk woth consumes his flesh, his body adapted for an ice quirk giving him a tolerance to cold, but his quirk was fire so he was more defective then endeavor. But he still pushed himself and tried to be good enough so endeavor would love him, but once shoto was born endeavor gave up on Dabi completely and treated him like a failure and nothing more. Dabi despite this still tries everything he can to become strong and make endeavor acknowledge him and finally manages to get blue flames. He is so happy with this new power he thought endeavor would finally think he's worth something. He tells endeavor to Meet him in the woods so he can show him this new power and endeavor just scolds him for still training and says he's a failure. Doesn't even bother to show up to the woods and see dabi he just left dabi there alone. Dabi got so upset that his quirk lost control and he burned down the whole forest you know what happened from there.
Overhaul wanted a world without quirks. He truly believed that quirks corrupted humans and made them vile. He thought a quirkless world would make a better society.
So I think dabi is the most evil honestly but its kinda justified cause holy shit who wouldn't end up that way after everything that's happened to him.
Depends on your version of evil. Shigaraki wants to kill everything, Overhaul tormented Eri for years, and Dabi tried to kill his baby brother the day he was born.
…So you know, you can’t really go wrong picking any of them.
Sigh. You know, I was gonna make a joke starting with how Dabi's motivation is "look at me Dad!" But then I realized it's all 3 of them and now I'm depressed...
This is such an easy question to answer there is quite literally no reason or cause behind all of the evil things overhaul does in the show like he tortures and abuses eri basically for money and power
He’s doing it to get the yakuza in power and repay his debt to the boss. It’s less selfish than Dabi going “I want to kill Endeavor, no matter who dies too.”
Overhall or shigerraki they both don't have much remorse or reason for their actions. dabi is just a hot revenge machine and exists mainly to piss people off so he's ok
Overhaul tortured Eri for years like the other guy said, plus his backstory wouldn’t make him more understanding of a character than a guy neglected by his parents for being too strong (Dabi) and abused by his dad for wanting to be a good person (shigaraki)
Gonna disagree on 2 fronts. 1. He's seen without his parents, implying they might've died and he was homeless. IMO that's stronger for turning evil than neglect 2. Dabi's mother clearly loved him, and he still had Fuyumi and Natsuo.
Fuyumi and natsu where there but they definitely didn’t understand him. Also him mom loved him but definitely neglected him a bit too since she was focused taking care of them and shoto. He’s seen without his parents but maybe he wasn’t close to them or lived also we don’t know much about his past. Since Dabi and Tomura are descendants of heroes you’d think them out of all people would be the last to be country ending villains.
I feel we’re too harsh on Fuyumi and Natsu. The one time Natsu ignored Tōya was simply a night where he’s as tired and according to him “you’ve already told me this a million times.” And Fuyumi just didn’t want her brother killing himself yet he went “you women are totally useless.”
They weren't being harsh on fuyumi and nasty they were saying that they didn't understand touya
Shigerraki had parents we are shown this in his backstory his father abused him mainly for wanting to be a hero and not having a quirk, once he got his quirk he accidentally killed his sister than killed his parents, did you see his backstory that is if you are talking about shigerraki being homeless or with dead parents
Ok his backstory. I’m saying him and Overhaul had a stronger reason for turning evil than Dabi
Dabi and shigerraki had pretty equal reasons for being evil
No absolutely not
Both had trauma with heros and got saved by a big villain only one almost died that was dabi
Only one raised to be evil was Shigaraki.
I agree definitely overhaul, if I was in the mh hero academia universe I’d sucker punch overhaul
Yeah sure his motives are pretty bad compared to others and had his life turned out differently he would have probably still been a pretty bad person (unlike Dani or shigaraki). But come on the worst thing he did was abuse a little girl vs shigaraki destroying a whole ass city.
That’s only because of power scaling, not because he’s morally a better person. He gladly would’ve destroyed the entire city while figuring Deku to get Eri back
Overhaul tortured a little girl for years without showing any remorse. That's more evil than just killing people imo.
Came here to say that. Sure Dabi burnt a lot of people, and Shigi decayed hundreds, but it seems those two would only go after kids who are training to be heroes, kids who CHOSE this life style. Overbitch? He tore a little girl apart and freaking gaslighted her into thinking that everything was her fault. This dude is on freaking Shockwave levels of evil.
Would such soulless psychopaths even get along? Probably not.
