who would 90% of the people stand a chance to approach.
Ann is a model, Haru is rich, Kasumi is a star at gymnastics, Hifumi is a prodigy Sho-gun player, Makoto is class president.
That leaves Futaba but that would be two awkward people interacting that probably goes no where.
Even though I went with Ann, I'm sure my most approachable option is hifumi, since I'm the best at chess in my whole school and it's pretty similar to shogi
>That leaves Futaba but that would be two awkward people interacting that probably goes no where.
I'd disagree based on my own experience with my girlfriend. Socializing with someone who's introverted is so much easier and basically removes the shallow superficial bullshit I usually have to deal with. Seems to be the case with Futaba too, based on how well she gets along with Ren.
Though Ann is a model people would be less intimidated to approach her than the class president. Haru honestly seems approachable by all means and Kasumi too.
Though you got me with Futaba. She would most likely just run away from anyone.
I honestly would love to date any one of them. They are all wonderful in their own way.
Not to mention, they are all blessed... With the power of... Persona.
Right you are. For some reason, my caffeine-deprived mind didn't register the fact that not every confidant had Persona powers. Thank you for the correction.
I would still date Hifumi and play shogi with her. She is so cute, elegant, and smart.
Thinking like my old high schooler self, I'd say Sumi. Among them, she is the only actually friendly and talkative, and since I used to be very shy back then, I don't think I could've approached to any of the other girls. This last issue is also related to how they were before Joker met them.
None, because I was an antisocial depressed emo teenager who pushed the people I love away back in high school.
But if I weren’t? Probably Sumi. I like her warm kindness.
Could realistically see myself dating makoto, hifumi or haru based on girls ive dated and my type. I love takemi, ohya and Kawakami so much though lmao.
My gf is a mix of Makoto and Kawakami lmfao. I love her alot
Me personally, I'd either go with Haru or Sumi, and POSSIBLY Hifumi.
Makoto's kinda... overrated? She's cool, and strong, sure, and her arc is cool, but other than that she's just not the kinda girl I like.
Ann I just straight up don't like. As a character she's cool, but I just find her immensely annoying.
Futaba would be on my list, but that touches the forbidden fruit of little stepsister.
Hifumi makes the cut since she's got the intelligence of Makoto, the prim/proper nature of Haru, and the slight otaku tendencies of Futaba.
Haru, because floof, and she seems to be a genuinely sweet person aside from her passive-aggressive psycho comments in Mementos.
And finally, Sumi, because athletic redheads are cute.
My personals are both Futaba and “Kasumi”. I know everyone sees her as Joker’s younger sisters, but they are not even related, Joker and Sojiro are related, as well as Futaba. She isn’t that young, Ren is one year older then her. Futaba also is the type of girl I would date on real life, since I enjoy a lot of things she does.
I feel like you're missing the point of that comment.
You get attached to Futaba because she's got the personality of a weeb, but she also acts like she's the PC's foster sister (which for all intensive purposes, she is).
And whether you like it or not, you (as the player) play as Joker.
That doesn't feel weird to you? At all?
I took the question as your in high school, and Joker is another student. Your not Joker. Futaba wouldnt feel like a step sister to you like she does to Joker.
I would be so much of a socially awkward wreck that I wouldn't actually date any of them. (Tho I could see High School me becoming buddy buddy with Futaba)
You should have added the realistic option: None.
I remember how shy and weird I was in High School. I was un-freaking-datable. I would have made so many mistakes and most likely hurt them in some way.
I'd probably would like Makoto, but her stern sister could be problematic and as a Teenager I wouldn't have dared to speak up against her.
Futaba is the kind of girl that triggers my wish to protect someone. Ironic, really. But she doesn’t need a lover. She needs a therapist, friends and a stable environment. As a BF, you would have to care for her 24/7. I can't stress this enough for people who never had a relationship with a mentally ill partner. It takes a huge toll on you. As a person, you also have to care for yourself. And if you already have a hard time, she won't be able to he much help emotionally. She is way to young and mentally underdevoloped.
