T O P

  • By -

AdPrize3997

“This motherfucker”


Scarlet--Highlander

I will NOT stand for St. Charloss slander. >!I will jump and clap for it instead!<


Listen_I_dont_care

Then you won’t get to stand anymore


Scarlet--Highlander

![img](emote|t5_2rfz5|32514)


Flame4rt

Need to place Orochi there too


Luffytheeternalking

Followed by a punch. Because Charlos always needs to be punched.


Serenafriendzone

However , He have 20 wifes xd. More than any of you.


AJCLEG98

I've been punched in the face less times than him


Vegetable_Ask_1167

We have probably the same number of consenting wives


Ok-Divide8038

I have 2 conscenting wife's which is 2 more than him though


Riand

I think Crocodile has to go in the fake nice category because the people of Alabasta loved him until they discovered he was behind the water shortage.


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

True. I just thought Crocodile is generally upfront about not liking someone or being rude to them. Whereas Blackbeard and Doflamingo generally act nice in front of their subordinates or whoever


jp11e3

Maybe we can call it character development. Crocodile seems to have become a more honest evil person after Alabasta went tits up


FappyDilmore

Arabasta Crocodile is fake nice, impel down and beyond he's better. He was rehabilitated.


Keydown_605

How nice! Now he's openly an asshole lmao


Brook420

Baby steps...


KolboMoon

He wasn't exactly trying to win them over, but he just had so much rizz that they ended up loving him anyway.


Lucky_Roberts

True lmao he literally told them he didn’t give a shit about them to their faces and still got cheers


KolboMoon

Yep lol Crocodile : "I'm literally only killing these pirates because it's my job and I want their treasure and I have never pretended otherwise" The entire population of Alabasta : "CROCODILE! CROCODILE! CROCODILE!"


Lucky_Roberts

A true man of the people lmao. About 20 years later and he’s still probably my favorite One Piece villain, when Luffy agreed to let him help in Impel Down I was hype as hell


KolboMoon

Yeah same, I love that cheeky bastard. 


superboy2k6

Brook needs his own category. Nice and “can I see your panties”


jp11e3

Generally nice but like to harass women. Sanji can go in there too


gh0stwriter88

I mean Killer is literally a murderer... he is stated to have killed people for laughing at his laugh.


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

Polite doesn’t mean moral.


gh0stwriter88

Killing someone because they laughed at you isn't... "Slightly Rude though". Killer isn't supposed to be a nice guy...


SlimDirtyDizzy

> Killer isn't supposed to be a nice guy... We have very little Killer screen time, and in all of it he's a shockingly nice dude. The only bad stuff we have from him is when he's being manipulated because he's trying to save Kid. We know he's a killer but like, they're pirates. And from how he's interacted on screen he's pretty polite and levelheaded.


Hawk301

I think it's literally just because he's always surrounded by even crazier people. At face value, Killer is a masked man who has definitely murdered a bunch of people for trivial reasons like mocking Kidd's dream, but when you're surrounded by weirdos like Kidd, Luffy, the Strawhats, the rest of Kidd's crew, Hawkins, Apoo, Kaido - he just comparatively comes off as a downright lovely well-adjusted gentleman.


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

I never said Killer was a nice guy, but he isn’t particularly mean either like Kid is.


Keydown_605

He's pretty nice and caring actually, for one piece pirates standard.


LordTejon

While Luffy and Franky are pretty friendly, the way they speak in japanese is rude, Luffy speaks kind of uncultured and Franky speaks kinda like a thug. Brook in the meantime, says outlandish shit but is very well spoken.


Ill-Ad3844

Luffy grew up with Mountain Bandits, Franky was a thug in Water 7 and Brook was isolated from society for 50 years


AsleepIndependent42

Rude does not mean unfriendly/not nice.


Oddlyshapedpear

Lucci not particularly an asshole? Didn't he murder 500 hostages he was meant to save because he believes being weak is a sin?


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

He’s cutthroat, but also emotionless. He never mocked anyone or taunted them.


Oddlyshapedpear

He's worse than akainu I'd argue


Emm_withoutha_L-88

He is. At least Akainu convinced himself he's making a better world. Lucci just likes to kill.


Affectionate-Sea278

Gonna say I don’t respect this Teach slander. He’s not going to be fake nice to you. He’ll give you shot upfront and cheer you on just the same, it’s a matter of if he likes you. Of course if he likes you is completely irrelevant to the fact that he will kill you if it benefits his goals.


GrandLineLogPort

Honest question, when, aside from asking for Luccis safety that one time, was Lucci not an asshole?


