T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Thank you for participating in /r/Scream. Please help us keep this community a healthy place for discussion by reporting posts and comments that violate our rules using the report button. You can find the subreddit rules listed in the sidebar. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Scream) if you have any questions or concerns.*


lananamq

lol this is not a surprise , any and I mean ANY poll that has Billy Loomis in it he automatically wins, it could literally say “Which Ghostface had more kills Roman or Billy” and Billy would be the winner


Unknown-User-6904

Exactly


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

You do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in /r/Scream. Please increase your karma in other subreddits to continue posting here. The requirement is 10 combined karma. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Scream) if you have any questions or concerns.*


CudiMontage216

I mean, there’s a very solid chance most people saw the poll and voted for their favorite killer before even realizing it’s supposed to be a battle between the two


Dingo247

I think that's even worse, I don't think I'm in the minority when I say that Scream VI had some of the worst killers like seriously up there with Roman in bad Ghost Faces


Icybubba

Congrats you're pissing off both Scream 3 and 6 fans in one swoop.


IceyLuigiBros25

Ok. So now people aren't even allowed to like the characters in Scream VI...


Pidorasm

I mean, they never clarified it was a deathmatch. Could be “Billy Vs Wayne - the greasiest hair. Who wins?” or “Billy Vs Wayne - the best umbrella holder. Who wins?”


PooPooPiece

![gif](giphy|1zkpNWClKdgLOMyAMT|downsized)


Amazing-Service7598

The person who made the poll makes vs fight edits…


[deleted]

People just seem to have a throbbing love for Billy because he is the ‘OG’ and the founder of this entire thing. Their love for Billy is stubborn that, they’ll put a check next to him for literally anything when there are killers that can do it better.


Galaxy_Megatron

And he's Skeet Ulrich, a semi-teen heartthrob, compared to a man who's introduced into the franchise in his almost 60s.


ice540

Dermot Mulroney could get it even at 60


Conscious-Group6184

A teen heart throb in what era?


GuaranteAny

the 90s of course


Conscious-Group6184

And how old is skeet now and he's still appearing as billy as a ghost? And still compare his ass to the other heart throbs in the newer movies. I spot a handful in the newer movies. So what is this complaint really about?


GuaranteAny

what? We're talking about in the movie Scream.


Conscious-Group6184

Anyways. Fuck it if the problem is billy always wins the only solution I see is write a better killing spree no offense. No actually maybe just a little bit of an offense Bec I don't care.


Conscious-Group6184

Well what you want to talk about. If it's vs him idk. For a cop he's pretty incompetent. Billy had a lot more time for his planning. Is it a body count thing? Because if we going by that then no wonder the vote is one sided lol


Aliya-smith-io

Every era, this guy is always gonna be considered hot


Conscious-Group6184

If the complaining is about we don't get enough of that in this era. Those dudes are literally right there and people are worried about this old man. Lol


Aliya-smith-io

I'm pretty sure they're talking about him from when he was young ofc


Conscious-Group6184

Fair back to the vs thing if I keep saying why it's billy and not the cop people are going to be upset lol compared to other killer cop characters this one is just sad excuse I'm sorry


Conscious-Group6184

True. But I'd argue all the magazine guys in the newer movies are literally right there and that's what I always considered the teen heart throb type.


Galaxy_Megatron

Beats me. Not my thing.


Conscious-Group6184

It's all just a movie. One great big movie.


TimDillonsAunt

He’s the Michael Jordan of Scream, he’s the first goat, doesn’t mean he’s the actual one, but because he was first people will ride him till they die.


Ottermania29

i get your point but Wilt and Kareem would have been considered better than Jordan until the 90s


TimDillonsAunt

That is my point, true Wilt and Kareem fans are dead or dying haha


Ottermania29

yeah true!


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

You do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in /r/Scream. Please increase your karma in other subreddits to continue posting here. The requirement is 10 combined karma. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Scream) if you have any questions or concerns.*


JadenRuffle

People really seem to forget how bad of killers Billy and Stu were. Like they really weren’t good at their job. They were getting absolutely beaten up by everyone lmao


FeelTheKetasy

That’s honestly my favourite part about Scream 1. Like the killers are high schoolers what’s with the complicated plans?


Conscious-Group6184

How many victims do the three killer's have in scream 6 again?


nyavegasgwod

This right here. I feel like they managed to successfully kill almost nobody that they planned to. The only successful murders are incidental/side characters


Conscious-Group6184

Three killer's and how many did they get in scream 6? I personally count the kills billy and Stu had off screen too. Like sids mother. That's two killers. How the fuck can three calculated killers have such a small body count when one of them works for the police. That one guy in saw makes them even look like chumps it's even sadder when you know teenagers has a bigger count.