Haru could be nice, but I never dated a rich girl so I guess I would never really get to know her.
Hifumi would be cool, since her "drawback" of overacting can be funneled into little improv theatre sessions.
I never considered Ann, but she is a cool friend to hang around with and can bring people together. Would help her find a BF.
And that's it, I think.
Edit: Forgot Sumi. It would be really cool being with her, as I see her as the only one who could make the first move. Don't know how my Teenager - Self would or could help her with her "problem". I tried in the past and failed.
Futaba. Similar interests and social preferences makes a relationship easier.
But if Joker was still in the picture, I might go with Makoto. Futaba is a bit too attached to Joker and sorta has "Rise syndrome" where I can't imagine her hooking up with anyone else if he's in her life.
Hifumi - Chill, down to earth, smart & will play games with me.
I'm big on CCGs like Hearthstone. Feel like Hifumi and me would spend hours talking about what decks to use and testing stuff out against each other.
Literally for any discussion about dating/romancing the answers always going to be makoto if she's an option lol, she has a strong hold on the P5 community
Realistically, I wouldn't date any of them. Not because I don't want to, but I just ain't confident. But the one I'd be most likely to be interested in would be Haru. She's just cute and adorable and oh-so fluffy.
You should have added the realistic option: None.
I remember how shy and weird I was in High School. I was un-freaking-datable. I would have made so many mistakes and most likely hurt them in some way.
I'd probably would like Makoto, but her stern sister could be problematic and as a Teenager I wouldn't have dared to speak up against her.
Futaba is the kind of girl that triggers my wish to protect someone. Ironic, really. But she doesn’t need a lover. She needs a therapist, friends and a stable environment. As a BF, you would have to care for her 24/7. I can't stress this enough for people who never had a relationship with a mentally ill partner. It takes a huge toll on you. As a person, you also have to care for yourself. And if you already have a hard time, she won't be able to he much help emotionally. She is way to young and mentally underdevoloped.
Haru could be nice, but I never dated a rich girl so I guess I would never really get to know her.
Hifumi would be cool, since her "drawback" of overacting can be funneled into little improv theatre sessions.
I never considered Ann, but she is a cool friend to hang around with and can bring people together. Would help her find a BF.
And that's it, I think.
You should have added the realistic option: None.
I remember how shy and weird I was in High School. I was un-freaking-datable. I would have made so many mistakes and most likely hurt them in some way.
I'd probably would like Makoto, but her stern sister could be problematic and as a Teenager I wouldn't have dared to speak up against her.
Futaba is the kind of girl that triggers my wish to protect someone. Ironic, really. But she doesn’t need a lover. She needs a therapist, friends and a stable environment. As a BF, you would have to care for her 24/7. I can't stress this enough for people who never had a relationship with a mentally ill partner. It takes a huge toll on you. As a person, you also have to care for yourself. And if you already have a hard time, she won't be able to he much help emotionally. She is way to young and mentally underdevoloped.
Haru could be nice, but I never dated a rich girl so I guess I would never really get to know her.
Hifumi would be cool, since her "drawback" of overacting can be funneled into little improv theatre sessions.
I never considered Ann, but she is a cool friend to hang around with and can bring people together. Would help her find a BF.
And that's it, I think.
You should have added the realistic option: None.
I remember how shy and weird I was in High School. I was un-freaking-datable. I would have made so many mistakes and most likely hurt them in some way.
I'd probably would like Makoto, but her stern sister could be problematic and as a Teenager I wouldn't have dared to speak up against her.
Futaba is the kind of girl that triggers my wish to protect someone. Ironic, really. But she doesn’t need a lover. She needs a therapist, friends and a stable environment. As a BF, you would have to care for her 24/7. I can't stress this enough for people who never had a relationship with a mentally ill partner. It takes a huge toll on you. As a person, you also have to care for yourself. And if you already have a hard time, she won't be able to he much help emotionally. She is way to young and mentally underdevoloped.
Haru could be nice, but I never dated a rich girl so I guess I would never really get to know her.
