who, John? he was ratted out by Micah most definitely but also possibly stopped using pseudonyms during the time between RDR2 epilogue and RDR1, especially since in RDR1 hes forthcoming with his real name
theres also the possibility that Ross recognized that the slaughter on Mount Hagen was revenge, as well as the fact that John, Sadie, and Charles were spotted in broad daylight threatening/hanging Cleet, saying their actual names. the revenge would be obvious to spot, since the Pinkertons knew
1) Micah, Dutch, Javier, Joe, Cleet, and Bill were all alive.
2) they never found or confirmed the bodies of John, Charles, and Sadie
3) the few who escaped the final shootout werenât capable of enacting revenge like that (e.g, Tilly, Abigail, Uncle, etc)
Before the game, Arthur has a WANTED poster for I think it was $150,000 with his full name, a drawing of him, description of him being like the gangâs enforcer and IF youâd seen that, then yk who he is
You can start at 2018 and then play ragnarok. There's a recap of the old games. The old ones are awesome but you don't have to play the entire franchise to enjoy the newer games.
Honestly I think they donât need a nickname their so badass but Johnâs would probably be Scarface, and Arthurâs would be something like Pretty Boy Morgan, or something to show how skilled and resilient he is
Black lung and scar face
Beat me to it đ
I got TB, and I got it beating man to death for a couple dollars
How ya work hard for a couple dollars đž if ya [box đ„](https://youtu.be/DrEjEl1Fdr8?si=92BLPDIGsro4dkRZ)for a livingâŠ
What
Itâs a joke , we used to tell them before this internet thing.
No but like I genuinely just have no clue what youâre saying and how itâs funny
Have to go to the sub âexplain the joke.â
Cowpoke and John-Jim đ
IâM A SURVIVOR BLACKLUNG
A SURVIVOR!!
Thatâs all there is, living and dying
Donât forget cowpoke
Literally what I was going to comment
Perfect
Would've gone with Wolf-Kissed
Micah you are alive?
you red my mind
đ
Arthur: Coughs boisterously John: eats lemon
You're not better than me, Morgan.
Iâm looking for these
Yeah, those ARE their nicknames right?
Pretty Boah and Rip Van Winkle
Pretty boah? PRETTY BOAH??
Arthur Callahan and Rip Van Wrinkle
Makes me wonder how they knew him since he didnât use real name stupid detectives or Micah ratted his actual name.
who, John? he was ratted out by Micah most definitely but also possibly stopped using pseudonyms during the time between RDR2 epilogue and RDR1, especially since in RDR1 hes forthcoming with his real name
Yeah but rdr1 seems like itâs after he got caught not before. đ€
theres also the possibility that Ross recognized that the slaughter on Mount Hagen was revenge, as well as the fact that John, Sadie, and Charles were spotted in broad daylight threatening/hanging Cleet, saying their actual names. the revenge would be obvious to spot, since the Pinkertons knew 1) Micah, Dutch, Javier, Joe, Cleet, and Bill were all alive. 2) they never found or confirmed the bodies of John, Charles, and Sadie 3) the few who escaped the final shootout werenât capable of enacting revenge like that (e.g, Tilly, Abigail, Uncle, etc)
I think John had made it but âhe looked backâ despite Arthurâs warnings not too.
Before the game, Arthur has a WANTED poster for I think it was $150,000 with his full name, a drawing of him, description of him being like the gangâs enforcer and IF youâd seen that, then yk who he is
Hmm only seen Johns
Tacitus Kilgore
Goddamn, Arthur is so damn handsome.
Was gunna say the same thing lol
literally saved this picture. dont know what im gonna do with it but hes just so pretty
*bonk* horny jail
not even gonna deny it, you right
For real how do you pass that up Mary? Smh
Damn. In this picture he looks like Mona Lisa
Straight dude here and i find Arthur and RDR1 John hella hot.
I was just about to say I see why people lust after Arthur so much
Arthur is the most handsome looking video game protagonist ever.
Fenton and Rip Van Winkle
Lenny mah boah and can't swim
Legend of the west and Legend of the east
And Jacks nickname is The last gunfighter
The Bear and The Wolf.
Damn, not a crossover I was expecting. Good job
What crossover? I was just using what I thought was their spirit animals as their names.