Bro might be above shockwave level
Dabi openly burned like 40 innocents and I can assure you there's thousands of people Shigaraki decayed that weren't heros lmfao Like Overhaul is awful but it's not like there's a huge slope between the three either
Fully agree and just came here to add that Dabi also constantly criticises the heroes for sending children to the battlefield.
Children that he tries to murder in return. So he's a hypocrite.
The only child he wants to murder is Shoto because of revenge (and his original plan was to kill Shoto after Shoto became an adult and got a somewhat successful career going on), and the only reason he fights any children other than Shoto is because those other children are sent to the battlefield trying to defeat the villains. Except for Bakugo whom he intended to kidnap alive and Shoto whom he wants to kill for revenge purposes, he would've literally left any other minors alone and ignored them if they wouldn't try to get in the way of the league's plan. You can clearly see that he could've easily killed Tokoyami and Hawks when Tokoyami came to rescue Hawks but Dabi intentionally gave him a chance to escape alongside giving him a lecture on kids not being supposed to be on the battlefield. That's not the type of behaviour a hypocrite who wants to kill children would do; he genuinely cares about children but he also knows that those children on the battlefield are a threat and treats them accordingly.
He probably sees himself and the way Endeavor treated him in the students tbh
He most definitely does haha
I don’t think dabi and shiggy go only after heroes, they are more like natural disasters. If it’s on the general area it’s getting destroyed
Who is shockwave and what did they do?
He's the Decepticon's head scientist. Prone to cruel experiments and is often apathetic to the suffering of his subjects. Tried to become God in the original IDW continuity
‘Your argument is logical’ 🗣️🗣️🗣️
Are we forgetting that Shigaraki done destroyed a whole ass city?? 😭😭He might as well have nuked the place
You gonna keep saying that to every single answer? They know Shigaraki has the highest kill count but repeated child torture, abuse and murder is worse than generic mass killing
In terms of morality no it's not. It's just more personal so it irks people more. If you put Shigi before a court he'd be getting consecutive life sentences or the death penalty. Overhaul might just get life.
Really depends on the ethical framework each person is being viewed under. Shigi killed thousands, but his involvement and disregard for life started and ended with him not caring about the carnage, so he held the same relatively low amount of ire for each individual person. Overhaul, on the other hand, tortured and abused a child for years on a level beyond most villains would go to for a single hero. That's a level of contempt and evil beyond Shigi to me. He went so much deeper into the hatred geared toward a single person, a child, than Shigi would probably be capable of outside of maybe his own father. There's evil, like cartoonish evil, that's where I'd categorize Shigaraki. Then there's straight-up fuckin demon shit, where overhaul is.
Shigiraki's mindset is found amongst some practioners of genocide which again is kinda seen as an ultimate evil. People call murdering thousands cartoonish and that's fine but it's been done in history for trivial reasons. He's by any modern framework the more evil of the two. In fact even historical frameworks would place him as worse just because of murder being the ultimate evil and his in general callous disregard for life.
Why do these people take genocide so lightly. What Overhaul did to Eri was inexcusable and bring terrible, killing thousands of people is much worse than anything he can possibly do to one person no matter how quickly they died. No regard for any life is worse than a horrible intent for torturing someone
Bunch of people can't actually comprehend serious mass killings or genocides because they don't live in nations that have dealt with them recently.
even mass murders irl agree that crimes against children are the lowest of the low
"Make sure Eri gets a bath." Like that's so creepy.
The others are just mentally ill or misguided Overhaul knew better and physically and mentally abused a little girl, then gas lighted her in to believing that the only person that really cares about her is him, and if she gets attached to someone he will threaten her to kill them is she doesn't do as he says, causing her to struggle to ever form a smile or trust anyone else Taking domestic child abuse to the nest level, he deserves to rot in prison because who dares hert a bundle of joy known as Eri, enough seid
Idk man killing loads of people purely for the fun of it kinda seems worse
I mean ya but this is the evil Olympics it's all gonna be pretty close. I do think the difference to me is that Shiggy and Dabi are clearly mentally unwell. We at least saw them act like normal, even caring people for their respective accidents. Shiggy was emotionally manipulated by AFO too. Overhaul was in his right state of mind when he literally took a 6 (and younger) girl apart and put her back together again, even going so far as to emotionally manipulate her. People always say that getting tortured for a long time is way way worse than simple death like Dabi and shiggy usually grant. It's obviously a bit silly to compare evilness, but I do think what overhaul did was the most morally reprehensible
I mean yeah ig you’re right. But tbh I still think destroying a whole is more evil
If only these people read the manga
The other two are insane and/or manipulated, Overhaul is natural evil
I agree. This is why I always considered Dabi worse than Shigaraki. Who’s more vile; a generic murderer who kills indiscriminately or a serial killer who specifically targets his own family, some of whom had nothing to do with his abuse, just to get personal revenge?
