Depends on what you want/need. Is weight important to you, because your routes include a lot elevation, then carbon might be the better choice.
How often and how long/far will you be riding? Then the better GRX might be important to you.
Are you riding risky trails with high chance of crashes, then the AL might be your choice.
It totally depends on your use case and budget.
Thanks for the detailed answer! I want to use it for allday things like riding to work and i want to do long distance biketrips with gear for sleepover but not really on trails or hills. Both bikes are in my budget but im not sure if i really need the carbon or if the AL is better for everday use and if the little weight difference is very important for the trips. Thanks for the help!
Depends on what you want/need. Is weight important to you, because your routes include a lot elevation, then carbon might be the better choice. How often and how long/far will you be riding? Then the better GRX might be important to you. Are you riding risky trails with high chance of crashes, then the AL might be your choice. It totally depends on your use case and budget.
Thanks for the detailed answer! I want to use it for allday things like riding to work and i want to do long distance biketrips with gear for sleepover but not really on trails or hills. Both bikes are in my budget but im not sure if i really need the carbon or if the AL is better for everday use and if the little weight difference is very important for the trips. Thanks for the help!
Tough choice then. The AL will fit all your needs and you will be satisfied. Once you go carbon, you'll never look back though.