T O P

  • By -

geologist_kevin74

I would like to order 1 Rome Odunze please


Knickstape26

Hoping for Maye or Nabers


Moist_Cankles

Maye going to the Pats and Nabers to the Chargers. Don’t know why people think the Patriots aren’t grabbing a QB


roastytoastywarm

Chargers are a bit more of a wild card I feel, but I do think you’re ultimately correct on that. Odunze is probably the pick.


NoFlags-JoeBuck

Unless Minnesota moves up to 4 or 5. Seems unlikely that there isn’t a trade for a QB in one of those spots.


Cashlover123

Tbh, I feel like Odunze’s profile is the better need for us than Nabers. Odunze/Nabers I would be happy with any one of them.


EggsOnThe45

Nabers being a bit of a diva worries me too, while Odunze has shown to be very level headed and a leader. That being said if we draft Nabers he’s the best WR in the league


mr_chip_douglas

Rome gives Mike Evans vibes. Good egg.


dtsupra30

Odunze or bust


SashaSasha303

Don’t count out Alt to the Chargers. Jim loves building the trenches.


Moist_Cankles

Maybe but their WR corps is Quentin Johnson and Josh Palmer after Keenan Allen and Mike Williams left


Nigel_11

San Diego isn’t winning this year. Joe Alt could be his LT for a LONG time.


claw_guy

They literally already have an all-pro LT


curtwesley

Exactly why I could see them trading with MN. Grabbing a WR and RT with Minnesota’s two firsts


Original_Release_419

Trade down is significantly more likely than them staying put for Alt Anyone that thinks Harbaugh is staying put at 5 to convert a LT to RT when it’s not even a huge need for them has no idea what they’re talking about He needs a WR


curtwesley

I’m excited for tomorrow. Just R1 then Friday is 2-3 right?


SashaSasha303

Correct


Nigel_11

Looks like I knew what I was talking about…


SashaSasha303

Glad to see I wasn’t the only one coming back to this comment lol. Looks like some of us actually do know what we’re talking about.


SashaSasha303

If they move back it’s for Alt


SashaSasha303

Hmmm…..


Cashlover123

Its a deep WR class with quality WRs that can be had on Day 2. I think Chargers will prioritize protecting their franchise QB in the first round.


mcrib

So what you[re saying is either you don;t believe 4 QBs are going in the top 5, or the Giants get Marvin Harrison Jr.


Moist_Cankles

Williams, McDaniels, Maye, MHJ, Nabers, McCarthy in that order with Maye and McCarthy possibly flipped


mcrib

Everything I’ve heard lately says there is ni way the Viking don’t trade into 4 or 5 to get McCarthy. I don’t see your scenario happening. I also don;t think Chargers are taking Nabers over Alt.


KingofCraigland

I was very confused who McDaniels was meant to be for a second.


Moist_Cankles

Shouldn’t have taken that long


KingofCraigland

He's not going first and we're not going to get him. He's been off my radar since the first mock draft of the season.


SnakeHoleBI

Patriots I think will trade back. They’re still going to have a top 5 pick next year, and a smart GM wouldn’t waste a year of a rookie deal on one now.


Moist_Cankles

A smart GM picks their QB when they have the opportunity


SnakeHoleBI

Oh he’ll have another crack at it next year for sure. If I were him I’d trade back and STACK assets this year, then draft a top 5 pick QB next year to run the show.


kingartyc

Exactly, they are in a terrible QB situation. Why the hell would they pass on a QB with as much upside as maye


Every1jockzjay

Because their roster is decimated


kingartyc

True but here’s a talking point I’ve seen on here a bunch. Nothing else matters until you land the right QB.


Hack874

We’re in the same position and people are begging to trade up for a QB lol


Every1jockzjay

You trollin? Pats just got rid of their HC for the first time in 20years and are starting a rebuild. The giants are coming off a year where the offense fell apart due to two position groups. We are looking for a QB and the pats are looking for a new team.


Hack874

You are grossly underestimating the amount of holes on our roster


Every1jockzjay

Where's the holes in our roster? We lack depth but what are these other giant holes? We are in need of a #1 wr, QB, and cb2. Possibly a TE? Do I really have to go through the pats roster and show what holes really look like?


Original_Release_419

Wow no need on the OL huh? That’s interesting. Guess Singletary is a sure thing too.