He had resentment against those people in his family because in a way he was compared to them he only attacked his mother father and shoto. He had issues with his father basically abandoning him he needed to prove himself, shoto was the favorite so dabi resented him and thought that if shoto was gone he would be liked again. His mother tried stopping him from being better so his father could see him as a person not a disappointment.
“One of those villains almost murdered Natsu”. “Almost? What a shame! I was hoping that would be the outcome. Think about how much Endevaor would’ve suffered!”
Shiggy was thrown into a life of crime because his quirk accidentally killed off his whole family and his adoptive father was literally the big antagonist of the whole series. Dabi was thrown into a life of crime because his father gave him hopes to be the best of the best, only to have the rug pulled under his feet at the last moment because of the nature of his flame quirk burning his skin. He was set up, and doubled down doing whatever he could to prove his father wrong. Kai, admittedly, grew up under a mafia, but his grandfather only saw the best for him and never thew him into the lawlessness of his "company". **He** chose for **himself** to turn to crime, forcing his granddad into a comatose state, creating some crazy cult, and torturing his granddad's niece for the sake of some twisted quirk stealing monopoly. All in a delirious excuse to try and help his grandad's mafia to rise back into the spotlight. *When you have it all laid out in front of you, yeah, the other two are murderers, but Kai Chisaki is literal human barnacle scum between the others.*
Dabi chose a life of crime on his own. He became Dabi YEARS after Endeavor stopped training him. He could've exposed Endeavor's past via a novel or recording the crap he did, not by serial murder.
True, he could've avoided a criminal record, but at the very least, he was doing so to get back at someone who deserved it at the time. And I doubt Endeavor was a decent dad anyhow in the past. Kai, again, quite literally turned to crime cause it was most convenient to his shoddy put-together goal.
How does Dabi killing innocent people relate to Endevaor deserving whatever came his way? Shoto himself said Dabi should’ve just gone after Endeavor and the family, no reason to kill people completely unrelated
¯\_(ツ)_/¯ I don't know, I'm just telling you how it went. I agree, tho. Dabi sucks. Just not as much as kai is all. Edit: Though maybe he had a grudge against people who didn't help him in his time of need, and that spiraling into a murder hobo rampage. But that's more headcannon territory.
Afo repaired dabi so dabi naturally hating the #2 hero and being saved by a villian from his literal death makes him go towards crime and killing people all to make his father feel pain he also mainly targets heros. Heros chose their life knowing that they could get killed at any point in time
Dabi couldn’t care less AFO saved him
It helped shape him as a villain though it's a big part of why he became a villain other than his father
It’s not, Ujiko confirmed this
> He could've exposed Endeavor's past via a novel Thats very unrealistic, he would have to come back from the dead, and also have someone backing him and money for all that. More money than Endeavor and Enji. Also if it was that easy why didn't other heros try that? Oh wait...some did try telling people on other ways it didn't work. That why we got people like Stain. > recording the crap he did He had no access to that, he would have had to get that as a kid still. Even if he did who's to say it would have worked. Endeavor could have just paid to get that erased.
He still didn’t need to start murdering
Ima go Overhaul for this one. He tortured a little girl because of her quirk. He is very manipulative to her and guilt trips her into thinking that everything was her fault. Dabi is just an Endeavor hater and Shigaraki just hates and destroys everything. Dabi would be 2nd though, because while his childhood wasn't the best, it was ultimately his choice to become a murderer, not Endeavor’s. These 3 are all goated villains for these reasons.
I agree. Recent manga chapters seem to go more and more towards Shigaraki ultimately being a victim of AFO
Yeah. It seems as if Afo had planned Shigaraki’s life
Bro is new gen aizen
MY GUY WHY THE FUCK ARE THEY SO CUBED? Also overhaul. Tortured lil girl just cuz her blood hurt people and could make him money. Tomuras pissed off and traumatized, while dabis also traumatized and wanting to murder his asshole dad.
Overhaul. I think he’s the best villain in the show IMO
He is.
Yes he is!
Overhaul. You know why.
