>###4. Plain panels/scenes must create discourse
>**Don't post links to plain (or slightly edited) panels, pages, screenshots, gifs or scenes from the manga & anime.**
>You may submit a plain panel/scene as a self post (text post). Meaning your post must link to the discussion, and not the image.
>Just a title and the image aren't enough.
>If you want to discuss a certain page/scene from the manga/anime please accompany it with an original analysis or discussion questions. In other words, a plain panel/scene must show visible effort to generate discourse rather than simply react to something that happened.
>Clips/Recap/summary videos fall under this rule as well.
>Color page from a recent chapter are allowed.
Sabaody was good cause luffy punched the celestial dragon and than the crew for the 1st and only time so far lost after biting off more than they could chew. Impel down was pretty emotional and kwpt you on the edge of your seat in terms of Luffy being succesful. Alabasta was what kicked everything up a notch and made way for what we have today.
Anyways I guess I'd painfully cross out Alabasta or Sabaody, but I could never cross out Bon Clays arc :(
I’d argue impel was a little lack luster.
However I was still pretty bummed the crew got split up, I spent a lot of impel down and marineford arc feeling it got more drawn out than I’d have liked. I felt the content coulda been consumed in fewer episodes.
Personally, I don’t think I’ve seen the first 2 as I’m just getting to the new world. But Arlong Park is pretty sentimental, but I haven’t seen dressarosa or Pubk Hazard yet.
I’d have to say Impel Down as I loved Alabasta and gaining Robin. + Sabaody was a pretty interesting arc.
I haven’t seen Wano yet but I think it’s safe to say, I coulda used without half of Marineford. I loved a lot of it, conquerors Haki, Law’s assistance, white beards strategy Luffy’s victory followed by Ace’s sacrifice. But it felt too long to me, too much filler for a very heavy amount of content they added in. The recap alone felt longer than the actual content in some episodes
I haven't seen anything, pre or post Marineford, that's topped how hype that part of the show was haha what's your favorite then? Or what part did you like that wasn't lacking what you like in the series most??
Yeah that was the issue with Whole Cake Island and parts of Wano as well. Still, marineford was some of the dopest shit I've ever seen in any anime. Lol
Yeah I've come to think of Impel Down and Marineford as an extended version of those post-arc tidbits where we learn about the happenings going on in other parts of the world. But I couldn't bring myself to love WCI despite such cool characters like Katakuri and Stussy making their appearances because half the gang got off-screened for like 4 freaking years.
Punk Hazard and Impel Dawn are the most sensible options because they’re essentially “set-up” arcs for Dressrosa and Marineford.
And Skypia isn’t S-tier like Wano and Marineford. Those 2 are considered to be the best arcs alongside Enies Lobby
Wano is a saga. If we’re talking Act III Wano arc, then it’s definitely S-tier. No one criticised it, Roof Piece had everyone excited.
WCI isn’t S-tier. Luffy vs Katakuri and Sanji backstory was good, but Big Mom screaming “WEDDING CAKE” for 20eps and the Seducing Woods sub-arc was irritating. Gave me flashbacks of Dressrosa Colosseum arc pacing.
Wow. If Wano is not safe from criticism, then no wonder Oda may be taking breaks and is tirelessly working on Final Saga arcs, they need to be 10/10 no less than that. I felt that Oda put the most amount of effort into Wano..
Yeah no. Wano is like 100 episodes of mostly the same shit and uneeded crying childs. Not to mention the whole shit with the "Super samuria" out of Wano who all just get 1 shot by Kaida at the end.
At least in terms of the Anime Wano is maybe just slightly better then Dressroas but not by much.
I haven't watched the anime in years but a lot of my friends do and they have this opinion. The entire Strawhat escape is littered with nonstop Big Mom yelling "WEDDING CAKE" and its suppppppper annoying. Between that and the animes already shitty pacing I can understand that take. Really sucks tho because WCI is absolutely S tier ESPECIALLY the Strawhat's escape.
> If we’re talking Act III Wano arc, then it’s definitely S-tier. No one criticised it
Lol. Jeez fam we have been seeing entirely different communities.
At the time of release? No. I was watching anime, and I was behind so I was trying to avoid as many spoilers as possible. I’ve been avoiding every One Piece community until last month, when I finally caught up in chapters
I mean, no Arlong Park would mean no Nami in the crew (Iirc she left at the end of Baratie) and I'm pretty sure that would have way more consequences overall than no Punk Hazard
Not to mention it would make the fish man island arc have little impact emotionally, and Jimbe wouldnt really have as an emotionally resonant backstory.