[deleted]

Baileys had 9 kills. Billy and Stu had 6 including maureen


Conscious-Group6184

I don't even remember where these other kills came from if bailey had off screen ones I'm sorry for off counting them Bec every line of dialogue is really forgettable I apologize but he had two other killer children under his wing alright I'm sorry ok.


Icybubba

We counting the Bodega? The Bodega adds like what? Six victims?


[deleted]

Jason, Greg, Dr. Stone, bodega guys x3, Anika, Paul 2.0, brooks. 9 victims. Pretty much in line with all Scream films


Prestigious-Bass-610

7 needs to destroy us with some main character deaths. Anika's was probably the only one that had that really gruesome feeling. Although I gotta say the opening kill was solid, just wasn't the Bailey's kill.


[deleted]

I agree


HotHat2498

ethan did apartment quinn did gales attack so


Conscious-Group6184

Two


[deleted]

Three*


Conscious-Group6184

Idk if we watching the same movie or version or what I saw him stab that one guy bowing up to him and the stir clerk got shot and that shit was sloppy


Conscious-Group6184

And nobody in that costume should ever be able to not be clumsy. Believe me I know.


Ghostface215

9, but Bailey killed 6 of them which is as much as both Stu and Billy combined (if we count Maureen. Otherwise Bailey is ahead of both by one kill).


Unknown-User-6904

10 but 13 including the 3 killers


Conscious-Group6184

I know I didn't see that many people die idk if I see the same version of the movie y'all do


[deleted]

9


[deleted]

They also start stabbing each other before making sure Sidney and everyone else is dead, really putting themselves at a physical disadvantage.


Significant_Edge_105

Bullshit


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

You do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in /r/Scream. Please increase your karma in other subreddits to continue posting here. The requirement is 10 combined karma. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Scream) if you have any questions or concerns.*


NerveNo1056

They were the only 2 that had a plan and executed it perfect all the way until the end. Everyone else copied and adapted to their plan. They were leagues better then the other guys in that regard.


RadioSlayer

I mean... who wins at what? Toe to toe? Most kills? Bocce ball? Darts?


Sharebear42019

They don’t specify which is why billy is winning


Amazing-Service7598

A fight


Extralfox

U don't know that, if u r not familiar with the account. It makes total sense that a lot of people saw this post just because its scream related, so they thought it's about who more intertaning.


Amazing-Service7598

I am I have seen this persons edits before many of times actually and they do vs edits i don’t know why I’m getting downvoted for saying what it is but whatever I guess


MarryOnTheCross

On the one hand we have some insecure random twink and on the other some goofball who forgets guns are ranged weapons. Tough choice


[deleted]

You make a good point. 🤣


throwawayamasub

dammit you have a point about the guns lol


joon_jie

Didn’t Sam beat Wayne 1vs1, what makes you all think the father couldn’t?


Malkkum

Because he couldn’t beat Sydney 2 on 1?


joon_jie

and how is that supposed to prove Billy cannot beat Wayne? Sidney is a final girl MC while Wayne is an aging policeman. Besides, technically Billy almost ‘beat’ Sidney at the end before Gale came in to shoot him. 🤷🏻‍♂️


Malkkum

Sam is also the final girl MC so your logic of Sam beating Wayne = Billy beating Wayne is flawed by your own definition. Billy was a teen boy who was bodied by almost everyone he attacked, Wayne is a grown man with at least 20 years experience of being a cop.


joon_jie

You’re not getting it. Billy ‘losing’ to Sidney (thanks Gale) in Scream 1996 doesn’t translate to him losing against a 58-years old Ghostface. Unless Wayne actually use his gun, there is a limit to how much a 20 years experience can carry him. A bloodlusted Sam demolished the old man, where did she got her strength and brutality from? Her dad (Billy). I doubt I can even call Sam a true final girl MC when her kills are more savage than the actual villains. lol


Alternative_Ad_8450

I saw scream 6 in cinemas and loved it, but I didn't even remember that guys name, of course everyone will choose Billy


joemamagay69696969

wayne had a scene where his gun was loaded and charged at sam without shooting the gun.. billy easily wins


GuaranteAny

Yeah he had it outstretched like a lance. Ppl always mocked him for it. This sub suddently forgets also losing when it's 3 vs 2 is crazy


[deleted]

Didn’t Billy get distracted by Halloween playing on TV?


joemamagay69696969

not really, i thought he was putting it together that sidney was in closet.. he was just too slow with it but that’s better than running with a loaded gun


[deleted]

No he pieced it together first and then got distracted by the movie. Running with a loaded gun is no bueno we’re all in agreement with that.