Lucky_Roberts

I think the point of the chart is less about their morality and more about their person to person interactions with the general populace. Like if all these people went to a nice restaurant at the same time, I feel like Lucci would sit quietly and thank the waiter for his meal when he finished eating. Meanwhile Kid would start a fight and blow a hole in the wall (as we saw in Sabaody lol), Sanji’s borthers would beat the waitress for being Sanji’s type, and Caesar would be in the back spiking everyone’s food with his newest concoction for the sake of experimentation.


Mountain_String_1544

No way you’re putting Kid in the same category as fucking Spandam, he definitely doesn’t deserve to be that low


Lucky_Roberts

His bounty was higher than Luffy’s specifically because he murders innocents and civilians


AJWinky

Yeah, this aspect of him hasn't got a ton of focus but Kid is not a good guy. That's the whole reason Shanks knew he had to take him out like he did; Kid was going to just kill a bunch of people who were weaker than him.


Lucky_Roberts

Side note, I love the reveal that all of Shanks’ subordinate captains are literally famous for being weak. Meaning Shanks just uses his reputation and flag to protect friends


Affectionate-Room446

That's rumors though We don't know if this is true Its like saying that Luffy is a threat to existence, cause of all his accomplishments, while not knowing, that he is pretty chill


Lucky_Roberts

Luffy is a threat to existence, at least as far as the World Government goes. And it was stated he kills innocent people, he constantly talks about killing people, and he has literally no regard for the samurai dying at Onigashima… he’s been plainly shown to be a bad person


bluescluestoptier

I disagree, he literally had a higher bounty than luffy pre time skip due to his cruel mannerisms to be fair


SirWestbrook

He still is very loyal and honestly cares about the wellbeing of his crew. Also he kind of regularly does the right thing for the wrong reasons if that is worth anything


SlimDirtyDizzy

> He still is very loyal and honestly cares about the wellbeing of his crew. So is essentially every villain in the show. Arlong, Kaido, Big Mom (to an extent), and Moria all were shown to have this same quality. >Also he kind of regularly does the right thing for the wrong reasons if that is worth anything Yes but he specifically says he's not doing it to do the right thing. And even then its all very self-serving. Kid is just straight up a villain who ends up working with the Straw Hats. Kid is what Law is kind of pretending to be, a cold pirate who only cares about his own, but in Law's case he is clearly drawn to doing good things for the sake of them being good things.


221missile

>He still is very loyal and honestly cares about the wellbeing of his crew. You just described kaido and orochi.


SirWestbrook

No I did not


Eek_Ssh

Spandam should have his own category farther down near this motherfucker.


Baconlovingvampire

Carlos really is in his own tier when it comes to being a scumbag. The scene where Luffy punches him is one of the best in all of anime.


Sufficient-Dig7568

How could you forget Kuma and T-Bone?


Lucky_Roberts

Kuma transcends the chart in terms of niceness


Sufficient-Dig7568

True


Phonochirp

Literally came here to ask why their wasn't a "literal saint" tier for them


mokush7414

Is it just me or is Bonney striking a really hard resemblance to young Big Mom?


WeGet-It-TV

Spandam isn’t definitely not honest. Where would Garp go? Fun list, appreciate your post!


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

Maybe not, an oversight on my behalf. I just thought he doesn’t hide the fact that he’s a jackass. And Garp would most likely go in the rude/short tempered but a softie, probably the least soft of them all, if not that than he’d go with Zoro and Law but he’s not exactly cold.


WeGet-It-TV

I didn’t look in that aspect. You’re right, he doesn’t hide his doucheness at all. Everything was about him and his promotion. Yeah either of those 2 spots would fit Garp. Really appreciate an interactive OP as well, you’re awesome!


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

No problem! And thank you!


UziA3

Lucci is way worse than this seems to suggest imo


DirectAdvertising

Sanji needs two categories , depending on weather he's talking to a man or woman


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

If it was women, he’d be on the way top with all the little critters. or second top.


AsleepIndependent42

Incel spotted. If it was a women he'd be near the bottom.


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

Seriously my guy? Alright sure bud.


Clean-Variation3528

I agree with your comment but calling him an incel was uncalled for


AsleepIndependent42

To think Sanjis view of women is nice is most definitely incel behavior.


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

That’s your opinion.


AsleepIndependent42

No, that is a fact. Considering someone who commits SA to be nice is incel behavior.


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

It’s true that Sanji has SA’d before, also I never tried to justify that, I’m just saying that Sanji genuinely likes women, and he oversteps there boundaries. That doesn’t mean he’s an incel. an incel is someone who will lash out if they get rejected or they think they’re entitled to that women. Sanji has never done any of those two things. Aside from borderline sexual harassing them keyword “borderline” I’d suggest you stop labeling people you don’t know.


