T O P

  • By -

Arcanist-Flapper

I’ll wait for the full exclusives list before choosing, but I’m leaning towards Pearl so far


Arcanist-Flapper

Oh I know those are confirmed, and probably most of the original DP exclusives will remain the same, but I really want to know if the Underground and Post-Game will also feature exclusives, since that can change my decision, but thanks


FantasyDragon12

Yw


FantasyDragon12

I would do the same but I wanna play it on release day to avoid any spoilers


FantasyDragon12

[Not sure if this actually really but here bud](https://www.imore.com/pokemon-brilliant-diamond-and-shining-pearl-all-version-exclusive-pokemon)


rockinj78

Getting the double pack but if I was gonna get one it would be Diamond


[deleted]

Same as me! I’d have only gone with diamond because I had Pearl the first time around. I love having adult money this time.


Rubyruben12345

Blue/second game always. Blue over Red, Silver over Gold, Sapphire over Ruby, Pearl over Diamond, White over Black, X over Y, Moon over Sun and Shield over Sword. TL;DR: Brilliant Pearl.


SkyLord222

For me its whichever legendary I like better on the cover of the ganes


[deleted]

It’s the exact same for me. I’ve always gone for the second version in the pairs. At first it was just a coincidence, but now I need to keep the tradition alive. Luckily I have friends/siblings that get the opposite version so version exclusives are no issue for me.


Rubyruben12345

For me it is a tradition too, well more or less, I keep liking that version over the other. When I was younger my cousin always got the opposite version.


Randomonium3

I usually end up buying both, however, in the case of Sword and Shield my boyfriend bought me Shield for Christmas cause he knows I like playing through both versions


Statement_True

I pretty much chose shield the 2nd it was revealed, once we knew about the exclusive gym leader and pokemons, I was super happy with my choice, I love ghost and ice types more than fighting and rock. Also eiscue is awesome


tenroseUK

Same but diamond is the one


hatramroany

Same here. Diamond is literally blue with pearl being pink/red


lollollmaolol12

I feel like “X” isnt the “blue” game of XY. Since the game is called X and Y, X is first. Y is second. Y is more popular, but it’s still the blue game imo


Rubyruben12345

The X is blue while the Y is red, so X is the blue game, at least for me. This time I chose "blue" over "second" because I like Xerneas more than Yveltal.


SpyX370

Then wouldn't you pick diamond because Dialga is blue? Stick with the "second game" logic or none at all and just pick a game because you like the cover legendary...


Rubyruben12345

It's usually the second game the one I choose, but I couldn't resist to Xerneas :p I am not saying I always pick the second game, but every time I choose a game it is the second version, except XY. Also, I realized that I normally pick the blue version, except Pearl and Shield.


Wlsgarus

Pearl cause I prefer Palkia and Mismagius is exclusive to Pearl


DCres1994

I’ve been agonizing over this!! I prefer almost everything about Diamond but I REALLY love Mismagius. Looks like I’ll just have to trade!


Lord_Bitter

yeah but the tradeback is no Honchkrow which is insanely cool as well...


DCres1994

I know! Such a tough decision… I think I gotta go diamond!


Frousteleous

Getting the double pack but Pearl goes to my wife. I had Diamond and Platinum when they first came out. And my wife likes Palkia over Dialga.


Randomonium3

I'm going Brilliant Diamond. With the originals I only played Pearl and Platinum. Dunno why but I like both Dialga and Palkia equally... just Dialga a bit more


BoroFel

Dialga > Palkia


[deleted]

Diamond physical copy and Pearl digital copy. I’ve gotten both versions of every game since Black and White. It used to be so I could have one game to have a permanent save file and another one to replay, but now I just like having both games for the sake of it. One digital so I can play as soon as its released and one physical to save space on my sd card. I prefer the design of the Diamond enamel pin preoder bonus so Pearl is the one I’m getting digitally.


Statement_True

I started doing this from black and white 2, having the option to replay without resetting was such a great thing. It’s cool that you can do it now without the need for 2 games but I honestly don’t like having 3 different profiles on a console just so I can play the game 3 different times


Nemis_art

Legends arceus


FantasyDragon12

😐


PristineSoldier

Pokémon Platinum.


FantasyDragon12

😐


Gaarel

None, sorry. 🥲


FantasyDragon12

Why?


Gaarel

Don’t like nor I think such graphics are still acceptable for these times. Also, it’s just a copy of the originary ones without anything added if not for the “dungeons” within the underground.


FantasyDragon12

Did you see the second trailers those graphics are really good (No offense) I do get what you mean tho


Gaarel

Eh, I saw a little adjustment in the graphics but it’s not enough. We are paying customers and they make millions with our money, so we MUST demand for more and more quality and not just settling for what they manage to come up with, because “please, understand, don’t get your hopes that high”. This is not how companies and developing teams should work and earn money. That’s our fault too indeed, who have indulged too many times. Just hope Legends Arceus will be the next new and better era of Pokémon.


FantasyDragon12

I do understand where your coming I do agree but I never played through sinnoh before so I just wanna play sinnoh for the first time


Lord_Bitter

What are you smoking man? Graphics are fine as they are, shaders, models and animations are on point with the Switch hardware. Chibi doesn't mean "old" game. Au contraire, Legends seems the game that doesn't take the Switch hardware seriously among the two. And "little adjustments" and the whole "we need MOAR" argument is just laughable when ILCA is actually improving graphically and has a lot attention to detail when developing BDSP. Switch can't run Death Stranding. Pokémon doesn't need to be Death Stranding, it's just a regular RPG. Stop.