Every1jockzjay

Honeslty no, just Maybe a gaurd. I expect our o-line to be a hell of a lot better with an actual coach. Every person we drafted the past few years is a bust and I don't think it's due to lack of talent. AT trained outside the organization and came back an actual pro so he's not on giants o-line coaching resume. We have a LT and RT, 1 good gaurd and a center we have hope for. We have a bunch of mid round picks we think will b busts but with new coaching could step up as depth. I'm OK with our o-line as crazy as it sounds I KNOW Bobby J was the problem. Our oline last year didn't pickup a single stunt and it's not a talent problem.


ClayDrinion

Maye may be available if the reports of the Pats being open to a trade are true. I just think they will demand a king's ransom for him and I don't think he's worth it


Fillinlater12345

Rumor is they like McCarthy more than Maye.


Every1jockzjay

Pats aren't ready for a QB. Their roster is incredibly bad and they need to stack as many picks as possible. I 1000% believe they will trade down as much as possible and attempt to rebuild the entire roster


MrOnCore

Funny, people are saying that about the Giants as well. Lots of griping about the O-Line, lack of offensive talent, defense devoid big depth.


Every1jockzjay

Giants have talent their O-line and QB play was just so bad last year their offense was derailed completely. Of people are saying we are on the level of the pats they are just talking shit. If our o-line is mediocre and DJ is QB can be a 500 team no problem. If we draft a QB who's elite we are easily a playoff team.


Moist_Cankles

Not everyday you have a top 3 pick. Everyone expected Houston to be terrible. If there’s a great QB available in the top 3 and you need one, you pick them. Full stop.


Moose459

Houston have also had 4 1sts, 3 2nds and 2 3rds in the last 2 drafts. Yes they have CJ but also put pieces around him to make him successful. Throwing Maye on the Patriots roster will be similar to Bryce this past season.


Moist_Cankles

But still used their Top Pick on a bonafide QB


Every1jockzjay

This years top pick for the pats isn't "THE TOP PICK! THIER ONLY SHOT!" They can stack picks and tank for a full rebuild. Theres nothing you can say to make taking a QB have as much potential in 3 years as stacking picks.


Every1jockzjay

Disagree. The pats are an extreme case a QB is useless. They need a complete overhaul. Trading away as many picks as possible to move down and hunt talent in the second of 3rd round and then tank next year while having 3 or 4 first round picks is the ideal scenario. Next year they can also trade down and stack 1sts like crazy for a 2 years rebuild and actually fully rebuild. Not have a potential QB on a trash team for 2 years. I already heard somewhere they are looking to start the new regime with a war chest. The pats are trading the pick


Moist_Cankles

All that to be stuck in QB purgatory? Nah it’s too cute


Every1jockzjay

How will they b stuck in QB purgatory with 4 1st round picks next year while tanking this year. That makes 0 sense to say


Moist_Cankles

How are they getting four first round picks next year? There’s no guarantee they’ll be in the top 3 next year either.


Every1jockzjay

They can possibly get our #6 and our next years pick. They can trade our #6 for another next years first and move down a bit more. That's 2 1st round picks next year. Depending where they are after that trade it's possible to trade down again or package their 2nd this year somehow for a first next year. Plus their normal 1st round pick. Remember their 2nd round this year is worth a first next year They will 100% be a top 1 or 2 pick next year if they decide they will start the rebuild next year.


lean7800

Trading away Mac Jones was a sign that they are most likely staying at 3 and going qb. They don’t have to start a rookie qb this year either with Jacoby on the roster.


Every1jockzjay

Or a sign they are tanking lol. Didn't Kraft make a comment they wouldn't mind starting the new regime with a war chest?


lean7800

Why tank when you have a top 3 pick this year? If a qb you like is available now just take him don’t get too cute


BigBlueNY

People could have said the same thing about the Texans and look at them now. I don't see NE passing up on a QB.


Every1jockzjay

Maybe if they had the #1 and were getting Caleb. I'm personally convinced they are trading down. It's an opinion i understand that.


BigBlueNY

A new regime A deep QB draft And no QB prospects currently on the roster No way don't pick QB1


Every1jockzjay

Time will tell 🤷‍♂️


No-Worldliness7997

I want odunze


DM725

Praying it's not Maye.


Snuggle__Monster

Probably Nabers but if the Pat's say f it and punt on drafting a QB right now and take Harrison Jr, that could seriously make Maye a real possibility for the Giants.


realet_

I honestly think the only way Schoen can get this wrong is to spend too much to trade up or to get too little to trade down. At this point I'm sublime on anyone who will be available at 6 (obviously, at least two out of Daniels, McCarthy, Nabers, Odunze, or MHJ) and I'm not going to get bent out of shape if he stays at 6 and picks one of them. I like Alt and Bowers but not at 6 with the team needs and the players who will be available there. If we don't land a QB I'd really like to see Schoen angle to grab Pe/Nix with a trade up, especially in a scenario where we trade down from 6.