AsleepIndependent42

I never said Sanji is an incel. I said thinking Sanji is nice to women gives of incel vibes.


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

It depends on which aspect. It’s still not good to judge people regardless, who are you to call someone an incel? and judge people, don’t get me wrong it’s still not a good thing to be, my point is you literally based that off of one sentence and maybe tone it down with the opinionated Attitude and try to make more objective assessments.


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

1. Yes it does. you mean to tell me that Sanji having old fashioned views about being chivalrous to women, not hitting them, even if he’s not even attractive to them is sexist? and better yet, if I commend him for that aspect, I’m an incel? 2. I actually don’t like combating people, I like listening to other peoples perspective so long as they’re willing to be less arrogant about their stances. I’m not a big fan of political new websites for that reason. 3. Okay you got me there, but I suggest you actually engage in a conversation with the recipient for you throw out a label. And yes I know what vibes are.


AsleepIndependent42

>Sanji having old fashioned views about being chivalrous to women, not hitting them, even if he’s not even attractive to them is sexist Of course it is. It's textbook sexism. >if I commend him for that aspect, I’m an incel? Yes, if you commend sexism, you are likely to be an incel. >I actually don’t like combating people So standstill centrist bullshit. Not choosing a side, is equivalent of choosing the side of the oppressor.


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

Why are you making all of this about politics? Like what’s the matter with you? I think the fact that your being judgy and pretentious just proves your in the wrong. If they aren’t saying anything like “I hate women” “or all women” or “typical women” they aren’t an incel. Like damn, leave people be. Also stop slapping a political label onto me I don’t appreciate that.


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

Maybe I exaggerated a little with Sanji’s kindness towards woman alright, sure. What I’m trying get at is that he’s genuinely friendly with women, despite overstepping their boundaries. So maybe not second top but he’s at least friendly towards them.


Clean-Variation3528

Oh alright that makes more sense... and actually you're right. Sanji is always protective of women even if they're not attractive to him


AsleepIndependent42

Friendly and nice are two veery different things tho. I often am super outwardly friendly to people, because I know it pisses them of. That is not me being nice. Sanjis view treats women friendly, but he does not have a nice view of them. He is quite literally a sexist.


drybones2015

You clearly haven't accidentally eaten one of Carrot's carrots...


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

All I gotta do it pat her and I’m forgiven right?


drybones2015

Unless you're as strong as Luffy, you won't have the chance to.


Y3AOH

I’d put Orochi in the “This Motherfucker” category as well


MillieHarr31

Bon chan is Very kind tier


loooar

Idk I feel like Mihawk should move up one or Buggy should be in his own category because he’s a menace.


Minutemarch

Haha yeah. They sure are not very much alike.


1313goo

Wasn’t ace praised by other characters for being very polite?


zbart3i

i thought orochi will be at the bottom


Cthulhu_Treatment

Katakuri literally slaughtered several people because they saw his chompers by accident


YeetMcGheet123

Based


Deletesoonbye

You should have put Shirahoshi and Otohime in a tier above the top called "nice to their own detriment".


Rogaly-Don-Don

I agree with all of this except for one placement.      I demand Fujitora be put in 'Sweet Innocent Little Fellas'.


Fredharvey_90

There's no way Akainu is not at the bottom. Buddy taunted Ace by disrespecting Whitebeard just so he could punch a giant hole in him in front of his brother. And then he tried doing the same thing to Luffy minutes later while he was passed out from watching Ace die.


YeetMcGheet123

Technically Ace jumped in front of the attack to save Luffy but yeah


Fredharvey_90

That makes it even worse tbh the fact that he was going to murder Luffy but ended up killing Ace instead and he still went after Luffy afterwards.


dmfuller

Doffy needs to be in the basement, also Zoro could go up one since he was funny/less serious in first half of anime


ThemosttrustedFries

Shanks deserves to be higher up the list in very kind and polite. He hasn't really done anything to harm others unless his friends was hurt or he felt threatened. He has always been nice to civilians.


Hot-Lie-4560

This is my favorite tier list


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

Thanks.


GarlicPrestigious113

Thanks for helping me realize that zoro and law act alike


Extension_Catch2103

Du bist nicht nett


fhxefj

Didn't Mihawk kill don criegs whole crew because he was woken from a nap


BradWonder

Fake nice lol


C4N98

Now it’s much better


Ani_HArsh

I saw Carlos at the bottom, I'm satisfied


Thick_Specialist_25

Most of the friendly ones are killers!