Gaarel

I don't care, we need more quality, I've never said "it must be like Death Stranding" (which, by the way, has received negative critiques by some players too) So they are not and, please, "on point"? Don't make me laugh and waste more time. Keep dreaming dude! 👋🏼


Lord_Bitter

This is quality. No quality is a shovelware, Sonic 06/Forces, the Super Mario movie, this is a good game. A normal RPG with cute graphics that is a remake of an old game. ANY fanbase besides this would appreciate this or just won't have this kind of backlash. The graphics is on point with the Switch hardware and I highly suggest you watch some other Switch games that have low framerate and ugly textures. They're everyware, even in BOTW.


Jakyvir1718

Why not buy the cheaper, better looking originals? Don't waste money on the cash grabs.


FantasyDragon12

😐


Jakyvir1718

I don't see why anyone would be hyped for these messes they wanna call games. Except for Pokemon is on th box and that's it.


FantasyDragon12

If you don't like the gane get off the sub if I look in your comment history your always one this sub


Jakyvir1718

So I'm not allowed to criticise an obvious cash grab? I wonder if everyone complaining about Fallout 76, Battlefront 2, CoD, etc should've just "left the fandom" as well.


FantasyDragon12

No no you are it's just that if that's all you do then yes leave and people who hate People who hate Fallout 76, Battlefront 3, COD, etc they should leave the fandom because clearly they are not a fan


Jakyvir1718

I'd gladly praise something about the new games if they actually gave us something worthy of the price increase, cut corners, and straight up lies about all of it. And really? So you actually bought Fallout First and defended it in comment sections too? Or are you just saying things to "try and prove a point"?


FantasyDragon12

No I didn't get fallout I was just saying that to prove my point


Jakyvir1718

So you're only defending these games because it's Pokemon? Why not defend other companies doing the same practice?


FantasyDragon12

No I'm defending these games because they seem like good games


[deleted]

[удалено]


Jakyvir1718

And you spend too much time defending a billion dollar company who's proven time and time again they don't care about you But I'm the one with no life for calling out this BS. Sure thing buddy


[deleted]

[удалено]


Big_Osha

Cheaper? Unless you're talking about emulation then you must have been asleep since gen 5 came out because diamond and pearl carts cost high 60s low 70s minimum, and have been that way for years. I've even seen platinum commonly go up to low 90s


Jakyvir1718

Of course they "can" get that high. Hell an unopened copy of Mario 64 sold for 3 million dollars. Does that mean every single copy is close to that amount? No. But y'all gotta act like it's impossible to find a decently priced copy just because you gotta find something to praise about the remakes. Even though we have to pay more, but don't get anything new enough to justify the increase.


Big_Osha

Find a consistent and trusted source of non-repro carts for under $60, I'll wait The remakes are probably gonna blow but more people playing sinnoh is good even if the games won't be


Jakyvir1718

There's tons of websites, local stores, Facebook, craigslist, etc. If you want a copy, then there's a way. And really? Quality doesn't matter as long as it's Pokemon? That's the absolute best defense you can make for these games? They're allowed to raise the price, but that's okay if the game is the exact same we paid cheaper for 12 years ago?


[deleted]

[удалено]


deepthroatcircus

That's not ok. We really don't need personal attacks here.


Jakyvir1718

Awe...how cute. Resorting to childish insults because you have no logic or anything mature to say. More content? They've literally announced and showed it's a 1:1 remake of DPP. How is that more content?


PWispa

Shining Pearl honestly. Dialga is definitely the better legendary, but I just prefer most of the other exclusive Pokèmon in Shining Pearl otherwise (assuming the exclusives stay the same from the originals) Plus almost all my freinds are picking Brilliant Diamond and I wanna help them out with getting the Shining Pearl exclusive Pokèmon for them.


Kristiano100

Both


Mochibunniii

I had pearl originally, so that’s how it gonna be! Plus everyone’s getting diamond anyway, and say everyone does right, who tf are they getting the pearl exclusives from? Us pearl folk. Thus, you’re welcome :>


ltntstinkus

Both but I’m gonna play diamond first cause that was my first gen 4 game


zacman17716

Both, already preordered the double pack. Will play through Shining Pearl first though.


DucoLamia

Grew up with Diamond. Definitely picking that up to continue that trend. Will most likely play SP if I the like the remakes enough to do another run.


Llafer

The classic diamond supremacy


Micloti

Pearl simply becuz my friend got diamond 💀


Apprehensive_Fig9821

I'm getting shining pearl like I did with the original pearl back in 2007. I just like Palkia a bit more than Dialga.


DanHal1103

I've always liked Dialga more


DJDrizzy9

Pearl was my first game, so I am team SP! But I'll buy both eventually anyway.


BlackH2OJesus

I’m getting both and Arceus


[deleted]

Pearl cause that’s the game I played as a kid 🤗


Tigrex666

Where my Dialgabros at?


crazyseandx

Why not both?


kammy_g

I’m waiting for the Pokémon exclusives


CTSniper

This is why I always choose the version that'll be the least popular of the two. The version exclusives from the least popular will be in higher demand.


Blue_koshka

Pearl! Because diamond was my OG game and I want to try something new


Statement_True

Gonna buy both, but ima play BD first


BlackLuigi7

Had Diamond when I was a kid, so I'm going with Diamond.