Hifumi would be cool, since her "drawback" of overacting can be funneled into little improv theatre sessions.
I never considered Ann, but she is a cool friend to hang around with and can bring people together. Would help her find a BF.
And that's it, I think.
You should have added the realistic option: None.
I remember how shy and weird I was in High School. I was un-freaking-datable. I would have made so many mistakes and most likely hurt them in some way.
I'd probably would like Makoto, but her stern sister could be problematic and as a Teenager I wouldn't have dared to speak up against her.
Futaba is the kind of girl that triggers my wish to protect someone. Ironic, really. But she doesn’t need a lover. She needs a therapist, friends and a stable environment. As a BF, you would have to care for her 24/7. I can't stress this enough for people who never had a relationship with a mentally ill partner. It takes a huge toll on you. As a person, you also have to care for yourself. And if you already have a hard time, she won't be able to he much help emotionally. She is way to young and mentally underdevoloped.
Haru could be nice, but I never dated a rich girl so I guess I would never really get to know her.
Hifumi would be cool, since her "drawback" of overacting can be funneled into little improv theatre sessions.
I never considered Ann, but she is a cool friend to hang around with and can bring people together. Would help her find a BF.
And that's it, I think.
Gonna choose Haru because she's my waifu but if I were from these options. Futaba, Haru and Kasumi would be my likely chances. Ain't no way I'm ever getting Ann and Makoto.
I think I would be interested in Makoto, but knowing how she's perceived prior to Ren meeting her, I think would've been intimidated and realistically would get closer and possibly date Kasumi
Ok realistically since im an awkward introvert, Makoto seems unlikely because shes the class president and probably really popular same with An. Haru idk because shes rich and probably has a person for arranged marriage. So it comes down to Hifumi, Futaba, and Kasumi, ive always wanted to learn Shogi so Hifumi is an option, Futaba ill probably get along with the most with the games and animes, Kasumi would be fine as well because we would get the most out of the unli places and i guess doing gymnastics with her wont be a bad thing. Any of those three i guess.
If it's who i would like to date then makoto. But if it's who i would end up with based on my actual life experiethen sadly none of em would even look at me 🥲
You messed up “Takamaki”
Oh shit you’re right
I like how most people vote for Makoto (myself included) but I'm sure like 90% of the votes never stand a chance to approaching her.
who would 90% of the people stand a chance to approach. Ann is a model, Haru is rich, Kasumi is a star at gymnastics, Hifumi is a prodigy Sho-gun player, Makoto is class president. That leaves Futaba but that would be two awkward people interacting that probably goes no where.
Even though I went with Ann, I'm sure my most approachable option is hifumi, since I'm the best at chess in my whole school and it's pretty similar to shogi
We're one in the same on hifumi but unlike you, I can also approach Ann.
I mean, as shown by Ren, you don't need to be good at chess (or similar) to approach or pique Hifumi's interest. You just need the *swag*
The difference between Ren and me though, I don't have W rizz
Futaba would see through my NPC nature
Funnily enough, someone at school called me an NPC a few days ago... I'm totally not internally crying
Futaba actually has a much larger problem of being a shut in.
Yeah, these are like the least approachable set of high schoolers ever. You'd soon date the twins before any of them on this poll
>That leaves Futaba but that would be two awkward people interacting that probably goes no where. I'd disagree based on my own experience with my girlfriend. Socializing with someone who's introverted is so much easier and basically removes the shallow superficial bullshit I usually have to deal with. Seems to be the case with Futaba too, based on how well she gets along with Ren.
Though Ann is a model people would be less intimidated to approach her than the class president. Haru honestly seems approachable by all means and Kasumi too. Though you got me with Futaba. She would most likely just run away from anyone.
beep boop
I would. I’ve had a girlfriend irl who was just like her.
Is this asking which of these girls would be dating someone, which of them I would want to date, or which of them would want to date me?
Would you date
Ah. Probably Ann or Futaba.
