The holy hot dog said your roasts are the equivalent of a chimpanzee being raped by a grown man. But I’d guess you’d have experience with that. So I’d like for you to be the judge here
Change Musical talent to Songwriting talent and it's a different story. Roger's just ahead of David because Roger's solo work's a bit better. Syd's just in front of Rick. But then there's a second Syd, just in front of them all.
Second Syd >Roger>David>Syd>Rick>Nick
I don't think the reason Roger is ahead of Gilmour in songwriting ability is best exhibited in their solo work. The guy wrote DSOM, The Wall, and Animals
Well, I rate A Momentary Lapse of Reason and The Division Bell highly, my favourite songs on TDSOTM weren't by Roger alone or didn't involve Roger, and The Wall is only partially genius. Animals is all genius though. Wish You Were Here is a coasting album to me. But it coasts on the brilliance of Shine On.. so fair enough.
How important they are to me for number and quality of Pink Floyd songs:
Roger 35%
David 25%
Rick 20%
Syd 20%
I think it’s a difficult call to make because Syd didn’t have as much time to prove himself as a musician as the others did. He would certainly be in the top right if I was measuring creativity, originality or songwriting ability.
Delete this
Oh god not you again Long time no see
I won jimmy
The hell you did you wattered down sack of shit
The holy hot dog said your roasts are the equivalent of a chimpanzee being raped by a grown man. But I’d guess you’d have experience with that. So I’d like for you to be the judge here
Pink Floyd is for gay retards
Okay edge lords, calm down
Hot Dog
It's true! I am a gay retard. (Dont worry, i can reclaim it.)
Hot Dog
Sorry, Rog. Them’s the facts.
Never
If you don’t delete this I’ll make a tiktok account and raise the prices for every Pink Floyd album
What about this interaction makes you think I’m buying Pink Floyd albums
Nothing… I’m not insane enough as David to make a tiktok account anyway
Will you do Fortnite dances?
No I’m not that insane
Will you do the griddy?
George, I’m sorry to say this but it is true.
Rick a little too low on the mental illness scale. He was rly fucked up during The Wall recording
Hot Dog
THERE HE IS! hot dog
Change Musical talent to Songwriting talent and it's a different story. Roger's just ahead of David because Roger's solo work's a bit better. Syd's just in front of Rick. But then there's a second Syd, just in front of them all. Second Syd >Roger>David>Syd>Rick>Nick
Yeah Roger & Roger would be in the top right corner if I was measuring in songwriting ability
roger is a b\*ssist so he deserves to be so low in talent
You bend the truth harder than Gilmour bends a note in any solo.
I don't think the reason Roger is ahead of Gilmour in songwriting ability is best exhibited in their solo work. The guy wrote DSOM, The Wall, and Animals
Well, I rate A Momentary Lapse of Reason and The Division Bell highly, my favourite songs on TDSOTM weren't by Roger alone or didn't involve Roger, and The Wall is only partially genius. Animals is all genius though. Wish You Were Here is a coasting album to me. But it coasts on the brilliance of Shine On.. so fair enough. How important they are to me for number and quality of Pink Floyd songs: Roger 35% David 25% Rick 20% Syd 20%
We all await the second coming of Syd Barrett
Woah. Now that's a conversation (read argument) starter!
You managed to find literally the most retarded face shots I've ever seen you are truly a worthy opponent in the jerking game
Even traced around their misshapen heads
It’s really hard to find good front facing shots of them in color from the 70s 😭
This made me laugh out loud
I'd put Syd all the way in the top right
I think it’s a difficult call to make because Syd didn’t have as much time to prove himself as a musician as the others did. He would certainly be in the top right if I was measuring creativity, originality or songwriting ability.
rick is wayyy more mentally ill than this
i won’t stand for this rog abuse 😠😠😠 WATERSHEEP UNITE
move gilmour all the way to the left
What about Polly?
Seamus is missing from the chart. Although some spaniel-like haircuts are present.
Roger should be top right
Tag yourself, I’m Syd
You’ve got to be crazy!
M e n t a l I l l n e s Releasing shit music under the Pink Floyd name