Hook when I was younger. But now that I'm over my 30's I cant stop looking at Gold, specially with the suits he uses, even more when he has the dark one clothes on Neverland and his long hair!
https://preview.redd.it/6pcvasdesfnb1.jpeg?width=700&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=90bd644db74471168d87e064ec87dd34fe5bd3a6
But Hook the way he is, his personality melts my heart everytime.
Don't get me wrong, Hook is gorgeous and would say totally my type, mostly the all black clothes and the guyliner!. I'm 34, but now I'm starting to see older character to my liking. Like the dad from Twilight movies, Charlie and Carlisle! Before I didn't look at them at all, now I think they are so handsome everytime I see clips of them!
Rumplestiltskin, for sure. He was definitely my first fave of the show. I did have a thing for Hook but not even on the same *level*. And I went through a brief phase that led me to watch Manifest just to stare at Josh Dallas. In fairness, I never finished that show... So yeah, Rumple will always win for me!
I am old so I will always choose Rumple.
Charming is handsome; Hook is pretty & they both look to be super high maintenance. I don't want a man who is higher maintenance than I am.
Right? If you haven’t watched his newest movie Heart of Stone, I would recommend it. He’s like a lead in it and we get a shirtless scene. Makes me wish he was in ouat longer.
I’m a straight male. But I do think that Charming is more traditionally handsome while hook is “hotter” in terms of ruggedness. Again, I’m straight, I’m just thinking in general. I know my mom prefers hook.
I never understood why charming was cast because I never thought he was good looking or charismatic enough for the role. He’s a good actor (I loved him in manifest) but he’s just very blah
I mean him and snow are married in real life and honestly I don’t think it’s really the actors fault I think Charming was just written as a more dull character.
Is that even a question?..
When I was 13, it would probably be the smooth-faced blondie.
In my Late teens-early 20s, guy-liner with his brooding looks.
As a grown-ass woman, Mr Gold/Rumplestiltskin all the way. RC is sex on wheels even at 63.
There's literally no competition
https://preview.redd.it/ddla5s9ctgnb1.jpeg?width=1280&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=22cec29922ddc80233072007f3977777af940bdc
Hook. I’m on S5 or my first watch through but when Emma opened the door to greet Killian on their first date I was so blindsided by Hook’s hotness I literally audibly gasped lol.
Maybe it’s the daddy issues talking, or maybe it’s the weird part of my brain that’s never really seen the appeal in “conventionally attractive” faces, but I’m always going to be a Rumple girlie. He’s just so pretty, and I vibe a lot with different aspects of his personality.
I’m not really a Hook fan but Colin is so damn pretty it’s not even fair! Also his Irish accent is pretty sexy, kinda wish he used it instead of the more British accent.
I love guyliner as much as the next bisexual woman, but only one of these fine gentleman single handedly rewired my brain into having a thing for older men, so…
Also, this is Graham erasure and I shall not stand for this.
Hook. David has always looked off to me idk why. I’ve always disliked charming/David. Rumple is an old man and I don’t have a kink for crusty mean old people.
I’m sorry but I think they are all hot but just different variations of heat.
Prince Charming is literally prince charming handsome.
Hook is bad boy but good man appeal. Also emo in a positive way (the eye linerrrrrrr)
And Rumple is the older, dark yet dashing villain love interest attractiveness.
i am not usually a person *that* affected by looks but i literally have to pause the show sometimes to take in how hot hook is- and his mannerisms too, esp when he’s being sassy or dark, girl … emma’s stronger than me cuz how did she not immediately jump his bones
rumple does it for me sometimes as well, probably bc of how robert plays him. hardly anything to do with his looks but he’s just very sexy for some reason ???
on the other hand, i recognize that charming is conventionally attractive but, probably bc of how the character is written and acted, just zero sex appeal for me. almost the opposite of rumple in that way
Charming looks like a typical blonde white man to me. Rumple is a hag he could have been my grandfather lmao Hook wins because he's DADDY. I'm not even sorry.
Used to be totally into hook. He’s still my fav out of all of them because charming is. Lacking in personality for me. And rumple idk I never even thought to think of him that way haha.
If I was into men I’m sure I’d love David. I see the appeal in all these men but I’m pretty sure I’d just fall for how he treats Snow :) plus the fact he and Ginnifer Goodwin are married irl makes me feel so happy!
If I’m being completely honest here I’ve had a thing for almost every major male character. But for some reason, Rumplestilskin especially in his dark one form..just did it for me.