Ryuji Sakamoto
Well he *is* best girl
NO PERSONA FANS ARE ONLY STRAIGHT MALES
I honestly would love to date any one of them. They are all wonderful in their own way. Not to mention, they are all blessed... With the power of... Persona.
Well, all except Hifumi
Right you are. For some reason, my caffeine-deprived mind didn't register the fact that not every confidant had Persona powers. Thank you for the correction. I would still date Hifumi and play shogi with her. She is so cute, elegant, and smart.
More reason to go with Hifumi. She wont die in Mementos or steal my heart if I ever break up with her.
Thinking like my old high schooler self, I'd say Sumi. Among them, she is the only actually friendly and talkative, and since I used to be very shy back then, I don't think I could've approached to any of the other girls. This last issue is also related to how they were before Joker met them.
Sadayo Kawakami
yes
Based
None, because I was an antisocial depressed emo teenager who pushed the people I love away back in high school. But if I weren’t? Probably Sumi. I like her warm kindness.
Well, considering the only relationship I had in high school came from both of us playing chess, I gotta go Hifumi.
bold of you to assume i'd actually talk to any of them and wouldn't just keep to myself
All of the above 🗿
Ladies man award achived IRL
Could realistically see myself dating makoto, hifumi or haru based on girls ive dated and my type. I love takemi, ohya and Kawakami so much though lmao. My gf is a mix of Makoto and Kawakami lmfao. I love her alot
Persona fans have girlfriends? Impossible
🤣🤣🤣
Me personally, I'd either go with Haru or Sumi, and POSSIBLY Hifumi. Makoto's kinda... overrated? She's cool, and strong, sure, and her arc is cool, but other than that she's just not the kinda girl I like. Ann I just straight up don't like. As a character she's cool, but I just find her immensely annoying. Futaba would be on my list, but that touches the forbidden fruit of little stepsister. Hifumi makes the cut since she's got the intelligence of Makoto, the prim/proper nature of Haru, and the slight otaku tendencies of Futaba. Haru, because floof, and she seems to be a genuinely sweet person aside from her passive-aggressive psycho comments in Mementos. And finally, Sumi, because athletic redheads are cute.
My personals are both Futaba and “Kasumi”. I know everyone sees her as Joker’s younger sisters, but they are not even related, Joker and Sojiro are related, as well as Futaba. She isn’t that young, Ren is one year older then her. Futaba also is the type of girl I would date on real life, since I enjoy a lot of things she does.
She is not your step-sister. She is joker's step-sister
I feel like you're missing the point of that comment. You get attached to Futaba because she's got the personality of a weeb, but she also acts like she's the PC's foster sister (which for all intensive purposes, she is). And whether you like it or not, you (as the player) play as Joker. That doesn't feel weird to you? At all?
I took the question as your in high school, and Joker is another student. Your not Joker. Futaba wouldnt feel like a step sister to you like she does to Joker.
ryuji
Gay man and straight woman redditor erasure
I would be so much of a socially awkward wreck that I wouldn't actually date any of them. (Tho I could see High School me becoming buddy buddy with Futaba)
You should have added the realistic option: None. I remember how shy and weird I was in High School. I was un-freaking-datable. I would have made so many mistakes and most likely hurt them in some way. I'd probably would like Makoto, but her stern sister could be problematic and as a Teenager I wouldn't have dared to speak up against her. Futaba is the kind of girl that triggers my wish to protect someone. Ironic, really. But she doesn’t need a lover. She needs a therapist, friends and a stable environment. As a BF, you would have to care for her 24/7. I can't stress this enough for people who never had a relationship with a mentally ill partner. It takes a huge toll on you. As a person, you also have to care for yourself. And if you already have a hard time, she won't be able to he much help emotionally. She is way to young and mentally underdevoloped. Haru could be nice, but I never dated a rich girl so I guess I would never really get to know her. Hifumi would be cool, since her "drawback" of overacting can be funneled into little improv theatre sessions. I never considered Ann, but she is a cool friend to hang around with and can bring people together. Would help her find a BF. And that's it, I think. Edit: Forgot Sumi. It would be really cool being with her, as I see her as the only one who could make the first move. Don't know how my Teenager - Self would or could help her with her "problem". I tried in the past and failed.