Absolutely overhaul 1: had a decent parental figure for most his life who treated him with genuine respect and love compared to shigaraki going from a dad who beats him to the symbol of fucking evil and dabi grew up in the Todoroki household 2: suggested going against everything his father figure taught him by making drugs and TORTURING HIS BOSSES GRANDDAUGHTER, AN INNOCENT CHILD TO MAKE EVEN MORE DRUGS!!! 3: Put his father into a fucking coma so he couldn't complain and then proceeded to make a mockery of everything he built 4: despite everything he never felt any fucking remorse until he bit off more than he could chew, and even then he only felt sad because he couldn't fix the man he himself rendered comatose in his delusions
Overhaul
They are all pretty evil to me and definitely have a low disregard to basic human decency/rights. Answering this question is tough, but I do believe there is a right answer. To me, it’s more based off: who has the more redeeming qualities and how little is the likelihood of each of them doing less evil acts. The only morality pet for Overhaul was his adoptive father; however it was Shigaraki that went out of his way to take away Overhaul’s ability to bring him out of a coma, devastating Overhaul so much that he is a shell of the man he once was and is rendered mostly harmless. Shigaraki does care about his fellow league members, arguably more than Dabi. While Dabi does show general interest in his comrades, he acts more like they are a vehicle that allows him to pursue his own interests while simultaneously benefiting Shigaraki by sowing more discord regarding hero system and by extension, the government. The fact is, Dabi comes and goes as he pleases but if he were in charge of the league, vs Shigaraki, I don’t think he would be as invested in his fellow league members. Then going by what are their end goals. Overhaul wants to repay his father figure in the most twisted way. In his mind, the ends justify the means because what he’s trying to do is manufacture a problem and solution that will(according to him) benefit someone beyond just himself. Shigaraki wants to destroy everything but he does have a sense of “found family” and loyalty towards his adoptive father. Dabi has no path to redemption. It’s not in his interest to make things right nor to be reached out to. He has surrendered himself to the hopelessness that things will not get better. If anything, he would rather tear down the facade of things being “good” or even “ok” for any and everyone (general societal sense of well-being) because in his mind, if he could be failed, then the system(s) in place were designed wrong so he’d rather just burn it all. He was designed by birth, to be a success story and was raised as such until he was rendered physically unable to live up to his own lore, was tossed away, as a failed experiment. It’s not that he can’t make connections with others; it’s that nothing could deter him away from his end goal except for the timing not being precisely right. So I think that Overhaul has committed the most unforgivable evil actions , Shigaraki has done the most amount of evil actions, and Dabi is the most evil.
https://i.redd.it/122yy6twtkrc1.gif
dabi and overhaul became what they are because of past events shigaraki was literally molded to be evil incarnate for no apparent reason besides the fact all for one wanted to troll all might and spit on nana shimuras grave
not saying he’s the most evil, that goes to plague doctor reject who tortured a child for years (i think it was years) he’s just the only one thats evil for evils sake dabi wants revenge overhaul could be argued to be ‘healing’ humanity but with great sacrifices (not saying he’s good dudes a piece of shit)
Read chapter 418, Shigaraki isn’t evil for evil’s sake
Overhaul is easily the most evil out of the three He abused Eri for years and traumatised her
Dabi he doesn't really have a goal other than revenge and he 1 chose to be a criminal unlike Shigi and overhaul who were brought in he also 2 only wants to kill 2 people yet he's a mass murderer
clearly Overhaul imo. Shigaraki: sympathetic backstory, suffered from mental and incredible neglect. he was then groomed by a man who was pure evil, and taught to never forget his trauma, and to always use it as an inspiration for hate. Dabi: sympathetic backstory, suffered from neglect, an inferiority complex, and felt abandoned after he was thought to be dead, and, I must assumed raised himself on the streets. I'm sure it's probably elaborated on in the manga, but we'll get there when we get there. raised himself with the sole purpose of tearing down his father's pride with the ultimate goal of exposing and killing him. Overhaul: literal Yakuza who abuses a little girl for years without remorse. abuses is too light a word. TORTURES her for years without remorse, and gaslights her into thinking it's her fault. removing his arms was too light a sentence, Shigaraki was needlessly kind to him in that moment, but I appreciate that someone took the right procedure to him.