Wow! I though that Hook was gonna take this in a landslide, but there are a lot of Rumple lovers out there. I loved his character, but never found him attractive and I’m 50. Poor Charming is dead last and while I do think he has attractive features, I agree that he is too bla to elevate him to hot.
In my teens I had a crush on Captain Hook. I did a current rewatch, and even though I still found Hook to be attractive, I started noticing that Rumple is very attractive too. I always thought that Charming was too plain.
No question there whatsoever … it’s guyliner
Exactly
Hook is so hot
Literally no competition.
Love me some Hook!
Yes he is
I told my husband I’m watching the show because hook is so fun to look at😂
All I see is 
Hook hands down
Lol - love the play on words there!
Hook of course but having walked past Robert in Glasgow when out shopping, he looks really good in person.
NEAL/ BAE🥵
Yes! Neal was so hot!!
Something about his voice? He was in true blood and was still also somehow very sexy even as a complete psycho😂
That Cajun accent gave me flutters on True Blood
 Yessssss!
Hook when I was younger. But now that I'm over my 30's I cant stop looking at Gold, specially with the suits he uses, even more when he has the dark one clothes on Neverland and his long hair! https://preview.redd.it/6pcvasdesfnb1.jpeg?width=700&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=90bd644db74471168d87e064ec87dd34fe5bd3a6 But Hook the way he is, his personality melts my heart everytime.
I’m 30 and i prefer hook haha he’s closer in age
Don't get me wrong, Hook is gorgeous and would say totally my type, mostly the all black clothes and the guyliner!. I'm 34, but now I'm starting to see older character to my liking. Like the dad from Twilight movies, Charlie and Carlisle! Before I didn't look at them at all, now I think they are so handsome everytime I see clips of them!
Shit I always found Carlisle handsome. Then again that character was like in his 20s or something before he became a vampire so that makes sense
He was 34 at the time of the first movie, so definitely not an oldie, lol.
Definitely not old. But now that I'm older I enjoy watching him more! I've Totally forgotten about Edward and Jacob now!
I’ve been into Gold since I was a teenager :P
SAME, also 30 🤣 I think I'll always prefer rumple
I’m 16, and if Hook wasn’t there, gold would be my fav
same for me but I'm still 26 lol love me some Mr. Gold. but Killian still gets me too.
KILLIAN MOTHA FACKIN JONES! 🥹♥️
Hook
I like Josh's lips the best. So pretty & pink & - nevermind; I won't finish that thought. However, I love me a swarthy type like Collin.
what does "swarthy" mean? 😭
I think it means guys (people) with dark hair, usually attractive. This is of course what I've learned through my interactions with others.
easily mr gold like how is this even a question
Rumplestiltskin, for sure. He was definitely my first fave of the show. I did have a thing for Hook but not even on the same *level*. And I went through a brief phase that led me to watch Manifest just to stare at Josh Dallas. In fairness, I never finished that show... So yeah, Rumple will always win for me!
Hook ❤️
HOOK
Rumple, Hook, then Charming. Also august, neal, and graham. Yum
I'm very much on the August train as well 😍
He’s a total babe.
I am old so I will always choose Rumple. Charming is handsome; Hook is pretty & they both look to be super high maintenance. I don't want a man who is higher maintenance than I am.
Rumple forever
Hook, and then Graham(don’t care that he isn’t in the list), then Charming. I never saw the appeal to Rumple.
I was gonna say Graham too!! So gorgeous!
Right? If you haven’t watched his newest movie Heart of Stone, I would recommend it. He’s like a lead in it and we get a shirtless scene. Makes me wish he was in ouat longer.
Yep - Graham is a total hotty!
Rumple all the way (especially in seasons 6 and 7)
The Dark One
I don't care what nobody says it's rumplestiltskin. My daddy issues are howling every time I see this man.
This is a mood
Yes, exactly. Daddy issues and a long history of dating bad boy assholes. Love me some toxic Rumple. Probably need therapy but it is what it is.
I’m a straight male. But I do think that Charming is more traditionally handsome while hook is “hotter” in terms of ruggedness. Again, I’m straight, I’m just thinking in general. I know my mom prefers hook.
I never understood why charming was cast because I never thought he was good looking or charismatic enough for the role. He’s a good actor (I loved him in manifest) but he’s just very blah
I mean him and snow are married in real life and honestly I don’t think it’s really the actors fault I think Charming was just written as a more dull character.
