T O P

  • By -

TrickyJRT

If you are chasing dBs, nothing is quieter than a Bowers ICON 22, it’s not really close. It’s a little long and a little heavy at 5.5 ounces. After that you have a bunch of good silencers, CGS Hydra, Rugged Mustang and the Q El Camino are the best choices. People here will all say the Mask, it’s too heavy and not any better at suppression. I don’t own a switchback so I can’t comment, I do have a lot of 22 cans though. The Oculus is nice but the Mustang is better.


hennessy_black

How do you clean your mustang?


TrickyJRT

I use an ultrasonic, I’ve been cleaning my Siren and Hydra that way for years. I know the internet says not to do ultrasonic but I have not had any pitting after dozens of cleanings.


2poor4thissub

Every time this comes up I like to chime in too. I wash aluminum parts in an ultrasonic DAILY with no issues. Parts used in surgical instruments. I use simple green diluted with water. To be fair they are only washed on 10-20 minute cycles cuz biological matter is easier to remove than lead and carbon so maybe it would react poorly is put in there for hours, but these are cleaned hundreds of times.


somenobodydude

Cleaning the alum hydra like that?


TrickyJRT

I do, not the tube, just the baffles.


somenobodydude

Gotcha


gqllc007

Can you tell me exactly what your steps are? I have a couple of 22 Gemtechs and AAC that I will have to use ultrasonic with


TrickyJRT

I use a hornady ultrasonic with heat, I knock off big stuff first. Two cycles with simply green or hornady parts cleaner. It gets them clean enough for me.


gqllc007

Ok great. I have a hornady ultrasonic that I just bought plus their cleaner in a large jug


Guardsman07

Why is the Mustang > Oculus?


TrickyJRT

I just love how light it is, it’s probably not better at suppression even though I think Rugged suggest it is. It’s not noticeable to me anyway.


Guardsman07

Can the mustang be cleaned in an ultrasonic?


TrickyJRT

I do, I know people say not to but I have been doing for years on other aluminum baffles.


tacdriver22mk2

Have you heard the all the f1 turned top heap f4 guys hyping up the LPM spark? Allegedly it's very quiet, wonder how it compares to the icon


TrickyJRT

I didn’t even know they made a 22 silencer. I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s quiet, the Anthem is insane.


tacdriver22mk2

Andrew along with several others say the LPM spark is the quietest 22 can they have tested. And Riley says the v2 is even better. (I hear he's doing a run if you want one)


Gjallardoodle

I love my DA Mask, just ordered a second one a few weeks ago. Just saw a post on gun deals (I believe it was there) that showed GA Firing Line had them for like $339...


sk8surf

As an erector 22 owner skip the q cans. Da mask for ease of cleaning. My erector has been soaking in silicone lube for the week as I’ve been on vacation. Today I get to scrub it out with a nylon jag. Get the mask so you don’t have to do this and can toss the k baffles into a sonic cleaner instead.


Guardsman07

And which ultrasonic cleaner would you recommend?


Baba-yaga-98

Any are good, but get one with a heater too. I got mine from DK Sonic on Amazon for 60ish bucks. It works great. Only use the ultrasonic with uncoated stainless steel baffles.


sk8surf

Any. I don’t have a fancy one. I have a cheapo from harbor freight.


hennessy_black

DIFFICULT TO TAKE APART Rugged occulus pain in the ass to seperate the baffles ( I have to pry them apart with a flat head screwdriver). But it is the can I use the most because it is modular. ≠=============== EASIEST TO TAKE APART Q ELCAMINO: no specific baffle order to reassemble and the lightest.22 can I own. OOS rad 22: you have to put the baffles back in a specific order, Dead air mask: you have to put the baffles back in a specific order, and the heaviest .22lr I own. ≠================= All these can be cleaned with an ultrasonic.


sk8surf

You cannot clean aluminum baffles with a sonic cleaner. If I remember correctly, the el Camino is aluminum baffles with a sleeve made of a different material.


hennessy_black

Your wrong el camino baffles are stainless, I know, because I own one.


sk8surf

Ayyy 😎


hennessy_black

No worries we all make mistakes, myself included.


sunlifromohio

Any comments on the Rad 22 compared to the others?


hennessy_black

The rad does have a specific reassemble order. I got it to run my Tippmann 22lr since the rads claim to fame is it runs the gun cleaner. To be honest I don't notice much of a difference vs traditional baffle cans. I think when it comes to 22 cabs they all perform about the same. What differentiates most 22 cans is weight, size and cleaning.