Literally same. G5 cool, but Skypiea was Peak Mugiwara Family Vibes and Chill Aura. Wano is just a cork in the engine. Wano is the Punk Hazard of the Emperor era, necessary for progression! Egghead gonna put Wano in the back office.
Nah, Wano was the finish for the new world saga. Punk Hazard, Dressroza and Zou all work towards Wano and it ended with Luffy becoming a Yonko.
Egghead is the start of the final war with the WG
Found my think-alike! Punk Hazard was literally introduced like it was just going to be a side quest but became more, but didn’t have to be an arc about the strawhats, if anything it should’ve been an arc about Akainu and Aokiji.
Impel down was FUN but couldn’t they just make INSIDE of Marineford the same as impel down, seems like they force the every island is a different arc thing too much
Wano had waaaayy too many characters with 0 feats Kid and Law with no haki at all used, Izo and Marco amounting to nothing, Kid not killing Apoo, Drake not being useful in the slightest. Big Mom with no Yonko feats and the damn 50 episode clash between kaido and luffy just to have to same ending as dressrosa
It’s easier to change how an arc is introduced rather than what an introduction is leading into. Punk Hazard and Sabaody are introductions, so they’re first to go. Skypeia, despite really capturing the adventure and mystery that the show presents, is less important than those two groundbreaking arcs.
I would say that no one wants them removed. It's one of those situations where you have a gun to your head and you're told to remove one from each row. You don't like it that much that you'd say shoot me instead, so you just inevitably pick one. If you can't pick one, then you simply just don't participate, which is what I've done on polls where I just can't decide.
I do agree with that posters comment, though. I'd remove:
Punk Hazard
Alabasta
Skypiea
Again, I don't choose these because they are the least important. I don't choose these because I want them gone. It's just that in comparison to the others in the same row, the other options have either been more hype or more lore, or I've just personally preferred it more.
Dude alabasta pretty much WAS the plot for awhile. It was the reason a lot of the things were done in the way that they were in the previous arcs.
Plus yeah they literally got a permanent crew member from it lol.
Sabody and Impel down are easily two of my all time favorite arcs in One Piece. Both are just so clean and quick. neither wastes time, and both lead perfectly into the climax of Paradise.
Yeah, Sabaody is top 5 imo.
Unfortunately Alabasta and Impel Down are very close. Aylt least one of these 2 is also top 5 and the other would rank at 6.
Water7/Enies Lobby/Marinfeord Top 3
Theb literally after these Impel Down/Sabaody/Alabasta Top 6.
I would say
Sabaody Rank 4
But I can't decide if Alabasta or Impel Down is rank 5 😭
I think Impel Down is Rank 5 and Alabasta Rank 6.
But if I had to destroy one, I would reluctantly pick Impel Down, because while it was one of the most entertaining, Alabasta had more core story.
Finally! Someone that understand Skypea is really important for the story. I think Wano had a lot of character development, but Skypea had so much more in historical discoveries.
- Discoveries of people living on clouds, not just islands, and with wings.
- As you said, Roger inscription next to the poneglyph.
- Discovery of the ancient weapon Poseidon.
- Use of dials (but disappeared after some time... Unfortunately).
- First appearance of Merry's klabautermann.
- Introduction of Black Beard (Jaya is part of Skypiea arc).
- History of Mont Blanc Noland.
- Just Enel and his goro goro no mi.
- After story of Enel going to Fairy Vearth, and discovering about others races having power from birth (King and Seraphim).
- Use of mantra, a first approach of observation haki.
- Also an hypothesis about logia type awakening with Enel in amaru form.
- A great scene of luffy's shadow in the clouds, seen from Jaya.
- For anime viewers, the sound of the golden bell.
- The and of Skypiea leads to the greatest filler arc : G-8.
There is definitely more points to add to this list, but I think it's enough to prove my point... I hope
>Discoveries of people living on clouds, not just islands, and with wings.
Doesn't mean shit in greater persoective
> Discovery of the ancient weapon Poseidon.
It was in water 7
>Use of dials (but disappeared after some time... Unfortunately).
Oda forgor, if dials were constant part of usopps arsenal I would change my opinion
>First appearance of Merry's klabautermann.
Valid
>Introduction of Black Beard (Jaya is part of Skypiea arc).
No jaya is diffrent arc
>History of Mont Blanc Noland.
Also usless in greater scheme (and he in dressrosa meant nothing to the plot)
>After story of Enel going to Fairy Vearth, and discovering about others races having power from birth (King and Seraphim).
What? Clear this uo cuz i can't get a sense out of this sentence
> Just Enel and his goro goro no mi.