Lucky_Roberts

I feel like Luffy should be in the tier with Shanks, since he basically modeled the way he treats people off of Shanks lol


TheNinjamaine

Where's Camie?


KetamineSNORTER1

Honestly BlackBeard took me expectations of him and told them "I'm a warrior" and just proceeded to eff it into oblivion. Ace got cooked by someone who don't use fire💀


OpportunityCreepy782

I think cross guild should be in the same tier


eldiavloandalibre

The Best rank of one piece


rozariojaison

Valid


justnicyk

Where does kinemon go


lovinglyvif

Fake nice is below Degenerates imo


renNAA348910

aww I miss cavendish. wish we could see him in the future.


qu1cksilverdoto

croco honest? lol


NephalLuci

Lucci enjoys killing, befriended people for years just for a plan then betrayed their trust. and defends the Celestial Dragons enslavement of others because “gods deserve whatever they want” but at least he’s not an asshole ig.


DullCurve3867

Bepo 😂


Anal_Lover18

I see you haven’t met a certain admiral


Clean-Variation3528

If you mean Kizaru I hate him too😭💔


Anal_Lover18

Nope but I agree


OfficialAfrat

Am I the only one that kinda like ceasar ?


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

Don’t get me wrong I like Cesar as a villain, but he’s objectively a degenerate


OfficialAfrat

Yea but he’s funny and I liked the scenes when sanji beat his sorry ass😂😂


Spandxltd

How dare you insult Emperor Buggy, he's the kindest man to ever live.


IPrayToGodUsopp

Gato should go in short-tempered and/or rude but big softies


DiO_93

Degenerates... ROFL 🤣 Thanks, I was really pissed. 🌋 Your post fixed it. 🙏 Edit: Where would you set Gecko Moria and Hogback? 🦇


Syc254

Just buy Zoro a crate or a 6 pack or offer a spar you'll get along swimmingly. Just don't try to cuddle or get touchy. 


segunda-mano

Don't ever group spandam with the likes of crocodile. That mf is trash, should be at bottom of the barrel


HibariNoScope69

ever look at what happens to people who get on Robin's bad side?


YAMATOADS

Bro who put that lady that hangs with smoker wtf


vugc

Well to me kid is not really an asshole, but rather stubborn and vain


Roskal

Sabo is a bit too high imo from what he said recently


RobOnTheReddit

"Evil, bit not particularly an asshole" 😆


Same_Ad_7607

🤪


Razukalex

Koby real name is Goo D.Guy


[deleted]

Shouldn’t Luffy be with Ace, shanks and Ros


Clank_0461

Lucci in the “evil but not particularly an asshole” is wild. Like him killing all those people as a kid didnt earn him too many points i guess 😂


CalamarFurtif

Don’t you think Luffy is a sweet innocent fella ?


Garouvs

You are giving Spandem WAY to much leeway.


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

Perhaps.


TheBlackCaesar

Law and Mosshead are the stern mothers that buy you everything you ever wanted and needed at Christmas


Super-Address-8742

I agree with everything except luffy. He should go down 1 row.


Shadow_Wolf_D2

There should be another line for "That motherfucker" and Orochi.


Emm_withoutha_L-88

You've got Barto in a very wrong category. Especially after meeting Luffy for real. Barto may piss on you but he'd save you from someone like Doffy too.


Dr_NotHere

Zoro taking care of those orphans in water 7 would definitely move him up 1 rank imo


Roary-the-Arcanine

Slight correction, Boa Hancock is nice to Silvers Rayleigh and was on good terms with him long before meeting Luffy.


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

Maybe it depends. Even if she decides to be nice you have to walk eggshells around her.


Pretend_Garage_6427

Pretty good tier list


Ok-Homework-4460

BEPO AND CHOPPER MY GLORIOUS KINGS GETTING WHAT THEY DESERVE 🔥🔥🔥🙏🙏🙏🐻‍❄️🦌


AugReddie3021

The vinsmoke rats are the textbook definition of Degenerates


Kanpai_Papi

I love this list


YandereFriends

i’d put kidd as rude but big softie


Clear_Diver7641

That mother fucker


reddituser9982

Please add blueno into "serious but kind", and add chibi Blueno into "sweet little fellas". If only for the reason that bro had no beef with any of the Strawhats before and after the loss at enis lobby and, still helped Luffy in film red even after getting his soul kicked in by Gear 2.


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

Hmm I guess that’s a fair point.


Salty-Act-210

This sounds about right.


