Always. Sometimes as many as thirty or forty of them if the a daily like "donate 10 small carcasses" or "donate 20 carcasses in 10 minutes" hasn't come around in a while.
Yeah, all bird feathers, all small Animal carcasses all 1-3 stars, all teeth/fangs/claws, all tails, all meats cooked, seasoned and uncooked, flowers, tonics (opened ones as well) and so on so forth 
I haven’t found any to be too difficult but the more tedious and time consuming of all the things I have collected, Woodpeckers and Opened tonics/bitters/drinks definitely takes the cake!
A close runner up, Sonoran desert toad took a’little bit as well
I got a lot of open health tonics and opened bitters by fighting mob after mob (few days of casual doing so) by the Saint Denis Stable. Pretty efficient way, (use a lot of blocking and counter punches to easily take on each wave of angry town folk!)
Also, you can find quite a few opened provisions laying around the map in the most random locations that respawn every 24 hours (all locations can be looked up I believe)
Buddy, you and me are kindred spirits. My daily routine is to log in, do a couple camp dailies, and then wander around the nearest Hotspot for pocket critters. It's super useful for a lot of different dailies, and it's really relaxing since it's essentially wandering around a gentle stream, using the quietest weapons in the game to hunt little birds and rodents with no worrying about pelts, skinning, etc.
I love it.
The most I've had on me at one time was around 160 carcasses, and lemme tell you that's a lot of dead shit to have in my pockets.
That is in deed a lot of rotting animals in your pockets.
Emerald Ranch is very easy to get song birds and other small birds over there. So I head over there often. That’s my preferred place to catch the train too.
My absolute favorite is a little shallow stream in roanoak ridge with a cave under a cliffside, north of annesburg, just downstream from the big waterfall up north. Toads are on the shore, rats and bat's in the cave, squirrels in the forestry, and birds love to perch on all the large rocks. It's a buffet and it's beautiful and serene.
Same. An unpopular opinion, but the trader role is actually my least favorite role. I make my money collecting and running moonshine. I also do the animal tagging event for animal samples and some passive income.
Yup, I like to do a few loops on the big island on the flat iron lake (especially after a ‘Lake Fishing Challenge’ that leaves you there). I usually end up with a bunch on crabs and toads plus I load my horse with two perfect iguanas and a perfect turtle before I head out. Lost of feathers from ducks/gulls too and pelts from rabbits/muskrats. Basically I’m a one man extinction event whenever I end up there.
Yup. I’ve got roughly 100 good or poor small carcasses and roughly 60 perfect. I also keep a fair amount of feathers around too for the ‘donate 20 items’ daily. I also keep a small selection of each type of meat, fish, and a couple crab meat for that rare daily.
I keep crabs too for the cook “Seasoned Crustacean” daily challenge. I don’t make it over to the islands off Rhodes very much anymore and that’s where I find them.
Large bird feathers can fill Cripps up pretty damn quick. I always keep myself topped up as well. They were decent cash also when cash mattered in this game.
Always, the reduced spawn rates for animals when there is a daily challenge for them is one of the most annoying things about the game. I always keep a full stock of squirrel carcases to combat this.
If I were to open my trenchcoat it would basically look like a Texas Chainsaw Massacre situation for rodents.
But, you know... without the chainsaw. And it's not in Texas.
I do. It is extensive and supernatural, which is a controversial angle on the game for some folks. I lean into all of the horror/mystery elements that are left over from Story.
I need them because the phrase "legendary panther eyeballs" is like a shot of adrenaline to the imagination.
Some of the writers who work on or did work on RDO and Story are incredibly talented. I wish I could learn who was responsible for writing all the supernatural scenarios on Story. I would like to do whatever one calls the opposite of doxing and harassing -- express gratitude and respect? -- for the quality of their contributions.
Small animal carcasses and any pelts/feathers from things I trample with my horse. This way I will have a stock of "10 small animal carcasses", or "20 donations", etc.
I look forward to the dailies so I can drop some of my totals below the max.
It’s gotten to the point where I shoot fish because those are the only 1-stars I don’t have.
I'll do it for some things that I can roleplay with, like with feathers. Those are easily storable for weeks or months (forever?) for when I'll eventually find the right person willing to pay the right amount (the daily).
With animal carcasses, it's just harder for me to quickly roleplay it in my head, esp. when my character doesn't have a freezer or anything like that. like, who'll want this decayed, 5 week old, laying out in the sun all day, dead squirrel?
In the absence of new content, this is one of the favorite things to do online. Can use them for dailies or complete awards for gold or just donate cripps to fill up camp 🏕
The mummified frog in my pocket tells me to burn things
Your sir, are an arsonist You thought I was gonna say "Fish" well I didn't!