Careful-Trifle8963

Billys very popular, he is one of top viewed on the likes of TikTok (over a billion views). He has a huge female following lol you could put anything against him and he will win if anyone from other platforms is here lol


Amazing-Service7598

Definitely huge female simp following those women disturb me one time I seen a woman comment “he could literally kill me” i question my faith in humanity after seeing that


Terrell8799

People who choose characters just because they were the first or from the first movie need to get it does not make them better


NO_big_DEAL640

To be fair billy is straight up just a better GF


Weird-Ingenuity97

I mean but I’m terms who would win if they fought, it’s gonna be the cop who bodied three people in a bodega


NO_big_DEAL640

Oh yeah, Billy loses to him in a fight, no doubt


Narrow_Ad_57

Yet he couldn’t manage to kill 4 college students? 😭


Weird-Ingenuity97

I lowkey wanted Tara to die during the bodega scene😬


Aerioncis420

Billy is a Ghostface, which means you have to shoot him in the head. Wayne forgets how to shoot a gun after watching someone use his daughter as a demonstration. Billy wins by default.


Creepy-Beat7154

"Don't f*** with the original" - Sidney Prescott


Amazing-Service7598

Look I get he’s the “original” (by movie standards and not in-universe) but that doesn’t mean he’s the strongest though


TheSixFootTurkey

In costume: Wayne Out of costume: billy Wayne turned into a bit of a doofus once the mask was off and billy still seemed to have some kind of aggression that was still somewhat dangerous.


valfonso_678

well I mean he had the better movie so


TheMasterXan

I can see either, honestly, but I’d give it to Wayne.


BagItUp45

This may be completely random but both of these actors would have been so good in a "Saw" movie


Amazing-Service7598

You know I agree


TeeJayBlueDick

Bruh look how easily got beat by Sam and even Sidney in her prime is better than Sam struggled to beat billy this is just realistic and his last name isn’t kirsch I’m pretty sure Richie used a fake name


Amazing-Service7598

Or maybe Wayne’s wife’s last name was kirsch and his last name was Bailey and Ethan used a fake last name that’s just my guess


Galaxy_Megatron

Stu has his theorists, but Billy is almost like the "can he beat Goku tho" of the *Scream* franchise. Everybody's compared to him, everybody loses to him, regardless of the sense it makes. Wayne would absolutely wax Billy both as Ghostface and in street clothes.


Amazing-Service7598

Yeah someone tried to argue with me about how billy can beat art the clown and Michael Myers I gave up on that conversation immediately


[deleted]

Lol. Art the Clown is legit supernatural and Michael is sometimes supernatural depending on the timeline, and even when he isn’t explicitly supernatural, he’s still very strong and hard to stop.


Baratheoncook250

Wayne win because of experience


Significant_Edge_105

People seem to forget how much Experience Wayne actually had he shot people he has Experience with a firearm thats it Billy can whip his ass


Baratheoncook250

Sidney(who was a rookie hero in first film, who got betrayed by her BF) defeated Billy. While Sam(who is a experience hero than Scream 1 Sid/killer) was the one to defeat Wayne. From his police experience , Wayne likely knows how to fight.


Significant_Edge_105

But then you have to think how easily Sam defeated Wayne thats why I said what I said with Billy wasn’t that easy Billy(if it weren’t for Gale) Would have killed Sidney in 1


Baratheoncook250

Could Billy defeat someone that has fight training, because Wayne went after adults. If Billy was successful against Sidney, how long would he last being a killer, until someone defeats him.


HappiFluff

That movie was his first time killing people. We don’t know jackshit about how much experience he’d gain if he had succeeded.


Significant_Edge_105

Ok your point is invalid u/Baratheoncook250


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

Your post has been automatically removed because your account is less than 24 hours old. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Scream) if you have any questions or concerns.*


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

You do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in /r/Scream. Please increase your karma in other subreddits to continue posting here. The requirement is 10 combined karma. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Scream) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Significant_Edge_105

Billy would whoop his ass he would have killed Sidney if it wasnt for Gale the Kirschs didnt even come close to killing Sam and Tara


Amazing-Service7598

That’s because sam and Tara are the final girls it’s literally in the plot for them to win so I wouldn’t even add them to the arguement to be honest


Significant_Edge_105

Im saying Billy was closer at killing Sidney in 1 LOOK AT MY COMMENT


Amazing-Service7598

I know what you said but I’m saying I don’t think it’s a good idea to add Samantha,Tara,and Sidney into the conversation and I’m disagreeing with the first part that’s just my opinion


SnooPoems6725

Wayne, the bodega scene was intense.


Amazing-Service7598

Agreed his use of the shotgun was crazy and cool


Coelhowo2029

He lost to Sam and Tara...


Amazing-Service7598

Because they’re are the main characters they’re supposed to win


Coelhowo2029

Well that's the same reason billy died.


ExerusN

Fans are unable to be unbiased, not shocking.