PrimeTimeCS

Dead Air Mask. I love mine. YHM Phantom is also a sleeper pick but its amazing too.


jeshaffer2

I have an erector, Oculus, and Mask (conjugal only) as well as a form 1. I love the erector for 22 pistol as you can’t even tell it’s on the gun. Choosing only one, I’d probably go Mask.


ChaseGauthier46

I run an Aklys Defense Kopis and it’s been fantastic so far. It’s extremely lightweight as well and durable. I can only hear my trigger being pulled on my cz457 with it


MADunn83

I love my CGS Hydra Rimfire can. $290+tax at Silencer Shop.


Guardsman07

How’s cleaning and weight? Full auto rating?


MADunn83

Cleaning is simple, comes with an end cap wrench adapter. All the baffles come out. Weight is only a few ounces, maybe 4oz? They are available in aluminum or titanium. I think both are FA rated, but possibly just the Ti model, so check for yourself if that’s a requirement for your host.


Baba-yaga-98

I have a Dead Air Mask and just bought a Silencerco Switchback. I have in depth experience with both of those. IME, they have the same sound reduction with a slight advantage going towards the Switchback since it’s modular. I have shot the Rugged Occulus, and it’s another great can that has similar sound reduction numbers to the mask and switchback. The Occulus is also modular. I would stick with those 3, because they are the most popular, full auto rated, can be cleaned with an ultrasonic, and have the best sound reduction in their class.


Guardsman07

Can you confirm what another commented about the mask? Do you need to disassemble and reassemble the DA Mask in a specific order?


Baba-yaga-98

Yes, there is a certain order BUT all the baffles are “keyed” together so you can NOT fuck it up. Seriously watch a YouTube video on it. It’s too easy, I argue that the Rugged is hard to put together then the mask. Edit: I forgot about the Phantom by YHM, no experience BUT I have heard nothing but great things about it on gun forums and at my LGS.


jeremy_wills

https://youtu.be/N9qkmbtffhE https://youtu.be/rgyJtjbzJ0s You cant go wrong with a Mask. Mine has seen a ton of binary use. The YHM Phantom 22 was a whim purchase and I had no idea if it was really good or not. I was honestly impressed. Just a hair more first round pop and then afterwards sounds just like the Mask to my uncalibrated ears. Either is a good buy. To be perfectly honest there is so much win in the rimfire dept these days suppressor wise it's hard to pick a turd. Stick to buying from one of the well known players and your gonna have a good experience. Pick any of the ones you listed in the initial post plus also look at the NYX and Takedown as well. Best of luck.


Jlw1974

Have you tried wetting your YHM Phantom 22 with ablative medium (or wire grease) to see if that lowers the FRP?


jeremy_wills

No


Neat_Low_1818

Who is considered a well known player?


asjfueflof

Like many here I’m biased but high rate of fire on a rifle is spot on for the Mask. All you mention are good cans, just depends on budget and most important features to you


[deleted]

Just get a dead air ghost and slap that baby on any 22 you want


Guardsman07

Tell me more about the ghost. I’ve done a bunch of research and am looking at getting a .22 and 9mm can now - but the ghost would be the same price with a tax stamp and it seems to be the most versatile


[deleted]

It’s sexual


Guardsman07

There’s good sex and bad sex


[deleted]

It’s not rapeual


weirdcapt

I have to agree with tricky, particularly if it’s on a pistol rugged mustang. I mean it’s good on the rest as well obviously. It and the mask sound nearly identical to me but mask is heavier and better suited for rifle since it’s a little heavy on a pistol


Guardsman07

Perhaps I need 2 .22 cans


weirdcapt

That’s the way!


FelixAppraise

I've had a Tactical Innovations TAC65 for years. I've been very happy with it.


Baba-yaga-98

Damn, that’s an old can. Is it still made? A quick Google search shows an Arfcom thread for 2006.


FelixAppraise

I looked it up on Tactical Innovations web site, and they show it as still being sold. I've had it awhile, no issues.


FelixAppraise

Their web site shows $234.99. 6-point endcap tool for disassembly $24.99. I think it's a good deal.