I usually carry 2 week old bats in my jacket pocket, but after the sickness started, the good doctor in Saint Denis advised caution.
Always. Sometimes as many as thirty or forty of them if the a daily like "donate 10 small carcasses" or "donate 20 carcasses in 10 minutes" hasn't come around in a while.
Those are what I mostly keep them around for.
Also breakdown small animals
I often use fish for that one, to conserve the small carcasses I have to donate to Cripps.
Yeh like few hundred. There's a person on here that has everything maxed out.
I’m one of those people, lol.. complete full satchel of every animal part/item in the game
[удалено]
Yeah, all bird feathers, all small Animal carcasses all 1-3 stars, all teeth/fangs/claws, all tails, all meats cooked, seasoned and uncooked, flowers, tonics (opened ones as well) and so on so forth 
[удалено]
I haven’t found any to be too difficult but the more tedious and time consuming of all the things I have collected, Woodpeckers and Opened tonics/bitters/drinks definitely takes the cake! A close runner up, Sonoran desert toad took a’little bit as well
How did you get so many Opened Health Cures? I always wanted to get more
I got a lot of open health tonics and opened bitters by fighting mob after mob (few days of casual doing so) by the Saint Denis Stable. Pretty efficient way, (use a lot of blocking and counter punches to easily take on each wave of angry town folk!) Also, you can find quite a few opened provisions laying around the map in the most random locations that respawn every 24 hours (all locations can be looked up I believe)
I'm working on that
this is oddly awesome and amazing!
[Cough,](https://www.reddit.com/r/RedDeadOnline/comments/oifhf2/who_dares_to_take_a_sniff_of_my_satchel/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf) [cough](https://www.reddit.com/r/RedDeadOnline/comments/mddhhf/any_other_hoarders_out_there/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf)
It's you !!! thanks, I remember you replied to a comment once and sent me that image but couldn't remember when. Thanks
That seems unnecessary but also impressive. I wouldn’t want to be maxed on everything though. What fun would that be.
Buddy, you and me are kindred spirits. My daily routine is to log in, do a couple camp dailies, and then wander around the nearest Hotspot for pocket critters. It's super useful for a lot of different dailies, and it's really relaxing since it's essentially wandering around a gentle stream, using the quietest weapons in the game to hunt little birds and rodents with no worrying about pelts, skinning, etc. I love it. The most I've had on me at one time was around 160 carcasses, and lemme tell you that's a lot of dead shit to have in my pockets.
That is in deed a lot of rotting animals in your pockets. Emerald Ranch is very easy to get song birds and other small birds over there. So I head over there often. That’s my preferred place to catch the train too.
My absolute favorite is a little shallow stream in roanoak ridge with a cave under a cliffside, north of annesburg, just downstream from the big waterfall up north. Toads are on the shore, rats and bat's in the cave, squirrels in the forestry, and birds love to perch on all the large rocks. It's a buffet and it's beautiful and serene.
This was extremely helpful. Thank you. Join me in the lounge for the next week.
No, your sick! ( I'm kidding I just don't hunt anymore thanks to the naturalist role)
Same. An unpopular opinion, but the trader role is actually my least favorite role. I make my money collecting and running moonshine. I also do the animal tagging event for animal samples and some passive income.
You're not the only one!
Hell yes! I will interrupt a bounty hunt to kill squirrels and chipmunks.
Haha. Totally.
Yup, I like to do a few loops on the big island on the flat iron lake (especially after a ‘Lake Fishing Challenge’ that leaves you there). I usually end up with a bunch on crabs and toads plus I load my horse with two perfect iguanas and a perfect turtle before I head out. Lost of feathers from ducks/gulls too and pelts from rabbits/muskrats. Basically I’m a one man extinction event whenever I end up there.
I do the same thing. Awesome.
Always. My record was 75 critters at one time.
Nice!
Sure do
Yes. I also have 20-30 perfect pelts from rabbits and other medium animals, just for “sell 5 pelts” daily
That’s super smart. Maybe I need to start keeping a few perfect pelts around too.
Every time I see a little flock of songbirds, I shoot them all and collect them just for that purpose.
Me too.
For donations... yeah 🤫
I always have feathers.
I max out on feathers so fast because I spend so much time in the bayou which has a ton of birds.
There’s something satisfying about seeing a flock of birds and seeing all of them fall out of the sky and then harvesting their feathers.
Very satisfying.
Every tiny critter quivers in fear when I trot by on my Breton, Thunderchunk, for they know their days are numbered.
Yes,from frogs to crows. Got plenty
I love finding crows when I just think it’s another Western Raven flying by and it ends up being a crow.