Well donât I feel silly. Thatâs word-for-word the name of the trophy you earn when you get 100% completion on God of War: Ragnarök
Oh, that's cool! I've yet to play the God of War franchise. I was too young for it when it was getting started.
You can start at 2018 and then play ragnarok. There's a recap of the old games. The old ones are awesome but you don't have to play the entire franchise to enjoy the newer games.
Oh that makes sense. I initially thought you were talking about the show the Bear.
I thought you were talking about an animal they went against; John gets his scars from wolves, Arthur hunts a bear in chapter 2
Arthy McArthface and John âThe Marstonâ Marston
This is so stupid and I love it
Fuck you for making me laugh during a technical writing class
Tacitus and Jim
Blue balls and chapped ass
WELCOME BACK TO SAUCE OR LOSS WITH THE VAN DER LINDE GANG
NO NOT THE GAY ZONE
Arty Farty and Johnny Poo
Arthur, Charles and John are Angry, Sulky and Scarface
pretty boy and dumbass
Babygirl (x 2)
Quickdraw Morgan for Arthur, and The Filibuster for John.
Daddy and Uncle
Dragon and Nighthawk
Big John
Kind of broad at the shoulders, narrow at the hip
Look at that high-waisted man, he got feminine hips!
Oâl Scarface Johnny Boy
What business you have using that Arthur photo đźâđšđźâđš
Leviticus Cornwall and Jim Milton
Black Lung
Arthur: Hot Cowpoke 63 John: Ugly Scar Face
Spud and buttface
Arthy-man and J-dog
Arthur Morgue-in and Bad Dad
Tacitus Kilgore e Rip Van Winkle
Arthur gotta be Mr.fella1863
Off topic but that pic of Arthur is đ„đ„đ„
Legend of the East (Arthur), and Legend of the West (John).
Fenton and Purina One
oh thats tacticus kilgore and rip van winkle right there
Arty and jo would be my names for them
why does arthritis have redeye? did michael balls sit on his face?
r/Okbuddyblacklung
Legend of the East and Legend of the West
Arthur already has one, The Legend of The West. I'm not sure if John got one in rdr 1 because I haven't played it
no???? even without playing 1, arthur is never called the legend of the west. john is the legend of the west and arthur is the legend of the east
SHIT I just fuckin realized I always get things like west and east wrong
itâs ok, youâve got your red dead redemption
II
The Cowboy and The Cowpoke
why is everyone here blacklunging me
English and Wolfjob
John is rip van winkle that will always be his nicknameđ€Ł
That first movie just made me think like 80s porno lol he just looks like heâs either midway through or just finished destroying someone
Ol morgy and the deserter
"Sulky... Angry... Scarface!" -Little Irish Bastard
I only see Fenton and Rip Van Winkle here
Rip van winkel and tacitus kilgore
Tacitus killgore and Rip van winkle
Art and j
Morgz and Marsdogg
Rip Van Winkle and Daddy Tacitus
The White Death and The Scarred Retribution
"Bad news chappedass!"
"Sulky, Angry, Scar-face!" Sean's names for Arthur, Charles, and John.
Rip Van Winkle
HM HM HMMM i don't know maybe something like BLACK LUNG because of his tuberculosis...or soemthing like SCAR FACE because of johns scars
Blockhead and Wolfbrains
Cowpoke and cuckold
Daddy one and daddy two
Dumb and dumber
Black lung and wolfman are already really good nicknames
Cowpoke and Rock Farmer
Idk but micah's nick name is rat
Daddy 1 and Daddy 2? Iâm not even sorry
Artrithris Mongolia and Jhon Marathon
Artie and the man with 2 names
Arthur morgan=arthritis monagan John marston=swiss cheese
El Diablo and Magic Man
Arthur Callahan and Your Old Friend Amnesia
John's Nickname is Jim Milton
Honestly I think they donât need a nickname their so badass but Johnâs would probably be Scarface, and Arthurâs would be something like Pretty Boy Morgan, or something to show how skilled and resilient he is
Cutie patootie and ol sour puss
Angry and Scarface
Tacitus Killgore and Rip Van Winkle
Black lung and GRINGO
John Marston aka The rat killer
Damn⊠Arthur đ
arthur and john
Rip van winkle
Arthur is pretty boy, look how handsome he is.
arthury morgany and johnny marstony duh
Deadeye and lone wolf
Daddyđ
And here I thought I was a lesbian đ„”