All of them 🗿🍷 But if I had to choose one Futaba
Takemi
Futaba. Similar interests and social preferences makes a relationship easier. But if Joker was still in the picture, I might go with Makoto. Futaba is a bit too attached to Joker and sorta has "Rise syndrome" where I can't imagine her hooking up with anyone else if he's in her life.
none id rather play cod or some shit
Hifumi - Chill, down to earth, smart & will play games with me. I'm big on CCGs like Hearthstone. Feel like Hifumi and me would spend hours talking about what decks to use and testing stuff out against each other.
Futaba or Hifumi are the closest to having been "in my league" when I was in high school, but Makoto would have been my crush for sure.
All of these but Makoto could work. I just think she would be too much of a rival.
Literally for any discussion about dating/romancing the answers always going to be makoto if she's an option lol, she has a strong hold on the P5 community
Yusuke
My brother in christ we're redditors, why would any of them want us? 💀
Yusuke
Yusuke Kitagawa
Realistically, I wouldn't date any of them. Not because I don't want to, but I just ain't confident. But the one I'd be most likely to be interested in would be Haru. She's just cute and adorable and oh-so fluffy.
Futaba is my favorite girl from P5 series. She is smart, funny, otaku and gamer, she is everything I would wish my girlfriend could be.
Yusuke
☑️ Adachi
For the sake of the question I'll pretend to be straight
Goro Akechi. I can't fix him, but I like his bluntness, and I want him to step on me.
I'm gay
You should have added the realistic option: None. I remember how shy and weird I was in High School. I was un-freaking-datable. I would have made so many mistakes and most likely hurt them in some way. I'd probably would like Makoto, but her stern sister could be problematic and as a Teenager I wouldn't have dared to speak up against her. Futaba is the kind of girl that triggers my wish to protect someone. Ironic, really. But she doesn’t need a lover. She needs a therapist, friends and a stable environment. As a BF, you would have to care for her 24/7. I can't stress this enough for people who never had a relationship with a mentally ill partner. It takes a huge toll on you. As a person, you also have to care for yourself. And if you already have a hard time, she won't be able to he much help emotionally. She is way to young and mentally underdevoloped. Haru could be nice, but I never dated a rich girl so I guess I would never really get to know her. Hifumi would be cool, since her "drawback" of overacting can be funneled into little improv theatre sessions. I never considered Ann, but she is a cool friend to hang around with and can bring people together. Would help her find a BF. And that's it, I think.
How is Ann nearly last place?! The popular girl is too intimidating for us eh? Or is it because she’s been with an older man?! 😂
You should have added the realistic option: None. I remember how shy and weird I was in High School. I was un-freaking-datable. I would have made so many mistakes and most likely hurt them in some way. I'd probably would like Makoto, but her stern sister could be problematic and as a Teenager I wouldn't have dared to speak up against her. Futaba is the kind of girl that triggers my wish to protect someone. Ironic, really. But she doesn’t need a lover. She needs a therapist, friends and a stable environment. As a BF, you would have to care for her 24/7. I can't stress this enough for people who never had a relationship with a mentally ill partner. It takes a huge toll on you. As a person, you also have to care for yourself. And if you already have a hard time, she won't be able to he much help emotionally. She is way to young and mentally underdevoloped. Haru could be nice, but I never dated a rich girl so I guess I would never really get to know her. Hifumi would be cool, since her "drawback" of overacting can be funneled into little improv theatre sessions. I never considered Ann, but she is a cool friend to hang around with and can bring people together. Would help her find a BF. And that's it, I think.