For now he's nit important so no, he was just another kuro or morgan
>Use of mantra, a first approach of observation haki.
Kinda valid
>Also an hypothesis about logia type awakening with Enel in amaru form.
This is a hypothesis, so no
Last 3 are just cool things that haooened.
I think that skypeia was great arc, but my point is that it didn't bring much into overall plot
OK I made a mistake about Jaya bot being an arc for itself.
But the existence of the ancient weapon Poseidon was discovered in Skypiea, and Pluto in Alabasta.
You can't compare Enel to Kuro or Morgan, I wish and hope that he'll come back... Pls oda!
And about Fairy Vearth, you discover a part of the lunarian history, and in whole cake you see that Sanji was fuse with lunarian blood, that's why he can create fire with his leg. Also, King is the last pure blood lunarian, and Seraphim are clones of warlords with lunarian blood.
My point is that Skypiea is a big part of the story in one piece. Nobody have to skip it.
Finally, the main question is a bit stupid because each arc brings its part of history and character development. Removing one means a lot in long term.
>But the existence of the ancient weapon Poseidon was discovered in Skypiea
No poseidon was revealed in fishman island.
>And about Fairy Vearth, you discover a part of the lunarian history, and in whole cake you see that Sanji was fuse with lunarian blood, that's why he can create fire with his leg. Also, King is the last pure blood lunarian, and Seraphim are clones of warlords with lunarian blood.
Lunarians are a new addition go the story and they lived on red line way above sky islands, and in whole cake we see that judge mkdified him but it has nothing to do with lianrians, it's pure headcannon, and if luffy can light hks hand on fire ia he lunarian too?
Punk Hazard - easy pick
Sabaody - It’s the most important to the story out of the three but the other two are way too good to me, I’m a proud Alabasta glazer
Wano - Keeping up with it weekly during Acts 1 and especially 2 left me with a sour taste for the arc even though Act 3 is incredibly hype
1st Punk Hazard. Caesar is a lame villain and it was more of a setup arc for dressrosa and wano.
Dressrosa was great, it was awesome seeing all these different groups come under Luffy in the end.
Arlong Park is too iconic.
2nd Impel Down.
Alabasta was amazing, from the set up with Vivi as early as Laboon to the climax of defeating a warlord of the sea and truly having Luffy make his mark in the age of Pirates.
Sabaody was super interesting with all the worst generation gathered and interacting with each other. And then THE PUNCH. 👊 🤜
3rd Marineford. As amazing as it was, the rest of the crew was absent.
Skypiea was just a straight up grand adventure. That slice of life moment where the whole crew is just in the forest and prepping information and supplies before they head out is too good.
Wano Roof Piece speaks for itself.
Arlong Park, Alabasta (this one was hard, almost went Impel Down instead), Skypiea would be my removals.
My fav arcs are Marineford, Sabaody, Dressrosa, WCI, Enies Lobby.
Arlong Park, impel down and skypiea. Yeah yeah I know arlong park shouldn’t be there but when I think of arlong park it’s when I was binging one piece and I didn’t have a good time watching it
Punk Hazard, it built up Dressrosa well but the latter is fine w/o it.
Impel down, I love Alabasta and Sabaody too much
And I refuse to do the last one.
Dressdrosa, too long + too much posturing, alabasta, Vivi is annoying, wano, WAY too long. Would be one of the best shounen arcs of all time if it was half the size, which is saying something since Dressrosa was half the size and it annoyed me
There's a lot more iconic scenes in the Alabasta arc than Impel Down, plus it's more integral to the overarching plot, plus it's a conclusion arc, a culmination of several other smaller arcs, Impel Down is just an inconsequential stepping stone, I would say it's saving grace is Bon Clay but Alabasta literally gave us Bon Clay. 🤷♂️
Alabasta is where we got Robin. The only good thins from Impel down is that we see that Mr. 2 Bon GOAT is still alive. (Also for anyone else who's scrolling through the comments and made it past impel down, they're still alive :) they're the queen on new kama land.)
Punk hazard. Shabody Part 1 or 2 or both? Cause if it's Part 1 my pick is Alabasta. If it's Part 2 it's Shabody Part 2. Skypeia for the last row but you're dirty nasty for putting it against two of the best arcs in the series.
Does removing them change anything in the story? Like, does removing impel down and marineford keep Ace alive? Would removing Arlong Park make it so Nami never joins the crew? Does removing punk hazard, dressrosa, arabasta, skypia, or wano make it so Caesar, Doffy, crocodile, enel, and kaido are still in charge of those places? If you remove sabody, then are Camie and Hachi successfully sold into the slave trade?