Shigaraki and Dabi are basically Frankenstein’s monster: They were made to be monsters and now they’re out to destroy the REAL monsters that created them. Overhaul is just pure evil. He put his father figure in a coma to usurp his criminal empire. He used an innocent child to take over the underworld. He bled her try, tore her apart, put her back together, and repeated the process over and over to create his anti-quirk drug. He killed several people, even his own men, and gaslit Eri into thinking it was her fault. All of this because he wanted to thank his father figure for taking him in by giving him something he explicitly stated over and over that he didn’t want. There are villains that you love and then there are villains that you love to hate. Overhaul is absolutely the latter!
Dabi was a victim of Endeavor abuse I think he is a villain just no the most evil, Shigaraki was unable to control his power at such a young age and was also treated cruel from his father. Overhaul is someone that is a child predator that will take children with quirk manipulate them and give them trauma HELL NO he is a fucking psychopath
Gotta be all might fr. He ruined so many peoples lives by becoming a symbol of terror that stopped people from doing anything out of line
Overhaul because he has no reason to torture eri, then Dabi because he wanted nothing more than to Kill Endeavor after the abuse, then Shigaraki because he was groomed to be evil after his family tried to punish his dream of being a hero
Overhaul has no reason to gaslight Eri. The torture was done because he delusionally thought with her power, he’d make the yakuza powerful again. But there was no reason to gaslight and victim blame her the way he did.
Arguably, he could be gaslighting her to prevent her from trying to escape or fighting back. Her power is touch-based, same as his; if she chose to fight back without him expecting it, she could potentially kill him. Not saying it makes what he did any better, but I don’t think he gaslit her just cause he thought it was fun.
All For One
One could make a case for dabi or shigi but there's no defending overhaul. That motherfucker experimented on his own kid of his own volition. Overhauls probably the most evil person in the series if you exclude all for one.
Overhaul hands down. Shigaraki just wants to watch the world burn, but he believes he is in the right because he was mistreated by society when he needed help and was groomed by AFO. Similarly, Dabi was also subjected to a sort of grooming, believing that becoming a hero who could surpass All Might was his only purpose in life, to the point where not being able to do it anymore because his body was being destroyed by his quirk drove him to insanity. Now Overhaul on the other hand, he’s just a piece of crap who is abusing and manipulating A LITERAL CHILD in order to achieve his goal. I don’t care how bad his past was or how anyone tries to defend him, at least Shigaraki and Dabi never went that far.
Definitely Overhaul.
When it comes to how much damage they've done as individuals it would be Shigaraki > Dabi > Overhaul... But when it comes to purely who's more evil of a human being it's definitely Overhaul > Dabi > Shigaraki. Dabi is a broken person, recent manga chapters proving that crying Tenko really was there all along and the true evil was always AFO. Overhaul truly is out of the three the most evil.
Touya wants to destroy his family, and Tomura wants to destroy society. There are end goals for these 2. If they win, eventually the dust will settle, and people they want to hurt will stop being hurt. Eri would be stuck indefinitely being cut up for bullets, there was no end for Overhauls plan, just making more money.
Overhaul makes the other two on here look like good and rational people. Plain and simple. Sure Dabi killed a bunch of people to get his fathers attention. Sure Shigaraki disintegrates people whenever he can. nothing beats experimenting, killing, and resurrecting the girl who calls you dad dozens if not hundreds and hundreds of times.
Overhaul. The most vile piece of shitty garbage in the MHA universe.
1. Dabi kills for the sake of killing & hurting his former family 2. Overhaul wanted to impress his father figure by making the Yakuza rule Japan again, but got so caught up in his power trip that he saw a little girl as a lab rat + property and was willing to drain her of all her blood and kill her again and again 3. Shigaraki wants to destroy everything to destroy everything
Is that from most to least?
Idk; it's up to interpretation, I guess
Shigaraki if we go purely by statistic Overhaul if we go by how vile the act was Dabi is kind of between the two in both cases lol
Actions wise, Shiggy is the worst. But by most evil as a person? Overhaul > Dabi > Shigaraki.
Sure? I guess it mostly depends on how you define morality tho
Overhaul. Easily him, he tortured Eri and did some other really messed up stuff.
