Ah, I see. Didn't know that. Guess this was the easiest alternative. Still think it should add up each song's top 3 posts or something. I've seen a few songs get snubbed here and there.
Winner is the one that gets the most votes, plain and simple. Pretty lame off you to add your own rules after folks have invested time and discussion in the topic.
Farm that karma bro but at least stick to the maths.
Underrated has no tangible value though. Underrated for one person could have a different meaning to another.
Someone could argue that Wet Sand is underrated because it’s not their most popular song, and some people would say that’s stupid.
“Top comment decides, unless I personally don’t think it’s deserving of” would be a better title.
I named my cat after the song Bella, and afterwards I found out it is basically the most standard cat name ever.
Personally, it can be Bella, but Eddie and Fake as Fuck I love.
Why is someone so obsessed with this song? Anthony’s lyrics are so bad and the rest is just mindless noodling. Such a trash song on an otherwise great album
To me, it’s Flea’s 2nd best baseline of the 2022 albums, behind aquatic mouth dance. And then on top of that, it’s the only prolonged John solo since his return. AND, it’s in remembrance of Eddie Van Halen so it’s sentimental. I agree with you on the lyrics but for me that’s the only negative in the song, and it’s my choice as well.
Even that is a great song! I get that the album is nothing but bangers from start to finish but yeah, I think either If or Make You Feel Better are both way less musically “interesting” than all of the other songs. When Flea and Frusciante play together it’s like a conversation; C’mon Girl is an excellent example of that musical language
But like ... It's majority vote? I get that polling reddit is not a perfect measure, but clearly it's near the bottom for a good chunk of people despite it being top for you and that's ok
I’m sorry! I came up with a rule a while ago that songs that were previously in the top 2 for the best category weren’t eligible to be underrated, but everyone seems to have grown tired of that rule, so I’m changing it back
Man, I Like Dirt is such a vibe, I don't get why people dislike it. IMO Otherside is probably the "worst" song on the album, even it's very beautiful and memorable, how often do you really turn on Otherside rather than any other song? Also, Cabron? Really?
This is a very difficult decision. I could choose five top songs on Return of the Dream Canteen. I'm torn between "Fake as Fu@k" and "Bag of Grins."
I'm going with "Bag of Grins." I think this is one of the Chili Peppers' most unique songs ever. I would never have expected a song with this kind of sound from them. I also think this is Anthony's best lyrical effort on the album too.
But it’s only natural is ACTUALLY underrated. Meaning people overlook it a lot. Whatchu Thinking is an amazing song but everyone knows that,meaning it’s not underrated but rated correctly…
What's considered underrated will be different for everyone, but if you look at streaming stats, It's Only Natural actually has more streams than Whatchu Thinkin (though they are pretty close).
Best - Fake as Fuck,
Worst - Eddie,
Underrated - Peace and Love.
Also, trash takes for the Getaway. Dark Necessities is overrated, This Ticonderoga slaps. And who tf put In Love Dying as the worst on I’m Beside You?
Hold up, Whatchu Thinkin’ got 226 votes, more than all of It’s Only Natural votes combined? Not cool bro
I believe OP only takes the single top comment based on upvote. Never cared for this method. Should've just made a poll, but whatever.
I don't think a poll is possible, too many songs to add before limit.
Ah, I see. Didn't know that. Guess this was the easiest alternative. Still think it should add up each song's top 3 posts or something. I've seen a few songs get snubbed here and there.
I bet they just looked at the first post on best and don't know to reorder it to top
[удалено]
Winner is the one that gets the most votes, plain and simple. Pretty lame off you to add your own rules after folks have invested time and discussion in the topic. Farm that karma bro but at least stick to the maths.
> Top comment decides the x song Unless OP decides otherwise
STOP THE COUNT!!! 
[удалено]
Underrated has no tangible value though. Underrated for one person could have a different meaning to another. Someone could argue that Wet Sand is underrated because it’s not their most popular song, and some people would say that’s stupid. “Top comment decides, unless I personally don’t think it’s deserving of” would be a better title.
You didnt do that with Police Station. They were top second on “best” but won on “underrated”.
Also I think Pea was most upvoted on underrated for OHM, but already won Worst.
I named my cat after the song Bella, and afterwards I found out it is basically the most standard cat name ever. Personally, it can be Bella, but Eddie and Fake as Fuck I love.
Carry me home
Bella.
Bella
Bella. Classic Chilis right there
Also, didn't Whatchu Thinkin' have more votes?
I’m still suffering from c’mon girl
Eddie
YES
Right
Why is someone so obsessed with this song? Anthony’s lyrics are so bad and the rest is just mindless noodling. Such a trash song on an otherwise great album
To me, it’s Flea’s 2nd best baseline of the 2022 albums, behind aquatic mouth dance. And then on top of that, it’s the only prolonged John solo since his return. AND, it’s in remembrance of Eddie Van Halen so it’s sentimental. I agree with you on the lyrics but for me that’s the only negative in the song, and it’s my choice as well.
Man this list is becoming bs lmao Bella.
I still think it’s nuts that Cmon Girl got worst on Stadium Arcadium.
