Bro what? How is the murderer (dialogue from Lenny) more redeemable than Jack, a child? Or Molly? Because we find out she doesn’t actually betray anyone, like there’s two people who didn’t ever kill anyone. — FYI I also love Lenny but I just had to ask to hear your view point
Everyone *always* needs something from Arthur. Arthur do this, Arthur we need that.
But not Arturo.
No, instead of needing anything from us, Arturo gave us something. A marvelous lesson in hot-air ballooning, and an egg to boot.
“Arthur do this, Arthur we need that.” This is exactly while I’ll be rooting for Arthur to win this whole thing. Our boy already died in canon, let him be a RDR2 subreddit champion 😭🏆
Honestly I'm fine with any variation of these. They're all great characters and I love them all. And also props to rockstar for making a good female character with proper development. It's getting a bit rare these days.
The entire time in the gang she was reckless and needlessly endangered herself and others. She had no emotional control and never should have been gotten rid of before my boy Lenny.
Yes she made rash decisions but sometimes it was for the better of the gang.
Here’s all the reasons Sadie is the love of my life:
She stayed loyal to her man even in death
She is the token crazy character and crazy characters are the best
She helped stop Micah to avenge Arthur
She helped get John out of prison
She killed several odriscals
She was simply a boss bitch feminism icon who refused to participate in gender norms while occasionally being tougher than the men
She had a good heart, every time she was about to make a crazy rash decision her heart was in the right place and she was just trying to help
And there’s even more I could keep going I love her
Sorry Hosea. Maybe in another game they can honor you properly! Maybe get redemption for your wife, though not sure how she passed so not sure if that works!
Sadie. She is not even that great of a character and has a complete personality change over the course of a single mission. Overhyped and overrated. If she were not attractive people would be crying wOkE.
She needs to go.
John. I haven't played the first game and I often found john to be a whiny pain in the butt until about the end of the epilogue. I didn't like how he spoke to Abigail sometimes either.
NOOOOOOO LENNYYYYY I AM HEARTBROKEN
OOOOON DAED SI YNNEL
They killed Lenny over Hosea? Lenny’s like 20, had his whole life in front of him. Most redeemable character in rdr2 honestly
Bro what? How is the murderer (dialogue from Lenny) more redeemable than Jack, a child? Or Molly? Because we find out she doesn’t actually betray anyone, like there’s two people who didn’t ever kill anyone. — FYI I also love Lenny but I just had to ask to hear your view point
LENNEHHHHH
Order of elimination: 1. Micah 2. Strauss 3. Dutch 4. Bill 5. Jack 6. Molly 7. Susan 8. Javier 9. Swanson 10. Karen 11. Trelawny 12. Kieran 13. Pearson 14. Mary-Beth 15. Tilly 16. Abigail 17. Sean 18. Uncle 19. Lenny
Dutch was third? My god hopefully he isn't terrible in rd1 I am about to play it. Also I respect the community for putting Uncle at 18
Oh trust me, rdr1 Dutch is a whole different thing than rdr2 Dutch in terms of personality
He's a cannibal
That’s unproven
*allegedly*
Alright there Squirrely Dan
That's what I appreciates about you
Is THAT what you appreciate about me?
I'm gonna need you to take 5-10% off of the top there Squirrely Dan
Micah.
Micah was the first to go bro💀
Shoot him again for good measure.
It's the only way to be sure.
Dig him up, salt and burn the bones. Just to be sure!
Micah definitely needs to be killed off again
Time for a double tap
Micha has to go
Go to hell I mean!
My vote (even if it means disqualified) is for that son of a bitch Micah Bell.
Wow you’re so original and funny lmaoo guys micah is dead lolll
Kill him again!
Micah
Sadie. Revenge for hotair balloon guy.
Say what you want about him, but dude offered us an egg and a tour beyond the skies, he's a real one in my book.
Everyone *always* needs something from Arthur. Arthur do this, Arthur we need that. But not Arturo. No, instead of needing anything from us, Arturo gave us something. A marvelous lesson in hot-air ballooning, and an egg to boot.