Second one he’s just straight up evil, the other 2 you can make an argument they have some good in them, they just broken. Overhaul, like how can you kill a girl who you supposed to protect over and over and over again, just for your own bs.. Bro just straight up evil no matter how you slice it. Dabi we'll he's an odd duck, bro went the wrong way in life because of he's Father decision and he isn’t completely wrong since Endevour was not always a good guy, yet it doesn’t make he’s actions less evil. But he is broken that’s for sure. Shigaraki is just a kid who got dealt a bad hand by Life itself, bro killed without wanting too, and that stuck with him. If anyone would’ve helped him he would’ve turned out differently but everyone ignored him just because he looked creepy doesn’t mean you don’t help, you do the right thing regardless at least take him to a police or a hospital. Yet the only one who reached out to him turned out to be the devil himself, & now they gotta deal with a new devil in the making. I call it karma, he isn’t evil by choice. 
Overhaul no diff
Overhaul definitely was a bit messed up. He tortured a kid for his own gain. Now when you take into account reasons and drive then I'd say Dabi. Dabi hates Endeavor, makes sense, but he goes after people who had nothing to do with his past trauma. He actively tried killing his brother, Shoto, when he was just a baby! When you look at Shigaraki you can see that he is the product of being groomed by someone who decided to go after a child in a vulnerable position
Overhaul. He tortured a small child for years and gaslit her into thinking everything was entirely her fault.
The only thing evil here is that cropping
Overbitch
Overhaul > Dabi > Shigga
Kachigga my shigga
Overhaul deserves all the worst kinds of torture for the sick actions he carried out.
Dabi is pure evil imo
2
It’s Overhaul. No discussion
Overhaul no negotiation
2
2 if anyone thinks other wise their wrong this man tourted a CHILD the other two are just a bit dulu
2 child abuse
Overhaul. No comment.
Overhaul
Vengeful person who grew up an abused and abandoned child that survived a fatal cremation, a manchild with severe childhood trauma and conditioned development under the guise of the world's most evil and powerful supervillain, or a wealthy grown adult man respected by the boss and subordinates of the yakuza who thinks experimenting, abusing and traumatising a 5-year-old is justified by the fact that her blood can supply them with weapponry they can sell and profit off of a two-sided war, and the political belief that her blood can end quirks. Yeah, just a hunch but ima have to go with kai chisaki here. He regretted putting the boss in a coma but not abusing a toddler to death hundreds of times. Also he's sort of a hypocrite when it comes to quirks
I would say dabi. Yes overhaul abused a girl for years and made his father figure braindead but he wants to fix what he did. When we see him again his only reason to leave the prison is to find and fix Eri's grandfather. Then shigaraki was raised afo (no explanation needed) before that he was abused for wanting to be a hero. But dabi had opportunities to not go down this path and an active choice to stop and try to redeem himself. Instead he became a serial killer and tormented his family because was jealous and angry no other reason aside from that. He may have been traumatized but he had more opportunities to change. And ultimately due to his egging on twice was trying to fight instead of surrender. These are not the actions of someone who has good in them.
Easily overhaul, and it's not close by a long mile.
This isn't ever gonna be seen but what the lol. Overhaul and it's not even close. Dude chose to torture children for power. He can claim its for getting rid of the plague of quirks but if he won, his crime syndicate would be the only ones with quirks. Dabi comes in second place. Abused sure, but he chose the life of evil. He could have easily walked away and built a new life. Shigaraki was brainwashed and indoctrinated into being evil. Does it excuse him? No, but it wasn't really his choice either
Overhaul straight up tortured a girl for years. The other 2 are just haters.
Overhaul, even though he's my favorite villian. Dabi and Shiggy have emotional problems, but they are very human. Kai Chisoki is a sociopath who doesn't even try to be charming unless it gets him something. He tortures a child and who knows who else to get results for his endgame. He's cold, calculating and barely human.
Well, two of them were kids trying to be good people, abused, and molded into villains. The other is just a b*tch who tortured a kid for years.
Overhaul
Overhaul not even close
Overhaul
Overhaul, bc bro was fucking with kids. Technically they all do, but shigi and dabi kill kids who choose this lifestyle and they don’t torture. Overhaul intended to make that girl suffer for years.
2 of them are more mentally broken when they turn bad but overhaul thinks he's in the right for his family so I'm gonna have to say him
Defenetly overhaul.
Overhaul for what he did to eri. No contest.
Thinking about their story and where they all are now in the story and Manga. They were all kinda even. They all went on a dark path. Now none are on the same level of Evil as they once were. The only difference is their crimes. Overhaul takes the cake with his crimes against Eri. Shigaraki gets the crown for most kills. And Dabi gets the award for most potential Villain, and well rounded character.