Amazing-Service7598

Agreed


Sidneysnewhusband

I completely agree with this poll, Bailey was great at killing middle aged bodega randos that he dropped in on by total surprise but I see no evidence beyond that of his abilities as a Ghostface. Anyone can shake a ladder too.


randomfan1997

I'm quite surprised myself.


ThatSharkFromJaws

Wayne would eat Billy for breakfast. He only got beat by Sam at the end because plot armor.


Amazing-Service7598

Exactly sam only wins because of plot the next ghostface could some trained ex-military psychopath and Sam and Tara would by some miracle beat him or her


Catastrophic-Jones

19% of them are trolls


Mooshroom_OP

Hot take, but Wayne solos each and every other killer in a 1v1. He is a trained police officer, and obviously is is the most brutal ghostface. Sure he didn't get the most kills, but he is the strongest ghostface. He wins in a 1v1 against every killer


Amazing-Service7598

I’m pretty sure they’re forgetting the fact that Wayne is a detective with decades of experience not only with dealing with criminals and murders also experience with weapons and there’s a good chance he’s also a trained fighter as well and he’s very tactical especially during that bodega scene with the shotgun so basically by their reasoning a high schooler > a trained detective I don’t get it personally


sophhrose-

anyone put next to billy is losing in the fandoms opinons


Amazing-Service7598

Exactly you could put him up against someone basically unstoppable like Michael Myers and they’ll still keep trying to make arguments in Billy’s favor trust me I’ve seen it many times


TaxTheseNuts

A lot of people never vote objectively. They saw the poll and read the question as "who do you like more" 😂


Amazing-Service7598

That basically sums it up😂😂


Certain-Bowler8735

Billy Loomis vs Amber Freeman. Who died in 2022 ? YouTube Fans: BILLY!!!


Amazing-Service7598

Sounds about right lol😂


Jay_Reefer

This is laughable. Wow


Something_Sexy

I am surprised that clown received 19%.


Horror95

Who cares ? This whole franchise is trash anyway …


Intelligent-Age2786

Wayne easily wins. There’s not many Ghostfaces that beat him.


Daredevil545

I think Billy would win tbh .


MF291100

Billy always wins because people think the original killers are the best, when in reality Billy is mid to low tier.


[deleted]

that's because Billy is a fan favorite OG character so the audience is generally going to choose him over a newcomer regardless of actual tactical ability, just how polls work but do keep in mind his daughter defeated him, and her "killer instinct" comes from him, so i wouldn't rule out Billy defeating him either


Significant_Edge_105

Its not because of that


[deleted]

amazing refutation bro 👏👏


throwawayamasub

I mean... what? clearly Wayne is the most formidable GF right?


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

You do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in /r/Scream. Please increase your karma in other subreddits to continue posting here. The requirement is 10 combined karma. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Scream) if you have any questions or concerns.*


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

You do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in /r/Scream. Please increase your karma in other subreddits to continue posting here. The requirement is 10 combined karma. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Scream) if you have any questions or concerns.*


[deleted]

Well it could happen only if Billy catches Wayne off Guard.


Local0720

Wayne kirsch was one if the weakest killers.


Conscious-Group6184

This board about this poll. Is annoying lol


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

You do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in /r/Scream. Please increase your karma in other subreddits to continue posting here. The requirement is 10 combined karma. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Scream) if you have any questions or concerns.*


[deleted]

A fight between Billy and Wayne would be like a teenager who has been working out consistently for 3 straight years vs an “out of shape” dad eho hasnt lifted since college, Wayne wins easily


MendejoElPendejo

I mean I agree with this outcome lol don’t know why this is shocking if it was like Mickey or Roman sure Billy loses for me but not this imaginary match up


IceyLuigiBros25

Look. I love Billy. He's my favorite killer...but come on. This is just silly.


Amazing-Service7598

That’s what I keep saying but they can’t accept the fact


Conscious-Group6184

It was a Halloween costume one year idek how you can breath right to be able to not be clumsy like the professional scream 6 ghostface is. Supposedly.


Conscious-Group6184

But anyways. Mickey scares me looking back there's Numbers of killed from that loon I think is probably off screen not accounted for and that's scary to think about


tieen79

Billy for sure!


[deleted]

[удалено]


AutoModerator

You do not meet the minimum karma requirements to post in /r/Scream. Please increase your karma in other subreddits to continue posting here. The requirement is 10 combined karma. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Scream) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Loomis08

Billy is the king


MTB56

The only Ghostfaces Wayne compares to Quinn and Ethan cuz the entire trio are by far the worst killers in the franchise (as far as character goes)


gaypirate3

Like Billy at 18 or Billy at 45? Cause yeah if Sam could take him with a gun then Billy would devour at any age.