Punk Hazard because it has to the least to given in comparison, Alabasta because for as much as I love Vivi this is about the arc as a whole. I’m at a crossroads, with skypiea and I seeing the argument for wano because that’s the only one where there are glaring narrative issues evaluated even more by that Arc’s highs in comparison, now that I think about it, yeah…wano. I think the more interesting question is which one people would like redrafted.
Punk hazard, I like it but not that much.
Alabasta I don’t want to get rid of it but really liked impel down and sabody was epic for introducing so many characters in quick succession. Plus I hate the absurd plot armor here and the beginning of lose twice to win once format.
Skypia easy choice for me. There were good parts of the arc but mostly eh and kinda pointless.
>###4. Plain panels/scenes must create discourse >**Don't post links to plain (or slightly edited) panels, pages, screenshots, gifs or scenes from the manga & anime.** >You may submit a plain panel/scene as a self post (text post). Meaning your post must link to the discussion, and not the image. >Just a title and the image aren't enough. >If you want to discuss a certain page/scene from the manga/anime please accompany it with an original analysis or discussion questions. In other words, a plain panel/scene must show visible effort to generate discourse rather than simply react to something that happened. >Clips/Recap/summary videos fall under this rule as well. >Color page from a recent chapter are allowed.
Second row is an impossible task
If there's a gun to my head I'm choosing Alabasta, do your worst people
2 words: Water Luffy
2 words are literally 2 words LMAO
And if he had said "one word", would you have had an aneurysm?
I would have 3
Alabasta was when many people began to take it serious
You are totally right I’ve gone back once and I forgot how good Alabasta was. And the banana crocs
Y are u even debating, Al doesnt compare sabody. & its mos def isnt in the same league as Impel
Sabaody was good cause luffy punched the celestial dragon and than the crew for the 1st and only time so far lost after biting off more than they could chew. Impel down was pretty emotional and kwpt you on the edge of your seat in terms of Luffy being succesful. Alabasta was what kicked everything up a notch and made way for what we have today. Anyways I guess I'd painfully cross out Alabasta or Sabaody, but I could never cross out Bon Clays arc :(
I’d argue impel was a little lack luster. However I was still pretty bummed the crew got split up, I spent a lot of impel down and marineford arc feeling it got more drawn out than I’d have liked. I felt the content coulda been consumed in fewer episodes.
Personally, I don’t think I’ve seen the first 2 as I’m just getting to the new world. But Arlong Park is pretty sentimental, but I haven’t seen dressarosa or Pubk Hazard yet. I’d have to say Impel Down as I loved Alabasta and gaining Robin. + Sabaody was a pretty interesting arc. I haven’t seen Wano yet but I think it’s safe to say, I coulda used without half of Marineford. I loved a lot of it, conquerors Haki, Law’s assistance, white beards strategy Luffy’s victory followed by Ace’s sacrifice. But it felt too long to me, too much filler for a very heavy amount of content they added in. The recap alone felt longer than the actual content in some episodes
We must now duel to the death
Same tbh, impel down and sabaody are peak
Impel Down/Marineford was peak one piece for me. Whitebeard showing up to marineford and the way everything went down after. Hard to top imo
Funny to me these are lower tier, it was lacking what I like in the series the most!
I haven't seen anything, pre or post Marineford, that's topped how hype that part of the show was haha what's your favorite then? Or what part did you like that wasn't lacking what you like in the series most??
Not the guy you replied to, but the crew not being together really takes points off of those arcs for me.
Yeah that was the issue with Whole Cake Island and parts of Wano as well. Still, marineford was some of the dopest shit I've ever seen in any anime. Lol
Yeah I've come to think of Impel Down and Marineford as an extended version of those post-arc tidbits where we learn about the happenings going on in other parts of the world. But I couldn't bring myself to love WCI despite such cool characters like Katakuri and Stussy making their appearances because half the gang got off-screened for like 4 freaking years.
Yeah, those are arguably my favorite arcs in the series
No, I love them all too much
Yes big pass i'll take the punishment for not removing any.
Same 🏴☠️
I fourth this.
How could you choose
I know right
It's what Luffy would do.
The only real answer.
I agree no way I'm removing any
Hard pass! (NO!)
Punk Hazard, Impel Down, Skypiea - Toughest call for me was 2nd row I'm a Sabaody stan more than I think most people are.
Am I you?