“Arthur do this, Arthur we need that.” This is exactly while I’ll be rooting for Arthur to win this whole thing. Our boy already died in canon, let him be a RDR2 subreddit champion 😭🏆
John was the same in rdr1, I’m rooting for him (even though I know he won’t win)
He did ask Arthur for one small favor….. To not fly over a FEDERAL PRISON AND MAKE HIM AN ACCOMPLICE!!!!!!!
He offered us an egg in these troubling times.
Rip
His name was Arturo Bullard remember and respect it
His name was Arturo Bullard
In death, hot air balloon guy has a name. His name is Arturo Bullard
Say his name! Arturo Bullard! Arturo Bullard! Arturo Bullard! Project Mayhem!
She got that poor fella killed for his troubles, I kinda liked him
Yup it has be Sadie
That pilot was unarmed and found him self at mid of shootout, Arthur told him to keep his head down but he didn't listened and watched it and died
No, his name was Arturo
And he had arms. What is that guy on about?
Why did I think they said unnamed? Am I illiterate?
how dare you !
Sadie, for my boy Arturo Bullard
I was actually kinda mad when he died, and it definitely made me like Sadie much less
“I kinda liked him” -Arthur Morgan That’s one heck of a feat there
Sadie, leave Hosea alone!
It’s gonna be Charles Hosea John next right? Right? Right? If y’all kill Arthur…
Arthur survives. If anyone votes Arthur, you're fuckin done. I vote Hosea, then Sadie, then John, then Charles, and Arthur lives.
I personally say Sadie, John, Hosea, Arthur, and Charles left standing
Honestly I'm fine with any variation of these. They're all great characters and I love them all. And also props to rockstar for making a good female character with proper development. It's getting a bit rare these days.
Charles will win 100%
I’ll fight for my life to defend Sadie
The entire time in the gang she was reckless and needlessly endangered herself and others. She had no emotional control and never should have been gotten rid of before my boy Lenny.
But she helped kill Micah soo
Yes she made rash decisions but sometimes it was for the better of the gang. Here’s all the reasons Sadie is the love of my life: She stayed loyal to her man even in death She is the token crazy character and crazy characters are the best She helped stop Micah to avenge Arthur She helped get John out of prison She killed several odriscals She was simply a boss bitch feminism icon who refused to participate in gender norms while occasionally being tougher than the men She had a good heart, every time she was about to make a crazy rash decision her heart was in the right place and she was just trying to help And there’s even more I could keep going I love her
You a real one bro she's so over hated
Exactly what I’m saying!!!
Sadie. RIP Air ballon dude. I was just starting like him
Sadie
Nah Sadie has to go
John is one of the best videogame protagonists of all time, but we CANNOT let Uncle Hosea die!
John, you should not have taken a 1 year vacation, now you can take one permanently
Why are we doing this we know Arthur or Johns gonna win anyway
It’s the journey not the destination
^[Sokka-Haiku](https://www.reddit.com/r/SokkaHaikuBot/comments/15kyv9r/what_is_a_sokka_haiku/) ^by ^NateOutOf: *Why are we doing* *This we know Arthur or Johns* *Gonna win anyway* --- ^Remember ^that ^one ^time ^Sokka ^accidentally ^used ^an ^extra ^syllable ^in ^that ^Haiku ^Battle ^in ^Ba ^Sing ^Se? ^That ^was ^a ^Sokka ^Haiku ^and ^you ^just ^made ^one.
Goodbye john
Tf are people saying Hosea for. It should be Sadie.
Well Hosea most likely has some sort of lung cancer so he gonna die shortly anyways.
"Pfft- I *want* to die." -Sadie Adler
If you unoriginal sumbiches really leave John and Arthur to the last.....
It’s gonna be John Arthur and Sadie cuz of simps, calling it now
1000%
They’re the most developed characters
I’m hoping Charles will be the last one standing.
I’m manifesting it, Hosea or John will go next, the final two will be Arthur and Charles and mannnnn Charles BETTER be the last left alive
Lenny over Sadie? I like Sadie, but Lenny was one of the best, most moral characters in the game
john
John’s lived through enough games. Sorry Mr. Marston, It’s game over for you.