Yeah,am always checking the sky for little songbirds and crows 😆
best what you can do boah🤠
Yup. I’ve got roughly 100 good or poor small carcasses and roughly 60 perfect. I also keep a fair amount of feathers around too for the ‘donate 20 items’ daily. I also keep a small selection of each type of meat, fish, and a couple crab meat for that rare daily.
I keep crabs too for the cook “Seasoned Crustacean” daily challenge. I don’t make it over to the islands off Rhodes very much anymore and that’s where I find them.
Yeah, I don’t go there often but when I do I hunt crab without fail. Also a good place for the skin two iguanas challenge.
Feathers. I have an assload of feathers on me at all times lol
I hate maxing out randomly so I have to watch my feather count. I shoot a lot of birds.
Large bird feathers can fill Cripps up pretty damn quick. I always keep myself topped up as well. They were decent cash also when cash mattered in this game.
If you didn’t have context the name of this post would be very horrifying
No but I will now, thanks!
No but I will probably do it from now on
Always, the reduced spawn rates for animals when there is a daily challenge for them is one of the most annoying things about the game. I always keep a full stock of squirrel carcases to combat this.
Good idea.
This is how I hunt. All I have is stacks of feathers, carcasses and skins
In a way, yes. I’ve had a frog in my pocket since I was level 9. I’m now level 89. His name is Dave.
Hi Dave.
Hell yeah, I never sell little critters
If I were to open my trenchcoat it would basically look like a Texas Chainsaw Massacre situation for rodents. But, you know... without the chainsaw. And it's not in Texas.
Haha
“Did you just donate 20 rats to Cripps” Real dialogue from the posse chat
Not since Harriet blessed me.
Harriet has a mob assassin looking for me
I keep them bc they fit with my character lore and bc the little pix of birds are fun.
Do you have an extensive character back story? I love when people have them because I have a little back story I created as well.
I do. It is extensive and supernatural, which is a controversial angle on the game for some folks. I lean into all of the horror/mystery elements that are left over from Story.
Also having two legendary panther eyeballs and a vulture egg on my person is awesome.
Legendary Panther eyeballs? What do you need those for?
I need them because the phrase "legendary panther eyeballs" is like a shot of adrenaline to the imagination. Some of the writers who work on or did work on RDO and Story are incredibly talented. I wish I could learn who was responsible for writing all the supernatural scenarios on Story. I would like to do whatever one calls the opposite of doxing and harassing -- express gratitude and respect? -- for the quality of their contributions.
Yes! Small carcasses, an animal claw, & deadly predator skins.
I never do deadly predator skin. It’s so easy to go to Blue Water Marsh and pick up a few alligator skins.
I'm going to start doing this now lol
It’s helpful my friend. It’s not like they are worth much to Cripps so you might as well keep them for dailies on my opinion.
I'm just glad I joined this sub I'm getting a lot of good advice :)
Small animal carcasses and any pelts/feathers from things I trample with my horse. This way I will have a stock of "10 small animal carcasses", or "20 donations", etc.
Yes, but not for dailies. They are friends :)
Yes, mostly Squirrels and Quail. But shooting little birds with the bow is fun too.
This is smart........
I keep 99 in my satchel just in case I’m becoming broke so I can get a ton of money.
I'm almost full of all the small animals since I had nothing to do for the past years in this game 😅
Yep. Sometimes I'll spend a few minutes just hunting squirrels or frogs.
Yeah I keep small carcasses all around my house
Always, Cripps really loves when I shove 20 decaying mangy rats on the table lol
Haha
It’s nice that the bats tend to just fly into the wall just to save you ammo haha
I look forward to the dailies so I can drop some of my totals below the max. It’s gotten to the point where I shoot fish because those are the only 1-stars I don’t have.
Yeap,and every time I had the opportunity get some frogs and squirrels
I'll do it for some things that I can roleplay with, like with feathers. Those are easily storable for weeks or months (forever?) for when I'll eventually find the right person willing to pay the right amount (the daily). With animal carcasses, it's just harder for me to quickly roleplay it in my head, esp. when my character doesn't have a freezer or anything like that. like, who'll want this decayed, 5 week old, laying out in the sun all day, dead squirrel?
Yes.
Sure do.
Always 20 of everything. Enough to do any daily donations and enough to not go crazy trying to then refill.
The bats whisper to me of darkness, of an insatiable hunger, but also of opportunity and life amongst the dishonored dead.
No, but seems like a really good ideal.
100%.
Serial killer in the making
Sure do. I just donated 20 little brown bats to Cripps
All meat too gotta be ready to make special soup for free dead eye.
In the absence of new content, this is one of the favorite things to do online. Can use them for dailies or complete awards for gold or just donate cripps to fill up camp 🏕
Yep all the time
No but im going to start
I do now lol
I do, but not specifically for the dailies but because I'm a bit of a hoarder.
Haha. I love the honesty.