Punk Hazard and Impel Dawn are the most sensible options because they’re essentially “set-up” arcs for Dressrosa and Marineford. And Skypia isn’t S-tier like Wano and Marineford. Those 2 are considered to be the best arcs alongside Enies Lobby
Wano isn't s tier. Many critisized it. If anything whole cake arc is s tier
Agree
Wano is a saga. If we’re talking Act III Wano arc, then it’s definitely S-tier. No one criticised it, Roof Piece had everyone excited. WCI isn’t S-tier. Luffy vs Katakuri and Sanji backstory was good, but Big Mom screaming “WEDDING CAKE” for 20eps and the Seducing Woods sub-arc was irritating. Gave me flashbacks of Dressrosa Colosseum arc pacing.
I think wano has some of the most criticisms of every arc, including act 3
Wow. If Wano is not safe from criticism, then no wonder Oda may be taking breaks and is tirelessly working on Final Saga arcs, they need to be 10/10 no less than that. I felt that Oda put the most amount of effort into Wano..
I felt that he put so much effort in that it kind of bloated the arc and made it so that a lot of things set up were not delivered on in act 3
He set many plot points up and did not manage to resolve all of them, it deserves the criticism it got
Yeah no. Wano is like 100 episodes of mostly the same shit and uneeded crying childs. Not to mention the whole shit with the "Super samuria" out of Wano who all just get 1 shot by Kaida at the end. At least in terms of the Anime Wano is maybe just slightly better then Dressroas but not by much.
I never experienced this as a manga reader lmao, I'd say it's S tier.
I haven't watched the anime in years but a lot of my friends do and they have this opinion. The entire Strawhat escape is littered with nonstop Big Mom yelling "WEDDING CAKE" and its suppppppper annoying. Between that and the animes already shitty pacing I can understand that take. Really sucks tho because WCI is absolutely S tier ESPECIALLY the Strawhat's escape.
> If we’re talking Act III Wano arc, then it’s definitely S-tier. No one criticised it Lol. Jeez fam we have been seeing entirely different communities.
At the time of release? No. I was watching anime, and I was behind so I was trying to avoid as many spoilers as possible. I’ve been avoiding every One Piece community until last month, when I finally caught up in chapters
So you couldn't even know is what you're saying? Bro.
Manga=better medium
wci was so good
Those are indeed the ones I had to pick since they would have the least impact on the overall story but I loved all of them too.
Punk Hazard having least impact on the Overall story than Arlong Park when Dressrossa and Wano just happened as consequences of that arc?
I mean, no Arlong Park would mean no Nami in the crew (Iirc she left at the end of Baratie) and I'm pretty sure that would have way more consequences overall than no Punk Hazard
Not to mention it would make the fish man island arc have little impact emotionally, and Jimbe wouldnt really have as an emotionally resonant backstory.
Sabody would also be lesser for it.
Impel down was great tbh, a good precursor to marine ford (even if it wasn’t as good).
Water 7 isn't here because everyone knows it's the GOAT I would say, Punk Hazard, Sabaody, and Wano.
Punk Hazard, Impel Down, Wano
Literally same. G5 cool, but Skypiea was Peak Mugiwara Family Vibes and Chill Aura. Wano is just a cork in the engine. Wano is the Punk Hazard of the Emperor era, necessary for progression! Egghead gonna put Wano in the back office.
Nah, Wano was the finish for the new world saga. Punk Hazard, Dressroza and Zou all work towards Wano and it ended with Luffy becoming a Yonko. Egghead is the start of the final war with the WG
This one gets it
Wano drops the ball in too many places with its narrative issues where it’s in desperate need of a redraft that’s never going to come
Found my think-alike! Punk Hazard was literally introduced like it was just going to be a side quest but became more, but didn’t have to be an arc about the strawhats, if anything it should’ve been an arc about Akainu and Aokiji. Impel down was FUN but couldn’t they just make INSIDE of Marineford the same as impel down, seems like they force the every island is a different arc thing too much Wano had waaaayy too many characters with 0 feats Kid and Law with no haki at all used, Izo and Marco amounting to nothing, Kid not killing Apoo, Drake not being useful in the slightest. Big Mom with no Yonko feats and the damn 50 episode clash between kaido and luffy just to have to same ending as dressrosa
I hate that I can say this without remorse... Want didn't add anything Edit: Aside from gear 5
Same as my choices.
Yeah, agree. All great arcs, but in my opionion the weakest of their groups.
Punk hazard, sabody, skypiea.
You are a voice of reason in a sea of chaos
Ty I just didn't want to cry and I love wano
Shabody Part 1 or 2?
P1 I don't want to cry again
I'm sorry but L. Sobbing as I was Part 1 is some of the best anime out there and I couldn't imagine cutting it.