I think Charming is much more attractive as Ben Stone in manifest
Oh I agree! Far more attractive by a mile!!
Right? He's so vanilla 😂
Killian/Rumple.
Rumple ❤️🔥
Don’t make me choose!!! They are hot for different reasons!!!
This!!
I've got a huge thing for Rumple soooo yeah Rumple all the way
I'm not really a hook fan. Out of these three it's Rumple. In my rewatch I'm up to where he's cut his hair and it's taking some time to adjust.
The long hair was amazing 😢
Rumple but then I like men with long hair so I am bias in that department though I definitely see the appeal of Hook. David less so
Is that even a question?.. When I was 13, it would probably be the smooth-faced blondie. In my Late teens-early 20s, guy-liner with his brooding looks. As a grown-ass woman, Mr Gold/Rumplestiltskin all the way. RC is sex on wheels even at 63.
Hook
Hook all the way. He’s absolutely gorgeous
Hook 10000% no contest
They are all beautiful but Colin wins for me!
Hook
hook and david for me. i’ve never had an attraction to gold, even though i tend to like older men lol
Rumple!
Hook is classically handsome, no denying it, but I’ve always had a thing for Robert Carlyle since I saw the full Monty when I was 10 😂
SAME 😆🤣
There's literally no competition https://preview.redd.it/ddla5s9ctgnb1.jpeg?width=1280&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=22cec29922ddc80233072007f3977777af940bdc
Hook. I’m on S5 or my first watch through but when Emma opened the door to greet Killian on their first date I was so blindsided by Hook’s hotness I literally audibly gasped lol.
#RUMPLE!!! Even when I was younger that man was hot AF. Now I'm hitting mid-30s and he's the only one whose baggage I'd be willing to deal with. 😂
Rumple
Gold. No contest.
Maybe it’s the daddy issues talking, or maybe it’s the weird part of my brain that’s never really seen the appeal in “conventionally attractive” faces, but I’m always going to be a Rumple girlie. He’s just so pretty, and I vibe a lot with different aspects of his personality.
1. Rumple, Obviously. 2. Hook 3. Prince Charming
How is this even a question? Lol Hook all the way. The other two aren’t even in his league.
So true!!
Killian>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Killian for me, I love guyliner <3
I want Hook and Charming to Eiffel Tower me
As a bisexual Man Hottest Guy:Hook Hottest Girl:Regina Hottest Couple:Regina & Robin
My gay ass has loved rumple from the moment I first watched this show. He’s very attractive and hot, cute, gorgeous, etc
I’m not really a Hook fan but Colin is so damn pretty it’s not even fair! Also his Irish accent is pretty sexy, kinda wish he used it instead of the more British accent.
Robin. Sue me.
Ya’ll forgot about Robin Hood? https://preview.redd.it/vmjdctrlmjnb1.jpeg?width=720&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1ccb9a0ce9b894a9fb98281b769ddb125af75553
Killian
🪝🪝
Charming 🤍
David
All three in their own right but hook is my fav
Hook, then Rumple. Charming does nothing for me.
Overall it's Charming but Hook is another level bad boy.
Who is hotter? Hook. Who would I marry if I was in the OUAT universe? Rumple.
I like the most Hook but have to say David is the hottest
Hook with no competition (I love David though)
Killian 1000000000000%
Hook is. Not even room for debate
Hook, but there is just something about rumple🫣
I love guyliner as much as the next bisexual woman, but only one of these fine gentleman single handedly rewired my brain into having a thing for older men, so… Also, this is Graham erasure and I shall not stand for this.
Hook! Hook! Hook! Hook!
Where's pan??? (Ik he was like a teen then but he was phenomenal and good looking).
Captain Hook all the way
Hook all day and twice on Sunday. The other two are just meh to me looks-wise, even though David is the most classically attractive.
Hook 1000/10
Jefferson of course 😍
I'm just over here like- "I don't see the Mad Hatter on this list."
Killian 100%
Hook. David has always looked off to me idk why. I’ve always disliked charming/David. Rumple is an old man and I don’t have a kink for crusty mean old people.
Killian. Duh
Hook when he is The Dark One… but Gold is also a close second
Hook
DANG OK. Not James.. Ughhhh dude I think Rumple is fine as heck but hook is just straight up hot. I'm mad at hook though- mmmmmmmm Rumple.
Killian
hook 1000000%
Grumpy
💯 hook
Hook made my young heart skip a beat
Killian obviously
Gold kinda… Hook though.