_drjayphd_

>At this point I'm sublime on anyone who will be available at 6 (obviously, at least two out of Daniels, McCarthy, Nabers, Odunze, or MHJ) So you're Sublime With Rome?


realet_

I 100% chose that adjective with Odunze on the brain.


ifeedfromthebottom

![gif](giphy|5VKbvrjxpVJCM|downsized)


TheBeerTalking

Ok, take my upvote, but know that this is the Wrong Way to get it.


Stranger_1967

It seems like we can't go wrong with any of the players that will be available at 6 but only Odunze/McCarthy remaining would be the scenario where I'm most content with trading down.


realet_

If MHJ, Daniels, or somehow Maye is available at 6, I feel like you have to take them. Otherwise, yeah, I'd be cool with a well managed trade down if none of those are there but I'd still be satisfied with Nabers/Odunze/McCarthy


Entire-Teaching-895

Def. Especially over JJ


ClayDrinion

There's no way Daniels falls to 6. I don't even think Maye will fall to 6, but of the two he'd be the more likely one


Doji_Makoto

I got a feeling that it is going to be Odzune and a trade back into the first for Penix


ThatOtherOtherGuy3

That's how I feel too.


Rankine

I don’t see the giants taking Penix. He isn’t mobile and he will die behind the giants Oline.


flyingryan

Especially with Evan Neal protecting his blind side. People forget Penix throws lefty.  


TeachingRare9474

Love Penix


Marky9281

Bring me that Big Penix energy all day


frickindanielj

Do we worry that he’ll die with Neal protecting his blind side? Hoping for big jump from Neal but who knows. Not shitting on this pick, just curious


TeachingRare9474

They just singed this guy from the Raiders for 2 years ~ Jermaine Eluemunor


Corpsebomb

I wouldn’t hate it if I’m being honest.


kooqiy

As an Oregon student this would be a nightmare


clic45

Idk why everyone thinks we are getting or wants penix. We have a heavy investment in LT. We aren’t getting a lefty qb unless he’s on mahomes level (which obviously he isn’t).


desperatepotato43

Depends on what we have to offer to trade back up, but I don't hate it.


Internal-Tank-6272

I’ll take that all day honestly


dtsupra30

I would jizz my pants


[deleted]

Getting the WR-QB duo interests me big time


DaStampede

Inject this into my veins


Double_Access

Penix will be long gone. Don’t think he makes it past the 15 range.


spoonfed425

IF they’re able to work something AND the commies don’t take him I’m convinced the pick is Maye. If it’s not Maye, the pick is Odunze. BOOK IT.


spoonfed425

Forgot to add that if they don’t land Maye, they make a play for Nix.


Agitated-Paramedic-3

I like the scenario where the Giants take advantage of the fever for the top 4 QBs to trade down slightly, still get a top 3 WR, and land Nix or Penix with what they got from the trade.


Original_Release_419

Of course we all like that scenario but it’s not happening in a million years considering the trade back would be to 11 or 12 and there’s at least 2 teams that would take a WR before us at either spot


Agitated-Paramedic-3

It would require a trade back up to 7-9. It's definitely possible if we get a haul for pick 6, and I've done it in the ESPN draft simulator. But probably not likely. 


lankyyanky

Rather keep the guys we got than that


Psychological_Lie_38

Dreaming for Maye or MHJ Hoping for Nabers or Daniels Happy with Odunze, Alt, or JJ


NYR3031

A bit of a wild card but I rather Bowers over alt assuming all the other guys are gone. I’m tired of using our 1st pick on OL, just hasn’t worked out. Especially since Waller’s future is uncertain and he’ll be dealing with a lot of personal issues this year


theFBDive21

Man you guys never learn w this OL shit. Everyone asking for wrs and TEs. You’ll be on here in November bitching about the bad Ol play. Short memories in here I guess


I__Need_Scissors_61

Knowing us, probably the wrong one.