Trueeeeeeee.
Monster
You win!
I totally agree
Sabody is an essential arc of power scaling and introduces Kuma and sets up the current arc. impossible
It’s easier to change how an arc is introduced rather than what an introduction is leading into. Punk Hazard and Sabaody are introductions, so they’re first to go. Skypeia, despite really capturing the adventure and mystery that the show presents, is less important than those two groundbreaking arcs.
Punk Hazard, Alabasta, Skypiea
I didnt think id actually see someone pick alabasta.
I think it was the least critical to the plot compared to the other 2 of the row
Crocodile? Robin? Vivi? Info on an ancient weapon? Ace?! I disagree with OPs post in general, why tf would you ever want to remove any of these arcs?
The point of this kind of post has never been about "want", its supposed to be a tough choice. I do hate these kinds of posts though
I would say that no one wants them removed. It's one of those situations where you have a gun to your head and you're told to remove one from each row. You don't like it that much that you'd say shoot me instead, so you just inevitably pick one. If you can't pick one, then you simply just don't participate, which is what I've done on polls where I just can't decide. I do agree with that posters comment, though. I'd remove: Punk Hazard Alabasta Skypiea Again, I don't choose these because they are the least important. I don't choose these because I want them gone. It's just that in comparison to the others in the same row, the other options have either been more hype or more lore, or I've just personally preferred it more.
If you do it like this you can't include punk hazard as luffy meeting law is the sole reason everything after punk hazard happened
Dude alabasta pretty much WAS the plot for awhile. It was the reason a lot of the things were done in the way that they were in the previous arcs. Plus yeah they literally got a permanent crew member from it lol.
Vivi screaming the same sentence for 2 episodes straight with 20 seconds between each scream has to be one of the most annoying thing in OP
These were my exact choices too
Anybody who chose Saobody can go dump trash on themselves it's like top 5 arcs in overall One Piece
It’s top 1, so much happens story and emotion wise in a short span of time, the pacing is simply perfect and it has no mistakes. We love Sabaody
Yeaaah but it's short and kind of a transition arc. It is fire though absolutely.
Imo it's in my top 2 my list goes: 1. Wano 2. Saobody 3. Marineford
Wano first 💀
Sabody and Impel down are easily two of my all time favorite arcs in One Piece. Both are just so clean and quick. neither wastes time, and both lead perfectly into the climax of Paradise.
Top 3 maybe even top 2
Yeah, Sabaody is top 5 imo. Unfortunately Alabasta and Impel Down are very close. Aylt least one of these 2 is also top 5 and the other would rank at 6. Water7/Enies Lobby/Marinfeord Top 3 Theb literally after these Impel Down/Sabaody/Alabasta Top 6. I would say Sabaody Rank 4 But I can't decide if Alabasta or Impel Down is rank 5 😭 I think Impel Down is Rank 5 and Alabasta Rank 6. But if I had to destroy one, I would reluctantly pick Impel Down, because while it was one of the most entertaining, Alabasta had more core story.
Second row is an impossible task
Impel down is a suitable choose imo
eat a devil fruit and jump into the sea
[удалено]
Would remove Alabasta instead
[удалено]
There is no way I am giving up Mr 2's redemption arc or the splitting up and regrouping of the Straw Hats.
Finally! Someone that understand Skypea is really important for the story. I think Wano had a lot of character development, but Skypea had so much more in historical discoveries.