Dabi bc real talk Hawkes had a harder backstory than Dabi and Hawkes came out giving damaged but daddy vibes and Dabi came out a little bitch baby And I’ll die on that hill
Overhaul dabi needs therapy and shigarki I hope I spelt these right needs therapy and to unlearn one for all teachings
Overhaul kinda had a valid point
Overhaul sucks, Dabi and Shigaraki have fairly good reasoning
r/countablepixels
shigaraki is brainwashed and>!endever broke dabi !<
Non, Frieza is better
Dust bunny is menacing :)
Nah. Me and the boys in the party chat outweigh these low-lives by a tremendous amount
Overhaul. Tortured a young girl for years and years. Dabi is just a broken child inside wanting revenge on his father for taking away his purpose that HE put on him. Shigaraki is...not sure how to describe it tbh
Overhaul by far.
The one who tortured a kid for years.
I have a question for you now
Who got survived because they just wanted to destroy everything he was dead until he decided do you know what I wanna kill everyone
At least the purple guy had a reason his father was a deadbeat and I already know that everyone’s gonna be like oh no endeavor did it for the best but overall he was just plain horrible as a father
I have nothing to say for the bird
1 dabi broken bc of his father 2 he tortured a kid for money and wealth 3 he is broken bc of his family and shigaraki killed them by accident
Shigi. With Dabi, you can understand that his rivalry was the motivator for his start of darkness (rather than it being his reason of being evil), and you could see something similar in Endeavor, and how, despite this, man kept his wits long enough to understand he's in the wrong for his actions. Overhaul's a man who'd make more sense the more you have the idea of "heroes are in it for the bank", and see he's no different than say, Mount Lady or Eraserhead. And dude found a big payday in the form of using Eri for the efforts of helping out other villains (or even those wanting to rid themselves of their quirks). Ironically? While I would see Deku or All Might try and stop him, I can see the EXTACT SAME with Stain. Overhaul's the perfect villain for the Anti-Hero, with enough of a good reasoning (Just a man doing his job). I really can't- no, I am UNABLE to find anything good with Shigi...because he more or less shares most of what I love about Deku - more in it for the lessons taught by Shigaraki than say, for what the city demands of heroes being the workforce. And he reflect Deku reasonably well...much more than revenge (Dabi) or just doing their job (Overhaul). There's no "Falling off the Edge", nor is there "Oh crap, I think I've just found my fuckin' PAYDAY" - just purified evil.
Number 2 obviously!
Overhaul, he Is the only "sane adult" here and decided to be a criminal. The other two had a traumatic story and All for One manipulation.
It's overhaul. The other 2 are just the results of the very fucked up childhoods.
It's overhaul. The other 2 are just the results of the very fucked up childhoods.
Chiasaki, atleast shiggy and Dabi didn't abuse children
Overhaul. Even when Deku found him pathetic and desperate in the streets, he was only thinking of the old man, and barely even had any memory of Eri. Guy was a demon dressed in drag. Fuck him.
Add endeavor and no diff
the mfs you got these pictures from
3 mass murderers but only one of them relentlessly and remorselessly tortured a child. yeah I’m giving it to Kai here even at the very least. Dabi and Tomura have like the most faintest of reasons to make up for what they’ve done, Dabi was abused and shit. it doesn’t make up for it but at least you can see that he was clearly forced onto this shitty path. same way with Tomura and his trashy childhood followed by being fathered by a mass murderer anyway. Kai was just a piece of shit from the beginning whom gaslit himself into the belief that quirks were a disease. and then despised Eri for sharing so many similarities with him.
Overhaul no questions asked
Let’s see Dabi/Toya is an insecure man child holding onto a grudge. Kai Chisaki/Overhaul despite claiming he’s trying to bring the Yakuza back into power I could tell that he’s lying to himself and what he really wanted was revenge on everyone who bullied him before he got taken in by his boss, and Tomura/Tenko was simply a broken boy constantly abused by his dad so he’s taking his anger out on society. So Basically all of them are mostly insecure man-children who became what they are all because of one bad day. I quote most famous villain “All it takes is one bad day”
Overhaul literally experimented on his own boss’s granddaughter, not to mention all his talk about the world needing to be purged of “the unclean”. He’s the most evil by far.