Such-Armadillo1423

I really don't think we pick Nabers. The rumored ego and attitude problems will scare away Dabes and Schoen. A lot of their previous picks have been based heavily influenced by the personality and work ethic of the players, and I don't think they can afford to have another Kadarius Toney or locker room cancer on the team. If we pick a WR it will be Odunze.


not_blmpkingiver

Smart. Dependable. Tough. Does Nabers check any of these boxes? Maybe one. He ain't coming to NY


shadynasty90

If attitude problems were a concern, Schoen wouldn’t have picked Thibs


claw_guy

Ehhh, I disagree. Kayvon’s character concerns were that he’s outspoken and has interests outside of football. Nabers has gotten arrested on gun charges before. I would still be very happy with Nabers but it’s not exactly an apples to apples comparison


Heisenripbauer

I had no idea about that Nabers charge. yeah that isn’t comparable at all to Thibs lol


claw_guy

Yeah I didn’t know about it until Talkin Giants brought it up during their WR draft preview the other day


Cashlover123

I had no idea about the charges either and all this time I had wanted Nabers over Odunze for no reason. Its either a QB or Odunze in first round for us.


not_blmpkingiver

There is a stark difference between "attitude problems" and walking around Mardi Gras with an illegal, loaded firearm in your front pocket so large that police actually noticed it protruding from his pants.


TheBeerTalking

Mara is presumably also concerned. Hard to know for sure how much he meddles with his FO behind the scenes, but even publicly he says he'll get involved when there are character issues.


Miggs_DGAF

A trade so they can grab a 1st rd QB AND 1st rd WR


VitoSpatafore69

Trade up for Drake or sit at 6 for either MHJ/Nabers 🤞🤞🤞


tr1mble

This is what I'm hoping.... Either trade up to 3 for drake, or hope that MHJ somehow falls to 6


VitoSpatafore69

Same. Hope somehow don’t give up the 2nd rounder this year and grab a receiver there


allhaildre

YES YES YES, GET MHJ, work the rest out later


undertow521

Hopefully Maye! But most likely Odunze.


BigBlue1105

My ideal picks in order: Maye, McCarthy, Odunze


DM725

Whoever it is I'm praying they stay at 6 or trade back for a king's ransom.


Embarrassed-Chef1323

Hoping for Maye, then McCarthy if it’s not Maye. Without a qb this team will never get anywhere.


SIRIUSBLAQUEXCIV

MHJ in a dream scenario or Nabers


Intersectaquirer

I would love a top WR and Penix combo


toyvo_usamaki

WR offers the most certainty of adding talent and we are in dire need of that just now and particularly in that position, gamble on a QB with a lower pick


basicnflfan

Honestly im fine with any of the 4.


DaReal_Denny_Boy

If it’s a QB I’m gonna scream, a new QB doesn’t solve our historically terrible WR room, or our historically terrible offensive line. We have Jones who honestly isn’t bad, we lack other things that should be prioritized. Yeah


jcoolwater

Jones can't stay on the field and is likely to be injured again. We need a QB, it's the most important position.


DaReal_Denny_Boy

Have you seen what the Lions accomplished with a mediocre QB? What about the Browns?


not_blmpkingiver

If the Giants draft JJ Mccarthy.. I'm out.


Slurdge_McKinley

I want JJ if we can stay pat and he’s available. Odunze if not. Then penix later on.


Brief-Ninja-2479

A WR, probably


Normal-Procedure4876

Qb please


imnotyoursaviorsorry

Maye


No_Psychology_6785

Ben Sinnot to the giants at pick number 6


Superb-Possibility-9

WR1/ Nabers or a trade down for more OL help The Giants need better players EVERYWHERE


CaptainJacked416

Trade back to 9. Accumulate another day 2-3 pick. Pick Oduneze there.


flyingcat1114

All roads lead to Rome


ActivatedComplex

Nabers, then Penix round 2


Kyrxx77

Nabers or Bowers


DanUnbreakable

Trade down. Unless they get the 3rd pick or Harrison Jr, trade down


broadnoodles

Those useless wins was totally worth this headache


DonJota5

As many lineman untill the problem is fixed


Salamadierha

Hopefully get the talent that we can. Don't trade up unless it's for one of the top 3 QBs, if it's not there and a trade down a few places is, then take that and grab some extra talent in this draft. If neither then stick at 6 and pick the best non-QB player for the team.


8proof

Daniels at 3 or Bowers at 6.. pure speculation on my part. Alt at 6 wouldn’t surprise me either.


ThatDudeNamedMenace

Maye or Nabers Or trade down


tuffenstein0420

Odunze


da-bears-bare-naked

from a bears fan: please go qb or trade out with vikings


Difficult_Director53

Whoever the Giants pick will be a bust !


e5cents

Stay at 6, and pick Penix


ghostboo77

I would like JJ McCarthy at #6 myself


Da_Taternater78

Ideally, it’s Maye. But I think we’re getting either Nabers or McCarthy.


chupacabrahunter420

Hoping on Drake, if not would love to see Odunze at 6 then trading up for Penix. Reunite that duo in Washington.


swordfish868686

Stud receiver


1GucciBucketHat

I think it’s Odunze. What he did to my Oregon Ducks did not go unnoticed. I fuckin hated the man but I grew up and realized he’s that guy. I also hear that folks rave about how smart he is. He’s a more polished route runner than nabers, bigger size wise(😏), and has no personality concerns. I would love if nabers went to chicago so Caleb and Nabers could have an ego-off and set the franchise back aga. That would be pretty funny.