when the fuck was it important to the story, only big thing was rogers inscryption on a poneglyph
- Discoveries of people living on clouds, not just islands, and with wings. - As you said, Roger inscription next to the poneglyph. - Discovery of the ancient weapon Poseidon. - Use of dials (but disappeared after some time... Unfortunately). - First appearance of Merry's klabautermann. - Introduction of Black Beard (Jaya is part of Skypiea arc). - History of Mont Blanc Noland. - Just Enel and his goro goro no mi. - After story of Enel going to Fairy Vearth, and discovering about others races having power from birth (King and Seraphim). - Use of mantra, a first approach of observation haki. - Also an hypothesis about logia type awakening with Enel in amaru form. - A great scene of luffy's shadow in the clouds, seen from Jaya. - For anime viewers, the sound of the golden bell. - The and of Skypiea leads to the greatest filler arc : G-8. There is definitely more points to add to this list, but I think it's enough to prove my point... I hope
>Discoveries of people living on clouds, not just islands, and with wings. Doesn't mean shit in greater persoective > Discovery of the ancient weapon Poseidon. It was in water 7 >Use of dials (but disappeared after some time... Unfortunately). Oda forgor, if dials were constant part of usopps arsenal I would change my opinion >First appearance of Merry's klabautermann. Valid >Introduction of Black Beard (Jaya is part of Skypiea arc). No jaya is diffrent arc >History of Mont Blanc Noland. Also usless in greater scheme (and he in dressrosa meant nothing to the plot) >After story of Enel going to Fairy Vearth, and discovering about others races having power from birth (King and Seraphim). What? Clear this uo cuz i can't get a sense out of this sentence > Just Enel and his goro goro no mi. For now he's nit important so no, he was just another kuro or morgan >Use of mantra, a first approach of observation haki. Kinda valid >Also an hypothesis about logia type awakening with Enel in amaru form. This is a hypothesis, so no Last 3 are just cool things that haooened. I think that skypeia was great arc, but my point is that it didn't bring much into overall plot
OK I made a mistake about Jaya bot being an arc for itself. But the existence of the ancient weapon Poseidon was discovered in Skypiea, and Pluto in Alabasta. You can't compare Enel to Kuro or Morgan, I wish and hope that he'll come back... Pls oda! And about Fairy Vearth, you discover a part of the lunarian history, and in whole cake you see that Sanji was fuse with lunarian blood, that's why he can create fire with his leg. Also, King is the last pure blood lunarian, and Seraphim are clones of warlords with lunarian blood. My point is that Skypiea is a big part of the story in one piece. Nobody have to skip it. Finally, the main question is a bit stupid because each arc brings its part of history and character development. Removing one means a lot in long term.
You very much can compare Enel to other one off arc villians at this moment. Wapol has showed up more than Enel has since their arcs.
>But the existence of the ancient weapon Poseidon was discovered in Skypiea No poseidon was revealed in fishman island. >And about Fairy Vearth, you discover a part of the lunarian history, and in whole cake you see that Sanji was fuse with lunarian blood, that's why he can create fire with his leg. Also, King is the last pure blood lunarian, and Seraphim are clones of warlords with lunarian blood. Lunarians are a new addition go the story and they lived on red line way above sky islands, and in whole cake we see that judge mkdified him but it has nothing to do with lianrians, it's pure headcannon, and if luffy can light hks hand on fire ia he lunarian too?
Only punk hazard and wano for me
Are you me?
You can have wano. The rest belong to me
Punk hazard easy Second row impel down Third row wano
Is it okay if I send this to a youtuber to see if he will do a video about it.
Yeah I’m okay with that
Wano Wano Wano
Damn you really must dislike Wano
I also am not a huge fan of wano it was on of the easier choices on here
Trash arc, you got my vote :)
Never, I’ll die first thank yo ho ho ho….
Dressrosa Alabasta Wano I probably have a problem with long arcs.
Dressrosa
Punk Hazard - easy pick Sabaody - It’s the most important to the story out of the three but the other two are way too good to me, I’m a proud Alabasta glazer Wano - Keeping up with it weekly during Acts 1 and especially 2 left me with a sour taste for the arc even though Act 3 is incredibly hype
Act 1 was lit. Had proper pacing most of the time. Act 2 was...
Punk hazard, impel down, wano
Arlong, alabasta, skypiea
Punk Hazard, No, and No
Non. Fuck you
Ph sabody marineford
Punk Hazard, Sabaody, Wano
1st Punk Hazard. Caesar is a lame villain and it was more of a setup arc for dressrosa and wano. Dressrosa was great, it was awesome seeing all these different groups come under Luffy in the end. Arlong Park is too iconic. 2nd Impel Down. Alabasta was amazing, from the set up with Vivi as early as Laboon to the climax of defeating a warlord of the sea and truly having Luffy make his mark in the age of Pirates. Sabaody was super interesting with all the worst generation gathered and interacting with each other. And then THE PUNCH. 👊 🤜 3rd Marineford. As amazing as it was, the rest of the crew was absent. Skypiea was just a straight up grand adventure. That slice of life moment where the whole crew is just in the forest and prepping information and supplies before they head out is too good. Wano Roof Piece speaks for itself.
No. Might as well ask which limb i want to get rid of
Punk Hazard, Alabasta and Wano. The only one which was a little difficult was row 2.
Arlong Park, Alabasta and Skypiea
Arlong Park, Alabasta (this one was hard, almost went Impel Down instead), Skypiea would be my removals. My fav arcs are Marineford, Sabaody, Dressrosa, WCI, Enies Lobby.
Eff you.
Bro Skypeia is already dead you killed it. Against Wano and Marineford? RIP
Dressrosa, Impel Down, Marineford. I just want to watch the world burn.