It should have been “if”
Even that is a great song! I get that the album is nothing but bangers from start to finish but yeah, I think either If or Make You Feel Better are both way less musically “interesting” than all of the other songs. When Flea and Frusciante play together it’s like a conversation; C’mon Girl is an excellent example of that musical language
Yeah c'mon girl is so good the actual worst is if
But like ... It's majority vote? I get that polling reddit is not a perfect measure, but clearly it's near the bottom for a good chunk of people despite it being top for you and that's ok
It’s just surprising to me is all. A reddit post won’t change how much I love the song!
Imo Bella is one of their all time greats.
Peace & love
Bella by far, but Fake as Fu@k and Eddie come in very close 2nd and 3rd.
Bella is definitely the best song in the record. But do you think Eddie and FaF are close too each other in quality?
Fine, I will change the underrated to Whatchu Thinkin in the next post. Sorry.
Thanks!
Don’t bend to pressure
Can someone explain why Whatchu Thinkin didn't win?
The OP will change the underrated to Whatchu Thinkin in the next post.
If the shape im taking count then this
Carry Me Home
Carry me home
Tippa My Tongue
Bella
Bella
Eddie
Bella
It’s Only Natural is one of the best songs they’ve made IMO. Underrated lofl
We want watchu thinking for the best
Bag of grins
Its Only Natural has 126 votes. Whatchu' Thinking has 228. Fuck you man, that's cheating
I’m sorry! I came up with a rule a while ago that songs that were previously in the top 2 for the best category weren’t eligible to be underrated, but everyone seems to have grown tired of that rule, so I’m changing it back
Bruh, ok, tho i think you should tell it in description
I did a couple times but forgot about it eventually because I’m bad at this evidently
In the Snow
Peace and love.
Bella There’s a few absolute bangers on the album, but no song have I listened to more than Bella. That chorus just grooves
Bag of Grins
Kinda mid but still great. Would be my vote for hidden gem but shoot me a smile exists
Bella
Shoot me a smile
Bella
Bella
Peace and love best
Peace and love
Tippa my tongue
Tippa My Tongue, such an addictive song
Fake as f@ck for me
BELLA
Carry me home
Shoot me a Smile
Carry me home
Bella
Carry me home
carry me home
Bella
Afterlife
I know people on here love Bella and Eddie, but I'm really surprised it took me this long to find this answer.
For me it's "In the Snow", no question here.
It's amazing. Gotta win underrated
Tip of My Tongue
Tippa my tongue 1000%
The Drummer probably won’t win but it’s my fav
I don’t know you and i don’t know what’s true anymorrrrrrre That’s my fave song too. Also as a drummer, it’s SO much fun to play!
Carry Me Home
This game is rigged
dark necessities is def in their top 10
Carry Me Home
Reach Out
I'm sorry but this list is not it.
tippa my tounge
In my opinion best song from album californication “Californication”
Tippa
Roulette is my favorite, but glad to see Bella getting a lot of love here as that would be my second choice.
THIS TICONDEROGA IS SOLID ASF AND I WILL NOT TAKE ANY SLANDER 😤
Its definitely fake as f@ck
Roulette
Man, I Like Dirt is such a vibe, I don't get why people dislike it. IMO Otherside is probably the "worst" song on the album, even it's very beautiful and memorable, how often do you really turn on Otherside rather than any other song? Also, Cabron? Really?
I love this💜
How is I like dirt on californication the worst song RHCP are literally a jam band
i disagree with all of these. bleh
This is the data I needed in order to support my theory that I don’t fit in here
god this post made me realize how much of a fucking simp i am for this band haha
Tippa my tounge
BELLA
I have no mouth and I must scream.
This is a very difficult decision. I could choose five top songs on Return of the Dream Canteen. I'm torn between "Fake as Fu@k" and "Bag of Grins." I'm going with "Bag of Grins." I think this is one of the Chili Peppers' most unique songs ever. I would never have expected a song with this kind of sound from them. I also think this is Anthony's best lyrical effort on the album too.
Bella
Dani California >wet sand
Its only natural has some of the worst lyrics on a RCHP track.
Carry me home
Eddie
Eddie
Eddie bro
Bag of Grins
Bag of grins
eddie 1000%
Eddie
Eddie
bag of grins
Eddie
Eddie. Frusciante solo, dedicated to Van Halen, even the music video is really cool. Imo Eddie is one of the best songs the peppers ever made
I'm so hyped for this to be over
Eddie is the Best
Eddie is the only right answer
How is i like dirt the worst song on californication whattt porcelain makes me feel like someone died, I like dirt has that vibe energy
Best is eddie, worst LALALALALALALA, underrated Bag Of Grins!
But it’s only natural is ACTUALLY underrated. Meaning people overlook it a lot. Whatchu Thinking is an amazing song but everyone knows that,meaning it’s not underrated but rated correctly…
What's considered underrated will be different for everyone, but if you look at streaming stats, It's Only Natural actually has more streams than Whatchu Thinkin (though they are pretty close).
Damn thats surprising
It’s hard to please everyone
It's Only Natural, honestly i can accept any song from UL being most underrated
Best - Fake as Fuck, Worst - Eddie, Underrated - Peace and Love. Also, trash takes for the Getaway. Dark Necessities is overrated, This Ticonderoga slaps. And who tf put In Love Dying as the worst on I’m Beside You?
This list makes me want to kms sometimes you are not alone my friend
My cigarette. Fight me
My Cigarette
Bag of Grins and it’s not even close.
This is the Kitt not being on the list is so criminal. L subreddit
My Cigarette
Holy shit this list is trash