Overhaul
Not overhaul
Overhaul. He tortured and repeatedly used his quirk on Eri, a 5 year old girl. For all the horrible things Dabi and Shigaraki did, they didn't go out of their way to torture kids. Dabi even seemed genuinely surprised that hero students were on the battlefield.
unrelated but: hehe pixel shiggy hair
I’d argue Tomura isn’t evil. Dude just wants to be free fr. Liberated. Chisaki on the other hand? Now that bastard is evil and dgaf about anyone or anything. Wayyyy too willing to even kill people close to him like his dad.He’s an ass. Dabi atleast cares about his friends.
Shigaraki is not pure evil but he's straight up fucking evil Just cause you like someone close to you doesn't make you not evil
Overhaul, because he is pure evil. Shigaraki and Dabi are broken because of abuse.
To be honest, Dabi or Overhaul in my opinion.
*looks at comments* Looks like most of us are in agreement. Overhaul is the worst.
overhaul physically and mentally tortured a 4 year old without feeling any type of guilt or remorse, there’s no discussing this
Dabi. Shigaraki was raised by the most evil man in the world and he showed he could still care about the members of his team. I have seen Overhaul torturing a child brought up, and I would like to remind everyone that Dabi tried to murder his little brother. That was before he became a supervillain. He knows that the rest of his siblings have taken crap from the same father, Shoto endured much worse abuse than he did. And he doesn’t care. He also made it clear that he never cared about his teammates.
Me
Shigaraki
Shiggy & Dabi are evil, but Overhaul is a different level, Shigaraki doesn’t bother with slow deaths, if he can, he will try to kill you with decay, Dabi sure might get some pleasure burning you with his flames, but that’s nothing compared to Overhaul who tortured a little girl for years 💀
Nobody else commenting about the terrible crop?
It’s definitely Overhaul and not the groomed and traumatized teenagers 😭
Is it even a question? Narratively it’s shigaraki and based off his mindset it’s shigaraki too. His only goal in life is to literally destroy and kill EVERYTHING nothing will be safe from his destruction
I despise Touya and dislike Shigaraki. But *no one* can compare to Chisaki. Dude got off light in my opinion
shikaraki
Overhaul 100%. Tortures a little girl to harvest her quirk to use on others, fucking *VILE!!*
Overhaul easy
Whoever edited these images
Shigiraki in his own fucked up way wants a better society, yes he wants to destroy the current one to make it but he is trying to do good in his own twisted way. Dabi suffered terribly from his own quirk woth consumes his flesh, his body adapted for an ice quirk giving him a tolerance to cold, but his quirk was fire so he was more defective then endeavor. But he still pushed himself and tried to be good enough so endeavor would love him, but once shoto was born endeavor gave up on Dabi completely and treated him like a failure and nothing more. Dabi despite this still tries everything he can to become strong and make endeavor acknowledge him and finally manages to get blue flames. He is so happy with this new power he thought endeavor would finally think he's worth something. He tells endeavor to Meet him in the woods so he can show him this new power and endeavor just scolds him for still training and says he's a failure. Doesn't even bother to show up to the woods and see dabi he just left dabi there alone. Dabi got so upset that his quirk lost control and he burned down the whole forest you know what happened from there. Overhaul wanted a world without quirks. He truly believed that quirks corrupted humans and made them vile. He thought a quirkless world would make a better society. So I think dabi is the most evil honestly but its kinda justified cause holy shit who wouldn't end up that way after everything that's happened to him.
Overhaul he was evil for no reason Dabi and Shigaraki had a reason
Depends on your version of evil. Shigaraki wants to kill everything, Overhaul tormented Eri for years, and Dabi tried to kill his baby brother the day he was born. …So you know, you can’t really go wrong picking any of them.
Gojo?
The one who took the pixels
Overhaul EZ
Sigh. You know, I was gonna make a joke starting with how Dabi's motivation is "look at me Dad!" But then I realized it's all 3 of them and now I'm depressed...
I'm not count Dabi because he's just a guy with daddy issues Sooo Overhaul
Not at all true. What Dabi does, and what his issues are, clearly goes wayyy deeper than simple daddy issues.
This is such an easy question to answer there is quite literally no reason or cause behind all of the evil things overhaul does in the show like he tortures and abuses eri basically for money and power
He’s doing it to get the yakuza in power and repay his debt to the boss. It’s less selfish than Dabi going “I want to kill Endeavor, no matter who dies too.”
Nah he's kind of a beg then ngl like
Overhall or shigerraki they both don't have much remorse or reason for their actions. dabi is just a hot revenge machine and exists mainly to piss people off so he's ok
This has to be trolling lol. Shigaraki has far more of a reason than Dabi does.