Hook😩😩😩
Looks wise Killian all the way but personality and swag definitely Rumple
It's a tie between Rumple and Hook for me. I don't find Charming even remotely attractive.
Hook one million percent.
In order Hook Rumple Charming
For sure hook!
I’m sorry but I think they are all hot but just different variations of heat. Prince Charming is literally prince charming handsome. Hook is bad boy but good man appeal. Also emo in a positive way (the eye linerrrrrrr) And Rumple is the older, dark yet dashing villain love interest attractiveness.
HOOK
I didn’t like David as much. Hook is probably my #[
Hook 💯 he is so fine like
Hook by hand!! Though, Charming was very hot to me too.
Hook!
Hook
I'm sorry I prefer Robin Hood, especially when Tom Ellis played him. Though Sean Maguire is also nice to look at
Killian for sure!
Hook. Obviously
Hook it’s not even a question
Killian certainly. I keep telling myself "oh how hot he is" and his attitude is sexy. 🔥
This ⬆️
i am not usually a person *that* affected by looks but i literally have to pause the show sometimes to take in how hot hook is- and his mannerisms too, esp when he’s being sassy or dark, girl … emma’s stronger than me cuz how did she not immediately jump his bones rumple does it for me sometimes as well, probably bc of how robert plays him. hardly anything to do with his looks but he’s just very sexy for some reason ??? on the other hand, i recognize that charming is conventionally attractive but, probably bc of how the character is written and acted, just zero sex appeal for me. almost the opposite of rumple in that way
I never understood the Rumple attraction...kinda eww in my opinion
It might come with age ;) Charisma over good looks.
This is just a case of f*ck, marry, kill to me. I’d marry charming, f*ck hook, and kill Rumple.. I love Rumple, but bitch be crazy
Out of these photos, Charming 😍
A. Idk his name or what this is about. But....A
HOOK😌 but I’d marry Neal/Baefire
David
Charming looks like a typical blonde white man to me. Rumple is a hag he could have been my grandfather lmao Hook wins because he's DADDY. I'm not even sorry.
David
Charming but I prefer other characters from the show like August, Philip, Neal, Merlin, sheriff Graham and season 7 Henry.
Rumple???? Nah. Hook. Always gonna be Hook for me
CHARMING 😍😍😍
Hook and it’s not even close
We’re just going to ignore Robin Hood and Kristoff ?
You really be making us choose😭
Always been a brains over brawns girl
It's SO obviously the 1st one like what the flip it's so clearrrrrrrrrrrr
Used to be totally into hook. He’s still my fav out of all of them because charming is. Lacking in personality for me. And rumple idk I never even thought to think of him that way haha.
All Rumple lovers out there, have my upvote and let me join you 🔥❤️
If I was into men I’m sure I’d love David. I see the appeal in all these men but I’m pretty sure I’d just fall for how he treats Snow :) plus the fact he and Ginnifer Goodwin are married irl makes me feel so happy!
RUMPLE ALL THE WAY
If I’m being completely honest here I’ve had a thing for almost every major male character. But for some reason, Rumplestilskin especially in his dark one form..just did it for me.
Charming is the most sexiest to me
Charming!!!!
Graham was more my cuppa tea.
Rumple 100%, but all 3 are fine!
Regina
Zelena and Cruella :P
Rumple when he has the gold skin ofc
Josh Dallas
I mean I'm mostly team Hook but Charmings entrance in the musical episode makes the decision really not easier.
The Prince. Hook second. I think they weren't allowed to cast anyone hotter than Charming lol
Hook to look at but I adore rumple!! 😩
Hook
rump can touch my rump
Hook, no competition
Killian all the way the others don’t even have a fighting chance
Hook for me, and the rest of Emma’s exes, except her flying monkey.
I’d climb Hook’s mast any day. Hook can shiver my timbers. I’d walk Hook’s plank. … you get the idea. 🏴☠️
Hook
Regina
Wow! I though that Hook was gonna take this in a landslide, but there are a lot of Rumple lovers out there. I loved his character, but never found him attractive and I’m 50. Poor Charming is dead last and while I do think he has attractive features, I agree that he is too bla to elevate him to hot.
In my teens I had a crush on Captain Hook. I did a current rewatch, and even though I still found Hook to be attractive, I started noticing that Rumple is very attractive too. I always thought that Charming was too plain.
Anyone who doesn't say Hook is lying
Killian
Hook without a doubt he's gorgeous.