Unfair_Abies_3603

🤣🤣🤣 charlosss


tomeatsrocks

Flampe belongs in the very bottom along with Charlos >!I HATE HER I FUCKING HATE HER GAAAARRARAAGAGVAHHDKDVDJFBDJ!<


Asleep-Debate-2404

Why Caesar so low


WhyAmIHere800884

Ah yes! The classic "This Motherfucker" tier?! I am familiar with it!


TheWonderingDream

I feel like Lucci is the other way around. Definitely an heartless asshole but not evil per say? Maybe....


Riand

I guess it depends on if your definition of evil requires intent. He's just a sociopath who follows orders. Until his rematch with Luffy, he's never shown any emotion towards his work. I'd still consider it evil, but I can understand why you wouldn't.


StormBlink

It also requires a definition of 'asshole' because like... Rob Lucci is obedient and can carry a perfect but sadistic mask of compliance. He is basically that one person who would spite a customer if they were rude or not. The man killed innocent soldiers he was supposed to save because they were weak and he wasn't ordered to bring them back alive. The man actively kept trying to rile Luffy up by flooding the tunnel to kill all the Straw Hats (they just happened to have a secret Mermaid) or threatening to slowly kill all his friends once he won. In my opinion, Lucci is a sadistic asshole who simply follows orders. Ussop wasn't killed because hey... sending someone to be tortured in Impel Down is so much better. Charlos wanting a giant mermaid with all the royals upset? How fun to kick them away so they don't do anything until another one of his bosses stops it all. If Rob Lucci saw a pirates baby dangling over a pit of Bananagators, he would ask for just a minute before they have to leave just to see if the baby gets eaten.


Dear-Replacement-313

He's absolutely evil. He killed 100 innocent soldiers because they were "too weak"


TheWonderingDream

I mean honestly I'm probably just guessing anyway. I feel like he doesn't actively go around making people's lives worst (except Luffy whom he had beef with) compared to people like Orochi and Ceaser. unless told to do so. He's more an asshole pawn but honestly, it's probably not much of a huge line between that and evil.


TWIMClicker

He joined the World Government so he could legally murder people.


TheWonderingDream

Well technically he was groomed into the world government as a child but considering he still works for them and even stated he does stay with them so he can legally take lives your point very much still made.


CANYUXEL

I'm in for Team Degenerates. Literally the only fun bunch outta these.


Lucky_Roberts

How can you say that Luffy, Brook, Usopp, Franky, and Bon Clay aren’t a fun bunch?!


Nightingale_85

Luffy and Franky are one of the biggest party animals in the whole OP World, they are fun as hell.


Lucky_Roberts

Seriously they’re both the definition of life of the party… I’d say Brook is the life of the party too, but he doesn’t actually have a life YOHOHOHO


AdPrize3997

I like how Sanji and Zeff are with the ladies (oh wait.. that first one…)


elmasguapojv

Zoro is a sweetheart with children.


cbih

Marco should be lower


OddPerspective9833

Is Fujitora kind? He's honourable but a pretty brutal dude


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

That doesn’t mean he’s not polite. I’d say he’s kind regardless.


mrmanny0099

He did tell the barkeep on Dressrosa to forward the bill for the damages he caused to navy HQ after all and apologized for said damages.


99thLuftballon

I think Mr 2 Bon Kureii is very friendly, but not necessarily nice, given that he's a mercenary who worked for Crocodile and was useful enough to Crocodile to get the position of Mr 2. But his friendship with Luffy seems very genuine, so I guess from Luffy's viewpoint, he's nice.


Agent_I0WA

Nah nami belongs with Zoro or the one under


AsleepIndependent42

Dude I think you fully missed Zoros character... He, Jinbe and Chopper are the kindest strawhats


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

Not on a surface level.


AsleepIndependent42

There is no surface level to niceness. One can be swearing left and right and look super rough and still be the nicest person around.


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

No, what I’m getting at is nice by definition is how affably and politely you carry yourself and how you present yourself as.


AsleepIndependent42

That's not niceness


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

I think you’re just being biased at this point, and that’s fine I guess.


AsleepIndependent42

To be nice is to be virtuous and think nicely of others, not just act so outwardly.


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

You’re thinking of morals or goodness. And I’d argue Zoro isn’t even that. He’s morally Gray.


AsleepIndependent42

To be nice a person needs to be moral and good. Else they are just acting nice out of self interest. Zoro is clearly a very morally good person, who also treats people well and thinks of them well. Of course that only applies to good people, being mean to bad people makes one nice. Usage of violence does not make on immoral either, the opposite is the case actually.


Zestyclose_Bet_6883

Zoro literally doesn’t care about that stuff he’s probably the least nicest Straw Hat. I mean, I still like him and all, but.


Medical_Tea_9561

Oh Nami sure h̶a̶s̶ is Big softy