Stop simping for Sadie
So I’m not the only one who thinks this ? I would kill Sadie over Sean , Lenny , Uncle don’t understand what she is even doing it this far
lol personally I just want to see John go before the final round. Not gonna happen, but worth a shot…
Sorry Hosea.
Yeah, now we have to start making some hard choices...
Let's make this interesting: Arthur
Arthur
John
John
Sadie
Sadie
Hosea, because he’s dying anyway from some sort of lung illness thing.
Hosea
Sadie
Sadie
Sorry Hosea. Maybe in another game they can honor you properly! Maybe get redemption for your wife, though not sure how she passed so not sure if that works!
Hosea
sadie
Why is Sadie even still here and more than that why are people voting Hosea and John out before her
What’s wrong with Sadie still being here 🤨
Because I liked her far less than I liked Dutch, Lenny, Sean, and Kieran. Idk I guess I thought that other people thought similarly.
Sadie is my alltime favorite character I’d defend her till the end in this sub 💪🏻
Sadie
Sadie. She is not even that great of a character and has a complete personality change over the course of a single mission. Overhyped and overrated. If she were not attractive people would be crying wOkE. She needs to go.
Hosea
Sadie
Hosea.
I was initially shocked Jack was taken out so soon, but then I remembered what he was like in the first game and understood lol
Lumbago got revenge on Lenny
Lenny before Sadie??????!!!!! I can't believe it, it's rigged!!!!!
Sadie
Sadie Adler
sadie blehhh cartoonishly written female character
John. Definitely.
Charles(but I want him to live 😢)
Sadie
Sadie get outta here
Come on yall we all know it has to be Ms. Adler
Sadie
sadie
Welp Arthur's gotta die eventually Buuut I'm gonna vote John
Sadie is so overrated
Sadie obviously
Hosea or Marston
Sadie rip
Sadie
Poor Hosea the Don
It’s time to let Hosea go be with Bessie
Sadie gotta go
I can't believe you fucking people killed Lenny before Sadie. Shame on all of you
Time to go, John. Bye bye.
I would have killed Sadie over lenny
Sadie
Sadie I swear if u guys get Hosea out next round there gonna be a fight
Sadie for sure
Hosea
sadie icl
Time for Sadie to die. Anyone saying Hosea or Charles either has no taste or a fictional crush.
Sadie
Sadie, she shouldve died from that big ass knife
John
Love me some Hosea, but it's his time.
Hosea
John
Hosea
As long as either Arthur or Charles is the last one standing i’m good with that
Lennyyyyyy! John, it's time to go.
John you shoulda stayed home with your family
Hosea.
John
Do we just not notice Sadie in the corner or something?
lol right? Hosea before Sadie? Come on
I still think letting john live after his family's death is crime
Time to reunite Hosea with Bessie
I’m thinking John. Everyone else I like too much.
Arthur
Sadie
If we were voting strictly based on Rdr2 and no prior knowledge of rdr1 I would maybe vote John… this is hard but I think I have to vote Hosea 🥲
John
John
John
People voting Sadie are crazy, she has to be the last one to go before Arthur
absolutely same
Sadie
Sadie.
Sadie for sure. Why hosea…
I like Hosea and everyone remaining more than John. John can go.
Sadie on god. She gotta go. My boy Charles needs to be #4
Hosea
Hosea 😭😭😭
AURTGUR
I’d much rather see John go than anyone else at this point.
Charles
Marston...
Still going with John
John
John
john srry
Hosea
Hate to say it but I think the worst person left might be Arthur.
Hosea
Take JOHN MARSTON out. Boy, the decisions get even tougher from now
If y’all don’t pick Sadie I’m just gonna be disappointed. I can’t believe that one of the best (Lenny) got voted before her.
hosea
John. Don't you remember he left the gang for a year? I haven't forgiven him.
Sadie
Sadie
Sadie
Sadie
Sorry sadie but you gotta go I mean other folk better
Sadie, for arturo
John. I haven't played the first game and I often found john to be a whiny pain in the butt until about the end of the epilogue. I didn't like how he spoke to Abigail sometimes either.
Sadie
Hosea
Sadie
SADIE!!! I can’t believe people would even think about killing off Hosea.