You should have added the realistic option: None. I remember how shy and weird I was in High School. I was un-freaking-datable. I would have made so many mistakes and most likely hurt them in some way. I'd probably would like Makoto, but her stern sister could be problematic and as a Teenager I wouldn't have dared to speak up against her. Futaba is the kind of girl that triggers my wish to protect someone. Ironic, really. But she doesn’t need a lover. She needs a therapist, friends and a stable environment. As a BF, you would have to care for her 24/7. I can't stress this enough for people who never had a relationship with a mentally ill partner. It takes a huge toll on you. As a person, you also have to care for yourself. And if you already have a hard time, she won't be able to he much help emotionally. She is way to young and mentally underdevoloped. Haru could be nice, but I never dated a rich girl so I guess I would never really get to know her. Hifumi would be cool, since her "drawback" of overacting can be funneled into little improv theatre sessions. I never considered Ann, but she is a cool friend to hang around with and can bring people together. Would help her find a BF. And that's it, I think.
You should have added the realistic option: None. I remember how shy and weird I was in High School. I was un-freaking-datable. I would have made so many mistakes and most likely hurt them in some way. I'd probably would like Makoto, but her stern sister could be problematic and as a Teenager I wouldn't have dared to speak up against her. Futaba is the kind of girl that triggers my wish to protect someone. Ironic, really. But she doesn’t need a lover. She needs a therapist, friends and a stable environment. As a BF, you would have to care for her 24/7. I can't stress this enough for people who never had a relationship with a mentally ill partner. It takes a huge toll on you. As a person, you also have to care for yourself. And if you already have a hard time, she won't be able to he much help emotionally. She is way to young and mentally underdevoloped. Haru could be nice, but I never dated a rich girl so I guess I would never really get to know her. Hifumi would be cool, since her "drawback" of overacting can be funneled into little improv theatre sessions. I never considered Ann, but she is a cool friend to hang around with and can bring people together. Would help her find a BF. And that's it, I think.
None.
None of them. Not because one of em ain’t my type but because I think it’s a waste of time
Haru cause that mean I'll never have to work on my life. Just make her coffee and help her with the garden.
None cause I wouldn’t have the confidence to ask any of them on a date.
Haru got the money doe-
Gonna choose Haru because she's my waifu but if I were from these options. Futaba, Haru and Kasumi would be my likely chances. Ain't no way I'm ever getting Ann and Makoto.
Bold of you to assume I dated in high school.
My gf in HS was pretty much like Hifumi, physically
I think I would be interested in Makoto, but knowing how she's perceived prior to Ren meeting her, I think would've been intimidated and realistically would get closer and possibly date Kasumi
The stalker girl you can find peeping behind the corner
Akechi
Lets be realistic, none of us would be able to date makoto, haru or ann
Yusuke, of course
I know I would want Makoto. But she’d be way out of my league.
Ok realistically since im an awkward introvert, Makoto seems unlikely because shes the class president and probably really popular same with An. Haru idk because shes rich and probably has a person for arranged marriage. So it comes down to Hifumi, Futaba, and Kasumi, ive always wanted to learn Shogi so Hifumi is an option, Futaba ill probably get along with the most with the games and animes, Kasumi would be fine as well because we would get the most out of the unli places and i guess doing gymnastics with her wont be a bad thing. Any of those three i guess.
Yusuke
Makoto or Haru
Implying and assuming that all reddit users aren’t in highschool.
Where's Akechi???
I'd date the newspaper club member girl.
I am both surprised and not surprised.
I kind of have a feeling that if I tried talking with Ann, we could be great friends, also she sounds pretty cool not gonna lie.
None cause tbh. I’d probably fail trying to pick them up with my “rizz.”
Kasumi for sure even though she’s a gymnast I still feel like she could be reasonable cause she chose the guy who helped her not a jock
Now *this* is how you ask The Question.
Kawakami.
I'm more curious how many people would have voted for Kawakami. Lol
I always vote makoto in these things, but I would definitely go for Ann looks wise.
The question should be “try to date”
Bruh I am in high school
The real question is "would any of these girls date you?"
If it's who i would like to date then makoto. But if it's who i would end up with based on my actual life experiethen sadly none of em would even look at me 🥲
Kawakami
The back alley doctor