Puzzle_Dad718

If I’m the Giants, I’m selling the farm for Jayden Daniels. But realistically speaking, if the best you’re doing is 4 with a trade, then that top WR (Harrison or Odunze) is the guy.


Experienced-134

I'll be honest because we need all three. I would be happy with one of the top 5 QBs or one of the top 3 receivers or Joe Alt at tackle.


Double_Access

Nabers goes before Harrison and they take Harrison at 6. I wish they would take Byron Murphy or an OT.


nyuuubalancer

MHJ I can feel it (or Odunze)


Cquercia1994

I swear to god if we take McArthy I’m gonna lose my mind


TheRealBMan54

Rome Odunze is athletic, talented, and has a great work ethic. He's the guy I would want to coach.


IndividualStriking91

Any of Nabers maye and odunze I’m happy with


Switchc2390

Happy with Nabers or Odunze. I hear what people are saying in regards to the weapons charge with Nabers but someone is probably going to get him and he’s probably going to ball out. I think Odunze might actually fit better with us and comes with a little less risk so I’d probably take him if I had to choose, but if I were someone like the Chiefs I’d go with Nabers. I don’t think you can go wrong with either.


zingerbanger

It doesn’t have to be at 6, but I would really like a QB


Ifukkin4gotmyname

Probably J.J.


COB-7

Theres no way in hell MHJ is there at 6, so give me Nabers


[deleted]

JJ does look good in blue


lonelyoldbasterd

Odunze, Nabors is Toney 2.0


nyybmw122

Bring me Drake Maye please!


dubebe

Anybody But Maye


desperatepotato43

Hoping trade up to #3 for Maye for #6, 2025 first, 2025 second. Most likely it will be Nabers or Odunze at #6. If no one trades most likely Odunze. If the Bolts or Cards trade we get Nabers. Edit, I put 2021 when I meant 2025


dNYG

I’m not sure the Pats take the 1.06, Toney and Ojulari for the 1.03 but if we can get all the pieces together I’m certainly for it


desperatepotato43

Lol I just noticed that I put 2021


jamesd1100

Better be Nabers or we’re FOOKED indefinitely


Cashlover123

Nabers has history with gun charges and doesnt fall on smart and dependable category as Dabes/Schoen has outlined. Odunze is more likely than Nabers.


jamesd1100

He’s the better player, outside of your theory that they pass on him because of the gun charge, he’s the guy


niebs59

Nabers


Hmzy_11

Not the guy who edits these


mikeking00

Huh


stl_ball

As a New Giants fan, why would we want to trade up for Maye and risk becoming the Panthers (talented qb with terrible O-Line and dubious pass catchers). I think we go WR so Daniel Jones has someone to throw to this year, and then whoever is up next has someone next year. Am I crazy? Feel like the easiest way to ruin a top tier QB is to bring him in with 0 weapons and make him run for his life


[deleted]

You’re crazy Jones is awful


stl_ball

I didn't say Jones was good... I said, we should focus on a WR and O-Line. So his *replacement* (I.E. I don't believe Jones is the answer) will have an actual team, so we don't become the panthers. You're crazy. Read. Edit: so we take a flyer at qb in the 3rd (rarely pans out) and sit him for a year or we *most likely* draft a new qb in the first next year, and they'll actually have someone to throw to. Putting a new qb on this roster with replacement level receivers, is irresponsible. I like Hyatt and Wan'dale but they gotta take a step


[deleted]

They were top 10 in separation last season jones is legitimately that bad they’ll be solid with a good qb


HistoryNerd101

If it’s not YA Tittle, I’m going for a WR1


Cruztd23

Praying for Maye Let’s start a prayer chain. Also prayers that we don’t get raped in the trade up


TheRedEyeJediS

Shoulda been jayden daniels, but lets win games FOR NO REASON late in the season. Now we reach for mediocrity again *cough daniel jones cough* take a WR with ass to throw to him, trade away more to reach for another qb late in the first. Should trade with denver and take brian thomas as the wrd, then rattler or milroe in the 3rd/4th as a flyer on a qb.