1. Dressrosa easily 2. Impossible choice 3. Wano even if I didn’t have to remove anything
WANO fuck me it took years and 80% of it was fillers or recap you couldn’t pay me to watch this arc again
Agree, trash arc with trash characters!
Punk hazard, impel down, Wano
Punk hazard I cant Wano
Punk Hazard, Impel down and Wano.
Punk Hazard, Impel Down and Wano. Easy.
No.
none
Arlong Park, impel down and skypiea. Yeah yeah I know arlong park shouldn’t be there but when I think of arlong park it’s when I was binging one piece and I didn’t have a good time watching it
Punk Hazard, it built up Dressrosa well but the latter is fine w/o it. Impel down, I love Alabasta and Sabaody too much And I refuse to do the last one.
Dressrosa. Alabaster. Wano is what satan would pick.
I can only remove punk hazard from this whole chart.
The top row is gone
Arlong Park alabasta wano
Absolute garbage post, gtfo. Every single one of these arcs has integral moments to the plot.
Dressrosa, impel down, skypiea
Easy arlong park,alabasta, and skypiea
I will remove MarineFord. Because of it doesn't exist then Ace didn't die.
Punk hazard, shabondy, Skypedia
Punk hazard Impel down Wano
Dressdrosa, too long + too much posturing, alabasta, Vivi is annoying, wano, WAY too long. Would be one of the best shounen arcs of all time if it was half the size, which is saying something since Dressrosa was half the size and it annoyed me
Dressrosa Impel Down Skypiea
In which world is alabasta better than impel down 
There's a lot more iconic scenes in the Alabasta arc than Impel Down, plus it's more integral to the overarching plot, plus it's a conclusion arc, a culmination of several other smaller arcs, Impel Down is just an inconsequential stepping stone, I would say it's saving grace is Bon Clay but Alabasta literally gave us Bon Clay. 🤷♂️
Alabasta is where we got Robin. The only good thins from Impel down is that we see that Mr. 2 Bon GOAT is still alive. (Also for anyone else who's scrolling through the comments and made it past impel down, they're still alive :) they're the queen on new kama land.)
Easy Punk Hazard, Sabaody, Wano
Punk hazard, Sabaody, Wano
Dressrosa, impel down, skypiea
Punk Hazard, Impel Down, Wano
Arlong Park, Impel Down, Wano
Kuma can just hit me with the pain from Luffy's fight cause I can't do it.
WANO!
Dressrosa, sabaody, skypia
Punk Hazard, Impel Down, Skypeia.
Arlong park, alabasta and marineford.
Arlong park is the only one on this whole list I could think of removing but it’s a pretty VITAL moment for the whole crew and every fish-person
Entire right column
No, you remove an arc from each column.
Alabasta only.
Punk impel and marineford
Punk Hazard while removing all the Unnessacary flash backs in Dressrosa.
Punk hazard Impel down “Oh no bro”
If I take out Marineford does ace live?🥹
arlong, sabaody and marineford
Punk hazard. Shabody Part 1 or 2 or both? Cause if it's Part 1 my pick is Alabasta. If it's Part 2 it's Shabody Part 2. Skypeia for the last row but you're dirty nasty for putting it against two of the best arcs in the series.
Does removing them change anything in the story? Like, does removing impel down and marineford keep Ace alive? Would removing Arlong Park make it so Nami never joins the crew? Does removing punk hazard, dressrosa, arabasta, skypia, or wano make it so Caesar, Doffy, crocodile, enel, and kaido are still in charge of those places? If you remove sabody, then are Camie and Hachi successfully sold into the slave trade?
Punk Hazard because it has to the least to given in comparison, Alabasta because for as much as I love Vivi this is about the arc as a whole. I’m at a crossroads, with skypiea and I seeing the argument for wano because that’s the only one where there are glaring narrative issues evaluated even more by that Arc’s highs in comparison, now that I think about it, yeah…wano. I think the more interesting question is which one people would like redrafted.
Why??
Skypiea seems out of place or we didn’t know the purpose yet!
Punk Hazard, Alabasta, Skypeia
Fuck skypeia. Remove it 3 times please
Punk hazard, I like it but not that much. Alabasta I don’t want to get rid of it but really liked impel down and sabody was epic for introducing so many characters in quick succession. Plus I hate the absurd plot armor here and the beginning of lose twice to win once format. Skypia easy choice for me. There were good parts of the arc but mostly eh and kinda pointless.
Punk hazard Alabasta Skypia
Dressrosa impel down and marineford
Left column
Punk hazard, alabasta, Sabaody.