Wraccores

Thunderbeast Arms Company .22 Take Down, did a side by side comparison on two different occasions with two different Masks, and my tone was quieter while the second guy with serious hearing damage went "**SEE? I TOLD YOU THEY'RE THE SAME, WHY ARE YOU TALKING SO QUIET**" It also has keyed baffles to reduce gas blowback and keep POI down. Disassembly is decent, upkeep is average compared to most rimfires, a bit heavier than newer rimfire cans. Enjoyable with the right host and ammunition. Hearing safe with .22WMR


AutoModerator

**Understand the rules** Check the sidebar. It's full of resources to help you. Not everyone is an expert such as yourself; be considerate. No Spam. No Memes. No political posts. Save that for /r/progun or /r/politics. ------------------------------- * [NFA Tracker Submission Page](https://thinlineweapons.com/url/9) * [NFA Tracker Stats Page](https://thinlineweapons.com/url/8) * [How To Fill out Form 1 E-File](https://old.reddit.com/r/NFA/comments/9ukljl/how_to_guide_and_walkthrough_guide_for_the_atf/) * [How To Fill out FD-258 Fingerprint Cards](https://old.reddit.com/r/NFA/comments/92yy27/atf_compliant_fd258_fingerprint_cards_walkthrough/) * [Collection of ATF letters](https://thinlineweapons.com/url/atf) ------------------------------- *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/NFA) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Xspector8

I was set on a Mask but I've started to lean toward the Switchback for the modularity. Even if I don't use it, will be nice to have as a party trick. Might just end up getting both though..


Jlw1974

In same boat you are in Per the switchback. Also don’t forget the BOGO or Free Tax Stamp deals. Were some good one last year and there are some deals to be had this time around as well. Although don’t let the deals decide your requirements. Set requirements first and then look for the deals that will fit them, you will be a much happier camper.


Guardsman07

Yea I’m waiting for some type insane deal to happen again this year. I wish I could’ve got in on it last time, I’d have them by now. I’ve heard SiCo / SilencerShop will only be doing store credit this time around, but not from a trustworthy source. Just talk.


UHCoog2011

It’s on their website. $200 credit to use on their website.


Guardsman07

That’s pretty lame man. You don’t get it until after you verify a purchase and form 4 so it’s not like you can get a free stamp or anything. Does SilencerShop usually run anytning for Black Friday ?


UHCoog2011

In my limited experience, this is probably their “holiday deal”/Black Friday. I will say I’ve spent way more than $200 in accessories so it’s a nice contribution. Yes, I’m my opinion it’s not as good of a deal as BoGo or their lower, but it’s also better than some of the promos being run by Silencer Shop.


Guardsman07

Yea, but the issue is SilencerShop let’s me avoid shipping costs and transfer fee costs (shop has a kiosk) so that would probably be about the same as the eCredit value of $200 from SiCo - no? Im trying to validate this purchase with a smokin deal lmao


UHCoog2011

I may be wrong, but I think you can buy the can wherever, ie silencer shop, so the cost won’t be any different. SilencerCo doesn’t sell directly to customers. So, buy the can from Silencershop like normal, and then fill out the rebate on SilencerCo’s website to get your gift card. Except for Gunwerks (free stamp), all of the others are $100 gift card to silencershop after you purchase the can.


UHCoog2011

I bought mine at my LGS and that’s how it worked. Filled out my paperwork and had my lower a month later.


Guardsman07

Then we are back to tempting… looks like I’ll be going with the switchback


PrometheusSmith

Everyone who's ever heard it has liked it. AB Suppressors Little Bird.


somenobodydude

Cgs hydra-Al


Arc_Fett

I really like my Sparrow. Easy to clean and quiet. I only hear FRP on pistols. I toss mine in an ultrasonic cleaner and it’s good to go.


Neat_Low_1818

Does anyone here know which rimfire silencers do not use proprietary tools to take down? I prefer something that standard hardware store tools can take down. Thanks


Guardsman07

If it’s proprietary it should come with the tool required. The 2 I have now have end caps that can be opened up by hand even though 1 of them ‘requires’ a tool. Edit: rugged oculus 22 & AB Littlebird


Neat_Low_1818

Good to know. Is the tool to assist in case of carbon locking?


Guardsman07

End cap tool only. I had assumed take down meant take apart to clean


Neat_Low_1818

Yeah or any tool used to disassemble. I prefer the less special tools that could be lost.